๐ŸŽ Black Friday: 50% off Unlimited and 30% off Pro annual plans
Bullish (BLSH)
NYSE: BLSH ยท Real-Time Price ยท USD
20.36
+1.09 (5.66%)
At close: Nov 18, 2026, 4:00 PM EST
20.50
+0.14 (0.69%)
After-hours: Nov 18, 2026, 7:10 PM EST
โ† View all transcripts

Earnings Call: Q3 2026

Nov 18, 2026

Summary

Q3 adjusted revenue rose 10% YoY and adjusted EBITDA margin was 42% despite crypto-market headwinds. The Equiniti deal and issuer-led tokenization underpin medium-term cost, cash flow and growth ambitions, though adoption and regulatory timing remain uncertain.

Operator

Good day, and welcome to the Bullish third quarter 2026 earnings conference call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speaker's presentation, there will be a question-and-answer session. To ask a question during the session, you will need to press star one one on your telephone. You will then hear an automated message advising your hand is raised. To withdraw your question, please press star one one again. Please be advised that today's conference is being recorded. I would now like to hand the conference over to your first speaker today, Liam Foley, Director of Corporate Development. Please go ahead.

Liam Foley
Director of Corporate Development, Bullish

Good morning, and welcome to our third quarter earnings call. I am Liam Foley, Director of Corporate Development, and I am joined on today's call by our Chief Executive Officer, Tom Farley, and Chief Financial Officer, David Bonanno. This call will contain forward-looking statements, including those relating to our expected performance and business opportunities, our pending acquisition of Equiniti Group, the anticipated benefits and strategic rationale of the transaction, expected timing and closing conditions, the combined company's targets and business opportunities following the transaction, our tokenization of securities and the adoption of tokenized securities, and our share repurchase program. These statements are not assurances of future performance and are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially.

Such risks include, among others, the possibility that the Equiniti transaction may not be completed, failure to obtain required regulatory approvals, the possibility that anticipated benefits may not be realized, and risks related to the integration of Equiniti's business, the evolving legal and regulatory environment for digital assets and tokenized securities, and the timing and extent of any share repurchases. For more details on these and other risks, please refer to today's earnings press release and our SEC filings, including our 20-F dated March 9, 2026. We undertake no obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements. This call will also include a discussion of non-IFRS financial measures. A reconciliation to the most directly comparable IFRS metrics can be found in our earnings press release and presentation, which also contain additional information regarding non-IFRS financial measures and key performance indicators. I will now turn the call over to Tom.

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Thank you, Liam. Very thorough. Good morning, everyone. Thank you for joining. This morning, Bullish reported strong third quarter results despite significant macro headwinds and the full throes of the crypto bear market. We grew adjusted revenue 10% year-over-year, Subscription, Services & Other revenue 13% year-over-year, and we expanded our adjusted EBITDA margin to 42%. Our growth is testament to our success building a business that can perform across cycles. Looking forward, I want to discuss four things: a key leadership addition, Equiniti, tokenization, and capital allocation. Then, Dave will take you through the figures. First, leadership. Last week, we announced that Stacey Cunningham, my former colleague and the former President of the New York Stock Exchange, has joined Bullish as President.

She was my Chief Operating Officer at the New York Stock Exchange, and she succeeded me as President when she became the first woman to lead the Exchange in 220 years. Stacey and I worked closely at the New York Stock Exchange to build a new, efficient, and performant exchange and post-trade technology environment that was both value-added for customers and far less expensive to provide. The result was a business that grew earnings dramatically over many years. Stacey's relationships and experience working with thousands of issuers will be invaluable as we pull together all the pieces of modern market infrastructure focused on the needs of those issuers. We believe that when one of the most respected leaders in capital markets chooses to build the next generation of market infrastructure at Bullish, it tells you where this company and this industry are headed. Second, Equiniti.

