Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by. Welcome to the Q4 earnings call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speaker's presentation, there will be a question and answer session. To ask a question during this session, you will need to press star one on your telephone. If you require any further assistance, please press star zero. Thank you. I would now like to hand the conference over to your respective host, Mr. Richard Galanti, CFO. Sir, you may begin.
Thank you. Good afternoon to everyone. I'll start by stating that these discussions will include forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. That these statements involve risks and uncertainties that may cause actual events, results, and/or performance to differ materially from those indicated by such statements. The risks and uncertainties include, but are not limited to, those outlined in today's call, as well as other risks identified from time to time in the company's public statements and reports filed with the SEC. Forward-looking statements speak only as of the date they are made, and the company does not undertake to update these statements except as required by law. In today's press release, we reported operating results for the fourth quarter and fiscal year 2019, the 16 and 52 weeks ended September 1st.
Reported net income for the quarter was $1.097 billion, or $2.47 a share. That compared to $1.043 billion a year ago, or $2.36 a share. This year's fourth quarter was negatively impacted by $123 million pre-tax reserve to SG&A, or $96 million after tax, or $0.22 per share, related to a product tax assessment. In terms of this $123 million pre-tax reserve or charge to SG&A, last week we received an assessment related to certain product taxes. It covered a seven-and-a-half-year period from January of 2009 through July 2016. While we'll be filing a protest to this, a reserve for this assessment was recorded in the fourth quarter in accordance with U.S. GAAP. Excluding this reserve, Q4 2019 net income would have been $1.19 billion or $2.69 a share, a 14% increase over last year's fourth quarter.
Net sales for the quarter came in at $46.45 billion, a 7% increase over the $43.41 billion last year. For the entire fiscal year, net sales in fiscal 2019 came in at $149.35 billion, a 7.9% increase over last year's $138.43 billion. In terms of comp sales, as was reported in the release, for the 16-week fourth quarter, reported U.S. was 6.2%. Excluding gas deflation, FX, and Revenue Recognition, it was 5.2%. Canada reported 2.6%. Ex deflation, FX, and rev rec, 4.7%. Other international reported 1.9%. Ex those items, 5.0%. Total company, both for the 16 weeks with and without those items, was a 5.1%. E-commerce was a 19.8% reported comp and a 21.9% ex FX and rev rec. In terms of the Q4 comp sales metrics, fourth quarter traffic or shopping frequency increased 3.7% worldwide and 3.6% in the U.S.
Weakening foreign currencies relative to the U.S. dollar negatively impacted sales by about 60 basis points. Gas price deflation was a negative 50 basis points, and rev rec benefited comp sales in the quarter by a plus 110. Those three things together essentially zeroed out. Our average transaction or ticket during the fiscal quarter was up 1.4%, both with and without the impacts of gas, FX, and rev rec. Next on the income statement, our membership fee income reported in the fourth quarter was $1.050 billion, up $53 million or 5.3% over last year's fourth quarter. Ex the impact of FX, the $53 million increase would have been $58 million or up 5.8%.
During the fourth quarter, the 23-month cycle to recognize the incremental P&L benefit of the fee increases that began in June of 2017 was completed, and the impact in the Q4 results was almost zero, less than a $1 million benefit to the quarter. In terms of renewal rates, at Q4 end, our U.S. and Canada membership renewal rate came in at a 90.9%, up two-tenths of a percent from 90.7% as of the end of the last quarter. Worldwide, the renewal rate was 88.4%, up from 88.3% a quarter ago. Both of these figures were all-time highs. In terms of number of members at Q4 and fiscal year-end, we had 53.9 million member households. That's up from a quarter ago of 53.1 million. Total cardholders at the end of the year, 98.5 million, up from 97.2 million at the end of Q3.
