Earnings Call: Q4 2018

Feb 6, 2019

Good day, everyone, and welcome to the Asbury Automotive Group Q4 and Year End 2018 Earnings Call. Today's conference is being recorded. And at this time, I would like to turn the conference over to Matt Pattoni. Please go ahead, sir. Thanks, operator, and good morning, everyone. Welcome to Asbury Automotive Group's Q4 2018 earnings call. Today's call is being recorded and will be available for replay later today. The press release detailing Asbury's 4th quarter results was issued earlier this morning and is posted on our website at asburyauto.com. Participating with us today are David Holt, our President and Chief Executive Officer John Hartman, our Senior Vice President of Operations and Sean Goodman, our Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. At the conclusion of our remarks, we will open the call up for questions and I will be available later for any follow-up questions. Before we begin, I must remind you that the discussion during the call today is likely to contain forward looking statements. Forward looking statements are statements other than those which are historical in nature. All forward looking statements are subject to significant uncertainties and actual results may differ materially from those suggested by the statements. For information regarding certain of the risks that may cause actual results to differ, please see our filings with the SEC from time to time, including our Form 10 ks for the year ended December 2017, any subsequently filed quarterly reports on Form 10 Q and our earnings release issued earlier today. We expressly disclaim any responsibility to update forward looking statements. In addition, certain non GAAP financial measures as defined under SEC rules may be discussed on this call. As required by applicable SEC rules, we provide reconciliations of any such non GAAP financial measures to the most directly comparable GAAP measures on our website. It is my pleasure to hand the call over to our CEO, David Hohle. David? Thanks, Matt, and good morning, everyone. 2018 was a record year for Asbury. In a flat star environment, we generated $6,900,000,000 of revenue, retailed over 185,000 vehicles, serviced over 2,000,000 vehicles, delivered front end yield per vehicle over 3,100, grew parts and service gross profit by 5%, achieved an adjusted operating margin of 4.6% and grew adjusted earnings per share by 31% to a record of $8.41 Our success was driven by growth in our used vehicle business, higher F and I gross profit and continued solid growth in parts and service. This was coupled with a balanced approach to SG and A, disciplined spending while at the same time investing in our future by developing omni channel capabilities. During 2018, we continued our strategy of balanced capital allocation, seeking the highest risk adjusted returns through investments in our existing business, acquiring new stores and returning capital to our shareholders. During 2018, we repurchased $105,000,000 of our shares, we acquired and integrated 3 stores and we recently signed an agreement to acquire 4 stores in the Indianapolis market that we expect to close in Q1 of 2019 subject to customary closing conditions. With this transaction, our total stores in the Indianapolis market will increase to 7. Turning to the future, to capitalize on our unused fixed capacity and enhanced employee retention, on Monday we announced a package of industry leading benefits for revenue producing associates. These benefits include subsidized medical plans, education grants, a 4 day work week, extended vacation time, paid maternity leave and equity grants. The frontline equity program is expected to be part of Asbury's new equity plan which is subject to shareholder approval in the Q2 of 2019. Finally, the omnichannel investments that we have made in the past are the foundation of a differentiated guest centric retail model that we have been developing for the future. Our frontline associates are critical to our vision and we are excited to be able to offer them industry leading benefits that we believe will enhance our long term growth potential. I will now hand the call over to Sean to discuss our Q4 financial performance. Sean? Thank you, David, and good morning, everyone. We are pleased with our operating performance in the 4th quarter. Overall, compared to the prior year Q4, revenue increased by 7% and gross profit increased by 5%. Gross margin of 15.8% was 30 basis points lower than last year. SG and A as a percentage of gross profit increased by 90 basis points to 68.2 percent. Adjusted operating margin of 4.5% was 20 basis points lower than last year. Our adjusted net income increased by 14 percent to $43,200,000 and adjusted earnings per share increased by 22% to $2.20 This year we implemented accounting standard ASC 606 for revenue recognition, the net impact of adopting ASC 606 in the 4th quarter was to increase net income by $1,200,000 or $0.06 per diluted share. Net income for the Q4 of 2018 was adjusted for a $3,700,000 pre tax non cash charge or $0.14 per diluted share for franchise rights impairments. Our effective tax rate was 25.3 percent for the quarter, up from 21.9% in the Q4 of 2017. And our full year tax rate was 25.3%. We successfully managed our SG and A expenses during the quarter to achieve SG and A as a percentage of gross profit of 68.2%. This is despite continued omnichannel investments that for the year exceeded $10,000,000 Overall, SG and A as a percentage of gross profit for 2018 was 68.5 percent, down 60 basis points