Plaza Retail REIT (TSX:PLZ.UN)
Canada flag Canada · Delayed Price · Currency is CAD
5.23
0.00 (0.00%)
Sep 14, 2026, 4:00 PM EST
← View all transcripts

Earnings Call: Q4 2018

Feb 28, 2019

Operator

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you for standing by. I would like to welcome everyone to the Plaza Retail REIT Fourth Quarter 2018 Earnings Conference Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. Following the presentation, we will conduct a question and answer session. Instructions will be provided at that time for you to queue up for questions. If anyone has difficulties hearing the conference, please press star zero for operator assistance at any time. I would like to advise everyone that this conference is being recorded. I will now turn the conference over to Mr. Michael Zakuta, Plaza's Chief Executive Officer. Please go ahead, Mr. Zakuta.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Thank you, operator. Good morning. Thank you for joining us on our Q4 2018 results conference call. I am legally obliged to tell you that today's discussion includes forward-looking statements. We would like to caution you that such statements are based on management's assumptions and beliefs. These forward-looking statements are subject to uncertainty and other factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from such statements. Please refer to Plaza's public filings for a discussion of these risk factors. In 2018, we sacrificed the short-term for medium and long-term gain. We are real estate entrepreneurs operating in a public market environment. We have taken a real estate-first approach to our decision-making. We invested CAD 85 million in new developments, redevelopments, and high-yield structured deals. This was a record year for new investment for Plaza. We sold non-core assets for proceeds of CAD 37 million.

This capital recycling temporarily reduces NOI and FFO due to the lag between asset sales and the reinvestment of these proceeds in new developments and redevelopments. We look forward to the benefits of the reallocation of capital that will ultimately provide growth and create value for unitholders. Plaza's pipeline remains strong. We foresee continued growth and opportunity for both redevelopments and new development projects. We are pursuing a number of joint venture initiatives with various types of partners, such as residential land developers with excess retail lands and institutions and property owners seeking a strong and capable development partner such as Plaza. We will continue to recycle capital in order to fund our growth, and we will pursue structured deals with private institutional-style investors. We expect that we will recycle in the range of CAD 25 million- CAD 30 million in 2019.

One-third of this amount will come from the sale of non-core assets and two-thirds from property refinancing proceeds. We are continuing to see large retail property owners working to exit all but the big six markets in Canada. This trend has created a temporary oversupply of retail assets in certain regions. Plaza has been able to execute on several opportunities to purchase income-producing assets with value-add potential at attractive prices. We see this sell-off continuing through 2019, and we are excited about the prospect of acquiring more properties with upside potential at compelling going yields. At the recent ICSC conference in Whistler, our leasing team met 66 different retailers or their representatives during the two-day event. The majority of retailers present were looking to open stores or improve their locations. They will be described as value, specialty, or necessity-based retailers.

We had no discussions about rent reduction or meetings about retailers wanting to get out their leases. In 2018, we were burdened with the comparison and the impact of lease termination deals that we made in 2017. We anticipated that we'll be burdening ourselves once again. In the first half of 2019, we expect to conclude lease termination deals that will generate in the order of CAD 5.5 million. After incurring the cost of downtime and the installation of replacement tenants, we expect to make a substantial profit from these transactions. Plaza's unit price has been significantly impacted by investors exiting retail REITs across North America as they maintain a negative view of bricks and mortar retail. We believe that many of the reasons for this strong exit are not relevant to Plaza.

Our properties are typically smaller and very community-centric, attracting customers on a regular basis as they conduct their pre- and post-work routines. Plaza's tenant lineup features value, specialty, and necessity-based retailers that require a local physical presence. Plaza possesses strong leasing and development infrastructures and can seize interesting growth opportunities. We have always focused on developing or redeveloping properties for value, specialty, and necessity-based retailers. Over the years, we've built a stable and geographically diversified portfolio to support our monthly distributions. We are confident that our value-add business model is poised to take advantage of current retail trends and will create significant value for our unitholders. I will now turn the call over to Floriana Cipollone , Plaza's Chief Financial Officer, who will provide you with a brief summary of our results for the quarter and the year.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Thanks, Michael. For the fourth quarter, funds from operations or FFO per unit was down 3.7%, and adjusted funds from operations or AFFO per unit was down 5.3% from the same period in 2017. Positively impacting FFO and AFFO per unit for the quarter was considerable growth in net property operating income or NOI of CAD 1 million from developments, redevelopments, and acquisitions, offset by a large decrease in NOI from property sales of half a million.

