Operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Enterprise Financial Services Corp Fourth Quarter 2022 Earnings Conference Call. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. After the speaker's remarks, there will be a question and answer session. If you would like to ask a question during this time, simply press star followed by the one on your telephone keypad. If you would like to withdraw your question, again, press star one. Thank you. I will now turn the call over to Jim Lally, President and CEO. You may begin.
Colby, thank you. Thank you all very much for joining us this morning, and welcome to our 2022 Fourth Quarter Earnings Call. Joining me this morning is Keene Turner, EFSC's Chief Financial Officer and Chief Operating Officer, and Scott Goodman, President of Enterprise Bank & Trust. Before we begin, I would like to remind everybody on the call that a copy of the release and accompanying presentation can be found on our website. The presentation and earnings release were furnished on SEC Form 8-K yesterday. Please refer to slide two of the presentation titled Forward-Looking Statements and our most recent 10-K and 10-Q for reasons why actual results may vary from any forward-looking statements that we make today. Throughout 2022, we stressed our commitment to building partnerships with our clients, the execution of our strategic initiatives, and our diversified business platform.
This cadence of consistency produced record results for both the fourth quarter and for the entire year. The financial highlights for the fourth quarter begin on slide three. We capped the year with tremendous momentum, both for loan growth as well as earnings. We earned $1.58 per share for the fourth quarter, which resulted in a 1.83% return on average assets and a 23% return on tangible common equity. This is inclusive of our tangible common equity to tangible assets ratio expanding during the quarter, and we closed the year at 8.43%. Additionally, our robust earnings helped to contribute approximately $2 per share to our tangible book value during the fourth quarter, which closed at $28.67 per share.
Turning to slide four, you can see that we had an outstanding quarter with respect to loan growth. On an annualized basis, we were able to grow the loan portfolio by 16%. The diversification on which we have focused was on full display as just about every market and business line contributed to these outstanding results. Scott will provide much more color about these markets and businesses in his comments. Our posture on deposits has not changed. We continue to actively manage deposit rates and focus on the relationship aspect of this side of our business. The goal of this is to find the appropriate balance between retention, growth, competitiveness, and stability. I'm really pleased with how this has played out as evidenced by the de minimis amount of runoff, a relatively low cost of total deposits, and a stable DDA percentage right around 42%.
This level of discipline, coupled with the rise in short-term interest rates, resulted in a net interest margin expansion of 56 basis points. Our credit statistics remain outstanding as both non-performing loans to total loans and non-performing assets to total assets improved from the very low levels that were reported at the end of the third quarter. We did record a modest provision expense in the quarter due to our strong loan growth outpacing the risk reduction in the portfolio during the fourth quarter. Slide five provides a recap of our highlights for the full year. On a fully diluted basis, we earned $5.31 per share in 2022, an increase of 38% from 2021. We grew portfolio loans at a rate of 11% for the year, with contributions from all of our regions and businesses.
Along with our balance sheet performance, this growth supported our record financial results. Our Pre-Provision Net Revenue expanded 25% over the prior period. This helped drive a Pre-Provision Net Revenue return on average assets that easily surpassed 2% to end 2022. All in all, 2022 was an incredible year for EFSC. We entered the year with a focused mindset of delivering consistent results. The record earnings per share that we produced is a product of a well-executed plan that focused on diversified revenue growth, disciplined pricing within our deposit base, consistent credit and pricing fundamentals, patient and thoughtful capital and investment management, and responsible expense management. As we turn the page and head into 2023, our areas of focus, which are found on slide 6, have not changed.
Despite the continual change of our operating environment, which include ongoing short-term rate increases, intense deposit competition, and the likelihood of a mild recession, we are confident of our ability to perform at the high level that we have become accustomed to. The conversations we've had with our clients gives us confidence that 2023 should be another outstanding year for EFSC. For the most part, backlogs and order books of the operating companies that we serve are strong, with corporate balance sheets that provide ample room for continued growth. They are still dealing with some of the same issues that have become commonplace, such as sufficient, competent labor and reliable supply chains. We do not see these issues as derailers to the success of these businesses.