from the prior year. Floorplan interest expense in Q4 increased by $4,000,000 over the prior year, driven mainly by higher interest rates. A reminder that our floor plan debt has a floating interest rate, while all other debt is fixed rate. At the end of the quarter, our total leverage ratio stood at 2.9 times and our net leverage ratio at 2.5 times, thanks to our strong operating results and solid cash flow generation. A 2.5 times net leverage ratio is at the low end of our targeted range of 2.5 to 3 times. We believe that this positions us well to capitalize on potential attractive future capital deployment opportunities while taking into consideration the economic cycle. We repurchased $48,000,000 of our own shares in Q4, bringing the total share repurchases for 2018 to $105,000,000 Our remaining share repurchase authorization stands at $82,000,000 In 2018, we spent $40,000,000 on non real estate related capital expenditures and approximately $69,000,000 on 3 acquisitions. From a liquidity perspective, we ended the quarter with $8,000,000 in cash, dollars 33,000,000 available in floor plan offset accounts, $78,000,000 available on our used vehicle line and $237,000,000 available on our revolving credit lines. Before I pass the call over to John, I would like to make a few comments regarding our expectations for 2019. We are planning our business for a declining SAAR with an expectation of between 16,500,000 and 17,000,000 units. The 4 stores in the Indianapolis market that David mentioned in his remarks are expected to close during Q1 of 2019 and generate approximately $250,000,000 of annualized revenue. We expect front end yield per vehicle to remain stable at around $3,100 with any pressure on vehicle margins being offset by F and I. We believe that we can continue to grow our parts and services gross profit in the mid single digit range. We expect SG and A as a percentage of gross profit to be in the range of 69% to 70%. This reflects our balanced approach to SG and A with disciplined spending, while at the same time investing in our future. This guidance includes the impact of expected lower sales volumes, accelerated investments in our omni channel capabilities and additional costs associated with the enhanced benefits packages that we are providing to frontline associates in 2019. Based on the current forward LIBOR curve, the average interest rate in 2019 should be approximately 100 basis points higher than in 2018. Note that a 1% increase in interest rates results in additional interest expense on our floor plan debt of approximately $9,000,000 We expect our tax rate in 2019 to be between 25% 26%. Finally, we are planning for CapEx of approximately $55,000,000 This amount excludes any real estate purchases and potential lease buyout opportunities that we consider to be financing transactions. I would now like to hand the call over to John to walk us through the Q4 2018 operating performance in more detail. John? Thank you, Sean. My remarks will pertain to our same store performance compared to the Q4 2017. Looking at new vehicles, our new unit sales were up 2%, while SAAR was down 1% from the prior year as we took market share in most of our brands. Our new car margin was 4.3%, flat versus last quarter and 50 point basis points lower than last year. Though margins were down in all segments, we experienced volume growth across our brand portfolio and delivered a front end yield of $3,229 Our total new vehicle inventory was $865,000,000 and day supply at 67 within our targeted range. Turning to used vehicles. This quarter, we were able to increase our used to new ratio by 160 basis points, resulting in used vehicle unit sales increasing by 5% and used vehicle gross profit increasing by 7%. The successful deployment of our omni channel initiatives and used car enterprise software help us drive these strong results. Our used vehicle inventory of $159,000,000 was at a 34 day supply, which is within our targeted range of 30 to 35 days. Turning to F and I. Our team continues to deliver strong results. F and I gross profit increased by 3% due to increased volume sales. Our F and I gross profit per vehicle decreased slightly to $16.48 Turning to parts and service. Our parts and service revenue and gross profit increased by 5%. This was achieved with a 6% increase in customer pay. The improved used vehicle sales drove reconditioning work within parts and service to increase by 5%. I would like to take a moment to give you an update on the progress of some of our omni channel initiatives. We are currently over halfway through the rollout of our centralized brand certified digital sales team and we are on schedule to onboard the remaining stores within the next 6 months. Stores participating in the program during this quarter increased digital sales by almost 20% year over year. Our PUSHSTART online sales tool handled over 3,900 vehicle sales in the quarter, which is approximately 8% of our total retail units. We continue to grow traffic utilizing our digital parts and service scheduling tool and we reached a record of 114,000 online service appointments, which is up 24% from the prior year. We are excited about our omni channel driven growth and we are pleased that we've been able to invest in building these capabilities while maintaining our SG and A discipline. In conclusion, we would like to express our appreciation to all our teammates in the field and our support center who continue to produce best in class performance and drive us towards our vision of being the most guest centric company