Some lease buyout revenues recorded in the prior year and higher interest expense in the current year, mainly due to the record amount invested in developments, redevelopments, and acquisitions. For the year, impacting the results was CAD 1.7 million in lease buyout revenues recorded in the prior year. Excluding this and other non-recurring items, FFO per unit would've been 1.7% higher than the prior year, mainly from net growth in NOI. Notably, NOI grew by CAD 3.6 million from developments, redevelopments, and acquisitions, well in excess of CAD 1.8 million in lost NOI due to a large amount of property dispositions. Excluding the non-recurring items, AFFO per unit for the year would've only been 2.3% lower than the prior year, impacted by higher leasing costs related to new tenancies.

Total NOI was up 1.6% for the quarter and up 2.4% for the year-to-date, excluding the impact of the lease buyout revenues recorded in the prior year. Same-asset NOI was down by 5.7% for the quarter and was up 0.1% for the year-to-date, excluding the impact of the lease buyouts. Same-asset NOI for the quarter was impacted by higher operating costs and maintenance expenses, particularly at Plaza's enclosed malls. Same-asset NOI for the year-to-date was impacted by new lease-up and rent increases in the portfolio, partly offset by bad debt expense recorded due to a tenant going into creditor protection and vacancies at one of Plaza's enclosed malls. Plaza is in the process of stabilizing the occupancy at the one enclosed mall. Occupancy at that mall is up 5% from December 31, 2017, and rents from some new tenants have commenced late in the fourth quarter of this year.

Those are the key points relating to our financial results for Q4 2018. With that, we will now proceed to open up the lines for any questions. Operator?

Operator

Okay, thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we will now conduct a question-and-answer session. If you have a question, please press star, followed by the number one on your touch-tone phone. You will hear a one-tone prompt acknowledging your request. Your questions will be polled in the order they are received. If you would like to decline from polling process, please press star. Please ensure you lift your handset if you are using a speakerphone before pressing any keys. One moment for your first question, please. Your first question comes from Jenny Ma from BMO Capital Markets. Your line is open.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Hi. Good morning, Michael and Floriana.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Good morning.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

I couldn't help but notice the weighted average cap rate on the IFRS moved quite a bit. I think you guys were stable at 7% for the longest time. It looks like it was small increases pretty much across the board. Can you give us a little bit more color on what led to that and sort of when you think about the magnitude and the locations, just a little bit of color to help us understand that move in cap rates and why at this time in particular?

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

I don't know if I can give you the appropriate color in terms of why this time in particular. We are quarterly getting updates from an updated matrix on cap rates. We certainly have discussions with the evaluators about cap rates on a regular basis. I think a lot of the increases is coming from secondary markets. That's where most of the increases are coming from. I think a lot of it is due to some of the oversupply at the moment that's out there with sales from some of the other REITs in secondary markets. I guess now they've got maybe some additional data points to point to when they're putting their matrices together. That would be kind of the color that I'm seeing.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

It's really..

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

It does appear to be a big jump in one quarter, but I think it's just more data points really.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay. It's really in response to actual transactions we've seen as opposed to sort of a preemptive move on a view of the secondary markets.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

There's always some of that. I think there's always been some of that within the evaluators putting together their matrices. In my mind, that's always out there, but I do think that the increase in Q4 is partly related to more data points.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Jenny, Michael, I have a little bit of a different view. We have a system which we've used now for a number of years where Altus supplies a cap rate matrix, and they give, I think, a low, medium, and a high range of the cap rate. We take the medium. I started to maintain my own list of cap rates based on my knowledge of each property, and we have the Altus number, and then I put in my number, and sometimes we agree, but very often we do not agree. It's a process, and it's supposed to be very objective. Does it reflect true market value? I don't believe so. That's the system, and we live with that system.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Yeah, there's a lot of talk about where the secondary markets will shakeout relative to the primary. Given that you guys more or less specialize in the secondary side, obviously there are some markets that will do just fine, and there are some that will see some weakness. When you assess the markets, couple of questions. Number one is, do you think there are a handful of markets that you're currently in that you think might be on the weaker side that you might look to exit out of? And what proportion of that is in your portfolio? And then number two is when you're looking at new markets to enter, what are the metrics that you look at to measure sort of the medium to longer term attractiveness of a certain market? We don't want to paint all the secondary markets with one brush.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

There's a few questions in there, I'm not sure where I want to start. What we're seeing is the move in cap rates. What we've seen, the large real estate players, some of them REITs, mostly REITs, the product that they're selling into secondary markets is a format which is difficult for a lot of investors to deal with, meaning the deals are larger size.

