Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. (CCO)
NYSE: CCO · Real-Time Price · USD
2.400
0.00 (0.00%)
At close: Apr 30, 2026, 4:00 PM EDT
2.410
+0.010 (0.40%)
After-hours: Apr 30, 2026, 7:17 PM EDT
← View all transcripts

The Citigroup Global TMT Conference 2024

Sep 6, 2024

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Morning, everyone. My name's Jason Bazinet. I'm the Media and Entertainment Analyst here at Citi. Very pleased to have Clear Channel Outdoor with us today. Scott Wells, President and CEO, and David Sailer, CFO, thank you.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Thanks for having us.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah, how are you guys doing this morning?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Doing well, and you?

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Great.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Doing great. Doing great. So can I start off with a high-level question?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Sure.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay, the strategic review.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yeah.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

You've got some things behind you, some things that I think are sort of still in order.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yep.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

My question is: Can you just sort of describe what you've done, what's still to come, and maybe give us a sense of when do you think all of it will be behind you?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

So, look, we started this at the beginning of 2022, and our goal, we started the European part of it. Our goal was to sell the business as a platform, and the Ukraine war, frankly, made that impossible. Once that happened, the appetite for buying the business and just transacting, I mean, credit markets were a mess. I don't know, I'm sure people remember back how crazy things were in sort of that part of year. So we pivoted at that point and focused on de-risking the business and exiting some of the markets that had been more cash-depleting during COVID and that were generally more challenging. And we successfully did that, and the message that we gave to everyone at that point was, "We're gonna do this.

We're gonna get the business generating positive cash in Europe. We're gonna de-risk it, and we're gonna work to... We're committed to selling it. We think it's the right thing to do, sell it, but we're not gonna give it away.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

'Cause there were investors in our investor base who were very vocal that we should just give it away. And I think if you look at our financials now, you can see that what we have is actually a good, viable business and a business that, you know, is gonna generate tens of millions of EBITDA for us this year, of cash, not just EBITDA. So-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Can I just pause on that?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yeah.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Do you remember off the top of your head what Europe North did in the last quarter? It was up a significant amount.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yeah, no, it was up 10%.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

This is only on the last 12 months. It was up 10% top line and in the low 20s for EBITDA.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yeah, no, it's been-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... it's been performing brilliantly. And, you know, it's a, it's a classic example of focusing on the best assets and giving the management team a very clear mandate of what they need to do. And so, fast-forward to now, we threw, we kind of reinvigorated the Europe North sale process at the end of last year, and we threw a broad net again. We had thrown a very broad net at the beginning of 2022. So, you can imagine that we have met pretty much anybody who is a prospective buyer of the business, and we have a number of interested parties, and we are, you know, in the process of working through.

It's one of those things where there's a lot of complexity in the business, a lot of things to diligence, a lot of things to get comfortable with in terms of contract renewals and how CapEx works and all that kind of stuff. So I have not at any point given timelines, and I'm not gonna give you one today, Jason.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay. It's all right.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

But you know, I feel good that we have people who see value in the business and that, you know, we're not being unreasonable. We're not looking to, like, get the perfect multiple for it-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... but we're also very much not giving it away, and so that's, that's where we are in Europe. LatAm started considerably later. You know, we started that process kind of the beginning of this year, end of last year, beginning of this year.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

You know, similar thing, threw a broad net. You know, there has been interest. Latin America has been complicated this year with various political things, various economic things. For those of you who aren't close, for us, Latin America is Brazil, Mexico, Chile, and Peru. And I think three of those four have had meaningful political things going on in them this year. So, but just-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Which one is the stable one? Peru?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

I struggle to say it, but yes, for this year.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay, okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

I mean, if you look at a three-year view, you can't say that.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

But for the time period, it has been... And honestly, it pro- I think we're four for four, actually, as I reflect on-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... what actually is going on, but despite that, I mean, we are talking to people who are familiar with doing business there. We're working our way through that. It is small. You know, the EBITDA of the whole of Latin America is less than, you know, small markets that we have in the U.S., but again, we're not gonna give it away.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

We're going to, you know, find a way to monetize it as effectively as we can. And, you know, feels like a pretty good process. Some of the, it will probably end up also being a multi-transaction situation.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

You mean country by country?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yeah

