Altus Group Limited (TSX:AIF)
Canada flag Canada · Delayed Price · Currency is CAD
45.67
-0.70 (-1.51%)
Apr 24, 2026, 4:00 PM EST
← View all transcripts

Earnings Call: Q1 2023

May 4, 2023

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, good afternoon. My name is Abby. I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Altus Group First Quarter 2023 Results Conference Call and Webcast. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. After the speaker's remarks, there will be a question and answer session. If you would like to ask a question during that time, simply press the star key followed by the number one on your telephone keypad. If you would like to withdraw your question, press star one once again. Thank you. Ms. Camilla Bartosiewicz, you may begin your conference.

Camilla Bartosiewicz
Chief Communication Officer, Altus Group

Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to Altus Group's first quarter conference call and webcast for the period ended March 31st, 2023. The news release announcing our results was issued after market close this afternoon. It's posted on our website and SEDAR profile, along with our MD&A and financial statements. A presentation to accompany our prepared remarks has also been posted to our website under the Investor Relations section. Joining us today are CEO Jim Hannon and our CFO, Pawan Chhabra. We'll start with some prepared remarks. Then we'll move right into the Q&A session. If we miss any questions, please contact me directly by email. Some of our remarks today may contain forward-looking information. Forward-looking information is based on assumptions and therefore subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from those projected.

These assumptions, risks, and uncertainties are detailed in our forward-looking statements disclaimer in today's materials. Please be reminded that Altus Group uses certain non-GAAP financial measures, non-GAAP ratios, total of segments measures, capital management measures, and supplementary and other financial measures as defined in National Instrument 52-112. We believe that these measures may assist investors in assessing an investment in our shares as they provide additional insight into our performance. Viewers are cautioned that they are not defined performance measures and do not have any standardized meaning under IFRS and may differ from similar computations as reported by other similar entities, accordingly may not be comparable to financial measures as reported by those entities. These measures should not be considered in isolation or as a substitute for financial measures prepared in accordance with IFRS.

An explanation of these measures as are detailed in today's IR materials, including the news release, presentation, MD&A, and other filings with the Canadian Securities Regulators. I would also like to point out that unless otherwise specified, all the growth rates we'll be referencing on this call are on a constant currency basis over the same period in 2022. Okay, over to you, Pawan.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Thank you, Camilla. Good evening to everyone on the call. We had a positive start to the year, continuing our multi-quarter trend of top-line growth and margin expansion. We are now on eight consecutive quarters of double-digit revenue growth and three consecutive quarters of delivering margin expansion at the consolidated level. Beginning with our consolidated first quarter results, although we had foreign exchange rates working in our favor, as Camilla pointed out, unless specified, the growth rates I will be referencing are on a constant currency basis. Revenues were up 11%, supported by double-digit growth at both analytics and property tax. Adjusted EBITDA was up 43%, driving a nice 330 basis point improvement in margin, which stood at 14%. Profit was negative CAD 2.4 million, which is CAD 9 million better than last year.

As a reminder, Q1 of 2022 included a CAD 8.4 million restructuring charge. Q1 of 2023 reflects higher interest rates on our bank credit facilities. We also incurred higher year-over-year expenditures related to the implementation of the new ERP and CRM systems. We're proud to say that our ERP went live in Q1. I'd like to congratulate the team for their hard work in getting us there. Per the plan phasing of the project, the CRM deployment continues through Q2. Adjusted EPS came in at CAD 0.33, and free cash flow was negative CAD 34.4 million. Free cash flow in the quarter reflects the impact of our annual bonus payouts, payments related to our 2022 global restructuring program, and increased working capital balances due to anticipated delayed billings as we cut over to the new ERP system.

As expected, we're seeing an improvement in April in collections and working capital operations. Turning to our business segment performance, starting with analytics. As you will see in our results, the momentum continues in analytics. Revenue was up 12%, and notably, recurring revenue was up 19%. All analytics revenue is now organic. To offer more color, revenue growth continues to be driven by strong recurring revenue performance, which is where our go-to-market efforts and investments are focused. This includes growth across key revenue streams in software, Valuation Management Solutions, and in data solutions. A high percentage of our recurring revenue growth continues to be driven by customer expansion and supported by the ongoing transition to cloud subscriptions and steady new customer additions. Adjusted EBITDA continues to grow with higher revenues and improved operating leverage. Overall, we're really pleased with the sustained momentum and recurring revenue growth.

