Mutares SE & Co. KGaA (ETR:MUX)
Germany flag Germany · Delayed Price · Currency is EUR
24.55
+1.30 (5.59%)
Apr 27, 2026, 5:35 PM CET
← View all transcripts

Earnings Call: Q4 2022

Apr 18, 2023

Operator

The conference is now being recorded. Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the Mutares Earnings Call for the full year 2022. On the call today, the CIO, Johannes Laumann, and the CFO, Mark Friedrich, will present the results and most relevant events of the full year 2022. After the presentation, they will be available to answer your questions. The presentation shown is available on the Mutares website after the call. Before we start, I would like to remind you that this presentation contains forward-looking statements, including projections which may not develop as currently expected. I therefore kindly ask you to take note of the precautionary warning about forward-looking statements that is included in the materials on the website. Let me hand over to Johannes Laumann.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Good afternoon, good morning, good evening, all of you. Very warm welcome to our conference call for the financial year 2022. I'm very happy to be able to kick off the presentation by introducing you to a new record year of the history of Mutares in 2022. Also later on looking forward into 2023, which looks very promising that we will continue, that we deliver what we promise. I will guide you through company, remind you again on our business model, and then my colleague, Mark Friedrich, will take the financials before I will close the sessions on the outlook. A small introduction. Faces should look familiar, are unchanged. Unchanged is also the shareholding we currently have as a management and supervisory board. We are very happy with that.

We have no plans to change that. We have no plans to divest this. We have no plans to delist this. On the contrary, I think, we believe in the company, and you will see when it's possible that this share potentially also might increase in the weeks and months to come. Let me take you to the key highlights of 2022. I think, we delivered what we promised, we delivered what we said, and we delivered also what you out there expected. On the transaction buy-side, we conducted 13 buy-side transaction, which is more or less one a month, as we did. All over our segments, all over sizes, all over our countries. We'll come to that later on as well. On the sell-side, we conducted six sell-side transactions.

The largest one was the Nordic sell-side transaction. The year we finalized with the Royal de Boer sell-side transaction, which we sold to Turntide Technologies, a strategic player from America. When we look at the portfolio development, and Mark Friedrich will go a deep dive into that in the financial segments, we faced three challenges in 2022, which are very obvious, but I would like to remind you on this. The first one was the start of the war, beginning of 2022 in Ukraine, which also consequently had obviously an impact on certain other things, like the energy prices, which significantly increased. Just to give you a flavor, in part of our company's energy-heavy companies, we saw increases of energy costs of 300%-400% compared to previous year.

Last but not least, the whole supply chain topic, the whole global supply chain topic, shortage of material, especially also on the, on the auto business, constant change of call off, constant change of production planning from the OEMs, of course, causes also some difficulties in the market. No significant capital market transaction happened in 2022. However, we already did the preparation for the refinancing of the bond, the Nordic bond facility, which we just striked a couple of weeks back with a refinancing of the existing facility and a slight upgrade to EUR 100 million. Overall, Mutares Holding has 200 people. It's grown to 200 people, which is another increase of 40 to 50 people. Mutares Group, close to 20,000. This is our key asset. That's why I want to mention it here.

I think it's also a good moment to thank these guys and and girls to for the contribution and for what's happening on the growth side. Without our people, without our employees, without the team spirit we have, it would never be possible to have this steep and really unique growth path we are going since 2019. We are following what we, what we said, and we delivered what we said. Thanks to the guys, thanks to these 190+ people, and thanks to this 19,000. Without them, I couldn't present you the results I'm presenting you. For this call, I would like to give you a little flashlight of the Nordics. The Nordic office in Stockholm was created in late 2020.

I think the path we have set here proves our concept of we want to be local in order to grow the business. We want to be local in order to make transactions. What you have seen, what Carl Kistenmacher, who's leading this Nordic enterprise, and what Carl has done with his team, have eight transactions signed. We have built up a team of 12 professionals, M&A and operational. We have opened up the Helsinki office again and have our main one in Stockholm. We have a business and operation which is above EUR 1 billion of turnover. With Nordic, we have conducted already and proved the concept. We have already conducted our first exit in Nordic.

A very strong development, and Nordic stands for 20% of our total business at Mutares Group. I would like to give you this flashlight because also with Frigoscandia, with Terranor, with Palmia, with Arriva, which is a business predominant in Denmark acquired from Deutsche Bahn, transaction will be closed mid of May. We really have a very strong footprint there, and we are one of the key players or the key players in the Nordic market when it comes to turnaround. In a very short period of time, a super great achievement from our team in the Nordics. Very happy to see that. Let me quickly go in our business model, and I would like to cut it in a slightly different manner than we did before to not annoy you.