We remain on track to close in early January 2027. Antitrust clearances are behind us, and in October, we received a series of change of control approvals. What remains are a couple final regulatory approvals before we are all systems go. The terms are the same as the ones we announced in May, the assumption of about $1.85 billion of debt and the exchange of roughly 60 million Bullish shares based on the $38.48 share price set when we signed. We've used these six months to be ready on day one. Day one plans are set, and the technology roadmap is clear. One modern platform for transfer agency and share plans, one portal for issuers, shareholders, and employees alike, and tokenization built directly into the register itself.

We aim to deliver issuers and shareholders with an upgraded and enhanced experience from day one, capable of handling all their share-related needs, whether it be paper, electronic, or tokenized shares. Shifting to tokenization, we've seen a technology transition like this before. Shares first moved from paper certificates to electronic records, and now they are moving on-chain. The importance and nature of an issuer's actual share itself doesn't change, but the rails underlying it do. We believe the move from electronic to tokenized is just as inevitable as the move from paper to electronic, and for the same reasons. It is faster, more efficient, and far cheaper. The economics are too powerful to ignore.

For banks, brokers, and market infrastructure providers, we believe that the immediate and transparent nature of on-chain shares can unlock many hundreds of billions of dollars of trapped collateral and take billions of cost out of the system. For issuers, it is a technology upgrade that brings them new benefits. Over the past few months, we have met with a significant portion of Equiniti's roughly 3,000 issuers to discuss this technology upgrade. We walk them through how issuer tokenization differs from other forms and help them prepare for this upgrade. At launch, issuer tokens solve real problems, always on markets that settle in seconds, a real-time view of cap table non-objecting beneficial owners, and access to investors across more venues, geographies, and hours.

Looking ahead beyond launch, we expect issuers to build on this infrastructure in ways that open up new use cases and new growth, including a deeper connection with their shareholders, such as by the provision of discounts, loyalty points, or other perks that are provided directly to investors on-chain wallets as a reward for loyal shareholding. With Bullish's relationships in crypto and Equiniti's roughly 3,000 public company issuers, we believe we are at the center of this effort to bring equities into the digital age and to build this next generation of infrastructure. In September, we launched the Issuer Token Coalition with Equiniti. Members include many brokers such as Alpaca, Apex, DriveWealth, and SoFi, market makers such as QRT, DRW, and Flow Traders, infrastructure providers such as Superstate, Vertalo, and zerohash, and exchanges including the New York Stock Exchange.

This coalition is working through the standards and mechanics for the actual shares of listed companies to reside on public blockchains. This will catalyze the evolution from paper to electronic and to now our on-chain future. You may have read news about issuers rejecting so-called tokenized shares. These stories were referring to third-party tokens, where the tokens in question are definitively not the issuer's actual shares and are rather some form of IOU, entitlement, or other type of derivative. That is not what either the Issuer Token Coalition or Bullish is working on. We are working with the issuers on their actual shares, and these conversations are well received. The demand for issuer tokens is real and growing, and we will share more of our exciting plans post-closing of our Equiniti transaction.

As mentioned on prior earnings calls, the largest unknown for me is the pace of adoption of tokenization technology and when exactly growth will meaningfully accelerate. However, we feel better now than ever about the tokenization opportunity and the probability of that being a long-term growth driver for us. Our existing businesses tallied solid results during a soft market in this quarter. We added institutional flow globally and onboarded, or are in the process of onboarding many various clients, including SoFi, StoneX, and others. Marex, with more than 3,400 institutional clients, now sources liquidity from Bullish. Our derivatives licensing efforts in the United States. are moving forward, and we continue to expect access, p ardon me, w e continue to expect to access the U.S. derivatives markets far sooner than we had originally believed. Liquidity services remained resilient in the quarter despite lighter crypto activity and prices.

CoinDesk Indices continued to win new product mandates, and CoinDesk Media maintained its position as the leading crypto news business. Finally, turning to capital allocation, our board authorized a share repurchase program of up to $300 million. We believe our shares are undervalued at current prices, and we have conviction in our long-term trajectory. Dave will walk you through the details.

