Good morning and thank you everyone on the lines for joining us for the Adecco Group's Q1 2021 Results Call. With me today are Adecco Group's CEO, Alain Daz and CFO, Coram Williams. Following prepared remarks by Alain and Coram, we will open up the lines for your questions. Conference. Before we begin, I would like to draw your attention to the information on slide 2.
On today's call, we will be referencing both GAAP non GAAP financial results and operating metrics. This conference call will include forward looking statements. These statements are based on assumptions as of today and are therefore subject to risks and uncertainties. With that, here's Alain.
Thank you, Benita, and a warm welcome to everyone on our call. Before we begin the results review, I would like to take this opportunity to thank Nick for his pending contribution over the past three and a half years as our Investor Relations leader. Happily, this is not a farewell as Nick has moved into a new assignment here at the Adecco Group. So thank you, Nick, and we wish you all the very best in your new role. And welcome, Benita, our new Head of Investor Relations.
We are looking forward to working with you, serving our investor community. Let's now start with the Slide 3 and the key takeaways from the quarter. We had a robust start to the year, again showing our business resilience and our sector leading profitability. Even with the continued challenges presented by COVID-nineteen, we returned to modest revenue growth, led by growth in Adecco. Several of our businesses are now back above 2019 levels, including Adeco Southern Europe, LATAM and Japan, but also, HHH and General Assembly within Talent Solutions and our modest consulting business.
We also saw double digit growth in our margin accretive solutions, namely outsourcing and training. And we delivered a broad based margin improvement with all global business units contributing strongly. This reflected positive mix development, pricing and cost discipline across the group. Financial results. During the quarter, we progressed the implementation of Future at Work.
We successfully transitioned to the new brand driven customer centric organization model, which simplifies the management of the business and brings strategic alignment results within our GBUs. And we have defined the key initiatives that will drive sustainable growth and EBITDA improvements in the coming years. Our passion for making the future of work for everyone is undiminished. We are proud to have upskilled approximately 70,000 people in the Q1. And in addition, We expanded our inclusion programs in France with 12 new dedicated branches opened.
In the U. S, general assembly launched a public sector practice building on its successful community reskilling initiatives. Let's now turn to Slide 4 to summarize the quarter financial results. Revenues were up 2% year on year. Percent and Best in Sector EBITA margin of 4.2%.
Our focus on improving mix, pricing discipline, good cost control and productivity growth had a very positive effect. We ended the quarter with a strong financial position and cash flow development. The cash conversion ratio was 117%, and our net debt to EBITDA ratio was 0.3 times. With this financial strength, we can deliver attractive returns to shareholders, while continuing to invest in our future. We maintained our dividend throughout the crisis and in APPRO distributed a dividend of CHF 2.5 per share following shareholder approval at the Group's 2021 Annual General Meeting.
In addition, the €600,000,000 share buyback program recently got underway. I would now like to hand over to Coram to discuss the results in more detail.
Thank you, Alain, and good morning, everybody. Let me begin with some perspectives on the group results. Revenues of €5,000,000,000 were up 2% on a trading days adjusted basis. Quarterly results benefits from a 9% year on year improvement in revenues in March, aided by an easing comparative. Trading conditions on a sequential basis were broadly stable due to the ongoing COVID related restrictions as we described in our prior earnings call.
Group EBITA, excluding 1 ops, was €207,000,000 The result includes approximately 20 basis points of favorable contribution from employment support schemes in Adeco Americas and Northern Europe, which we expect to reduce significantly in Q2. This leaves a very robust improvement of 100 basis points, driven by both gross margin strength and our disciplined investments. I'll explain more on both later in the presentation. Cash generation was strong With cash flow from operating activities of €114,000,000 compared to €69,000,000 in the same period last year. This was driven by higher operating income as well as continued good collections with DSO down 2 days year on year.
Related deferred payments in Q3 of last year, hence the number is clean. The balance sheet remains very strong with a net debt to EBITDA ratio of 0.3x@quarterend. Overall, We have solid cash and balance sheet positions, which allows us to balance continued attractive shareholder returns with investments to execute on our ambitious Future at Work strategy. We moved to a new global business unit structure on January 1. So you'll notice some changes in the following sections, which are intended to help you understand the performance of each of the GBUs more clearly.
