Thank you all for joining. Good morning. It is the Premier Interim 2027 Results Presentation that you have joined. We have Kobus Gertenbach, Group CEO, Fritz Grobbelaar, Group CFO, and Rolf Hartmann, Commercial Managing Executive, on the call this morning. Kobus and Fritz will go through a presentation for about 20-30 minutes. Fritz is very eager, Kobus is very eager to get through it. We will take questions at the end of the presentation. If you can just put up your hands at the end or post your questions in the chat, I will direct the questions to management. Once again, thank you all for joining, and over to Kobus.
Sumil, thank you very much, and thank you to you guys and Standard Bank for hosting this results presentation for us. Much appreciated. We are going to start with the formal presentation, and then as Sumil said, we will do some questions at the end. Some key performance highlights and overview of the business. I think the completion of the acquisition of the RFG business during March of this year is well communicated. Effectively, from 1 April, the start of the six-month half year for us, we had a full contribution coming in from what we now refer to as the Culinary division. On 1 July, we fully integrated the whole product portfolio of the Culinary division onto our merchandising infrastructure, which is a structure that we run with Pack n Stack.
Then in the middle of September this year, we managed to go live with the supply chain integration. What that means is that as of the middle of September, we pretty much invoice all of the RFG product portfolio on our ERP systems, and we distribute the prolonged life side of their business through our supply chain and our depot and warehousing infrastructure, with the fresh division of the Culinary division being the ready meals business for Woolworths and the pies and pastries that require a cold and frozen chain still operating through the infrastructure that it has always been running through, but it is invoicing through our systems.
Where we are now is, we still have the factories running on the legacy ERP system, and over the next couple of months, we will, factory by factory, implement our ERP system, and then hopefully within the next 6-12 months, we will completely shut down the legacy RFG ERP system. From an earnings perspective, very satisfactory performance, obviously heavily influenced by the prior year by the inclusion of the Culinary results. Even though with that inclusion and the additional shares that was issued in terms of the acquisition, we still managed to grow our headline earnings per share at 27%. From a revenue perspective, we had quite low revenue growth if you strip out the addition of Culinary, and really boils down to big deflation on grain prices, especially maize being 20% deflation versus the same period prior year, and wheat at 5% deflation.
We've taken selected price increases across the Culinary division to implement some corrective margins. We have rice that have run up globally with a 10% price increase that we've implemented on the 1st of October, so hence, after the 30th of September, that's the end of this current period. We still see quite benign inflation in general across our business, other than the oil prices, where we've selectively across the legacy Premier portfolio also taken price increases over the last six months to recover some of that cost to the market. The investment program is running ahead at quite a rapid rate, ZAR 759 million in the six months. We are in the final stages of finishing up all the civil construction work at the Aeroton Bakery, even though it's fully operational and running and baking.
We've still got a lot of construction work going on in Middelburg to finish all the civil construction work there, even though the 8,000 line was commissioned in September and is now starting to approach its design capacity. We have closed the legacy bakeries, Hermanstad Bakery in the west of Pretoria. That was done earlier this year. Then now in the month of November, we've closed down the Potchefstroom Bakery as well, as Middelburg's volumes have ramped up. Very proud of our third phase at Lords View that have opened up in September. That was quite important in terms of onboarding the Culinary product portfolio onto our supply chain. That facility now really state-of-the-art, very large scale, approaching 50,000 sq m under roof, and really a fantastic platform for us to deliver all these products from within the inland market.
Very pleasingly, return on invested capital being back above 20%, as we've now got the full Culinary results starting to come into our numbers. Gearing remained at 0.7 times, really impacted by the debt we've onboarded from that was on the legacy RFG balance sheet, as well as the 1.1 million shares that was just under over ZAR 200 million worth of shares that we bought back in July as part of our ongoing share buyback program. From a macroeconomic perspective, I've alluded to the fuel price being impactful, costing us in excess of ZAR 20 million extra cost per month, having necessitated then some 3%-4% price increases across our portfolio to push that cost through and recover that from the market. Still seeing ongoing disruption from the March and March anti-immigration protests.
Our estimate is that in excess of 400 spaza shops in the KZN market in particular have remained closed. I think that now in the wake of the local government elections having concluded last week, we are monitoring the situation quite closely to see how those shops respond, whether the people have permanently left the country or whether they will slowly but surely start to reopen some of those trading locations. Lastly, we are quite well advanced with our Tulbagh fruit canning plant that we have closed, but more on that in the next slide. From a Tulbagh perspective, we have communicated previously that we certainly did not contemplate that this business would see such a rapid decline in terms of its financial prospects.