At CAD 85.3 million in the quarter, recurring revenues represent approximately 90% of total revenues. This provides us with a resilient revenue base. The 740 basis point Adjusted EBITDA margin expansion in the quarter reflects revenue growth and improvements in our operating model. Those include focused go-to-market activities, cross-border salary leverage, streamlined processes, and better resource management. We remain confident in our plans to expand margins in 2023. Turning to property tax, revenue growth was solid, growing at 13%. This reflects double-digit growth in Canada and the U.K., and steady performance in the U.S. In the U.K., our pipeline of cases to be settled in the upcoming quarters has grown and remains robust.

We are now officially on the new 2023 rating list that commenced on April 1st, and through the investments we've been making, we remain well positioned for the new cycle with a much better backlog. Adjusted EBITDA benefited from the revenue growth, and our margins are holding steady per our expectations. Finally, appraisal and development advisory performed steadily in the quarter, driven by development advisory team in the APAC region. Turning to our balance sheet, we finished the quarter with a cash position of CAD 42.9 million and with CAD 350.1 million in bank debt. The Funded Debt to EBITDA leverage ratio, as defined in our credit agreement, was 2.21 x, well below our limit of 4.5 x.

Applying our cash, the Net debt to Adjusted EBITDA leverage ratio was 2.13 x, representing a very healthy balance sheet. Regarding our capital allocation priorities, we'll continue to reinvest in the business to scale effectively, opportunistically pay down debt, and maintain financial flexibility should attractive acquisition opportunities materialize. With that, I'll now turn it over to Jim.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Thanks, Pawan. As we're sitting in Toronto tonight, I want to start with good luck to the Toronto Maple Leafs. As many of you know, I am hesitant to say I live in Florida. My colleagues around me said I was not allowed to buy a ticket to the game. Struck me as odd, but okay. They didn't know I was going to say that. All right, let's get to it. I'd like to start by thanking my colleagues for a productive start to the year. Their efforts and commitment to our mission are driving the growth of the company. Our ongoing transition from on-premise software to ARGUS Cloud is tracking to plan. We ended the quarter with 67% of our ARGUS Enterprise users contracted on the cloud and expect to finish the year with a large majority on cloud.

We're growing the number of users on our platform and now have over 10 million valuation models in our environment, representing an estimated 960,000 unique properties modeled on ARGUS globally. As we expand our advanced analytics capabilities, the large volume of models in ARGUS Cloud will provide us with exceptional asset-level intelligence that we can leverage to enhance the value we bring to our clients. Turning to new bookings, as noted in the name, this metric only captures new business. It does not include renewals or assets added to current portfolios which we service. Although our pace of new bookings growth slowed in Q1, we continue to grow from a larger base of clients and with low churn. The majority of our quarterly bookings occur in the 3rd month of the quarter, the banking sector made headlines in early March.

This macroeconomic news slowed down the decision-making of some of our larger clients. On balance, new bookings benefited from continued addition of portfolios in our VMS business and strong ARGUS Enterprise bookings performance throughout the quarter. Our software pipeline continues to grow in line with our historical pace. We remain optimistic. At the same time, we continue to keep an eye on macroeconomic conditions and will throttle our investments accordingly. Last week, we held our Altus Connect Client Conference, the first since the start of the pandemic. The Altus Connect Conference had a terrific turnout. The attendance of many senior professionals validates the growing strategic importance of our offers across their organizations and the Altus-trusted relationships in the market.

