Oceania Healthcare Limited (NZE:OCA)
New Zealand flag New Zealand · Delayed Price · Currency is NZD
0.7300
+0.0250 (3.55%)
Sep 17, 2026, 5:00 PM NZST
← View all transcripts

AGM 2021

Jun 24, 2021

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and fellow shareholders. Thank you for joining us today for the annual meeting of Oceania Healthcare Limited. I am pleased to advise that this meeting has been properly convened and the notice of meeting duly given. There being a quorum of shareholders present, I declare the annual meeting open. I am Elizabeth Coutts, Chair of Oceania Healthcare. To begin, I would like to take this opportunity to introduce to you those people alongside me today. On my immediate right is Brent Pattison, our Chief Executive Officer. I would like to welcome Brent to his first annual meeting as Chief Executive. Although Brent was only appointed to the role in March 2021, he brings a great deal of experience to the role with over 10 years experience in the aged care and retirement village sectors.

We're delighted with Brent's appointment, and it's great to see him continuing to execute Oceania's growth strategy. Alongside Brent is Alan Isaac, an independent director. Alan is chair of our audit committee and a member of the remuneration committee. To my left is Dame Kerry Prendergast, an independent director. Dame Kerry is chair of the clinical and health and safety committee. Next to Dame Kerry is Greg Tomlinson, an independent director. Greg is the chair of the development committee. Joining us today by video link is Sally Evans. Welcome, Sally. Great to see you pop up there. Sally is an independent director. Sally is chair of the remuneration committee and a member of the clinical health and safety committee. Sally lives in Sydney, and due to the pause in the travel bubble between New Zealand and New South Wales, she is unable to join us here in person today.

Patrick McCawe, an Independent Director, also resides in Sydney, and he is unable to travel here today for the same reason, so he sends his apologies. Patrick is a member of the Audit Committee. Also in attendance today, there are members of our executive team. Kathryn Waugh on the end. Stand up, Kathryn. I've got to introduce Kathryn, is our Chief Financial Officer. Anna Thorburn is our Group General Counsel. Mark Stockton is our Group General Manager Property and Development, and Jo Copeland is General Manager, People and Culture. Unfortunately, Dr. Frances Hughes, our Group General Manager, Nursing and Clinical Strategy, is unable to be here with us today as she is en route to Australia. Also in attendance with us today are representatives from PricewaterhouseCoopers, our auditors, including our Lead Audit Partner, Leo Foliaki. Thank you, Leo, for joining us.

Our legal advisors are Chapman Tripp, and thank you for coming here, Roger Wallis. Our voting. When we come to the formal business of the meeting, I shall put various motions to the meeting that will need to be seconded. Where appropriate, I shall give an opportunity for discussion and then put the motion to the vote. In accordance with the NZX listing rules, voting will be by poll, and I will ask only shareholders and/or proxy holders to vote, please. PricewaterhouseCoopers, our auditors, will act as scrutineer. The results of the meeting will be published to the market later today. I will give further directions on voting later in the meeting. For now, you should all have a voting paper which was given to you when you registered.

If you do not, can you please indicate now by raising your hand and a member of Computershare team will assist you. Is anyone without a voting paper that requires a voting paper? No, we look like we've been well catered for. At the appropriate time, should you wish to address a comment or question to the Chair, please raise your hand and we will bring a microphone to you. By way of introduction, please introduce your name, whether you are a shareholder or a proxy holder, the name of the shareholder represented. The notice of meeting was mailed or emailed to all shareholders and contains the business to be dealt with this meeting. Apologies. Are there any apologies that anyone would like to have recorded, please? No, there's no apologies. A number of shareholders have appointed proxies to cast their vote.

418 shareholders holding 238,835,962 shares, which represents 33.88% of the shares on issue, are represented by valid proxies. The board is holding 231,951,666 of these proxy votes. I will advise on the number of proxies held by the board to be voted in favor after each resolution that will be put before the meeting today. The minutes of the previous annual meeting were reviewed at the first meeting of directors of the company following the annual meeting and were confirmed as a true and correct record of the meeting. The minutes are available for review on the company's website. The Group General Counsel also has copies available should any shareholder wish to review them at the conclusion of this meeting.

The first item of business is to consider and receive the annual report and the financial statements for the 10-month period ended 31st of March 2021, and the audit report thereon. The annual report containing the financial statements and the annual report for the 10-month period ending 31st of March 2021 is available to shareholders on the company's website and was circulated either electronically or in hard copy form to all shareholders on the register at the time of mailing. We shall take the annual report as having been read. Before seeking your comments on the annual report, I will provide you with an update on your company's performance. This will be followed by an address from Brent Pattison, our Chief Executive. This is the first annual shareholders meeting since we changed our full year balance date to 31st of March from 31st of May.

Much of the financial performance set out in the annual report and the financial statements contains a shorter full year period of 10 months and covers the trading period from 1st of June 2020 to 31st of March 2021, rather than a full 12-month period. We are pleased to observe that both of our underlying metrics being underlying earnings before interest, tax, and depreciation, and amortization, and net profit after tax, are up 8% and 4% respectively on the prior corresponding 10-month period from 1st of June 2019 to 31st of March 2020. These strong financial results have been underpinned by record sales volumes, strong key performance, and the successful delivery of our new developments, which we will outline later in the meeting. Brent will take you through the financial result for the 10-month period ending 31st of March 2021 shortly.

One of the highlights of the period was the successful completion of an oversubscribed NZD 100 million equity raise in March 2021. This equity raise was undertaken by way of an NZD 80 million placement and an NZD 20 million retail offer. It was great to see existing and new shareholders supportive of Oceania's growth. The proceeds of the equity raise were used to fund two new acquisitions. The first acquisition was the acquisition of Waterford in Hobsonville Point, Auckland. This village provides Oceania with an attractive development in a highly sought-after location and currently comprises 64 independent living villas and 36 independent living apartments, as well as a vibrant resident community. The existing site also offers development land that has resource consent to develop approximately 60 apartments. This is a highly attractive brownfield bolt-on acquisition to Oceania's existing portfolio.

Since taking ownership in late April, Oceania has already secured new sales of apartments. Oceania has also completed the acquisition of its leasehold site in Franklin, also in Auckland, together with some adjacent bare land. Franklin is a key location in the broader Auckland region and part of the fast-growing southwestern corridor. We are in the process of finalizing development plans for the site with a mixture of independent living units, independent living apartments, and Care Suites to be constructed on the site. These recent acquisitions signal a pivot in our strategy to the identification and execution of value-accretive M&A activity, as well as growing our greenfield presence. In addition to acquiring these two new sites, Oceania is making good progress on its development projects.

Some of our directors visited our Eden, Waimarie, and Lady Allum development sites in Auckland last month, and it was pleasing to see how each of these developments is taking shape. Brent will again provide more detail on each of our development projects later in the meeting. Oceania has continued to focus on improving and refining resident experience. Everything we do is designed for our residents and the things that matter the most to them, being their identity, connection, and purpose. There has been increased scrutiny of the retirement village sector recently, and the terms that operators offer to their residents. The retirement commissioner has recommended an urgent review of the retirement villages legislative framework. The industry's response through the Retirement Villages Association is that the commission's call for an urgent review of the legislation is unnecessary and excessive.