We really, in July, had the first proper view where our sales teams internationally came back with the prospects and sales prices, what we can expect from an export market perspective. We started to look at various different options available to the business and ultimately concluded that there is only place in South Africa for one national champion to can fruit and try to gain maximum economies of scale and compete in the international market. Tulbagh and Langeberg were both running at sub-50% production capacity, and at those levels, you simply cannot get to price points where you can compete against the Chinese, in particular, in the global markets. For the right reasons, the Tulbagh factory was closed down, or shall I say, permanently closed down following the conclusion of the previous fruit canning season. Premier has been engaging very constructively with the Competition Commission in this process.
Even prior to us giving notice to the market of the imminent closure, we engaged with the Competition Commission because we knew it would be a sensitive item for them in the wake of the merger approval. We have been fully transparent. We have provided every single request for information that the commission has had.
As of this past weekend, we have now agreed with the Competition Commission to dispense of the urgent hearing of the matter before the tribunal, and that the matter will now only be heard sometime in the next calendar year, and really on the basis of, one, whether Premier contemplated any form of closure of its facility prior to receiving merger approval from the tribunal on the 6th of March, which we filed multiple affidavits and multiple sources of information that clearly contradicts and that says that there was absolutely no such action or contemplation on our side. Factually, there really is not, in our view, much of a basis for the Competition Commission's allegations. Secondly, the commission has also got to prove that anything that we might have had to disclose would have been required as because it is merger-related.
It is quite obvious and clear that the closure of the facility had nothing to do with the merger and was purely driven by global fruit canning market and economic conditions. In our mind, even if we get to the tribunal eventually and we have, for some reason or another, the tribunal still finds a way to rule in favor of the commission, our assessment is that our obligations would then be limited to the public interest fallouts from that. We have, as you will see going forward in the next couple of points, Premier feels that it has bent over backwards and done significant amount of, and spent an enormous amount of money to try and accommodate and soften the closure of the facility for the various stakeholders. We believe there is very limited public interest harm or claim that can be left.
Premier has entered into voluntary separation agreements with 403 employees. That has cost us pretty much ZAR 40 million to implement. It is double what we would have had to pay from a statutory perspective. The Labour Court has dismissed the union's case to set aside the voluntary separation packages as of Friday morning, and they have actually come out and been quite complimentary of the process that Premier has followed in resolving the voluntary separation agreements. We believe that that part of the or that specific case has now also been put to bed. A significant contingent of the employees, of the 409 of total affected employees, have found alternative employment by now, and we have certainly, within Premier, also managed to redeploy a number of employees into different parts of the operation.
From a farmer perspective, we have reached agreements with 82 farmers, representing over 20,000 tons of peaches, to effectively pay them an aggregate amount of ZAR 67 million to remove their peach orchards. Peaches, in particular, is a major problem. If you cannot can them, then there is very little other use for the peach. A number of farmers have agreed to repurpose their land and cultivate other crops instead of the peaches. To put that into perspective, the payments equated to approximately ZAR 150,000 per hectare, and in our estimation, it certainly does not cost much more than ZAR 15,000-ZAR 20,000 per hectare to remove the trees. Ample money has been provided to remove the orchards and plant new crops for future cultivation.
From a Langeberg perspective, we felt it is very important that Premier also tries to do its best to support Langeberg to be successful, and we are still in discussions, but in all likelihood, we are looking to provide approximately ZAR 40 million of support through equipment that we will provide for free, and through subsidizing the fruit that gets delivered to the Langeberg facility by ex-Tulbagh farmers in the upcoming season. We have also pretty much given the Langeberg business access to the Tulbagh facility's international customer base to find buyers for whatever product they manage to can in the coming season. The final point I want to make on the fruit is that all remaining fruit, or effectively all fruit contracted by the Tulbagh facility previously for this upcoming season, has now found a home or been settled through the extraction of the trees.
The remaining fruit will either get processed through Premier's pulps and purees plant in Groot Drakenstein or through the Langeberg canning facility, and therefore, all fruit has found a home. The Tulbagh facility remains available for repurpose. It is 240 hectares of fertile land with ample water rights, with road infrastructure, electricity infrastructure, offices, and factory cold store rooms, et cetera, et cetera. We are certainly trying to engage with as many different constituents as we can to try and find viable alternative business proposals to repurpose the facility to recreate some of the lost job opportunities. Lastly, Premier is also actively engaged to look at various support initiatives into the Tulbagh community over the coming year. From a Premier perspective, if I focus now back on the business, we have got over 12,000 employees, 52 brands, quite large-scale operations across the different manufacturing facilities.