During the quarter, we had 10 net new openings, eight in the U.S., one in the U.K., and our first warehouse opening in China in Shanghai. At fourth quarter end, paid executive memberships totaled $20.8 million, which was an increase during the quarter of $362,000 or $23,000 a week. In terms of going down the gross margin line, our reported gross margin in the fourth quarter was higher year over year by a reported 14 basis points and ex gas deflation and rev rec up by 20 basis points. As usual, I'll ask you to jot down a few items for explanation purposes. In the fourth quarter, you'll have two columns, both reported and then without gas deflation and rev rec. The first line item would be merchandise, core merchandise on a reported basis year over year, it was down eight basis points.
Ex gas and rev rec, it was down three basis points. Ancillary businesses up 29 basis points and ex those items up 31 basis points year-over-year. 2% reward minus three and minus four basis points. Other minus four and minus four. If you add those up, you get the plus 14 basis points as reported and again, ex gas and rev rec up 20. In terms of the core merchandise component of gross margin was lower by eight or might really lower by three ex gas and rev rec. Looking at the core merchandise categories in relation to their own sales or what we call core on core margins year-over-year were higher by four basis points.
Subcategories within that year-over-year in the fourth quarter showed increases in fresh and soft lines, partially offset by a little down year-over-year in hard lines with food and sundries being relatively flat year-over-year. Ancillary and other business, as mentioned, was higher by 29 basis points and 31 higher ex gas and rev rec. Most of that was attributable to strong gasoline margins. Other was minus 4 in both columns. Moving to SG&A, I'll ask you to jot down the following. Again, two columns reported and ex deflation and gas deflation and rev rec. Operations plus 3 basis points and minus 2. Minus 2 meaning higher by 2. Central minus 5 and minus 5 or higher by 5. Stock compensation plus 2 and plus 2, lower by 2 basis points year-over-year. Other minus 27 and minus 27.
With that, you would get to a reported SG&A % year-over-year being higher or worse by 27 basis points coming in at 10.09% of sales up from 9.82% of sales a year ago. Excluding the one-time item discussed earlier, the SG&A would have been flat year-over-year on a reported basis and ex gas and rev rec higher by five. In terms of the components here, the core operations component, excluding the impacts of gas and rev rec again was two basis points higher. This figure included the impact of the two wage increases that were taken in June of 2018 and March of 2019, which essentially hit the year-over-year comparison by an estimated five to six basis points in the quarter.
We estimate that once the first one anniversaries now during the quarter, we estimate that the impact in Q1 and Q2 until that one anniversaries will be about a 3-4 basis points hit. Central was higher year-over-year by five basis points, both with and without gas and rev rec. IT was the biggest driver of that increase. In terms of stock comp, again, that helped the SG&A by two basis points. Again, lastly, as discussed earlier, the $123 million hit to SG&A. This item accounts for the 27 basis points. Next on the income statement, pre-opening expense. Pre-opening expense for the fourth quarter came in at $41 million, $10 million higher than the $31 million fourth quarter of last year. This year in the fourth quarter, we had 12 total openings, 10 net plus two reloads.
Our total pre-opening was up year-over-year, primarily due to the pre-opening costs related to our chicken plant in Nebraska. It's now open for business. We'll have an estimated 45-week ramp up to full production from the September 10th go live date. All told, reported operating income in Q4 increased 1%, coming in at $1.463 billion this year compared to $1.446 billion last year. Again, excluding the one-time item discussed earlier, operating income was up 9.7%. Below the operating income line, interest expense was $3 million lower or better year-over-year, coming in at $45 million, down from $48 million a year earlier. Interest income and other for the quarter was higher or better by $23 million year-over-year.
Actual interest income was better by $15 million, a combination of both higher invested cash balances and higher interest rates, with a balance of $8 million positive variance, primarily favorable FX related items year-over-year. Overall, pre-tax income, again reported, including the one-time item, was up 3%, coming in at $1.492 billion this year, up from $1.449 billion last year. Again, excluding the one-time SG&A charge discussed earlier, operating income would have been up about 11.5%. In terms of income taxes, our tax rate in the fourth quarter came in at 25.7% compared to 27.4% in the fourth quarter a year ago. This quarter tax rate benefited from a few favorable discrete tax adjustments. A few other items of note. Again, in the fourth quarter, as I mentioned, we opened 12 total locations net of reloads at 10 net new locations.