The RVA is suggesting the Retirement Commissioner's Office instead focus its efforts on working with the industry to implement a series of improvements that are already underway. Oceania is an active member of the RVA, with Brent being a member of the RVA Executive Committee. We take our responsibilities as a retirement village operator very seriously. As noted in the annual report, Oceania has made tangible progress with our sustainability initiatives over the last three to six months, as it's continuing to work towards its goal of becoming carbon neutral in the future. One of the main contributors to Oceania's waste is the disposal of incontinence products. It's pleasing to see some initiatives being developed to address these issues. For example, in recent months, Oceania is participating in a trial of v ermi composting of incontinence products.

We're looking forward to hearing how the trial is progressing to see whether this is a project that can be rolled out on a larger scale. Directors have visited many of our sites around the country since last year's annual shareholders meeting, both as a board and individually. As I noted before, some of us visited the Auckland development sites last month, and we enjoyed holding our March board meeting at the Bellevue in Christchurch. We appreciate meeting with our staff and residents at sites to observe the culture and day-to-day operations and receive feedback, which we can then incorporate in our continuous improvement processes. The landscape in which Oceania operates has changed significantly since our listing in 2017. As you would have seen from our corporate governance statement, over the last two years, your directors have attended a significant number of additional meetings during this period.

This has resulted in increased demands on directors' time. Last year, there was considerable heavy lifting to do by directors with the bond issue, acquisitions, capital raising, the change in financial reporting date, as well as governing in the challenging COVID-19 environment. Looking forward, directors' workload will increase with more legislative and regulatory changes being proposed, stakeholders' expectation increasing to consider and monitor a broader range of non-financial measures together with governing through the ongoing uncertainties of a COVID-19 environment. Given this environment and Oceania being positioned for performance and growth, your board considers it may be beneficial to consider appointing additional board members. The directors' skills mix was provided in the 2019 annual report and is available on Oceania's website. The skills matrix has served Oceania well to date.

Over the next year, the board will consider additional skills that would be beneficial to Oceania as well as start planning for board succession over the next five years. The board will also undertake a review of directors' fees in the next year, noting that fees to each director have not changed since Oceania's listing in 2017. The maximum aggregate amount of remuneration payable by Oceania to directors for fees and board committee responsibilities was fixed at NZD 582,500 in the product disclosure statement dated 31st of March 2017, when there were five directors. With the subsequent appointment of two additional directors and the resignation of one director, the pool is now NZD 672,500 per annum for six directors, inclusive additional remuneration for committee chairs.

As part of the intended review, the board will consider the introduction of additional payments should significant additional board work be required over and above usual duties.

This is an approach taken by many other NZX-listed companies. At this time, Oceania is in the early stage of considering these matters, and we'll provide an update in due course. Dividends. We were pleased to declare and pay a final dividend of NZD 0.021 per share, which takes full-year dividends non-imputed to NZD 0.034 per share and represents 55% of underlying net profit after tax. This reflects strong trading performance and operating cash flow throughout the period. The dividend reinvestment plan for our New Zealand and Australian shareholders was also applicable for this dividend. Looking ahead, we'll be releasing our financial results for the six months to 30 September 2021 in late November 2021. In closing, I would like to thank our team, our dedicated staff across all of our 46 sites.

They've worked extremely hard over the past 18 months in challenging conditions to keep our residents safe, each other safe, and all the while providing outstanding care and service to our residents. I would like to thank the board. Your directors have a broad and complementary range of skills backed by years of experience, wisdom, and your input has been invaluable, particularly in these difficult times. Finally, I would like to thank you for all of your support of Oceania and for attending the meeting this afternoon. We remain committed to transforming the aged care and retirement village sector by putting our residents at the heart of what we do and to define Oceania as a provider of better outcomes and growth. I'd now like to hand over to Brent, our Chief Executive, who will present our financial results and talk about the execution of Oceania's strategy. Brent.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thanks, Liz. As Liz has already said, a very warm welcome to everyone here today. It's a fantastic day looking at the sun out on Eden Park. You will see from the front page of our annual report that we have led with Believe in Better. This is far more than a catchphrase. It signals our intent to build upon past achievements and to challenge ourselves to be even better in the delivery of a resident experience, the positive impact we make in our local communities, programmed growth for the business, shaping perceptions around aging, being alert to our carbon footprint, as well as making a conscious effort to make Oceania a great place to work. Touching on the financial overview. Firstly, I will take you through the financial results for the 10-month period ended 31 March 2021.

As Liz has already mentioned, unaudited underlying EBITDA of NZD 56.2 million for the 10 months ended 31 March 2021 was 8% higher than prior corresponding period of the 10 months to 31 March 2020 unaudited. We've delivered an increase in our premium revenue strategy, a step change in our sales volume, and strong underlying EBITDA growth. This was largely as a result of both strong sales of new developments and resale volumes in the current period, as well as the ongoing receipt of deferred management fees from developments completed in prior periods. Oceania's total assets as at 31 March 2021 are NZD 1.9 billion, compared with NZD 1.5 billion as at 31 May 2020.

This material increase is due in part to the reversal of CBRE Limited's COVID-19 related valuation assumptions that had led to a decrease in the value of Oceania's existing investment property assets in the prior year. The completion of key development sites, as well as reflecting strong sales volumes of new retirement village units and Care Suites that have been developed over the last two years. For the 10 months to 31 March 2021, operating cash flow was NZD 96 million, compared to the NZD 99.4 million for the 12-month period to 31 May 2020. This reflects strong sales volumes over that 10-month period to 31 March 2021. As at 31 March 2021, Oceania had current drawn debt and bonds of NZD 329.9 million and NZD 79.9 million of cash, representing NZD 225 million of undrawn net debt headroom.

This low gearing, coupled with sufficient bank facilities in place, puts Oceania in a sound position for future growth and enables us to continue to execute on our development pipeline. The effects of COVID-19 have continued to have an impact on the business in the 10-month period to 31 March 2021.

As we have noted previously, the business showed resilience throughout the COVID-19 related disruptions, given its focus on care. In the 10-month period to 31 March 2021, Oceania operated under Alert Level 2.5 or higher restrictions for 53 calendar days. This is an addition to the 50 days of Alert Level 3 or higher restrictions in the 12 months to 31 May 2020. Despite the shorter 10-month trading period and the number of days operating under lockdown restrictions, we recorded 388 total ORA sales in the 10-month period to 31 March 2021, which is an increase of 9% or 33 units and Care Suites on a full 12-month period to 31 May 2020. When this is considered on a 10-month corresponding period basis, the business actually achieved 25% growth in volumes across both our units and Care Suites.

Our 194 new sales included over 75% of sales outside of the Auckland region, including villa, apartment, and Care Suites sales in Gracelands, which is in Hastings, Green Gables in Nelson, Elderslie in Upper Hutt, The Bayview in Tauranga, and Awatere in Hamilton. Despite this regional bias, our development margin remains strong at 26%. Our 194 resales in the 10-month period were up 17% on the 12-month period to 31 May 2020. It has certainly been another busy year for our property and development team. Despite ongoing COVID-19 disruptions, we delivered 217 units in Care Suites across our brownfield portfolio in three geographical regions. This was the number of new units in Care Suites that we had intended to build over the full 12-month period, so it was very pleasing to achieve this result for the shorter 10-month period.