Our fleet, the number of routes that we distribute on, the number of customers we are serving per day, we are certainly a large-scale business with a significant amount of competitive advantage and moats around the operations that we operate. Countrywide, you will see we are operating now 43 different factories and 28 distribution depots across South Africa and into our neighboring countries, Lesotho, Eswatini, Mozambique. From a Millbake perspective, 66% of revenue now. Our bread market shares continue to tick up, and this is only formal market share now sitting at 29%. Our wheat market share has been relatively stable, and it really does depend on how aggressive one is on promotional activity, where you end up in any given period. I think our maize business has also performed quite well, especially over the last six months period.
From a Culinary perspective, a magnificent product portfolio with extremely strong brands, now representing 13 different factories that manufacture the products. Especially proud of our major profit contributors being our juice business, Bull Brand really starting to come into its own, the Hinds Spices, Pakco and spices business, also Southern Coating, really a strong business. Our ready meals, pies, and pastries running and performing extremely well. Our remaining canned product range being the vegetables, tomatoes, the beetroots, gherkins, and the, as I alluded to, the Bull Brand products all being very strong business for us. The legacy Premier Groceries businesses, our candy business, flat on market share for the year, but as we have stated in the results announcement, not a great performance from a financial perspective, and we are busy with some improvement interventions in that business.
I think there is lots of opportunity and potential for us to do better. On the fem care side, continued investment in our factory facilities, pads line, liners lines now starting to run quite nicely at good efficiencies, continuing to relocate more Rugeley tampon manufacturing machines from Taiwan into South Africa. We will shortly be up to 10 machines now and four Benino coating machines that provides the raw materials for those. So really continuing to increase scale of that operation, and I think we should expect to see nice further growth-
Check your cardio and salmon supplemental.
-in our business. Millbake had a good period. Aeroton is running well, Middelburg is coming on stream, and the maize deflation I have talked about. I am very proud of Iwisa's 70th birthday this year, it remains an iconic brand in South Africa. Good growth is coming through on alternative channels like food service and export channels, especially with the consolidation of the export sales teams from Culinary and the legacy product portfolio from Premier coming together, really having much more scale, much wider product basket, and now able to compete much better into especially the adjacent and other countries within the African continent. Then there was some improved operational performance. We have continued to make investments into the production facilities that have now come through, given us increased throughputs, better efficiencies, better scale, and we have seen a little bit of an uptick in product going into the Mozambican market in particular.
Then the onboarding of the Culinary portfolio added further scale to the operations within Mozambique. From an overall Groceries perspective, I think I am very satisfied with the integration of Culinary, really seeing the benefit of the merger-related synergies coming through and being totally on plan with what our expectations were, aligned to merchandising, as I have said, on 1 July, and looking at great execution in the market of the combined product portfolio. There is some nice innovation across the portfolios, including the Woolworths portfolio coming through. Our long-life division has continued to drive very good performance and good growth in spite of the closure of and exiting of the deciduous fruit canning category. The personal care business had some big disruption with especially some of the major retailers selling highly subsidized low-cost private label pads as a CSI initiative, but most of that is in the base.
I think that with further factory efficiencies and economies of scale coming through, we could continue to see improved performance in that business. Our U.K. business has done a good job of arresting the long-term decline in tampon usage with augmenting it with new innovation and new product ranges, including the increased performance of our cotton range in particular that has helped to offset the structural declines in that market. As I said, our sugar confectionery business, our one factory did not have a great period, it had some factory inefficiencies. We have made some changes and started remedial actions to address, and I think that we have a nice opportunity to see a better performance coming out of that business in the second half. Over to Fritz.
Thanks. Thank you, Kobus. Good morning, everyone. The Premier Group delivered a very good result, recording ZAR 14.3 billion revenue for the first six months. That includes the Culinary division. It is an increase of 39% year-on-year. Our continuous focus on increasing our operational efficiencies as well as optimizing our logistic platform, coupled with some synergies, merger synergies, all contributed to an increase in EBITDA. We have also, during this period, increased prices in various categories, various numbers to curb the fuel price increase. All of that culminated into a ZAR 2 billion EBITDA number for the year, which is a 51% increase year-on-year. We have also seen the overall margin of EBITDA increase by 120 basis points to 13.9%. With the Culinary onboarding, we have had to bring on additional depreciation as well as customer lists, which we have never had before.
That increased our depreciation and amortization to record an operating profit of ZAR 1.7 billion, which is a 52% increase year-on-year. We have also seen our margin increase by 110 basis points all the way up to 11.8%. With the onboarding of the Culinary division, we increased our debt, which then meant that the interest bill would have increased. We managed to curb that and pay back the ZAR 234 million voluntary debt. That then culminated in a net profit of ZAR 1.2 billion, which is a 62% increase year-on-year. We have also seen this margin increase by 110 basis points to 8.1%. During 15 September, we released a SENS announcement guiding the market that we will be up by 22%-32% on earnings per share and headline earnings per share. The actual for the year, Kobus alluded to that already, is 27% all the way up to ZAR 7.11.