We feel good about the continued growth of our investor CRE business due to the many projects that had broken ground in late 2021 and throughout 2022. New projects have been slower to materialize as a sharp rise in interest rates require the owner-developers to recalibrate their input metrics inclusive of additional equity. On the deposit side of things, we believe that we will continue to see a bit of pressure on rates throughout the year. There's always a lag on rate increases, especially for higher balanced commercial accounts. We've been hard at work throughout much of 2022 identifying specifically where we need to make proactive movements to preserve these highly valued relationships and feel very good about where they stand. With that said, I feel very confident that we can fund our expected loan growth with the various deposit generators that we currently have.
With that, I would like to turn the call over to Scott Goodman, President of Enterprise Bank & Trust, for his insights about our markets and business lines. Scott?
Thank you, Jim. Good morning, everyone. As you'll see on slide number seven, loans at year-end totaled just over $9.7 billion, representing an 11.3% increase from the prior year net of PPP. $984 million of core growth was well diversified across the major loan categories as detailed on slide number 8. Strong growth in C&I reflects continued success in attracting new operating company relationships across our footprint. Specialty business lines contributed a similar level of growth overall as C&I and also continue to perform consistently. Growth in commercial real estate, while more modest overall, generally reflects an intentional approach to partner and go deeper with a select set of strong investors and developers in each market rather than chase projects or transactions.
Q4 was a period of strong loan growth as reflected on slide number nine, with contributions by nearly all markets and lines of business. Originations for the quarter were up nearly 15% from the prior period. Q4 is typically a seasonally strong loan production quarter for us, but this was further bolstered by wins on a number of larger new C&I relationships and nice performance out of the gate by our new team in Dallas. The specialty lending units contributed roughly a third of the growth this quarter with an aggregate increase of $141 million. SBA finished strong, posting growth of $43 million in the quarter despite the continuing headwinds of higher short-term rates.
The team is focused on proactive steps to moderate payoff activity with existing borrowers and continued consistency in our product offering to the market with a relatively stable pipeline heading into 2023. Life Insurance Premium Finance had a seasonally strong quarter based on the timing of premium renewals in the book. Growth has been further accelerated by additional new referral partners in 2022, including new opportunities from the legacy First Choice book, which we've been able to nurture and grow. Tax Credit also executed well with $52 million of quarterly growth, pushing the total to $73 million or 15% for the year. The strong quarter mainly reflects advances on the existing projects in process along with several new ones. The necessity for affordable housing and the continued adoption of these programs by more states should provide continuity of our opportunity pipeline in this business looking forward.
Sponsor Finance posted a small decline in the portfolio for the quarter, mainly relating to slightly lower origination activity and some churn in the existing book through the sale of platform companies. Year-over-year growth for this business has been quite strong at $127 million or 25%. Much of the activity in this channel is timing contingent due to the aspects of the M&A process, and the lower origination volume reflects some delayed closings which will carry over into Q1. In general, though, the pipeline of new deals for this specialty remains healthy and active. Turning now to the regional results, which are on slide 10. Our Midwestern markets of St. Louis and Kansas City grew $99 million in Q4 and posting year-over-year growth of 9.4%.
Both markets experienced a modest increase in revolving line outstandings and had solid new origination activity in the quarter. Notably, we onboarded several new middle market C&I relationships, along with a nice volume of refinance and new commercial real estate development loans in the Kansas City market. Our Southwestern markets grew by $81 million for the quarter, resulting in solid year-over-year growth of 14.6%. This includes $27 million in growth from our new Texas team, bringing their production to $43 million for 2022. This office, which opened mid-year, is off to a strong start and with a nice balance of both new C&I and commercial real estate clients.
The Arizona team also had some nice closings this period, including a large retail center for a new investor relationship and a development loan for a large, well-known community-based organization serving children in the Phoenix Metro under a New Markets Tax Credit structure. In Southern California, we grew $51 million in the quarter and are building nice momentum heading into 2023. We continue to execute a strategy in this market of expanding the legacy relationships from predecessor banks and developing a larger C&I portfolio through talent acquisitions. This period, we onboarded several new C&I relationships, assisted a large legacy franchise operator with an acquisition, and materially expanded a credit facility with a legacy CRE investor. Moving now to deposits, which are on slides number 11 and 12.