For the whole year, we opened 25 total locations, including five relocations, so a net increase of 20. About three-quarters of those were in the U.S. and a quarter of them international. At Q4 end, our square footage stood at 114 million square feet. Regarding CapEx, fiscal 2019 total spend was right at $3.0 billion. We'd estimate the CapEx for the upcoming year will be that or slightly above that, not that different than the past fiscal year. In terms of stock buybacks in the fourth quarter, we repurchased 52 million shares, 194,000 shares at an average price per share of $268.08. That brought the total year to $247 million on 1.097 million shares at an average price of $225.16. Moving on to a couple other items of note. E-commerce, again, as mentioned, for the quarter on ex gas and rev rec was up 21.9%.
We saw particularly strong growth during the quarter in what we call majors, electronics and appliances and the like. Total online grocery continues to grow at a very healthy clip, recognizing it's still pretty small. That both includes the 2-day as well as 1-day fresh with the help of Instacart. E-com for the first time this past quarter carried some new items like KitchenAid appliances and Weber grills and several high-quality beauty brands for the first time. In addition, we rolled out a few examples of what we-- If you've shopped in the warehouse, what we call merchandise roadshows, kind of a treasure hunt for the warehouses. Some of those things are now being put online. We sold another large diamond ring during the quarter for $220,000. We have upcoming e-com sites planned for two new countries, Japan and Australia, later this fiscal year, sometime mid-fiscal year.
In terms of the Costco app, we've started to add a few things to it, including it can be used as your Digital Membership Card. That was added in July. We now have over 2.5 million activations during the quarter. Currently, the app allows, in addition to Digital Membership and the register as well, view current gas prices. Executive Members can view their growth and their annual 2% Executive Member Reward. We have a few things related to the pharmacy in terms of refilling and managing pharmacy prescriptions, as well as being able to renew and upgrade, the beginnings of some new shopping lists and current promotional offerings. I know plenty of additional enhancements are in the works, we'll continue to roll those out and more tie-ins with Costco, both in warehouse and online.
I mentioned earlier that during the quarter, we opened our first unit in China in the city of Minhang, part of Shanghai. That was on August 27th, to great interest. Due to the overwhelming crowds, it was actually closed about four hours into the opening day. Subsequent to that, crowds have been well managed, and sales have remained very strong over the past month. We've had record sign-ups there. I think it's been helped by the first one that we've opened there, as well as the social media presence. We currently have over 200,000 members signed up. Just to put that in perspective, worldwide, the average Costco, ones that have been open for months and ones that have been open for 35 years, all told, have approximately 68,000 member households per location. Our next opening is planned for early 2021 and also in Shanghai in the area of Pudong.
In terms of tariffs, next item. A quick update. There continues to be a lot of moving parts and changes and a few increases along the way. A few comments. As you're probably aware, the first three lists, which total about $250 billion of imports from China. It includes things from water pitchers and air fryers, to bicycles, to steel shelving, to furniture, to luggage, to shredders, to things like that. Those are currently being tariffed at 25%, with the current plan, we understand, to possibly go to 30% effective October 15th. We'll just have to wait and see. List 4A, which is about $110 billion, it includes things like kitchenware and cookware and domestics. It includes TVs, although I don't think we source from there on that. That started at 15% tariff on September 1st. We'll see where that goes.
Then list 4B, which is an additional $155 billion worth of goods, including electronics, laptops, tablets, toys, small appliances, some apparel and footwear as well. That's currently planned to go to 15% tariff effective December 15th. Again, we'll wait and see. Since the beginning of these tariffs over a year ago, we continue to be active in managing and, where possible, mitigating their impact. Where we can, we accelerate shipments before a tariff is being put into effect or is being planned for an increase in terms of the tariff percentage level. We are working with suppliers daily. We've gone to pretty much every supplier on every item to see what we can do to both reduce costs and figure out how to do that. In some cases, we've reduced our commitments on certain items and again, based on the impact of what we expect.