The conference featured panels on a variety of topics and included a Solutions Café where we held product demos, including the new Altus Market Insights offer, which is powered by the Altus Performance Platform. Overall, it was great to connect with our clients on important topics affecting commercial real estate and to foster dialogue about the topics most relevant to our industry. Actionable intelligence is a table stake requirement today. Intelligence and information are key to being nimble and responsive to changing market dynamics and investor and regulatory requirements. We deliver the combination of data, technology, and expertise to our clients as offers. This is Intelligence-as-a-Service. We left our Altus Connect conference with renewed conviction in our long-term strategy. At the conference, clients and market experts from within and from outside Altus discussed at length the challenges and longer-term opportunities created by the current macro environment.

A consistent message from the experts is the significant need for transparency and actionable intelligence. Our mission to help our clients drive portfolio alpha and manage data has never been more relevant. We continue to successfully navigate this dynamic business environment to position ourselves strategically for the longer-term opportunities. We know that volatility in the market drives demand for our advanced analytics offers. Our business model is resilient and provides us with stability across various economic cycles. To reiterate, one, we have a diversified revenue base of offers by geography and across various customer segments. two, we have a strong recurring revenue base in analytics and highly reoccurring and repeatable client engagement at CRE Consulting. Finally, we have expense levers that provide us with the flexibility to respond to macroeconomic conditions.

Our restructuring activities in FY 2022 have provided us with the ability to invest for future growth while continuing to expand margins. As we stated in our February business outlook, we're well positioned to grow our consolidated revenue and Adjusted EBITDA for full year 2023. We have multiple paths to deliver on our plans and remain confident in our ability to reach our goals. Okay, let's open the line up for questions. Operator?

Operator

Thank you. As a reminder, if you would like to ask a question, press star, then one on your telephone keypad, we will pause for just a moment to compile the Q&A roster. We will take our first question from Yuri Lynk with Canaccord Genuity. Your line is open.

Yuri Lynk
Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

Hey, good evening, everyone.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Yuri.

Yuri Lynk
Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

Jim, I'd love a bit more color on the macro and what you saw in the quarter. I'm wondering if the banking issues we saw in terms of the impact on purchasing decisions and bookings for you. I mean, do you feel that those issues served as a distraction, or was it more causing a more fundamental slowdown due to, say, tighter lending conditions in CRE and stuff like that? Just a bit more color.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Sure. Great question, Yuri. I want to start on that. I'm not an economist. We listened closely to our clients last week, as I know you did as well. We heard consistently across the board that the news in early March kind of put everybody into a pause while they go, "Wait, what just happened?" The fundamentals of CRE, especially at the various segment levels, not, you know, as you know, not all CRE segments are the same. The fundamentals are strong. The cash flows are strong, which is why this is such an attractive asset class and will always remain an attractive asset class. We're watching it carefully. We'll react. Right now, we're hearing mostly it's a pause. We're watching the rise of private debt funds.

The balance between the use of debt and equity, and then the implication that we'll have on pricing may adjust, but our clients have a significant amount of dry powder on the sidelines. We'll, you know, they are engaging with us. As soon as it got announced, they engaged with us immediately to go deeper on valuations, which is good for us. They immediately wanted the data on what's going on, which is, you know, in the market, what are we seeing across, you know, hundreds of thousands of properties. It's great to be in that position with them. We see it as a pause until the fundamentals change. Interest rates obviously tweak up, which, you know, is either, you know, which will be reflected in different pricing of the assets.

We don't trade on the price of the assets, and our, you know, our revenue is not a function of transaction volume.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

just maybe to add to that, what was clear to me coming out of the Connect meeting was our clients are looking for a trusted partner to help them navigate through the current and upcoming volatility, which I think will be a positive for us in regards to being able to help people manage alpha data.

Yuri Lynk
Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

Yeah. I mean, I was talking to a lot of the same people you were, and I mean, sometimes you walk away and you feel like they might be, because of all of this uncertainty, heavier users of your services. But that's not what we saw in the first quarter, but that was obviously at the onset. I guess just a follow-up to that. I mean, given what you're seeing with your bookings, do you have any expectations of throttling back investments at this point?