We've been selling small bite size at very low cap rates, completely different from the cap rates that somebody would be dealing with for a CAD 15 million or CAD 20 million or CAD 40 million acquisition in a secondary market. If you're selling a CAD 1 million property or CAD 1.5 million or CAD 2 million property, we're seeing substantially lower cap rates than we're seeing for CAD 15 million, CAD 25 million, or CAD 40 million property. There's no liquidity in the CAD 10 million and up world.

There is liquidity in the smaller, I call it bite-size style assets, across our geography, small markets or medium markets or large markets.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Is that why the cap rates on the QSR boxes haven't moved, I think they're actually down a touch?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yeah, because we're setting the market. I'm telling you, we're surprised. I tell the disposition guys that if you can get below that number, we're a seller, and all of a sudden, the offers are coming in below that number. I guess there is a very important difference today between small asset cap rates and larger asset cap rates. How will that continue? Who knows?

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

It's real.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay. As far as markets go, are there any within the portfolio that you think will have a little bit of weakness going forward?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Well, we've exited the markets that we don't like.

Maybe have one or two properties in markets that I don't have great belief in. No, we've cleansed the portfolio in our minds. I've talked about this in the past, we have our four-step process. Our first step is the market, and if we don't like the market, we don't go any further in looking at a deal. Sometimes we don't pass the market test. As we pass the market test, we get into locations and vision for the property and numbers. Clearly we're not venturing into markets that we don't believe in. We never have, I don't expect that we will. I don't see why we would change that. We're careful. We're experienced operators. We're very experienced secondary market operators.

I think we know our way around it very well, and we're doing deals based very often on tenant orders, meaning that we have a real tenant seeking a location or seeking to relocate or upgrade somehow, and that's the basis of how we do business as a retail developer.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

What are the metrics that you look for in a market? Are you looking at diversified industries, population growth? What is it that you measure?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Obviously if you get population growth, that's really interesting. We're looking at whether we believe it's sustainable or not. It's often quite clear that some markets are not sustainable and therefore should be avoided. There are small markets that are robust for all kinds of reasons. You tend to see us very often in tourist-related markets, in secondary markets, because they have growth. Where I say tourism, it's not just like PEI tourism, but it's cottage country tourism and stuff like that. That's always been something that we've followed. Clearly, we're looking at every market carefully, and that's often the most difficult part of the decision making is do we believe in the market or not? We have some real debates about that internally.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay, that's helpful. Turning to the residential development. Michael, I know in the past you have mentioned that that's something that you're not interested in doing, certainly not through Plaza directly. Is this a little bit of a shift in your strategy in terms of trying to bring in a partner and getting a little bit of the economics over the duration of the development? Or would you still be more inclined to sort of sell the option to a developer? I'm just trying to think if there's been a little bit of an evolution in Plaza's thinking about how to intensify with res at the sites that have the opportunity.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

I don't think we made any mention of anything change of strategy. We have been involved in residential style projects where we organize a site, we sell the site to the condo developer, we buy back the commercial condo. We've done that successfully. We have sold land that's integrated into a project. Examples in Sherbrooke, Quebec, where we have a very nice property, and in the back corner, Réseau Sélection built a seniors tower. We're actually about to close on a sale of additional lands in that project for a second res tower, which is integrated to the project. It's not integrated to our buildings. It's integrated to our project.

You have to be very careful, and we are looking at some of our mall situations where we think that the residential can be attached. Clearly, there are certain types of res developers that can command higher rents if they're attached to commercial, to retail. We're trying to take advantage of that. That's a slow process, but definitely something that we're looking at. I do not see us being involved in the ownership in any way. I think that's we're renting land or we're selling land. I think that's a different skill set that we would have to develop, and we're not, at this moment in time, prepared to do that.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay. You won't economically expose the REIT to residential development?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

No. You look at the returns, and our returns are a lot stronger. Obviously, there are stronger arguments for being in residential. That's not our strength, and we can't get our heads around the types of returns that one can get. Really, the way to make money, what I see, is that you could develop res, but you have to sell it. We're not interested in that. We're looking for cash flow and for income-producing properties.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay. The res is really just to augment the strength of your commercial properties then?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

To realize on excess land or create additional cash flow if you're able to rent land.

