âmight as well. All right. Good morning, everybody. Welcome to the RBC TIMT Conference. I'm Brad Erickson. I cover internet here at RBC. Very nice to see everybody. Fresh faces. Very pleased today to be joined by Zillow COO, Jeremy Hofmann. Niceâ
Thanks for having me.
Nice to see you. We're both out in the Northwest, so we flew to New York to have a chat for 30 minutes, which is nice. So, we were just joking, you guys have been public for not quite a couple of decades now, so normally we might do the like, "Hey, catch us up on the story lately," but I'm not going to do that. We're just going to jump in. We're jumping right in.
That's all right.
If that's all right.
Yeah.
So, all right. You guys are going through a model transition, right? Pretty big one. You used to do a prepaid ad product, now you're moving to more of like a transaction-oriented program. You call it the Preferred. You're kind of getting to three-quarters of the leads on Preferred, I think, by the end of this year, and then towards 100% next year, right? Hopefully we can contextualize, but there's a revenue hit, as often happens with revenue, with model transitions like that. As we get to next year, help us with the growth rates of what's normal, what you guys should be doing versus the market, and just sort of how to think about that.
Yeah.
Because lately, there's been a big offset, and we recognize it's because of this model transition, but as we get to 100%, what happens?
Yeah. You're right. We're going through a transition where, historically, the business was in a prepaid advertising model. It's moving to a transaction-based success fee. Basically, when we deliver a connection to a real estate agent, when that real estate agent closes the transaction, a customer has moved, the real estate agent has successfully transacted, and we get paid out of that success fee, or a piece of the commission. That is the transition that we're going through. There is a headwind associated with it, as we go through the model transition. We should be through the model transition by first half of next year, and then that headwind starts to dissipate.
Going forward, our expectation is actually much of the same from what we've done the last three or four years, which is meaningfully outperform the housing market. We'll do that through a combination of more revenue, more revenue per transaction, so more conversion, and adding more services like mortgage. Then we couple that with adding more software and listings marketing to the Preferred program as well. When you put all those things together, we end up in a position where revenue per connection is pretty meaningfully outperforming the old model.
Yeah.
In 2025, the new model effectively outperformed by 23%.
In 2026, it'll outperform by, we think, about 35%.
Yeah.
Our expectation is we're going to continue to outperform the market. We like the model because it aligns our incentives with the consumer's incentives, which is to moveâ
Yeah.
âand the agent's incentive, which is to close transactions.
Yeah. On that 23% and 35%, can you just explain, like, why is that accretion happening? Like, you mentioned the parts and pieces, butâ
Yeah.
âlike, give us a little bit more on the mechanics of, like, what actually drives that upside.
Yeah. So it's higher conversion. So our Preferred agents are converting at higher levels. That is one way that you get accretion. The second way is through more Zillow Home Loans transactions. So in a Home Loans transaction, we make anywhere from $10,000 to $12,000 in revenue per transaction.
That is accretive as well. Then we've been able to sell more of our software, primarily Follow Up Boss, into the Preferred channel than other, more than we were able to in the prepaid model.
Yeah.
More of our Listing Showcase product as well.
Got it. Okay. Then remind us too, like, when you give an agent a Preferred lead, maybe a tour, for example, or maybe on a mortgage or whatever, again, like, relative to that model transition, can you just remind us sort of, like, what close cycles look like on that?
Yeah. So typical, not every consumer is the same, so the time in which it takes them to move is obviously individual per person, but on average, it takes four to six months.
Okay.
Yeah.
Okay. All right.
From the lead delivery to actually closing the transaction.
Yeah. Is that on the core product, on the core lead? Is mortgage any different?
It's about the same.
It is?
Yeah.
Okay.
It tracks what a buyer's typical timeframe is.
Got it. Okay. We do a lot of channel checks. Respectfully, we call a lot of agents that work with you. Sorry about that. One of the things we've heard, I think we've written the word in our last maybe, like, three or four rounds of channel checks is friction.
Yeah.
Right? It's clearly a difficult environment given the rates and everything.
Yeah.
And you guys are sort of pushing this model transition. So what are the challenges you're finding as you move agents from an MBP world to Preferred, and how are you kind of getting over some of those challenges?
