Good morning, and welcome to the Archer Daniels Midland Company Third Quarter 2016 Earnings Conference Call. All lines have been placed on a listen only mode to prevent background noise. As a reminder, this conference call is being recorded. I would now like to introduce your host for today's call, Mark Schweitzer, Vice President, Investor Relations for Archer Daniels Midland Company. Mr.
Schweitzer, you may begin.
Thank you, Kelly. Good morning, and welcome to ADM's 3rd quarter earnings webcast. Starting tomorrow, a replay of today's webcast will be available at adm.com. For those following the presentation, please turn to Slide 2, the company's safe harbor statement. Which says that some of our comments constitute forward looking statements that reflect management's current views and estimates of future economic circumstances.
Industry conditions, company performance and financial results. These statements are based on many assumptions and factors that are subject to risks and uncertainties. ADM has provided additional information in its reports on file with the SEC concerning assumptions and factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from those in this presentation and you should carefully review the assumptions and factors in our SEC reports. To the extent permitted under applicable law, ADM assumes no obligation to update any forward looking statements as a result of new information or future events. On today's webcast, our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Juan Luciano, will provide an overview of the quarter.
Our Chief Financial Officer, Ray Young, will review financial highlights and corporate results. Then, Juan will review the drivers of our performance in the quarter, provide an update on our scorecard and discuss Please turn to Slide 3. I will now turn the call over to Juan.
Thank you, Mark. Good morning everyone. I thank you all for joining us today. This morning, we reported 3rd quarter adjusted earnings per share of $0.59. Our adjusted segment operating profit was $650,000,000.
After working through the challenging environment in the first half of the year, we capitalized on improving operating conditions in the third quarter and are positioned well for a solid finish to the year. Act Services results were driven by U. S. Exports that search through the quarter, creating improved merchandising opportunities at the global market relied heavily on U. S.
Exports of corn and soybeans. Results for corn included strong performance in North American sweeteners and starches, growth from our international corn operations and the steady results for bioproducts. Oilseeds results were impacted by significantly lower global soy crush margins weaker origination results in Brazil and the unusual equity loss from our Wilmar investment. WFSI results including strong growth from white labels with mixed results from our Specialty Ingredients businesses. During the quarter, we continued a manufacturer of specialty in Asia's growing and evolving food demand by increasing our strategic ownership stake in Wilmer to 23%.
Our ethanol dry mill review has progressed and we are targeting receipt of final proposals from a short list of interested parties by the end of the calendar year. And we have implemented nearly $250,000,000 of new run rate savings actions through the third quarter and expect to exceed our $275,000,000 target by the end of the calendar year. In line with our holders in dividends and share buybacks and a large U. S. Harvest combined with the team's solid execution capabilities.
We feel good about the remainder of the year and a stronger 2017. I'll provide more detail on our scorecard progress later in the call. Now, I'll turn the call over to Ray.
Thanks, Juan. Slide 4 provides some financial highlights for the quarter. Adjusted EPS
for
but was $650,000,000, down $34,000,000, mostly on Wilmar results. The effective tax rate for the quarter was 28%, compared to 31% in the third quarter of the prior year. Our tax rate is lower this quarter compared to last year due to the geographic mix of earnings and the tax impact with the 28% guidance for the calendar year that I provided to you at the last quarter's call. Our trailing 4 quarter average ROIC of 5.8 percent is 80 basis points below our 2016 annual whack of 6.6%. Lower ROIC reflects the challenging offering conditions that we have experienced during the latter part of 2015 and the first half of twenty sixteen.
We do expect our 4 quarter trailing ROIC to improve as we move to the end of this year. On Chart 18 in the appendix, you can see the reconciliation of our recorded quarterly earnings of $0.58 per share to the adjusted earnings of $0.59 per share. For this quarter, we had impairments restructuring and settlement charges of $0.08 per share, had losses on sales of assets of about $0.02 per share. These were offset by about $0.09 of LIFO inventory credits. Slide 5 provides an offering profit summary in the components of our corporate line.