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Yeah. Let me comment on what we saw in Q1. We saw a rise in the number of assets that we serviced in VMS. We saw a rise in the number of ARGUS users in total, as well as ARGUS Cloud users. We did see growth in Q1. It's the bookings number at the end of March where we're saying, "Well, let's watch and see what impact that will really have on maybe 2024, if any." When we talk about multiple paths, talking about multiple paths to our internal cash flow targets, you know, that's where we remain optimistic. Yes, it absolutely could provide, you know, it was a bookings pause.

It could absolutely lead to higher volumes for us, not from a number of assets, but from reliance on our analytics and data. We are certainly getting more and more engaged and being asked to engage on debt valuation. Whether it's from deploying debt capital or whether it's from looking at, implications of already underwritten assets. It actually, we think this is gonna open up several market segments for us. To your point on bookings and, pulling back or throttling investments, one, the ARGUS bookings remained strong throughout the quarter. With that same profile of many of the bookings come in later in the quarter. ARGUS is just a very privileged position for us to be in.

As far as throttling the investments, as you know, we had, you know, 1,100-1,200 bits margin expansion in Q4 year-over-year. Thought that gave us the financial ability to add capacity in 2023, 'cause as I've commented on throughout FY 2022, every metric we had told us to add go-to-market capacity, particularly LTV to CAC ratio, and we weren't doing it until the model proved out. We were also holding back in FY 2022 because of the volatility in the market, the geopolitical and the inflation aspects of last year. We held back then. We messaged that we would be increasing that significantly this year, which is why we talked, why, you know, we talk about 300 bits expansion when we think about how we allocate across our portfolio.

Obviously, the restructuring we did last year, the operating efficiency from last year, the pricing lift we get from the move to cloud gives us a lot of flexibility in our EBITDA. That's what we're talking about when we say we get throttle investments. We won't go as fast in the sales capacity, but we will still add some 'cause we're investing for 2024.

Scott Fletcher
Equity Research Analyst, CIBC Capital Markets

Okay, great. I'll hop off. Thanks, guys.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Sure.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Thanks, Darren.

Operator

We will take our next question from Stephen MacLeod with BMO. Your line is open.

Stephen MacLeod
Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Great. Thank you. Good evening, everyone. Just wanted to follow up a little bit on the new bookings. Can you just talk about how sort of that was trending, up until March? 'Cause it sounds as though, you know, as per your press release and headlines, it sort of became more, more noisy in the, in the beginning of March. I was just wondering if there's been any change that you can report on a quarter-to-date basis.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Stephen, we did our Q4 earnings call February 24th, somewhere around there. On there, I commented that our Q1 pipeline and our coverage ratios were stronger. They were. Month one, Month two, we're tracking along at a nice clip. It's really just the reaction to the March headlines. I think as the market takes a deep breath and goes, "What just happened?" We will pace ourselves accordingly with what we see in the market. Going back to last year, if we run relatively flat in new bookings, that gets us to the plan that we have in place for the business.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Yeah.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

As far as quarter to date, That's typically not something we jump into right now. What we do track is I had a comment in there about our pipeline build. What we track is at, specifically at an ARGUS Enterprise level, the number of leads that go into our pipeline per week. We were expecting to see that trail down in March and April, and it is almost dead on our weekly trend for the last 2 years.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Yeah. Stephen.

Stephen MacLeod
Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Nothing you don't know, but, you know, 2/3 of our sales typically happen in month 3 of a quarter. Given the timing of the news, it obviously had an overweight impact in regards to the finish. Just adding a little bit of color on how that works.

Stephen MacLeod
Managing Director and Senior Equity Research Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay. Yeah. Thanks, Alan. That is helpful. Then I guess, in terms of the new bookings, is that coming from existing or new customers? The slowdown is, I guess, is it really, or is it a mix of both?

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

It's a mix of both. We still I'm looking at the team here, couple of hundred new logos, not as many new logos. Like, we've been running in that 250 range. We are, we added just over 200 in the quarter. It's more at the scale end of the market.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Oh, I see.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Now, it could be the large funds are the first ones to reach out and engage us. When the banking news hit at the beginning of March, it was those large funds, those deep trusted relationships, where they immediately called us in.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Yeah. Okay.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

From an analytical perspective.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Yeah, I see. I see. I just wanted to clarify one thing you said there, Jim. Did you say that if you run flat in new bookings, it'll still get you on plan to where you wanna be for this year?