Overall group occupancy has increased to 92.4% for the 10-month period, compared to 91.5% for the full year 2020. In terms of our strategy, we are focusing on being the provider of choice for critical infrastructure and essential services for older people. We adopt a people-centric approach in everything that we do, whether it's in the design of our buildings, so that our Care Suites can accommodate couples, or our hospitality-led dining experiences, or the investment in our nurse practitioners so that we can continue to provide outstanding care to our residents. Turning now to our people. Our people are at the very heart of what we do. We are pleased to announce that we have made three senior appointments prior to 31 March 2021 to further strengthen our leadership team.

Kathryn Waugh has been promoted to the role of chief financial officer after joining Oceania in 2009 as financial controller. Kathryn is a qualified chartered accountant, and prior to joining Oceania, she held senior roles at PricewaterhouseCoopers. Anna Thorburn has been promoted to group general counsel. Anna joined Oceania in 2012 after having previously worked as a Senior Solicitor in Corporate and Commercial Teams at Russell McVeagh. Both Kathryn and Anna have been heavily involved in Oceania's corporate transactions over the last five years, including the IPO in 2017, the corporate bond in 2020, and the most recent capital raise and acquisitions in March 2021. Jo Copeland joined the Oceania team in March 2021 as General Manager of People and Culture.

Jo started her career as an employment lawyer and then spent the last 20 years in human resource leadership across a variety of industries, including IT, telecommunications, professional services, and pharmaceuticals. We've seen some other changes within our executive team. Mark Stockton is now the Group General Manager, Property and Development. In addition to overseeing Oceania's current development projects, Mark is also responsible for identifying potential land banks and development sites for further greenfield development. Dr. Frances Hughes is now Group General Manager, Nursing and Clinical Strategy. Dr. Hughes was instrumental last year in leading the industry response to COVID-19, and her work in this area has continued with the rollout of the COVID-19 vaccines. In addition, Dr. Hughes is the Chair of NZACA Nursing Leadership Group, which provides nursing leadership and focuses on ensuring that registered nurses in aged care are supported to work to their full potential.

Over the last year, we have demonstrated a continued commitment to invest in clinical training and development for our staff so that we can offer a genuine career development pathway and learning opportunities for all staff that enable to practice to their full potential. We strongly encourage our people to undertake professional development as clinical leadership and education are key to the delivery of quality care, improving overall skill levels and surveillance activities. We are also offering our employee share scheme to all permanent employees again this year. The scheme has achieved a 77% uptake in September 2020, and it's great for our staff to own a piece of Oceania and to further reward them for the vital role that they play in Oceania's ongoing success. I'll now move on to an overview of our current developments and our development pipeline.

As Liz mentioned earlier, we have continued to make good progress on our development sites during the year and have proven our ability to execute a brownfields pipeline. We currently have 402 villas, apartments, and Care Suites under construction across six regions. We noted in our annual report that 221 units and Care Suites are due for completion during FY 2022. I'll now provide an update on each of those developments in turn. In April 2021, we completed the construction of 49 luxury apartments and a new community center at Eden in Auckland. Eden Village is a well-established village located in the heart of Mount Eden. With the completion of new apartments, the village now comprises 67 Care Suites and 89 independent living apartments and outstanding community spaces. Some residents have already moved into the new independent living apartments. We are continuing to take applications for these.

We're expecting to complete the development of 113 Care Suites at our Lady Allum Village in Milford during the second half of full year 2022. Building works for this project are significantly advanced, and the completion of this new care development will enable further site optimization. Stage 2B of the Bellevue in Tauranga, comprising 39 independent living apartments, is also scheduled for completion before Christmas of this year. We completed 35 independent living apartments at the Bay View in March 2021 and have already seen strong sales from this premium development. We're also scheduled to complete a further 18 new independent living villas at Gracelands in Hastings during full year 2022. Gracelands is a highly sought-after village, and following the successful sell down of the previous two stages, we're seeing strong levels of pre-sales in this final stage of the villa development.

We are looking forward to welcoming our newest residents to Gracelands in September 2021. We are expecting to complete two villas at Stoke in Nelson in the next two weeks. Stoke is a well-located village on the main road. It offers a range of affordable one and two-bedroom villas. We're intending to continue to develop two new bedroom villas at this village as space becomes available on-site. Looking further ahead, we are progressing other significant developments at stage two in Awatere, which is in Hamilton, and Waimarie Street in St. Heliers Bay here in Auckland. Construction of 63 independent living apartments and a new community center is progressing well at Awatere. This development is expected to be completed in the first half of full year 2023. The property already comprises 39 independent living apartments, as well as 90 Care Suites that were completed in 2019.

The completion of 63 additional independent living apartments will complement the existing offering at Awatere, which is a very well-located village close to the center of Hamilton on the banks of the Waikato River. Our flagship development at Waimarie Street is also progressing, with groundworks well underway. The village is in one of Auckland's most sought-after locations, with 360-degree views of Auckland and the Waitematā Harbor. Once completed, the village will comprise 79 independent living apartments and 31 Care Suites, and we've already had a high level of initial interest, with a significant number of inquiries already registered. As you will see from the video that we're about to play, as well as offering magnificent views across Auckland, the site also boasts the largest tower crane in New Zealand, and we're expecting this development to be completed in full year 2023.

In conclusion, we are focusing on delivering performance and growth to our investor community moving forward, while also maintaining and continuing to deliver clinical and operational excellence. We are intending to build on the success of our projects over the last period and to continue to invest in resource and infrastructure to achieve this. As I've explained, we have a significant development pipeline to build upon, including both brownfield and greenfield opportunities. Thank you everyone for your ongoing support.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you, Brent. We now move to question time. Are there any questions arising from the annual report, from my address, or the presentation from Brent? If you wish to ask a question, please raise your hand and we will bring a microphone to you. Please advise your name, whether you are a shareholder or a proxy advisor, and the name of the shareholder represented. We have a gentleman with his hand raised just back there. Thank you.

Alastair Duncan
Shareholder, E tū Incorporated

Alastair Duncan, shareholder with E tū Incorporated, one of the unions for our staff here at Oceania. I want to thank the board for the presentations, congratulate them on the work of building better, and particularly acknowledge the dynamic that now sees a board with a proper gender balance and some recent board appointments where we see women. My eyes are drawn to the poster on the right-hand corner of the woman who looks interested in something going on, and behind her are a series of placards, and I've been trying to work out what those placards might say. What I'm mindful of is I can find out how much our board members receive for the important work they do. I can find out how much our senior managers do for the important work they do.

Because I work for the union that represents the staff, I know what you might not. I know that too many of the women who may be behind those placards, who work in our cleaning, our laundry, our kitchen, our administration roles, are paid on or close to the minimum wage. My question is,four years ago, the organization Oceania aspired to become a living wage employer. What steps have been taken so that those women who continue to deliver the extraordinary service that underpins us are actually valued properly? Thank you.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

Thank you for your question. Brent, would you like to address that first?

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Do I need [crosstalk].

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

Oh, [crosstalk].