Jenny Ma
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Right. Okay, great. That's fantastic color. Thank you very much.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Thank you.

Operator

Again, ladies and gentlemen, if there's any additional questions at this time, please press star followed by the number one. As a reminder, if you are using a speakerphone, please set the handset before pressing your keys. Your next question comes from Michael Markidis from Desjardins. Your line is open.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Hey, good morning.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Good morning.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

I might have missed it during the opening comments, the CAD 5.5 million of lease termination income this year for the first half certainly stuck out a little bit. Michael, could you give us a little bit more color in terms of potentially who the tenant or tenants are there and the quantity of space?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

We're looking at two deals. The first deal for CAD 1.5 million will be a tenant exiting about 20,000 sq ft. The deal is now conditional on us finishing the replacement tenant. We're not doing this deal without the replacement tenant. Replacement tenant is all negotiated. It's down to the last Really at the end of the deal. I think we're there. That's a very straightforward deal. Second deal is about a 15,000 sq ft building, where we'll be getting present value plus a penalty. That's a somewhat lucrative deal. We don't have a replacement tenant, but we're being paid rent for the next seven years. We're confident that we will get a replacement tenant. We expect to execute that deal in the beginning of the second quarter.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Okay. These are two very isolated incidents then?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yes.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Okay.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Just the numbers are a little bigger than we've seen in the past.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Okay.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

We're just taking advantage of the market.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

No, that's fair. I guess then the associated NOI downtime with that isn't really that material in the grand scheme of your t otal asset base then. What about in terms of incremental capital you'd have to spend to get these new tenants in place? Well, I guess one looks like it's a pretty near-term possibility, and the other one would be potentially a search for a new tenant.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Well, again, we're more than compensated for that. In the first case, on the CAD 1.5 million, we need CAD 500,000 to bring in the new tenant. We need CAD 500,000 to subsidize the difference between what the former tenant was paying the new tenant for a substantial number of years, and the CAD 500,000 is incremental profit. On the second deal, we expect that out of our CAD 4 million payment, we'll spend CAD 500,000 maybe. There may be a subsidy for another CAD 500,000-CAD 1 million, and the balance is profit.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

When you say subsidies, you're saying you anticipate the rents of the new tenants would be somewhat lower than the old tenant?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

That is correct. When we look at these deals, if they have seven or eight years left on the lease, you have to look at if there's a difference of X CAD, we want to be paid for that, and we are paid for that.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Okay. These are two buildings where you think the replacement tenant rent would be lower. Are these two particularly weak properties?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

No

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

I'm just trying to conceptualize how somebody should think about the rents versus market.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

No, they're not. Well, again, I can't say that. The second property, we haven't marketed yet. This deal's come quickly. We think it's a very good location of quality, but I'm being cautious. It's very well located. It's a modern building. It's not a piece of junk. It's really a question of being prudent here.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Okay. Floriana, I really like the table that you guys have. I know it's been there for a while, but on page 14, just showing the NOI contribution of the quarter, then you always show for us what the annualized NOI contribution should be from each bucket once the developments that have already been transferred and acquisitions are sort of contributing on a full basis. It looks like there's actually quite a lot of embedded growth when you add up those three individual line items, and specifically, I'm referring to the ones that were recently transferred, the acquisitions and the NOI from properties currently under development and redevelopment. Does that bucket or those buckets, how do we tie that to the under development table in the beginning of the MD&A on page five.

I guess, is it all the projects there once they get delivered, or is it just the stuff that's right now under construction?

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yeah, it's a mix of things, but it's mostly the stuff that is currently under development and redevelopment.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Okay

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

on the chart on page five that you're referring to.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

It'd be something that's either under construction or to be under construction within a very near timeframe.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yes.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Okay. That's fair. Do you have a rough ballpark? I know you guys spend X amount, between CAD 30 million and CAD 50 million every year, but for the NOI that you've added up here in terms of the opportunity, what the rough range of incremental capital would be to drive that upside?