Adecco's global revenues were up 2% on a trading days adjusted basis in Q1, with March revenues up double digits. On a sector basis, the business was well positioned to win further contracts in logistics and e commerce, Healthcare and Government Services. Less favorably, automotive continued to be tough The impact of lockdown restrictions on the retail and hospitality sectors continued to be significant in the quarter, although we're starting to see some improvement as economies begin to reopen. These are small businesses at a group level, but are more important in some markets such as France and Benelux. EBITA excluding 1 ops was €173,000,000 with a margin of 4.4%, revenue guidance, up 120 basis points year on year.
Approximately 25 basis points of that improvement came from employment support schemes. The remaining 95 basis points came from a combination of favorable mix, pricing and sustained cost discipline. When we talk about mix, it includes a number of dimensions, all of which we're focused on. First, it means expanding the proportion of revenues coming from our higher margin service lines such as outsourcing and training. It also means focusing our flexible placement services on the parts of the market where our solutions are most differentiated, Such as more specialized skill sets or non traditional models like long term placements or apprenticeships.
And last, it means in some cases, exiting contracts where it's not possible to generate the returns that we expect. We successfully established the new global Adecco organization, which is simplifying management of the business, adding assistant performance management and benchmarking and bringing strategic alignment across the regions. We're pleased with how dynamically the new organization is operating. Moving to Slide 7. You can see the performance of Adecco at the regional level.
In France, revenues were flat year on year, and we maintained our market share. The flexible placement business did well in light of its more meaningful exposure to sectors such as automotive, retail and hospitality, which were all significantly challenged in the quarter and its lower exposure than competitors to the construction sector, which grew well. France offset the headwinds from its sector mix through continued expansion in targeted growth sectors Such as logistics and medical. Good growth in its nontraditional models, including long term flexible placements and very strong growth in the higher margin solutions area. Going forward, management will continue to drive product and services diversification, while maintaining price discipline and delivering cost efficiencies.
Northern Europe was also flat year on year with good growth in the U. K, up 13%, offset by declines in Benelux and Nordics. In Adecco DACH, revenues were flat year on year, but Germany improved with previous restructuring efforts now delivering benefits. Southern Europe and EE MENA was the standout performer, 4 subregions delivered growth with Italy up 21%. In the Americas, revenues were flat year on year.
Latin America was up 23%. North America was 9% lower year on year. And has a clear path to delivery. We're implementing an omnichannel operating model with a streamlined branch network, central hubs and digital channels. We're focusing our sales force on high growth sectors enabled by data analytics.
These actions lay the foundations for strong performance, but it will take some time to fully deliver. Lastly, Adecco APAC was down 2%, mainly driven by the exit of certain lower margin activities in India. Growth in the important Japanese business remained positive, up 3% year on year. Let's turn to Slide 8 and Talent Solutions, which comprises our LHH, General Assembly, Professional Recruitment and pontoon brands. Revenues were flat year on year, reflecting the diverse performances of the subunits and natural hedges within the portfolio.
Let me summarize the Q1 dynamics. Revenues from the countercyclical LHH business career transition activity in Europe picked up and we saw accelerating demand for talent development services. Customers are reviewing the scale and timing of restructuring projects given the sharp improvement in the U. S. Economy.
The flip side of the lower career transition activity in the U. S. Is that we saw U. S. Professional recruitment improve sequentially, We're also seeing some interesting market dynamics.
Approaching 50% of our job orders are now candidate location agnostic, meaning that remote working is possible. That's a shift compared to pre crisis when only a small proportion of jobs were remote. Although it's early, we believe this is a positive development for us. We can leverage a national network and talent pool, combined with front office tools that are sufficiently flexible and powerful search and match capabilities. Global professional recruitment sequentially improved, but was 6% lower year on year, reflecting its exposure to European countries still in the midst of lockdowns.
General Assemblies revenues were 1% higher year on year. B2C is softer as job prospects in the U. S. Economy improve and the opportunity cost to individuals of full time training rises. On the other hand, General Assembly is seeing very strong demand for its reskilling offerings among business customers.
In pontoon, revenues were 4% lower year on year. The business saw good growth in MSP, fully mitigated by the impact of its exit from certain lower margin direct sourcing activities. Battery and Hyatt were successfully integrated in the quarter and the Hyatt brand was commercially relaunched. Bookings have been strong. Turning to the drivers of the business' 8.7 percent EBITA margin.