in the automotive retail industry. We will now turn the call over to the operator and take your questions. Operator? Thank you, sir. And going first to Rick Nelson at Stephens. Thanks. Good morning. Nice quarter. So I'd like to ask about the acquisition environment. You required 4 more stores, your appetite considering the cycle and your balance sheet seems to be in great shape and you've got the opportunity to execute, but just wondering how aggressive you want to get along those lines? Rick, this is David. I'll say, I don't think aggressive would be fair to term it that way. We're kind of looking at it as opportunistic. We've looked at a lot of deals in the last 12 months and only closed on 3 and we have these other ones in Indianapolis that we are about to acquire. We are really looking at the deal from what's best for our shareholders, what business. So I think our disciplined approach to M and A and not getting overly excited or falling in love with the deal for lack of a better term is the approach that we'll continue to have. We do see the market getting harder. We do see a lot of opportunities come up, but it's far too early in the game to tell whether there will be good opportunities for Asbury or not. Thanks for that color. Also like to ask about PUSHSTART, 8% of sales, the opportunity there? And if you could compare the profitability on a push start sale with an in store sale that would be helpful? We see continued opportunity with PUSHSTART. We've built out the experience, so it's basically front to back. I think we're looking for that percent to increase over time as a percent of sales as consumers get more used to the tool that is available. As far as the deal and the gross profit, there's no material difference between the in store experience and what we're seeing online. The big thing is the experience for the consumer. So I think moving forward, that business will continue to grow and that percent will continue to grow. But we don't see a material difference between the in store experience as far as the gross and what the consumers are doing online. The only thing I'll add to that Rick from the last call that we had with you all, We finally executed DocuSign and we have several of our documents on DocuSign for consumers to transact online with us. Certainly not the full deal. We still have many states that require wet signatures, but we're constantly progressing in that area. To include uploading insurance information, driver's licenses, facilitating the trade much easier and instant decisioning with our API connections with Route 1 and DealTrack. And provide a home delivery if the customer asked for that, what percent of sales would in fact be home delivery? We've been doing it for a few years now. Initially when we went into it, we thought it'd be close to half and half. It traditionally runs 70% to 75% of the consumers picking up at the dealership and 25% to 30% delivery. And the main reason for them wanting to come to the facility is really to create that relationship with the service center. And are you having more success with new cars with PUSHSTART or used cars? That too has fluctuated. Early on, we expected it to be more pre owned than new and it was just the opposite. It was more new than pre owned and it was actually the volume midline import cars that were taking up the percentage of it. It does seem to fluctuate by quarter and today it runs a little bit more pre owned than new, but pretty close. And your expectation now for a stable front end yield that incorporates lower gross profit on the vehicle and a higher F and I per unit? Is that correct? When I look back at the Q4 of 2015, which was a tremendous year for us and I look at now, our total front end yield is pretty similar to it was 4 years ago within a few dollars $40 or so. So as the front end has gone down, F and I has gone up, but certainly those will reach a peak. We see it stabilizing. We see it staying in this area based on what we have now. The toughest part of forecasting that PVR for this year is really going to be our partnership with the OEMs and what comes out from incentives this year. We saw it in the Q4. We're already seeing it now in the Q1, very reactionary incentives coming out that weren't planned. So very difficult to model, but we feel very confident we'll certainly be above the 3,100 number. Great. Thanks and good luck. Thank you. Thanks Rick. And moving next to Bret Jordan at Jefferies. Hey, good morning, guys. Good morning. Quick question on the new comp plan. I guess sort of does it indicate a more aggressive hiring environment in the space? Or is this something to sort of keep the active sales people involved despite maybe a volume turn down? I mean, I guess are people trying to hire away or is it just sort of trying to keep people in the business? Yes, I would say the technician piece is certainly a competitive market and everyone wants them. We tried to be thoughtful a year ago when everyone got the break with the tax incentives and what we're going to do for your associates and a lot of companies gave a flat dollar amount. We kind of wanted to have a more thoughtful approach and give something that paid out over time as we certainly benefit from it as well. We have also been working on what we think is our future retail model. And this is really just kind of falls in line with our plan and where we're at. If you want to create great numbers and be the best, you have to employ the best and have the best. And we thought these benefits would differentiate us from our peers and hopefully