Pan African Resources PLC (LON:PAF)
London flag London · Delayed Price · Currency is GBP · Price in GBX
123.40
+2.50 (2.07%)
Sep 25, 2026, 4:35 PM GMT
← View all transcripts

Earnings Call: H2 2018

Sep 19, 2018

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the Pan African 2018 final results presentation. To those attending in person, thank you very much for taking the time to be here today. Welcome also to those of you dialing into the conference call facility in South Africa, from the U.K., and from elsewhere. In terms of the proceedings today, we will kick off with a 10-minute recording that hopefully provides some background to the Pan African journey over the last year. It truly is and continues to be a journey. I believe it is important to showcase the Pan African assets, but more importantly, some of the Pan African people to our shareholders, analysts, and the broader audience. We are so proud of our people and what they achieve every day. Please bear with us for a couple of minutes.

For those of you dialing into the conference call, a link to that video is available on our website also. Following the video, we will run through the main body of our presentation. For further detailed information, please refer to our SENS and RNS announcement and to the supplementary information available on the Pan African website. Please rest assured that the presentation will be brief and that there will be an opportunity for questions afterwards. We will first take questions from the floor and then from our conference call participants. Can we please now spend a couple of minutes on the video? It's a very challenging space at the moment, both in terms of gold, but also in terms of South African mining.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

The whole industry has experienced massive inflationary pressures over the last decade or two.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

We are faced with a very low gram gold price.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

A lot of the industry has become marginal from an economic perspective.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

We've had a tough 24 months, we believe we've acted decisively and quickly in order to remedy what was required.

Speaker 9

Pan African Resources is an African-focused, mid-tier gold mining company listed on both the JSE in South Africa as well as the AIM market in London. Operations include Barberton Mines in Mpumalanga and Evander Gold Mines, incorporating the Elikhulu project in Evander. Despite the tough operating conditions in the 2018 financial year, we at Pan African Resources have kept our eyes firmly on the prize.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

We aspire to be the gold investment of choice, not only in South Africa, but also from an international investor perspective. We are a sector-leading dividend. We've had to cut that in the last year, but we believe it'll be back in force going forward. We have very exciting growth. We have low cost, sustainable, safe ounces in terms of tailings. We have a world-class underground long life ore body in the form of Barberton. All of those factors combined, we believe to make us incredibly attractive for gold investors and for investors in general.

Speaker 9

Pan African Resources produces approximately 170,000 ounces of gold per year. What really sets us apart from our competitors is the quality ore bodies. Ore bodies with good cash flow margins and a low execution risk.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

Pan African differentiates itself from the rest of the mining sector in that it gives shareholders a proper return on their capital. That is demonstrated with the sector leading dividend yield that we've had in the past five years, as well as a very attractive return on equity.

Speaker 9

We have had some key challenges in the last year, which required a repositioning strategy in order to execute a decisive turnaround.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

The challenges were specific to the underground operations at 8 Shaft. There we experienced massive cash flow hemorrhage, especially in the last financial year.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

We could not afford to have Evander underground continue and be loss-making. As a group, we're simply not big enough to absorb continuing losses. We had to curtail that operation and then refocus on higher margin, low-cost operations such as Elikhulu.

Speaker 9

The Elikhulu tailings retreatment plant in Evander is a key component of the future growth prospects of the company, and the project has been commissioned in record time.

Jonathan Irons
Group Consulting Metallurgist and Executive Accountable for Tailings, Pan African Resources

We started building the plant in August last year, and it has taken us less than a year to try to construct a plant of this magnitude, which it hasn't been done before in South Africa.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Well, we're incredibly proud of Elikhulu and what we've achieved. We only received our definitive feasibility study in December 2016. We raised the money in April of 2017. All the permitting was in place by August of 2017. We've built a ZAR 1.7 billion plant in less than 12 months.

Jonathan Irons
Group Consulting Metallurgist and Executive Accountable for Tailings, Pan African Resources

We are going to do our budgeted tonnage, which is 1 million tons a month, and we've got three tailings storage facilities that will be treating through Elikhulu. Each one of the tailings storage facilities will take about four years to treat. Elikhulu has created over 400 permanent employment opportunities, and we are employing people from the local community and people that were retrenched from the mine as well. We are going to increase the output of the group in terms of the ounces by more than 25%-30%, which is really great for the team.

Speaker 9

Future lower cost underground mining is underpinned by the attractive Egoli project, which will be serviced by Evander's 7 Shaft. There is a high-grade block which will be mined, thus extending the life of mine to approximately 15 years.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

Pan African has been compelled to move away from the deep-level underground mining. We focused on our lower cost, lower execution risk underground ounces at Barberton, as well as surface operations.

Speaker 9

The production sources at Barberton, going forward, form part of the repositioning strategy. The increased focus on surface operations required us to install a 1.7 megawatt regrind mill in order to maximize the output of this plant.