This is a good result, up 130 basis points year on year, helped by mix, reflecting LHH's growth and well supported Let's turn to Modis, our technology and digital engineering business on Slide 9. Performance in Q1 was solid and should be seen in light of the later cycle nature of the business. Modis was more resilient than our other GBUs through the crisis and particularly at the beginning of the downturn. Its comparative is therefore tougher than in the Adecco business, for example. Revenues were 3% lower year on year.
On a geographic basis, APAC continued to grow, up 3%, led by Japan. The Americas was 4% lower and EMEA declined by 9%. The business delivered well on its strategic ambitions. There was strong improvement in the U. S.
Business, reflecting early wins from repositioning towards Smart Industries. Higher value, higher margin tech consulting activities were up 5% year on year and are at pre crisis levels. Margins benefited mainly from mix and improved bench utilization. Moving to Slide 10. Let's return to the group's results, this time by service line.
A clear theme over the last 12 months is that the diversification of services in Adeco Group's portfolio drives margin resilience. In Q1, we saw the cyclical businesses improve, while countercyclical career transitions slowed. We also saw strategically important service lines outperforming with training, upskilling and reskilling growing 28% organically and high single digit growth in outsourcing and consulting. Turning to Slide 11 and gross margin developments. Overall, gross margin performance was strong, up 80 basis points in reported terms and organically.
The impact of currencies was 10 basis points negative and was offset by an equivalent positive impact from M and A. Flexible placement had a positive impact of 80 basis points. Approximately 20 basis points came from COVID-nineteen employment support schemes. That leaves a strong underlying improvement of 10 of 60 basis points, reflecting disciplined pricing, better mix and the continued approach to selectively exit lower margin activities. Permanent placement had a 30 basis points negative impact.
As is usual at this point in the economic cycle, perm growth is recovering less quickly than flexible placement. This creates a drag on margins as This business enjoys fees with close to 100% gross margin. Offsetting the decline in permanent placement were career transition, which added 10 basis points and other services such as outsourcing and training, which added 20 basis points. Let's move to Slide 12, where on the left hand side of the slide, we can see the SG and A development relative to sales and gross profit. Overall, we continue to manage our SG and A effectively with costs down 2% organically year on year, even with revenues growing, driving strong operating leverage.
Outlook. Looking at the breakdown of the SG and A movements, FTEs were down 6% year on year with personnel expenses EBITDA down by 4% organically. As activity picks up, we've brought back most of our colleagues who'd been on short term work. With that, the impact of COVID related employment support on SG and A has further diminished to around €3,000,000 in Q1. On the other hand, the improved performance in Q1 commitment to the bonus and commission accruals were up year on year.
We continue to invest in IT and our digital capabilities strategy. Strong operational discipline meant that our productivity ratio, gross profit Per FTE increased by 12% organically in the quarter. Our conversion ratio reached 20.7% and was up 5.40 basis points when compared to prior year, organically and excluding 1 offs, leading the peer group. The organic dropdown ratio, meaning incremental gross profit converted into incremental EBITA, was 136 percent in Q1. As we said last quarter, when the growth is close to 0, the recovery ratio financial performance.
On the right hand side of the slide, you see the impact of the gross margin uplift and the strong operating leverage. EBITA margin was 4.2%, up 120 basis points on both a reported and an organic basis. Revenues returned to growth in Q1, up 2% organic and trading days adjusted with 9% growth in March. In the revenue recovery as lockdown measures were tightened across most of our markets. As we exit the quarter, year on year growth has sharply accelerated due to the comparisons.
We also see gradual improvement in the weekly sequential trends in April as vaccination campaigns accelerate and restrictions are eased in some countries. We expect this to continue, though we are cognizant COVID-nineteen and economic uncertainties remain elevated, and the recovery is likely to be nonlinear. Outlook. On the cost side, we will remain disciplined in our approach to investments with a focus on driving strong productivity and operating leverage from the return to growth. We also expect the group to continue to generate solid cash flow underpinning our balanced capital allocation policy.
With that, I'll hand back to Alain.