We've looked at alternative country sourcing where possible and feasible, although again, there's a limited amount of that ability to do that. We've taken advantage of lower pricing on a few U.S. items that have been impacted the other way. The exchange rate, by the way, between our two countries has helped a little bit. All those things. As you might expect, it's all over the board. Every item and every vendor is a little different. In some cases, we're able to hold off on some, and some we need to push it forward and to pass it on. We'll continue to pursue that. Overall, we think we're in a good position relative to retail overall, given our size and scale and our ability and our relationships with our vendors.
The last thing on tariffs, just another area of potential tariffs that relates to yesterday's WTO announcement that the U.S. can legally impose tariffs of up to $7.5 billion in EU-produced goods annually. Later yesterday, the USTR released a list of products it plans to target, with duties planning to take effect October 18th. Some of the products included on the list include 25% duties on certain whiskeys and apparel items from the U.K., various cheeses and olive oils from certain European countries, and certain pork products, butter, and yogurt from various European countries, to name a few. That's pretty much it in terms of what we have to say. Lastly, in terms of upcoming releases, we will announce our September sales results for the five weeks ending this coming Sunday, October 6th, on Wednesday, October 9th, after the market closes.
With that, I'll open it up to questions and answer and turn it back to the operator. Thank you.
Thank you. At this time, I would like to remind everyone, in order to ask a question, please press star then the number 1 on your telephone keypad. That's star then the number 1 on your telephone keypad. We'll pause for just a moment to compile the Q&A roster. Your first question coming from the line of Michael Lasser from UBS. Your line is now live.
Good afternoon. Thanks a lot for taking my question. You've recently run a few promotions to drive membership growth. You've done this in the past periodically. Should we interpret this as any different than that, particularly given that you're now anniversary all the benefit from the price increase? A skeptic could say, well, you want to increase membership growth, and so that's what's driving that decision. How should we think about that?
No, I think as it relates to the one I think we've got currently underway.
Yeah
It's very similar to the three or four we've done over the last three years, four years, I think. We try to put some time between them. We don't want to get people waiting for a promotional item, but they do work, and they help, and I think the timing is just that. Nothing beyond that. I don't anticipate us doing another one for a while, as we haven't in the past.
Okay. That's very helpful. Then on your growth in China, did it surpass your expectations? Does that influence how many and how quickly you can expand in that country?
Well, it clearly surpassed all of our very high expectations. That being said, we're pretty methodical when we go into a new country, wherever it is, and we open 1 or 2 units to start with over the first year or two and go from there. A lot of it has to do with the fact of building the people structure within a country. While we have help from neighboring countries and other areas to start the process, you really want to build your supervisor and your functional managers in the country. If you had asked us before we even opened the first one and felt positive it would be good, but who knew how good we would do. You ask how many we'd have five years hence, the answer would probably be the same as it is today.
We'll open a couple in the first year or two, and then open a couple of more perhaps, and see where we go from there. We're certainly pleased and excited about what we've seen. Maybe it gets a little bigger, but we're gonna be pretty methodical about it as we have in other countries.
Thank you very much, and good luck.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Simeon Gutman from Morgan Stanley. Your line is now live.
Hi, Richard. On gross margin, it looked pretty solid. I want to make sure I heard properly. The core on core was up four, which I'd say looks pretty normal for you, up a little, down a little, which means that the reported, it sounds like the ancillary, the gas, was a big piece of that. Can I ask you if the dynamics there, I think over the past couple of years, have improved in general? Are they still getting better, or this is just pure market dynamics on the gas side?
I think the last few years, not only for us, but other big gas retailers, the supermarkets, and the Walmarts, generally, the new normal over the last couple of years has been better. Particularly for us, I think as prices historically have come down, and some retailers bring them down a little and some a little more, it's still given us the ability, in our view, to have improved margins and operations and probably show even a greater savings relative to what we had a few years ago. That being said, the quarter was good. There were a few quarters back year-over-year that was also good. It does fluctuate, but I'd say the new normal overall is, on average, better than it had been.