David Bonanno
CFO, Bullish

Thanks, Tom. Good morning, everyone. This morning, we filed our third quarter results and shareholder update 6-K, including reconciliations of our non-IFRS measures discussed on the call. Turning to our third quarter results on page 10, total adjusted revenue was $84.4 million, up 10% year-over-year, with Subscription, Services & Other revenue of $56.3 million, up 13% year-over-year, and adjusted transaction revenue of $28 million, up 5% year-over-year. Third quarter adjusted operating expenses were $48.7 million, resulting in adjusted EBITDA of $35.6 million at a 42% margin. Finally, adjusted net income was $18.7 million, up 35% year-over-year. Turning to Bullish's full-year guidance on page 18, we are narrowing our previously provided range for SS&O revenue to $225 million-$235 million and lowering our previously provided range for adjusted operating expenses to $220 million-$225 million.

These updates reflect both the challenging crypto environment, including lower prices and the failure to pass the CLARITY Act, as well as our response to those conditions, including execution of meaningful efficiencies action during the third quarter. Finally, we raised and narrowed our full-year 2026 finance expense outlook to $60 million-$65 million to account for a higher interest rate environment and outlook for the remainder of the year. As a reminder, we do not guide on adjusted transaction revenue, and our monthly trading metrics are available on our IR website. Next, I'll turn to Equiniti's full year 2026 outlook as shown on page 20. We now expect total revenue of $910 million-$965 million, including $220 million-$240 million of interest income, and adjusted EBITDA less CapEx of $360 million-$370 million.

This outlook is essentially unchanged from the one we provided in May, with the exception of approximately $20 million in revenue coming from a large event, which we have broken out separately. Equiniti will occasionally generate outsized revenue from uniquely large or prolonged corporate actions, such as extended proxy campaigns or M&A activity. While these large events do occasionally occur, they are infrequent and unpredictable, and as such, we do not forecast them and encourage investors to exclude them from the normalized revenue base of the company. Turning to our combined medium-term outlook on page 21, we continue to expect revenue growth to ramp up throughout the period, albeit at a slower pace over the near term, which reflects some of the headwinds I previously mentioned.

For operating expenses and profitability, we now expect net cost reductions of $75 million-$100 million over the medium-term outlook as compared to the combined 2026 cost base, up from our prior guidance of $25 million-$50 million in net cost reductions. We expect the net cost savings to be front-loaded over the medium-term outlook, with all actions completed by year-end 2028 and a substantial portion of total net cost reductions realized during 2027. Putting these updates together, we continue to see combined adjusted EBITDA less CapEx margins in excess of 50% by the end of the medium-term outlook, as well as approximately $300 million of EBITDA less CapEx growth and more than $1 billion of cumulative free cash flow over the period.

Regarding combined interest expense, D&A, and other, we now forecast that line item to be between $205 million and $225 million in 2027, driven by the increasing interest rate environment. As a reminder, these comparisons are versus Equiniti's normalized revenue and profitability, excluding large event income previously discussed. Lastly, regarding the share repurchase authorization approved by our board, we have the financial capacity to simultaneously invest for growth, aggressively execute on the Equiniti integration, and tactically create shareholder value via share repurchases when appropriate, all without compromising our ability to execute on future M&A or deleverage our balance sheet. Before handing it back to Tom, I want to provide some additional important disclosures on the share repurchase authorization.

Before commencing any share repurchase activities, Bullish intends to file a comprehensive financial package under Form 6-K with the SEC the week of November 30th, which will include pro forma financials, Equiniti's 2024 and 2025 audited financial statements, and unaudited interim financials through September 30th, 2026. As a reminder, please also refer to the additional disclosures contained in our press release and Form 6-K. With that, I'll turn it back to Tom for closing remarks.

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Thank you, Dave. We came to the public markets as a crypto exchange just over a year ago. Our stated objective was to provide mission-critical products and services designed to help institutions grow their businesses, empower individual customers, and drive the adoption of stablecoins, digital assets, and blockchain technology. Following the expected closing of the Equiniti transaction in January, we will serve roughly 3,000 public companies and more than 20 million shareholders with the technology to bring their shares on-chain whenever they choose. Thank you. Operator, we're ready to open the line for questions.