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yeah. Let's see here. For projects in construction, we've got about CAD 13 million - CAD 14 million left in completion costs.

That's just for the ones that are currently under construction. For projects that are in planning or in development that are expected to be completed by the end of this year, it's only CAD 3 million or CAD 4 million left on those.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

CAD 3 million or CAD 4 million left.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yeah

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

That would be the bulk of the, that CAD 4.5 million of total NOI. That's what you'd expect is just basically, call it high teens to CAD 20 million.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yes.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Okay. When you look at the acquisitions, I can't recall what was completed this year, but the acquisitions, they're separated out, so they're not under development or currently in development. I know you guys sometimes or oftentimes would buy a property that does require some work. Is that just an acquisition that's stabilized and just by virtue of the fact that it hasn't been contributing for a full period is not up to speed yet? I'm just trying to get a sense of the gap there.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yeah. Most of the acquisitions that we do are things that end up in development or redevelopment and in the chart on page five. For example, we did have one opportunistic acquisition that needed just a little bit of leasing, but it didn't need a lot of development or any development or redevelopment from us. It needed a little bit of leasing, which was completed fairly quickly after. It was mostly an opportunistic acquisition. That would be something that didn't even appear on the chart on page five, but is part of our acquisition. We are seeing more of those opportunities arise. As long as it's opportunistic and gives us very heavy returns and in markets that we like and that we want to be in and are a part of our core asset class, then we'll do those acquisitions, right?

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Okay. Last question from me, just in terms of the capital, you guys, sounds like a pretty healthy number you expect to get on property refinancing this year. Is that going to be stuff in the normal course as your maturities come due, or is there going to be some defeasance associated with that, just as we look to model out for 2019?

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yeah. We are actually in the process right now of looking at not only 2019 but also 2020 expiries, just given that bond rates have come down recently. They've been very volatile, but they have come down recently. We are looking at doing a few defeasances and incurring early discharge fees. I can't tell you right now what the amount will be.

Because we're just still early stages of us looking at which ones are economic or not for us to do, and whether they make sense from a lease maturity standpoint or otherwise. You definitely should be modeling some amount of defeasance and early termination fees because we are looking at that.

Michael Markidis
Analyst, Desjardins

Okay. That's helpful color. Thank you.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Okay.

Operator

Your next question comes from David Brown, Private Investor. Your line is open.

David Brown
Analyst, Private Investor

Yes. With respect to your future development projects, can you please describe what steps you take to help the customer have lower costs in the future? I'm thinking of lower energy costs and anything else that you can make your brand stand out as having a lower cost location for your customers.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

What we do first is to understand our business versus perhaps many other shopping centers. We're basically in the strip shopping center business. That means that we have nothing to do with our individual tenants' energy consumption. What we do control is our parking lot lighting. Our parking lot lighting, any new project would be LED, and we've changed over most of our assets to LED progressively over time for our existing buildings. That's really where we can have an energy impact. Now, each tenant has a different approach to energy, and it's basically up to them. We don't have common meters. We don't heat the premises or air condition the premises of our tenants. That would be their responsibility. We don't have a lot of opportunity to use energy-saving strategies.

David Brown
Analyst, Private Investor

What about insulating the building?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Again, energy costs. A new building is going to be built to present-day standards. Some older buildings may not be as energy efficient. Again, basically very much up to the tenant because we are not paying the energy consumption.

David Brown
Analyst, Private Investor

Well, okay. Thanks very much.

Operator

Your next question comes from Sumayya Hussain from CIBC. Your line is open.

Sumayya Hussain
Analyst, CIBC

Thanks. Morning.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Good morning.

Sumayya Hussain
Analyst, CIBC

You guys are following a pretty active year for developments and new investments. Do you expect 2019 to be comparable, or would you see maybe a little bit lower investment activity and the balance maybe going towards buying back your units?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

We're going to be active in 2019. We have stuff on the go. I don't think we'll be as active as in 2018. We are initiating our share buyback, in a modest fashion to start.

Sumayya Hussain
Analyst, CIBC

Okay, great.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yes, Sumayya , we've been budgeting to be more in our normal range in terms of investment. Certainly, as things come up, which they are more and more, it may tick up, but we're certainly not expecting that at this time.