Very similar for headline earnings. We generated ZAR 1.8 billion of cash from operations, which is a 43% increase year-on-year, and as a result of the good EBITDA increase as well as working capital that was well managed. We had an opportunity to buy back some shares during this period. We managed to purchase back 1.1 million shares, equating to ZAR 207 million, and that will help us with the dilutionary effect of shares for the next year. I have already mentioned, we managed to pay back voluntary debt of ZAR 234 million during this period versus ZAR 70 million the previous year. Group leverage ratio settled at 0.7x geared. We always indicated that we want to be below 1x geared, and we probably would see this being a bit lower closer to the year-end. ROIC is up above the 20% again.
When the Culinary deal was done, it was sitting at 17.6%. It is now all the way up to 20.6%. Similar to ROE, that has increased to 23.5%. We report in two divisions, Millbake and Groceries. Millbake has decreased in revenue as the contribution was always 81%. It is now down to 66%. We have seen Millbake revenue increase year-on-year by 1%, which is mostly contributed by volume growth. The increase in EBITDA year-on-year is sitting at 24% in this category, and it is mostly related to the opening of the Aeroton facility as well as a bit of the Middelburg facility, and increasing our operation efficiencies everywhere. We have seen the EBITDA margin increase from 10.5% all the way up to 16.8% this year. We have also recorded operating profit of ZAR 1.4 billion for this period. The Groceries division, that includes Culinary, HPC, and Candy.
The revenues increased to ZAR 5 billion for this period. Also seen the EBITDA increase to ZAR 513 million for the period. EBITDA margin has expanded from 7.7% all the way up to 10.4%. Remember, in this number, the Culinary or the Tulbagh closure cost is included in this number. Thanks, [Paul]. Headline earnings waterfall. The three key items here that we need to look at is the depreciation, the tax, and the net finance cost. Depreciation and amortization has increased by 45%, and it is a result, as I previously alluded, the additional depreciation that was taken on from the Culinary integration as well as the customer contract lists. Net finance cost, we managed to curb the increase there. It is only 17%, although we took on ZAR 1 billion of debt during the consolidation. Tax is increased in line with what the EBITDA profitability is. Cash flow.
We managed to generate ZAR 1.8 billion of cash from operations, as a result of the increase in EBITDA and working capital that was well managed. With that, we paid ZAR 139 on finance costs, tax of ZAR 403. We paid final dividend of ZAR 306 million, and that was paid in August. ZAR 759 million was spent in CapEx, of which ZAR 404 million is expansionary CapEx. The rest is maintenance. We managed to buy back the shares to ZAR 207 million, as previously mentioned. Pay back some debt, voluntary debt of ZAR 234, and that left us with ZAR 380 million cash in the bank at the end of the period. Capital expenditure, that has always been a focus for us, spending the CapEx where it increases our profitability. For the period, we have seen ZAR 759, which is 5.3% of turnover, up from the previous year that was 4.9% during that time.
ZAR 404 million was spent on expansion CapEx. The rest was on maintenance. If we look at the graph on the right-hand side, ZAR 534 was spent in the Millbake division, and that was for Aeroton, Middelburg, as well as adding some bulk flour supply for our transport. Debt breakdown. We have mentioned this before, but when we listed, we were sitting at 1.7x geared. That is all the way down to 0.7x at this stage. We are sitting with a ZAR 1.5 billion RCF facility that is available to be drawn if we need it for future expansion or anything else. The debt is repayable in 2028, and during this period, we returned ZAR 513 million to shareholders via our share. The purchase of ZAR 207 million and dividends of ZAR 306 million.
Right. Outlook, then we will go into Q&A. I think we will see an acceleration of merger-related benefits coming through as all the changes that we have made and the things that we have implemented start to gain traction, and also some nice growth opportunities coming through from a unified portfolio. I think that from a political perspective, we hope that the climate calms down a bit post the local government elections, and that we will start to see, especially in the informal trade, a more normalized trading happening, but we are monitoring that closely. As we have said, we really have a constructive engagement with the Competition Commission, and we will look, and I would be quite confident that we can resolve the whole situation quite amicably. The grain price deflation will continue through year-end, and then we will pick up the El Niño-related inflation starting in April in our financial numbers.
The two newly commissioned bakeries are starting to run quite nicely. We have ramped up the production quite well, and I think that the structural synergies that we are going to have are going to continue to gain momentum from that investment as well. You will remember previously that we supplied areas like the Free State out of the Eastern Cape and had quite a lot of interim arrangements in place. Obviously, all of those are starting to fall away as we start to gain production capacity in the new facilities. We are going to certainly direct our cash generation towards capital expenditure. I think the amount we have spent in the first half will continue to be similar in the second half of the year, especially as we start to ramp up new opportunities within the Culinary portfolio as well to drive further growth in that portfolio.