Thank you, Coram. And before we conclude, A short reminder of the strategic direction of the group. With Future at Work, we have developed distinct strategies for all 3 global business units, Adecco, Talent Solutions and Moody's. For Adecco, focus is on market share, cost leadership and differentiated services with a digitized omnichannel strategy, driving superior client and candidate experience. In Talent Solutions, we will drive growth by addressing the end to end skills transformation needs of our customers, bringing together the complementary strength of the various brands.
And with MODIS, we are building a market leader in technology consulting focused on smart industry. Underpinning the strategies of all three business units is a group wide focus on customer experience, differentiation and digitalization, the key enablers of future at work. And central to the entire strategy is a clear common social purpose to make the future work for everyone. Let me conclude with Slide 15 and our 2021 priorities. We look to build on the Q1's growth with each global business unit pivoting towards growth areas in a disciplined and data driven way, leveraging our unparalleled service range.
The GBUs will also prioritize the delivery of strong margins and cash returns, sustaining a disciplined approach to pricing, cost and investments in their businesses. The implementation of Future at Work has begun well, But we are in the heavy lifting phase. Successful execution of our key digitization and transformation initiatives is front of mind. As we continue to implement our strategy, we will not lose sight of our objectives to make the future work for everyone. And with this, I kindly hand over to the operator for the question and answers.
The first question comes from Andy Grobler from Zisis. Please go ahead.
Hi, good morning. Just a couple from me, if I may, to start with at least. You talked about the 40% growth in logistics and e commerce during the quarter. Can you just give us a sense of how big that is within Q1 as a proportion of, say, Adecco's revenues. And secondly, as we go into Well, actually, I have 3 questions.
Secondly, so go into Q2, can you give us a bit of guide around gross margin and SG and A? And thirdly, savings from previous years in terms of grow together and so forth, do you expect those to become apparent within numbers through 2021 2022 or have they kind of been reinvested into the business or lost in the mix during that period?
Thank you, Andy, for your questions. Regarding the segment logistics and distribution and the 30% growth in this quarter. We speak about 9% of our global revenues.
And let me pick up on the questions around gross margin and grow together. So in terms of the gross margin going into Q2, I think you know we have a diverse portfolio, so giving precise guidance is tricky. But let me try and give you a couple of pointers. Firstly, M and A is likely to be a slight positive because of the divestment of the vendor parts business, so probably around 10 basis points. Foreign exchange is likely to be a bit more negative than it was in Q1, so maybe around minus 20 basis points.
And then thirdly, the hedge that we've seen in our gross margin between perm and career transition, the dynamics are shifting slightly. So as we've outlined, the growth in career transition is slowing as economies pick up, But perm is starting to become a bit more positive. So I think it's fair to assume you'll see that natural hedge continue and the 2 largely offset each other. And then that leaves the temporary gross margin, the flexible placement gross margin, That's likely to be positive in Q2. The reason for that is there were a number of one offs relating to COVID-nineteen in Q2 2020.
We quantified those at around 40 basis points This time last year, they will reverse and there's probably going to be a little bit of underlying improvement in gross margin as well as we focus in a disciplined way on pricing and mix. So I would assume 50 to 60 basis points of positivity on the temp gross margin. In terms of conversion ratio, drop down ratio, The way that we manage the business is on that 50% drop down. So in other words, €0.50 of every euro of additional gross margin drops through. It's obviously been higher in Q1.
That's because It's a little less meaningful when the revenues are around 0 because small movements create quite big variations, but it still shows we're being very disciplined in the way we're managing cost. And so I think going forwards into Q2, you should expect us to be closer to that normal level of 50%. And that's because as revenues come back, we invest in FTEs, there's less employment support and some of our variable costs go up a little bit, such as bonus and travel and expenses We talked about this obviously in previous calls. We were very pleased with the way that, that program worked and we delivered €240,000,000 in 2020. I mean, not all of that, as we know, dropped through to the bottom line.
That's partly because revenues were significantly below what we expected at the beginning of the cycle. And we also made some strategic decisions to invest in ventures, IT and digital. Nevertheless, I think you can see from the strength of our margin performance, the productivity improvements that we've got, the 12% up on gross profit per CEO that there is definitely an underlying benefit from the Grow Together program, and you see that in our margin performance right now.
Thank you for your questions, Andy.
Thank you.
The next question comes from Oskar Balmaz from JPMorgan. Please go ahead.
Yes, good morning. Can you hear me well?