On the numbers, we still have the target of 2025, where we want to be at EUR 7 billion and then the EUR 125 million-EUR 150 million of profitability on holding that income level, and this guidance is confirmed. I am super confident that we will achieve that we again will deliver what we promised. Mark will go a little bit detail, and later on we also see the 2023 guidance more in detail. Let me focus on the left side, what we do and why we are so successful and why what is the basis for all these numbers. We have now opened with Warsaw our 10th office in Europe. We are all over the continent, and we want to be the number one when it comes to turnaround special situations in the European market.

By doing this, we want to have a position in order to decide if we want to make the transaction or not. Maybe a quite interesting story, we are currently working on a deal in France where we got to know from the advisors before we got granted exclusivity on the buy side. There was one of our competitors asking if we are in the deal or not. By a positive signal from the advisor that we are in the deal, our competitors pulled out because they believe if we are in the deal, they will not win it. This is a great sign. This is the first in mind, first in choice DNA I would like to have in the team, and I would like to have as a perception.

The three diversified segments, the auto segment, the engineering technology, and the Goods & Services. This is a really great driver also from a risk mitigation point of view, not only from a growth where we see, you know, different segments, early cycle, late cycle, but also from a risk mitigation. When you see, and Mark will come to that later as well, the auto segment was under heavy pressure in 2022, so it lost almost EUR 50 million in operating result. However, what we see is this has recovered now. Q1, we see quite a strong income on the auto business, which we expect also to continue in the rest of the year.

The diversification of our segments is good for the buy side, it's good for the sell side, but it's also really good for the risk diversification within the portfolio after acquisition. On the company size, I think we have moved our sweet spot up. A EUR 100 million company in turnover up to EUR 750 million is what we say this is the area where we are in. When you see the buy sides of 2023, if you see MoldTecs, if you see [Shimads], also if you see Arriva, which is going to be closed now in May, those are all businesses in the EUR 200 million, EUR 300 million, EUR 400 million, EUR 500 million turnover size. This is our new sweet spot, where I think we operate in all the countries quite successfully.

This is, for me, the Mutares DNA, corporate carve-out, European headquarter base, three segments, company sizes in this range. This DNA is something we will always respect, and we will not let go because this is what made us strong and which what, in my view, also will make us even stronger. On the next slide, I would like to give you a little bit how we interpret this on a daily basis and how we take decision on a daily basis. Our DNA is the European focus, the turnaround, and at the end of the day, the three segments and the size of the companies. Whatever we invest, whatever company we acquire, we ask us the question: Can we support the DNA? Can we support our targets? Can we support our guidance?

What we want as a kind of a gatekeeper is whatever we invest, can we make 7x to 10x the return over the life cycle? The investment is roughly in 10% of the cases, it's a purchase price. In 90% of the cases of our investments, we talk about commitments. We talk about equity injections at closing date in the company. We talk about providing financing lines at a certain period of time for restructuring effort. This is the investments we take. The decision based on this investment is, do we get 7x to 10x our money? Then we start off in the first phase, which we call the realignment phase. The realignment phase is the heavy restructuring phase, where we put our forces together. We put our consulting team.

More than 140 people as we speak today are flying out on a Monday, are returning Thursdays or Fridays back to the families, and trying to fix the company. I believe the first six months after acquisition, those are the crucial months in order to separate the company, to carve it out, and to make the important steps to turn it around. The second one is the optimization phase, what we call. This is when the companies turn around, and we are able to provide dividends to us. In 2022, we had some very strong dividend payers, which are at the end of the optimization phase or even in the beginning of the harvesting phase, which also contradicts positively to the return of the 7x to 10 x. Last but not least, the exit proceeds.

The exit proceeds are coming over our average holding period, which is three to five years. You will see later on the outlook that 2023 is the year where the, let's say, the adopted Mutares way of working, which happened in the mid of 2019, That this pays off now. We have the strongest sales pipeline ever because we started to grow 2019, 2020, 2021 heavily. Since then, we make one transaction a month on average. This one buy-side transaction a month, when you respect the holding period, this is now what it starts to materialize in 2022.