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Sorry. A very good question. Obviously, staff are incredibly important to us, and if we think about the staff that we have across our organization, it's very large. We have over 420 registered nurses. We have over 550 kitchen and household staff. It has been part of the desire of the company to attract, retain, and provide the right sort of work environment for those staff. We do pride ourselves on paying our registered nurses well above both our peers and what we're contractually funded for as it relates to nurses. We know that this is an area of skill shortage in New Zealand. A new grad coming into our employment starts around NZD 29, and as their skill levels increase, we're paying around NZD 39 for a senior registered nurse.

Last year, this category of staff received a 3%-7% pay increase to compensate them for the amazing job that they had done during COVID-19 keeping our residents safe. Our kitchen and household staff are paid between NZD 20 and NZD 22.51. They received a 3% increase in July, and then a further 2% increase in April. As it relates to equal pay staff, we have about 1,500 staff that are paid in line with legislation. Each year, we assess where we sit relative to our peers, we assess where we sit relative to our market. We're undertaking both wage rate, but also environmental factors to ensure that we have a motivated, engaged, and well looked after staff in the execution of what we're doing.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

Thanks, Brent. Thank you, Brent. We have another question from a gentleman.

Rob Chamberlain
Shareholder, Private Investor

My name is Rob Chamberlain. I am a shareholder. If anybody here posts on Trade Me, my post there is Maverick. I have got three questions. I know I am only allowed one, but I am hoping my friends here will give me a couple. My first question is a technical one, and it is on the net new Care Suite sales. Your Care Suite sales have been predictable, which has been good until this year when it went a bit strange. I had worked out you were supposed to sell about 60 in the first half of the year, and you sold 84. In the second half of the year, adjusted up, so it is six months, obviously it was four months, you sold 33, which is well under the 60 I was expecting.

It raises a couple of concerns because you've said that it's not a seasonal problem in one of your other meetings. Either you sold them too quick in the first half and didn't have any left in the second half, which means perhaps they were a bit cheap, which may be intentional. The other concern is that the demand dropped off a cliff on the second half, which is a problem. My question is, if you could comment on why they were so heavy and high in the first half and so low in the second. If you could just give a general chat on how demand is going on the new Care Suites and the resales, particularly in the recent deliveries that are starting to mature of Meadowbank, Sands, and Bayview.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yes. Okay. Well, I'll attempt to answer that question if I can, Liz.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

Thank you, Brent.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

I think what we'd say is we had 388 sales. 194 of those were new sales, and 194 of those were resales. The Care Suite product sold very well in that initial first six-month period that you've just referred to. There is often a seasonal impact if we think about available days during that Christmas period. People either delaying a decision to move into an independent living unit or delaying a decision around care. Given that care is a needs-based product, we do see some fluctuations in the purchase. Some of it's represented in the availability of stock. We're materially up as it relates to sales momentum year-on-year in Care Suites and indeed ILUs. We have just progressed quite a significant new delivery around Care Suite product. That will be part of what we hope to grow into in this new financial year.

I think unpacking your question, there's nothing untoward in terms of that last period. It was only a four-month period, so it was a difficult period, disrupted to a degree by Christmas, January, February summer holidays. Also there was still some lingering COVID-19 disruption in that period as well, which accounted for some softening around Care Suite. As it relates to new demand, we're seeing very strong demand for our product. People have realized that to be in our facilities and in our care is a great place to be. We've seen renewed inquiry into our product, and we are seeing strong sales momentum in both new sale product that we have available and resale that we're making up and down the country.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

Thank you.

Rob Chamberlain
Shareholder, Private Investor

That was the answer I was hoping for. When you said it wasn't seasonal previously, it threw me off. The second question's real easy. This is probably for Greg or for Liz, being the building people. Can you comment on the supply issues we're hearing around the country and cost of tradies, how that might be affecting Oceania's pipeline and budgets?

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

Greg, do you want to answer that?

Greg Tomlinson
Independent Director and Chair of the Development Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yeah, sure. Yeah. I'm not going to hear anything.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

You've got Mark in the front row as well.

Greg Tomlinson
Independent Director and Chair of the Development Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

That's right. Well, I might get Mark to step in if I can't answer it all. You're right, that there is pressure in labor and resources, particularly materials, with some large price escalation. Now, what I'm pleased to say under our model, what we've got is fixed price contracts. We're actually sitting in a very good position. That's not to say, as we go into our new projects, there will be escalation in pricing. Hopefully, that will be captured in sales.

Rob Chamberlain
Shareholder, Private Investor

What about supply issues?

Greg Tomlinson
Independent Director and Chair of the Development Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Supply. Well, we're resourced up to handle that. We do a lot of that internally. We really manage. It's probably not the right word, but we certainly have a great oversight into the materials, particularly for the subcontractors. We're here as a watching eye on everybody to make sure we can get our projects completed on time. I know in instances we have invested in storage. In certain items where we know they're hard to procure, we've actually bought in early, and we are paying for that storage of those items.

Rob Chamberlain
Shareholder, Private Investor

May I ask one more?

Greg Tomlinson
Independent Director and Chair of the Development Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

By all means.

Rob Chamberlain
Shareholder, Private Investor

This one is probably for you, Brent. I'm very nervous, sorry. This one's for you, Brent. Sorry. With the government regulations that you touched on earlier looming, the overhaul, my question is, can you give your opinion on what they might be asking for? We've heard all kinds of things from something reasonable to, well, in my opinion, unreasonable sharing, capital gain, and all that stuff. What might they be asking for and what it might look like? More importantly, would that actually affect Oceania materially? Are you doing this kind of stuff already with your contracts?

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yeah. I would like to think that what people are most interested in is the resident voice. If legislation is improving and securing resident voice, both as it relates to the services that we and others provide, then that's a good start. Now, we've already set ourselves the challenge of doing that, and that's part of a change in our marketing brief around Believe in Better, setting that expectation for ourselves as an organization. I think there has been a lot of commentary in the press, and it's actually hard for people to make sense of it. Oceania holds itself to a very high standard as it relates to the services that it provides. A number of the topics that have been canvassed by the retirement commissioner are things that we already had well in hand.

We're very sensitive to residents leaving our care and having weekly fees continued or independent residents with weekly fees continuing. We've always been in the practice of stopping those immediately. We're very sensitive to buying back residents' apartments or villas or Care Suites as they vacate because that's the very nature of where we make our profits by reselling that product. I think if the legislation and the commentary focuses on what we're providing as a service and encouraging participation as people age, and we know there's a very strong tailwind of an aging population, if that's where the focus is, then we're totally supportive of that. We are not supportive of the narrative around urgent review. The sector provides fantastic services to residents. As a consequence of that, we're going to continue to speak into that just through what we do.

We'll see that with admissions, we'll see that with the services, we'll see happy and full villages through that provision of service. I sit on both the Retirement Villages Association board and the New Zealand Aged Care Association board, and am actively interested in those things that are in the industry and actually getting some facts out there. We surveyed 95% of the resident population, I'm talking as a sector, and have had very high approval rates. We wouldn't characterize residents as vulnerable. Residents in our care are intelligent. They've been involved in many property decisions over their life, and the way in which they contract with us is relatively straightforward, and they seek independent advice and have an opportunity to change their mind. It's actually hard to get cut through, but the best thing we can do is just keep delivering great service.

Rob Chamberlain
Shareholder, Private Investor

Okay. That's me done. Thank you for your patience, and congratulations on a great year getting through COVID and your two acquisitions this year. Thank you very much.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you. Hello.