Total deposit balances were down $229 million for the quarter and $515 million or 4.5% year-over-year. Breaking this down, non-interest bearing accounts were stable for the quarter and up year-over-year. The declines were really isolated to the interest bearing categories, with a majority of the funds being a limited number of higher cost transactional accounts or idle balances of larger businesses. As you heard from Jim, we've taken an intentional approach of selectively managing our deposit pricing to prioritize retention, deepen our key relationships, and attract new ones. We've also developed a number of competitive deposit options for clients, and our bankers are having proactive conversations to mitigate outflows. The deposit breakdown on slide number 13 provides some clarity by region. Larger impacts tend to be within our more concentrated C&I markets and legacy portfolios.
In the Midwest, for example, a large portion of their $281 million decline for the quarter is attributable to a single upper middle market company that we had assisted with a Main Street loan. Upon recent repayment of the Main Street loan, we were unable to retain the full relationship which moved back to a national bank, along with the accompanying deposits of roughly $120 million in the quarter. More generally, though, we have been successful in growing relationship-based balances, originating over $1 billion of deposits from new relationships during the year, with average balances for these new accounts materially exceeding those in closed accounts. Lastly, I'd like to point to the growth of our specialty deposit verticals, which are detailed on slide number 14, and which continue to enhance our flexibility to optimize our funding strategy.
During Q4, balances grew within each of our specialties, community associations, property management, and third-party escrow. Specialized deposits in aggregate grew $102 million in the quarter and $302 million or 13.6% for the year. I'd like to turn the call over to Keene Turner for further financial highlights. Keene?
Thanks, Scott. Good morning, everyone. My comments begin on slide 15, where we reported earnings per share of $1.58 in the fourth quarter on net income of $60 million. Organic growth in earning assets and continued margin expansion drove a meaningful increase in operating revenue in the fourth quarter. This led to record earnings per share that expanded 20% from the third quarter. Non-interest expense and the provision for credit losses both increased in the quarter. These increases were more than offset by the 16% sequential increase in operating revenue. For full year 2022, we reported net income of $203 million and earnings per share of $5.31 compared to $3.86 in the prior year.
Turning to slide 16, net interest income for the quarter was $139 million compared to $124 million in the linked quarter, an increase of $15 million. The increase came as a result of higher average loan balances along with the benefit of increasing interest rates driving our asset yields higher. The increase in net interest income was primarily driven by a $21 million increase in loan income and was partially offset by a $6 million increase in deposit expense. With the current composition of our balance sheet as of December 31st, we expect the full impact of the existing interest rate increases will result in a quarterly net interest income in the range of $143 million-$146 million.
As noted in the earnings release, approximately 17% of the variable rate loan portfolio reprices on the first day of each quarter and did not benefit from the fourth quarter interest rate increases. We expect that with the Fed reducing the magnitude of interest rate increases, that first and second quarter actions will be largely offset by lagged deposit costs. We're experiencing better than expected repricing on interest-bearing deposits. We do expect that we will continue to address deposit costs and competition in 2023. That is to say that net interest income growth will be correlated with loan growth and any additional actions by the Fed. Moving on to slide 17, net interest margin on a tax equivalent basis was 4.66%, an increase of 56 basis points from the linked quarter.
With an asset-sensitive balance sheet, we continue to benefit from rising rates and assets yield rose more than liability costs in the period. Earning asset yields improved 78 basis points, which included 77 basis points of loan yield improvement, including a 6.64% origination rate on new loans, and the investment yield improved 26 basis points as reinvestment rates continued to increase to a 5.2% fourth quarter tax equivalent rate. Asset yields were also aided by an enhanced asset mix as we continue to grow loans and investments while reducing cash balances. The cost of interest-bearing liabilities increased 40 basis points from the prior period, driven mainly by higher deposit rates and variable rate borrowings.
Our deposit portfolio remains more than 40% non-interest-bearing balances, which allows us to be more deliberate with deposit pricing compared to prior rate cycles. The loan portfolio is our largest driver of asset sensitivity, as 63% of loans are variable rate. More than 60% of those have interest rate floors, and essentially all of those with floors are currently priced above the floor. While our variable rate loans have enhanced earnings during this cycle, we executed several interest rate swaps in the fourth quarter to protect future earnings if rates should begin to move the opposite direction. Our interest-bearing deposit beta was approximately 30% in the fourth quarter, and while it is higher than the previous periods in 2022, it remains below our expected and historical level.