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

... it's more? Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Maybe not country by country, but it might be kind of chunks and pieces. 'Cause it's just the way the buyers-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... line up. So, you know, it again, I'm speculating on that at this point, and as with Europe, I'm not gonna give you a timeline. But, you know, I think it's moving along well.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay, and just to level set for everyone, can you. This decision to sort of exit Europe, exit Latin America, where you're gonna become a U.S.-focused asset, is that just purely focused on sort of the long-term goal to convert to a REIT? Is that sort of what the underlying narrative?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Well, it-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Or it's deeper than that?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

It is deeper than that. The business model of out- of- home is very different in Europe, and in some ways marketers like it better. So, like, one of my great frustrations has been how much TV money is coming to the street furniture assets in Europe, whereas TV money is going to CTV and, you know, streaming and, you know, TikTok here in the U.S. It's just different the way, 'cause TV money is kind of leaving TV everywhere.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

But the business model is very different. It's very capital-intensive, and for a highly levered company, I mean, kind of what happened in COVID, illustrated the challenge of the business there. Because we ended up seeing revenue dry up in all of our geographies, but in the places where we had very large minimum guarantees, you know, you end up just hemorrhaging cash.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Understood.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

And so, for a highly levered company, I think focus and going after kind of the highest margin, highest growth prospect businesses is the right play for us. I think the other part of it is it will make us very streamlined relative to what we are right now. I mean, the complexity you have, every country that you add, it's more tax work, it's more compliance work-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... it's more, government relations work, different real estate laws. Like, the complexity that gets added as you add countries. And, you know, the reality of it is, there are a couple of big countries that we had internationally, but we have a very long tail of countries where we're quite small, and where they're just quite small. And they're nice businesses. It's not that they're not businesses that are viable and that work, but they're just a distraction relative to, you know, what-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Understood

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... what you're trying to do at the core. And since... You know, we took a really hard look at, were any customers looking to buy globally? 'Cause I know this is like a complete anti-you know, globalization play that we're doing here. Everybody else is trying to become global. We're trying to become U.S.-focused. I get the irony of that. But the reality of it is that customers buy locally.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

They don't... You know, there's... I could point to, like, two or three campaigns over the last five years-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... that were truly bought globally.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Sure.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

The laws are different in terms of what you can do with data, and so as data becomes a more important part of it, that gets complicated. And then you have the whole regulatory regime. You know, kind of the trend everywhere globally is more, and in some cases, the more is getting, you know, really, really onerous. And so you end up in audit committee meetings spending, you know, 20% of your meeting talking about 2% of the EBITDA, because... And that's just not a good use of your brain power of your board.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

It's not a good use of the brain power of your management. So focusing one language, one country, and the REIT part of it is kind of out there as a strategic-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Option

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... option downstream.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

I think it's something that motivates us, but we're very realistic that we are not anywhere near ready to be a REIT until we de-leverage.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay, and so that sort of, and this is my own bias, and I ask you this every year, and I don't know why I'm so fixated on it, but I look at your enterprise value, and there's a lot of debt and less equity, and I'm like, "How do we make this a real, you know, sort of"-

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

How do we split it a little more evenly?

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah, split it more evenly. And then I always go down the path of, you know, sell assets at a higher multiple than your leverage. And yeah, every year you shake your head. And so please just remind us why that- why you think that's not-

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

You know, someday I'm gonna get you to sit down at a tax seminar with me, Jason. This is, this is not hard. I mean, if we were, if we were talking about multiples for U.S. businesses in the, like, high teens-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... if we were able to sell assets at 17 times, you are spot on.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

But if you're able to sell assets at sort of 12-14 times-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yes

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... we have a low tax base. We've been around a long, long time, and when you're 10 times levered and you have to pay, you know-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

That much tax.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... I mean, who knows what the new tax rate is gonna be? But you have to pay-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... 20%-30% tax on it, you basically-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Just wipe out whatever.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... de-scale the business-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... without actually making any progress on the leverage.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