give us an opportunity to grow. We've said this over the years from a fixed standpoint. We don't have a brick and mortar issue. We can certainly grow a large amount with our current brick and mortar setup. We need to fill this service base. So this is certainly one attempt to do that while also taking care of our associates that are generating and running our business today. Okay. And this question sort of follows on that. I guess as you look at your customer pay service, it was up pretty nicely. How do you feel about that number versus the local market growth? Are you taking share or did you just see strength in service demand across your geographies? Yes. Brett, it's really difficult for me to say how we're doing in the market other than what I can see with that brand across the peers, but I can't see the independence in what they're doing. I would tell you that there's a huge space out there. We all know about the 270,000,000 cars on the street. So our potential and our runway is great. And our continued growth is really going to be based on how well we service and communicate with our customers and create that guest centric model I was discussing while filling the base with the additional techs. But I am very optimistic and know how much capacity and available time and or dollars are out there for us to really grow our business. And I think a very disciplined thoughtful approach in making sure that we're not doing a knee jerk reaction is imperative. And that's exactly what we think this plan is. Great. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. And we'll go next to John Murphy at Bank of America Merrill Lynch. Hey, guys. This is Jourdan on for John. Congratulations on the quarter. So first, head into a decline in the U. S. Market, what kind of sales level do you think it will take to keep your earnings flat? Jordan, it's Sean. We disclosed in our investor presentation that around 70% to 80% of our SG and A costs are variable. And this really does moderate the impact of a downturn scenario on our results. And so that's one thing to consider. The other thing to consider is that the SAAR impacts our new car sales and to a certain extent our used car sales, but almost 50% of our gross profit comes from parts and services. And parts and services is a relatively stable part of our business and we've seen that over the economic cycle. And so we expect to be able to continue to grow that part of the business even in a declining SAAR environment. Okay, makes sense. Thank you. And then on your omnichannel efforts, you've highlighted in the press release that helped you lower cost. I was wondering maybe you're willing to share some specifics around that. And I guess as these initiatives develop, where are you seeing the greatest opportunity in terms of cost reductions? Yes, I wouldn't want to get into specifics. But I would tell you the ability with software, the educated consumer, what they're spending the time that they're investing online, educating themselves on what they want allows us to be more efficient and flatter at our personnel expense and our operating expenses. So I think there's a lot of benefits to come in the future. This is starting for us. But we're confident we've landed on the right model for the future. And we're just really starting to attack that right now. But it's mainly through personnel expense and the ability of software. Okay. I mean, I think you noted you've invested over $10,000,000 in these capabilities last year. So should we expect a similar level of investment in 2019? So I think the way to think about 2019 is we guided to SG and A expenses of between 69% 70% of gross profit. And included in that guidance is 1, the continuation of the omnichannel investments that we started back in 20 17. 2 in there is the enhanced benefits packages that we spoke about earlier. And then 3 is also the equity program for frontline associates. So all of those investments are included in that SG and A number. And because of our sort of 2 pronged approach to SG and A, we'll be very disciplined in our expenditure, but also we invest for the long term through SG and A as well. We are able to keep our SG and A in the 69% to 70% range, which is roughly about 100 basis points higher than we were in 2018, where our SG and A for the full year 68.5%. Okay. That's very helpful. Thank you so much. That's it for me. Thank you. Thanks. And next we'll go to Armintas Sinkevicius at Morgan Stanley. Sir? Good morning. Thank you for taking the question. When I look at F and I, the chart in your slide deck is up into the right, which is a testament to your execution ability. But as you talk about the 3,100 front end yield supported by F and I, how do we think about peak F and I? What is the run room here and just sort of any context you can provide around that? This is John. And then what the drivers historically have been around F and I as far as is it what's been driving the move higher here? So, two things. First of all, I think there's more room in F and I. As a company, we focus on the bottom half of our producers and try to get them up to average. And when we can get them up to average, it lifts the whole. As far as what's driving it, there's been a shift over time. We focus on product sales. We're about 2 thirds product sales now and 1 third reserve. So it's really focusing on those penetration levels on service contracts and products to increase the number. Okay. And any way to contextualize sort of the remaining room on F and I? How much more do you think we have to run? This is