Very pleased to have Infinity Natural Resources here, Cary Baetz, CFO, Tom Marchetti, VP of IR, are with us today. Cary, I want to start with, you joined the company this August. I want to see, you obviously had a lot of opportunities. You left a pretty good gig. What was it that attracted you to join Infinity?
Great question, thanks everybody for coming here today to listen to me. Hopefully, it will be a good 30 minutes of your time. I think the world of I've been a commodity guy most of my life, so I've done cement, agri, concrete, steel. I've done international services, domestic services. I've said I produced oil in foreign countries because I was in California for five years. I don't think I was looking for anything when it came up. Then started to kind of A search firm reached out to me. I met with Zack. I liked his energy, I liked the idea of growing.
The industry had turned into a manufacturer. 0%-2% growth, 10% free cash flow yield, wash, rinse, repeat. You got somebody who's young, they're energetic, they don't know what they don't know because they're young and they're energetic. They're not scarred yet enough by the industry. He has a group of people around him that are young and they're energetic, and it makes it fun. So you got somebody who wants to grow, somebody that knows they need help, and the ability to do it in a basin which they know extremely well was very attractive.
I think if you look across the basins, the Appalachian basins, outside of Toby, it's kind of a forgotten basin. EQT dominates it, and there's a couple of other small players around there. There's people miscellaneous, but nobody really focuses on it. Nobody's really growing it, and that was a lot of energy, which excited me.
I guess for folks that are new to the story, you mentioned the growth being a differentiator. Anything else that you see as a differentiation from theā
We're molecule indifference, hydrocarbon indifference. We actually have assets on the Utica side, we're in the Marcellus side, and I think the focus for us is where are we going to get the best return long term, and where do we have optionality? The other thing is we also have midstream operations, so we have about 1 Bcf/d of capacity at midstream. I think that allows us to be able to keep our costs down as low as possible, makes our assets a little more attractive, also gives us a little competitive advantage when we're looking at opportunities for growth, synergies that we can leverage on to be able to bring things down.
I think that's another differentiator versus many in that peer group, which seems to be either dry gas or Utica, period.
I guess digging in on the growth side a little bit, you've been doing it organically for the most part as a company to date since your IPO. How are you viewing that growth going forward?
It's hard to get scale with the drill bit alone. I think we're very good at the drill bit. We have the very attractive inventory. I think most people know we're bringing our deep dry gas Utica, our first well online this quarter, which is exciting. But the reality is for us to get scale, and scale's important because of all of you people, we need to make sure that we get in front of enough eyes, we keep enough float in the stock to be able to keep our valuation supported and do that reasonably. But the reality is M&A within that area needs to happen.
EQT has obviously been very aggressive in growth on through M&A. I think nobody else has really been pushing that very hard, and there's a lot of opportunities to really get some more scale in that area that needs to happen. It can't be a half a Bcf/d company in a public market. Doesn't work. You need to think about how you're going to get to 1.5 Bcf/d first, and then you need to think about how you're going to get to 2.5 Bcf/d, and then now you're going to get to 5 Bcf/d. And being able to do that with a good balance sheet where you're adding value and creating shareholder value will be the key.
There's a lot of people who grow, and I won't pick on people within different basins, and they've grown tremendously, but they haven't seen stock price grow. So how do you grow and create value for your shareholders? And I think that's the other thing that we have to work on.
I guess in terms of, obviously getting scale gets you on the radar of more investors. Anything else that you are looking to achieve with this group?
Cost advantage, synergies. You can bring infrastructure, so pads, midstream, more efficiency on rigs, less downtime, more efficiency on fracs, less downtime. The more uptime you are running, the more efficient you are going to be, the lower your costs are going to be. In the same way with midstream. We are not a midstream company, we are an E&P company, but the midstream is important from a cost advantage point of view. At some point in time, the midstream also gives you an opportunity to monetize, to some extent, to be able to be capital raised that way as well.
