Cloetta AB (publ) (STO:CLA.B)
Sweden flag Sweden · Delayed Price · Currency is SEK
53.65
+0.40 (0.75%)
Sep 17, 2026, 5:29 PM CET
← View all transcripts

Earnings Call: Q1 2021

Apr 23, 2021

Nathalie Redmo
Head of Investor Relations and Communications, Cloetta

Good morning, and thank you for joining us on the Q1 Conference Call for Cloetta. My name is Nathalie Redmo, and I'm Head of Investor Relations. With me here today are CEO, Henri de Sauvage, and Frans Rydén, CFO. Henri and Frans will take you through our first quarter results, and we will then move on to a Q&A session. I will now hand over to you, Henri.

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

Good. Thank you, Nathalie, and welcome everybody. A few key messages on what we did see in the business in Q1. It was very pleasing to see that the branded business came back to growth, whilst we still have quite some out-of-home channels with a lot less shoppers. Pick & Mix was still negatively impacted by COVID, although March was a good month, which we'll show you later. That of course, has to do both with the comparator and also that Easter was in March. Difficult to calculate exactly the effects of the two. Also very pleasing to see is the progress we're making on the roadmap to profitability for Pick & Mix. A lot of pricing and premiumization was done in the last couple of months, and that also starts to show in particular on the growth margin in that underlying business.

I'm also very pleased to say that although we're still managing the pandemic, there's a lot of progress on the strategic agenda, and today we'll talk a little bit more about e-commerce and sustainability, which are gaining traction. A few quarters ago, we talked about our Innovation 2.0 setup, so fewer innovations, but bigger ones. This quarter we're actually launching quite some disruptive innovations, which we'll disclose a little bit more about, and then going forward, we can tell you a little bit about the success. Still very good focus on the VIP+, the savings program, delivering also on the indirect, moving towards a global shared service center in the Netherlands and in Slovakia. Also very good progress over there.

Frans will talk a little bit about the refinancing of the group, which we have done, and we also approved an investment into new packaging technology for carton boxes. With that said, we can have a look at the sales. Of course, I don't like the first bubble, the -4.2. That's still negative, which is not success in my books. If you then unpeel it, of course, it is very good to see that we are growing the branded business again, which is of course a very important part of our total business and something we were consistently doing before the pandemic, and now we're back to growth. Very good. On Pick & Mix, you can see that we're still heavily impacted by the pandemic, both in sales channels, in activation, but also in consumer behavior. March looked a little bit better.

Just to remind you, of course, last year in March, in the second half of March, the pandemic actually was called out as a pandemic, and consumers and customers started to react. Also the comparator versus last year becomes a lot lower, and hence we will see like this, a positive development. We internally are constantly looking also at 2019 figures and how we get back to those levels. Next one, please. Important for us and maybe also for you, in a highlight just to see what is happening with consumers across some of our main geographies. You can see that depending a bit on the markets, that there's a lot less traffic in areas like retail and recreation.

Look at the U.K., I mean, -60, but also the Netherlands, when there's a full lockdown, people are not allowed on the streets after 9:00 o'clock in the evening. Let's not only take the Sweden perspective, where of course we are having a very mild set of measures compared to, let's say, the Netherlands and the U.K. These are markets where we also operate. You can see that a little bit over here, also transit stations, so there's very much people moving around or going to work. Again, that's where Cloetta is selling products. A bit the same pattern that the U.K. is worse in that sense, but also the Netherlands quite bad. Then workplaces, so where people are working again, U.K., very low, and the rest more or less in line. We're tracking this.

It's also fair to say that now in the U.K., since mid-April, things are going so well that society starts to open up. We get a biweekly report within Cloetta with many more details because this is something we can learn from to see how our consumers and hence customers behaving when things start to open up again. We take those lessons and implement them into our other markets. If we're looking at the branded business, first of all, we have made the estimation of the split between the two channels. Why is an estimation? Because some of our customers are serving both channels, and then we have to determine the exact split, which we not always get from them.