We can. Good morning.
Great. Good morning. So I have three questions. The first one on just the sequential organic revenue growth. I was wondering if you could provide a bit more detail on the monthly trends.
So you provided March plus 9 from minus 19 last year. That looks like you're running at 90% of 2019 levels. Could you quantify the 2019 kind of the sorry, the April level and How much you've recovered in April? That's the first question. The second question is around branches.
Has COVID-nineteen changed your thinking around the need for branches in the medium term. And then the third question is around your digital investments and maybe Adecco Group's Adecco Group. Could you provide an update on how Adecco is going in the U. S? And I think you mentioned over the past few quarters that you were transitioning Adecco from a hospitality exposed business to an industrial exposed business.
Could you comment on how that switch is going? Thank you.
Thank you very much.
Let me start on the revenue question. I think you're right to focus on 2019 because clearly the comparatives move around a lot in 2020 given that the crisis started in the middle of March. So in terms of the comparatives versus 2020, we were up 9% In March, in terms of the quarter for Q1, we were down 8% versus 2019. And if you look at the weekly trends in Q1, the sequential performance was very stable. It didn't move up significantly.
It didn't move down significantly. And that's because the restrictions that were in place during Q1 in a lot of our key markets acted as a little bit of a cap to growth. What we've seen in the early stages of Q2 Is a modest improvement in sequential in the sequential performance. So the weeklies have improved modestly through the month. There's little bit of noise at the beginning of April because of Easter, but we are definitely seeing a modest improvement in sequential performance as the restrictions start to get lifted as vaccination campaigns really come through.
And clearly given the comparatives in Q2, that will mean a significant bounce back in terms of revenues. But I think To reinforce the points I made in my script, we'd expect that modest sequential improvement to continue through Q2,
Thank you, Coram. Now coming to your questions regarding the branches. What we see is that COVID has not changed the megatrends, that has accelerated the megatrends. And with this, the digitalization, also the digitized relationship with candidates and our customers. So you have seen in the quarter indeed a decrease of about 9% of our number of branches.
In these branches, you have a mix of classical branches, but also on-site. We strongly believe that, yes, branches will are here to stay, but for sure, Their role is changing. They are becoming more and more focused on opportunity of customer facing and candidate facing. A lot of process are and will be automated, But at some point of time, for an advice regarding Carrier for a special assessment and If you especially if you are in blue color areas, you need to test the dexterity, you need to assess the dexterity of your candidate, and you need a physical presence to do this. And so that's how we see for the role of our branch developing.
So not really a disruption, but a continuous evolutions with also the development of this new role. Then on the digital investment and more specifically your questions regarding AdeA U. S. Yes, we are very pleased with the pilots that Adecco has done. To give you some direction regarding the figures, we had a triple digit growth in the Q1 of this year.
The business is still small, but beyond, I would say, business growth. This is also for us a way to develop, learn, test some new automated processes and order processes that we can apply in the traditional Adeco business. For example, Adecco Direct is also largely inspired by what we have learned to Adecco in Adecco. Thank you for your questions.
The next question comes from Hans Pluejers from Kepler Cheuvreux. Please go ahead.
Yes, good morning, Mehul. First of all, question on On-site. You just mentioned that maybe also you closed a few of the branch in On-site, but could you give maybe some feeling on what the growth was in On-site, let's say, what the sales trend there was year on year? Secondly, coming back on the gross margin, 80 basis points improvement year on year in the Flex part. You already mentioned, let's say, that there was a mix changes, the 20 basis points impact from from furlough support, but to give you maybe some more color on the rest.
You also mentioned idle time was reduced In the professional part, is it also impacting that? And also on the low margin contract, could you give us some feeling What the impact was that on the gross margin? And maybe more in general also, what was the impact on exiting low margin contracts on sales. And then a last question from my side. Now let's say you see that the market is recovering.
You have been very disciplined on pricing, but how do you see competition and especially from the smaller and mid sized players? And what do you see the risk there
I'll take the first three of those, so on-site and the strength for the gross margin and the impact of exiting sales, and I think Alain will pick up on the final one. In terms of the mix, It's actually we've seen similar trends all the way through. So the on-site business continues to do well. It's up high teens in terms of percentage year on year. So I hope that gives you a sense of how On-site is doing.
