Chorus Aviation Inc. (TSX:CHR)
Canada flag Canada · Delayed Price · Currency is CAD
22.98
-0.39 (-1.67%)
Apr 28, 2026, 4:00 PM EST
← View all transcripts

Earnings Call: Q3 2019

Nov 14, 2019

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by, and welcome to the Chorus Aviation Inc. Third Quarter 2019 Earnings Analyst Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speaker's presentation, there will be a question-and-answer session. To ask a question during the session, you will need to press star one on your telephone. If you require any further assistance, please press star zero. I would now like to hand the conference over to your speaker today, Nathalie Megann, Vice President of Investor Relations and Corporate Affairs. Please go ahead.

Nathalie Megann
VP of Investor Relations and Corporate Affairs, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Thank you, Kenzie. Hello, and thank you for joining us today for our Third Quarter 2019 Conference Call and Audio Webcast. With me today from Chorus are Joe Randell, President and Chief Executive Officer, and Gary Osborne, Chief Financial Officer. We'll start by giving a brief overview of the results and then go on to questions from the analyst community. Because some of the discussion in this call may be forward-looking, I direct your attention to the caution regarding forward-looking statements and information, which are subject to various risks, uncertainties, and assumptions that are included or referenced on page 44 of our Management's Discussion and Analysis of the results and operations of Chorus Aviation Inc. for the period ended September 30, 2019. The outlook section and other sections of our MD&A where such statements appear.

In addition, some of the following discussion involves certain non-GAAP financial measures, including references to EBITDA, adjusted EBITDA, adjusted EBT, and adjusted net income. Please refer to section 17 of our MD&A for a discussion related to the use of such non-GAAP measures. I'll now turn the call over to Joe Randell.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Thank you, Nathalie. Good morning, everyone. Since becoming publicly traded in 2006, we've reported 54 consecutive profitable quarters. Today, I'm pleased to share with you yet another. With over 90% of our revenues secured through long-term contracts, our business is predictable and transparent. We currently have a minimum of approximately $2.5 billion in future contracted revenue, inclusive of the $0.6 billion of CPA fixed margin. As such, our business delivered results that once again met our expectations, and we made advancements in growing our leasing business. We've been extremely busy since our last quarter report out, having acquired or delivered 17 aircraft in our regional aircraft leasing segment. This was a tremendous accomplishment by our team and a clear demonstration of our technical and transactional bench strength. I commend our employees for their professionalism.

These recent deliveries account for approximately 22% of our non-CPA committed fleet to date. Our revenues are starting to reflect the new leases we've added to our portfolio. This trend is expected to continue as our leasing business grows and aircraft are delivered. Our diversification strategy is taking hold, as evidenced by the 76% increase in adjusted earnings before tax, or EBT, generated by this segment over the same period in 2018, accounting now for approximately 22% of overall adjusted EBT. I'm very encouraged by this growth and the strength of our team. We further demonstrated the capabilities of our maturing aircraft leasing business when we completed our first sale of leased assets with the divestiture of three Dash 8-400s that had been on lease since July of 2017.

We're very pleased with this transaction, as it not only provided a positive return on our investment, it generated capital to reinvest in future aircraft acquisitions, an indication of our disciplined approach to maximize returns. Finally, the growth momentum in our leasing business continued as we welcomed a new customer, Malindo Air, a member of the Lion Air Group, with a lease of 2 ATR 72-600s and the acquisition of 2 existing ATR 72-600s already on lease from another lessor. These aircraft further expand our reach into the rapidly growing Southeast Asian market. We have a healthy pipeline and expect to have news of additional lease transactions soon.

As relayed in the last quarter, we also have the capacity to grow our leasing portfolio by up to 20 aircraft per year through a combination of new debt and internally generated cash flows to fund the equity portion of future aircraft acquisitions. Gary will have more to say about this in his comments. We take a process-driven, conservative approach to building our leasing business. Our objective is to maintain a diversified customer base with good prospects, seek geographic diversification, and limit aircraft type concentration. As has been proven in the past, regional aviation is a resilient sector of the aviation industry. As a CPA operator, we do not bear the commercial risks or exposure to fluctuations in fuel price as these are managed by Air Canada. Further, our CPA is provisions for minimum guarantees related to fleet size and fixed fees.