David. I would say there's a couple of peers that are ahead of us and do a better job with F and I than we do. And I wouldn't there's no reason we certainly can't get to those numbers. This is the old adage, you get the bottom half and fix that and you'll have a material impact, But life happens as you're running the business. So we're continuing to strive at it. We've had solid growth, but we certainly see an opportunity to grow it even more. Okay. And then with your push start initiative and the delivery ability, can you talk about do you use 3rd party logistics? Do you use your in house logistics or and how you think about that going forward? Yes, it's all in house. There have been some one offs that have been significant distance for deliveries where we have used third parties. But other than that, the vast majority is in house. Okay, great. Thank you for taking the question. Thank you. And next we'll go to Chris Bottiglieri at Wolfe Research. Hi, thanks for taking the question. I guess first I want to follow-up on parts and services guide, I know you addressed this earlier, but kind of surprised Q4 was so strong and then the guide so strong for next year just given kind of a number of years of flat to declining SAAR. So I guess like with that pretext behind, was there any accounting like how much of the accounting change benefit Was there any benefit from the hurricane compare or the number of selling days? Like anything to think about for that Q4 number? I'll jump in and Sean can follow. No, the hurricanes that happened, certainly anyone that had stores in the southern area of Texas was a big deal. We didn't. We had one store in Houston. So the hurricane wasn't a material impact last year or naturally this year with the comps. The hurricanes we had in Florida were not damaging and really weren't any vehicle loss or anything like that. So I would say no. This industry as a whole, especially on the retail dealer side, has tremendous potential to grow its service retention numbers. And I think it's just our I'll speak for us. We have a very thoughtful and steady approach to growing it and I hope this comment comes across the right way. We're not trying to mass market and bring a lot of people in If you can't bring them in and handle them timely and pay attention to their cycle time and their transaction time, how quickly it is, you're just going bring them in, they'll never come back to you. So we're very thoughtful about how much traffic we increase to make sure that we can handle it at the store level and service our customers with a great experience. And then we're slowly trying to build on that. Got you. And then do you think it's I'll just add in on that. Sorry. Sorry, I'll just add in on that because I think you mentioned was an accounting impact. There was no impact from the revenue recognition accounting in Q4 and a very small negative impact for the full year about $600,000 on gross profit for parts and service, So no real accounting impact there. That's really helpful. And then thinking kind of about do you think it's just that your scale is allowing you to take share from other franchise dealers without has significant scale and digital capabilities? Or do you think there's some secular channel shift going on where customers that previously might have gone to like independent repair shops are now moving towards franchise dealers or anything like that that's driving it? One person's opinion, so please take it at that. These cars, it's different than 10, 15 years ago. Sophistication technology in these cars are much different. Most of the independents are not able to work on the vehicles. They don't have the special tools to work on them and they certainly don't have the manufacturer training to work on them. So I mean even as you look forward with electrification and everything else, it's only going to grow even more to push more business towards the dealers. So for those that are worried about electric vehicles and what's going to happen to parts and service, I would respectfully say it's going to be a long time before there's an impact, number 1, because right now electric vehicles have a lot of warranty work on them. While there's the typical mechanical that isn't there, there's a lot more warranty because of the software. And that's certainly going to be for a long time. But as the dollars come down even years beyond that, you're going to see retention numbers really jump because the independents really won't be able to service these vehicles. Well, that's our opinion. Got you. That's helpful. Thank you for the time. I appreciate it. And next we'll move to Stephanie Benjamin at SunTrust. Hi, good morning. I just kind of wanted to ask about the current incentive environment and if you've seen really any material change in the 4th quarter. I know you said you felt that most of the incentives were pretty reactionary and just kind of what the expectations are through 2019? Thanks. Typically the Q4, the manufacturers, because the year end offer very strong incentives. So there was good incentives going through for the whole Q4. But moving forward, we can't predict what they're going to do. Some of them have been reactionary, but specifically the luxury stores in Q4 have very good incentives. This concludes today's discussion. We appreciate your participation and certainly look forward to speaking with you in April. Thank you very much. Have a great day. Once again, ladies and gentlemen, that does conclude today's conference. And again, I'd like to thank everyone for joining us today.