In terms of the strength of the gross margin, there are a couple of things going on here. Firstly, the natural hedge that we have seen all the way through the crisis Between career transition, the countercyclical business and perm placement has continued. Unit. Earlier in the crisis, career transition was growing strongly, which was helping us to offset the perm placement drag. That slowed a little bit, perm placement has started to improve.
So you still see that natural edge. And I think that's a real differentiator within our gross margin. In terms of the flexible placement business, which is up 80 basis points. Yes, 20 basis points of that comes from employment support schemes, primarily in Adecco Americas and Adecco Northern Europe. There's also some costs that we incurred at the beginning of the crisis in Q1 2020, which didn't repeat in Q1 2021.
And we said at the time that was worth around 10 basis points, but you still have an underlying improvement in our gross margin of about 50 basis points, which is really strong, and it comes from 3 things. It comes from our continued discipline around pricing. It comes from a continued focus on the value that we're delivering to our clients, and it also comes from mix point that I highlighted earlier in my script, where we are homing in on higher margin business, like outsourcing, like training and really making sure that what we're building is a better, higher quality revenue base with stronger underlying margins. It's the discipline with which we are approaching the crisis. In terms of the exiting, there are a number of and this is really continuing the theme actually of the discipline and building a higher quality business.
We have exited a number of contracts where we just We think we're generating the kind of returns that we should. So for example, in the Benelux, we've done it. We've done it in India. We've exited some low margin direct sourcing in pontoon, and there have been a couple of other areas in the business around the group, where we have chosen not to continue to operate those low margin contracts, because we We believe that's the way to build a sustainable business. And in terms of the impact on revenue, it's probably somewhere between 1% to 2%
Yes, I can confirm that we have been and will remain very disciplined. We are aiming at sustainable profitable growth. What we see at this stage is that, yes, because of the vaccination, reopening of economies, Some business are growing. Do we see more pressure coming from this from midsized players, not really. You see also that in some areas, there is scarcity of candidates, which justify the value of the work we are providing.
So at this stage, no specific pressure on the pricing side coming from mid sized players.
Maybe one follow-up question on the gross margin. As you just mentioned, underlying 50 basis points improvement in Q1 and especially then looking at your Q2 guidance of 50 to 60 basis points positive, While it was your last year still a 40 basis points negative impact from COVID, doesn't let's say For me, it sounds a little bit the guidance for Q2 a little bit on the low end, especially if, let's say, if you price discipline, exiting contracts and focus on higher margin business is, let's say, somewhat is more sustainable. So I can't precisely match those 2.
Look, I think we're coming there's been a period pre crisis where there was a lot of gross margin pressure in the industry as a whole. And I think what you've seen margin business. Now built into our guidance is the absence of the 40 50 basis points every quarter, but we're very focused on making sure that we continue that discipline and that we continue to deliver a strong gross margin and an industry leading gross margin.
Thank you, Hans, for your questions.
Thank you.
Next question comes from Paul Sullivan from Barclays. Please go ahead.
Yes, good morning, everyone. Just really to follow-up on that. I mean, so is the message on is the message really sort of ignore organic focus on gross profit organic going forward because your gap to the to Randstad and the others seems to have deteriorated over the last few quarters. And how does that fit in with your previous desire to grow with the market? Or should we really not Or should we be really focused on that gross margin and gross profit organic growth going forward?
And then just secondly, your thoughts on underlying market wage inflation and how you see coming through the business and just your overall perspective on that, please. Thank you.
Thank you, Paul. I think on the question about relative performance, We do have a different mix of businesses. We have a different mix of geographies. In particular, We have a big French business. And as you know, the French market has been challenging because it is the one where there are still the tightest restrictions of any country in Europe and that has dampened growth.
And other areas like certain parts of Northern Europe, we don't have such a presence. So I think there's an element of mix in this. As I just mentioned, we're also exiting certain business because we are very focused on making sure that we're building the right quality of business and operating in a disciplined way, and that's worth 1 to 2 points. So I think that's had an impact as well. In terms of market share, I hope you get a sense from our script that we're actually pleased with the market share performance.