Yeah. The question here, much of our Preferred agent base was previously folks that paid us in market-based pricing, the ad-based model. So what's happening is we say to the set of agents in a particular city, "Hey, we're moving from market-based pricing to Preferred. Would you like to join us?"
Yeah.
And vast majority of those folks say yes, but it is a change in what they have to do and the way they have to operate. What we've seen is actually the acceptance rate we've seen actually go up from market-based pricing to Preferred during this period of time, and I think there's probably two reasons for that. One, I think it's just clear to people what's happening, right? Previously, we were really managing the two models kind of in concert.
Yeah.
And I think that was a little bit less clear for agents as to what they were going to be able to receive. So there's clarity that comes from it, and then also in a challenging macro environment, we end up being a pretty important lead source for them.
Okay.
They're, I think, even more willing to actually come along with us on the ride.
In some of our work, we've actually heard that maybe the environment is making it harder in the transition, just because they're already just reeling from the environment and trying to keep their business stable or hopefully growing, and then adding in a new variable of learning new process. Is there an argument to be made that on the other side of whatever this is, maybe there's an elastic benefit to you guys there versus maybe some of the friction we've been hearing currently?
We haven't felt much friction in terms of people coming along. I think there's friction in, "Hey, it's going to change in process."
Yeah.
That may be what you're hearing.
Yeah.
But in terms of people saying, "Yes, I want to be part of the program."
Yeah.
We're seeing those rates very healthy.
Okay.
I think when we get past this transition, which will happen in the first half of next year, the interesting part becomes you're really just managing a network of real estate agents.
Yeah.
And you're looking to allocate the connections to the highest converting people that treat our customers the best.
Yeah.
That becomes very exciting to us.
Yeah.
That's been the thesis the entire time, and getting to 100%, we get excited about, okay, now we can really just operate here rather than managing these two models.
Yeah. Got it. One last one, just on the accretion. The 35% is kind of like an intermediate term goal. Is that fair, or have you seen evidence in markets that maybe we could go past that at some point?
I think it's more than anything we think about it as, do we think the business model is a better one going forward?
Yeah.
How do we make sure we feel confident that is the case?
Yeah.
We see that in the revenue per connection numbers.
Got it.
I wouldn't necessarily put those as like, "Oh, that's how every market performs," or anything like that.
Yeah.
It's more, do we feel like it's the right model from an alignment perspective, from a customer satisfaction perspective, and then can we make more money doing it long term?
Got it. Okay. Let's flip to the quarter. It was a little bit of a challenging print, we'll call it. Walk us through what happened. Let's start with for sale and mortgage in particular, just what drove kind of the miss, and then obviously the lower guidance there.
Macro was pretty challenging.
Yeah.
To say the least. Interest rates spiked about 100 basis points in the quarter. Our core consumer on the for sale part of our business tends to be median income, first-time home buyer. When interest rates go from 6.5% to 7.5% over the course of a month or two, that buyer is less interested in buying a home.
Yeah.
You saw that happen both in their agent business and in the mortgage business, where basically the pipelines for transactions in both of those businessesâ
Yeah.
âfell out, and that was the impact on Q3 that you saw, then the impact in Q4 as well.
Got it. Maybe just, can you give a little bit more on the numbers of you guys relative to the market? Because I think that's what people are always sort of trying to figure out of likeâ
Yeah.
âwhen you're ahead or behind or whatever.
Yeah. Through all that, total company grew 7% in Q3, and the mortgage market, which is the one that's probably most analogous to our customer base, was down 4%. So we outperformed by 1,100 basis points through that period of time, which I think is a testament to our ability to take share, and then also it is recognizing that 40% of the revenue base now is rentals and software.
Yeah.
It is not, those parts of the business are less sensitive to-
Yeah. I guess I was more asking on the for sale kind of part of the business or whatever.
Yeah. I mean, for sale outperformed as well. I cannot remember exactly what it grew, but I think it was probably 200 basis, or sorry, grew 2% when we net out all the different moving pieces and Preferred. So outperformed, I call it, 600 basis points.