Carly VanCamp
Shareholder, Private Investor

Hi. Carly VanC amp, shareholder. I've been hearing some alarming stories about the porosity of cheap Chinese steel that has gone into southern CBD builds. I'm asking about your procurement, especially when supplies are in short supply. Where are you sourcing your steel and concrete from?

Greg Tomlinson
Independent Director and Chair of the Development Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

That's a very good question. Well, concrete, that's pretty obvious where that's coming from.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Local.

Greg Tomlinson
Independent Director and Chair of the Development Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

That's local. Mark, just on steel, we're very stringent on everything meeting standards. I suspect there's some risk, of course, but Mark, maybe you would like to step in and give some further depth.

Mark Stockton
Group General Manager of Property and Development, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Does it work? Yeah, here we go. You are quite right. There's been instances of reports in the press around steel from China. We did find it on one of our jobs, and we've removed it all, and that was two or three years ago. We're sourcing all our stuff, as Greg's already mentioned, we've got our standard contracts in place, our specifications that clearly stipulate what contractors can and can't do. We're very much around getting our levels of compliance, our documentation. Some of our stuff does come from overseas, that's just the nature of the game. It's making sure that you're employing competent contractors via our standard contracts to make sure of the surety of supply.

Carly VanCamp
Shareholder, Private Investor

Is it coming from China?

Mark Stockton
Group General Manager of Property and Development, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Some of it will do. Absolutely.

Carly VanCamp
Shareholder, Private Investor

Are you testing it all?

Mark Stockton
Group General Manager of Property and Development, Oceania Healthcare Limited

No, we rely on the independent testing and validation that comes with the product. We don't physically independently test ourselves. We have our consultants who go through the checking process to make sure the product meets the building codes in New Zealand. It's also independently verified and checked by council as well as part of building consent process.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

John. Okay. Oh, sorry.

Hayley Ching
Shareholder, Private Investor

Sorry. My name is Hayley Ching. I'm shareholder of this company. Just to say a little bit about the steel. What about the Tiwai Point in the South Island? They are making steel. Can they supply those steel to me, to us? Yeah. What should I say, I had built my own house 20 years ago, and I used New Zealand Steel for one of the beamings, and it's really good. There are two earthquakes happened to my house, I was at home, and one is 4.8 something, around the Rangitoto Island. What should I say? I was sitting in my chair suddenly like bungee jump. It just went down and then went up. At first I don't know what's happening. At the 6:00 P.M. news is earthquake.

When I look at the house, nothing wrong. Really nothing wrong. Both. The house built by New Zealand Steel is really number one. Not to save money, but to have the best product. Yeah. Thank you.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

Thank you. Thank you for that. That's good that you had a good experience.

John Boscawen
Proxy Holder, Hobbs Enterprises

Thank you. My name's John Boscawen. I'm a proxy holder on behalf of Hobbs Enterprises, a shareholder in the company. Look, my questions relate around the theme of parking. Before I raise them, let me just first of all congratulate the directors and the management on obviously running this business during the period of COVID. It was very difficult for all people. I've had the privilege of visiting most of the company's facilities, including all of the facilities you mentioned today. I think you're building some of the best facilities in the country, and I'd be very surprised if there's any facility that can beat Waimarie Street once it's completed. Having said that, building premium facilities requires obtaining premium prices, requires you providing premium facilities. If you look at a place like The Sands or Meadowbank, you've fully provided underground car parking.

Yet when I go to Bellevue in Christchurch, which is where the directors held their meeting in March, I don't see any underground car parking. I see car parking totally on grade. I know the first stage is only 22 independent apartments, and most of that building is Care Suites, and most of the Care Suite clientele won't be driving. You are planning to build some more independent units alongside it. My first question relates to Bellevue. Are you satisfied with the parking arrangements in Bellevue? The way I see it, a very active 82-year-old, 85-year-old wanting to go shopping is going to have to walk out in winter with an umbrella to their car and bring their groceries back with an umbrella.

I think that's a problem, and I think that will, you may prove me wrong, but it will impact your ability to get premium prices at Bellevue. That's my first question.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yeah. If I can tackle that, John, I think it's a very important point. Thank you for your positive comments about our build profile, as I know that you have visited a number of our sites. Part of the reason why we have on-grade parking at Bellevue was to do with the resource consent and just the street frontage as it relates to Windermere, so Windermere Street. We are sensitive to the local environment, and Christchurch can be cool over the winter months, as we know. One of the things that we're thinking about, because there isn't the provision of underground on-site parking, before we get underway on our next stage of development, is we have the ability to put in some overhead canopies for parking.

We also are thinking about the provision of some form of concierge car parking activity to support residents for those more inclement days, as you describe, grabbing groceries out of the car and making their way along and into their apartments. We have 26 apartments. There's plenty of parking on the site. As part of our resource consent, we weren't able to put the normal canopies that you might see, for argument's sake, in a shopping car park, which provides some of that additional protection. That is very much on our mind, John. It is good to raise it. We do think about design, and we certainly put our hand up when we get it wrong and try to do better as we move forward. We are thinking sensitively about that particular site.

We have another site in the i n Tauranga, we were doing a multi-stage development of apartments. There's some villas on that property that has some disruption. We put a concierge car parking service in place for a small number of disrupted residents to just be sensitive to the very need that you're talking about.

John Boscawen
Proxy Holder, Hobbs Enterprises

Okay. Well, Sorry.

Greg Tomlinson
Independent Director and Chair of the Development Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Sorry, John. Just to add to that. I don't know which Is that working? That's better. One of the key concerns in that Christchurch location is liquefaction. We've made sure that we are not going to ever have that problem with that design. I think that's important to note.

John Boscawen
Proxy Holder, Hobbs Enterprises

Thank you. The point you make, well made, and I guess it highlights the fact that I could have this private conversation with Brent myself, but I'm raising it publicly because it's a chance to talk to all the directors. Mr. Tomlinson, I know you've got a big personal interest in this company. My money is with yours, so I take some comfort that you're representing both of us. Let's go back to Bayview.

Greg Tomlinson
Independent Director and Chair of the Development Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

John, all of us.

John Boscawen
Proxy Holder, Hobbs Enterprises

Let's go back to Bayview. Brent, you've built 35 independent units there. My understanding is there's only about car parking for about 30 in that underground car park. You are completing, you say today, a further 39 later this year. Essentially, only one person or one apartment in two can have undercover car parking. You also were proposing, I assume, solar to build at least two, if not three more blocks. My understanding is they don't have underground car parking, the ratio of people who enjoy undercover access might only be one person in five or one unit in five. Just like Waimarie Street is in the heart of the wealthiest part of New Zealand.

Bayview is very well located in central Tauranga. You've got a tremendous chance to create a premium product and get a premium return. If people who have got NZD 1 million or NZD 1.5 million to spend on an independent apartment find that, "Hey, I've got to go and park my car." If it's out by Waihi Road, it'll be 200 meters. It'll be impossible, and you'll basically deny yourself a sale. I guess the reason I raise it, finally, my final point with the directors is I do think you need to look at the design of that Tauranga to maximize the returns. Thank you.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yeah. I think that's very useful feedback, John. I guess we're also conscious as we think about car parking, and those future stages that you've mentioned at Bayview, just what's happening with motor vehicles generally. We are thinking about sustainability. We're thinking about our carbon footprint. We're thinking about the costs of underground car park. We've got an eye to the premium product. We are a premium operator, as it relates to the new developments that we have underway. We have seen as we've canvassed residents' voice around car parking, that that ratio has come below one car park, one resident. It sort of sits around 0.8. We've also got an eye to the future in terms of where motor vehicle transportation is going and the need that residents may be coming into our apartment living, without a car or sensitive to selling a car.