You can see between the brackets what it was a year before, and now in 2020, we can see it went down to 75/25. Last three months market data is very important for the mix element. We can see that pastilles and gum markets are still down -13%. In Q3, they came up a bit, then they started to go down again. Here we also have above-average profitability, which impacts our mix within the branded. Candy bags still being very positive in the in-home channel. This doesn't say anything about the loss we see, of course, of sales in the 25% other channels. The increased candy and chocolate demand is still there, and I would say less impulse sales is also still a trend. Not so much change here versus the previous quarter. We're doing a lot of things.

The step up in brand investments in the top 25 brands is happening also in Q1. We spend more in absolute sense. Also, in the next quarter, of course, we'll continue where we had a very low spend last year when the pandemic started. I talked about the Innovation 2.0. We'll talk a little bit further on the e-commerce. The valorization, very important, is that all the products we're now, or all the innovations we're bringing to the market under the Innovation 2.0, they should have a gross margin which is higher than the category average of that category in the country where we're operating. That over time, we're also, in that way, lifting the gross margin of the group.

The same, of course, with the Pick & Mix, with a lot of pricing quarter after quarter coming into play and starting to show in the results. For pastilles and gum, we are working on a strong point of sales program, both in the out-of-home market but also in the retail, to bring those consumers back into the category. For Pick & Mix, same overview as last time. What has changed in U.K., I would say, we see at the end of March, early April, we see some of the channels opening up again. Consumer activation, largely unchanged. Less price promotions than normal. Consumer demand also still very much following what we have been seeing. There's positive news as well. In April, we do see that the U.K. has started to get into a better place on these traffic lights.

If you look at the actions we're taking, we have higher merchandising per kilo if the volume is less, we are costing that out towards our customers, which we have been doing. We have some very good activation through cup promotions. That's an idea we have from the U.K., where they're selling not in bags, but in cups, and we're doing those activations now as well in all the Nordic markets. We're the first ones. Really good. The premium Candyking 2.0 rollout is progressing. I would say also some really nice barter deals with other companies for the Candyking brand, where we are then bartering. We then put those brands onto our fixtures, our bags, and then in return, we get media on the kind of channels they have.

That is also a very effective way for us with limited budgets to get the new Candyking 2.0 concept communicated. Yes, Frans.

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

Good. Thank you. As usual, I will start with net sales. In the quarter, our organic sales declined by 4.2% versus last year, and then almost the same on account of currencies. It is important to recall that in Q1, we are still comparing ourselves largely against pre-COVID sales. January and February is pre-COVID, and March is partially pre-COVID, as the impact was only really starting to be felt towards the end of March. Actually, the World Health Organization only declared COVID a pandemic on March 11 last year. It feels like it's been going on for longer, but that's what it is. With that said, we are very pleased to report 2.5% growth on the branded packet sales for the quarter, and I'm going to add some perspective to that on the next slide. Also for Pick & Mix, sales are down almost 23%.

This is significant. We certainly have our work cut out for us to get that business back to a good place. Henri spoke about a number of things we're doing. I also want to put that in perspective on the next slide. Here, looking at the sales by quarter, top row, starting with the 2.5% growth in our branded packet business. If you exclude the last two quarters leading up to the pandemic, then 2.5% growth is the highest growth that we have delivered for branded packet sales for several years. Now, it's fair to say that there is some cannibalization on Pick & Mix. Q1 2020 was also not a very strong growth quarter, including due to COVID-19, but we are on par this quarter with Q1 2019, which was arguably our best Q1 for branded packet sales for several years.

This is despite that, as Henri laid out, outlets in our markets are still experiencing significantly reduced footfall. Looking at the lower half of the slide in the Pick & Mix business, 23% decline. I am reluctant to use the word, but that is the best quarter we've seen since COVID-19 began. If you look on the very right, you can clearly see the impact of COVID, where January and February is down significantly, very similar to the prior quarters. Whereas in March, we grew. Easter do come a bit earlier this year, but clearly society deals with COVID better now than during the start of the pandemic last year, and so do we, and it is very encouraging to see this partial recovery. With those, let's call them green shoots, let's look closer at the profitability.