Later on you will see 2023 will be a super strong year when it comes to the exit. We have already done four in the first four months. I'll come to that later on. It's important to understand when we acquire, and that's a day-to-day decision of Robin and myself, do we get the money back 7x to 10x ? Firstly, we take it back through our consulting management fees, which is predictable. We know exactly what we want, and here we will be in 2023 on a run rate above EUR 100 million. Optimization is the dividends taking out of outperforming portfolios. Last but not least, exit proceeds when we provide an exit and when we conduct an exit after we have finalized our holding period.

When we come to our portfolio, and I will only deep dive in a few, you see a quite good leverage on automotive, engineering technology, and goods and service when it comes to the turnover. You see the balance, what I said before, on early cycle, late cycle, non-cycle. This is basically the development, how our portfolio looks today. Let me pick out one of each, which I would like to mention. The first one in the automotive, I think, it was also public, it was announced, it was launched, was the Amaneos Group, a group where we focused especially on the e-mobility when it comes to plastic injection molding parts. We are the new kid in this segment. We are the new kid in the block.

More than EUR 1.2 billion of turnover. This EUR 1.2 billion are all over the world. We are on every continent: India, Asia, U.S., South America, Africa, and especially also Europe. We have all OEMs on our customer bank. This is the new kid on the block, and I think the launch and the taking the synergies and introducing this to the customers, I think Mathieu Purrey, who's running this as a CEO, has done an amazing job when it comes to this. Second segment, engineering technology. I think here I would like to highlight in 2022, we acquired two businesses from Siemens Energy.

Siemens Energy itself in a transformation, typical seller, putting themselves up in a new strategy, have businesses which doesn't fit the strategy, complex carve-out of a large corporate, not maybe the most agile company in the world, but we made it happen together with them to carve out the business. I think especially NEM, which is a business in the Netherlands, and we acquired and we combined with the Balcke-Dürr Group, lately. I think this was a big, big effort to carve it out, to make it happen, and it already materializes in 2023, positively on the holding level. I think, Fatma Veselaj from the operations team there did a fantastic job in order to put all this on the street and, put the horsepower there.

Last but not least, goods and service. I'll obviously take Lapeyre here because a lot of questions from the shareholders are running through that, so I use the opportunity. Lapeyre is performing to budget. In 2022, we exactly met the budget what we have put ourselves there in 2021, as the numbers. We see a very nice development in the main segments of Lapeyre. We have stabilized the operations, the plants we have. We have sold the plant. We have consolidated a bit. The operation is stabilized. We have absolutely skyrocketing improved the customer experience, the shops, the way we're selling products, which is very nicely done. Obviously, last but not least, we have really catched up on the CapEx backlog, introducing new products to the market.

I'm very optimistic that 2023 Lapeyre, for the first time since more than 10 years, will reach an operational positive result of the business in 2023. When it comes to our ESG approach, which is obviously not only valid for the holding, but also valid for all our portfolios where we try to align our targets and our highlights there, I would like to stress out maybe three things here, if you allow. First of all, when it comes to CO2, the CO2 emission, with LMS, one of our automotive part of the Amaneos Group. It's a big plant close to Frankfurt, roughly EUR 350 million of turnover. Main customers, Mercedes, for example, here, and Audi.

We have put a strategy in place to become this plant, which is a plastic injection molding part, including a full-fledged paint line. We put ourself a target to put this CO2 neutral within the next five to six years. This is happening. We work on the CO2 neutrality. This is our main focus when it comes to the environment here. The middle segment, I would like to stress out the community engagement. It's not only what it's mentioned here, donation to Tiptree Hospice, which we do. I think whatever the business does to us and whatever result we delivered, and I know we delivered the best results in history, and I'm also sure that this will continue. We live on the bright side of life, and we should not forget about people who are not there.

Our main engagement here in 2022 really was our plant in the Ukraine, and our employees in the Ukraine, which we heavily supported. Before I come back with the outlook, which will be quite intense and more detailed than in the past, I would like to give you a deep dive, and Mark can much better facilitate than I.

Mark Friedrich
CFO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Thanks. Thanks, Johannes. Thanks. Coming to the financials, starting with the overall development. We as a group are quite pleased with the development that we saw in 2022. We were able to increase the number of portfolio companies and thereby also increased the revenue of the group to almost EUR 3.8 billion. The EBITDA decreased to EUR 180 million compared to 2021, and this is mainly due to the biggest acquisition that we did in 2021 with Lapeyre, where we acquired the biggest bargain purchase gain of more than EUR 400 million that is included in 2021.