Speaker 8

A lot of the slime sand has a consistency of sea sand, which is very coarse, and it tends to settle out in the tanks. We had to install a regrind mill to mill it finer so that we are able to treat it and pump it. It has extended the life of the mine and also have increased the opportunities of retreating now the older dumps, which are very coarse.

The biggest highlight is being able to treat 100,000 tons through BTRP for the first time since commissioning. We processed 100,042 tons through the BTRP and also managed to meet our gold target.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

That has differentiated Pan African from its peer group, doing repositioned itself as a low-cost producer in the local sector.

Speaker 9

Barberton Mine is Pan African Resources' flagship gold operation, it is vitally important that we continue to establish sustainable underground operations that are flexible and responsive to any potential challenges that we may face, especially at the 11 block.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

The 11 block is critical to the Barberton underground operation as a result of it being such high grade. On average, our reserve grade is 25 grams per ton plus. If the 11 block sneezes, all of Barberton, and actually all of Pan African, catches a cold.

Speaker 8

In the past year, we have hauled into the next platform, which gave us a little bit more flexibility. Currently, we do have two platforms at (Good Mining) and MRC. Both of them are high-grade platforms, and we developed quite a long laydown as to the next one as well.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

We are developing towards a third platform. We should be there early in the new year. That bodes very well for Barberton Underground going forward.

Speaker 9

Underpinning this repositioning strategy is an ESG culture, which is a business imperative. Paramount to this is the health and safety of our employees.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

In order to have a license to operate, we need to understand that we have to be safe. Barberton and Evander are safe operations. We achieved a million fatality-free shifts at Barberton recently, but you can never take your eye off the ball as far as safety is concerned. We take it incredibly seriously. It's something we discuss and think about and action every single day.

Speaker 8

By achieving a million fatality-free shifts for Barberton Mine, it makes me feel great as a group shift manager because I'm on the driver's seat, making sure that I provide proper guidance to ensure that all our people are returning back home unharmed. I can say we are the best in the market by such an achievement.

Speaker 9

Through these actions that we have taken in the last year, as well as our plans for the future, we aim to continue delivering sustainable returns not only to our shareholders, but also to our employees and communities.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Without having a constructive relationship with these stakeholders, we can't operate. We need to understand that. I think we've put our engagement efforts with specifically communities on steroids in the last year, and we've been seeing the results.

Speaker 9

We continue to drive various community-focused development projects. In Evander, we sponsor the recently opened Business Incubation Center, and Mpumelelo Primary School is one of two schools that form part of the Adopt-a-School program. The Sheba Multipurpose Center forms the heartbeat of the Sinqobile community in Barberton. Through the provision of land, seedlings, water, and mentorship, Barberton Mines have empowered a group of local women with the necessary skills to successfully run the Sinqobile Vegetable Project. Lastly, Fairview Primary School is a gem in the local community, an outstanding example of the formalization of the community through education.

Speaker 8

It is very much important because as a mine, we've got that social responsibility to look after our communities. We work in the communities, we work with the communities, we must also invest in our communities.

Speaker 9

Looking to the future, Pan African Resources has to continue growing while still meeting our strict capital allocation criteria and ESG compliance.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

We see within our existing portfolio good generic growth opportunities, both surface as well as underground, that will deliver into those criteria, such as, for example, the Royal Sheba.

Speaker 8

We're busy drilling the Royal Sheba project here at the back. The gold is quite close to surface. We've just finished the first phase, there's quite a lot of potential, especially for ore bodies close to surface. That means that the potential may be for open cast mine, also it's low cost, low risk. Yeah, we're very excited about this.

Very soon we will be taking that project work for a definitive feasibility study, all indications that it's going to be a very positive result.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

We're very excited about Royal Sheba. We found effectively a very large resource in our backyard. It's very encouraging in terms of the exploration results and the mineral resource and reserve estimates up to now. We believe we can expand on that further a further process is that we don't have to pay for it. It's on our mining lease.

Speaker 9

To further ensure our continued growth through differentiation, we must remain focused on preserving the quality of our ore bodies and unlocking value for all our stakeholders.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

What we're doing in Barberton for our future is Fairview has the deepest shaft system of the two mines, the Sheba Mine and the Fairview Mine. We are utilizing that to access the depth extent of the ore bodies from the Sheba side. The ZK ore body, we're chasing that at depth.