Before one discusses the offering results, to highlight some of the unique items impacting our quarterly results. In the operating segments, we had some small impairments and restructuring costs, and loss on disposals of assets. As a reminder, the results of the equity earnings at Wilmar are reported by ADM on a 1 quarter plague based The Asia loss in oilseeds reflects ADM's portion of the Wilmar loss reported in their 2nd quarter results. In the corporate lines, net interest expense was up slightly due to interest on $1,000,000,000 of new long term debt issued this quarter in the absence of an interest credit related to tax provisions in the prior year. Unallocated corporate costs of $106,000,000 were down from the year ago quarter, primarily due to lower SG and A costs and lower spending on various strategic projects.
Minority interest in other include some impairment charges on certain investments in the settlement and related expenses. I'd also like to highlight that our prior year numbers included a charge of $198,000,000 related to buying back higher costs, U. S. Debt in issuing lower cost euro denominated debt. Turning to the cash flow statement on Slide 6.
You can see the cash flow statement for the 1st 9 months ended September 30, 2016 compared to the same period the prior year. We generated about $1,600,000,000 from operations before working capital changes during the period, slightly higher than the same period last year. Total capital spending for the period was $621,000,000, down from the prior years $819,000,000. Capital spending has been lower during the more challenging first half of twenty sixteen, and we do expect to finish up the year spending below $1,000,000,000. Acquisitions of $136,000,000 to date includes harvest innovations, medsops, the Moroccan corn processing operation in Catarina Food, Included in the other investing activities line is our increased investment in Wilmar to a 23% level.
During the current period, we spent 754,000,000 We're heading towards repurchasing a goal of $1,000,000,000 this calendar year. Our average share count for the period was 589,000,000 diluted shares outstanding. Our total return of capital to shareholders including dividends was about $1,300,000,000 for this 9 month period. Slide 7 shows the highlights of our balance sheet as of September 30, 2016 2015. Our operating working capital of 7.3 up slightly from the 2015 net debt level of $5,600,000,000.
Earlier in third quarter, we issued a $1,000,000,000 of U. S. 10 year debt at a coupon of 2.5 percent, the lowest cost U. S. Long term debt in our portfolio.
Our leverage position remains comfortable with the net debt to total capital ratio of about 25%. Our shareholders' equity of $17,600,000,000 was down from the $17,900,000,000 level last year due primarily to shareholder capital returns in the excess of net income and a decrease in the cumulative translation account. We had $6,100,000,000 in available global credit capacity at the end of September, if you had the available cash, we had access to over $7,000,000,000 of short term liquidity. Our balance sheet remains solid. Next one will take us through a review of the business performance and drivers.
Thank you, Ray. Please turn to Slide 8. In the third quarter, we earned $650,000,000 of operating profit, excluding specified items, down from the $684,000,000 from last year's third quarter. As we explained last quarter, of the challenging conditions we saw in the first half of the year began to subside late in second quarter. This led to a more favorable environment in the third quarter.
As a result, we were able to execute well and capitalize on the more favorable environment. Adjusted segment operating profit was up about 13% versus last quarter. But down about 5% versus the year ago quarter. It is important to note that the unusual loss related to our equity earnings of Wilmar negatively impacted us this quarter. Excluding Wilmar, our 3rd quarter operating profits would have been up about 8% year over We saw improving market conditions, particularly increased competitiveness of US corn and soybeans, especially late in the quarter as we were able to export record volumes.
Results for corn included continued strong performance in sweeteners and starches as the North American business continued to perform well with solid demand production efficiencies and improved raw material costs. Oilsys results were impacted by lower global soy crush margins, lower origination volumes due to the reduced Brazilian soybean and corn crop and the Wilma results in Asia. Excluding the startup items, WFSI operating profit was up slightly compared to the year ago quarter. Now I'll review the performance of each segment and provide additional detail. So starting on Slide 9, Act Services results benefited from record export volumes as crop shortages in South America accelerated this year's seasonal shift in global demand to North America.
In addition, as the record North American harvest started in the quarter, we saw improved merchandising, warehousing and storage opportunities as well as improved margins. Our global trade desk results were lower in the quarter as some commodity prices declined causing global buyers to drill down their inventories which limited merchandising opportunities. In transportation, results were up due to increased utilization, strong exports and improved freight rates. Milling and Other had another solid quarter. With results consistent with the third quarter last year on a strong product margins related to seasonal demand.