We will certainly look to reduce our debt levels a little bit further with cash generation through the second half of the year, and we will continue to monitor the share buyback opportunities in our share price. Then, one is hoping that at some point in time, we will get some relief on the oil prices. If we can see some resolution of the conflict in the Middle East, that might just be able to offset some of the inflationary pressures of the El Niño weather patterns that we expect. That is really it in a nutshell, Sumil, and I think we are going to move on to questions now.
Yes, excellent. If there are questions, just a reminder, you can put them in the chat or just raise your hand. Excellent. We have got Owethu with a question. Please go ahead.
Hi, Sumil, and thank you for hosting us. Just a quick question from my side. From that March and March guidance in terms of expecting things to normalize in FY 2027, that second half, what happens if the 400 spazas actually do not open? What is the impact on revenue that you guys expect it to have?
Look, the people will continue to eat, so the route to market will change. We have got an ability to monitor it quite closely, and we will make sure that however the product finds its way to the consumers, that we will adjust our supply chains to also meet that demand. So, I do not think it will have any revenue impact from our perspective, but it might have a mix impact. So you might see some trade going back to informal and reducing a little bit on the formal retail side. I think it is more that type of shift that we are trying to anticipate rather than us expecting any major change in revenue. Sumil, I just want to mention as well that the picture that is up at the bottom right, or that was up, that is the new Aeroton bakery.
Okay. Thank you. I mean, I would have expected it to have some kind of impact on the consumer, given that there is less disposable income, naturally, right? Instead of buying two loaves of bread, for example, a day, you would go to one and a half. Would you not expect that to be the case?
I think we have experienced that since July, yes. Basically, that type of experience, I think it started to really, and honestly, it started in June already. First half of June, we started to see specific geographical areas coming under pressure, and certainly, we have seen the volume in those areas coming under pressure. Yes, it is in our numbers for at least three and a half to four months of the period under review.
Yeah. We have not seen a decrease in bread volumes, definitely not.
But those areas have stagnated. You could definitely see that the trade is under pressure in those geographical areas.
Okay, perfect. Just the last one from me, Sumil, if you do not mind. The last time we spoke, I think you guys mentioned that you expect ZAR 100 million-ZAR 150 million in cost-saving benefits from the RFG acquisition. It sounds like that is still on track. Is there potential upside to those savings, and is it over FY 2027 or FY 2027 and FY 2028?
Look, we will see a little bit more benefit coming through. I think in the six months we have had now, we have actually incurred some costs in order to make some changes and to implement some of the initiatives. I think we will see a better, more synergies coming through in the second half than we have seen in the first half, but we will only get a full-year benefit of it in 2028. We still are confident of that range. I do not think we are still making progress. I think there is a chance that we will end up better than that range, but we have still got a lot more to do.
Yeah, definitely.
Thanks, guys. Appreciate it.
Excellent. We have got a question here on the chat from Tshepo. "Good morning, great results. Just one question. What caused the drop in sale of animal feed in South Africa?
What?
What caused the drop of animal feed sales in South Africa? Just because the good grazing at that stage.
Well, we are very small in animal feeding in South Africa. It is really some of the ruminant product that we bring in from Mozambique. If you have foot-and-mouth disease and you have a lot less cattle in feedlots and very good grazing conditions, then it is very natural that your feed sales into that specific part of the market declines. I think that was exactly the perfect storm that we hit in the April, May, June timeframe. But obviously, as the foot-and-mouth disease in particular dissipated, feedlots of stock back up, and the need for that really high energy level and high protein level type of feed into that part of the market has increased. We have seen a nice recovery in that business.
It is not a dial mover in this business.
Not at the Premier level, no.
We've got another question from Marco Ras. "How much of the Millbake margin gain came from lower margin, sorry, lower grain prices, and how much from the new bakeries? What margin can you hold once grain turns inflationary next year?
Yeah, look, I mean, the reality is that lower raw material prices reflect in retail prices quite quickly. It's a highly competitive market, very fragmented space. I mean, we represent no more than 10% of the maize market in South Africa. I honestly don't think that we managed to expand margins because we had grain deflation. I think a lot of that's been passed onto the consumer. I think from our perspective, we much more run a longer- term rand per ton type of marginal contribution on our milling side. We also continue to monitor our marginal contribution on a per loaf basis on the bakery side. We will adjust pricing over time to make sure that we manage those margins in a responsible way.