I do not think we would ever want to sell all of it because it is a cost advantage, but you could always find a partner who could add some capital to allow you to grow your E&P business as well.
It sounds like M&A is certainly part of the plan. How do you see the deal flow right now in Appalachia?
There are deals. I think there is a bid-ask spread right now. I think 2027 is a fairly clunky year when it looks at gas prices right now. I think if you go back and look at the elections and now what does it mean for power demand? Is that power demand now going to be delayed to some extent? What is that going to mean to gas prices? The reality is we are going to see power demand. We are going to see gas prices, gas firming up. The question is timing around, and I think getting people balanced around that and how you get transactions across the board that still give that seller optionality is the way we are looking at things.
There will be things that come out of competitive bid process. We will look at everything, but the reality is we are building an organization where we can be proactive, trying to get into deals before they hit the market. I think that is where we have the greatest advantage, so we can leverage our synergies to be able to get the best price for the seller, and maybe there is a little carry that they have to be able to ride the upside in the marketplace as well. We will look at that as well.
You mentioned at the top, you are molecule indifferent. I guess, what does that dual oil and gas strategy do for you?
I think it gives us the opportunity to seize the moment, right? We can move quickly from, and we pivoted this year. We started out thinking that 2026 was going to be a gassier year than an oilier year, and then somebody made oil very attractive. We pivoted fairly quickly, and moved to oil. Obviously, you capture that oil in the first 12 months in a pretty good return. So that allowed us to be able to flex fairly quickly, and I think we can do that time and time again. We are small and nimble enough, we have enough inventory, and we have enough available inventory that we can move, and create more value.
The question is when do we get paid for that? But that is a different day. Yeah.
You talked a little bit about the midstream. Most E&P companies do not have that integrated model. I guess, can you just talk about some of the advantages there that that provides, and in particular, what it does for your cost structure?
There are several. There are a few things. One is, we are not committed to any one midstream provider with volume, so we have the ability to manage our volumes better, if ever needed. It is our line, it is our cost structure, it is our GP&T, so it allows us to be able to minimize that. Also, we are a little unique in that we have opportunity on REX, which flows west, which is out of basin, which right now gives us a substantial differential improvement versus in-basin. Shoulder seasons for the Appalachian Basin can be fairly ugly, and they have the ability to offshoot a large amount of our production to the west.
We are seeing a substantial improvement in basis. If you look at just on the basis difference between REX and M2, you are looking 60 odd basis, $0.60 differential. If you add cost on top of that transportation cost, we are probably picking up somewhere about $0.25 more per Mcfe, which is substantial in a $2 gas market. I think it gives us also opportunities to outload, and that is roughly 300,000 a day that we can move that direction. On top of it, if you think about future transactions, now you have a midstream that you can leverage to be able to keep that cost down to give you a little competitive advantage in a bidding process as well.
Fifthly, sixthly, whatever I have said, it also gives you the ability, as I said, to monetize to some extent in the future, to give you optionality from financing source. So, you ever get that large enough, today we are running about 35% utilization. That will continue to grow quarter-over-quarter, year-over-year. At some point in time, that makes it an attractive opportunity for somebody who is in the midstream business, and at that point in time, maybe you are able to monetize a portion of it to be able to continue either manage your balance sheet or fund future E&P growth as well.
You mentioned that utilization, you are going to increase that. I guess, how much of your midstream are you utilizing right now, or how much of your gas flows through yourā
Basically, all of our gas flows through our midstream. Roughly most of our midstream is our utilization. There's a little third party of it, non-op partners and all that, their gas is going through there. But the reality is most of it's ours, and as we grow our production, we'll continue to see that flow. We are looking for opportunities for third party, but let's be honest, most producers don't want to give other producers additional revenue, but looking for people to help us partner with that as well to improve the third party.