While we expect this lag in deposit pricing to abate, we believe our ability to control deposit costs through this rising rate environment has been greatly enhanced versus prior interest rate cycles. We remain committed to funding asset growth through relationship-based deposits and our specialty verticals. On slide 18, we demonstrate our credit trends. Annualized net charge-offs remain low at nine basis points in the fourth quarter compared to two basis points in the linked quarter. For the full year, net charge-offs were $3.9 million or four basis points compared with $11.6 million or 14 basis points in the prior year. Overall, asset quality improved in the quarter, with non-performing assets and non-performing loans declining in dollar and percentage terms from both the linked quarter and the prior year-end.
Non-performing assets were eight basis points of total assets, and non-performing loans were 10 basis points of total loans. In addition to the improvement in the non-performing category, we also experienced a decline in past due loans in the quarter. On slide 19, we demonstrate the allowance for credit losses. The allowance for credit losses declined $3.6 million in the quarter to $137 million, primarily due to net charge-offs and the overall improvement in asset quality. While the economic forecast factors used in our CECL model generally worsened in the fourth quarter, the loan portfolio mix shifted to areas that carry a lower reserve. A provision expense of $2.1 million was recognized in the quarter, which primarily re-reflects an increase in the reserve for unfunded commitments.
The allowance for credit losses represents 1.41% of total loans, compared to 1.5% at the end of the third quarter. When adjusting for government-guaranteed loans, the allowance to total loans was at 1.56% at the end of December. Turning to slide 20, our fourth quarter fee income was $17 million, an increase of $7 million in the quarter. The increase was led primarily by a $6 million increase in Tax Credit income. As you recall, this line item was negatively impacted in the third quarter by rising interest rates on Tax Credit projects carried at fair value. While fourth quarter results did not see the same negative impact as rates were steady in the quarter and benefited from seasonally strong sales of Tax Credits.
Tax credit income will continue to be seasonal and subject to further interest rate movements. Fair value adjustments that reduce tax credit income are more than offset by higher net interest income in a rising interest rate environment. The fourth quarter also saw fees earned on community development investments compared to the linked quarter increase, and they were partially offset by a decrease in deposit service charges, driven primarily by an increase in Earnings Credits to clients based on recent interest rate trends. Turning to slide 20, fourth quarter non-interest expense was $77 million, an increase of $8 million compared to $69 million in the third quarter. Deposit service expenses were the main driver and increased $6 million from the linked quarter due to rising interest rates and growth in certain specialized deposit businesses.
Compensation and benefits increased $1.2 million from the linked quarter, principally from higher performance-based incentive and bonus accruals due to the company's strong financial results. The fourth quarter's core efficiency ratio was 48.1%, an improvement of 170 basis points compared to the third quarter. This reflects the continued momentum in operating revenue, outpacing the rise in non-interest expense during the quarter. Looking to 2023, we're expecting the core efficiency ratio to be in the 50%-51% range as we expect to see margin expand further from our fourth quarter levels. First quarter trends typically include an expected seasonal decline in fee income as well as higher compensation expense. Overall, for 2023, we expect salaries and benefits to increase around 6% from the fourth quarter annualized run rate.
The next big driver of expense is from increased deposit service expense from both rate and growth in certain specialized deposit businesses. We view this space as competitive and evolving. There may be some opportunity for us to manage throughout the year, but not necessarily in the next couple quarters. Our efficiency ratio guide reflects our posture on how we expect this line item to trend in 2023. Our capital metrics are shown on slide 22. The record earnings we generated in the fourth quarter of $60 million, combined with an improvement in Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income, resulted in tangible book value per share of $28.67, an increase of 8% from the third quarter.
During 2022, we still increased tangible book value per share by roughly $0.40 with our strong earnings level while returning $67 million to common shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. We announced another increase to our dividend for the first quarter of 2003, marking the 7th consecutive quarter the dividend has been increased. In 2022, we paid common dividends of $0.90 per share, a $0.15 increase or 20% compared to the prior year. While our dividend has increased, our dividend payout ratio of 17% in 2022 remains at a level that provides flexibility in our capital structure moving forward. The Tangible Common Equity to tangible asset ratio improved to 8.4% at the end of the year.