The thing of it is, like, look, the thing our investors should take a lot of comfort in. Our interest expense went up $100 million in the increases. We were caught with a very large, you know, variable rate part of our mix. We were 20%, 26%, 27%. It wasn't outrageous, and we had benefited from it mightily, so we had probably saved $70 million or $80 million in the couple of years prior. But because we were caught when rates went up, we have absorbed that $100 million. In a couple years' time, we're looking at being cash flow positive, you know, soon. We have expressed it in very precise ways as our-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... AFFO and then taking into account-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... our investment CapEx. You know, that's gonna be positive in the second half of this year, and we should be legitimately cash flow positive next year. You get a business like this to cash flow positive, you know, we are loved in the credit markets.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Mm.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

I mean, not to overstate it to my credit investors in here, we don't take you for granted. We love you, we appreciate you, but, like, we're loved in the credit, in the credit markets because people understand there's, like, a rock-solid asset base under

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yes

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... these assets. And so arguably, you can take a higher level of leverage. It then becomes a question of, how do you get the cash flow to where you're actually able to work that leverage down over time?

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

You think about the path that we're on. We get to cash flow positive. We exit and streamline the business in Europe. We cut corporate expenses. We bring you know, we continue to work on getting cash flow up. We have definitely been punished by the rating agencies. Like, during COVID, we were punished by the rating agencies, and they haven't walked it back. I think as we get cash flow positive, that's a conversation that turns. You get a couple of interest rate cuts. We work on some of the riskier debt. We have a pretty good runway until 2027 without having to do anything, and that debt that's coming up in 2027 is some of the best stuff we've got, so we're not in a hurry to work on that.

But we've got stuff in 2028, 2029, and 2030 that we can work on, along with the term loans. So, look, I think that, you know, we are at the cusp of actually being able to flip the story. It did take us a couple years to absorb that $100 million of incremental interest, but I see that $100 million of incremental interest going the other direction, you know, over the next, you know, 24-36 months.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay, that's great. So part of that, in terms of flipping it to free cash flow positive, I think, the big standout in the second quarter, other than Europe North, was airports.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Sure.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

So what can you just sort of unpack the strength? I mean, I think it was, what, revenue's up 21%, EBITDA up 17%. You raised your guidance for the outdoor airport segment-

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yep

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

... by a little bit also for the full year. Can you just unpack it a bit for us? Like, what's going so well?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

So we have been transforming the airports business over the last five years. You're sort of seeing in the last, I don't know, 24 months, the fruits of that to some degree. But we have gotten very focused, and it's a little bit similar to the conversation about Europe, where we have focused on fewer, bigger airports.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Hmm.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

So our portfolio is substantially smaller than it was. What's... You know, the tricky part on that is that you look at that portfolio, you know, five years ago, and you say, "God, the gross margins in these small airports are phenomenal," because you don't have the, like, really tough contracts with- that you get in, in-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah, yeah

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... a major city. But the thing is, is that there's still a lot of overhead to support it, and there's a lot of other, other things. And so we've actually grown the business, grown EBITDA. We have not added a lot of people because we have focused the people on working on the-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... the fewer, bigger. And so that's been a tenet of what we've been doing. I think a second tenet of what we've been doing is we've changed how we sell. Starting with when we launched San Jose, and we did some investor communication around this. It was six or seven years ago at this point, five or six years ago, I guess. We got very focused on longer-term sponsorship-type deals for parts of the airports to try to lock in chunks of the inventory and, you know, really, really have huge impact for advertising, and advertisers have really loved it. We've had a lot of success with advertisers, with them having a, you know, tunnel between terminals or them having a bespoke area in one of the terminals that is just all about their brand.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Hmm.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

And so we've done, we've done that. We've gone from, you know, a couple of those to tens of those at this point. And I think the third thing that we've done, and I've referred to this before, is that we've made it a lot easier to cross-sell across the business. And, so it is easier now for our airports people to sell our roadside, and it's easier for our roadside people to sell airports. And it does turn out that there's a pretty meaningful number of customers who are actually interested in both.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yes.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

And so that is something that has been a real success.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

That cross-sell, is that a technological thing that happened? Is it just incentives for the sales people?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

It's a lot of blocking and tackling, so it's working out how to make it easy because the thing about airports is when a customer has an idea of what they'd like to do in an airport, the answer is generally yes. But what that means is it's not like super simple inventory. So like, if you're gonna sell five billboards, everybody knows what five billboards are, and they work. If you're gonna sell a bourbon tasting with a domination and a you know handout or something, that's a different sale. And so what we did was we set up a kind of concierge team to facilitate that sale coming in, along with getting the comp instructions into a place.