Starting with Q1 this year, we are providing increased transparency on our results by reporting the operating profit for the branded packaged business and the Pick & Mix business separately. We believe this will help you as stakeholders in the success of Cloetta to better understand our results, our opportunities, and challenges. In a way, Henri teased this already in his CEO word in Q4, and I'm happy to also confirm that we're going to do this consistently going forward, not just during the pandemic. Before that deeper dive, let's look at operating profit drivers for the total business.

As you can see in the graph, we declined versus last year, and that's driven both by the volume loss, with associated under-absorption of costs in supply chain, and then in the unfavorable mix within the branded packaged portfolio that Henri also spoke about with refreshment category being harder hit by the reduced mobility of people and the social distancing. Operating profits further declined on account of increased cost of raw material after Q1 last year, as well as we have continued to invest behind our brands. It is difficult to underscore enough how important this is for us. We are a consumer-focused company, and after safety and quality, there is no more important spend than communicating with our consumers. We have some incredibly new products.

Henri will have some slides on this, looking at Kexchoklad Vegan, fruit-based candy, building on from prior innovations such as plant-based packaging and the 30% less sugar, we're going to further step up in the area of promoting our products to let the consumer know that, hey, we are actually here. Finally, you don't see too much of those increased costs come into the quarter, only SEK 6 million, as you see there. That's because of the continued efforts in our VIP+ program, I'll come back to that on a separate slide. Of course, pricing and other margin-enhancing initiatives that we've taken. Let's move to the split between the two segments. You can see here that the profit from the branded packaged business declined by SEK 40 million despite the growth. This is driven by several contributing factors.

There's the higher investment in marketing that I mentioned. There's also the impact of higher material cost I mentioned. It's also allocation of its share of the supply chain under absorption due to the overall volume drop. We're obviously using our plants to produce both packaged and the Pick & Mix products. That is also impacting us in this segment. I'm also highlighting here that we have taken cost in Q1 related to the recall of Easter products made for us by a third party. It does have a sufficiently significant impact on the quarter to mention. As this is work in progress, I'm not going to go into the details on the value. For the underlying this and looking forward, I think the most important aspect is the negative impact of mix that I mentioned with the reduced sales of refreshment products.

Looking at Pick & Mix below, you can see that we made a loss in this business of SEK 24 million. Let's triangulate that number a little bit. Firstly, in Q4, we shared that the volume lost due to COVID-19 had pushed Pick & Mix to a loss of SEK 135 million, or as we now report with inclusion of headquarter allocation, it's a loss in 2020 of SEK 154 million. You can see in the report that while Q1 last year was already impacted by COVID-19, most of the 2020 loss came after Q1. That makes for an average quarterly loss for the last three quarters of 2020 of SEK 44 million. You sort of have to compare those SEK 44 million to the SEK 24 `million loss in Q1 now. That is arguably already an improvement.

The loss is on par with last year despite the volume loss, although, as I mentioned, the supply chain under absorption is shared between Pick & Mix and branded packaged products. I think it speaks strongly for the various margin-enhancing initiatives that we have shared that we would do, and then we have also done. Fair pricing, exiting unprofitable contracts, reducing costs, be it for warehousing or distribution or merchandising or in support functions. Some of the action helped soften the damage in last year, but the full year effect you can only see now in Q1. We have taken additional steps during Q1, including further fair pricing initiatives. Ultimately, though, we need the consumers to be picking and mixing, driving scale and efficiency to get back to full profitability.

We can move to the sales general and admin costs and the continued delivery from the VIP+ program. It is also evident here in the reported financials. You can see that in the quarter, excluding items affecting comparability and forex, costs were down SEK 18 million. I also want to put that into perspective. First, I already mentioned that we increased investment in marketing during the quarter, so this reduction of cost is net of that increase. It is of course also net of the annual salary increases across the markets. Secondly, this is a reduction on top of the VIP+ savings we already reported in Q1 2020, and at that time we could report a reduction of SEK 19 million. On top of that SEK 19 million.