Speaker 8

The MRC, which is our best grade ore body, is open-ended, and we've got an aggressive diamond drill program underground to chase the depth extent. We are busy with the new sub-vertical shaft at Fairview Mine, which will enable us to go after the depth extent of the MRC ore body.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

We see Pan African as a business which continues to differentiate itself from the rest of the sector, with good returns, growing into the type of businesses that we believe are what our shareholders will be looking for, close to cash flow, good margins, relatively low capital outlay, and a relatively short period of time before the first cash flow returns are generated. Those opportunities are few and far between, but we will continue looking within both S.A. as well as the rest of Africa for those opportunities that meet that criteria.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

We're very proud of the team, and we've put a lot of focus and emphasis on the team and working together. We're a flat structure in terms of decision-making. We're very proud of what we've achieved, and we're very excited about the future.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

I am so proud of what we have achieved.

Speaker 8

It was time to up our game, and we have the grade and the team to do it.

To mine for gold is serious business. I take safety even more serious.

This is not only about underground mining, but we've got some of the best surface resource potential.

A healthy community is a happy community. If the community is happy, we as Barberton Mines are happy.

Jonathan Irons
Group Consulting Metallurgist and Executive Accountable for Tailings, Pan African Resources

Our safety record at Pan African Resources is one of the best in the industry, and I'm very proud of it.

Speaker 8

Mining is all about flexibility. Opening up platforms in Block 11 will take productivity to a whole new level.

When the communities win, we all do.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

I'm very serious about safety.

Speaker 8

I'm so proud of what we have achieved here at BTRP for achieving 100,000 tons a month.

Grade is everything. At the end of the day, we've got the grade.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Thank you very much for being with us. We will now proceed on to the quite brief presentation. We can please note our disclaimer and detail on forward-looking statements on page two and three of the presentation. If we move on to slide four, our mission statement is to be the safe, low cost, and sustainable mid-tier gold producer. We recognize that gold investors and generalist investors, even more so, have a universe of investment opportunities and alternatives. To be frank, if Pan African had continued with high cost and difficult deep-level mining at Evander Number 8 Shaft underground, in this environment, we would have had to reconsider this mission statement. The entire rest of this presentation is dedicated to demonstrating that Pan African Resources has turned the corner. We have delivered on our undertakings over the last year.

We have safe, profitable, and low-cost gold mining operations, and we have very exciting and attractive growth opportunities in the near future. We can then move on to a presentation summary on slide number six. We will start with the 2018 challenges, remedial actions, and the results of said actions. We will then provide further detail on our assets and how we have repositioned our business for sustainability. Deon Louw, our financial director, will provide color on the 2018 financial results, but more importantly, management views on key financial issues and how these will impact our future. We will then conclude by briefly talking about very exciting near-term value accretive growth opportunities within our own portfolio, as well as key deliverables for the 2019 financial year.

We move on to slide number eight, which is a high-level illustration of the relative relationship between cost increases in South African rand, gold prices, and gold prices over the last years. Pan African has always been known for its cost control, almost being quite frugal, and we have generally managed to contain general annual cost increases to approximately 8% per annum or below over the last years. We are, however, not immune to inflationary pressures, and therefore, we require a depreciating South African rand over time in order to maintain our margins. In December 2017, Cyril Ramaphosa was elected as President of the ANC. In the words of Charles Dickens, "It was the best of times, it was the worst of times for us." President Ramaphosa's election provided much needed certainty to South Africa.

It also resulted in a very rapid strengthening of the South African rand, a move that saw most of our operating margin disappear as the rand gold price reduced to almost ZAR 500,000 per kilo. I have to say that even in this environment, the bulk of our portfolio was still profitable, which is quite different to the rest of the South African industry. To compound our difficult situation in December 2017, on slide number nine, despite our best efforts, the Evander 8 Shaft underground was lost making. Our BTRP at Barberton was experiencing processing issues, and Barberton Mines' underground only had access to one mining platform in the exceptionally high number 11 block. We were also faced with an unprotected strike action and community unrest for a number of days at the end of December in Barberton.

We move on to slide number 10, I think one of Pan African's corporate values is resilience, and we believe that from the outset, resilience requires brutal honesty about one situation. Being brutally honest, in late December 2017, we had a major problem in terms of the sustainability of our business. The profits generated by Barberton and the ETRP at Evander were being eroded by the very weak rand gold price and also by losses from the Evander underground. We are not a management team that can sit back and hope for better gold prices or an improved operating environment while we and our shareholders suffer indefinite losses. I think a key Pan African strength is the ability to act quickly and execute well.

In late December and in the 1st week of January 2018, the entire Pan African management team was strategizing on how we turn the ship. By the 2nd week of January, we had developed a detailed action plan. I have to stress this was on top of remedial actions previously devised, implemented, and communicated to the market. We have a track record of delivery, and we now had to use this track record to deliver a much improved Pan African. In terms of repositioning, it wasn't good enough to be the best or lowest cost gold producer in South Africa. We had to be competitive with international peers. That means not producing at an all-in cost of circa $1,200, but rather look to produce at an all-in cost of between $800 and $900 per ounce.