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

We were saying that all through last year, that we didn't need, like, if the team ran basically the same. We, you know, obviously, Stephen, we need to make up the March piece of it. We're not seeing opportunities fall out of the pipe for the year. We're seeing them push to the second half. Part of that, you know, some of it could come together right in second quarter. I think our sales team is being conservative and saying, "Well, let's put it in the second half." That's good for us because then we plan our investments accordingly.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Yeah. Okay. That makes sense. Okay, great. Thanks, guys. Appreciate it.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Thank you.

Operator

We'll take our next question from Christian Sgro with Eight Capital. Your line is open.

Christian Sgro
Equity Research Analyst, Eight Capital

Hi, good evening. Thanks for taking my questions. The first one I wanted to ask is a follow-on of Stephen's question, and maybe it's been asked in other words, do you get the sense in conversations with customers that in March, they were, you know, frozen up, maybe pushing out the decision, call it to June, the 3rd month of this next quarter? Do you think, you know, maybe they're getting more thoughtful about which offers or solutions they're gonna pick up, and if they, you know, wanna subscribe to the same sorts of solutions? Is it a push-out, would you say, or more of a, like a halt at this point?

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Great. Thanks, Christian. Again, I'm gonna go back to some of the stuff that you heard from the stage last week, from clients, not from me. You know, our clients are in the business of deploying capital. They don't love uncertainty, so, you know, they got a Fed decision yesterday. They can get visibility across the broader banking sector. I think they'll be keeping a close eye on bank balance sheets and the implications there. Do we think the transactions are gone forever? Absolutely not. It feels more like a pause to us right now.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Yeah.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

It's not a, it's not an indefinite pause. I mean, back to the our Argus Enterprise bookings continue to be strong. That, you know, some of that's gonna be attributed to Argus is quite a powerful tool, not just for acquisitions or dispositions, but for also analyzing the performance of an asset. As our clients are evaluating the current pricing that's out in the last market, they're gonna be using Argus to do that. They're gonna be using, like, the new tools that we have, like Insights, Office Market Insights to do that. Eventually they're gonna deploy capital. As I said, pricing capital structure might change with interest rates, but there's still an economic formula that makes commercial real estate attractive.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Yeah. Christian, just in my conversations with the sales team as well too, I mean, there was clearly prudently measured response from our, from our clients in March after the headlines. The opportunities, the key opportunities that we were keeping an eye on are still in play. It's really more of just a slowdown.

Christian Sgro
Equity Research Analyst, Eight Capital

Got it. Then on the, you know, the cloud adoption rates that trended up in the quarter, I know that's a big part of the narrative and getting customers to move on to the cloud and adopt new cloud-based products. So my question is, have those conversations changed at all? Would you say the pieces are still in place for a lot of your customers to continue migrating through the year? How do you see that all trending?

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

We know our clients are watching our cloud growth. We know that our clients listen to these calls, we're really proud to report that 10 million models number. That is unbelievably powerful, especially at this moment in time. In 960,000 unique properties, that is quite the purview we have. Not that we don't take clients' data and put it out there, but it does give us a data derivative view that does, you know, for the clients that have given us those derivative rights, which is a significant amount of them. We're seeing more opt-in to giving us those rights because they want the analytics that comes from that type of massive data.

they also know invested hundreds of millions of dollars over the last 2 years to be able to turn that data into insights.

Christian Sgro
Equity Research Analyst, Eight Capital

Got it. Got it. Yeah. Thanks for all the color, Jim. I'll pass the line here. Thank you.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Thank you.

Operator

We will take our next question from Richard Tse with National Bank Financial. Your line is open.

James Burns
Senior Analyst, National Bank Financial

Hi, this is James Burns sitting in for Richard. I was just wondering, do you expect to still be on track to driving the 300 basis point improvement in Altus Analytics margins, by year-end despite the heightened investments?