Please turn to Slide 10. Corn processing results were up sequentially and year over year. Sweeteners and starches results improved as the North American business continued to perform well with solid demand in the U. S. And Mexico, continued production efficiency, improvements and lower raw material costs.
The company's international corn operations performed very well in the quarter. We continue to integrate our European e starch operation and are tracking well on fully capturing the identified synergies. Our Old Next joint venture in Mexico also performed well in the quarter. Bioproducts results excluding last year's Brazilian sugar impairment charge, were essentially flat with improved operational performance and margins from animal nutrition, offset by the slightly lower ethanol results compared to last year. Slide 11 please.
Oilseeds results were down in the third quarter versus strong quarter 1 year ago. Crushing and Origination results declined significantly versus a strong year ago quarter due to lower soybean crushing margins as competing proteins such as ddgs and feed wheat displays soy meal in some physrations. We also saw some periods of increased competitiveness of Argentine meal. Oils' results were also impacted by weaker origination in Brazil due to the smaller soybean and corn crop. Which created a high cost structure in our silo and transportation network during the quarter In addition, producer commercialization of next year's soybean and corn crop decreased due to lower commodity prices and the continued strength of the Brazilian real.
Refining Packaging Biodiesel and other results were up from 1 year ago, mainly due to good performance in biodiesel and specialty fats and oils. In addition, Our refined oils business continued to have a strong performance supported by solid food demand and strong biodiesel volumes. Our Golden Peanuts and tree nuts business had a good quarter benefiting from the facility expansion at our plant in Dawson, Georgia. We also saw the results from the operational efficiency improvements we made in our procurement and shelling operations throughout our network. Oilsys results in Asia for the quarter declined from the year ago period due to the impact of ADM's share of Wilmar's unusual loss in the second quarter.
In fact, it was Wilmar's first ever quarterly loss. ADM records his share of Wilmer results on a 1 quarter lag basis and recorded $48,000,000 of equity loss in the third quarter versus a $36,000,000 gain in the third quarter of 2015. On Slide 12, please WFSI results were up slightly compared to the third quarter last year. We saw strong operating profit growth for wild flavors and good performance from eaten foods. Offset by mixed results from our specialty ingredients businesses.
In protein, we saw strong overall demand led by functional concentrate and textured concentrate. Results for the quarter included operational startup costs for Tianjin and Campo Grande. Also in the quarter, we again added to our capabilities with the acquisition of Katarina Foods, a leading toll manufacturer specialty, gluten free and high protein pastas. Adding the caterina business help us as we continue building our portfolio to meet the needs of health conscious consumers. Walt flavors saw an 8% increase in revenue with a 20% increase in operating profit.
However, the challenges we've highlighted in recent quarters with some of our specialty ingredients business SCI, edible beans, and hydro colloids have continued. Our fibers business has been subject to industry oversupply issues that have kept pricing down. Partially offsetting these negatives has seen has been some strength in our specialty proteins business in the quarter. Our SCI businesses experienced some operation issues that have resulted in inventory write downs and some lost sales over the past year. We are addressing these issues aggressively.
As we continue to work with customers and other businesses within ADM, we've recognized that we can be more effective at meeting needs and driving performance by aligning SCI's businesses into other areas of the company. We believe that we can more easily achieve synergies and improve top line sales under a new organizational structure. Except teams working through those details right now. Now on slide 13, I'd like to update you on how we continue to strengthen and grow our company. We've highlighted some of the areas in which we made significant progress.
I'll discuss a few. We're recently expanding and streamline operations at our Golden Peanut and tree nuts crush facility in Dawson, Georgia and we're already seeing the results of this operational efficiency improvements. We have progressed our ethanol dry mill review. We are targeting receipt of final proposals from a short list of interested parties by the end of the calendar year. We have implemented nearly $250,000,000 of new run rate savings actions through the end of the third quarter and expect to exceed our $275,000,000 target by the end of the calendar year.
During the third quarter, we completed the successful deployment and go live of our 1 ADM business transformation. With our Ag Services U. S. Elevator System covering more than two hundred locations. Our 1 ADM program is our multiyear global investment that will help the company improve and standardize our business processes and deliver greater efficiency and effectiveness on our activities.