This comes, of course, partly from one-time activities like travel restrictions or lower merchandising costs due to lower volumes, but most of these are sustainable VIP+ savings delivered over the last two years and also continuing now in 2021. For example, Henri mentioned that, I'm really pleased to say that this month, actually from April 1, we went live with our new shared service center for accounts payables, which we co-located with our manufacturing in Levice, Slovakia, which will help improve how we work on things and enable further harmonization and automation. For the non-sustainable savings, some of that will come back into the business as society returns to normal, and most importantly, because the merchandising, those merchandising costs will also come with higher merchandising sales and the profit from those sales, that is going to be a good thing when that happens.

Looking at cash, we had a healthy cash flow for the quarter. I think there's two reasons why I can say that. First, as you know, with the seasonality of our business, we tend to generate our cash in the second half of the year. We did deliver a positive free cash flow already now in Q1. That's the middle of the top graph there of SEK 11 million. That free cash flow is also an improvement compared to last year when we had a loss of SEK 20 million. The improvement in free cash flow comes from improved working capital management as well as lower CapEx spend, as the installation of the new drying chambers is near completion, which more than fully offset the lower operating profit we had in Q1 2021.

As shared earlier this year, we have put in place a Cloetta cash committee to get more focus on cash in the challenging environment, and I'm pleased to see a continued good return on that effort. The improved working capital is driven obviously by the absence of last year's buildup of inventories as we were safeguarding our supply chain from disruption due to the pandemic. That's partially offset by lower payables that corresponded to that inventory buildup and also higher receivables as we finished Q1 sales much stronger this year than what we did last year. The working capital is nonetheless increased in the quarter compared to where we ended last year, and that's because of higher receivables, which is completely normal because the end of Q1, we have Easter sales, whereas end of Q4, post-Christmas, there is very little activity.

As for my last slide, as you know, leverage is one of our key financial targets alongside sales, EBIT, and dividend, and this slide seeks to capture that and our debt position. You can see from the bar chart on the left that our utilized credit facilities and commercial papers total SEK 2.3 billion, and then on the right that we have additional unutilized credit facilities, commercial papers not yet on the market, for almost SEK 2 billion. In addition, we held SEK 444 million in cash at the end of Q1, which was a lot, but then we also readied ourselves for the dividend that was paid on April 13. That said, as we hold this call, we have finalized the refinancing of our group through our existing club of banks.

I had shared at the Q4 earnings call that we expected to have this completed before the middle of the year. I'm very pleased to share that it has been done so already now, that we've had very good progress with strong interest from our full banking group to continue to partner with us. For the leverage, our net debt is 2.5x the EBITDA, given that the lower profit has pushed us up above our target to be around 2.5. It's well below the covenant of 4.0. Coming back to the financing, it consists of two loans and a revolving credit facility. It will be repayable in June 2023, 2024, and 2025, each with the possibility of extending for an additional two years.

This secures our financing and gives us flexibility for the coming years, in addition, we will continue our existing commercial paper program. We are, as part of that, also reducing the revolving credit facility with SEK 60 million, which provides us some nice savings. On that positive note, that concludes my part, I hand back to Henri.

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

Thank you, Frans. A few more flavors on the execution of the strategy. 14% EBIT, really important to start generating also more growth margin. The Innovation 2.0, which we started two years ago, now starts to deliver, I would say. These are three examples. There is many more of them. The first one, very much linked to the sustainability strategy into action, is a program where we are introducing PlantPack across our ranges, and PlantPack are plastic materials either made totally or partly from plant-based material, so not fossil fuel, and that has good traction with consumers who see that as a positive, and also gives us a reason to increase prices. The second one is that we are the first one to launch a vegan Kexchoklad into Sweden, but also in some other markets.

That's very nice to see that we're so fast. More or less the same time we were announcing, a global major competitor of ours was launching their intention to launch this as a big piece of news, and we are already on the market and really plays well into a growing interest among consumers for vegan products. Of course, again, at a premium price. Then the other one, the last one I'll mention out of the multiple examples we have, is fruit-based candy. This is candy made from 50% fruit. Again, we're the first ones here in our markets to do this, and also the first one we think globally with such a high percentage of fruit in the candy. Very much linked to several consumer trends of more naturalness, more products made from ingredients people recognize, and also tasting really well, I must say.