More important for us is the development of the adjusted EBITDA, so the underlying performance indicator of the existing portfolio that improved substantially even though we added more portfolio companies to the group, and normally we acquire loss-making companies. This shows quite strongly that we were able to execute the restructuring programs that we initiated in the different portfolio companies and were able to execute these kind of restructuring programs. In the following slides, I will go into more details when it comes to the different developments in the segments, and here you will see then the different developments of the adjusted EBITDA. The holding key KPIs, namely the revenue and the portfolio income and net income, pretty much followed the development of the group.

We were able to increase again the revenue that we generate with management fee and consulting to EUR 71 million, a bit more than 40%. Even more important for us is that the run rate that we already saw in Q4 of 2022 indicates that we have now a portfolio income to expect for 2023 of more than EUR 100 million, much likely to see EUR 110 million in 2023 as a revenue of the holding. Portfolio income increased quite substantially. We were able to generate much more dividends than expected across the portfolio.

Hannes already mentioned that the dividends are coming from a couple of companies across the life cycle, from harvesting, where we have dividends from Terranor, Clecim, or La Rochette, but also from companies in the other stages here in optimization and also in the realignment phase. The net income finally was EUR 72.9 in the range that we communicated all the time. Looking at the quarterly development in the different segments, you see again here that we had a quite challenging environment in the Automotive and Mobility segment, especially in the first quarter, and saw a gradual improvement in this, in the quarters here until almost zero in Q4.

This is continuing in 2023, so we are quite optimistic to see here the expected ramp-up of volumes, but also to see that our restructuring efforts are now contributing to an improved profitability. When we talk about restructuring, we normally mean that we refresh the management, that we streamline the organization, that we renegotiate supply contracts, and we reorganize the shop floor. In 2022, it was also important and one key element here in the de-development that we were able to renegotiate the prices with the customers. There's a bigger time lag between the cost increases and the rollover to the customers in the Automotive segment, and that's exactly what you see here.

We were able to roll over the price increases in the Goods and Services segment much faster, therefore were able to preserve the profitability here in a way better manner compared to the Automotive and Mobility segment. Engineering and Technology was quite stable throughout the year. We will see that there are some companies performing better than others, there are some lights and shadows in the segment, overall it was close to zero. Starting with Automotive and Mobility. Here we increased revenue again by more than EUR 300 million, mainly due to the acquisitions, also saw the organic growth which came from the increased volume, also from the increased prices with customers, especially in the Q4. Here you see again that we were able to narrow down the adjusted EBITDA close to zero until the end of the year.

The significant cost increases that we were experiencing especially in the first half of 2022, we were impacting the profitability, and then we were able to roll them over to the customers with the countermeasures that we were initiating in terms of streamlining the cost base. Contributing to the almost break-even EBITDA. Engineering and Technology segment, which were quite stable throughout the year, around zero all the time, where we had some companies were operating in the project-driven businesses, Donges, by Rothemühle, but also ADComms and Gemini. We have companies who performed quite well, like La Rochette, Clecim, but also the newly acquired entity, Steyr Motors. The profitability that you see here was almost EUR 4 million negative, was impacted quite heavily by the newly acquisitions of SMP by [TN CrossCo]. They combine a negative adjusted EBITDA of minus EUR 14.

On the other hand, we had a quite good development in La Rochette, which is the main contributor to the organic growth that you see here. It may seem. Also at SMP that we acquired in May 2022, and was contributing quite negatively in 2022. The run rate, especially in Q4, was already improving substantially to a positive number, and in Q1 is now fully on track in terms of the budget figures that we have agreed here with the company. Therefore we are quite pleased with the development. Here we have the segment also where we divested the Royal de Boer together with Japy Tech then in January and the Nordec Group.

Last segment, goods and services, the segment that was able to roll over the prices, the price increases much faster than the other segments. Therefore you see that the profitability improved then in Q4 quite substantially to 4%, more than 4%. In these segments we have with Lapeyre, the biggest company in the group, especially Lapeyre was also one company who contributed quite positively with approximately EUR 8 million adjusted EBITDA to the Q4 figure here. On the other hand, we saw also at Frigoscandia, also especially at Terranor, but HIEP and Ganter were also companies that were contributing quite positively and show that we were able to execute the restructuring programs, the optimization programs here. Then also see the fruits of the work that we have done here in the past.