The core on core was pretty normal for you as well?
The core on core? Well, yeah. I don't think there was any big surprises there. We always tell you that when it's up a little year-over-year, maybe it'll come down a little. When it's down a little, maybe it'll come up a little bit. As it relates to the underlying factors of competition, we feel that we haven't seen any giant changes in the competitive landscape out there. There's still a lot of competition, and there's a lot of headlines out there. At the end of the day, we're still pretty darn competitive ourselves.
Okay. My follow-up is on the EBIT dollar growth. It looked like it came in high single digit, like nine-ish% this year. If you take the average over the last several years, it's come in around high single digit, that range. As you look out to your next fiscal year. Is there anything one way or the other that should impact that? I think the consensus is modeling a lower rate. I know you don't comment on that, but it's been several years of a little bit outsized growth. I'm just curious if there's any big spending items, margin issues that we should think about as we model the next year.
There's lots of everything, Simeon. We really don't talk about the future. We certainly feel good about what we're doing merchandising-wise. All retailers are impacted with tariffs right now. That's a little bit of an impact. Beyond that, we feel good about what we've got going on in terms of opening up another 20-ish units next year and driving membership. Certainly, we're pleased with seeing our renewal rates continue to go in the higher direction and getting new members. Overall, we feel good, but we'll see.
Great. Thank you. Take care.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of John Heinbockel from Guggenheim. Your line is now live.
Hey, Richard. Two questions on gas. One, I don't think you, or maybe I'm wrong, you guys think about an interaction between gas margin and core-on-core, right? Meaning if you're getting more margin at the pump in any given quarter, you can put that back a little bit into core-on-core. Do you think about it that way? Then on gas gallon growth, where is that now versus where it's been over the last year or two?
Yeah. Well, in terms of the margin, if we're doing stronger in one, can we be a little more competitive elsewhere? While not completely, human nature dictates that, sure, when things are going well in one area, you see what else you can do in another area. I wouldn't say we don't manage it that way necessarily. As it relates to gallons, I think our gallons were up in the high singles. Yeah. Am I clear? Yes.
Okay.
We continue to do, in terms of gallon comps, much stronger than the whole U.S. industry of gasoline.
Secondly, where do you stand now with the opening schedule for the year, maybe by geography and cadence? I guess this past year was a little bit back-end loaded, and I guess it's the same in 2020?
Yeah. Probably so. We generally try to get things open before the holidays. If you miss the holiday, whether it's February or April or May, who cares as much? You try to push them forward a little bit as you approach back to school, Labor Day, all the way through Christmas and New Year's. I think the year before was the same way. We opened a disproportionate number of the locations in Q4.
Okay.
Generally speaking, yes. I don't have a schedule in front of me exactly.
Okay. Thank you.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Christopher Horvers from JPMorgan. Your line is now live.
Thanks. Good evening. One, ask you a question about average ticket growth, ex FX and gas. If you take a look in August, that slowed down pretty sharply relative to the prior trend. Wanted to pick at that a bit. Is that a comparison? Is that a change in mix or perhaps, lapping against some of the center aisle grocery price increases that the vendors started to put through last year? Is it investment in price? Just want to get your thoughts on what's driving that and any thoughts on the outlook there.
If I'm correct, I think the last in Q3, it was like 1.8 or 1.9, and this quarter is a 1.4. I don't have a good answer, a specific answer for you on that. It could be mix. It probably is mix, but I don't know off the top of my head.
Got it. On the tariffs, as you think about what's been passed through, how are peers acting? Are your peers taking a portfolio approach in terms of trying to keep key price items at certain price points and then balancing out, versus, say, less elastic items and how you're assessing the landscape on that side?