After the initial decline in the first quarter when market interest rates increased and negatively impacted Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income, the Tangible Common Equity ratio has improved in each of the last three quarters. While the Tangible Common Equity ratio is now within our target range of 8%-9%, we do not plan to execute any meaningful share repurchases in the near term. With the uncertainty on the path of interest rates and the potential economic impact of further short-term rate increases, we intend to let our organic earnings further strengthen our capital base. When market conditions and our capital position align, we still have 2 million shares available under a board-approved repurchase program. We had great momentum throughout the year and finished 2022 with a strong quarter.
We delivered a 23% return on Tangible Common Equity and a 1.8% return on average assets in the fourth quarter with a 19% return on average Tangible Common Equity and a 1.5% return on average assets for the full year 2022. We believe that we are well-positioned and look forward to carrying this momentum in 2023. Thank you for joining the call today. We'll now open the line for analyst questions.
At this time, I would like to remind everyone in order to ask a question, press star then the number one on your telephone keypad. We'll pause just for a moment to compile the Q&A roster. Your first question comes from the line of Jeff Rulis from D.A. Davidson. Your line is open.
Hi, good morning.
Good morning, Jeff.
Yeah, just wanted to kind of get a sense for the variable deposit costs. Keene, we got your kind of high-end guardrails on efficiency and expectations on margin and how that all flows through. Just wanted to narrow in on the variable deposit costs. Is that sort of a one-time catch? Is that seasonal in nature? I know you referenced sort of rate driven, but is there anything kind of year-end just trying to predict that line a little bit better, and how that, you know, from a run rate perspective?
Sure, Jeff. I'm happy to give you some color there. There was a little bit of catch up that was in there from year-end, and it really related to a competitive decision we made in the fourth quarter. You know, obviously everybody's fighting for liquidity now, I think the specialized deposit space is one where we're seeing some of the key players there. They've had some major deposit outflows and really trying to get aggressive. We're just holding our ground there. I think we had a good quarter in terms of balances and, you know, we were responsive to some competitive pressures that, you know, had a little bit of an effect on, you know, some of what was earned throughout the year, and there was some catch-up.
I would say going forward when you look at 4Q to 1Q sequentially, you know, we're thinking that that line item is up maybe $2 million-$3 million just depending on what happens with balances and rates and sort of everything that we know at the end of the year. You know, maybe based on December run rate itself, it's probably $2 million. Based on, you know, growth and maybe some more leakage from a competition perspective, that increases up to $3 million sequentially. I think, you know, if you layer that in with our efficiency ratio guide, I think, you know, you can kind of see how we think that plays out for 2023.
Okay. If I catch that right, you're referencing the variable deposit cost line item specifically, and that's-
Correct.
In addition to.
Correct.
Okay.
Right.
Then we got your salaries and comp in Q1 commentary as well. Looks like an up Q1, but again, to kind of use that efficiency ratio to back in for the full year.
Yeah, I think Q1 obviously won't compare to the 48% efficiency with the seasonal fee income and a little bit shorter day count from a net interest income perspective, and you have some seasonal expenses there. I think with that $2 million-$3 million for the first quarter sequentially on that Tax Credits line, or sorry, the ECR line item, that should give you some good starting points for modeling the expenses for one Q.
Okay. I wanted to jump over to the margin. I think it referenced, you know, putting on some swaps in the quarter. You know, I can't remember if that's the first we've heard of that. I mean, just trying to get a sense for have you been putting those on in quarters prior and/or just trying to get the strategy of are you trying to be more aggressive in moderating or locking in, again, margin to the downside should we flip on rates? Just trying to sense for the appetite of could we see more and how far do you go? Obviously, clearly benefiting on the asset sensitivity front, but want to see what the, what the other side and what you plan to do into 2023.
Yeah, Jeff, I think, certainly we've been focused in 23 on various strategies to, you know, essentially take some asset sensitivity off the balance sheet. You know, initially I think that was, you know, cash into securities and I think just in moving the loan-to-deposit up, you know, in and of itself, you know, did that to a degree with soaking up some of that excess liquidity and letting some of that go. You know, once rates were up what we would say is meaningfully, call that late second quarter, early third, we started looking at a hedging strategy to take, you know, somewhere between 50 and 100 basis points of asset sensitivity to the downside off the table. I'd say we're about halfway there.