The rest of this presentation will demonstrate how we have repositioned Pan African to be even safer, be sustainable, be more profitable, resume a sector-leading dividend, and also grow profitable production in future. If we can go to slide number 11, I do believe that we have, on a regular basis, communicated key challenges and achievements to the market over the last year. Let's summarize a few key points. To be clear, safety is our number one priority. Safety performances have also recently enjoyed renewed attention, both in South Africa but also internationally. We will never be complacent about safety. Despite an excellent performance in the last year, we can and we will do better. We have successfully curtailed unprofitable production ounces from the Evander Eight Shaft underground.

In January 2018, as a result of the issues highlighted above, the operation was burning almost ZAR 30 million per month. After an internal and external review, our board made the decision to curtail operations. It was all done within three months. Despite the human tragedy, this action has completely changed the cost and profitability profile of our business going forward for the better. The fact that we have managed to successfully close a large-scale operation in such a short timeframe also demonstrates that you can do business and do what your business requires in South Africa. The BTR regrind mill was our next achievement. We commissioned the mill on time, and it is performing exactly as we had anticipated. We are guiding to more than 20,000 ounces of production for the BTRP in 2019, which makes it an excellent profit and cash generator for our group.

We have significantly improved Barberton Mines' underground flexibility. We are currently seeing the results of our actions and our investments. In terms of near-term growth and in terms of profits and production, we successfully commissioned Elikhulu earlier this month, more than two months ahead of the original feasibility schedule. This slide 11 is quite a simple slide. Our investor relations firm questioned a strategy to make it more impactful. We believe actions speak louder than words. Again, the actions detailed in the slide completely repositioned our business. We are now safer, more sustainable, and much more profitable. Let us now have a look at our repositioned business and what shareholders can expect in the future. Slide 13 is a map of our gold operations, all in Mpumalanga, South Africa.

Moving to slide 14, I have to say, of all of the information contained in this presentation, this is probably the one that I'm proudest of. This is the first year that I, in my capacity as CEO, can stand before you and congratulate our teams on a fatality-free year. This is the first year where I don't have to pass condolences to the family of an employee that passed away in the line of duty. This was despite all the upheaval at Evander and the enormous number of man-hours spent on the construction of Elikhulu. Barberton has more than halved its reportable injury frequency rate in the last year, in terms of lost time injuries, I believe the operation leads the sector.

Going forward, our operation, with all of our business now so heavily focused on tailings, I would expect the safety performance to improve even further. Mandla Ndlozi, our Group Safety Manager, is here today. Well done to him and to each and every Pan African employee. We cannot, however, become complacent. We have to do even better. On slide number 13, the gold reserves that we have lost as a result of the curtailment of large-scale underground mining at Evander has been generally recouped by our work at Royal Sheba and Egoli, demonstrating the depth of our resource and reserve base. We have bolstered our mineral resource management team over the last year, they are delivering the results.

In terms of our long-life, low-cost tailings business, which now produces 50% or more of all of our gold, slide 17, I believe, demonstrates that the BTRP is still an exceptional asset. Just to recap, the life of mine is still 11 years. We're still costing all-in cost of production of $750 in the next year. The initial capital investment was repaid in less than two years, this has obviously served as a catalyst for the larger tailings business at Pan African. We're very happy with the achievements at the BTRP. On slide number 18, which is the much spoken about tailings business at Evander, principally the Elikhulu. I believe Elikhulu will change the face of Evander.

As we've said before, we've managed to build a ZAR 1.7 billion plant in less than 12 months, we managed to secure all of our permitting in seven or eight months, I think this demonstrates that one can build projects successfully in South Africa, we're quite excited about what Elikhulu will hold. In terms of the forecast for our tailings business at Evander, we are looking to tie up further surface sources to keep the Kinross plant producing, we anticipate approximately 10,000 ounces from this plant in FY 2019. Moving on to Barberton Underground, which has been a flagship asset for Pan African for many years. Barberton Underground certainly made its production targets for the last bit of the 2018 financial year. We've managed to really contain costs on a unit basis very well.

It bodes very well for the year that's ahead. We're forecasting 80,000 ounces of production from Barberton Underground for FY 2019. If we achieve that guidance, which there's every indication that we will, we can expect to have our all-in costs reduced even further, certainly quite a bit below ZAR 500,000 per kg, which I believe is very competitive in the South African context. Just a very brief, and I have to say, busy slide on slide number 21. We've tried to demonstrate the universe of opportunities we have, principally at Fairview and Sheba, as far as the 11 Block and other ore bodies are concerned. We've spoken about the sub-vertical shaft that we're in the process of constructing. We have flexibility now.