We think it remains pretty solid. And in a number of territories, we have taken there, particularly in Southern Europe, but there are others as well. And so in this early stage of the recovery, what we're doing is balancing the need for growth with the need to maintain good returns and really trading a fine line between the 2. We're not going after growth At all costs, we're doing it in a disciplined, sustainable way, and you see that in our gross margin and our EBITA. Longer term, we're convinced that that will position the group to allow us to deliver on our mid term goals I'm aware there's quite a debate about the effects of wage inflation right now.
We are seeing pockets 6 of wage inflation, particularly in Latin America and Eastern Europe. But actually, what's happened as a result The crisis more generally seems to be that the tightness of the labor market that we saw Before the crisis has eased a little and therefore actually wage inflation across the group is pretty limited. And the final point I'd note on this in terms of the way that the revenues and the margins reflect that.
Thank you, Paul, for your question.
Can I just follow-up? Just can you remind us how far we are through all these exits? I mean, it seems to have been a recurring feature now for many, many quarters.
I think it's I mean, I've given you a sense of the impact in the quarter. I think we will continue to be selective and disciplined about the way that we manage our business. And if exit if disciplined about the way that we manage our business and if exit if there are certain contracts that don't make sense, we will continue to exit them. It's part of building a better quality of revenues.
Yes. And we'll still see that impact wash through in the second quarter. There'll still be some digital impact of that. I know it will be distorted with the comp and everything else, but underlying we'll still see a drag from that going through?
Absolutely. You will still see an underlying drag, but you're right, the comps distort things in Q2. Yes.
Okay, brilliant. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Bob.
The next question comes from Ennish Agrawal from Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.
Hi, good morning. Most of my questions have been answered, but just on this pricing point. Now if you continue to focus on better pricing, theoretically should do higher revenue number even at lower volume going forward. Is that the right way to think about it? And then just if you can, the contracts that you are exiting, who is picking up that in the market?
Is that your more sort of midsized large competition or that is those contracts are picked up by the smaller players in the market. And another one is on just to clarify, so logistics were up 40% in Q1. Can you give a comparable number for Q4 2020 2020 overall, please?
Yes. I can start with the second question. When we look at logistics in Q4, we had a growth
for the
Q4 to be compared with the 40% of the Q1 of this year. And in 2020, we had a growth of around 20%. Yes. Go ahead.
And just in terms of your question on the sort of mechanics of pricing, Yes, it does have an impact on the revenue that we're achieving for every hour build, but it also and I think you're seeing this In the numbers, it clearly helps our margins and particularly around gross margin. And then in terms of the contract exits, it's very hard to generalize. So the various contracts are going to various different players and it's really spread around the industry, both in terms of size and the people who are picking them up.
And maybe sorry if I can ask one more. On the training upskilling business, can you tell us what are the gross margin dynamics And for that, like we know the career transition is very high, but what are the gross margins on training up skilling, reskilling business? And also, does this business have similar amount of countercyclicality as your career transition business? Or you think this business can growth beyond 2021 and therefore the natural hedge can turn into a tailwind at some point later in the year.
That's the LHH business, but higher than the staffing business. So You should assume probably a 60% gross margin on that business. I think in terms of the trajectory of The upskilling and reskilling business. Longer term, there is, I think, a real tailwind there because a lot of what will need to adapt to a different workforce, a different set of sectors and different ways of working. And I think that has to be a structural positive for that business going forward.
That's very clear. Thank you.
You're welcome.
The next question comes from Martin Keane from Jefferies. Please go ahead.
Good morning. It's Kean Marbourne from Jefferies. I've got 2 quick areas to cover off, if I may. The first is just some math. So If we compare with 2019, just looking at the organic revenue data that you provided over the last year and a half.
January looks like it's down about 6% relative to 2019, but March down 11%, Which doesn't feel like it chimes entirely with your narrative of being sequentially flat during the quarter. So I'm just wondering if you can help us square the circle there. And then secondly, on logistics, just coming back to that. The large U. K.
Contract that you have, Is that fixed in duration or does that come up for retender? And when would that annualize? So do you get a full contribution from Exane in Q3 and Q4 last year.
So perhaps Goran can start with your first question and
then I will follow-up
with your first question. Yes. Let me pick up on Q1. So the best way to focus on this is to think about it in terms of the quarter, where it was minus 8% versus 2019. And the reason that Picking it apart and looking at the month by month movements doesn't quite work is there were some very big trading day adjustments in January March.