Yeah. Then, just flow it through, obviously, there's a pretty high contribution margin in the business, just in terms of the EBITDA, the results, and the guide there.
Yeah.
What's kind of going on there, if you can help us?
Yeah. There, we ended up in Q3 being inside the range despite a pretty meaningful drop in revenue, which was due to cost controls that we were able to implement throughout the course of the quarter and going into it. But obviously, there's impact to EBITDA because the flow-through kind of works both ways.
Yeah.
When revenue is good, we get high incremental margins, and when revenue comes in lighter on the back of macro, it can'tâ
Yeah. Got it. Okay. Then let's talk about mortgage just for a second. Obviously, I think you guys explained it on the call, right? You have a kind of a finance first option. Somebody goes to the site, expresses interest, and that kind of fills up a pipeline that then comes through, and you mentioned the four to six-month kind of close cycles. That slowed down a lot, so pipelines get sort of decimated for the moment. I guess two questions on that. One, you've been hiring a ton of loan officers for a while, right?
That business has been growing a lot.
Yeah.
How do you feel in terms of the pace of hiring, continuing to add capacity there, given the pipeline fall-off? And second, just how quickly can those pipelines fill back up?
Yeah. It'll take time to fill back up, and we have seen that happen. We haven't lived through a rate spike like we did in Q3, but we've had times where rates have gyrated.
Yeah.
That occurs as part of the business. But overarchingly, the opportunity in mortgage is far bigger than quarterly fluctuations. We have basically been staffing up with our eyes on being one of the biggest purchase lenders in the country. We went from 2022, we were effectively at a standing start. We've 10xed mortgage volume since then. We're now a top 20 to top 25 lender in the country. And the opportunity for us to grow is pretty substantial because our ability to find customers early. Customers come to Zillow pretty early in their journey.
Yeah.
That gives us a real advantage, and then we have a great distribution network with ourâ
Yeah.
âpreferred network. As we get to 100% of share of voice in the Preferred network.
Yeah.
We feel really good about the ability to grow mortgage. Even in Q4, for example, where mortgage market we think is going to be down 10%-15%, that Preferred channel we expect to grow in the mid-20sâ
Okay.
âdespite all that.
Yeah.
It will take some time for pipeline to rebuild, but in terms of growth path for the mortgage businessâ
Yeah.
âthere's a lot of opportunity for us. It's highly fragmented.
Yeah.
We feel like we have a real right to win to be one of the biggest purchase lenders in the country, so we're trying to have our eyes on that rather thanâ
Okay.
âreally functioning on quarterly gyrations. Yeah.
No, understood. Is it fair to assume that, I would imagine the rate of growth is going to slow a little bit just because of the market and everything, and then bigger numbers? But is it fair to assume that your loan officer growth, like your hiring growth, will continue at a relatively steady rate?
Yeah, I think you'll see it follow loan volume, and I think that is ultimately a good thing. That means the business is continuing to growâ
Yeah.
ânicely. Where we've done well and we've been able to get the mortgage business profitable has been we've been scaling on a fixed cost base that hasn't really grown.
Yeah.
That's what we continue toâ
Okay.
âplan to do.
Okay.
Loan officer volume will continue to go up, but that will be on the back of revenue growth.
Yeah. Got it. All right. As we think about 2027, just the simple question is, how should we think about it? I realize the business is clearly rate sensitive. Nobody knows what's going to happen there right now, but just as you see early sketches of 2027, how do you think investors, or how do you want investors thinking about things top and bottom line, if you can help us?
Continue to believe we will outperform like we have the last coming on four years. We've had pretty meaningful outperformance at the total company level, at the for-sale level, at the residential level.
You pick the line. We expect to continue to outperform. We'll control costs along the way. Our cost structure philosophy has been pretty consistent, which is keep fixed headcount effectively flat, fight inflation in the cost structure for fixed headcount, dial up and down variable and marketing depending on the opportunities we see.
Yeah.
That allows us to have a pretty good formula for margin expansion. That playbook on both the revenue front and the cost front isn't going to change in 2027. Then the big question will be, what does macro do?
If you believe we're going to continue to outperform at the levels we do, you should feel good about revenue growth, but it is all dependent onâ
Got it.