A fantastic effort by the innovation and supply chain and marketing team to bring this to the market. Again, you now see here, Gott & Blandat, that we're launching this across markets under the different brands we have in those markets. I would say quite nice examples of how to increase margin through innovation. The second one is e-commerce. We already had this as part of our new strategy within Cloetta before the pandemic, because we have pockets of excellence, but not one approach. We put this together into one execution strategy for all the markets with a small team of experts helping the different markets to get going. On the left, you can see the kind of growth levels we are seeing.

The markets are in different stages of development, where the Netherlands is more advanced because you already have e-commerce there for the last 15 years, and the markets like Sweden or even Denmark being a bit behind. Very pleasing to see that we see some really good growth numbers and also that we are in most markets, we're outgrowing the market development. Our focus is very much on the omni-channel and pure players in each market to really understand the kind of activation, but also to optimize ourselves. That's both the digital shelf, pack shots which need to be different, but also an artificial intelligence tool to see how we are being shopped or how our products are being presented in all those e-shops from different KPIs. Really a step up, I would say. Also specific activations.

In the future, we're also looking at products. It's very interesting to see the kind of dynamics in this channel. Also, the kind of pack sizes, for example, we're selling. Next to that, we have a strong focus on marketplaces, Amazon across Europe, also Bol.com, which is the Dutch Ahold-owned Amazon, you could say. A lot of traction over there. Here it really shows that if we do things together, we only have to invent the wheel once rather than each market with limited resources trying to do this themselves.

If you look at the example over here, the shop in shop of Jelly Bean, which is doing phenomenally well in both the U.K. and Germany, relatively small markets for Cloetta, not with a lot of resources, and then being able to do this with the group, and then we can leverage that into other markets later on, maybe not even only in Europe. Very positive to see. The sustainability strategy. We will organize something in May to communicate more clearly our total program. I think we talked about the first column. The second one, a very interesting pilot project on the living income module together with some key partners, big global companies, and then the Rainforest Alliance to really work on cocoa and the farmers in a more direct way using blockchain.

We're also starting to look at a feasibility study for a partnership on gum arabic, which is coming from the Sub-Saharan area where there's both social, economic, but also planting of trees and keeping trees in that area as both a deforestation or a desertification countermeasure, and of course, giving income to people living there. On the footprint, we have subscribed to the climate-based scientific target. We're calculating our baseline on that. When that is ready, we will set ourselves that target. We're also very clearly now linking all the 20 supported brands to the sustainability agenda. I mean, what kind of sustainability parts are we going to lift into those brands? A lot of enthusiasm in the marketing and commercial units for that. Yeah, the key business priorities, they remain unchanged.

It is to get back the growth of the profitable segments of the branded goods. We talked about all the actions we're doing over there. At the Pick & Mix business, we need to get back to profits. All the actions we are having are focused on either improving the gross margins of the product or to look at the cost, which is mainly the fixtures and the merchandising. Very good to see the progress of that coming through. Cost and efficiency. We talked about the shared service center. There's more insourcing we're doing, even though it's not that easy with travel restrictions in Slovakia, for example. We also decided this investment in carton packaging technology had to be ready for the future.

That's also an important part of our perfect factory program to move towards a future which is built on modern equipment and digitalization. I think that was the last part we wanted to share, and then we're open for questions.

Operator

Our first question comes from Andreas Lundberg from SEB. Please go ahead.

Andreas Lundberg
Analyst, SEB

Yeah, good morning, and thank you. Just on your branded profits or branded package profits, could you share some light on the effect from mix and under absorption on the earnings decline there?

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

Thank you, Andreas. We're not splitting it up per se. I would say that, number one, we've shared before that our refreshment segment is a very profitable one, and that's of course very much hit by the continued COVID restrictions and people's mobility patterns. On the under absorption, yes, the key point there is that because how we're manufacturing our products and we're sharing the production resources between the two segments and sometimes even shipping between plants for further packaging, the volume drop that we're seeing in Pick & Mix is also impacting our branded package portfolio.