I am proud that the significant deployment was delivered on time under budget and with quality levels of execution, providing us confidence as we move to the next phases of the 1 ADM program. We also during the quarter acquired Catarina Foods, a manufacturer of specialty, gluten free and high protein pastas to continue meeting the needs of health conscious consumers. And our Stratas Foods joint venture recently acquired Supreme oils, a U. S.-based manufacturer and distributor of edible oils and related products. Strata's food is our joint venture with ACH Food Companies and is North America's a leading supplier of fats and oils to the food service.
Food ingredients and retail private label markets. Adin Supreme oils provides a JV with manufacturing locations in Tennessee Alabama and New Jersey. The Northeast presence is important and is one of the largest consumption areas for Edible Oils and one where Stratus black presence. This acquisition provides Stratus with entry into the growing seasonings sources and condiments category and its products and operations offer good opportunities for both cost and revenue synergies. These are just a few of the highlights from the quarter.
We'll continue to update you on our progress each quarter. And now before we take your questions, I wanted to offer some additional forward perspectives. As I indicated last quarter, the first half of the year presented some challenging conditions. However, We are seeing an improving operating environment in the second half of the year that we believe sets the stage for a stronger 2017. For Ag Services, the North American harvest is progressing well and we're seeing record yields and production for both corn and soybeans.
We expect this to translate into continued solid results for export volumes and better global merchandising and handling opportunities as we finish out the year. Export origination margins while good and improved versus last year are not at the same levels we realized in 2014. For corn, while 4th quarter volumes are expected to be due to normal seasonality, we are optimistic in 2017 for our sweeteners and structured business. With global sugar prices up significantly year over year and the ongoing progress of our operational excellence initiatives. Ethanol margins are currently being supported by strong domestic and export demand.
As in the past, margins will be a function of the supply demand balance and the impact of net inventory levels. As I mentioned earlier, we have made progress with our ethanol dry mill review. We have 7 original parties expressed interest and we have now narrowed that lease to a smaller number. We are having these parties undertake some additional due diligence prior to them submitting final proposals, which we are targeting for the end of the calendar year. For oilseeds, with ample soybeans from the record U.
S. Harvest, along with solid domestic demand, crushing volumes are expected to be seasonally high in the coming months. Crash margins could experience some short term resistance from competing global proteins. South America grain origination margins will be dependent on new crop volumes. At present, new crop origination volumes are slow and behind plan.
However, we do anticipate ultimately procuring the crop. The fundamentals of increased global protein consumption point to a long term sustainable trend, which supports higher soy meal demand and higher industry capacity utilization into the future. For WFSI, the 4th quarter is traditionally experience is some typical seasonality from the beverage industry. We expect continued strong results from protein in the 4th quarter. We will incur continuous start up costs for our TMG and Campo Grande plants as they begin their 1st phases of production late in the quarter.
So with that, operator, please open the line for
Your first question comes from the line of David Driscoll of Citi Research. Your line is open.
Good morning. This is Cornell and with a few for David.
Good morning Cornell. Hey, Cornell.
Just wanted to start off. I mean, there were a lot of negative headlines, I guess, in the third quarter, early surrounding kind of the poor environment in South America. Things seem to have turned out a bit better than perhaps we were expecting. Did the environment change drastically perhaps in the last month of the quarter such that a strong September providing the boost to 3Q numbers relative to how things were looking previously?
Yes, Cornell, this is Juan. Yes, I think your assessment is correct. I think that the quarter got increasingly stronger, August September, especially in the Ag Services and I would say in sweeteners and starches as well. So those, but increasingly in terms of exports from the U. S.
In August and number. Those were very strong months.
And then one last quick one is just what's the anticipated effect? I think you're starting to touch on it a bit of the large U. S. Harvest on the business going forward. So specifically as you look at each segment, can you explain what record U.
S. Crop production and record U. S. Exports will ultimately mean over the coming quarters?
Yes, of course, we're going to have better better volumes and better margins in Ag Services. We are seeing probably an export window all the way to extending not only in Q4, but also in the Q1 for North America. And we have very good ownership. So we have the pipeline filled. We think that we're going to have a strong crush margins in the Q4.
And the demand, particularly in sweeteners and starches and ethanol continues to be solid and we're going to have the product to to supply that demand. So we feel very strongly about the following quarters.
Okay. Thanks a lot. I'll pass it on.
Your next question comes from the line of Ann Duignan of JP Morgan.