Recognizing that we have fantastic amenity which allows them to still access the community, still access our transportation options on site. It's very good that you've raised it, and we're balancing the demands of both of that as we think about those future stages. We are not out of the ground entirely in Bayview, which is going to be a magnificent property until sort of three, four years from now as it's fully realized. That's part of the balance that we're working through, John.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

Thank you, John. That was an easier questioning than the board gave you, Brent.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

It was easier than the board paper. You must have read my board paper, John.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

Do we have any other questions? No other questions. Thank you. I will now move to the formal part of the meeting. All items of business are ordinary resolutions. To be passed, they require approval by a simple majority of more than 50% of the votes of shareholders entitled to vote and voting on the resolutions. Voting will be by poll. Each share held by a shareholder confers one vote. To cast your vote, please complete your voting paper by ticking for, against, or abstain in the appropriate place for each resolution when I invite you to vote on the resolution. Voting papers will be collected at the end of the meeting by Computershare. If you have any difficulty, please raise your hand and a member of Computershare team will assist you. Re-election of directors. We move to next item, which relates to the election of directors.

Under Rule 2.7.1 of the NZX Listing Rules, a director must not hold office without being re-elected past the third annual meeting following that director's appointment or three years, whichever is longer. In this case, Alan Isaac offers himself for re-election as a director of the company. The board has determined that in its view, if re-elected, Alan Isaac will continue to be a non-independent director. For the purposes of the NZX Listing Rules. Alan Isaac stands for re-election with the support of the other directors of the company. I now invite him to briefly talk in support of his re-election.

Alan Isaac
Independent Director, Chair of Audit Committee, and Member of the Remuneration Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thanks, Liz. By profession, I'm a chartered accountant, but I've had significant commercial experience with a range of international and New Zealand operations. I mention the commercial experience because it's not necessarily fashionable today to be a stale, pale male. In my opinion, experience is being undervalued in the interest of greater diversity. Thankfully, for the cricket fans in the room, the New Zealand Cricket is still valued experience. Well done, Ross Taylor. I retired from KPMG in 2006 after leading the firm in New Zealand for 10 years and have been a professional director since then. In my governance roles, I chair a number of audit risk committees. In addition, my other current listed companies are Skellerup and Scales, and I have in recent times been on the listed company boards of Opus, Wakefield Hospital, and Freightways.

As a non-executive director, I'm particularly proud of my IPO track record. I mention that because I've been involved in three listings and they've all been successful, and some of you will be well aware that a number of listings in the last five or seven years haven't been successful. Also, for the last two years, up until in theory next Tuesday, COVID alert levels in Wellington providing, I've been the president of the Institute of Directors in New Zealand, which has been a fantastic experience, but it's also facilitated me keeping up to date with current governance issues. Now, Liz has commented in her address on the board succession plans and one or two other items that have been raised by the New Zealand Shareholders' Association in their review of our governance.

Partly in response to one of the points that they raised, I would mention that either personally or through my family trust, I have an interest in more than 280,000 Oceania shares. In summary, I believe we have a well-balanced board, and I look forward to your support so that I can continue to add value to Oceania, which as mentioned earlier, has a strong balance sheet and is well-placed to achieve profitable growth. Thank you.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare

Thank you, Alan. I now move that Alan Isaac be re-elected as a director of the company. Can I have a seconder, please? Thank you, Ruth. Is there any discussion? I now put the motion. Sorry. Thank you.

Sheree Scolta
Shareholder, Private Investor

Hi, my name is Sheree Scolta. I am a member as well, and I also work for you guys. My question is, do you guys support mandatory safe staffing? Staff staffing. Mandatory staff staffing. Do you support it?

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

I'm not sure I understood that question. Okay,

Alastair Duncan
Shareholder, E tū Incorporated

If I can assist. Mandatory safe staffing means that we are believing in better and taking a leadership role. Do you support safe staffing being mandatory?

Alan Isaac
Independent Director, Chair of Audit Committee, and Member of the Remuneration Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Well, we certainly support safe staffing. That's what we're in the practice of doing. There may be some reasons as to why that can't.

Alastair Duncan
Shareholder, E tū Incorporated

Sorry. On a point of order, my question is not to you.

Alan Isaac
Independent Director, Chair of Audit Committee, and Member of the Remuneration Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Sorry.

Alastair Duncan
Shareholder, E tū Incorporated

My question is to the candidate.

Alan Isaac
Independent Director, Chair of Audit Committee, and Member of the Remuneration Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yeah. Well, absolutely I do. As Liz has mentioned and Brent's mentioned, the safety of our staff is paramount. If that helps, but certainly personally that's my position also. Incredibly important, obviously.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you.

Alastair Duncan
Shareholder, E tū Incorporated

The same question to each of the candidates, please.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

We'll ask them to address that in their presentations. I now put the motion, and if there's no further questions, I invite you to vote by marking Resolution 1 in your voting card, please. I'll give you a moment to do that. I advise that the board is holding a total of 232,276,502 directed and discretionary proxies which will be voted in favor of this Resolution. I now move to Resolution 2. In this case, Dame Kerry Prendergast offers herself for re-election as a Director of the company. The board has determined, in its view, if re-elected, Dame Kerry Prendergast will continue to be an independent Director for the purposes of the NZX listing rules. Dame Kerry Prendergast stands for re-election with the support of the other Directors of the company.

A brief biography regarding Dame Kerry is included on the website, and I now invite her to briefly talk in support of her re-election. Kerry.

Dame Kerry Prendergast
Independent Director and Chair of the Clinical and Health and Safety Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you, Liz. Good afternoon, shareholders. As you heard, my name is Kerry Prendergast. I've been a board member since the IPO in 2017. My skill set, I'll list them. I trained as a nurse in 1970, went on to get a diploma in intensive care, then worked as a midwife in management roles. I had 40 years in the health sector. I had 24 years in local government in Wellington, which gives me a good understanding of the Resource Management Act, which we need around getting building consents and resource consents. I was a member of WorkSafe for the first three years of it being set up by government. I have a good understanding of health and safety.

I've had 15 years of choosing residential and rest home and hospital level care for both of my parents and more recently, an aunt and uncle, where I hold the enduring power of attorney. Finally, I'm a shareholder. All of the above makes me really passionate about this sector, and I am honored to be part of this board. We attract two sorts of clients to our properties. There are residential clients who choose to buy a villa or an apartment, and then there are our rest home and our hospital and our dementia clients. The former, the people who purchase a unit, what they're looking for is they want a location that's close to amenities. They want ambience. They want great specifications. They want it to feel a great place, and they want added value amenities both within and close by.

For those who are there as our patients, they want quality spaces, of course, and they want really good clinical care. They want to feel safe. Whether they're choosing to go into a rest home or their families or their children are choosing for them, they're looking for quality clinical care. You want to know, as a child of a parent, that your parent or family members are going to be safe and well looked after. We invest in our staff in lots of different ways to make sure that they deliver the sorts of level of care that is both mandated, but also as a rest home provider, we make sure happens.