Operator

Thank you. As a reminder, to ask a question, please press star one one on your telephone and wait for your name to be announced. To withdraw your question, please press star one one again. Please stand by while we compile our Q&A roster. Our first question will come from Brian Bedell from Deutsche Bank. Your line is open.

Brian Bedell
Analyst, Deutsche Bank

Great. Thanks. Good morning, folks. And congrats on

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Hi, Brian.

Brian Bedell
Analyst, Deutsche Bank

Hi. Congrats on Stacey joining. That's very exciting. Maybe just to start with the tokenization trajectory and plans. I think I heard you, Tom, clearly that you're definitely pursuing the issuer-led route as opposed to entitlement tokens. Can you talk also about, I guess, two things. One, what you view as the pace of acceptance of tokenization, of issuers tokenizing their stock? And then secondly, around trading that, to what extent, or do you intend to use the tokenized securities venue that the SEC included within its innovation exemption, or rather an ATS license?

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Sure. Great questions, Brian. The Eskimo language has 10 words for snow. In crypto, we're the opposite. We have one word, tokenization, and it defines 10 different things. To be clear, you referenced the third-party tokenization, and I just want to be candid. You've read some articles about how issuers have not loved the idea of somebody else going out and tokenizing that issuer's shares and marketing them as the actual shares, and that hasn't been terribly well received. And I understand why. I'm empathetic. It introduces, in many cases, one or multiple brokers. It introduces credit risk and operational risk and settlement risk. And the issuer is saying, wait a minute, I didn't have any control over that. That is not at all what we are doing, Brian.

When you said, I understand you're going the issuer token route, that's the only route we've ever been going down, because ultimately, we believe that the issuer tokens are going to underpin trading, settlement, clearing, ledgering of these shares, other use cases such as lending, borrowing, pledging, collateral, and ultimately are going to give the issuer the ability to reward loyal shareholders, along the lines I mentioned in my prepared remarks. When we're speaking to issuers, this concept is not confronting to them. They're comfortable as long as the thing we're talking about is their actual share that they have control over, and it has all of the rights and obligation. A shareholder benefits from all the rights and obligations of owning the actual physical share. I hope that answered the first part of your question.

With respect to the second part of your question, the TSVs do allow for both third-party tokens as well as issuer tokens. So far, what you've been reading about publicly is all about these third-party tokens. We are working quietly in the background to make sure that issuer tokens, if these TSVs become liquid, become an actual successful venue, that these issuer tokens are plumbed in in the appropriate way. Stay tuned for more details in that regard.

Brian Bedell
Analyst, Deutsche Bank

Yeah. That's great color. A question for Dave, just on the cost save improvement from the pending Equiniti acquisition. To what extent was that driven by the ability to use AI in a lot of their back office or backend services? If that wasn't part of it, what do you see as potential upside from automating a lot of their backend processes?

David Bonanno
CFO, Bullish

Thanks, Brian. I'd say the change in the increase in our expected net cost reductions over the medium-term outlook, absolutely partially driven by advancements in technology such as AI and automation, and also simply us having had a lot more time to get to know the business, the people, the operations, and to firm out a plan that will be executable starting on day one. It's a combination of those two things. We think the advancements of technology are going to bring efficiencies to the cost base of both companies.

You have seen Bullish's ability to do that with our own cost base, taking very quick action during the third quarter in response to the macro environment, getting our own operational costs under control and back down toward the low end of the original range from back in February after we had begun experiencing some cost increases during the middle of the year. We are hopeful that we will continue to experience and be able to achieve efficiencies on both cost base going forward.

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

I just wanted to add one note on that, Brian. This is just one of the many reasons I am excited about Stacey coming aboard. At the New York Stock Exchange, when I arrived there, they had six different matching engine technologies that were live in some form or function. Turning those all into a single matching engine that really delighted customers and became the envy of that marketplace was a very difficult task with no AI, no LLM, but something that Stacey took on and achieved very impressively. We have a similar task ahead of us. The difference is, with respect to the Equiniti systems infrastructure, today we have AI and LLMs, which enables us to do things much, much more quickly, and we are already seeing that as part of our integration efforts.