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Yeah, as you can see, you know, we were 710 bps higher in Q1. You're seeing the restructuring activities, the operating model changes, the pricing changes, the retirement of old platforms, the platform economics we've been talking about. You can see that in Q1, right? That coming off of that base, it gives us a lot of room for investment, even in this macro environment, to invest for growth and still get to the 300 bps. Absolutely.

James Burns
Senior Analyst, National Bank Financial

Just to follow up on that. Do you think, like, should we expect the margins to really tick up in the back half of the year? Cause, I think the, yeah, the margin was about 21.4% this quarter, so you would need a significant uptick for the remaining three quarters.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Absolutely. You gotta remember when thinking about the seasonality of the business, there's millions of dollars of employment taxes that kick in in Q1, that most of them hit their thresholds mid-Q2, right? If you look at the analytics numbers, you know, the analytics revenue numbers, CAD 5 million is a significant amount. That's not all analytics. The majority of that's analytics. That's a significant number of bps in the quarter.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Yeah. I mean, we always plan for lower margins in Q1, just given what Jim said. This was in line with our expectations.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Actually, the margin was higher because we did.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Right

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

a bit.

James Burns
Senior Analyst, National Bank Financial

Okay, great. Thanks. I'll pass the line.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Thank you, James.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Thanks, James.

Operator

We will take our next question from Gavin Fairweather with Cormark Securities. Your line is open.

Gavin Fairweather
Research Analyst, Cormark Securities

Oh, hey there. Good afternoon. You touched in your prepared remarks on increased demand from, you know, lenders and credit funds given the environment. Maybe you can just provide a bit more color on that and also discuss the Finance Active product and kinda where we're at on bringing that to North America and igniting that cross-sell?

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Sure. Thanks, Gavin. The increased demand was as you can imagine, many of our clients are on both the equity and debt side. The majority of our revenues come from the equity investors. In this environment where you're sitting with, you know, it's across the large investors, it's also across the bank, the smaller banks where, you know, 60%-70% of commercial underwriting happens. That's all greenfields for us. Those are not segments we typically get involved with. Some of our larger clients are working with those smaller banks, and this is what they need valuation of what's happening with their portfolios, right? They need visibility now, 'cause they need to make sure that they're maintaining their capital requirements and their balance sheets.

It's been a fascinating few weeks to see the inbound engagement for us and watching our teams react. It's a different level of valuation. It's not the same level of precision that you're gonna do for LP reporting in a private fund, let's say. Right now they're more in a triage mode, and we're in a position to help them.

Gavin Fairweather
Research Analyst, Cormark Securities

That's great. Just for my follow-up, hoping you could touch on R&D kind of resource allocation. Obviously, a lot of work went into the new platform. You've also moved, you know, towards no longer supporting some of the on-prem versions. I guess I'm curious how many of your people are now kind of focused on, you know, functional innovation versus kind of the performance platform and older versions, and how has that changed over the past, you know, 6 or 12 months?

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Right. In September and October, that's where in some of our restructuring charges, there was restructuring of development skill sets that didn't apply to the cloud. In rough terms, we look at as our historical R&D spend. If you think of the on-prem legacy platforms versus the cloud, we were roughly 80% of our R&D spend was going into maintenance or we call it current engineering. About 15-20% was going into innovation, right, into next gen. We've pretty much flipped that on its head with that restructuring. The other move we made was we had a build, operate, and transfer type contract with a firm in India, and we exercised that option late last year to bring those folks in-house.

Most of them have been with us. They're associated with us for quite a while. Very talented team, and we wanted to give them career pathing opportunities with us and build out our presence there. They came in in-house, gave us very current market skills, and it also gave us some cross-border salary arbitrage.

Scott Fletcher
Equity Research Analyst, CIBC Capital Markets

That's helpful. Thanks so much.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Thanks, Gavin.

Operator

We will take our next question from Scott Fletcher with CIBC. Your line is open.

Scott Fletcher
Equity Research Analyst, CIBC Capital Markets

Evening, thanks for taking the question. wanted to follow up just on a comment, Jim, you made about the bookings sort of impact in 2024. Can you just remind us what the typical time is for both the recurring and the non-recurring bookings to end up for when they start to hit the revenue lines?