Sumayya Hussain
Analyst, CIBC

Right. That's good color. I know it's not a big piece, but just on your enclosed mall that's going through stabilization and seeing some new tenancies come in. Generally over there, how is the rent profile compared with maybe the prior tenants you guys had there?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Sorry, I'm not sure of your question.

Sumayya Hussain
Analyst, CIBC

Yeah, just you spoke to seeing improving stabilization on one of your enclosed mall assets.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yes.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yes.

Sumayya Hussain
Analyst, CIBC

Just an update in terms of rent before and after.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

I can tell you rent's not going up. Not in the near term.

Sumayya Hussain
Analyst, CIBC

Right.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Enclosed malls are the soft spot in the retail industry. We have three enclosed malls. In two of them, we have managed to increase rents on small stores from deal to deal or keeping them stable. In our mall in Newfoundland, it's a little bit tougher. It's very mixed. Rents are not going up. That's quite clear. That's the challenge of the enclosed mall world. There are probably lots of opportunities in that world. We've shied away from them. There are acquisition opportunities. We shy away from them because we look at a rent roll, and we say, "It hasn't hit bottom yet." It's hard to buy something that you think hasn't hit bottom.

Sumayya Hussain
Analyst, CIBC

Okay. Generally, what are the lease terms looking like for when you do get your tenants in?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

In an enclosed mall?

Sumayya Hussain
Analyst, CIBC

Yeah.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yeah, they're typically short-term, which is probably coming from both sides, tenant and landlord. They are typically short-term.

Sumayya Hussain
Analyst, CIBC

Okay. That's it for me. Thank you.

Operator

Your next question comes from Michael Smith from RBC Capital Markets. Your line is open.

Michael Smith
Analyst, RBC Capital Markets

Thank you, good morning.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Morning, Michael.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Good morning.

Michael Smith
Analyst, RBC Capital Markets

I joined the call late, so I apologize if you've already dealt with this. I'm just wondering what level of capital recycling do you expect for the balance of the year? Maybe can you talk about your joint ventures? Do you have a new set of potential partners, or is it the same folks you're typically dealing with?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

The first question, yeah, we did talk about, we expect to recycle between CAD 25 million and CAD 30 million this year. A third is property sales, two-thirds are refinancing proceeds. I hope that answers that question.

Michael Smith
Analyst, RBC Capital Markets

A third is property sales?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yeah. You're going to see CAD 10 million, CAD 12 million, maybe a property sale, something in that range. The balance is refinancing proceeds.

Michael Smith
Analyst, RBC Capital Markets

Okay.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

In terms of, we have a number of joint venture partner arrangements, we're pursuing them based on geography and types of deals. We've done a deal with a private group from Toronto. We're on our second deal with them. Those deals are much more development-oriented. Stuff that's more stable, that's more of a syndication-style deal to investors that we've worked with in the past. We also have joint venture partners based on specific locations, because they're a landowner, for example, or are bringing us a deal.

Michael Smith
Analyst, RBC Capital Markets

Okay. What is your thinking in terms of the economics? What's your philosophy on the economics with your various joint venture partnerships?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

I'm not sure exactly your question, I'll attempt an answer. We call it capital partner initiatives. Those are the deals where we own 50%, the partners own 50%, but we only put in 20% of the capital. The partners lend us 30% of the capital, five years, 5%. That's the price of admission. We've done that structure of deal now with different parties. We continue to work that structure. There are other instances where the partner is bringing us the deal. It becomes a straight up 50/50 transaction.

It goes from one to the other, and sometimes you can be somewhere in between.

Michael Smith
Analyst, RBC Capital Markets

Okay, those are the two general ones.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

That's correct.

Michael Smith
Analyst, RBC Capital Markets

Yeah. Just switching gears, how do you think about I know it's early stages, but in terms of share buybacks, how do you think about that versus a new development or selling an asset, let's say, an asset which you think you might be leaving something on the table?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

I would hope that we're not selling assets that we're thinking we're leaving something on the table. I think it is very early stage, and I think we have to do both. I think that we're a developer. That's our DNA, that's our business model, and if we stop developing, I think that wouldn't be very good. It's interesting, we've got a ton of stuff in the pipeline and a lot of opportunities, so therefore you have to pursue them. At the same time, I think you have to do a share buyback. That doesn't mean that we can't make a substantial sale and do a substantial share buyback as well. If the economics work, then that's something that we would seriously consider. We're not there yet. Very early.