Due to the predictable nature of our contracted revenues, the quality of our customers, and our resilient market sector, we are well positioned to seize new opportunities to profitably grow and diversify. I'll conclude my remarks by extending congratulations to the team of Voyager for winning Business of the Year Award from the North Bay Chamber of Commerce and to the Jazz team for being named amongst Canada's Safest Employers 2019, taking gold in the transportation category. These are wonderful acknowledgements of our professionalism. Many thanks to the Chorus team for delivering another safe and solid quarter. Thank you, and I'll now pass the line over to Gary to take you through the Third Quarter financial results.

Gary Osborne
CFO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Thank you, Joe, and good morning. Our group of companies had strong performance in the third quarter. Period-over-period, Adjusted EBITDA grew by CAD 5.8 million, in large part due to a 78% increase in Adjusted EBITDA in the regional aircraft leasing segment, with 12 leasing transactions closing in the quarter. Adjusted earnings per share grew by 12.5% from the second quarter of this year, in large part due to a 76% increase in earnings before tax in the regional aircraft leasing segment. We continue to have solid operating results at Voyager and Jazz, which includes the completion of two ESPs on the Dash 8-300s that now generate revenue under the CPA. Here's how the third quarter compares to the same period last year. We reported Adjusted EBITDA of CAD 92.6 million and an increase of CAD 5.8 million, or 6.7%, relative to the third quarter of 2018.

The regional aircraft leasing segment's Adjusted EBITDA increased by CAD 13.2 million related to the growth in the number of aircraft on lease. In addition to the aircraft deliveries in the quarter, we also completed our first sale of leased assets on October 25, being three Dash 8-400s that were on lease since 2017 for net proceeds of approximately $25 million after debt repayment. The regional aircraft services segment Adjusted EBITDA decreased CAD 7.4 million, partially offsetting the previously described increase. The regional aviation services segment results were in line with expectations and reflect the 2019 CPA amendments, which reduced the fixed margin and performance incentive revenue when Chorus moved to market-based compensation rates. These reductions were partially offset by the implementation of the controllable cost guardrail that mitigated the expected Third Quarter CPA margin shortfall related to reduced fees.

Beyond the changes related to the amended CPA, the third quarter results were impacted by a decreased stock-based compensation of CAD 2.1 million due to the change in share price and increased aircraft leasing under the CPA. Adjusted net income for the quarter was CAD 29.2 million, or CAD 0.18 per basic share, a decrease from 2018 of CAD 1.6 million, or 5.2%.

That was due to an increase in depreciation of CAD 4.6 million, primarily related to the additional aircraft in the regional aircraft leasing segment, an increase in net interest costs of CAD 3.8 million, primarily related to aircraft debt in the regional aircraft leasing segment, and an increase in non-operating costs of CAD 0.2 million related to a loss on disposal of property and equipment, offset by foreign exchange losses on working capital, offset by the CAD 5.8 million increase in adjusted EBITDA previously described, and CAD 1.2 million decrease in income tax expense related to lower adjusted EBT. Net income was CAD 24.2 million, or CAD 0.15 per basic share, a decrease of CAD 0.6 million over the 2018 period, excluding the quarter-over-quarter change in net unrealized foreign exchange losses on long-term debt of CAD 18.9 million.

The decrease was due to the previously noted CAD 1.6 million decrease in adjusted net income, offset by decreased employee separation costs of CAD 1 million. We ended the third quarter with a solid cash position of CAD 82 million. As mentioned last quarter, we had the capacity to grow our regional aircraft leasing segment by up to 20 aircraft per year through accommodation of new debt and internally generated cash flows. We will use these resources to fund the equity portion of future aircraft acquisitions in addition to the delivery of 9 CRJ900s in 2020 and 8 remaining ESPs to be completed by the year 2022. We will bolster our cash position through new debt raises as required to fund this growth. As has been our practice, we manage costs against the objectives of remaining within market acceptable ranges of leverage and maintaining adequate financial flexibility.