Good morning. This is Tom Simenech from Baader. Just one question on China. How do you expect China's current trade policies to impact each of your businesses in the balance of 20.16 and into next year?
Yes, thank you for the question. Obviously, we are studying that and you've seen many changes in China recently, not only the change in the way they handle their reserves or internal subsidies, but also some it import duties for DDGs. So certainly will impact some of the exports in that in whether it's barley, whether it's corn, whether it's DDG as they reduce their inventories. But demand continues to be very strong. So, we still believe very strong imports of soybeans from that perspective, but we're watching the corn and the sorghum and the DDGs export has been reduced.
That's helpful. Thank you. And in terms of U. S. Ethanol exports as well, think you mentioned in the last quarter that you're expecting 850,000,000 to 900,000,000 gallons.
With China absent from that market, is that expectations still intact?
Yes, it is. We've seen several, several destinations. I think the world market is consuming a lot of gasoline and certainly ethanol is a very good, obtaining cancer or oxygenate and as you think about some countries trying to reduce pollution created by automotive usage, we think that ethanol continues to be a very strong product for export. We've been exporting very heavily to Canada. We've been exporting much more than last year to Brazil.
China has been there, but we also had new destinations showing up. So, we feel strong about the export will grow into next year.
Your next question comes from the line of Sandy Kluseman from Vertical Research. Your line is open.
Good morning. Could you discuss the outlook for pricing in your sweeteners and starches business with pretty tight capacity utilization rates, elevated sugar prices, but do lower corn costs impact your ability to get pricing through in any way?
Listen, we have, we have already concluded this year's negotiation 2017 liquid sweeteners contracts. And we're very satisfied that the way things are evolving into this industry, as you described, volumes have been strong and and the industry has been very tight. In fact, this season did start earlier than normal this year. And so that's normally a good sign for us for expanded margins. So, I would say in terms of specifics, we will try stay to our traditional timeline to discuss in this outlook, although we have finished some contract negotiations as our portfolio continues to broaden that are all the other product lines that we're still wrapping up those negotiations.
So, I'd rather address the more specific to these in the next quarter's call. I would just say at this point in time, we are optimistic about that. It has been a positive negotiation so far.
Okay. Thank you. And just a quick follow-up. You mentioned the increased competitiveness of Argentine Meal And World Markets. Is any of this related to increased sales following the confirmation that subsequent cuts to the soy export tax would be delayed until 2018?
And how do you see this dynamic evolving going forward, particularly if growers are incentivized to increase plantings of born and wheat at the expense of soy?
Yes. So, many aspects to your question. Certainly, there was some discussion about the ability of the government to continue to reduce this taxes in Argentina, the government finally announced that it will not have the ability to honor that promise, but they also created some reductions for some provinces in the north to kind of balance the people that are farther away from the ports. So I would say this is going to be a fluid situation. As you described, the intentions of the farmer has been to shift to corn.
Some acreage in Argentina, but early planting conditions have maybe making a little bit more difficult to that. And some people have started to plant some soybeans. So I think it's a fluid situation and for the time being, we're going to expect North America to be the competitive, the competitive sourcing of soybean meal in the world. So, until we have the next South America crop,
Thank you very much.
Your next question comes from the line of Adam Samuelson of Goldman Sachs. Your line is open. Hello,
Adam?
Adam Samuelson. Your line is open.
Okay, Kelly. Maybe we'll go to the next question.
Sure. Your next question comes from the line of Farah Islam of Stephens. Your line is open.
Hi, good morning.
Good morning, Carter.
First question is on Refining Packaging and biodiesel. Your results were quite strong in the current
No, I think that the team has been have done a terrific job of especially in Europe of improving some of our specialty fat and oil business that maybe didn't quite perform last year and they they made some modifications to that. So you have an improvement, but I will not call it a one off. It's an improvement versus last year on good performance. And overall, we saw strong demand for oil and strong volumes for biodiesel and that drove the better performance but there's nothing unusual in those results.
So we shouldn't we can model that going forward. Is this sort of a new sustainable run rate?
I think you should see, I mean, obviously, we depend on biodiesel. You know biodiesel is rather volatile. So, so but I think the other business is refined oils, both the loyal and specialty parts. And I think those businesses you should expect this kind of performance going forward, yes.