Coming to the last view is the life cycle view of the group, where we always recluster the companies into the well-known four phases. The acquisition phase is the one that we normally have not shown so far. We have only one company in the bucket as of now, which is Arriva, the acquisition from Deutsche Bank to be closed mid of May, like Johannes said. Then we have the realignment phase, which is by nature negative because we acquire loss-making companies, and it's quite packed. That's good because it means that we have a lot of work to do for the team and also a lot of chances looking forward, when it jumps into the development in the group and to the final harvesting stage.

Optimization phase here is a phase that is supposed to be close to zero. We see here that we were already able to cut down the profitability to minus EUR 1.8. We have a couple of companies in that bucket that are performing well, but also had here with SFC Group and KICO SH Group, two companies that were from the automotive segment, heavily impacted by the trends that I explained before. Harvesting stage, final stage, we see that the profitability increased to almost EUR 50 million in adjusted EBITDA in 2022 with just five companies here. With this final stage, we normally signal to the market that we are willing to divest within the next 12 months. Today we also have this slide here in the deck that shows the development along the different quarters.

Here you see that the optimization phase was able to become positive in Q4. Something that we want to see here from the group. This was driven by what we saw, especially from the automotive companies that contributed then again, not so negatively like in Q1. On the other hand, we also saw that we were able to narrow down the negative impact in the realignment phase that is attributable, especially also here again to Lapeyre. Most important, it shows that the business model works. We are able to acquire loss-making companies. We are able to then bring them to zero profitability in the optimization phase, and then finally also bring them to a positive operating indicator, adjusted EBITDA, in the final phase, and then we want to divest.

Overall, we are quite pleased with the development and the restructuring efforts that we were able to execute, and that's what we have seen here in the financials, especially in Q4. With this, we come to the outlook.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Thank you very much, Mark. I would like to take you on the outlook quickly of 2023. Would like to give you a little bit more insight on our expectation, on my expectation, what will happen in the remaining eight months. In a nutshell, I'm very sure, and this will also be detailed out in the next slides. I'm very sure that 2023, again, we will deliver what we promised, and we will face another record year in 2023 since the firm was founded in 2008. Why do I think this? Basically, we see a portfolio development which Mark has already a little bit indicated. We went quite well into Q1.

We haven't done the final number yet, what we see so far for Q1 is very much promising and continues, I think, the good operation in the portfolios, which have started already in Q4 last year. We are quite pleased with the development of the start in the year of the portfolios. That's number one. Number two, when I look at the buy side, the buy side, what we see currently 93 projects with a total turnover of EUR 13.3 billion. I have made a check. This is the biggest buy side pipeline since I'm in charge and becoming charged in mid 2019.

I'm very confident that our target to grow, that our target to transact, that our, you know, kind of running story to make a transaction per month also continues in 2023 because in simple terms, there's a big, big pipeline ahead of us. Deals are starting to materialize now in Q2 and especially in Q3, building up, continuously building up. Pipeline is growing and not going down. The buy side is really, really, a tick mark. Why is that? What we see is the full impact of inflation will only come this year in our view. That is what is built up. Interest rates are going up and the material impact comes in 2023.

In crisis situation like we had in 2022, coming out of COVID, now the war happened, corporates typically go back to their core business and they try to divest things which are left and right of the core business. They concentrate and focus on the main asset of a business. This obviously is fantastic news for a turnaround investor who is specialized in carve-out situation of loss-making businesses. This is one of the trigger. We see more and more in Europe privatizations going on. One of them, for example, is what we have acquired from Deutsche Bahn, Arriva, one of the privatizations. We also see that now more and more coming in countries where privatization was not so active. For example, looking at the moment in one in France.

This is the buy side where I next to the portfolio, which is going quite well in Q1 and started in the year. The buy side looks really, really promising for 2023. As I mentioned before, taking the life cycle, taking the holding period, when you look at the sell side, I think this will be a super intense year on the sell side. We've already done three sell side transactions to strategic. FT, La Rochette, and Ganter France. FT, for example, we divested to Holcim, and then Chapitre, number four of the sell side transaction already in the first four months.

What we see on the sell side, and this is why it keeps me so confident that it will run also much, much larger than in the years before is we have now more and more the companies which we started to buy starting from 2019, 2020 onwards. That's number one. Number two , what we see on the sell side is two things. On the quantitative side of the bidder field, this has reduced and especially reduced on the financial sponsor side. The time where you just distribute information memorandums in the pub later in the evening, and then you get the bids in on a certain deadline, this time is not happening. That's over.