What's good for our residents and our patients, and our brand is that we fulfill all of the requirements that I've listed, and that means we get a good return, and that's good for all of you, our shareholders. Thank you very much. I look forward to your support.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you, Dame Kerry. I now move that Dame Kerry Prendergast is re-elected as a director of the company. Can I have a seconder, please? Thank you, Bruce. I now put the motion and invite you to vote by marking Resolution 2 on your voting card. Are there any questions? No. I'll give you some time to cast your vote. I advise that the board is holding a total of 232,833,380 directed and discretionary proxies, which will be voted in favor of this resolution.

These numbers are a mouthful, aren't they? In this case, Resolution 3, re-election of Sally Evans. In this case, Sally Evans offers herself for re-election as a director of the company. The board has determined that in its view, if re-elected, Sally Evans will continue to be an independent director for the purposes of the NZX listing rules. Sally Evans stands for re-election with the support of the other directors of the company. I'm assuming that Sally is online. She is online. A brief biography regarding Sally is included on the website, and I will now invite Sally to briefly talk in support of her re-election via the video link. Welcome back, Sally.

Sally Evans
Independent Director, Chair of the Remuneration Committee, and Member of the Clinical Health and Safety Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thanks, Liz. For not being in Auckland today, it is disappointing that after a prolonged period of living without restrictions in Sydney, that I am unable to join you today. I was fortunate to be able to join our May board meeting in Auckland and spend that time catching up in person with the executive team. While we have all managed to change to online meetings and frequent phone calls, it was great to be able to meet the executive and make the most of those face-to-face conversations. Thank you for considering my re-election to the Oceania board. Since I graduated from the University of Otago, I have worked in sectors where it was possible to influence and lead structural and systemic change in hospitals and aged care. It has always been with the intent to provide better outcomes for patients and residents.

If I couldn't see the value and the benefit to the users of our services, I couldn't see the point of any of the change. The last 10 years of my executive career was in the field of investing in residential aged care with a focus on the operational side of the business and delivering better care for residents. Since then, I've focused my career on working as a director in businesses that are leading change in retirement and aging sectors. That is the reason I was particularly delighted to be a member of the Oceania board.

I'm also a member of the Advisory Council to the Australian Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission. I am a huge supporter of the changes that will ensure that we have a sustainable safety system for staff and for residents. It has been a pleasure working with the board and executive at Oceania and meeting many of the residents and staff across New Zealand. I welcome the opportunity to stand for re-election and join the board and executive in delivering our plans to bring Believe in Better to life. Thank you.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you, Sally. I now move that Sally Evans be re-elected as a director. Well, I'll give you the opportunity in just one moment. That said, she may not have heard that earlier. That Sally Evans be re-elected as a director of the company. Can I have a seconder, please? Bruce, thank you. Thank you. Is there any discussion? I'll ask Sally just to answer the question, because the connections from here to Sydney may not be that clear. The question was, do you support safe staffing?

Sally Evans
Independent Director, Chair of the Remuneration Committee, and Member of the Clinical Health and Safety Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yes. Safety is a fundamental requirement. Unless staff are safe, our residents won't be safe. The two for me are very connected.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you, Sally. Are there any other questions? Any other discussion? Thank you. I now put the motion and invite you to vote by marking Resolution 3 on your voting card, please. I advise that the board is holding a total of NZD 232,856,785 directed and discretionary proxies which will be voted in favor of this resolution. I now move to Resolution 4. In this case, Gregory Tomlinson offers himself for re-election as a director of the company. The board has determined that in its view, if re-elected, Greg Tomlinson will continue to be an independent director for the purposes of the NZX listing rules. Greg Tomlinson stands for re-election with support of the other directors of the company. A brief biography regarding Greg is included on the website. I now invite him to briefly talk in support of his re-election. Greg.

Greg Tomlinson
Independent Director and Chair of the Development Committee, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Well, thank you, Liz, and welcome all. It was always hard going last, particularly behind the rating of these peak people around me. Look, I originally started in the aged care industry in the mid-1980s, building cluster housing for the elderly, and quickly moved into integrated care. I've experienced firsthand the evolution of the needs-based model of today. I'm very proud of the model that has been built to service our New Zealand elderly. All this has started from a very humble background, if you think about care for the elderly. I still hold the passion today for providing our aging population access to the best available housing and care to meet their changing needs of today and importantly, the future.

My skills and experience now, again, may not be rated like the others around me, which I put my hand up about, but my skill is really around risk and reward assessment. I've got a strong background in construction and development, business building, and importantly, the business of looking after the care of the elderly. Oceania. Sorry, Liz. Better put my glasses on. Yeah, it's really looking after Oceania's customers, employees, and shareholders, of which I'm one. If I'm re-elected, you have my commitment for another term of this very exciting business as it remodels itself to become the top provider in arguably the most strategic locations of New Zealand. Just to the workers union, of course, I really take great pride in looking after staff. It's not an accident this business has 3,700 residents and 2,800 staff.

You've got to be on your game to get to this level. Regardless, this business, it wasn't that long ago, it was a startup, and I being one of the original startups in this industry, so I know that well. I understand what it takes to keep everybody happy and keep everybody employed and importantly, pay the taxes and give a return to shareholders. I hope that answers it. Thank you.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you, Greg. I now move that Gregory Tomlinson is re-elected as a director of the company. Can I have a seconder, please? Bruce, you're doing a great job there. Thank you. Is there any discussion? Thank you. I now put the motion and invite you to vote by marking Resolution 4 on your voting card. I advise that the board is holding a total of 232,734,445 directed and discretionary proxies, which will be voted in favor of this resolution. The next item is the remuneration of the auditor. I now move that the directors be authorized to fix the remuneration of PricewaterhouseCoopers as the auditor of the company for the ensuing year. Can I have a seconder, please? Bruce again. You're so good. Thank you. Is there any discussion? I now put the motion and invite you to vote by marking Resolution 5 on your voting paper.

I'll just give you a moment to do that. I advise that the Board is holding a total of 232,464,005 directed and discretionary proxies, which will be voted in favor of this resolution. Thank you to all of you for your voting. This concludes the meeting's formal resolutions. The results will be published to the market later today. Please put your completed voting papers in the ballot box as you leave the meeting, and please ensure that your voting paper has been signed. You may have ticked the boxes, but please make sure that you've signed it. I now move to general business. Are there any items of general business that haven't previously been covered within the meeting that you as shareholders now wish to raise, please? Again, please raise your hand and we will get someone to bring a microphone to you.

State whether you're a shareholder or a proxyholder and the name of the shareholder you represent. Yes, thank you.

Jim Hamilton
Shareholder, Private Investor

Jim Hamilton, shareholder. I note that you're building a property five storey level or even more than five storey level. Can you tell me what people prefer? Do they prefer to be in the upper level or the lower level?

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

You can answer that, Brent. All of the above.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

I think all of the above. Sorry, my microphone's come on quite loud. I think all of the above, to be honest. Some people like the security of being on a lower level and having access to a small garden area. Some people like being in the middle of the building. Some people obviously like the higher floors, which may offer a view advantage, or a feeling of looking out across the property. It's not an easy one to call, but what we do have is obviously properties which have a mix of residents across all of those levels enjoying our services.