âwhat that outperformance is versus macro.
Is it fair to say the baseline assumption should be is that nothing changes at this point?
From a macro perspective?
Yeah.
Our perspective is we're planning as if macro is going to stay where it's been.
Got it.
Yeah.
Okay. You broke out a new, I guess, or gave us a little bit of new insight into the business on seller revenues this quarter. I think it was $300 million. I guess two questions on that. Why give us that at this point? Then separately, what are the parts and pieces of that revenue?
Yeah.
You can go into it.
Yeah, we thought it was important to just call out, if you think about the strategy evolution we've been on for the last, call it, five or so years, it's really been from being known for dreaming and shopping to being known for buying, selling, renting, and financing. We haven't talked rentals yet, but I'm sure we will at some point. We've talked some on mortgage and on buy side, but the fourth verb there is sell, and we've done a really nice job growing that. I think we wanted to shine a light on it. That's with our Preferred partners who are getting more and more sell-side transactions coming as a result of Zillow, and then our Showcase revenue as well, and the adoption there has been really nice as well.
Yeah.
The combination of both of those we wanted to call out. We also are seeing more and more opportunities for us to help more sellers as Zillow becomes more agentic as well.
Just the quality of conversations we're having and the number of conversations we're having that we previously would never really have the opportunity to have with a sellerâ
Yeah.
âis happening in AI mode and in our agentic experience, and that gives us the excitement to expandâ
Yeah.
âfurther because we just think we can help more people.
On those components within the seller revenue, can you give us a sense of maybe the growth rate levels that we're talking about? As well as, I don't know, historically you've given us some nice kind of telemetry around market penetration. Zillow Showcase, for example.
Yeah.
I think it was something like up to 10% or 15% in any given market or whatever. Any help you can give us with those parts and pieces as well as how fast the overall it's growing.
Yeah. The best thing I'd point you to on Showcase is market penetration at this point, and there we're north of 5% of all new listings, and there are some markets that are up in that 10%, 15% range.
Got it. Okay. Rentals, you mentioned it. Let's go there. I guess just in the last two years, you've probably more than, I don't know, doubled your multifamily. You've done the deal with Redfin, obviously, so that business has just grown dramatically over the last few years. I think there was a perception for a while. You were bringing on a lot of new multifamily customers, certainly you did right after the Redfin deal, but then consistently since. You bring them on, they start with a base level package. They get the leads and they start to see the value, and then they can build their mosaic of, "Okay, what's our return on investment?"
Where are you I've always looked at it as you're in some sort of an upgrade path, right, with each of these customers. As you think about the opportunity, and that business has been growing 20%, 30%, higher than that consistently, where are you in that upgrade path? And walk us through what's sort of remaining as you think about upgrading more of those customers, where I think it was at this conference last year, we had somebody from the channel who mentioned that you guys were providing an enormously higher ROI than maybe some of your largest competitors. Where are you guys in that runway for basically monetizing those customers better?
Yes. I mean, still pretty early days. And maybe for those of you that may not be as close to the rentals business, the strategy we're going after is different than anybody else in the category because we are effectively trying to be the one place for all rental supply. So whether you're a single family home for rent or an apartment building or anything in between, we want to be the one organizing place where a renter can come and see all the inventory. That has given us a pretty substantial traffic advantage, and it's allowed us to go into multifamily apartment buildings and be able to say, "Our traffic is very substantial. Our lead quality is high. The quantity of leads is very high, and we do it at best-in-class ROI."
That has been the story, and I'm not going to get the numbers exactly right, but we were probably 25,000 buildings and apartments three, four years ago. We're over 80,000 now.
Yeah.
Revenue for the segment was maybe $250 million three, four years ago, and it's going to be over $800 million this year.
Yeah.
Starting to see a path to that billion-dollar intermediate target.
Yeah.
I do think the expansion has been really, really strong, and it makes up 30% of the revenue base today. It has been a great story for us. At the same time, that is still not yet 10% of the spend in the category. We think $10 billion of multifamily spend happens every year, and there's some with us, there are some with folks that look like us as well, and then a lot on Google directly.