What we see is that the qualitative side of strategic bidders, and currently we have four live processes out there in the market in an advanced stage. What we see is that we have competition on strategic bidders. Strategic bidders became more and more, much, much more serious on transactions and much, much more active on transactions than they were during the COVID times. Quantitative bidder field went down. Qualitative, especially the strategic bidders, significantly increased in the last six months, and this is what we see in the four live processes we are currently running in an advanced stage where we see the strategics really interested in the targets we have out there in the market. That makes me also confident that the year 2023 is a year of significant and successful exits.

That also makes me more or less confident that we can already have part of this executed prior to our annual meeting in July. In a nutshell, portfolio, the start in the year was promising and continued a very, very good operation of the quarter four last year. Secondly, the buy side, largest pipeline in the last 3.5 years since I'm monitoring that. Very, very promising on the exit side. Already done four live processes in advanced stage, and I'm very happy and very optimistic that this continues with our harvesting portfolios. When you look at the geographical development as the last point on the outlook, we can confirm, and this is unchanged, the target of 2025 to be at a EUR 7 billion and EUR 125 million-EUR 150 million of net holding income.

We are confident that this is still the right guidance and this is the guidance we can achieve. Secondly, we have executed Warsaw now, to go to Poland and Eastern Europe. We have always said in the second half of 2023, we'll go to the United States of America. Not necessarily to go for the local deals in the U.S. and transport our business model to the U.S., but more for American corporates divesting or carving out global operations. Those deals are not made. Even though it's a global operation, those deals are made in America. Secondly, European corporates selling their U.S. business. Even though it's a European corporate, those deals are made in America, not in Europe. Secondly, large industrialized transaction on the M&A side. The large cap business in Europe is more or less down at the moment.

In America, still live. On the large cap transaction, there are always poison pills in the scope, and we should be the one h aving a solution and taking those poison pills out of the scope of the last Cap transaction. Those three are the main motivators and the main ideas when we go to the U.S. in the second half of 2023. Thank you very much for your attention and, before I give back to the moderator, again, the slogan on the slide before was: we deliver what we promise. I'm very sure also in 23 we will deliver what we put here on paper and what we promise. Why I'm so confident to do that? It's very simple in one sentence: because I have the best team in the world. Thank you very much for listening and, back to the moderator for questions.

Operator

Thank you very much. Ladies and gentlemen, if you would like to ask a question now via the telephone conference, please press nine followed by the star key on your telephone keypad. If you wish to cancel that question, please press nine followed by the star key a second time. The first question now comes from Zafer Rüzgar, Pareto. Please go ahead.

Zafer Rüzgar
Senior Director Equity Research, Pareto Securities

Yes, hello, I hope you can hear me.

Mark Friedrich
CFO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Yes. Hi, Zafer.

Zafer Rüzgar
Senior Director Equity Research, Pareto Securities

Yeah, Perfect. My first question is regarding your net income target and the contributions to that. Just to be clear here and to get a feeling what can be realized from the exits this year. If I do the math correctly, and I assume holding revenues of EUR 100 million and, let's say, OpEx of EUR 65 million and dividend proceeds of, yeah, let's say EUR 25 million. I think you would need exit proceeds of, yeah, around EUR 60 million to end up at a net income of EUR 100 million. Taking into account Mr. Laumann's statements regarding the fact that 2023 will be a strong year with exits, doesn't this look a bit conservative for this year with the EUR 60 million of potential exit proceeds?

Mark Friedrich
CFO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Maybe starting with the, with the first question. You saw that the, the ingredients of the net result of the holding in 2022 and 2021 were coming mostly from the dividend side. We have said here also in the quarter and in the quarters before that we think that we are now in a position to deliver much more exits in 2023 and the years to come, and are really focusing on this. Therefore, in the years 2023 and also then looking forward, we expect a much higher contribution from exits. Using your calculated EUR 60 million, like you said, it's maybe a bit conservative what we did, but we have learned that the exit process are not under our full control.

That's why we have now a couple of exit processes in the market. We maybe have to update our guidance for the net results throughout the year, maybe after Q2 when we have executed a couple of exits. For now, we have sticked to the communication that we did in the past, that we are between 1.8% and 2.2% of the expected group revenues. That's the expectation towards the net income of the holding. For the exit proceeds, Johannes, maybe you can add a couple of words.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

I'm typically a very conservative guy. No, I think I can confirm what Mark is saying. Obviously, we have them out in the market now, and at the moment, the number seems conservative compared to our expectation. We have not delivered yet. We have not. You know, the ink has not dried. We decided rather to keep on the conservative side now and then have potentially a positive deviation later than the other way around.