Andreas Lundberg
Analyst, SEB

I guess it's fair to assume that earnings would have been down also without any under absorption effects. Is that correct?

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

You're referring to that branded package business on its own, you mean?

Andreas Lundberg
Analyst, SEB

Yeah.

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

Yeah, there's a couple of things that are impacting that. I think one is when you're comparing to last year, the other one, if you're just thinking about sort of where we're coming off from when we executed last year. We have also, well, arguably a one-time event here with the Easter egg recall. That's of course impacting us. We have stepped up the A&MP, but there's more to come. As you see, there's a lot of activities that we've launched now, into Q4. We would have dropped even without the under absorption because of the mix and because of the Easter egg recall. That's correct.

Andreas Lundberg
Analyst, SEB

Okay, got you. Also, I think it touched upon a little bit, but on markets that have opened up recently, what do you see when it comes to both consumer activation and consumer demand? Thank you.

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

Yeah. It is early days because that has happened, I think last week in the U.K., opening. U.K. for us is of course a market which is, well, I don't want to say different, but our business is different. We have a lot of Pick & Mix over there and much less branded sales and no candy bags in that sense. What we have seen in the U.K. is that people are really coming back to the high streets. That is very important because we have a few very big customers like Wilko and Poundland who saw very low footfall. They were open, but very low footfall. Of course, when people are back in the streets shopping in those kind of places, we can see that sales also are coming back over there.

That is something, of course, to translate then into other markets that we will see the out-of-home channels coming back. For us in the Nordics and the Netherlands, they're more kiosks and those kind of places than cinemas in the U.K., which is also very important channel. Cinema and leisure is not open yet. That's going to happen in May. I would expect a similar kind of effect. Then it's too early yet to conclude on what is happening in the supermarket channel. I also do not expect that that will go very fast. I mean that Pick & Mix sales within the supermarket channel when restrictions are being lifted, will not immediately explode, I would say back to the 2019 level as communicated earlier.

That will take several quarters before we'll be able to get people completely back into Pick & Mix. We're following it. We get a detailed report with all the consumer insights on a biweekly basis, and are then drawing our learnings from that for the other markets. We're of course, happy to share that next quarter.

Andreas Lundberg
Analyst, SEB

Thank you. One on the online channel. Does it differ? Does your profitability differ versus your traditional channels? How does it work, or what's the differences between when it comes to marketing, merchandising? Do you share that more or less with your sales channels versus the tradition`al model, for instance?

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

Of course, we don't have any merchandising in these e-commerce channels. The marketing, I would argue, you do that for the brand, no matter where it is being sold. We're not allocating our marketing costs to a supermarket or a kiosk or a swimming pool, or an e-commerce channel. I would say that's the same for all of them. Some of the omni players, of course, are regular customers like ICA or Albert Heijn, who have both retail stores and e-commerce. There are pure players like, let's say Amazon or Mathem, and then the marketplaces with Amazon. Yeah, it is a mix of everything. I think it's too early to say, is it above or below or at par in marketing? We also are learning, we're seeing that we're selling different kind of packs in these places.

In Jelly Bean, we're selling actually, our biggest selling SKU is the big pot. That is the, let's say one and a half and two kilo pot. There's also a mix difference very clearly in that channel, which also impacts profitability.

Andreas Lundberg
Analyst, SEB

Okay, thank you. Lastly from me at least, on these new investment plans in the carton packaging technology, what do you expect to get out of that? Thank you.

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

Well, a few things. Modern lines with higher efficiency, so we're able to produce more, but also lower cost due to the fact that we'll have higher output with the same number or even lower number of operators. It's also making us future-proof that we are able to keep on supporting this packaging technology, which actually is quite important because we can see that there's more and more discussion about plastic. We are able to sell candy products in carton, like we have Läkerol or Zoo or Tutti Frutti in expanding markets in Eastern Europe and Asia. That's also an important future growth model, and it will support our perfect factory program, because we are also replacing with this investment, a number of very old lines with modern technology, which is able to perform at a much higher level with less waste, more flexibility.