From a mining perspective, we have two high-grading underground ore bodies on the MRC, being the C58 and the 272. We should be in the next platform early in the next year. That will give us three platforms, and it has been a long time since we have had three platforms in this very high-grading block. We estimate on average this block grades 25 grams a tonne. Some of the areas we're seeing 80 or 100 grams a tonne. That is exceptional and it demonstrates and improves our 20 years life that we currently have on this fantastic underground asset. We then can move on to slide number 23, which deals with ESG. Investors rightfully demand detail on ESG compliance and performance. We sometimes, I believe, sell ourselves short in this regard. However, ESG has become very much part of our business. Our operations make a positive difference where we operate.

We are involved in schools, we are involved in communities. We will do even more in future. Specifically at Barberton, as I've said in the previous presentation, we have put our community engagement efforts on steroids, so to speak, in the last six months. We are seeing the results. Community disruptions currently have been very limited. I will now ask our financial director, Deon Louw, to provide more color on the 2018 financials and also on the prospects going forward.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

Thank you, Koos. Good morning, everyone. Slide 25 summarizes the 2018 financial year's results, which differentiates between continuing and discontinuing operations. Continuing operations comprises Barberton Mines, the BTRP, the ETRP, the Elikhulu Project, and the ROM circuit at the Kinross plant, whereas discontinued operations comprises Evander Seven and Eight shaft complex. Revenue from combined operations, both continued and discontinued, declined by 13% to ZAR 1.87 billion, adversely impacted by both the lower gold price and lower gold sold volumes. The lower production volumes and high cost of Evander's underground production is reflected in the substantial increases in all three cost parameters for the combined operations, with all-in sustaining costs and all-in cost material in excess of the ZAR 538,000 a kilogram we received on average for the 2000 financial year for a kilogram of sold gold.

This burn rate, as Koos mentioned, was clearly unsustainable for a group of our size and compelled the repositioning of the group to ensure its sustainability. As expected, gold mining, with its high fixed cost structure, is disproportionately affected by lower production volumes and a lower ZAR gold price, and EBITDA from continued operations was adversely impacted, declining to ZAR 416 million relative to ZAR 816 million in the prior year. Losses from the combined operations amounted to ZAR 1.56 billion, following the ZAR 1.76 billion impairment of the discontinued operations. However, if the impact of the discontinued operations is excluded from the results, the continued operations still generated a post-tax profit of ZAR 202 million or GBP 11.5 million. Earnings per share on a combined operation basis was clearly impacted by the impairment of the discontinued operations, declining to a loss of ZAR 0.86 per share or GBP 0.0515 per share.

Headline earnings per share, which excludes the results from discontinued operations, was still positive at ZAR 0.1266 per share or GBP 0.0073 a share. The movement in net debt to ZAR 1.62 billion results from the ZAR 1.65 billion capital spend primarily on the construction of the Elikhulu plant, which was funded from drawings from the dedicated Elikhulu debt facility and a general purpose revolving trade facility, the RCF facility. (Slide 26) discloses the trend in production cost in ZAR and USD terms for the continuing operations only. The impact of the lower production volumes on unit cost is evident in the 2018 financial year as the trend turned negative. We are confident that it will reverse in the 2019 financial year as production volumes revert to the guided levels. We monitor cash flows judiciously, slide 27 discloses the cash flows for the 2018 financial year.

Notwithstanding the onerous cash outflows associated with Evander's operating losses and retrenchment costs, the group was still cash flow positive from an operational perspective to the extent of ZAR 66 million. As expected, finance costs increased commensurate with the increased debt levels as we funded the capital expansion program withdrawing from the RCF and Elikhulu facilities to the extent of ZAR 1.4 billion. We endeavor to maintain a minimum liquidity headroom of ZAR 200 million to ZAR 300 million for working capital purposes at all times and sold treasury shares in May to the extent of ZAR 149 million when the ZAR gold price was severely depressed, and we were concerned about possible disruptions at our operations. Slide 28 shows the maturity and amortization profile of the existing RCF facility. The orange line in the first graph is the RCF facility's existing amortization profile.

A restructured RCF facility is the blue line in the first graph, and the existing Elikhulu facility is in green. It's a straight line amortization over a five-year period. The existing RCF facility, that's the orange line, amortizes currently with three installments of ZAR 133 million commencing in June 2019, a further installment in December 2019, and a final installment of ZAR 133 million in June 2020, together with a bullet repayment of ZAR 600 million on that date, and that's why it goes down to zero on the graph. The original intent was that the bullet installment of ZAR 600 million in June 2020 would be refinanced on extended term.

In light of the group's growth prospects, specifically the Royal Sheba project, we deemed it appropriate to rather introduce a core revolving trade facility indebtedness of ZAR 1 billion for the next five years, as is depicted by the horizontal blue line on the first graph. Effectively, what we're saying is that that orange line will revert to the blue line. This obviates the compulsory RCF debt repayments of ZAR 400 million in the FY 2019 and FY 2020 financial year, which will enable us to finance the Royal Sheba project's development from existing debt facilities and internally generate cash flows as opposed to equity. With the restructured RCF, our annual cash flows for the next five years will be limited to ZAR 200 million per annum for the Elikhulu facility's amortization, as is depicted by the green blocks in the second graph, which shows the cash redemptions associated with the existing profile.