Operator

Thank you. As a reminder, to ask a question, please press star one one. In the interest of time, we kindly ask that you please limit yourselves to one question. One moment for our next question, please. Our next question will come from Pete Christiansen from Citi. Your line is open.

Pete Christiansen
Analyst, Citi

Good morning, guys. Thanks for the question here. Tom, I was just wondering if we can go back in time. It has been roughly a year since the IPO, and yes, the crypto markets have been kind of volatile over the last year. I am just curious if you could share how the U.S. business has performed since receiving the BitLicense. Can you provide any metrics around client growth, institutional adoption, or trading activity? Something along that line. Just curious how that business has flourished since acquiring the BitLicense. Thanks.

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Yeah. I appreciate it, Pete. I have a lot of great things to say, but I don't want to look like Baghdad Bob, to quote a 20-year-old reference. Crypto's been a bit of a, you said it politely, Pete, it's been a bit of a disaster, really. I mean, from the moment we IPO'd, Bitcoin, obviously the most prominent asset, is down by half. Ultimately, we didn't get the CLARITY Act across the line. I said on several earnings calls, while I didn't think the CLARITY Act was make or break, the truth was it would give institutions a bit more comfort, a bit of a safe harbor, and we would see those institutions kind of jump in with both feet.

I've met several banks in the last week or two, and it's actually been very encouraging to hear that they haven't put their plans on hold post-CLARITY Act. I will note, if you look at the major U.S. banks, with one notable exception, they're still not even holding Bitcoin on behalf of their clients. The truth is, we brought on a lot of U.S. clients. We've made a dent in U.S. market share in a very short period of time. As I said in my prepared remarks, we're hopeful that we'll be live with our derivatives franchise here in the U.S. in the next several months, maybe even sooner. Although ultimately, it's up to the regulator to decide when is the appropriate time.

We've signed up, as a reminder, Morgan Stanley for their ETF franchise, which has done very, very well, launching crypto ETFs, and we are the index provider, and many other anecdotes. But, the overarching macro headwinds have been so significant that the growth has been more muted than I would have expected, when you and I met, Pete, back in August around the time of our IPO.

Operator

Thank you. Our next question will come from Ken Worthington from JPMorgan. Your line is open.

Ken Worthington
Analyst, JPMorgan

Hi. Good morning. Thanks for taking the question. We've seen a number of tokenization initiatives launch, including at the DTCC. Does Bullish have a role if companies tokenize at other venues? If so, what is that role? If DTCC launched with 34 securities, has DTCC locked up the tokenization opportunity for those companies, or could there still be a role for Bullish with these companies in the future?

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Yeah. I appreciate it, Ken. There's a few questions nested in there that I'm going to do my best to unpack and not go on a long monologue. First thing I will say is, we're making a lot of progress on tokenization on the Bullish side. We've announced publicly several network partners. We already have some trading venue partners as well as other trading venue partners in the works. in the fourth quarter, we have started to record revenue from multiple customers for tokenization of, in particular, equities. All of that is moving forward in a positive direction, maybe even a very positive direction, but I don't want to put too big of a sheen on it, Ken, until we see it all come together post-closing. With respect to the issuer side, I don't want to speak for Equiniti.

We expect that transaction to close in January, at which point we will be able to provide more details about progress, specifically with respect to issuers and plans with respect to issuers. The net of it, Ken, is, and I know you know this because you're as good at channel checks as anyone, the net of it is that really the whole market is coming around to the realization that the underpinning for tokenization of equities, in particular, is going to be issuer tokens in some form or fashion. That isn't to speak ill of what, you mentioned DTC or what others are doing. These third-party tokens have a role, just like ADRs have a role, just like ETFs have a role. Most important, Ken, is the actual share.

No one is doing that today because only a transfer agent working with an issuer can do that today. It's not something to be rushed. So no, absolutely not. I applaud DTC for making progress with their own blockchain technology. Just like DTC holds paper shares, just like DTC holds electronic shares, someday they'll hold the issuer shares as well. What we are building, our model fits very nicely with the advancements that you're hearing about, reading about.

Operator

Thank you. Our next question will come from Owen Lau from Clear Street. Your line is now open.