You know, stupid detail, but these kind of things matter. In the old world, when somebody would sell a client into an airport from roadside, they would only get credit for the first contract.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Hmm

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... and then the renewal would go to an airport person. We now have that- we've worked out the comp where we split the comp, or it, you know, it depends. There's a lot of judgment goes into it, but making comp work is the biggest thing when you're trying to cross-sell.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Understood.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

So, yeah.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

There's been some, I don't know, small anecdotes out there in terms of commentary around travel, right? Like, I think Airbnb had some difficult numbers. There's been some concern around destination theme parks. I think you noted on your call that, you know, the airport traffic was at record levels, right? But I know investors are nervous about travel moderating, just based on what other companies are saying. Should investors be nervous about what traffic counts mean in airports as it relates to your airport segment, or is it more disconnected than a one-for-one relationship between passenger traffic and your airport revenues?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

It's definitely not one for one connected.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

The way passenger traffic affects us, obviously it is an underpinning of what we're selling to our customers, but it is not the only thing we're selling to our customers.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Part of why airports has done so well, and, you know, we haven't gotten into it yet, but I'm sure we'll get into the whole national, local conversation, and you're gonna say, "Well, why is national not good in out-of-home?" And I'm gonna say, "Well, national's fantastic in airports.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Hmm.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

So, like, part of why customers like airports is because of the audience it delivers. It delivers people who have the affluence to be able to afford to travel. There are a lot of business decision-makers who go, even if they're not on business trips, and then you get into the whole business trip, you know, aspect of it, of getting business travelers. And you've seen the big business hubs have really picked up in the last kind of 12 months. So it is not a one-for-one relationship, because a lot of what the advertisers are buying is access to that audience.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Hmm.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Barring, you know, really catastrophic drops in audience counts, I think we can manage that. It'll certainly be a factor. Like, look, when people pull back on advertising, we've been waiting for a recession for a long time. When people pull back on advertising in recessions, they don't just pull back on all of it for some period again, depending on how serious it is and things like that. That's not happening right now, and we don't see any evidence of it in the dialogues we're having with people into next year. But, you know, these things can change, and I am definitely not Pollyanna about the macro environment and all the different uncertainties in the world.

I'm quite attuned to all of those uncertainties. But so it affects us. It's not a one-for-one, and then the other part of it is, some of you might recall, we took on the New York Port Authority during COVID. We actually won that in March of 2020. That's when we heard. And the president of airports apologized to me, when he called to tell me we'd won, and I was like, "No, Morten, we're good.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Mm.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Like, we'll figure this out." But one of the things we were able to do, because we were in the middle of this great dislocation, is we built technology into that contract, that if passenger counts drop, the minimum guarantees, it moves... It doesn't move, like, dramatically, like, the Minimum Guarantee doesn't go away.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

But rather than having to negotiate at the time of the passenger drop, there are thresholds built into it where the minimum guarantee will scale-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

That's great

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... if passenger counts do. And that's a technology we're trying to build into other contracts. You know, I don't know that the industry as a whole has embraced it, and so, we're working on that part. But, you know, we are very attuned to being risk managers in how we-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

That's great

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... in how we manage these businesses.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

That's great. I'm gonna shift gears and talk about this national/local dichotomy that-

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Of course

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

... you touched on. I sort of, when I speak to executives across the industry, right, there seem to be two camps. There is the, "We have a slight secular issue as it relates to national advertising for the outdoor ad medium," and then the other camp says, "No, this is all... You can trace it back to weakness in specific verticals. There's no signal here," and I, I think you land a little bit more in the, in the former camp than the latter. Is that right?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

I'm kind of a third camp.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Third, okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

I'm actually so I completely agree. Like, I can do math as much as the next guy, and there is absolutely no question that specific verticals have hurt our space. If you look at the verticals that were big three or four years ago, and you look at the verticals that are big now, it has been incredibly dynamic how that mix has changed. But I think my third camp would focus a little bit more on agency economics and how the agencies are changing-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Hmm

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... because, that is what underlies how this gets placed. I mean, first of all, I'm gonna say it, I say it every time I'm in any of these interviews, there are no real national buyers in out-of-home.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Sure.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

So what everybody likes to call national is the large agency. It's the stuff that goes through the big hold cos. And the big hold cos are having their own challenges, some more than others. Some are having a pretty good time.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Uh-huh.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