That's the blue block here, which is the existing profile consistent with the orange line in the first graph. The restructured RCF, which now becomes a core indebtedness of ZAR 1 billion over a five-year period. That leaves us only with the ZAR 200 million for the Elikhulu repayment. In this regard, RMB has provided us with a term sheet to restructure the facility on this basis. We'll intend to have it in place early next year for Royal Sheba's development, assuming, of course, the DFS is as positive as we believe it will be. (Slide 26) discloses the specific items on Evander's fixed asset register that have not been impaired. Noteworthy is that none of the gold prospects and the projects have been impaired.

The land or the ETRP infrastructure, which will now form part of the Elikhulu project going forward. Fair value accounting compels us to impair the discontinued operations and the Kinross plant ROM circuit. Unfortunately, it does not allow us to fair value the Egoli project and the Elikhulu project, which were acquired as part of the original Evander acquisition. If we could fair value these assets, their combined NPV value of ZAR 2.1 billion would comfortably have offset the impairment loss of ZAR 1.78 billion. Finally, although the group's ROEs have been in excess of 60% in two of the past five years, the returns have been quite erratic over this period, a function of both the ZAR gold price and also production inconsistencies.

With the repositioning of the operational base, the risk of this level of production inconsistency has been materially reduced, which would positively impact on our ability to deliver into a more consistent return on equity in the future, also reinstitute our historical dividend payments, which remains a business imperative. Thank you.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Thank you very much, Deon. We will now conclude the presentation with briefly detailing value accretive growth in the near future and the prospects for 2019. In terms of growth, we have looked at a number of acquisitions in recent years, mostly in the rest of Africa. Most of these opportunities were priced such that after paying the acquisition and development costs, it was very difficult to generate an attractive return for our shareholders. We decided to again look in our own backyard in terms of projects, our own assets, and look what we found. We put out an announcement last week, I believe, in terms of Royal Sheba. You will recall that previously we were developing towards the Royal Sheba underground on level 23 at Sheba. The plan was to have the underground in production in the next three to four years.

The new drilling results has been disseminated to the market. We put down 20 holes. There's plans to do another, I think, 10 holes in the next month. It's a pretty inexpensive drilling program. The results again have been published. We're very excited. We have a very substantial resource now of almost 900,000 ounces, grading more than 3 grams a ton. What's even more exciting is that 350,000 of these ounces are sitting near surface at a compelling grade of almost 4 grams a ton. We are now completing a definitive feasibility study on Royal Sheba. We have also started engagement with all stakeholders in terms of the required permitting for this project. In South Africa, our people desperately need jobs.

Our people desperately need economic opportunity, and I believe Royal Sheba can provide a lot of that, certainly in the Barberton area, and that in a very short space of time. If we very quickly then also discuss Egoli, which is the underground project sitting as part of Evander. Understandably, I don't think our shareholders have the appetite for us to go back into any sort of VMS type underground development at present. I do think that if this project was a standalone project sitting in a sort of development company or an offshore company, and possibly if the project was situated in a different jurisdiction, the company would probably have a market capitalization of ZAR 50 million. I think very little value is attributed to Egoli in our portfolio at present. Again, it's not a priority for us to develop Egoli, let's be clear.

We need to demonstrate to the market that we are back on track in terms of production from the existing assets. We need to get Elikhulu to perform like we've said that it will. We need to progress Royal Sheba. I do believe that Egoli is an attractive project, and I believe that there certainly is value going forward in Egoli. In terms of the focus for 2019, we will continue to improve our safety performance and our ESG performance and compliance across operations. We will deliver into the gold production guidance of approximately 170,000 ounces for the FY 2019 financial year. We recently reached a three-year wage agreement at Barberton with all of our major unions. I think we were the first substantial gold company to actually get that agreement. It's a long-term agreement.

I believe it's a reasonable agreement in terms of what it delivers to all stakeholders, I believe it'll provide a lot of stability at Barberton going forward. We need to ensure that Elikhulu delivers according to expectations, we need to continue to incorporate the ETRP throughput into Elikhulu. As per Deon's guidance, we need to increase our balance sheet flexibility and capacity. Obviously that requires financial structuring and also requires us to deliver into what we've said we will do operationally, I believe we'll do that. We need to look to reinitiate our sector leading dividend payments. I believe we're well placed to do that in the future, in the near future, rather. Then we have to look to progress our growth opportunities, specifically Royal Sheba.