But from an overall point of view, we'll see that utilization creep up into the 50s to 60% over the next 12- 18 months, and it's a fairly attractive midstream system at that point in time.
You guys drilled your first deep Utica well this year. You're expected to turn that online, or maybe you already have, in the fourth quarter here. I guess, what does that mean for your inventory, or what do you see as your inventory there, and what impact could that have on your NAV?
I think I'll let Enverus speak for us this time. I usually don't let them speak for us, but they did come out with a report last week, or a couple weeks ago, and they said successful deep dry gas Utica, they see a $4 increase in our NAV. So, it's meaningful. It adds another, this one plus the other 65 locations, so it's a fairly attractive inventory. It's an attractive opportunity. As we get better on that, we'll see our CapEx come down. We'll see returns even growing more. I think the idea for us is how do we manage the gas production out of there?
How do we choke it to make sure that we're not blowing it out day one and seeing a steep decline? Those are things that I think people in deep dry gas Utica will be managing with, because it's fairly high production opportunities, and how do you manage that gas to stream it out over the long period of time to get the greatest return? But overall, I think it's a very attractive opportunity. It's obviously a very accretive opportunity and adds some really nice inventory and NAV value.
Do you think it will be part of your 2027 plan, or do you need to see this first well before you make any decisions?
We will see the first well. I think it will be a second half of 2027 plan. Again, if you look at the gas markets right now, I do not think it needs a whole lot of additional gas.
Yeah.
I think it would definitely be a second half 2027 plan, and then obviously going into 2028 and 2029, it will be a regular part of our plan.
You guys obviously, with this first well, probably cost was not probably the most important thing with this. I would imagine you are doing a lot of testing andā
It's not an inexpensive well.
Right.
Yeah.
But I guess where do you see that opportunity on the cost side? Because it seems like that was one of the big breakthroughs for CNX has been a leader in it. EQT seemed like they're starting to figure out how to drill in particular.
Yeah, I think the same way. It's going to be lessons learned. It's going to be scar tissue. How are you doing things better? What did you learn out of this one? From a drilling point of view, from a completions point of view, from an overall pad point of view, you obviously have all your infrastructure coming in day one, so how do you spread that out? How are you able to do that? I think we'll all get better. We're not to CNX territory yet on the CapEx side on a per-foot basis, but our aspirations is to get lower than that, and we're working hard to be able to figure that out.
Sounds good. You had some news today on changing your structure. Elaborate on that press release?
Yeah. The Up-C structure was It caused confusion in the marketplace because you had the original owners had units, then you had your Class A shares out there. Now everything's going to be a Class A. You get rid of any TRA provisions and liabilities going forward. I think it just makes it a very clean capital structure now. Simple. We have RBL, we have high yield, we have a preferred. But as you think about when you're looking, even people just have no idea what our enterprise value is because people look at some sites and it shows our market cap at $200 million.
Now at least we have consistency of information across the board, and everybody's on the same page, and everybody's treated the exact same way. So simplification, I'm a big believer. I tell everybody I'm public educated, so it has to be simple. From my point of view, the simpler we can make a small company from a capital structure point of view, from a structure point of view, it works better for investors. The more complex you are, I did work at Chesapeake for a while. If anybody ever remembers those capital structures, some of y'all are way too young, it's hard to tell a story to see where the value capture is. So simplifying helps you see better visibility value capture.
As you look forward, I guess, how do you see adding, or what do you think's going to add the most value for Infinity going forward?
There's several ways to answer that question. The biggest hangover we have right now is we're Zack has built a very good team. They have executed quarter after quarter, and we have yet to be paid on that execution. We're either growing too fast and not getting paid for that, burning through inventory. I think from my point of view, the biggest issue we have is we don't have enough available float in the marketplace for somebody to be an efficient buyer and seller in the stock. We've got to figure out how to improve our float in order for people to be able to buy into the story, knowing at some point in time they can exit.