We've done $200 million so far and, you know, we might have $200-$300 to go. We're not going to be, you know, incredibly aggressive. We would've liked to be maybe a little bit more assertive earlier on putting the hedges on, but quite frankly, the loan hedges move the same direction as the fair value of securities in comprehensive income. That was a guardrail that caused us to be a little bit more cautious. Now with TCE in a little bit better spot, we're layering some of those in, and with the way the rate curve is, those are probably shorter term hedges. We're not, you know, we're not gonna take 3% sensitivity off the table.
We're probably gonna take, you know, the better part of 100 basis points, and we'll probably end up sitting there. That's the way we're thinking about it. Then all of our net interest income and margin guidance is reflective of that we provided on my comments earlier.
That's helpful. Thank you.
You're welcome.
Your next question comes from the line of Damon DelMonte from KBW. Your line is open.
Hey, good morning, guys. Hope everybody's doing well today. First we wanna kinda continue on the margin commentary there. Keene, do you think you guys kinda peak here in the 1st quarter for your margin and then kinda are able to defend it and hold it as you progress through 2023? Or do you think you still see a rise, you know, as far as the 2nd quarter of this year?
Yeah, I think based on my comments, I think that seemed to reflect more defensive with first quarter peak. I think when you really look out at how we've forecasted it, I think that margin on a monthly basis peaks sometime in the third quarter. I'm not saying that that would actually result in third quarter margin being higher than second. Again, that's all dependent on, you know, what, you know, when we get the, you know, quote, 75 basis points of Fed funds increases that we're expecting to get. If that's all layered into the first quarter, then obviously, you know, second quarter is probably more like the peak. If that's a little bit more drawn out, I think, you know, maybe the peak is lower, but maybe it's later.
you know, we're thinking about it, you know, call it, you know, June-July timeframe in terms of peak. you know, probably first to second quarter is when you get, you know, what you guys will see as peak margin.
Got it. Okay. That's helpful. Thanks. With regards to the outlook for loan growth, can you just provide a little color on what the expectation would be for next year? You know, the commentary seemed pretty positive. Do you think you could kinda replicate the level you had in 2022, or do you think we start to see a bit of a pullback?
Yeah, Damon, this is Jim. I'll handle that one. You know what? We're very comfortable in that mid to high single digit number, you know, with everybody contributing. You know, we talked about the fact that, you know, we don't wanna jump into transactional lending or do the last project in any market. Just keep to the game plan. We're gonna have quarters like we had in the fourth quarter when it all comes together. We're comfortable with that mid to high single digit growth going forward.
Great. Then do you do much in the office space in your commercial real estate portfolio?
Scott, you wanna talk about that?
Yeah. I, Damon, I wouldn't say it's a focus, you know. It's a, it's a function of those relationships that I talk about in each of our markets. You know, it's not, it's not a large focus or a concentration for us. I think the portfolio we do have, it seems to be performing well. Generally, it's like neighborhood-type offices. We don't have a, you know, a large metro class A type portfolio.
Yeah. Are you able to quantify the percentage of overall loans or of the CRE portfolio?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Probably find that.
It's roughly, yeah, $450 million to $500 million, kinda sitting here today. Pretty, you know, pretty diversified in terms of industry as well, so relatively small in terms of the whole.
Got it.
Maybe I'll just add too. We had done a targeted review on that portfolio not too long ago and, you know, we're talking about LTVs averaging in 50% range. You know, debt service coverage is above a 150, so also performing pretty well.
Okay, great. That's all that I had. Thank you very much.
Your next question comes from the line of Brian Martin from Janney Montgomery. Your line is open.
Hey, good morning guys.
Hi, Brian.
Hey, just wanted to find out, just get a little bit more insight on just, you talked a little bit, Keene, about the Tax Credits business and kind of the rebound and the seasonality. You know, at one point maybe there was some seasonality going away. Last quarter, you know, the issue. Just in general that kind of Tax Credits or fee income, just kind of the, you know, some guidelines as far as how to think about, how you guys are thinking about that this quarter. Obviously the CDE this quarter was a little bit of an inflator, just, you know, any input or thoughts you have on the fee income would be helpful.