But as they work through it, they have had challenges on their fee structure.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Sure.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

And so they have had to figure out other ways to make money than how they used to make money, where it was just kind of a markup on whatever media that they placed.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

And in doing that, they have become more media traders, and they have... I mean, the options that you have if you're an agency. I mean, God, I used to be in the ad buying side of the business in the early aughts. Like, back then, you, like, looked at four or five different things, and that's how you placed your budget. Now you've got, like, a thousand things-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... you can place your budget on, and, and lots more coming every day. I mean, the number of people who are developing ad-served businesses or ad-supported businesses is just exploding. And so the agencies are doing what any reasonable business would do, is they're trying to, like, steer more of the money to places where they're able to get more value, and that comes from things like video production, it comes from, you know, principal buying.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Mm-hmm.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Like, there's a lot of dynamism, so I don't think, I don't think you can, like, I don't think you can distill the national challenge that out-of-home has, and then put it on top of it. You have programmatic. So programmatic, until recently, was an unvarnished good for the roadside people. You know, there are 10 or 12,000 large-format billboards, and programmatic. And automation is gonna be good for the industry over the time, so don't hear me becoming a programmatic bear. That's not true. Our programmatic business is performing wonderfully. The challenge with it is, as you have companies that spent-...

Substantially an out-of-home shift from buying direct from the vendors to buying programmatically, you're going from them looking at 10 or 12,000 large format boards roadside to, like, 90 or 100,000 screens, including, you know, all sorts of different sizes, in-store, adjacent to store, charging stations, gas stations. Like, the number of screens has exploded, and programmatic has made it easy to go in. And so one of the things that we have seen a little bit this year, it's not, it's not the explanation for what's going on with national, but I'm very attuned to it because it's something we have to be on top of, is that when a large brand shifts from buying direct to buying programmatically, and God forbid, goes to the open e xchange with the partners-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... they will spread that buy like peanut butter. And you'll see. And again, this has happened with a couple of accounts, and we are all over it, and we're working it.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Sorry, sorry-

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

But we have to pay attention to this because there's a quality thing. First of all, out-of-home will get a bad reputation. It's kind of what happened with display ads and programmatic, that, like, a bunch of junk inventory, sorry to my friends in the, the smaller format, but a bunch of weaker inventory comes in, becomes easy to buy, and it's cheap, and that then, like, causes people to say, "Oh, I'm getting efficiency." But they're not really getting efficiency, they're just getting small screens.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

When you say spread like peanut butter, I think that was the phrase you used-

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Mm.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

... you're not talking about spreading like peanut butter across the inventory that Clear Channel has. You're talking about spreading like peanut butter just across all-

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

I'm saying when you go from looking at 10,000 or 12,000 large format bulletins when you're dealing with the vendors, to 100,000 all-format screens-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... if you're on the open exchange and you're bidding, your money is going to gravitate-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

I see

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... to where you're perceived. And the data, when you especially get down to some of those small screens, the data's very dubious because you will have, you know, some box. I'm not gonna criticize any particular thing, but some box with a small screen on it in customer service at a Walmart claiming credit for all the foot traffic in the Walmart. Like, come on. Really?

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

So this is gonna get sorted-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... just like it got sorted in display. But it is something. Like, it was a significant headwind last year, the proliferation of the screens. That normalized a little bit, and we've seen programmatic- I mean, it has grown very nicely the first half of the year, and it's continuing to. But there are an awful lot more customers showing up in programmatic-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... who were formerly direct.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

And that's what we've gotta keep an eye on.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay. And, just, can you remind us how big programmatic is of your-

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

We've never-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... we've never, you know-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Disclosed

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... disclosed that.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

It's complicated because there are a number of different flavors.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

There's kind of the true SSP programmatic, where you're going through the whole ad tech thing and having all of the ad tech fees on it, and then there's, you know, automated direct, where-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah, cool

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... you're just trading, and there's no intermediary, really.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay. Understood. Can we talk about other sort of sales efforts beyond programmatic? I think you've made some efforts to try and hire some salespeople to sort of zero in on particular verticals-

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yep

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

... to be more effective at selling and sort of attacking this. Can you talk a little bit about what your hypothesis is, how you're sort of attacking it, and any sort of success you've had so far?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