In this case, we're also going to do a portfolio harmonization where we're going from something like 24 different boxes to something like four boxes in total. A harmonization, which will then bring us further improvements on the buying of the cartons, less complexity, less change over time. There's a lot of benefits actually coming from modernization of these packing lines.

Andreas Lundberg
Analyst, SEB

Thank you so much.

Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from Nicklas Skogman from Handelsbanken. Please go ahead.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Yes, good morning. I have a couple of questions. The first one is, what is the reason that you allocate an under-absorption costs to the package business? Is it because it's just too difficult to sort of split out?

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

That's part of it. I think it's also a fairer way of doing it. If you imagine that we have a production line, which is producing products that may both be sold in Pick & Mix and in branded packaged. Obviously when the volume goes down, it makes the whole line less efficient, so it impacts the volume across. In terms of the difficulty, and you're spot on there, because you might even have an instance where these products are then shipped to another plant where they may be packaged. At the production line, it might not even be clear exactly if this product will land in Pick & Mix or in a bag later on. It wouldn't be possible to do it.

I think the simple thing, it's because of the shared technology and shared use of resources, it is fair to allocate it based on the volume.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Okay. Good. Then, was there any negative impact from input costs in the quarter? How do you see this developing going forward?

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

Basically, there's an impact, if you will, on But maybe it's more of a facing impact where commodity cost went up last year and we saw less of that in Q1. Against that, I think what we're seeing now in Q1 is that's fair going forward because that's more of a comparison to last year and not the run rate. I think we are in a pretty good place now.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Okay. If we look at the factors impacting the packaged business in Q1, you have the under-absorption, the pastille, chewing gum, negative mix effect. They should all be in the comparables in the coming quarters, right?

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

Again, it depends, of course, what happens now in Q2. If we continue to see an opening of society and higher sales, the under-absorption of course, will come down. The mix should be improving. Input costs will, of course, be as they are.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Yeah, I just mean in Q2, Q3, Q4, you already had the under-absorption and the negative mix in packaged, right?

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

Yeah.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Last year. Yeah.

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

Yeah.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Okay.

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

Yes, of course. Yes.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Yeah.

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

Looking at this, just Nicklas, just bear in mind that when you do it by quarter, recall that we were very clear last year as well about the shift of some of these costs between Q2 and Q3. You just have to bear that in mind when you think about quarter versus quarter results.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Yeah. I will do that.

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

That's fine.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

The product recall that impacted this quarter, will there be any costs related to that also in Q2 as well, or?

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

No, we believe that we're fully and appropriately provided for that.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Okay. It's net positive sequentially then is my take. Anyway, finally, I'm not an expert on this field yet, but your vegan Kex, Klaas, could that be considered a plant-based product? It should, right?

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

Well, it's vegan, right? That means no dairy and vegan-based.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Yeah. Okay, good. Right.

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

That is the same.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

You have some other vegan products already, don't you?

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

Yeah, we do. We do. It's a growing interest. This is not going to be the last one. We're working as well in different markets on different brands towards vegan.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Do you mind sharing how much of your sales are vegan and maybe in 2020?

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

If we can, we would, but I don't have that figure here in my head. It's certainly something we are on that trend. It also, of course, has to fit the consumer, and the consumer is our boss. That's at least how we say and how we think and how we act. It cannot go at the expense of quality and because it is in the end, the second moment of truth is when you put the product into your mouth after you've bought it, and then it also need to taste really well. I would say it's important, but it's not the holy grail. It's not that if we move everything into vegan, that it will suddenly sell twice as much. It's like proper marketing. We look at consumer trends, at segments, how big they are, where the consumers are interested.

In Kex, for example, this is a, of course, article which is very big in Sweden with a lot of different target groups. It makes a lot of sense to do this, and we can do it as well with the fantastic taste so that all fits together.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

Sounds good. One final question now I remember. You talked about the lower cost for merchandising and Pick & Mix. I seem to remember that in previous quarters, you have sort of said that it's been difficult to adjust that cost base considering the drop in Pick & Mix. Has that changed or?