Yeah. I mean, I think year to date, Brian, I think, you know, for this year we're at, you know, call it two and a half million for, you know, Tax Credits income in total. I think that without any material movement in what we'll say are longer term rates, I think we look at, you know, that as probably a similar level for the upcoming year. You know, if 10 years SOFR moves further down, I think there's opportunity for more fair value and vice versa. We're kind of, you know, teetering at that point and I think there are some cash sales that we do expect will, you know, offset some of the startup and operating costs of that business for us. Then, you know, you asked about the kind of other income, CDE, private equity.
You know, I think we generally think about that annually as, call it $2 million-$3 million that we feel comfortable. Then there's upside in some of those depending on how some of those projects ultimately work out and are exited. You know, both of those businesses I think are seasonal and, you know, we probably think that they're second half weighted with obviously the Tax Credits business is fourth quarter weighted for us. Hopefully that gives you some perspective on where we think it is and what those we'll call variable line items look like in 2023.
Yeah. Just if you take out the Tax Credits line, Keene, the volatility and just fee income kind of in that when you look at all the line items, maybe a kind of a mid-single digit type of grower, is that how you're thinking about it if you strip out the, you know, at least the one item which had more noise in it last year? Is that a, you know, on the lower end-
Yeah
... of where, you know, it's reasonable?
Yeah. If you're looking at, you know, third and fourth quarter, you know, call it recurring fee income, I think we think of those as kind of mid-single-digit businesses together overall. You know, I think there's maybe a little bit of pressure and competition in the traditional Earnings Credit space, in, you know, some of our cash management and treasury management products. We're working to mitigate that. You know, we sort of think between card, wealth, deposit service charges, that, you know, 5% from where we're operating in the second half of the year is, you know, gets you in the ballpark.
Yeah. Okay. That's perfect. That's what I thought. Then just on the capital, you know, kind of getting back here as far as the buyback and, you know, potential, you know, M&A, I guess the organic growth sounds like it's there. You know, I guess when you look at the other options, how are you guys thinking about, you know, the buyback today and the and the M&A? I mean, you talked about the dividend already, so just any feedback on, you know, how to think about those or how you're thinking about those going into 2023?
Keen, you want to handle the buyback and I'll handle M&A?
Yeah. Sounds good, Jim. I would say, Brian, that we're trying to be thoughtful here about all the volatility that we've been through, that investors have been through. I think the idea is to create a really, really strong balance sheet. We already have it. The earnings power and the dividend profile give us the ability to do that. I think the allowance is maybe a little bit lighter than we would want it to be if there is a recession coming. Asset quality is so good that that's a struggle. I think the next line of defense is, you know, besides earnings and the allowance is capital. I think our goal would be in the near term to just to let that build and be a little bit conservative.
If we're operating with a little bit too much capital, I think that, you know, as we'll say the environment improves and valuations improve, you know, we are clearly a strong acquirer and we can deal with, you know, excess capital in a deal structure or something like that. Then, you know, Jim, if you want to talk about our appetite for M&A...
Yeah
... you know, now's probably the perfect time.
Sure. You know, Brian, it's one of those things, you know, we've got such great momentum in the business and, you know, M&A's on the list. It's further down the list in 2023 than say it was in 2019 and 2020. We still do our normal calling and meetings and things of that nature, but it's gonna have to be pretty dynamic and pretty special to stop what we're doing now to put something on top. You know, we've talked about this in the past. M&A also includes lift outs, M&A also includes teams and new businesses, and that's always an ongoing opportunity for us.
Gotcha. Okay. No, that's helpful. Maybe just on the deposit beta, I guess any change as far as where you think the cumulative beta, you know, kind of shakes out here and I think it sounds like your outlook is for a couple more rate hikes here in February and in March. You know, I'm not sure if that's, if those play out, how are you guys thinking about that deposit beta cumulatively?
You know, I'm looking at it here in front of me, and honestly the cumulative beta has obviously been increasing, but it's not, it's not dramatic. Deposit pricing, particularly in, you know, interest-bearing accounts has behaved extremely well. You know, even in December the beta is cumulatively under 25%. You know, we made some pricing adjustments late in the year and even the monthly beta is, you know, 50% and under. If you look at it for the quarter it's, you know, kind of 30 and under. I think we feel good about the stability of the deposit base and where the current rates are and what we've done to be responsive to it.