So we started doing direct. We formed our client solutions team probably six years ago, and we discovered we did it a lot of wrong ways before we kinda did it the right way.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

But we discovered that what really works is having somebody who's deep on a thing. And the deep on a thing, it could be something horizontal, like, "I know how to pitch people who've got funded by VCs," or it could be a vertical, where, "I know how to talk to people in the beverage industry.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

And so what our client solutions team has evolved to, initially we started out much more of just, like, "Let's go get the big accounts that aren't buying out-of-home and build relationships with them." What we found worked better was working with people who, you know, had relationships in a vertical or spoke the language of the vertical. And so we have, you know, low double-digit millions of sales that are coming from this initiative already.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Interesting

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... as a result of those investments that we made in the client solutions team. What we've really gotten traction on in the last couple of years is in pharmaceutical, where the combination of our data and analytics... 'Cause that turns out to be the real linchpin thing that you want, is the data and analytics that are the way they do the data analytics, not the way we think they should do it.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

We figured out how to do pharmaceutical analytics the way pharmaceutical does them. We have, you know, a kind of anchor client that's been with us a few years, and we've added a couple of clients, and we're now at the point where I think we're gonna have a real presence in pharma. We've got several campaigns running right now, and it's something that I think has relevance to an awful lot of drugs. These are drugs that are gonna have broader, you know, audiences. It's not for super niche, you know, specialty cancer drugs. It's for things that are, you know, diabetes-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... or mainstream, kind of, diseases that a lot of people have. And so, this is something that I think is an area that we can make real progress on. We need to bring the auto insurance vertical back. It's probably never gonna come back the way it was in the time of the 2019 time frame, but that is a vertical that we're definitely focused on. We're focused on consumer products.

We have beverage investment that's going on, and it's kind of a constant discussion between Bob McCuin, our CRO, and I on, like, "Okay, what are the next ones?" Because what we're trying to do is bring in that person or develop the person, 'cause in some cases it's somebody who came internally, but develop that capability, get them linked to the data and analytics so that they have the key to how that customer set thinks about it. And then, you know, wrap around some marketing and do, you know, some industry events and things like that. So that's-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... that's where we're headed with this. It is not inexpensive getting this kind of expertise. It's very different from how we did, you know, quote, unquote, "national historically." But I think with the dynamics going on in the agencies, it's actually critical for us to do it-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Mm

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... because being able to talk to the people who actually control the budgets-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Correct, yeah

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... is really centrally important to locking in business.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

That's great. Dave, can I shift over to you for a second?

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Sure.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

So I think during both the first quarter and the second quarter, you guys have articulated sort of a back half weighting towards the year.

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yes.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Can you just unpack that a bit and explain how much confidence you have in that, particularly given some of the macro fears that people have at the moment?

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Sure. I mean, and we'll go back to even what Scott was saying earlier. When we provided our guidance in the third quarter, and, you know, not reaffirming, but, like, I still feel the same as we did when we did that back in August. But we said earlier in the year when we got into it, you know, the first quarter was tough. Local's been strong. It was strong in the first quarter, second quarter, and I feel like that's gonna happen, you know, throughout the year. From a national standpoint, we said it was gonna be a little bit lumpy.

We started off the year strong in the first quarter, and similar to, you know, last year, national was kinda up and down, and the second quarter was tough. And as we're getting into the third quarter, you know, I feel pretty good about where we are as a business. When you compare the third quarter of last year to where I feel like we are this year, I mean, we said it last year, it's almost like the agencies took the summer off, and it was tough. Like, the third quarter of last year was pretty tough. We're not seeing that this year.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Mm.

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

I feel like the conversations are strong. I feel like the fundamentals are strong. One of the big things we'll talk about, and you mentioned before, you know, do you see a recession or the macro not looking good? We look at cancellations.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah.

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

And we saw a few of those, you know, as we were going into it last year. We're not seeing that this year-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Mm

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... as we go into the third quarter, and I feel like the conversations, you know, with the advertisers has been strong, and I feel like that will continue as we get into the third quarter. The fourth quarter is the biggest quarter. I mean, that hasn't landed yet, but as we're looking forward to the third quarter, I feel good.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay, that's great. Are there any questions in the audience for either Scott or Dave? Happy to... Got one in the front here.