That's helpful. And then longer term, if we look at ADM as a company, how should we think about the earnings algorithm for ADM? And how would the divestiture of the ethanol assets kind of impact that long term earnings algorithm?
Yes. So, let's talk a little bit about that. We said before that we would expecting this strategy that we put together a couple of years ago to give us over the next 3 years, dollar to $1.50 and we continue to be committed to that and expecting those results. At the same time, we saw our base being impacted by some of these headwinds going down from maybe a $3 level to maybe a $2.40 level. Obviously, we're coming back from that as you can see in this quarter and as you're going to see in Q4 and hopefully with a stronger 2017, it's still difficult to quantify given that we have only 1 quarter of that, how much of that base deterioration are you going to recover?
With regards to the ethanol dry mills, as you heard me saying in the prepared remarks, we are waiting for the 2nd round of beats before the end of the year. And at that point in time, Farja, we will sit down and assess the offers that we have in front us and we will make a decision based on that. So I think it's a little bit premature to speculate on how the dry mills should factor in our next year's earnings. Okay.
This is helpful. Thank you.
Your next question comes from the line of Ken Zaslow from Bank of Montreal. Your line is open.
Good morning, Ken. Good morning, Ken.
I will actually stick to one question. How's that? On the high level side, when you think of 2017, Is there anything in the operating environment that you would consider on the abnormal that we would not be able to start to get the typical type of results that you would expect from your company given the improvement in the operating environment as well as the cost efficiencies and all the stuff you've done. So 2017 kind of a critical year to show all your progress. Is there anything that would limit you from being able to do that?
Yes, Ken. I think that that's kind of the way we're thinking about it. We think that 2017 should provide an opportunity for us in a more normalized environment to demonstrate all the earnings power that improvements or through all the investments. There are risks as we face every year. Obviously, you have the potential China grain reserve significant release and how they manage that and how many years do they want to achieve that, that could be a risk.
Obviously, it's an all, the way producers will manage supply demand and inventories is another one. But I think in general, we feel strongly about everything that we have done over the last few years and to improve our company and position our company to take advantage of of this market condition. So we feel good about 2017.
Great. Thank you.
Your next question comes from the line of Rob Moskow from Credit Suisse. Your line open.
Hi, this is actually Robert Connor on for Rob Moskow. So it looks like your soy crush margins have been weak globally. But you kind of expected that to improve. Could you just maybe expand a little bit upon why they've been so weak And then what are kind of the forces that are going to improve margins?
Yes, I would say from our perspective. First of all, you were comparing with a very strong quarter last year. So, if you look at the underperformance of oilseeds, 60% of that is explained by the World Market, which is a very unusual result. So, when you look at the performance of oilseeds per se, we have origination inside oil seats for Brazil. And you know, the farmer in Brazil, there was 40 sold by this time last year.
It's only 20% sold now. So, we have less volume going through our operations. And if you think about the crush margins in the U. S, we didn't have some of the pressure that exports of meal brought maybe last year to the U. S.
So, obviously, with a big run up in meal prices by mid of the year by June or something like that, Other things became more competitive, whether it's a low quality feed wheat or whether it's a DDGs or corn got a little bit into the Russian. So, we think that demand is very strong. Still, we're thinking about 5% mill consumption growth for next year and we believe that the U. S. Will have high crush margins and we feel good about a potential expansion of that crushing margin.
It just could be a little bit attenuated by the fact that we need to fight with some substitution maybe over next quarter, but we feel good in general about oilseeds.
And your next question comes from the line of Eric Larson from Buckingham Research. Your line is open.
Yes, good morning, everyone. Thanks for squeezing me in here. In the last week or so, we've seen the basis on soy work very favorably toward you guys or toward the processors. Lot of supply out there. Thank goodness you have a lot of exports.
There would be swimming in grain. But can you talk a little bit about sort of the near term impact of that. And then the elevation margins that you're seeing, and we're seeing some transportation issues on the Mississippi. Can you kind of pull all of that together, it looks like storage is also pretty full. So it looks like the near term environment for your crush margins could be could be quite strong if export demand stays as strong as it is.