And so that creates some noise in the figures. I think the most important aspect of this is what happened sequentially in the quarter, and we saw real stability in those weekly figures, didn't get better, didn't get worse. It's very consistent with what we were seeing when we talked to you on the Q4 call and that continued all the way through the quarter, so sequential stability. And I think the just to remind you, the other point is that in April, we have seen modest improvements in that. And that is consistent with vaccination programs gaining ground, gaining momentum and restrictions being lifted.
Sorry, apologies, just following that. But so you provide trading day adjusted organic revenue growth numbers. So is there any reason why that wouldn't capture the trading day adjustments you've just referenced, Coram?
I think the only point is it puts a bit of noise into the monthly comparatives. So focus on the minus 8% for the quarter, The sequential stability and the fact that we've started to see sequential improvement in April. We're trying to give you a best guide as to what we see is happening.
Sure. Happy call.
Then regarding the logistics contract in UK that we won last year, This is not, I would say, a single contract. This is also part of a broad relationship we have with these customers. We see and by the way, that's what you see also overall, not only in UK, but in the world and in Europe, you see the growth of the e Commerce Solutions going up and with this, the logistics service related associated services. So we have a strong growth since the Q2 last year. And last year, it was also strong trends regarding e commerce and associated logistics and note that we don't have this offset business that we will continue to have a strong growth further.
Great time, Alain. Thank you.
You're welcome.
Investor Relations.
The next question comes from Michael Sood from Vontobel. Please go ahead.
Yes, good morning. Thank you.
Two questions from my side, starting with Automotive. Can you give us an indication on how your automotive business overall developed in the quarter? And Also, are you expecting sort of significant rebound here? What are you hearing from your clients? And it's also in automotive, if you can make a specific comment on how your automotive exposure in Germany Is developing.
And my second question is on the productivity gains. You showed quite impressive productivity show improvements. How is that actually being achieved in practice and how much further productivity gains Can you achieve in coming quarters? Thank you.
Good. Let me take both of those. So In terms of automotive, it was one of the few industries where we did not see a sequential improvement between Q4 and going into Q1, and it was down 20% year on year. It's about 6% to 7% of the group sales overall. I think there are 2 things happening there.
1, as we know, the automotive industry is going through a fair amount of disruption As the business moves from its focus on internal combustion engines through to EVs, that's creating Some disruption. It was further impacted by COVID-nineteen, which put some pressure on it. And then in Q1, we saw the chip shortages in semiconductors really impact a number of different manufacturers in the automotive sector. So it's really been a bit of a perfect storm for automotive. I think as it will start to come back, the chip shortage may take a little while to fix.
I think the main players are pointing to a couple of quarters. And units. The impact of the transition from ICE to EVs will continue to be a theme, but demand is coming back in the car industry. So I think we will start to see a modest improvement. In terms of the impact in Germany, That is a bigger proportion of the sales base, so it's around 15%.
But I would point to the fact that actually the German business has been quite effective at pivoting to other areas of growth and in Q1 was actually up 1% and is driving stronger margins. So I think we are managing the effects of that in the German business. In terms of productivity, It's I think there are a couple of things happening there. Firstly, as you can see, we've been very effective at controlling costs. We've been very disciplined about putting investments back into the business where we think It makes sense where we can see a growth trajectory, and we've been careful to hold back where we don't see that growth coming back.
So it's about the disciplined way in which We put FTEs and investment back into the business. And I think there's also a benefit that you're seeing from the digitization of the business and the productivity tools that we're implementing around the group. So that's driving the productivity improvement overall.
Thank you.
This was the last questions. And before closing the call, I would like to make some closing comments and statements. First of all, thank you, everyone, for joining the call and for your questions. We have seen that we have delivered a robust growth in the Q1 with several businesses now back above 2019 levels. Margin were strong across the portfolio with positive mix, pricing and cost discipline supporting year on year improvement.
Now we have successfully transitioned also to a new organization structure built around the 3 global business units, and we have made good progress with Future at Work, although there is much more work to be done. Looking forward, We are encouraged to see continued recoveries, though we are mindful of uncertainties related to the COVID-nineteen and the economic environment, even with vaccination campaigns underway and an easing of restrictions commenced. Professional agility and our strong financial position, providing a platform to generate long term value for our shareholders. Thank you and talk to you soon. Bye bye.