Owen Lau
Analyst, Clear Street

Hi. Good morning. Thank you for taking my question. First of all, congrats on the hiring of Stacey. Sticking with the tokenization theme, I know we have talked a lot already, but I saw your press release about the Issuer Token Coalition. You also had the tokenization showcase last month. I am just curious to hear from you, Tom, under what conditions issuers are happy to tokenize their shares? Is the control over their shares their main concern? I guess more importantly, what does it take for them to tokenize their shares? Thank you.

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Yeah. Thank you, Owen. Really great question. Let me do this a little bit by analogy. Equiniti has been around for 97 years. Actually, the reason transfer agents came about is, disreputable people would double-sell the same share before transfer agents. Transfer agents came about to keep track of every single share and who the holder was. In those days, as you would imagine, those were paper shares. For about half a century, transfer agents kept track of who owned a paper share. Then, the electronic share was introduced, and the transfer agent added, it did not replace, it added the ability to keep track of electronic shares alongside the ability to keep track of paper shares.

Believe it or not, in the year 2026, there is still a goodly number of paper shares in circulation, and transfer agents like Equiniti and others keep track of, Owen Lau owns three paper shares, and David Bonanno owns six electronic shares, and that equals nine total shares for this company. What is now coming, and in fact has already come in the case of Bullish and others, but what will come for the 3,000 issuers, is simply a technology upgrade that will enable transfer agents to keep track of shares in paper form, in electronic form, and in on-chain form. What they are keeping track of is the share itself, not a derivative, not an IOU, not an entitlement. Those latter bucket are the third-party tokens that you are reading more about. They are making more news in the press.

But, the far more important innovation is simply the ability to have shares on- chain because that will be the bedrock, and that will enable all the use cases for issuers and for brokers to take hundreds of billions of dollars of collateral out of the system. Finally, you asked, what does it take to tokenize? Owen, that's where we work with the issuers, and you write a smart contract, which is really just a piece of software. It sounds complicated. You create the shares. If somebody wants to move the shares from one public blockchain to the other, that's super simple. You just burn it on one, and you mint it on the other.

Now, you have a token, and you just need the ability to create it via smart contract, to have a whitelist to make sure that people who are KYC'd, AML'd can hold that token, and you need the ability to keep track of it on a ledger, such as operated by a transfer agent. Behind the scenes, getting all that plumbing working is what we're doing. Look, we've kind of sprinkled some tea leaves. I think that's the metaphor. I might be butchering it. That back in May, when we did the Equiniti transaction, the point of this transaction was to be able to provide this on-chain tracking, an on-chain registry for shares for 3,000 issuers, not for one or two or three over here or five over here.

So what we're working on quietly, Owen, is a solution that can apply and can be a technology upgrade at the option of the issuers for all of the Equiniti public companies.

Operator

Thank you. Our next question will come from Ed Engel from Compass Point. Your line is open.

Ed Engel
Analyst, Compass Point

Hi. Thanks for taking my question. In the presentation, you flagged a slower ramp in tokenization and blockchain services in 2027. Does that reflect slower performance from the legacy business just amid the crypto winter, or does that reflect maybe some slower uptake in tokenization from Equiniti customers? Thank you.

David Bonanno
CFO, Bullish

Thanks, Ed. That outlook does reflect the macro crypto environment we are in, some headwinds facing tokenization, and our core business going forward. We continue to work collaboratively with the issuers and network partners and other infrastructure partners, as Tom mentioned. Post-closing, we will have more to say about our go-to-market efforts, but that guidance today does reflect essentially the environment we are in today, where prices are down, and there are other macro headwinds that we think will slow the rate of growth into the early part of next year. We need to incorporate that into our outlook. Again, everyone knows we are in the middle of a pretty deep crypto bear market here.

For the sake of providing an outlook that reflects where we are today, we thought it was most appropriate to layer in some of those headwinds, which are also, I discussed, as impacting the change in the SS&O range to remove the high end and narrow the range toward the lower end.

Operator

Thank you. Our next question will come from Dan Welden from Wells Fargo. Your line is open.