Zafer Rüzgar
Senior Director Equity Research, Pareto Securities

Okay, good. The second one, a short question, because we haven't yet seen the balance sheet figures at holding level. What would be the amount you need to pay out a dividend of EUR 2 per share?

Mark Friedrich
CFO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

We said that we want to execute a substantial exit until then. EUR 1 more would mean that it's EUR 20 million. The exits that we have or the processes that we are currently running, well, our expectations towards these processes is that it's much more than EUR 20 million. Technically we need EUR 20 million, maybe EUR 25 million, but we rather focus on the execution of the exits and let's see which one goes through until the end of Q2.

Zafer Rüzgar
Senior Director Equity Research, Pareto Securities

Okay. Thank you very much. That's it from my side. Thank you.

Operator

The next question comes from Marie-Thérèse Grübner, HAIB.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Yes. Good afternoon, Johannes and Mark. Thanks for taking my question. Can you hear me well?

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Yes, we can, Marie-Thérèse. Yes. Hi.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Wonderful. Hi. Regarding the companies in the harvesting phase, you have five of them, and those will contribute an EBITDA of roughly EUR 50 million this year. Can you tell us, you know, at least, can you give us at least a range of the kind of multiples you are getting for this bracket of companies and the process and the selling or the exit processes which are currently running? Especially given the fact that you are mentioning that the strategic buyers are more playing a role this year, I would assume that those guys are probably willing to pay higher prices. Can you elaborate on this point, maybe?

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Obviously, you can't answer that very generalistic because each and every process is an individual, you know, piece of art, so to say.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

However, I think at the end, and I am, I know all these multiple tables of the industries. I believe in a process. At the end of the day, the multiple is driven by competition. You can have a high multiple in an industry. If you only have one bidder, the multiple will be most probably lower because you don't have the competition. That's why it's very difficult to answer. We have not seen so much deviation in expectation from the starting point of a process when they bid. Okay? You're still, when you talk about logistics or service, you're in a multiple range, which is somewhere between 6x and 9x.

When you're in the production side, more, more CapEx intense businesses, you're more, it depends on the USP you have. It can be between five and 10, actually, so the spread is longer. Auto, I think at the moment forget it to divest, and we don't need to speak about this at the moment. But it's a very individual process. The more competition you have, obviously, the easier is it to drive a multiple. But at the end of the day, we have to say, the qualitative interest of strategic went up in the current processes we are running, number one. Number two, that obviously is very individual then on the multiples, how much, you know, how a process is facilitated.

At the end of the day, I think it's always a deal when we divest, it's always a combination of price, a clean exit for us, and a good best new owner for the business, that we also have a kind of a full-fledged life cycle story. This is what we try to achieve with the current processes out there in the market.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Okay. Maybe follow up on that. What's the average level of leverage on the harvesting bracket? If I look at, you know, when I get to a mark, to, you know, to a market value or subtracting that debt, what is on average the leverage that would be put on these companies or that you're getting rid of in terms of debt?

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Looking at the five companies, Clecim, KICO, Terranor, Donges Group and SABO, the debt, the net debt of these five companies is less than EUR 50 million.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Less than EUR 50 for all five?

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Yeah.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Okay. Great. Thanks. Last but not least, the net income guidance you're giving for next year of EUR 92-112, does that mean that you are, you know, substantially increasing your dividend payout ratio? Or what should one expect in terms of basis dividend? I know it's very, very early in the year to say anything, but given the kind of leap we will see in net income, what are you intending to do with this cash?

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

I think you're asking for this year, Marie-Thérèse, right? You said next year, but the 92.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

No, no. No.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

The EUR 92 is this year. The payout.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Yeah, yeah. Yeah

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Will be next year. Two things. I think let us do our job first. I think we have shown in the past, and we have also shown this year, that if we are successful and if we deliver the potential or the expected growth, that we also let participate our shareholders equivalently. This is also, what we want to do when we are increasing now, our shareholders will participate. We have no plans to spend this money in different business models or in different, or in different capital market setups or in a fund or God knows what. We do our business, we do our core business, we grow internationally, we grow the segments, and we deliver what we, what we set.

Obviously, if you have more income with the same number of shares, then the chance is very high that the participation of the shareholders will also go up.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Is there an intent? I mean, given that you are targeting on average bigger companies that are with less bargain purchase gain, is it fair to assume that at least some of this cash will be reinvested safely in the next transactions and will not, you know, be distributed on a, you know, on a linear path, let's say, to shareholders?