I could say to start with that we don't see any major competitive issues. Certainly, I personally think it's easier to manage some subset of our 3,800 total items that we sell at a given time and location versus retailers that's selling 50 and 100, 150,000 items, and they're dealing with categories. Certainly on bigger ticket items, it's harder. When it's a smaller ticket item, it might be easier to eat a little bit of it. When it's something like furniture or lawn and garden, things like that's a little harder. Overall, we generally feel pretty good about it. By the way, the other thing is we're an item-driven business.
I don't have examples in front of me, but I'm sure there's been examples of items where if we weren't able to greatly mitigate or mitigate as best we can some of that tariff, in some cases, again, we would try to geographically move the item or source from another supplier. There are limits to what you can do on that. Overall, I think we're able to decide not to sell something and put something else in its place. I think that makes it a little easier for us relative to general merchandisers. Again, it impacts us all.
Got it. On the announcement last night, there's some items on there that stand out, olive oil and cheese. Can you talk about, particularly on the olive oil side?
Sure
you might be the largest seller of olive oil in the U.S. Can you talk about where you're sourcing there? Because I think Spain's covered, but Italy's not.
Yeah, we source from several countries, including the ones that you just mentioned. There'll be some impact.
Got it. I guess the last question is the money question here is another quarter down, and we haven't had any announcement as to what you're going to do with the cash on the balance sheet that continues to build. Can you talk about what your thought process is there? Has anything changed? Are you trying to keep dry powder for any particular reason? Thanks very much.
Sure. Well, I don't think there's any M&A related dry powder. We really haven't or currently plan to do anything. We do have a total of $1.7 billion coming due in December and February, $1.2 billion, and then $500 million, I believe. We'll pay that down. We are always asked about questions about the special dividend, and our comments have been is that we've done three of them. They seem to have worked well and are viewed positively. It's still in our back pocket. They are special, we'll have to wait and see what we decide to do in the future. There's nothing specific that we have planned.
Understood. Thanks very much.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Karen Short from Barclays. Your line is now live.
Hey, thanks very much. Just on operating profit growth, so the 10%-ish growth, it was up $140 million, excluding the product tax assessment. Can you just give a little color on how much stronger year-over-year gas margins might have impacted that growth rate? I was kind of backing into about $150 million in incremental dollars from better gas margins.
Well, we don't disclose the specifics, but as I think I mentioned, I think it was Q2 year-over-year that we also had good gas margins. Certainly, that was a help to that.
Okay. Is that estimate somewhere in the range, or is it way too high?
Karen, we really don't go into that specific a detail.
Okay. Wondering if you could maybe give a little color in terms of elasticity and anything you could point to on elasticity response with categories where you did raise prices?
Sure. Generally speaking, the bigger the ticket item, where you also have a good portion of the tariff impacts the price, it raises the price. This is an anecdotal example. There was 1 category of those types of items that typically is up mid-single digits year-over-year and instead was flat to down a couple %. That included some price increases. Probably it was down 10% in units. That's a subset of a category. I don't want to suggest it was everything. I've been given examples from our buyers where there have been items where essentially most of the tariff is reflected in a price increase, and we've sold just as many units as we thought we were going to previous to that.
There's been others where the price increase tariff related, less than half of the tariff went into a price increase, if even that, and you saw some unit reduction results. It really has been over the board. Generally speaking, the bigger the item, when you take an item that retails for $999 and have to get it up for yet even about $1,249 using a 25% example, or it'd be 25% of the cost, but nonetheless, first thing you try to do is get it to $1,199 and then go from there, or $1,099. It's really over the board. Net though, it's a slight negative impact.
Okay. I guess along those lines then, can you just maybe give a little color on what inflation was at both, I guess, cost and at retail, and then if you could parse that out between consumables and non-consumables?
It was very little. We've seen very little. You still see, taking tariffs away for a second, on electronics and things, you'll see some deflation. Overall on consumables, it's been pretty much steady she goes. One question I was asked earlier this week was about what's going on with the freight components. Freight has actually improved a little bit year-over-year. Still higher than it had been a few years ago. Overall it's all in the soup here.