Michael Smith
Analyst, RBC Capital Markets

Okay, perfect. All right, thank you.

Operator

Your next question comes from Brendon Abrams from Canaccord. Your line is open.

Brendon Abrams
Analyst, Canaccord

Hi, good morning.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Brendon.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

Good morning.

Brendon Abrams
Analyst, Canaccord

Hi, Michael. In the President's Message, I thought it was interesting where you state that the company's not going to sit back and wait for the unit price to improve only after the market eventually recognizes it. I was wondering if you could perhaps elaborate on this point and some of the options you guys are thinking about or your view on value or some of the conversations you've had at management or board level.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Clearly, we think that our share unit price is not reflecting our true value. We're looking at share buybacks, we're looking at asset sales that could lead to more share buybacks or different partnership arrangements to help us to surface value in our business. I think it's very early. I think you have to give us a little bit of time, I think we have the obligation to look at this and see how we can improve our business and surface value.

Brendon Abrams
Analyst, Canaccord

On the point of buybacks, I don't believe Plaza has really been active in the past in this regard. Is there a target or a quantum that you would say would be a decent level for maybe the medium term?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

I think we're working our way through that, stay tuned.

Brendon Abrams
Analyst, Canaccord

Okay. Just shifting gears to, I believe, your largest greenfield development, The Shoppes at Galway. Can you just maybe provide an update there in terms of progress on the Costco and perhaps some of the other pre-leasing and construction activities?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

We're about a year plus behind. Costco building is built. It's basically finished. Expected opening in June. We have 100,000 sq ft leased, under construction, as we speak, sort of following, picking up on the Costco timing. We have another 50,000 sq ft coming in the pipeline. That's where we're at today. We're getting there. It's been slow, been a tough slog to get approvals and get this out of the ground. We're there. Every time we do a phase, it's the same dance. It's a tough slog to get permitting in that particular market.

Brendon Abrams
Analyst, Canaccord

Right. Okay. Just the last question here, shifting gears. At a high level, there's been a lot of the largest retailers in Canada for several years now have created their own REITs or aligned themselves with certain REITs. Just out of curiosity, has that had any impact on your business ability to secure tenants, get deals done, or is it really they're looking for the best locations and retailers who can deliver, or, sorry, landlords who could deliver?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yeah. It's been very rare that we've lived that because we didn't have a If we had the best location, you're going to get the deal. That's been my experience. Clearly, that's what we have seen, and therefore, as able developers, as guys capable of assembling land and working through some complicated stuff, we've been able to do deals with the retailers that have an associated real estate structure. We've been very active with all of these parties. As what we're seeing is those REITs are much more focused on the big six markets, and clearly have virulent interest in the kinds of markets that we're strong in. I think there's even more runway today than there was in the past with those types of retailers. We're working hard to position ourselves as a reliable developer for all retailers.

Brendon Abrams
Analyst, Canaccord

Okay. We talked a lot on the call about primary versus secondary markets, I'm just wondering from a debt perspective and lenders, have you seen any changes there or shifts in the marketplace there?

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

We've had.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

No problems at all.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Yeah. No issue.

Floriana Cipollone
CFO, Plaza Retail REIT

There's ample money. There is ample competitive bids. Clearly we see some changes with respect to credit or spreads over bonds, not relating to the markets that we're in, more relating to what's happening to bond rates, what's happening with the Bank of Canada. Apart from that, very good depth on the lending side across all of our markets.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Just give you some color. That was one of our biggest challenges over the years. I've been in this business now for a long time, in the early years, it was a tremendous challenge to get a lender to the table in some of our secondary markets, and I think they really missed the boat. Inevitably they did when you look back. Today, no problem at all. We've seen a complete change in that world, whether it's because we're bigger and stronger or just people have figured out that you can do retails in the Charlottetowns and the Monctons and places like that or even smaller markets in Canada and have a good, solid property and value.

Brendon Abrams
Analyst, Canaccord

Okay. That's great. Thanks.

Operator

Mr. Zakuta, there are no further questions at this time.

Michael Zakuta
CEO, Plaza Retail REIT

Well, thank you everyone participating in today's call.

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. Please disconnect your lines.