We're also completing a study on the viability of mining the 8 Shaft pillar at Evander Underground, we will communicate to the market, I believe, in the very near future as far as that strategy is concerned. Then also certainly developing the sub-vertical project at Barberton and also, as I've mentioned, Egoli. Thank you very much for attending today. I think we will go to questions from the floor first. If I may be so bold as to actually sort of preempt what's probably a question that will be asked, which is, how are we doing with the ramp-up of Elikhulu? It's much better to hear from, I think the man in charge, Jonathan Irons. If you don't mind just sort of briefly detailing where we are as far as Elikhulu is concerned. Thanks.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

Just might have to use a microphone.

Jonathan Irons
Group Consulting Metallurgist and Executive Accountable for Tailings, Pan African Resources

Cobus, thank you for the opportunity. Firstly, congratulations. I think on a well put together presentation and a very exciting corporate video. In terms of the Elikhulu project to date Up to this morning, we've managed to smelt 56 kilograms of gold for this current month. We are projecting to do between 90 and 100 kilograms from a production forecast of between 700,000 and 800,000 tons for this month. Obviously, 1 million tons is our objective, I am confident that we are busy at this point in time settling the plant. People are getting used to the machine. People are getting used to the operations.

We are busy ironing out the issues, I think that into October, we should probably get very close to our 1 million tons per month target and 130 kilograms, then begin to get to the place where we are consistently at 1 million tons per month. Moving into December, we aim to have the plant expanded to incorporate the ETRP as per plan into the Elikhulu plant. We're looking forward to that as well. I think given the normal ebbs and flow of commissioning, which has, I think, gone very well, we're definitely benefiting in terms of risk and reward at this point in time from a project finished quite early, smelting some gold, making some money. I think we're poised for some positive results. Given the current environment, I think we're okay. Thanks, Cobus.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Thanks, John. Let's take questions from the floor. Thank you very much.

Arnold van Graan
Analyst, Nedbank

Cobus, thanks. Arnold van Graan from Nedbank. Just on Egoli, I'm getting a bit of mixed messaging. It does look like a good project, you've just closed down an underground gold mine now. There's a possibility of reopening that. What is the plan there? Is it basically getting it ready and trying to sell it? What would you look at as a benchmark or trigger to reopen that or to go for that? Would you be using a much higher hurdle rate given the higher risk associated with underground mining of that nature? That's the first question.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Thanks, Arnold. Yes. Let's be clear. Pan African will not develop Egoli in the near future, even though we believe it is a very attractive project. Our focus is delivering into our production guidance. Our focus is getting Elikhulu and ETRP to work. We need to progress Royal Sheba, I think that's very exciting. We need to resume our dividends, which is key. Egoli is, as I've said, a very attractive project. I'm very comfortable with the work we've done to date, we have to accept that our shareholders, at this point, do not have appetite to go back large scale into an underground operation. I think we will do whatever we need to realize maximum value from Egoli in the future. It does not exclude a development in future years, but certainly not in the near term.

Arnold van Graan
Analyst, Nedbank

Okay. The second question is on the dividend. You obviously want to resume that as soon as possible. What are you looking at? What metrics? What net debt, EBITDA levels?

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Well, we have.

Arnold van Graan
Analyst, Nedbank

When will you be comfortable to start resuming that?

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Well, we have a dividend policy. I think, Deon, if you wanna just quickly just help us out here. Thanks.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

Sure.

Arnold van Graan
Analyst, Nedbank

Thanks.

Deon Louw
Financial Director, Pan African Resources

Arnold, the dividend policy is unchanged, that's 40% of free cash flow. Obviously, taking into account the state of the gold sector, the state of the company, capital expenditure going forward. If there's no need to withhold any cash, we will be looking to paying out 40% of our free cash flow. Clearly, the debt restructure plays into that, the extent to which we need to pay cash back to the bankers.

Arnold van Graan
Analyst, Nedbank

Thank you.

Bruce Williamson
Founding Member and Chief Investment Officer, Integral Asset Management

Morning, Cobus.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Hi.

Bruce Williamson
Founding Member and Chief Investment Officer, Integral Asset Management

Bruce Williamson, Integral Asset Management. Just with respect to the dividend, when you guys now get sort of back on your feet properly, are you gonna be looking at paying both an interim and a final? Then also being a June year end, as investors, we certainly have to wait till December to pick up a dividend. Are you gonna go back and pay interim and final and try and pay us the money a lot sooner?

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Certainly, what I can say is our board has not excluded the possibility of an interim dividend. I do not want to commit to that right now. If you look at the history of Pan African, we've paid a very attractive, as a matter of fact, sector-leading dividend for almost all of the years that I've been involved. We understand that most of our investors appreciate and require that cash return. It's a key focus area of ours. You can rest assured that it's enjoying our attention, and we need to get back to where we were in the past, Bruce.