With the addition of the aircraft under both the regional aircraft leasing segment and the aircraft leasing revenue under the CPA, Chorus's estimated future contracted lease revenue is approximately $1.9 billion. When the CPA margin revenue of $0.6 million is included with the total future contracted revenue, Chorus's future revenue approximates $2.5 billion. Capital expenditures for 2019, including capitalized major maintenance overhauls and excluding expenditures for the acquisition of aircraft and the ESP, are expected to be between CAD 41 million and CAD 47 million. Aircraft-related acquisitions and the ESP capital expenditures in 2019 are expected to be between CAD 660 million and CAD 670 million related to the previously announced transactions. For additional information supporting our outlook for the balance of this year, I'll refer you to Section 4, the 2019 Outlook section of our MD&A for the period ended September 30, 2019. That concludes my commentary. Thank you for listening.

Operator, we can open the call to questions from our analyst community when ready.

Operator

At this time, I would like to remind everyone, in order to ask a question, please press star, then the number one on your telephone keypad. Again, that is star, then the number one on your telephone keypad. Our first question comes from the line of Konark Gupta with Scotiabank. Your line is open.

Konark Gupta
Analyst, Scotiabank

Thanks, and good morning, everyone. I just wanted to start with the sale of three Q400 aircraft that I think took place in October. So you mentioned there's $25 million net proceeds after debt repayment, but would there be any EBITDA impact in Q4? And what do you plan to do with the proceeds? Is it going to be deployed into new aircraft purchase?

Gary Osborne
CFO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Hi, it's Gary Osborne here. As far as the transaction, it will have a minor impact to our overall EBITDA and results in Q4. We're still working through those numbers due to the structure of that transaction. As far as the funds go, they'll be redeployed back into future leasing transactions, so we're going to plow that right back into the business.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Yeah, and if I could just add a little color to that as well. The business is really a trading business. It's an integral part of the business. And our customer was interested in acquiring the aircraft. And at the end, we achieved, excuse me, a better return with the combination of the sale and the opportunity to reinvest the proceeds in the business in terms of future aircraft acquisitions. So overall, we were very pleased with the transaction.

Konark Gupta
Analyst, Scotiabank

Okay, thanks. Thanks for that. And then following up just on the leasing side, so you mentioned there's 6 aircraft transactions since the end of Third Quarter, of which 5 have been received prior to November 13. I just wanted to clarify the table that you have in the MD&A. It has numbers which show, I think, 2 transactions in Q4 and 1 in Q1. So how do you reconcile all this? Do we see more leasing transactions happening beyond what you have suggested in the MD&A?

Gary Osborne
CFO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Yeah, so I guess if you look at that table, it includes the reduction due to Falcon 3. So essentially, if you take that into account, there would have been five in Q4 that are listed there. And then as far as the future transactions go, one with Winair, that's what we have announced to date. And I think we're certainly continuing to work through the pipeline, and we expect that we'll have future announcements in the near future.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Yeah, so essentially, the five that are pending that are shown in Q4, four of those five now have been delivered. Yeah.

Konark Gupta
Analyst, Scotiabank

Okay, thanks. And lastly for me, on the customer side of things, so have you seen any deterioration due to either economic conditions or some other issues? Any changes in customers' credit quality or ratings, be it in Europe or elsewhere?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

No, we've not seen any significant changes. We're still very much the same as when we entered into these transactions with these various operators. Demand continues to be robust. In our pipeline, future possible transactions look good. We hope to be in a position soon to make more announcements in that regard. We've not really seen any changes in the market in the regional aviation segment.

Gary Osborne
CFO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Just so I'm clear here again, just to reiterate, we do monitor our lessees actively. We keep a good eye on all their credit portfolios, and we're quite pleased with where they're at right now.

Konark Gupta
Analyst, Scotiabank

Okay, thanks a lot for that. That's it for me.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Thank you.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Doug Taylor with Canaccord Genuity. Your line is open.

Doug Taylor
Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

Yes, thank you. Good morning. I'll start by adding my congratulations to you, Joe, on your pending Hall of Fame induction. That was an announcement. Let me drill down a little bit more on the decision to exit the lease of these aircraft. Based on what you just said, can you just confirm you were approached about these particular aircraft? Are you actively looking at making any other changes or augmentations to your portfolio that might involve you exiting aircraft or rebalancing the portfolio in some way regionally or by airframe?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Yeah, in this case, the customer, the ultimate customer, approached us, and we were pleased to oblige. And I think it worked out very well. We got through the transaction very quickly. It generated good cash. And we felt overall that the redeployment of that cash and other opportunities would provide us with a better return. So that was really a motivating factor on our side. So it was really a win-win. We'll continue to look at opportunities to trade. We have nothing pending in that regard, etc. But it is very much a trading business. As you know, we've purchased aircraft from other lessors because they wanted to rebalance or felt they could better deploy the cash that they would develop as a result of that. So we'll continue to do the same. So it isn't all about just acquisition.