Dan Welden
Analyst, Wells Fargo

Hi, good morning. Tom, I wanted to ask you, Equiniti seems levered to the number of listed companies overall, and there's been a lot of initiatives in the U.S. over time to try to make it easier and less friction to publicly list. I wondered, as your new role in the markets post-Equiniti, how you think about the prospects of more listings, reducing friction points, rule changes, and how you can play a role in that.

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Yeah, I think that's a really thoughtful question. When we were contemplating the Equiniti transaction back in the first two quarters of the year, that was definitely one of the vectors we were thinking about, just total addressable market size and the total addressable market size growth over time. The other was just the absolute size of the pie for the transfer agent function in a world where shares are moving on- chain, and the transfer agent offering is getting less commoditized, more highly specialized, more value-add, offers new services that transfer agents haven't typically provided, such as what I described to Owen, the provision of the smart contracts, the provision of the whitelist, the connectivity to various new types of venues, liquidity provision, so on and so forth, all the sorts of things that Bullish was perfectly enabled to provide.

I have to be candid, we put a whole lot more faith in the latter than the former, meaning we put a whole lot more faith in the growing of the TAM because of the increasingly strategic role of the transfer agent. I remember when we announced the deal, there was some sort of eyebrow-raising, like, oh, wow, this transfer agent function, how important is it? Well, fast-forward, others have woken up to, Wow, this is a very critical role, from the Chairman of the SEC to many analysts who cover our business. Certainly, that feels right. But in terms of will the number of public companies grow, I'm gun-shy. As the captain of the New York Stock Exchange back in the day, I convinced myself that things were changing. We were in a deregulatory environment. We were going to see a lot more public companies.

Things like the JOBS Act would result in many more companies going public. It simply hasn't happened. I do have a small hope, but I don't want to oversell you on it, that actually blockchain technology itself is going to allow for far more efficient capital raising, broader capital raising, and an easier go-to-market path for companies, and that ultimately will result in more public companies. But, we're not banking on it. We didn't bank on it when we made the decision to acquire Equiniti, and we're looking at other things like, can we grow the TAM by providing more of these value-added services, and can we grow our business geographically?

Operator

Thank you. Our next question will come from Gareth Gacetta from Cantor. Your line is open.

Gareth Gacetta
Analyst, Cantor

Hey, guys. Thanks for taking the question. I just kind of wanted to double-click on the updated medium-term outlook. I know the SEC's innovation exemption has some caps on kind of the growth of regulated tokenization in the U.S. So I'm wondering if you could talk about kind of what the realistic ceiling is on tokenization revenue over the near term here, and what maybe has to happen for that ceiling to lift or for the restrictions to kind of be lower going forward. Thanks.

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Yeah, no, I appreciate it. Let me go full nerd blur on you, but do it really quickly. The innovation exemption, the word exemption, I'll come back to that, but focus on that. What the innovation exemption did is it said, if you operate a platform in the following broad way, you are exempt from registering for regulation with the SEC, and you can operate your platform, and you can trade third-party tokens, and it's really kind of oriented towards those third-party tokens, or issuer tokens, but a little bit less oriented towards those issuer tokens. Why did I answer your question by starting in that capacity? That's one small subset of on-chain trading, where we expect the bulk of on-chain trading to come from in the United States is from regulated venues, which are ATSs, alternative trading systems , affiliated with broker-dealers, or national securities exchanges.

The caps that you refer to, to be clear, only refer to trading that occurs on these so-called TSVs, these exempt venues. I applaud the SEC for pushing forward with the innovation exemption to get kind of the party started, if you will. But ultimately, and you've seen this with the announcements from the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq, ultimately, I expect from players like the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq and others, Bullish, that you will see far more trading ultimately on regulated venues in the United States of on-chain shares than on TSVs. I hope that answered your question.

Operator

Thank you. Our next question will come from Michael Kim from Bloomberg. Your line is open.

Michael Kim
Analyst, Bloomberg

Hey, everyone. Thanks for taking my question. Based on month-to-date data, it looks like your trading volumes have picked up thus far in November. Just curious if you might have seen any material shifts in market shares just following the events at Binance, and then just given your focus on compliance and licensing, is there an opportunity to maybe capitalize on a renewed focus on security, really across the industry? Thanks.