If you look at our results over the last five years, we've had over 30% increases in grain prices, and we've still sustained our margins. I think that it's really a matter of your ability to be agile, to have good visibility of what your pricing is going to do, to have enough hedging in place so that you have time to make the necessary changes, and then execute with discipline when you need to go and effect price increases in the market. I think all of those elements are a core part of Premier's execution capability, and we will continue to do that. At this point in time, I certainly don't feel that there is a major risk of a contraction of margins as a result of volatility in grain prices.
Yeah. Sumil, remember, during the building phase of Aeroton, we had the cost, but we never had the sales commensurate for that. That's now, so now you've got the sales in the spirit and the cost. That's probably also a bit of a reason for the expansion in the margin.
Were you not subsidizing or taking loaves from the old Pretoria bakery to substitute for Aeroton being offline?
Yeah, but both were open at that time.
Yeah, no, we only closed Hermanstad towards the end of April.
April. Yeah, end of March.
Yeah, end of March. We started to benefit from that cost savings coming through, not having to bake there and transport to Aeroton at the start of this six-month period, as Aeroton ramped up. You have to remember that you also, during your ramp-up phase, you also have initially your production damages are running very high as you're busy optimizing each different parts of the plant. I would say that we really only started to see a nice stabilization in the Aeroton performance sort of in the second half of this current six-month period. I'm quite confident, the same with Middelburg as well. I think that we will see improved performance out of those facilities in particular also in H2.
Just on that, I think Middelburg was a bit of a surprise. I don't think we were expecting you to put up a line in Middelburg. That was supposed to be a depot, correct?
Yeah, it was a depot, Sumil, but I think that it's more commensurate with the fact that we've just always tried to rather talk about what we've done than tell you what we're going to do. That is just an ongoing implementation of that strategy.
Would you actually put in a second line in Middelburg? Is there space for a second line?
I would have to kill you if I tell you.
Yeah, it is just quite interesting that the volumes or the demand is quite strong in the inland markets.
Look, Sumil, we have always said that we are way underrepresented in the inland market. If you look at our market shares by region, we by far had the lowest market share in the biggest bread market in the country. I mean, the core Gauteng market represents 35% of bread volume in the country, and we were way underrepresented. So, just getting our fair share of that market was always our game plan. We have communicated that over the last few years, and I think that we are very confident that we are starting to see that strategy coming to fruition.
Can you mention what you think your inland market share is at the moment?
We still think it is probably sub 20, but not far away from 20%.
Okay.
Where everywhere else it is 30%+ , yeah.
Okay, so there is a lot of headroom still for you to grow in the inland market.
Absolutely.
Okay. We've got a question here from Anda. "Thanks, guys, and congrats on the results. Please, can you provide us a breakdown between formal and informal channels in terms of group revenue? Which channel is growing faster, and are there any material differences in cost to serve?
I think traditionally we've said that depending on the category and the different businesses, that we're sort of in the 60%-70% range of informal trade. There are higher costs and lower costs, there's a lot of differences in terms of serving. I mean, if you supply a product to the Shoprite Group, you have a direct double link going straight into a central DC, and that's it. If you're distributing into the informal trade, you've got multiple 8-ton trucks running with smaller loads, servicing multiple outlets to service that market. On the bread side, it's even more slanted towards a higher cost to serve within the informal trade.
From our perspective, we certainly think that the whole way that we run the business is to be very responsible and make sure that we don't overemphasize one over the other, and that we maintain discipline in making sure that margins are also fairly consistent across those businesses. I think for us, it's more anticipating which one is performing better at which point in time, and it ebbs and flows. I don't think there's a specific long-term trend, and we just make sure that we're on top of it the whole time.
Okay. We're just waiting for more questions or for hands up. I can't see any. On that, the cost savings for or anticipated cost savings with the integration of Rhodes, how long do you think that will actually take to fully extract? I think it'll be more than just the year ahead that you've mentioned previously.
Yeah. I think we will continue to. It is only really done when we have done all the ERP implementation and a lot of other things. I think at this point in time, the first phase is sort of implemented. I think our second phase is underway, and we will have, by middle of next year, we should have implemented most of that. Then there really, there will be a third phase as well, which will look much more at overall synergies across the business where there is further opportunity for optimization. As the increased focus on capital investment and the innovation on the product portfolios also start to come through, we are really looking for an ongoing wave three that will give us the benefit over the next three to five years as well.
I think it is not just about, okay, you have done merchandising, okay, so you have got the cost saving there, and okay, you have done supply chain, now you have got the cost saving there. I think it is an ongoing opportunities, and I think we have certainly implemented what we had identified during due diligence and during merger, that we based our merger case on. But I think that as we move along, there is a host of other opportunities that we will continue to drive and chip away at.
Excellent. Matt, please go ahead. I see you have your hand up.