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

I think the level of investments we do in the last three years is quite stable. went slightly up last year. I mean, it's always about, you know, it's a dynamic market, so it's depending on the opportunities you have. I think we're currently, you know, looking at a business where I have the opportunity for a purchase price which seems to be significant, but it's 1x EBITDA.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Okay.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

I have synergies in my portfolio, it's an add-on. If I have the chance to buy for 1x EBITDA an add-on, even though the purchase price is whatever, EUR 8 million, EUR 9 million, EUR 10 million, I think it's a good deal.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Mm-hmm.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

This is really depending on the dynamics of the market, on the opportunities you have. You cannot have the linear math that you say the larger the deals are you make, the more cash you need in order to make this transaction happen. This is not a link you can make actually.

Marie-Thérèse Grübner
Head of Institutional Research, Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking

Okay. Okay. All right. Thank you very much, Johannes.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Thank you, Marie-Thérèse.

Operator

The next question comes from Stefan Augustin, Warburg Research. Please go ahead.

Stefan Augustin
Analyst, Warburg Research

Yes. Hello, thank you for taking the questions. Just two quick ones. The first one is actually on your consultants and your employees. Do you consider that you have a very good ability to get, especially, the specialists that you now need on the market? Is there any, let's say, larger constraints or difficulties to get people in the team? That would be the first question. The second question is actually also quite quick. It is on Lapeyre. If you look at your budget until the end of 2024, can you make a statement on your expected free cash flow from now to then? Is there a, let's say, a significant cash out to be expected still or are we more or less even in the phase where we have a positive free cash flow?

Mark Friedrich
CFO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Okay. Starting with the first question, how we can build up the team. We continue to build up the team. Want to add this year between 20 to 30 professionals across the different countries, across the different practices. We have now added, or we have built up a team of more than 125 professionals in our operations and, you know, try to add now team members and fill these gaps. Fill these gaps in terms of the different practices, but also the countries that or where we see gaps. We heard from Johannes today that the Nordics have become an important market for us. Here we see that in Sweden and also in Finland, we could add some professionals, and we will find them.

We will find them through the network of the existing team and with headhunters working in the different countries. Here we have built up, in the last couple of years, a decent network of headhunters that very well understand our culture, our way of thinking, our way of working, and what kind of characters we are looking for. Therefore, I'm quite confident that we will be able to add these 20 to 30 professionals in the course of 2023. We'll find the right persons who are willing to walk the way with us.

Stefan Augustin
Analyst, Warburg Research

Okay. That's good.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

The second question was a little bit hard to get, but we understood it was about the cash flow, the free cash flow of Lapeyre. Is that correct?

Stefan Augustin
Analyst, Warburg Research

Yes.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Okay. As I said before, we are quite happy with the development of Lapeyre, and Marc Ténart and the gang, I think conduct the right measures and counteractions in order to bring this to the plan we have. As of end of March, Lapeyre holds a cash position of EUR 192 million. Obviously there are plans for more CapEx and investments here. We do expect that, you know, this cash position is not significantly melting until the end of 2024. Also because Lapeyre is expected to be operational positive. Actually the only cash flow or cash burn you have comes from investments and not from the day-to-day operations.

That's the status of end of March, and we are not expecting it melting down too much until the end of 2024 because the operations is positive.

Stefan Augustin
Analyst, Warburg Research

Great. Thanks a lot. That also sounds quite positive.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Thanks.

Operator

At the moment, there are no further questions. If you would still like to raise a question now via the telephone conference, please press nine followed by the star key. There are no further questions. I'd like to hand back to the speakers for some closing remarks.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

We're three minutes ahead of time, so, very good timing. Thanks a lot for participation. As I said, we are very pleased with 2022. We are very happy to have this team on board we're having. We are super confident that 2023 will be again, a record year. Portfolio is going nicely starting the year. Again, I repeat myself, buy side looks super promising, and sell side, I think it will be the best year in, on the sell side ever. I'm very confident to deliver what we promise and potentially even, surprise you positively. Thank you very much. Enjoy the rest of the week. We see each other for Q1 in May. Thank you.

Mark Friedrich
CFO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Bye.

Johannes Laumann
CIO, Mutares SE & Co. KGaA

Ciao ciao. Bye-bye.

Operator

Thank you very much for participating in this call today. We wish you a great rest of the day. Until next time.

Powered by