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Scott. Sure. The typical time is 1-2 quarters when the bookings flow through. My 2024 comment was we do need to add sales capacity because we see this as a short-term blip, the macro market conditions. My. Oh, yes, it is 30 years experience. I was trying to round that down, but I can't. Is that you're looking at 8-12 months to get a salesperson up to fully productive. We do need to be thinking about our growth next year, especially since we think this is a short cycle of, you know, the pause here. We need to invest for that.

Again, to James's question earlier, we have plenty of capacity in the analytics P&L to support that, through all sorts of market environments right now.

Scott Fletcher
Equity Research Analyst, CIBC Capital Markets

Okay. That's.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

We're going a bit slower than we wrote into our plan. We are adding capacity there. You can think of it as it's more of a reallocation or the term I use is P&L geography. We reallocated resources where we had efficiencies to put it towards capacity. The 300 basis points we're very comfortable with, including adding that capacity for 2024.

Scott Fletcher
Equity Research Analyst, CIBC Capital Markets

Thanks. I did wanna ask just another question on the working capital changes in the quarter. It sounds like the ERP system led to some billing delays. Maybe if you could just help us understand what we should expect for the cadence of working capital for the rest of the year.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Yeah, no, I'll take that question. You know, we anticipated some billing delays associated with our transfer over to the new system, so it was in line with our expectations. Keep in mind, we made a hard cut over, so as any transformation goes or changeover goes, there is a timing period where leads to delays. You know, as we're looking at April relative to where we were in Q1, we're back on pace in terms of working capital operations. It was just really more of a transition over that caused a temporary delay.

Scott Fletcher
Equity Research Analyst, CIBC Capital Markets

It sounds like a pretty quick reversal, like all things considered.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Oh, yeah. Yes, We're not really viewing it as an event here.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Scott, as Pawan pointed out, we do pay bonuses in Q1 also.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

That's right.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

We have that optic in there as well.

Pawan Chhabra
CFO, Altus Group

Yeah. As I mentioned, we have the bonus payment. We also had the restructuring program as well too, that we paid out in Q1. That wasn't just necessarily all related to the anticipated delays. There's a host of things that happened in Q1.

Scott Fletcher
Equity Research Analyst, CIBC Capital Markets

Okay. Thanks for the color.

Operator

As a reminder, it is star one if you would like to ask a question. With no further questions at this time. I do apologize. We did just get a question from John Shuter with RBC. Your line is open.

John Shuter
Equity Research Associate, Technology, RBC Capital Markets

Hi, it's John on for Paul Treiber. Sorry about the last-minute question here. I'm curious about the CRE consulting and specifically on the U.K. property tax business. Can you set expectations for what's a reasonable outlook for property tax revenue in Q2? Should we be expecting it flat with Q1 or a typical seasonal rise outside of the U.K. billing cycle that we should expect? Thanks.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

The Q2 numbers. Our Q2 is normally a spike in the U.K. Our U.K. team, let me just start with, was absolutely crushed it in Q1, our U.K. tax team. They were focused on working down the last of the 2017 Rating List. As we book those, when you book in the U.K. and you win an appeal, you win it back to the start date. We overemphasized our efforts there throughout Q1 because that drives backlog that has 7-year revenue implications, right? It's very, very nutrient-rich backlog that we picked up. In Q2, you shift to the reset, so we'll have that natural decline of the annuity. We're going in with a stronger backlog than we originally anticipated.

John Shuter
Equity Research Associate, Technology, RBC Capital Markets

That's helpful. Thanks.

Operator

As a reminder, it is star one if you would like to ask a question. With no further questions at this time, I will turn the call back to Mr. Jim Hannon for closing remarks.

Jim Hannon
CEO and Director, Altus Group

Great. Thanks everybody. Thanks again for joining the call this evening. I'm guessing everyone's gonna be wrapping up and heading out to the game at this point. Again, my team here is saying, "Go Leafs, go." As always, please don't hesitate to get in touch with us through Camilla, or if you have any other follow-up questions. Thank you for your time.

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes today's conference call, and we thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.

Powered by