Right now, I think we're fairly range-bound on price. It doesn't matter how we execute in the field if people can't buy the stock. When we look at getting back to the transaction side, any transaction we look at, we're looking at what's the ability to issue some level of primary to get that done, because I said this, we had an analyst field day, what, about a month ago?
Right.
I did say, I look at the loop to a creek. The reality is I need more available shares in the marketplace for this company to be able to transact in a public marketplace to be able to get the value that it deserves. I think that's where our biggest value creation is figuring out how to improve our overall float. We have some large holders. You'll even see this even after the Up-C, our top 10 holders are going to control 90% of our shares. A lot of those are very sticky holders over a long period of time, so there's not enough turn.
I think we have one holder within that was original that I think will find their way out in 2027. It sure won't be Pearl. We need more shares available. We trade roughly 4 million shares a day, $4 million in shares a day. It's not efficient enough. We need to get that up. Doing that with really good growth opportunities, leveraging our infrastructure, leveraging our midstream, being able to do some primary issuance, I think also we start seeing value start to creep up.
What do you think is the most underappreciated part of the story, or misunderstood, or both?
I do not know if anything is misunderstood. I think there is not a lot of eyes on it for the same reasons we just talked about. I think we are small, and that keeps people, some eyeballs off of it as well. I think the reality is from our point of view, I do not know what that answer is. I know if we just keep executing, we keep delivering, we are able to fix the float issue, we get some scale, I think it is a very attractive investment. Again, I think misunderstood, we get no value for our midstream today. None whatsoever.
Replacement value, I think in one of our decks is $1.3 billion. Replacement value for an asset we get zero for. I think if you put all the pieces together, it is a really attractive investment. It just needs to have a little ump and a little energy behind it, some more scale behind it.
I guess that is where, if you were to sell off a piece of that, put a marker out there that could help.
Yeah. I think the other thing is, and this is on us, where is transparency? I do not think we Because most of the midstream we use ourselves, it is hard to how you segregate that. We are giving people utilization now on a quarterly basis. What is the uplift that we are receiving from the midstream so people get an idea of the value of the midstream. I think the other thing we may look at is how we segment the difference between Pennsylvania and Ohio, and let people be able to see, because we have another thing going on. If you think of us as a gas producer, we have higher cost, right?
Our costs are higher because we have a lot of liquid side of the equation. If you think of us as a liquid producer, we are low because we have a large gas production. I think if we kind of separate that and get people to look at the LOE and the GP&T for each one of these businesses standalone on each region, I think that will add a little more clarity to the business as well and stream out. We may be looking at segmentation differently as we go forward to improve transparency as well.
You put some third-party volumes through those midstream assets as well. Is that something you might consider?
We would. Yeah. That is another thing. If you monetize part of that midstream, whoever you monetize for, probably in the midstream business, that would help your third party probably pick up as well.
Right. Any questions from the audience?
What do you think the timing is around being able to get the liquidity in the stock up? What level do you think you would need to get to attract that level of investor you are talking about?
I will let really smart people answer. I will answer. You probably need, they say dollar value, $10 million-$15 million flow today. You can backwards math it. That still probably says we need to have, today, 90% of our shares are held by 10. We probably need somewhere 30%-40% of our shares floating on a daily basis. I have not worked that math. It is a fairly large. I think there are meaningful opportunities that are going to hit the market in 2027. The question is, how do we finance them properly?
If you get another Antero size of transaction, you could probably get to something like that. If you do a series of smaller ones as well, you could probably get there. We will be very focused on that. I mean, the idea is, I'm not really excited about issuing shares at 13 bucks today, I'm just going to tell you. You get a mid-teens to 15, 16, 17 range, I'm willing to take that hit on the way down to bring things up. There's lands opportunities we're going to look at. There's all kinds of things we can look at to go out to do the primary side of the equation.
I think 2027, a little wind behind the sails, I think we'll work hard at it. But it's probably going to be a 12- 18-month period to finally get where we need to get to be fair.