It's about trading, and it's about maximizing returns on your investment.

Doug Taylor
Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

You mentioned that EBITDA will obviously be impacted as those aircraft exit the fleet in Q4. Do you expect them to recognize a gain of some sort on the exit versus your book value of those aircraft?

Gary Osborne
CFO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

We are still working through the details of that transaction, but we don't expect anything to be material as far as gain or loss, so.

Doug Taylor
Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

So obviously, in a quarter like the one that you've just exited with, the volume of aircraft coming in, timing of when those aircraft comes in has a pretty big impact, I think, on the profitability within that quarter. Could you comment a little bit on how the deliveries were spread over the course of the quarter? I'm just looking for a little help in terms of the linearity or the sequential impact of the existing portfolio Q3 to Q4.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Yeah, we're just looking that up right now. I believe August was a very, very busy month in terms of the completion of some of the releases. So, Gary.

Gary Osborne
CFO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Yeah, I think just on page 28 of the MD&A, it lists the dates there, by and large, of when everything came in during the at least post the quarter. And as far as the other deliveries during the quarter, it was almost midpoint. It wasn't quite skewed to midpoint. I think it was a little bit on the back end of the quarter if you divided Q3 in half.

Doug Taylor
Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

So fairly well balanced then. Okay.

Gary Osborne
CFO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Yeah, fairly well. I mean, once you work it all out, it's pretty balanced.

Doug Taylor
Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

Okay, last question for me. Obviously, you've got a lot more scale now with your leasing business, and the interest rate environment would appear to be favorable. I mean, can you comment on your ability to lower the debt cost side of the equation, at least at the margins over in the near term with either the existing or aircraft-related debt or some of the other facilities that you've now put in place?

Gary Osborne
CFO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Well, as far as the aircraft goes that we have in the regional segment, regional leasing segment, those aircraft are generally backed by asset-backed debt. So they're fixed-term debt, and they're set. So those interest rates are essentially baked in. And if you remember, the lease rates associated with those lessees did move with that debt, so it preserves the margin. So at this stage, we don't actively look at trying to reset that debt because it is nicely matched with the lessee contracts. And as we move ahead with the interest rate environment where it's been and it's been on the lower side, as we know, that will certainly help the lease rates come down for our lessees. The margins will remain similar because that's the way the industry works. You bake in your margin there.

We see it as good for the lessees, good for us in that sense, but we don't have an active program where we're going to look at relooking at the debt that we've assigned per lessee.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

But going forward, we will be actively looking at how we reduce our cost of capital.

Gary Osborne
CFO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Absolutely.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Because that's a key factor in this business.

Doug Taylor
Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

Yeah, and that's.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

There will be more options, we believe, in terms of how we finance the business.

Doug Taylor
Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

Yeah, that's encouraging. I mean, I'll just ask one more question there. I mean, the last time we had the debt or interest rates environment that we are starting to see again, there seemed to be an increased competition, particularly on the narrow body side in terms of chasing down the lease rates and the returns. Have you observed any change in the return, the ROE profile, I'll say, given where the interest rates are and are moving in the new deals that you've signed?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

No, we're generally still targeting what we had originally planned on. It's a competitive environment. We chase a lot of potential opportunities to come up with what we put together in our portfolio here. But we've not seen a huge influx of new capital into the regional aircraft leasing business. I think it remains a very stable segment. We do realize that there's more pressure, especially on the wide body side and some on the narrow body. But again, currently, we're not seeing that same sort of abundance of capital really flowing into this business.

Doug Taylor
Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

Thank you very much.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Okay.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Walter Spracklin with RBC. Your line is open.

Walter Spracklin
Analyst, RBC

Thanks very much. Good morning, everyone.

Gary Osborne
CFO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Good morning, Walter.

Walter Spracklin
Analyst, RBC

So I want to start with, you mentioned 20 per year that you indicated before of self-funded growth in new leases. When you look at your pipeline right now, certainly in the near term, would you say that that is pretty much lined up with what you would expect to do in the next 12 months, or would you expect it to be higher or lower compared to that self-funded target?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

With the pipeline that we see right now, we anticipate no issue in growing by 20 airplanes as we've said.