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

No, I don't think it has changed. What we said in the previous quarters, that it is difficult to right-size the merchandising cost when we do not know yet how the volumes are going to be post, let's say, society opening up. We can see that we talked a little bit about the U.K. and how things are bouncing back. Would we have taken the decision to right-size our merchandising in the U.K. with the kind of loss we had over there, and you can see the kind of impacts of the mobility in the U.K., and also understand that's probably one of the markets where Pick & Mix has been most hit.

If we would have done that last year, we would not have been able to grow that business now in March, and we certainly would not have been able to do that in April when society's going back. What we said is we need a little bit more of a stable situation to right-size the merchandising in each of the markets. While having said that, we have just concluded a big benchmarking across all the markets on the merchandising cost to see and learn from each other. Who has best practice in merchandising, be it route planning, be it efficiency of filling, efficiency of cleaning, efficiency of ordering, et cetera. Then trying to bring all those lessons across the group, and to lift everybody to a higher level.

There are interesting differences, let's call it like that, and opportunities to further streamline the ways of working in merchandising and how we work with merchandising. That is certainly not the last time we talk about merchandising costs in this call, I would say.

Nicklas Skogman
Analyst, Handelsbanken

All right. Thank you very much.

Operator

Thank you. Just as a quick reminder, if you wish to ask an audio question, please press zero one on your telephone keypad. Once again, please press zero one on your telephone keypad if you wish to ask an audio question.

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

Good. We have a few questions here on the screen. The first one I would ask Frans from Stifel.

Frans Rydén
CFO, Cloetta

Yeah. Stifel had two questions here. One was on the gross margin last year and how to think about that impact this year. That I think probably this question came at the same time as Nicklas. Last year we had SEK 35 million in cost that spilled over into Q3. When you think about the comparator, you have to keep that in mind. This year we're not going to have any movements like that. There's always a little bit of phasing between quarters, but there is nothing significant impacting from Q4 going into Q1, nor is there between Q1 going into Q2. That's one piece. The other question from Stifel was about the Easter sales, and Henri touched on it very briefly. Basically there's two pieces here. One is that Easter has moved by eight days.

The other aspect of this, which makes it very difficult to really untangle, is that at the end of Q1 last year, at the end of March, sales really dropped incredibly because of COVID, because that was really the first time it really hit us. Untangling what is because of the phasing and what is because of COVID is difficult. We've looked at this by week, almost by day. I think a fair way of looking at it would be to say that in 2019, when we had a similar shift of Easter, we estimate that that was roughly SEK 30 million-SEK 40 million that were shifting. I would say that we're talking about roughly half of that now. Somewhere SEK 15 million-SEK 20 million is probably the benefit of the phasing of Easter in Q1 this year.

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

Good. I can confirm to Nicklas that it is plant-based, so you can now tell all your friends to buy Kexchoklad Vegan because it's plant-based. Just to confirm that fact. We have a question from Trojan Trading. Yes, the opening of Cineworld in the U.K. will have a positive effect on Pick & Mix. Yeah, we are in dialogue, of course, with all our customers. Together with them, we also said we'll wait one week after the opening to see what kind of footfall they are getting into the cinema, because Pick & Mix is, of course, also something you want to have fresh, and it needs to have a certain rotation for the concept to be fresh. That's a big segment. Cinema as a leisure are one of the three pillars on which the U.K. business is built.

One is high street, second one, cinema and leisure, third one is, let's say the more traditional supermarkets, the way we know it here in the Nordic. That's absolutely a fair observation, that is a very important step forward for the U.K. Can I comment on Katjes buying shares in Cloetta? No, I can't really. They are a competitor on one hand. On the other hand, they are a third-party producer. Remember that we sold our Italian business to them, and they seem to have a investment strategy where they are purchasing shares in companies they know very well. Their real underlying reasons, I would say you need to ask them. Yeah, that was the last one, I think, from the screen. Any other ones on the audio?

Operator

There appears to be no further registered questions from audio.

Henri de Sauvage
President and CEO, Cloetta

Good. Well, I would like to thank everybody for their attention and wish you a good day.