Jim Hamilton
Shareholder, Private Investor

Can I just make a comment?

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yes, please.

Jim Hamilton
Shareholder, Private Investor

In New Zealand, we seem to have a strong opposition to building apartments at the moment. That's why I asked the question.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yeah, I think people are aware of the general housing crisis that exists in New Zealand. I think there's general acceptance that higher density is required, whether that's in a residential setting or whether that's in the services and products that we provide. We're sensitive to that. Our sites up and down the country we find work very well by having a combination of different building types, whether that's a villa or whether that's an apartment or whether that's a Care Suite. It's inevitable that we will go to high density. I'm talking about just the broader market with the unavailability of land.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you, Brent. Are there any further questions? No. No further questions. Yeah. Oh, in the back there. We'll bring a microphone to you.

Derrick Tan
Shareholder, Private Investor

Hi, Derrick Tan, shareholder. In the recent rights issue, was there a formula used to allocate the shares, and was it applied universally?

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yes, there was a formula that was disguised for the capital raise. We were very encouraged by the level of oversubscriptions that we received for the capital raise. I think it's a vote of confidence around the maturity of the business. It was a vote of confidence around the acquisitions that we were raising that capital for. Unfortunately, for all of us, we were scaled on the same basis. All of us probably sitting in this room would have liked to have received more shares than we did. We had applied uniformity as it relates to the scaling both on the retail offer and on the private placement. While we were flooded with demand, we didn't take that extra demand.

We were very sensitive to raising enough capital to put the business on a good path as it relates to its growth, but to be sensitive to loyal shareholders that have traversed with us. The capital raising represented about 8% of the total shares that we had on available at the time. We were sort of sensitive to the size and also consistency around application of proceeds.

Derrick Tan
Shareholder, Private Investor

Would you be able to reveal the allocation formula, please?

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yes. In what sense?

Derrick Tan
Shareholder, Private Investor

Sorry?

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

In what sense? We have applied it consistently.

Derrick Tan
Shareholder, Private Investor

I just want to see if it's applied fairly.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Well, Roger, would you like to answer that?

Derrick Tan
Shareholder, Private Investor

Is that a secret?

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Sorry?

The way it was applied consistently and evenly.

Derrick Tan
Shareholder, Private Investor

Yeah.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Prorated, yes.

Derrick Tan
Shareholder, Private Investor

Yeah.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yes, it was done on that basis, prorated and consistently applied.

Derrick Tan
Shareholder, Private Investor

Sorry, would you give the formula, please?

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

The formula was simply the division of shares that you'd asked for relative to the demand that we had. I guess on that basis, if you'd asked for 10,000 shares and we had NZD 30,000 worth of demand for those 10,000 shares, then that's the ratio that we've used for the scaling. If we had three times the coverage for the shares, then that's the sort of the scaling that was applied.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

I believe you've answered that.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

On the question of consistency, there wasn't a level of assurance in terms of the allocation process, so the allocations as calculated were checked by the share registry. It was consistently applied.

Derrick Tan
Shareholder, Private Investor

Right

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

We got assurance that that had taken place. Everybody was treated the same way.

Derrick Tan
Shareholder, Private Investor

All right. Okay, thanks.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you. Are there any other questions? Yes? There's a question third row back in the middle. Thank you.

John Ryden
Shareholder, Private Investor

Sorry, thank you. My name is John Ryden, shareholder. My question is, can you see any more raising of capital coming up in the next few years, like we had recently?

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

We do not have any on our agenda at the moment, but if we see opportunities to acquire, grow, develop, then we will be coming back to shareholders.

John Ryden
Shareholder, Private Investor

If potentially you might need to raise capital, then why not reduce or stop the dividend altogether so you have the money available?

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Because some retail investors like to receive the dividend, and secondly, if a shareholder wishes to reinvest, we offer the DRP, dividend reinvestment plan. If you want to keep investing in Oceania, you can participate in the DRP.

John Ryden
Shareholder, Private Investor

Wouldn't you save the cost of raising capital if you had the dividends sitting in the bank and also, tax-.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yeah, that's correct.

John Ryden
Shareholder, Private Investor

...wouldn't be tax advantage.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

It's not material enough, the dividend, to if we're going to raise capital for large acquisitions, it would be much more than our dividend. As I say, to appeal to a broader range of investors, it is more ideal to actually have a dividend. We get a broader base of investors.

John Ryden
Shareholder, Private Investor

Okay. Thanks.

Hayley Ching
Shareholder, Private Investor

Yes, I'd like to complement his question because I'm a shareholder of Arvida as well, I think they save a lot of money just by buying more villagers. Each year, they will not raise more than 20% of the company's shares to give them to the existing villagers we would like to sell to Arvida. Arvida just got these villagers free of charge. Yeah. That's good. Yeah. Yes, indeed. Oh, sorry. Yeah. Thank you. I think we should have tea now.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you. Thank you. We have a question at the back. Afternoon tea is in the back room, so I can assure you it is not running away. We have got plenty of time for questions.

Robert Gray
Shareholder, Private Investor

Good afternoon. My name's Robert Gray, shareholder. I thoroughly dislike these capital raisings. I put in one in the past where I applied for a whole lot of shares, and I got less than 1% I asked for. Since then, I very rarely take them up, but I nearly always take up rights issues. I just don't like a whole lot of money that I'm not floating around that I'm not going to get any shares for, and again, it gets paid back into the account, and it's a blooming nuisance. Most people, I think, agree, prefer shareholder, prefer rights issues.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you for letting you know your preference. Look, we got any other questions? You only get an opportunity once a year to ask us questions.

Joshua Wang
Shareholder, Private Investor

Hi. My name's Josh. I run the Joshua Wang YouTube channel. We talk a lot about your stock on the YouTube channel. Just a question on-

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

You're representing a shareholder?

Joshua Wang
Shareholder, Private Investor

Shareholder.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yes. Thank you.

Joshua Wang
Shareholder, Private Investor

I was just wondering on the DHB subsidy allowance.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Sorry.

Joshua Wang
Shareholder, Private Investor

Can you provide any commentary on the government subsidy for aged care for the next year? Is this higher or lower than you guys expected, and what's the impact on care going forward to the next year?

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Yeah. That's actually ahead of us. I can't comment because it doesn't get gazetted until the 1st of July. It's fair to say that Oceania and its peers have provided essential services. We've seen the great services that were provided across the sector during COVID. Hopefully, that's represented in the funding that we receive from the DHBs. We won't know what that is until on or around the 1st of July of this year.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

There's a question down here.

Speaker 20

Any forecast for the next year or first next half year or next year for the performance of the company? Thank you.

Brent Pattison
CEO, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Well, we've provided, hopefully, our outlook in terms of developments that we have underway for the next financial year. There's been a good canvassing of questions, so very grateful for that in terms of how the sector's performing and what lies ahead of us. Our materials do provide a very strong and transparent view of what we hope to achieve in the next year.

Elizabeth Coutts
Chair, Oceania Healthcare Limited

Thank you, Brent. All right. Well, thank you for your attendance. I now declare the meeting closed and invite you all to join the directors and management for afternoon tea and refreshments. I would also like to remind you to please put your completed and signed voting papers in the ballot boxes as you make your way to afternoon tea, which is served in the room behind us. Thank you very much. We'll see you next year.