Our goal and our path from here is really, can we continue to be the best ROI sourceâ
Yeah.
âfor these property management companies and take wallet share from everyone that they advertise with?
Got it. Okay. When you bring just, if it can be helpful, because I do get this question a fair bit.
Yeah.
When you get a multifamily customer onto the platform and then, kind of like I described earlier.
Yeah.
They start to see the value and renewals come up, they spend more. Are they spending 2x more, 50% more? Any sort of help on dimensionalizing that?
Yeah, there's no perfect answer on what is the land and expand path.
Yeah.
It is a land and expand.
Yeah.
A land and expand happens in two different ways. One is they start on a lower tier package.
Yeah.
To test out, and also many of these property management companies are in more than one geography. So they try with one geography. If it works well, they expand into more geographies as well.
Yeah. Okay.
It is the combo of both of those, and I would think about it as how much of the overall spend are we gettingâ
Yep. Yeah.
âvis-a-vis the entire category, and that still feels pretty early.
Yeah. Got it. Okay. Let's have the AI agentic.
What is that?
Conversation. First time we have mentioned it today.
Yeah. Okay.
I waited like 20 minutes.
I know.
So, I mean, the simple question, this comes up, you guys field this, I field this a lot on our side. Like, listings are a commodity, right?
Yes, the MLS controls the data technically, but we all know it's out there. A lot of people get access to it. Why, as agentic tools grow in capability, whether vertical-specific or some of these new horizontal tools, why is that not a problem for Zillow?
Listings have been a commodity the entire time we've existed. We've been able to build the brand and the direct audience that we have on a commoditized set of listings. 80% of our traffic is direct today. That has been in an environment for 20 years where listings have been freely available any which way. You and I could start a site tomorrow to come compete with Zillow. I think time and again, when we've seen folks come in and spend a lot of money trying to dethrone us, we've tended to do pretty well because we are providing a really good and free service to people.
Yeah.
It's hard to displace a really good and free service.
Yeah.
When I think about the longer-term future state of what are the jobs that are being done by these horizontal agentic experiences, I think of the jobs to be done as things to make your life easier. Look over my subscriptions, book that restaurant, you pick the thing that is on your to-do list that you would prefer a robot to do. That's awesome. That's like great service for people, myself included. Dreaming and shopping for a home is not that. People want to be exhaustive. People want to spend time. People want to dream. People want to visualize what the backyard looks like, where their kids are going to sleep, where their kids are going to go to school, what the natural light looks like, all the things that you can think about when you're going through an apartment shopping experience or a home shopping experience.
We do that really well.
Yeah.
We've done it really well for a long time. There's a reason the brand is as strong as it is. There's a reason the engagement is as strong as it is. When I think about the dream and shop portion, I feel like we are very well insulated, so long as we continue to do our job.
Yeah.
We have to continue to provide the best service out there, but we've done that time and again throughâ
Yeah.
âmany cycles and many perceived competitive threats. I feel very good there.
I think the thing that we have to be really aggressive on and really thoughtful on is ensuring that the Zillow agentic experience comes along and is better than anything else you can find as well.
Like that, to me, is the thing that is really important beyond making sure dream and shop is strong.
Yeah.
That visual experience, it feels well insulated. The agentic experience that we're seeing in AI mode, that's our job toâ
Yeah.
âmake as good as possible.
Yeah.
The way that I kind of shorthand that is today, the way people use the term Zillow is to look at people's homes.
Tomorrow, I want that to be the way you move.
Yeah.
That is how the verb has to expand.
Yeah.
And that is our job to do, and that's where we're really excited.
Yeah.
I think it is totally fair to ask the questions of who could come into our world.
The way we are thinking about it internally is, how can we add more value to more people?
Yeah.
Historically, we have been constrained by how many calls to action you can put on a mobile screen or on a desktop website.
Yeah.
Take a tour, get pre-qualified, contact an agent.
Yeah.
Those are the highest converting ones. Those are the ones that are on our website. That's the way you get into the physical world. Tomorrow on Zillow, the agentic experience is you have conversations with people about all sorts of things, and as a result, you can start to help them in many more ways.
Yeah.