It was a line you said right at the beginning. You were saying that in Europe you felt that the outdoor companies were doing a better job of taking some of those sort of traditional display, I think, TV budgets, whereas in the U.S., that money's being diverted to connected TV and other platforms. Why is that? And is there anything you can do to change it, in particular with the sort of digital offering?

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

So I think, you know, first and foremost, marketers really appreciate the format of a bus shelter close to a shop. It's almost a point-of-sale kind of reference. And it has always been the case that, CPG in particular, which is obviously a big TV advertiser, has done more business with out-of-home outside the United States than inside the United States. And so, in this period where we have both, I'm leveraging the access that we have to some of those folks to actually get with their global people and have dialogue about, "Hey, you spend, you know, 5% of your budget on out-of-home in the U.K., and you spend zero in the U.S. Why don't you give us a chance?

Let's talk about how we, how we work through it." So that, that's a slow process, but it's, it's a little bit that tradition. And then I think the other part of it is, we can get a lot closer to video on bus shelters than you can... It's not, it's not full-motion video, and it certainly doesn't have sound, but we can do things that are very eye-catching and that are, you know, kind of in concert with the video ads that people wanna run on street furniture, that we just can't do on a roadside asset. So it's a, it's a little bit the form factor, it's a little bit the location, and then kind of the tradition, how it's gone. But I think that's the principal reason why, why there's a big difference there.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

So it's like that was the original retail media, I guess, doing a CPG ad outside of -

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

I mean, it's funny, outside the U.S., you know, retail media, we exited the mall business probably 15 years ago or 12 years ago, for very specific reasons about working with the malls, 'cause they kind of were selling the ads themselves, and it was a channel conflict. But, retail media outside, you know, we do the screens inside of Tesco and, you know, Sainsbury's, and, you know, depending on the country, different countries, different channels.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yeah.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

We actually operate those. I think oOh!media just had a big announcement in Australia about what they're doing with retail media, and it's the same thing. That has not been the way things have developed here with retail media, because the retail media is more of a repurposing of the trade dollars. And so the principals don't wanna give any of that up to the if we were to sell it. But I think that's an area that we would explore with people of. 'Cause, like, the way it works with many of these retailers outside the U.S., is that they will have a kind of protected list of accounts that they're selling directly to, and it's where they're getting their trade dollars and where they have their relationships.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

But then you can sell to anybody else who's not in conflict with those, and so that's how it works when they-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Right

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... when they market for retailers in other countries. I think that might be an opportunity for us downstream as retail media-

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Interesting

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

... evolves, but I'm not—don't hear that as this is a big strategic initiative. It's not. The going vertical and direct to advertiser is the big strategic initiative, not chasing a different channel.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay. You touched on this earlier, Scott, but Dave, maybe you could just remind everyone in terms, like, when I look at your bond maturity schedule, it looks fantastic, fairly benign, like there's no real moving parts there. Is that a fair characterization?

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yeah, I mean, look, from a... Obviously, the quantum debt is large, but from a maturity standpoint, I think the team, we've done a good job of pushing those maturities out. I mean, we've done a lot of work. We've been really active in the capital markets over the last couple of years, and our next maturity is in 2027, and that's actually a very attractive piece of debt. So we have created that runway really to grow the business from an organic standpoint and, kind of, going off the initiatives that Scott has been talking about. But that doesn't mean that, you know, as rates come down, and, you know, we obviously are more fixed than variable, but we still do have a term loan out there.

As rates come down, if there is something compelling that makes sense to the business, we'll absolutely, you know, take a look at it. And also, as rates come down, we do have maturities that start in 2028 and 2029.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Yep.

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

You know, and we'll start looking at those, you know, in a couple of years from now.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

And can you remind me, the term loan, is it SOFR plus? Is that how it's described?

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Yes, it's SOFR plus four hundred.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Okay, great! So that's a little bit of a tailwind, and hopefully we'll be talking about free cash flow.

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Exactly.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

All right, very good. Scott, Dave, thank you so much for the time.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Thank you, Dave.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

It's great.

Scott Wells
President and CEO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Thank you.

David Sailer
CFO, Clear Channel Outdoor

Enjoyed talking to you.

Jason Bazinet
Media and Entertainment Analyst, Citi

Absolutely.

Powered by