Sorry. Yeah, Sumil, there are a whole lot of questions in the Q&A, by the way. Just in terms of share buybacks, what is your strategy in terms of the buybacks? Where does it sit in the capital allocation? I mean, you guys do some pretty good forecasting. What is the capacity for buybacks in the next 12 months? Thanks.
Look, Matthew, I think that if you look at the buybacks that we've done so far, it's been when there was certain adverse shareholder movement. The first wave really was on the back of Brait doing another sell-down, and we wanted to just make sure that there's orderly trade in our share and that we mop up a bit of excess liquidity there. A similar thing happened when Capitalworks sold out their 10% stake in July, and we became active and made sure that there's an orderly trade in the shares during that period as well. I think in the short- term, we've still got overdraft debt from the RFG side that we would like to clear.
I think that combined with our capital investment program that is continuing to ramp up, and I mean, we're on track to spend ZAR 1.5 billion on capital investment this year, so there's a lot of money going into that, and it certainly is a priority for us. I think the share buyback program is something we view a little bit more opportunistically, and that is something that we are also cognizant that we want to make sure that we get close to the number of shares that your watering down will have in terms of the long-term incentive programs that are coming to maturity in the next two years or so. We want to try and balance those as well.
But I think for us in the short- term, it's now CapEx, it's get that overdraft paid off completely, make sure we have the money in the bank for what's becoming a big dividend payment now on an annual basis. Then, as we need to, we've got the firepower. If there's some opportunities within the share price, then we will be opportunistic.
Then just another question. To gain market share in Gauteng, what is the strategy? Is it through price or is it through better quality? How should we see that?
Top-quality product delivered every day, on time, on the shelf, and get it in the hands of people to taste it and experience the quality, and then we have always managed to get traction. It is certainly, we have never, Premier has never gone and try and buy market share. We haven't done it in a decade. There is certainly no expectation on our side to do that.
Perfect. Thanks, guys. Well done once again.
Thank you.
Yes, we do have some questions here in the chat. The first one's from Luando from All Weather. "Congratulations on a solid set of results. Does the Virgin Active deal announcement by Brait hasten placing the balance of Premier's stake in your view?
You've got an excellent opportunity to pose that question to Pete Hayward-Butt on Thursday or tomorrow in their results presentation. We are also chomping at the bit to hear the answer, so it would be interesting.
Okay. We've got another question from Luando. To Benny. Sorry, it just moved. "On slide 17 of the presentation, excluding Culinary, how did Groceries EBITDA and margin move year-on-year?
Yeah, so I mean, I think that we've said that we didn't quite have the performance in our sugar confectionery business that we were looking for, and so that's down on prior year, and that's really the main reason for that part of the business not performing exactly as we want to. But as I said, I mean, we've made management changes. We've got some new equipment that we are busy bringing on stream that will also help with some of the efficiencies and especially the inefficient areas where we've had to onboard products quite quickly and then didn't really have the right equipment to make it, et cetera. So, I'm quite confident that we will see an improved performance from that business. So, the Lil-Lets business, which was in there, is doing fine. Remember, some that used to be in there has moved over into the Volpack division.
As we've said, we've actually had quite a good run since July in the some business. So we see some nice, proper green shoots coming out of that business going forward. So, we're very happy with that performance.
There's a follow-on question. "CapEx, including prepayments, was ZAR 759 million or 5.3% of revenue. Once Middelburg and the Culinary depot upgrades are complete, what annual maintenance CapEx should we assume for the enlarged group, and what major growth projects still need funding?
Yeah, I think we need to expect that the current run rate of ZAR 1.5 billion will be sustained for the next foreseeable future.
Yeah.
We've got too many opportunities, especially within the Culinary space as well, that we're busy identifying and that we're going to need to make investments in. You don't sustain 20%+ EPS growth if you don't invest in your core operations and core capability. We have lots of opportunity, and we're going to continue to drive that very hard.
Yeah. At least for the next two years. I mean, after that, it's too far away to guide that.
That would be FY 2027 and 2028?
2028 and 2029.
Question from Siphelele at Matrix. "You mentioned that volumes in certain geographies have stagnated since June. Are we seeing a temporary disruption caused by the spaza closures, or is this indicative of a more structural deterioration in lower-income consumer spending? What are you seeing in terms of basket sizes and purchasing frequency? How is this spaza basket versus the Woolies experience you see through Rhodes?
Look, I think there's always a perception that we must somehow have quite a lot of insight into the informal trade due to our bread business trading into it and all our other product categories. But in actual fact, we actually have very little visibility. I mean, someone like Pieter Engelbrecht at Shoprite and the independent wholesalers and those guys have much stronger insights and much better views, because we never know what our competitors are doing vis-à-vis us. You never know whether it's you or your competitor or the market or the consumers or who it is. The only thing I know is that 400+ spaza shops are no longer operating that used to be delivered to on a daily basis within the KZN market.