Walter Spracklin
Analyst, RBC

Perfect. Okay. Now, should you go by grow more than 20, then what's been your targeted approach? Do you think your most favorable approach for funding that excess?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Well, right now, we're focused on the 20 and to deliver on the results. I think next year, we will see a lot of these leases kicking in with our earnings. I think that will and should produce an upswing in our share price, etc. And we are going to monitor what happens as we build these earnings into the company's results and look then at how we grow the business further. But for now, we're saying steady as it goes, 20 aircraft per year. We have the ability to fund that. We're going to continue executing. It's very stable. I think we've got a great portfolio of customers, a great equipment mix. And for us, it's just about performing. As we've said, we will perform, and then we will reevaluate.

I think the opportunities are greater in the business, but we are using a very disciplined approach in the interest of our shareholders.

Doug Taylor
Analyst, Canaccord Genuity

That makes a lot of sense. So in terms of the aircraft types that you're focused on right now and any emerging opportunities in those, we've talked a bit about the Airbus A220. Any update as to how you look at the type of aircraft that will be part of your portfolio, and have you leaned more toward expanding the number of types?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Well, first of all, we really like turboprops. From a residual value perspective and the stability of that part of the business and that, we think it's a great segment of the business. They are not replaceable by other types of equipment at all very easily in most markets, etc. So we'll continue to focus on the turboprop side, but certainly on the regional jet side, we're monitoring very carefully what happens with the Embraer product as it evolves from the E1 to the E2 product. The Embraer E2s are definitely within our scope and focus. The A220s, I've said that previously, are very much in our focus. And we like the 75-130-seat regional jet market, and especially some of the newer products. We are not heavily exposed with respect to the older technology, Embraers or the CRJs in our portfolio.

For instance, the CRJs that we operate for Air Canada, which where most of our Bombardier product on the regional jet side is, are secured through long-term leases operated through the CPA. We're very comfortable with that. We see and we do see opportunities to grow, especially in the newer technology regional jet market.

Walter Spracklin
Analyst, RBC

If you were to go to the A220, is the Air Canada option already kind of passed? Have they fully allocated how they're going to be financing that? Or could that be, if you were to get into the A220, could it be through the relationship with Air Canada?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

I'm sure as to where Air Canada is in terms of funding these acquisitions, etc. But we are interested in leasing the aircraft, but I can't really say any more than that in terms of Air Canada's plans on how they would finance their fleet.

Walter Spracklin
Analyst, RBC

Fair enough. Okay. Now, I don't think that the issues that were with the MAX really impacted your business, and correct me if I'm wrong. Now that there is at least discussion of it possibly coming back maybe in the near term, any reason why that would have any impact at all on your business?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

No. First of all, the impact that the MAX has had on our business, first of all, it hasn't had a financial impact on our business. But we were extremely busy in Jazz flying for Air Canada, increased utilization. Our block hours were up substantially in the quarter year-over-year as we increased the utilization on the fleet and on our flight crews, etc. But under the structure of the CPA, of course, we are paid a fixed fee, and we delivered that product to Air Canada at its request to assist with that difficult situation, and we continue to do so. As the MAX comes back, I think there will be a lot of changes in the pilot world as Air Canada introduces more aircraft and grows its operation. And of course, we continue to provide Air Canada with a lot of pilots.

We work closely with Air Canada in the transition of the pilots. 60% of Air Canada's new hires in the pilot side will come from Jazz. We anticipate that to be very busy with pilot flow next year, etc. In terms of impact on our bottom line, etc., it's now been de-risked, very predictable, as I said earlier. We're just there as a good partner to do whatever we can to assist Air Canada.

Walter Spracklin
Analyst, RBC

Okay, that's all my questions. Thanks very much.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Thanks, Walter.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Cameron Duerksen with National Bank. Your line is open.