Let's take your questions on part. There is a big crop coming and certainly the pipeline and the storage is becoming fuller and fuller. So, you see that reflection a little bit in the basis So that is good for ADM. We have good ownership obviously. In terms of the exports, We said before that 2014 was an unusual year because with all the all the fracking that was basically taking a big part of the rails them in the U.
S, there was a little bit of a glut going into the, New Orleans area. This year, although maybe you were reflecting on some recent issues with transportation. In general, if you compared to 2014, rail velocity has been so much better. Freight had been lowered. So in general, we didn't get to same level of elevation margins that we got in 2014.
So volumes are good. Volumes continue to be very, very strong into Q4 and margins are okay. They are not just the record that maybe used to be in 2014. I don't know, Ray, if anything that you would like to add to this?
No, I mean, I think elevation margins clearly did improve as we kind of went through the third quarter. So that's been very, very encouraging. Again, as one indicated, I don't expect it to get back to 2014 levels, which really resulted in an Ag Services offering profit, some very, very strong results, but we are going to have good results in the 4th quarter. There's no doubt about it.
Okay. Thanks everyone.
Your next question comes from Michael Piken from Cleveland Research. Your line is open.
Hi, good morning. It's Mike Henry in for Mike Piken. Quick, just a question. I was wondering if you guys could talk about any potential cost savings plan in 2017. Any potential magnitude on that and what areas or what buckets that could potentially fall into?
Mike, I mean, clearly, we've been on a multi year plan in terms of driving operational excellence within the company we set a target of 2.75 this year, which will exceed. We haven't set our targets for next year, but you should expect us to act continue to have some good targets in terms of operational excellence because, well, there's still more opportunities to be had. One thing I do want to point out, I mean, as Juan indicated, we talked about the 180M program whereby we're actually implementing this business transformation program within the company it does cost money. For, for example, this year in 1 ADM, we're spending about $100,000,000 as part of that project, some of its cash some of its operation, its operating expenses. This program is ramping up.
So therefore, I do expect next year, our spending will increase as we ramp up this program, we'll provide more context in the 4th quarter call because we're still working through what the actual spend will be. But what we're doing is we're actually taking some of these cost savings that we've had and we're going to reinvest in the company. So we're going to reinvest in terms of whether it be business process improvements or we're going to reinvest in R&D And Innovation as well. So again, we'll give more context of this when we get to the fourth quarter call, but I'm very pleased that these savings are coming but we are going to reinvest some of the savings in order to make this company stronger for the future.
Okay. Thank you.
Your next question comes from the line of Adam Samuelson from Goldman Sachs. Your line is open.
Yes, thanks. Good morning, everyone. Sorry about that multiple calls at once. Maybe a question on Ag Services. For the fourth quarter.
And this has been touched on in some respects, but I'm wondering, I mean, we all see North American export environment is very strong. We've got a record crop. At this point, we're a month into the quarter. Can you help us frame kind of the range of outcomes that you could think of for Ag Services in the current environment and what would be drivers to the upside and towards the lower end of that range? Thanks.
Yes. Thank you, Adam. Listen, I think we will continue to see a strong exports. We see that in that sense, Q4 should be stronger. We expect higher utilization of our storage and transportation assets, although maybe freight rates may be pressure a little bit due to higher transportation equipment availability.
I think I addressed that when I addressed Eric's question before. But in general, we will continue to see a stronger Ag Services performance as we finish the year.
And as that relates into the 1st part of 2017, is it really just as visibility as the South American crop increases that that drives the variability in the outcomes RAG services or anything else there you're mindful of into the first half?
Yes. So to give you some perspective, so we're expecting 16 to end between 14 15 obviously higher than 15 and not as high as 14. But I think that when you think about 17, we expect some of these exports to overspill into Q1. So the window obviously will depend a lot on what happened in South America. There are still 3 months of weather ahead of us, but we still believe that the U.
S. Will be, very full in the pipeline and will be exporting corn and soybeans well into Q1 next year.
Great. Thanks very much.
Thank you, Ari.
And this concludes the Q And A portion of today's call. I now pass the call back over to Juan Luciano for closing remarks.
Thank you, Kelly. Thank you for joining us today. Slide 15 notes some of the upcoming investor events where we will be participating. As always, please feel free to follow-up with Mark if you have any other questions. Have a good day and thanks for your time and interest in ADN.
And this concludes today's conference call. You may now disconnect.