Whether that product has resulted in a decline in consumption, whether it's been rerouted into other route-to-market options where the consumers now buy it at the Usave, or whether they get it at Boxer, or whether they get it somewhere else other than a traditional foreign-owned spaza store, we're still in the process of trying to figure that out. We honestly, as I sit here today, I don't really have the answer for you on that. I do get the overall impression that your consumers are definitely reacting somewhat differently as a result of the fuel price, i.e., it costs a lot more to take a taxi to go to a destination store like a big Shoprite. So maybe instead of going three or four times a month, you only go once or twice a month.
Other store formats that are closer to your home benefit because you don't need to incur the transport costs. So, I think there's ongoing developments like that, but one has to understand that, depending on various different assessments, we're talking about an informal trade universe of 120,000- 150,000 stores across the whole of South Africa. To really discern trends and understand what's going on in there at a macro level is of no real value to us. We are engaged on a street-by-street, block-by-block, area-by-area operations every single day, and we just try to make changes and try and anticipate how we need to change and be flexible so that we make sure we service the market.
Kobus, I'm just cognizant of the time. I see we've got three questions. I'm going to combine Palesa's and Wanda's question into one. Great results. Group ROIC has recovered to 20.6% as integration processes progresses. Could the combined business approach Premier's pre-acquisition standalone ROIC of around 28%, and over what timeframe? Would the existing synergy program be sufficient, or would that require further improvements in Culinary's underlying margins and asset utilization?
I think the biggest determining factor here is the fact that we have had to take on ZAR 3.5 billion of intangible assets as part of the transaction. Prior to the deal, your capital base that you used to calculate your ROIC was based on what you actually invested in real-life assets. It was property, plant, and equipment, and working capital investments. Now you sit with this market cap of Rhodes Food Group on your balance sheet, and you now have to go and calculate your ROIC based on this slug of intangible assets that you never had before. I think just due to the nature of how accounting works, it is not really possible for us to get to the same level of ROICs that we had prior to actually doing this transaction.
If we had an opportunity to just buy the assets and the productive assets and pay for that and put that on our balance sheet, I think you would see a much different ROIC. For me, the question you need to ask yourself is, if you really want to look at your productive use of capital that you are putting organically to use, you should actually discard that slug of intangible assets, go and look at what your real return on your productive assets are, and you will see that that will march on at the same trajectory as what Premier previously had on its balance sheet.
Yeah. You will remember that 20.6% is 8% above your cost of capital that we took.
Okay. Yeah, that makes sense. I think the last question is, staff cost in Millbake division grew above inflation. Is this ramp-up related? There is some level of duplicated cost during ramp-up or purely salaries? It is from Ntombowell.
Look, I mean, I think we continue to make investments, and as you bring up bakeries and you build out your distribution into areas that you did not go into before, our long-term expectation is that we will be a significant net creator of new jobs within our business. The opportunities for employment within Premier will continue to grow, and it is part of a growing business operation, and I think it is very natural. It is required in order to actually sustain the growth levels that we are going at.
Wage settlements are in excess of 4% inflation.
Yeah, but wage settlements, you do not settle wages for under 6% or so. I mean, it is still a pipe dream, the 3% inflation target of the Reserve Bank. It is simply just not. For the people at the bottom end of the salary scales and wage scales in South Africa, I think their experienced inflation is still higher than the official overall median inflation rate. I do think it is appropriate that one do give them slightly higher increases on an annual basis.
Yeah. As you increase your routes from your new bakeries, you have to employ more people. So it will definitely increase the salaries. We had the bakeries open during that period. Potch was only closed after the September numbers.
My experience over the longer -term has been that your natural inflation rate on your expense base doesn't really come down below 7%.
Yeah.
The extent to which your expenses grows faster than that, it's usually because you are growing the business somewhere. But to really get your expense base to go up from an inflationary perspective at under 7% is still extremely difficult in this economy and this geographical area that we operate in.
Sorry, is that with the fuel price increases?
No, I'm looking through the cycle, Sumil.
Cycle. Okay.
I am not just talking about the last six months. I am looking sort of through the cycle over a longer-term basis, and I am saying if I take a five-year average, it is not really possible to not have your expense base grow by 7%.
Mm. Excellent. We are at time. We will put up the presentation later today on our research portal and on your website, I guess. So thank you all for dialing in, and thank you to the management team for doing the presentation and answering all the questions.
Fantastic. Thank you for your opportunity, Sumil. Have a good day, everyone.
Also, everyone.
Cheers, guys.
Cheers. Bye.