Cameron Duerksen
Analyst, National Bank

Yeah, thanks. Good morning. Just a question on the, I guess, the cash debt repayments. If I look at the, I guess, the current long-term debt, roughly CAD 185 million or so, which you'd have to principally, you'd have to repay over the next 12 months, and that's as of the end of Q3. I'm just wondering if you can give us some indication as to what the 2020 kind of principal repayment might be given some of the transactions you've kind of concluded at the end of the quarter. Should we expect it to kind of creep, assuming the fleet and plans stay as it is, should we expect that to kind of creep towards the CAD 200 million mark in 2020?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

I guess as far as your modeling goes there, if you look at the current debt in that, there is one balloon in there for, I think, about CAD 15 million in the next year that we expect to refinance. So if you take that out and then just model it with the aircraft acquisitions, it should move directionally with that. I don't have an exact number to give you for 2020, but if you did something like that, it would give you a pretty good indication.

As far as our free cash flow and how we generate, if you look at the quarter and you start to assess that with the debt repayments and the cash flow from operations, I think you can get a pretty good you can see that the stream of inflows will certainly more than match and be greater than the outflows related to the debt.

Cameron Duerksen
Analyst, National Bank

Okay. Okay. No, that's helpful. Maybe just a second question from me. Just wondering if you can give us an update on the Voyager business, how the business is performing in the last quarter and prospects for additional contracts and things there.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Yeah. Voyager performed well in the quarter. The results have certainly improved at Voyager. It's meeting our expectations. They're very busy with aircraft modifications, the MRO business. It's being fully utilized, and we're growing some aspects of that business. It's not going to have a hugely material impact on results, but it really is strategically important to us for a number of reasons in that it really supports our third-party leasing business, but also the Jazz business, etc. And the demand for contract flying has been good with contracts being renewed, etc. So it's very much steady as it goes. And we're very optimistic about Voyager, though, and its impact going forward as really being a strategic enabler for us. So we're very pleased with the way the business is performing in North Bay.

Cameron Duerksen
Analyst, National Bank

Okay. No, that's great. Thanks very much.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Tim James with TD Securities. Your line is open.

Tim James
Analyst, TD Securities

Thanks. Thank you very much. Good morning.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Good morning.

Tim James
Analyst, TD Securities

First question on the CPA. I'm just wondering how we should think about the use of the guardrails in the CPA in the quarter. Does that mean costs were higher than expected and margins slightly lower, and that's why those guardrails were triggered? Maybe you could just refresh us on how that works. Do you basically get a revenue boost to offset any higher costs?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Yeah. So the way it works is it's $2 million annually plus or minus that the guardrails kicks in. So if you look at the way it worked in the quarter, any excess of the cost or the revenue would have been caught up with the guardrails given where the first quarter of the year we were a bit behind. And then likewise, had we overperformed, we would have reduced our revenue by the same amount. And if you look at what you're seeing is certainly a good quarter as far as performance in the CPA, and then you're measuring 2019 obviously against 2018, which was a different economic formula. Yeah. And of course, costs were running very high in the third quarter because of all the increased flying we were doing for Air Canada, etc. But all of that is basically covered. That's right.

The way it works, the way that works is that with the Air Canada extra flying and whatnot, we would bill Air Canada the rates under the CPA, and they would pay us as such, and then we would do the comparison back against the cost. As we did extra flying, if there's extra costs, it gets picked up in that guardrail.

Tim James
Analyst, TD Securities

So your reference earlier then to there being no financial impact from all the extra flying related to the MAX issue is because of these guardrails, which kind of brought you back into that ±$2 million range?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

You got it. Yeah. The impact is not significant on the bottom line at all, but it very much affects your revenues and expenses.

Tim James
Analyst, TD Securities

Yeah. Okay. Okay. That's helpful. Then just a general sort of very long-term question thinking about your cost structure here. Joe, could you give us kind of your updated thought on how we, as kind of outsiders, monitoring the long-term cost structure of Jazz and the provision of the CPA services, how we should think about the cost structure or monitor it to be comfortable with the competitiveness relative to peers and therefore the relevance to Air Canada? Is it best to look at it sort of trends in a cost per block hour, or how would you recommend we watch that?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Well, I'd say you have to break the cost down into the various buckets. The leasing costs are market. The third-party maintenance costs, the engine overhauls, etc., are all done at market rates. And really, the controllable part of the cost from our point of view would really be more in the direct labor side. And then I'd point you to the collective agreements that we have in place with the pilots. The agreement goes out to 2035. And so very predictable. The costs are very predictable, which is, of course, I think one of the influencing factors with Air Canada in terms of entering into a long-term agreement. And our other labor agreements have been brought in line with respect to it being industry competitive. And a number of those agreements still go for a number of years, etc.