What's the point as you look at the basin and you look at the gas supply dynamics that some of your peers start to talk about, of real potential tightening and inflection in pricing when you look at kind of 2028?
I think everybody thought it was going to be second half of 2027, right? Again, nobody knows. What's data centers when And again, I'm a firm believer, I don't care what your politics are, eventually data centers will be showing up because whatever political party you are, eventually you want revenue, you want to have wins, and the data centers are going to be wins. So power will be constricted. Is that move now to mid-2028? I don't know. The reality is if you give me $3.50 gas in perpetuity, I'll be fairly happy. We'll make a lot of money.
You give anybody $4 gas, we'll be really, really happy, right? I don't know. I mean, again, you look at forward curves, demand's going to be coming, but it's always going to be coming, right? We just don't know when. The famous gas. Gas is always going to be eventually going to be good. It is officially going to be good. Probably when oil turns bad.
Does that create this like window where you know you need to transact beforeā
That is why youā
Oil shows up and then all of a sudden the multiples are gone and like everybody wants too much?
That is right. I think that is the reason you work at the forward end. If you have buyers, especially private buyers who want to ride it up, then also give them additional equity to be able to ride it up as well. I am trying to do, again, I am trying to improve the float, but at some point in time, you are going to have to let them carry some of it as well. If you can improve float as well, but you are exactly right. You would rather do it in 2027 because 2028 is going to start moving up and 2029 will get really expensive.
The reality is nobody has been outside of Toby Rice, nobody has been a great consolidator in that base. I do not know why. I have not been around it enough, but Chesapeake was first there and then Expand. They kind of moved on to the Haynesville and lost focus there. You've got smaller, EOG has obviously a large presence up there, but not been big on the consolidation side. You've got EQT that's doing it, and then you've got a whole bunch of half a billion to billion dollar competitors up there that just kind of like their deal.
Eventually you need more consolidation. Gulfport would be somebody else I would think that would be a consolidator up there as well. They have new change in management there. Everybody I think probably knows Nick from that point of view. I'm sure they're going to be fairly looking at the same things that we are. We need two or three really good large producers in there. It's a nice market as well because I think the takeaway is a lot better than most people think. There's a lot of opportunities for takeaway, both from a gas and a oil point of view.
Even outside of REX, I think in basin it eventually becomes fairly attractive over time. Then that REX contract probably doesn't as valuable. That's not a bad thing. I think overall, I like the dynamics, and getting back to why I like the story, I like the dynamics of that Appalachian market. Everybody looks at gas as a national commodity. It's not. It's a very regionalized commodity. The infrastructure around it really keeps it, and I think the dynamics, if you look at where the dynamics from Ohio to Pennsylvania and the growth in that area, makes it long-term fairly attractive.
You mentioned the deal flow looks good going forward, and you're commodity agnostic. Are you agnostic between upstream and midstream assets?
We're an E&P company. We use the midstream from a cost advantage point of view. I think it is. The one thing I'm not agnostic about, you still have to Any transaction we have, you need to make sure you have inventory along with that transaction as well.
Okay.
I think that's every basin that anybody competes in these days. Inventory, inventory, and making sure that you have a nice supply of inventory and good inventory. That's the other thing that we'll look at. There's going to be I think the ground game on that is fairly There's still opportunities on the ground game on the inventory side, and we'll be exploring that.
Is that more on the Ohio side, or do you see the ground game opportunities in Pennsylvania?
There are some opportunities in parts of Pennsylvania. There's opportunities It's a little riskier, but there's opportunities in West Virginia. There's still opportunities in various sections of Ohio. There's also opportunities for trades to improve each side of the businesses as well. I think looking at trades to be more opportunistic about getting full units and all that is going to be something that I think several of us will be looking at as well. It's fun. There's a lot going on. It's what makes this industry fun. If you ignore headlinesā
Right.
There's a lot of things to do.