David Bonanno
CFO, Bullish

Appreciate the question. With regard to the monthly trading metrics, as we've mentioned in the past, our trading activity and therefore our market share, particularly in spot markets, is most heavily driven by volatility. So the higher the volatility, the better we tend to perform with our institutional customer base on a volume market share basis. With regard to the events at Binance, can't say today that we really see direct impact that's attributable to that event. That said, we do think it's another reminder to market participants that they take risks when they're on unregulated venues, and we do think that over time, market share will continue to migrate to regulated venues that operate themselves to the highest standards of professionalism, security, safety, and compliance. We think the trend remains in our favor. Then again, on the monthly trading metrics, mostly driven by volatility.

Again, we tend to outperform in highly volatile environments given our customer base.

Operator

Thank you. Our next question will come from Will Johnston from Canaccord Genuity. Your line is open.

Will Johnston
Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

Hi, thanks for taking my question. Maybe just one on tokenized shares. I think Bullish tokenized shares have been trading on the platform for a few months now. So just any learnings or early learnings from that and how holders are using them in unique ways and maybe any way that's just shaped conversations or things you are putting in front of other issuers. Thanks.

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Sure. Oh, boy, I am going to go high level for a second. I think looking into the crystal ball is a little bit fuzzy of exactly how all of this is going to develop. What is not fuzzy for us is that shares, the global securities market, which incidentally is $275 trillion, is going to move onto public blockchains for settlement, for registry, and then certainly for transferring, moving around, pledging shares as collateral, because that is where the most efficiency is going to come from. There are analyst reports that as much as $1 trillion will be pulled out of the system that today is just tied up, and really, is not tied up in a fruitful way. With respect to trading, one could imagine sort of a single monolithic trading or liquidity environment that is independent of how that share is being traded. What do I mean by that?

Today, when you trade on Nasdaq, you do not know if the person you are trading with is settling in a paper share or an electronic share. Tomorrow, you might be unaware, are they trading in a paper share, an electronic share, or an on-chain share? Then, the on-chain share market share will just simply grow from zero to something approaching 100%. The industrial logic, to me, would point in that direction. However, in the meantime, there is a whole bunch of people out there building platforms to demonstrate how good this public blockchain is, and so it requires some liquidity for the tokenized shares in particular, for the on-chain shares in particular. So that is what is kind of forming up, and that was kind of the gist of your question.

I want to tell you, it is not dead easy, and this is part of what Dave and I have been talking about on this call, about how quick the adoption will be for tokenized trading. It is not dead easy to predict because there is some challenges to creating that initial liquidity, and one of those challenges is simply the ability to quickly move from a paper share or electronic share to a tokenized share, and then back into a paper share or an electronic share. We have some things in the works that we look forward to sharing more with you about in the days and weeks ahead that will facilitate that, and will kind of grease the skids, and it will give us a clear pathway, and I think will be very, very helpful to our issuers and to the market at large.

But we are not quite yet ready to declare victory and share all those details, but stay tuned.

Operator

Thank you. I am showing no further questions at this time. I would now like to turn the call back over to Tom Farley for any closing remarks.

Tom Farley
CEO, Bullish

Hey, I just want to say thank you all for listening. Thank you all for bearing with us. As Dave and I said, it has been a tough crypto environment, with prices down by half and unfortunately not getting the CLARITY Act. We have never been as excited as we are. It is perhaps a bit counterintuitive. We think we are really well-positioned. We thought that in May, but we were a little nervous with the announcement of Equiniti. It is a certainty now, in our minds, that the market is moving in our direction, and we are going to be able to be very, very helpful to issuers in many different ways.

We feel good about this strategic portfolio of products and services that we've pulled together over the last half decade or more, and coupling it with Equiniti, we think is going to give us a chance to really delight issuers and put some money in shareholders' pockets. Thank you very much. Thanks also to Dave and to Liam and our team for their preparation for this earnings call.

Operator

Thank you for participating. This concludes today's program. You may now disconnect.