Okay, great. Thanks very much.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Chuck Grom from Gordon Haskett. Your line is now live
Hey, thanks Sam. Good afternoon, Richard. On the core on core between categories, a couple were up, hardlines was down, food and sundries, I think you said, was relatively consistent year-over-year. Can you dive into the hardline compression and then also the change from last quarter on the food and sundries segment? Thanks.
Yeah. Part of it's mix change. I mentioned earlier online, but also in store, electronics and majors. Electronics tend to be a little lower margin business. Good growth still. Again, when asked the $64,000 question of is it competition, we're not seeing a lot of big changes out there. There's a lot of headlines with what's going on, particularly on the food side. We haven't seen any big changes.
Okay. Fair enough. Can you just remind us how you guys are thinking about the company's long-term club growth potential, particularly here in the U.S., and if you're seeing any signs of saturation in any of your key markets, both domestically and internationally?
By definition, like in the U.S. and Canada, the rate of growth will slow down, but I would've said that three years ago with what we've done in the U.S. and Canada. We keep finding more opportunities, but over time, it'll slow down. We're also, of course, adding the business centers. We have, I think 18 in the U.S. and one in Canada with our second coming shortly in Canada. That'll add a little bit to it. When asked recently, what do you guesstimate, and it's truly guesstimate, over the next 10 years, on a base of what, 540-ish in the U.S., maybe another 12 plus a year. Right now it's been 15 a year, so it'll come down a little bit. In Canada, one plus a year. We thought we were saturated at 80 in Canada, now we have 101 or two.
That'll keep increasing. Certainly, I think the thing that we feel most comfortable saying is, five, six years from now, the penetration of the percentage of the total openings will certainly by then, likely by then, it's nothing certain, be outside of the U.S. and Canada.
Okay. Great. Then just last question. Online sales, I think are about 5% of total revenue. When you guys are analyzing shoppers that are using either Costco Grocery or Instacart, I'm curious if the purchases have replaced an in-store trip, and I guess if you've analyzed how that could potentially impact your in-store traffic over the next say, 2 to 5 years. Thanks.
Look, it's still early. It's the first full year, I guess. Generally speaking, you see more shops overall, recognizing it's a little less when they're shopping online. The net of the two is still a slight net positive to what we had seen before. What you have to be on the lookout is, does it replace a shop? How many shops does it replace? What we're seeing is, you've got more somebody who's infilling, if you will, and maybe reducing their trips to the location a little bit. I'd call it neutral to slightly good right now, but who knows what happens tomorrow. So far, we feel good about that, by the way, but we can't predict.
Right. Okay.
By the way, I think part of it also is, what I've talked about in the past is, to communicate to our members, aside from the traditional Costco Connection, a lot of the emails. The emails are not just for shopping online. The emails are talking about hot things that are happening in the warehouse, while supplies last in some cases. We've seen good examples of that can help drive frequency into the warehouse or create a trip. That along with gasoline. Not every person that fills up with gas comes in. I think about half do, a little over half do. Even if one of them is incremental, that's a positive. We don't check to see what that is. We're not asking them. We know it can't hurt and it's got to help.
I think those are the types of things that have helped us continue to drive traffic into the buildings, which we want to do.
Makes sense. Thank you.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Scot Ciccarelli from RBC Capital Markets. Your line is now live.
Good afternoon, guys. Scot Ciccarelli. Just a quick follow-up on Chuck's kind of store opening question. Do you have a plan for U.S. versus international store openings for the current fiscal year?
Yes. I think U.S. is still going to be a little more than half. I don't have a sheet in front of me.
A little more than half. Okay, that's good enough. Richard, when you guys bring popular brand name products where there's a lot of price transparency, you mentioned Weber Grills on the call under your website. How are you guys trying to target your pricing on those kinds of products where they can be found in lots of different spots? You guys have always been price competitive, of course, but can you provide any color on how you're thinking about price gaps when you've got, obviously the home improvement guys out there, Amazon Marketplace, et cetera?