You know, I think we generally feel good about, you know, how we can generate enough funding to, you know, fund high single digit, you know, call it 8% organic loan growth in 2023 with contribution from commercial specialty and then business and consumer banking. You know, we're cautious about it, from a lag perspective. I think all the guidance we give has some caution above where it's currently performing. You know, if we're at, you know, high 20s cumulatively or mid-20s cumulatively, you know, we think of marginal beta moving forward as, you know, 40%. The reality is we haven't we've had that view since the third quarter, and we haven't seen it.
You know, I think we feel like we've got a really good sense of what the account types are used for, where we need to be responsive and, you know, where we just have good stable core funding that really doesn't have to move from a rate perspective.
Gotcha. No, that's-- that makes sense. And, and maybe just last one for me was on the, you know, just the funding of the loan growth this year given-- I mean, the liquidity levels is obviously come way down. Is it fair to just think about the balance sheet or just the funding loan growth is coming from the, you know, the deposit growth this year? Is that, you know, how you're looking at it?
Yeah.
There's a little bit more liquidity to come down, but that's how.
Yeah. We're thinking about we'll fund it through everything Keene just mentioned, all the various.
Yeah
... units and teams and specialties that we have. We feel confident.
Okay
... that we can do that.
Yeah. Gotcha. Okay. That's it. Thanks for taking the questions and a nice quarter, guys.
Yeah, thank you, Brian.
Your next question comes from the line of Michael Hultquist from Piper Sandler. Your line is open.
Hey, guys. Good morning. I'm on for Andrew.
Morning, Michael.
Good morning. Just wanted to follow up on the last question. Can you give some color surrounding kind of the leftover runoff of potential rate sensitive deposits on the balance sheet right now?
Scott, you wanna talk about that?
Yeah. You know, it's kind of what I've said in the commentary. You know, a majority of the decline is really a handful of larger commercial clients that are redeploying excess funds and into, you know, non-bank alternatives, T-bills, maybe what I'll call competitive specials. You know, we see that in certain markets. I, you know, I feel really good about how we are having conversations with our clients. You know, we know that handful of clients. We've also developed, you know, some products that we can use, and we're proactively approaching, you know, the clients that we know have those excess funds, and we've been able to really moderate that. We're also having really good conversations with other deposit prospects in the market as well, and I feel good about our pipeline of being able to bring in new deposits.
I think, you know, the results that I talked about in the quarter show that we've been successful there as well. Hopefully that helps.
Yeah, that's super helpful. My follow-up question you kind of just touched on with the outlook growth, but, you know, do you think it's reasonable to repeat, you know, specialty deposit growth this year compared to last year at that same pace?
Yeah. We think this. We think that those businesses for us are consistent providers. you know, we've added some new sales people there, so we feel good about its ability to contribute appropriately for the total funding growth for our company.
Great. That's super helpful. Thanks, guys.
Yeah, thank you.
Again, if you'd like to ask a question, press star then the number one on your telephone keypad. Next question comes from Jeff Rulis from D.A. Davidson. Your line is open.
Hi. Just to follow up. The non-accrual decline, any color on the loans that were either back on non-accrual or paid off? Just looking for some detail there. Thanks.
Hey, Jeff. It's Scott. I can take that one. It's really the majority was in two credits, not new. They've kind of been in our workout process most of the year or maybe even in the prior year. Really successful conclusions to both. One was an ag credit that we completed a charge-off and a workout on, and then, a C&I credit that we actually had a recovery on as well. That's probably the bulk of the reduction in non-accruals for the quarter.
Gotcha. Keene, did that juice the margin at all on that recovery? I mean, is that meaningful at all?
It was a relatively modest recovery. Sorry.
Yeah. Yeah, no. The recovery Jeff went through, the allowance, I think that's what Scott's referring to. That was, you know, part of the net, but it didn't meaningfully impact margin. I think, you know, margin and, you know, net interest income were fairly clean in the quarter. Nothing, nothing too consequential either way that you'd need to think about for, you know, 1Q or anything like that.
Great. Thanks, guys.
Thank you, Jeff.
There are no further questions at this time. I will now turn the call back over to Jim for closing remarks.
Colby, thank you, and thank you all for joining us today and for your interest in our company. We look forward to speaking to all of you again at the end of our first quarter. Take care and have a great day.
This concludes today's conference call. You may now disconnect.