Bruce Williamson
Founding Member and Chief Investment Officer, Integral Asset Management

Thanks. You weren't exactly clear in saying that you'd looked out of South Africa but come back and are far more excited about Royal Sheba. Does that mean you've stopped looking out of South Africa and are you only looking at gold? That's one question. Can you just give us an idea, it looks the intersections at Royal Sheba below collar are really shallow. Potentially, what is your access plan into that ore body?

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

We have not stopped looking outside of South Africa. The focus has very much been internal and to fix what we needed to fix over the last year. Every time we do investigate and do due diligence on other assets, we learn a bit more about our own portfolio also. To give you an example, we looked at an asset in Mali. It's an old Russian mine. It was mined underground, which was now the plan to mine from an open pit perspective. That sort of, again, got us thinking about our own portfolio and the opportunities that we have certainly as part of Barberton. We will continue to look, but there's no way that we can buy assets at an 8% USD discount rate. Our shareholders expect a 20% circa USD return, that's what we need to give them.

Unfortunately, those assets are few and far between. We're quite disciplined as far as that is concerned. In terms of Royal Sheba, I do not want to preempt the outcome of the feasibility study. There are a number of hurdles that we would need to jump through from a permitting perspective, from a consultation perspective. Suffice to say, this is a very shallow ore body. The grades are very attractive. Four grams circa close to surface, you don't find those sort of ore bodies often, certainly not in Africa. We have power, we have water. We will have to improve or certainly increase our processing capacity if we wanted to mine it on any sort of scale. Let's not preempt. I think the other point to make is that Royal Sheba is not refractory, so it's free milling.

It's very susceptible to normal CIL, which makes it even more attractive. Let's not preempt the results of the feasibility study. There's a lot of work that we need to do, it would have been remiss of us not to put out these drilling results, which I think are excellent.

Bruce Williamson
Founding Member and Chief Investment Officer, Integral Asset Management

Thank you. Then just from a tax perspective, would Royal Sheba be ring-fenced, or would that be part of your Barberton tax?

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

It probably will not be ring-fenced in that you get the benefit of the tax deduction across all of the operations. We will look at, obviously, tax structuring within what is allowable. It makes sense for us to run it as part of the existing business.

Bruce Williamson
Founding Member and Chief Investment Officer, Integral Asset Management

Okay. Thank you.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Can we quickly take calls if there are any, or questions from the conference call facility?

Operator

Thank you very much. We have a question from Justin Chen of Nomura Securities.

Justin Chen
Analyst, Nomura Securities

Morning. Cobus, beyond the team. Thanks very much for taking the question. My first one is on CapEx and just what your plans are for this year and what your expectations are on that and what you can guide us to.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Sure. We're in a fortunate position where most of the capital has been spent on Elikhulu. We need to finish that project. I think as we sit here today, we have about ZAR 300 million-odd to go on Elikhulu, but that's obviously expansionary capital. In terms of the existing operations, which is in really Barberton, again, the capital number we expect to drop this coming year, which will assist us as far as cash flows are concerned. From a sustaining capital perspective, we are guiding in the order of about ZAR 110 million for 2019 for Barberton, and then about ZAR 40 million of expansionary capital, which is mostly further work on Royal Sheba, and then also work that we are doing on the sub-vertical shaft at the Fairview operation.

Justin Chen
Analyst, Nomura Securities

Okay, excellent. That's very helpful on that. Then just looking at Elikhulu and going forward, when you integrate ETRP into it, do you have additional tailings sources that you're looking at potentially bringing in or that you could purchase regionally to add to that?

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Certainly. We have secured pretty much all of the Evander Basin. There are very few opportunities on the East Rand as far as tailings are concerned. Our focus there will be to optimize the throughput for the combined Elikhulu ETRP and obviously maximize profits. Unfortunately, there's not an awful lot of other tailings in that area that would make sense. The West Rand is a different story. We have been looking at opportunities as far as the West Rand is concerned, it's early days.

Justin Chen
Analyst, Nomura Securities

Okay. No, thanks. That's helpful. Just from a strategic perspective, have you considered adding additional regional tailings businesses as a source of, you could call it external growth?

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Sure. Tailings, certainly I don't want to say that it's an easy business, because that would be a big disservice to our guys that do an excellent job in terms of running the surface tailings. Compared to mining two and a half kilometers underground, it's a whole lot more sustainable. It is a lot easier, safer, and certainly more profitable. I do think we will have license to look at expanding our tailings portfolio. It's a large chunk of our portfolio now. It has to make sense for our shareholders. Again, the shareholders have to see the returns. It's not about production, it's about profits, and it's about returns.

Justin Chen
Analyst, Nomura Securities

Okay. Thanks very much, Cobus. I'll free the line for other people to get their questions in.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Thanks.

Operator

Thanks, gentlemen. I'll take the questions from the lines.

Cobus Loots
CEO, Pan African Resources

Thank you very much for all of you that attended in person and on the conference call, we look forward to having a snack afterwards. Thank you very much.