That feels like our right to win, and that's where we get excited about not just defending and growing the tippy top of funnel listing search.
Yeah.
And really helping more and more people transact in an agentic way.
Got it. I think, yeah, I think we recognize, like, very unlikely to see, even despite the fact of software development costs coming down a ton with AI, very unlikely to see like a vertical-specific player. But I think Google is the one out there where, and you are seeing, I think from the outside in, like you are seeing them trying to adapt to providing the experience they feel like customers want, right? AI mode being sort of the latest acceleration for them. I think that's one where, I think we can all agree, like if Google came out with a listing service tomorrow, like it's probably not going to impact your business at all. How do you guys think of it from like a traffic perspective?
Recognizing there's a sort of like a 20% exposure, we 'll call it there, but like how do you think about the Google risk in that context?
Pretty limited.
Yeah.
I mean, 80%+ of our traffic is direct. Another 15% or so in SEO.
Yeah.
Call it less than 5% in SEM.
Yeah.
In SEO, it's our right to win on who shows up in the AI mode screen as well, and we'll rush towards that as a source of traffic. I look at what our traffic has been able to do in a challenged macro environment with 80%+ of people already using AI tools.
Yeah.
When they're looking to dream and shop. We have never been a higher share of trafficâ
Yeah.
âin the category.
Understood.
We were 77% of traffic this most recent quarter, and a year ago and two years ago, that would have been 60%-65%.
Yeah. Wow. Understood. Okay. One more AI question. Just internal use, like when does this start to show up in your financials, and how do you measure it? Like what's the latest? I know that a lot of CFOs get asked this question, but time goes on, I imagine your thoughts are evolving there. Like, how are you thinking about measuring your guys' use of AI internally and what you're spending on it?
Yeah. We feel like there's a lot of open space for us on the consumer front, and that will take time to build out. But the addressable market expansion that comes with having countless conversations that we never used to have.
Yeah.
Feels like both an addressable market expansion opportunity to help more buyers and sellers and other folks that are moving, and a conversion opportunity. We get excited about that, but it's early.
Yeah.
There's nothing that I would point to immediately to say, "Okay, and that showed up in Q3 in this particular way."
Yeah.
Just conceptually makes sense to me. We've been really good on cost structure for a while now, and some of that has been on the back of being able to ship more code with the same number of people. Beyond that, our software tools for the industry are getting stronger because of AI as well. We're seeing it in the usage and MRR growth and things like Follow Up Boss as well.
Okay. I mean, do you view it as something though that where your absolute spend is still going to grow on a year-over-year basis because you guys are leveraging so much more out of it? Or how do you think about just like a growth rate trajectory of the spend itself?
Yeah, I think the spend, we've been pretty thoughtful about how we scale up AI mode.
Making sure that we are hitting economic gates along the way.
So, I feel good that we're able to manage that as we expanded it to 100% of logged in users. Then with respect to employee tools, we spend money there, but we think it's the right spend to have, not just from an efficiency perspective, but also kind of retooling the employee base.
Got it. Okay. Lastly, just on capital allocation and everything, I know you guys have made a big pledge. You have the buyback and trying to reduce share count. But just any latest thoughts on sort of just philosophically how you're thinking about allocating capital, dilution, et cetera?
Continue to be opportunistic on buyback, and we'll manage that alongside liquidity. But we've done, I think, a nice job there. With respect to dilution, the way that we're able to manage dilution from an SBC perspective is as we manage fixed costs, 90% of our stock-based comp charge is in that fixed costs.
Yeah.
As a result, if we're not growing fixed costs much, that means SBC is not growing much. As a result, we're able to leverage it as revenue grows.
Got it. One last one that just occurred to me. You guys never get asked about M&A anymore, and I know you have that part of the business still. You look at everything.
Yeah.
What is the latest on M&A?
I mean, we're always looking. The door is open for us to do M&A. We'll continue to find ways to expand the product set as a result of M&A. But it's definitely second or third to internalâ
Yeah.
âproduct development. We don't necessarily see anything transformative on the horizon.
Got it. All right. We will close it there. Jeremy Hofmann, thanks so much for being here. Appreciate it.