As you think about growth and production, the industry's gone to, I think you were earlier calling it basically flat.
Boring.
How do you see that production growth profile over time? Why do you think a growth approach is the right way to go? Maybe just talk about.
Yeah, I think from our point of view, we want scale, right? We think there needs to be. The opportunity for us to get scale right now is leveraging our inventory. At some point in time, as you get bigger, growth will slow. But the reality is, from my point of view, it's always been a speculator's game, right? It's wildcatters. That's what made it fun. We've turned it into just financial re-engineering, what makes it fairly simplistic. But where's the energy in it? Where are you finding? Where's the person really stepping out to find something new and the next alternatives, and where's the next play and all that stuff?
You've always kind of had to have that little bit of curiosity. One of the things I like about Zack is, spending time with Aubrey, he's different than Aubrey, but he's not. There's not anything that Zack won't look at in basin. We look at every opportunity. That's fun. But I think eventually, from a growth point of view, we've got to get to a point where we have ample amount of shares available in the marketplace for it to trade freely, that trades upon our results and our outlook. I don't know what size that is, but eventually, at some point in time, you can't go way outside the market norm.
But I still think if you look at long-term fundamentals, you're going to need growth. 0% is not going to continue to work for a long period of time if power demand's going to go up where people believe, or even parts of it. If you don't have that DNA, how do you rediscover that DNA? Having somebody out there that has that DNA of understanding growth and how to grow and thinking about growth, I think will be a competitive advantage down the line. You may not need to grow 30% or 50% a year, but you may need to be growing low double digits, things like that.
I think that's a DNA that we'll have in our system and something that we can leverage on over a period of time. But the reality is, what creates the greatest value? Is it over time, longer term, is it going to be going and being like everybody else and returning capital back to the shareholder and let them decide what to do with the capital? Or do you get greater value and continue to let that drill bit run a little more? If you have cost, you're able to control your cost, you're able to leverage your midstream, your greatest return is going to be continuing to grow some.
I guess that was one that we didn't hit was cost. There's starting to be some signs of inflation. How are you combating that?
There's more than signs.
There's starting to be some real inflation. Certainly diesel and steel, I think. It sounds like some places, rigs, completion crews are getting tighter, chemicals, other things. I guess, what do you see as maybe the inflation for next year and how are you combating that?
I think from our point of view, we think inflation will be up, but we think we'll offset with efficiencies. So we're hoping to keep things fairly neutral from an overall CapEx point of view. But you're right, diesel's expensive. Diesel touches everything. Steel's going up as well. I think the world, coming from a guy who was a service guy, service providers are small, they're not as many, and they've moved rigs around, and there's not as much available services, especially in Appalachia.
So you always have to think about what you want to do and how's that going to impact your ability to pick up a rig somewhere down the line and all that as well. So staying very close. One of the things, we've had a very good relationship with both our drilling and frac provider. I don't see that changing. But I think it's one of the things that we worry about. But it's also the competitive advantage of having infrastructure you can lift it off, step out, changing how you're doing your laterals, U-turns, all of those things will continue to add value to be able to offset a lot of that cost inflation.
Hopefully we'll see diesel. Well, I don't know. You talk out both sides of your book, right? If oil stays high, that's a pretty good day with diesel. But we saw diesel starting to come down a little bit. We'll see what happens overall. But you can see, you may have a high diesel price exiting this year and a much lower diesel price exiting next year. So I'm much more worried probably on the steel side of the equation because that does impact everything that we do as well from a CapEx point of view. I don't see that changing for a period of time, at least two years.
I think we'll leave it there.
Thank y'all. Appreciate it. Everybody, I've already said this to everybody, have a great Thanksgiving. Appreciate your time, and if y'all have any questions, always feel free to reach out. Tom loves answering every question. Thank you.
Thanks, Cary.
Appreciate it. Thank you. Thanks for having us.
Absolutely.