๐ŸŽ Black Friday: 50% off Unlimited and 30% off Pro annual plans

UnitedHealth falls 10% and Humana drops 13% as CMS proposes wider Medicare Advantage audits

A black stethoscope on a light blue background.
Photo by Etactics Inc on Unsplash

UnitedHealth Group (UNH) fell 10.2% on Wednesday, a second day of losses for health insurers after the government proposed a rule to fight Medicare fraud.

The selloff spread across the companies that run Medicare Advantage plans, the private alternative to traditional Medicare:

Company Change on Wednesday
Humana (HUM) -13.0%
UnitedHealth Group -10.2%
Elevance Health (ELV) -7.6%
CVS Health (CVS) -5.2%
The Cigna Group (CI) -3.0%

The S&P 500 slipped 0.2%, while the Dow fell 1.1%. UnitedHealth makes up about 4.3% of the Dow, one of the index's largest weightings, according to Yahoo Finance. Barron's also tied the week's selloff to a renewed push for Medicare for All.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) published the proposal, called CRUSH, on Monday. The rule targets fraud across Medicare, Medicaid, the Children's Health Insurance Program and the Health Insurance Marketplace, and the agency says it could save taxpayers nearly $90B over 10 years.

The part that hit the insurers is about audits. Medicare Advantage plans are paid more for members with more diagnoses on record. CMS audits a sample of medical records to check that those diagnoses are documented.

Under the proposal, CMS would extrapolate what those audits find to a plan's wider payments, starting with audits of 2018. It estimates this would recover about $9B in overpayments for each payment year.

CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz said: "Every taxpayer dollar lost to fraud is a dollar that cannot support the care these programs were created to provide."

Oppenheimer analysts think the rule will end up in court, Yahoo Finance reports, since a federal court threw out a comparable framework in 2025. "We believe CMS will be subject to the same legal challenges that it faced in 2025," they wrote.

The analysts also said most of the projected savings would come from clawing back past payments, with recoveries concentrated in 2028 through 2030. And if the rule does hold up, they expect insurers to pass the added cost through in their bids for future plan years instead of taking the hit to earnings.

The rule is not final. CMS takes public comments until January 19, 2027, and can change the proposal before it adopts it.

Sources & Further Reading

  1. "CMS CRUSH Proposed Rule Aims to Reap Nearly $90 Billion for Taxpayers in Savings by Targeting Fraud Across Medicare, Medicaid/CHIP, and the Marketplace." Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. November 16, 2026.
  2. "Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare (CRUSH) Proposed Rule (CMS-6098-P)." Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. November 16, 2026.
  3. "UnitedHealth and other insurance stocks drag down the Dow after CMS proposes new anti-fraud rule." Yahoo Finance. November 18, 2026.

This article was drafted with the help of AI. Kyle Vallans fact-checked, edited and published the article and is responsible for its accuracy and quality. How we use AI