Those costs then, as we renegotiate the agreements, we'll be discussing those with Air Canada. I think we're provided to cover those costs. We will be in, I think, reasonably good shape with respect to the market. These are things that are addressed in the CPA and make labor costs very predictable going forward. I think that's really the check. I think if you look at block hour costs and that, you can compare those, I guess, vis-à-vis other regional operators. It's a fair comparison. We don't anticipate to be offside with respect to the competitiveness of our costs. In fact, just to kind of reiterate, we work very well with Air Canada. We're on the cost side, and the finance and the operational groups are all linked at the hip. They understand the cost.

The problem with block hour type costs and things like that, deployment, geographic deployment, things like that affect it. We work with Air Canada. They understand our costs. We understand them, obviously, very well. We're quite comfortable with where we're at. As far as the benchmarking and that sort of thing goes, it's very difficult, I think, from the outside looking in. But I can tell you that we work very well with Air Canada, and we are very cost-focused. We actually provide Air Canada with many more services than most CPA partners do as well. We do heavy maintenance, as an example. We do airport operations throughout Canada, whereas other CPA operators are really purely flight crew and maintenance. When you look at our costs, our costs really bring in all these other costs as well.

When you do the comparisons, it's always important that you do apples to apples.

Tim James
Analyst, TD Securities

Okay. That's very helpful. Thank you.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Thanks.

Operator

As a reminder, if you would like to ask a question, please press star, then the number one on your telephone keypad. Our next question comes from the line of Kevin Chiang with CIBC. Your line is open.

Kevin Chiang
Analyst, CIBC

Good morning. Thanks for taking my question. And again, congrats, Joe, on the induction there. I think you might have mentioned this earlier. I might have just missed it. Talking about the options around your debt financing, I think on the Q2 call, you mentioned you were looking or exploring looking at the unsecured market. If you can provide an update there. And does that change how many that 20 aircraft number? If you move to the unsecured market with a little bit more flexibility, could you, in theory, acquire more aircraft in a year with a more favorable debt instrument in place?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

We're still interested in the unsecured market, as you alluded to. We're looking at that market, and we're certainly interested in it. We'd continue to fund our 20 aircraft a year. I think back to the point I think I made on the call earlier, we continue to monitor our debt levels to make sure that we stay within industry norms and whatnot. With that in mind, whatever instrument we raise, we're going to stay within those metrics.

Kevin Chiang
Analyst, CIBC

Okay. Do you have a sense if that's something that could be completed in 2020, or is this still kind of in the early innings of the evaluation?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

So we're actively pursuing that. So it's part of our growth strategy. And as you see, we're really deploying our cash very well. So we want to continue to keep this pace. So we're looking to do it in such a way that it would allow us to do that. So as I said, announcements and that sort of thing, stay tuned.

Kevin Chiang
Analyst, CIBC

Okay. And maybe just last one for me. In terms of your charter flying, with your leasing business having obviously exhibited strong growth here, it seems like people are pretty comfortable with the trajectory and the risk profile. What do you see on the charter flying side in terms of opportunities? It seems like it's also something you're incubating here. Is that something you think you can grow much more significantly and maybe entering into markets on the contract flying side that you currently don't service?

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Yeah. Yeah. It's in our DNA, basically, contract flying. And the type of contract flying we do is quite varied from everything from the CPA operation with Air Canada to flying for the World Food Programme in Africa. And this is where, of course, Voyager has an enormous amount of experience in terms of special mission flying, etc. And the whole concept of using contract flying is really a focus of ours. And in other segments of the business are of interest to us on the contract flying side as well. But again, we're going to take a pretty measured, disciplined approach. But we see opportunities in that regard, and we certainly have the know-how to deliver on those services.

Kevin Chiang
Analyst, CIBC

Thank you very much.

Joseph Randell
President and CEO, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Okay. Thank you.

Operator

There are no further telephone questions at this time. I now turn the call back to Nathalie Megann for closing remarks.

Nathalie Megann
VP of Investor Relations and Corporate Affairs, Chorus Aviation Inc.

Thank you, Operator. We'll now conclude the call, and we thank you all for taking the time with us today. Have a great day.

Operator

This concludes today's conference call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.

Powered by