Yeah, look, we want to be the lowest priced and we're going to go as low as we can and feel good about. In some instances, we bundle, so we create a value that includes perhaps accessories with the item or an extra whatever. These are the real value. Real items that have a value to it, and to show an even greater savings. We've done that on all kinds of things, whether it's computers or big appliances. By the way, I think that a lot of times competitive pricing tends to be on some of the entry level, what would you see advertised, if you will. Consumers generally trade themselves up with all the extra accessories and what have you. That's where we continue to show good savings, too. We look at some of those big-ticket items, and they're very strong savings to traditional.
Got it. Thank you.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Bobby Griffin from Raymond James. Your line is now live.
Yes. Good afternoon, Richard and everybody else. Thank you for taking my questions. I just wanted to go back to the grocery delivery, and some of the initiatives that have been rolled out here in the U.S. Have those been rolled out to some of your other international markets that you're operating e-commerce sites in?
Yeah, Canada now. We've rolled it out in Canada with some help from others. We would look to do it in a few other countries, but we haven't said when and where. In short order.
Okay, is it safe to assume sometime in FY 2020?
In FY 2020, yes. Starting with the two-day, which is easier, two-day dry. In Canada, we're doing one-day fresh as well. We'll be doing one-day fresh, but we're not doing it yet.
Okay.
We're doing two-day dry up there already.
Okay, I appreciate that. I guess lastly for me, I just wanted to touch on working capital continues to be impressive with payables eclipsing over 102% of inventory now. How much more room do you think you have in that as we model out forward? And is there any one-time items there that are driving some of the performance that we got to keep in mind?
Well, there are seasonal issues. Our Q1 ends a month right around Thanksgiving time. That's generally when it's the highest payables as a % of inventories. I think generally the low point is Q2, mid-February, when sales are a little softer on a seasonal basis. Other than that, if anything, as we built out e-com and have more inventory in there, and we're trying to grow it, and that actually probably impacts it a little negatively, notwithstanding the fact that it's currently a very strong number. We also have some programs where ideally, sometimes you'll have vendors, usually smaller vendors, that even though we and they have negotiated extended terms in some cases, particularly on some seasonal items or stuff that's coming in a few months hence. Sometimes if they need working capital it's a good rate of return for us to pay early, if you will.
What's called anticipation. These are not big numbers, but those impacted a little bit that would reduce it. Overall, I'd probably look at what those percentages were at each of quarter ends for the last few years and assume it's not that different.
Okay. I appreciate that.
That's the best guess.
Yep. I appreciate the detail. Best of luck this fiscal year.
Thank you.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Chris Mandeville from Jefferies. Your line is now live.
Hey, good evening guys. This is Jeff on the line for Chris. A quick question. You touched on it just a little bit within the topic of tariffs. Wanted to know your general temperature check on the consumer. It sounds like they are responding in some ways with big-ticket items, like you said, with price increases. In general, what's your feeling on how the consumer is reacting, just given both tariff politics and geopolitical concerns and stuff of that nature?
I think our numbers speak in a sense that we're still seeing good growth, certainly very good renewal rates, good results at openings. We feel pretty good about it. Now, if you ask me how does that relate to consumer, who the heck knows? I think if we all turned off the television and stopped listening to everything every day, we'd all be better.
Right. Got it. Thank you.
I think everybody's a little desensitized to everything.
Right. No, I understand. Thank you very much.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Oliver Chen from Cowen and Company. Your line is now live.
Hi. Thanks. Congrats on the progress on Diamonds as well. Regarding the digital execution, the mobile app development has been really progressive. What are your thoughts on the biggest needle movers there? As you think across digital, whether that be adding new product or improving checkout and search or your new DC, how would you prioritize the bigger drivers for traffic and growth at large?
Well, I think first of all, as it relates to the app, just getting more people on it. I mentioned there's about 2.5 million since we improved it. There's still a lot of work to be done to add things to it. That was since July. I think we have over 10 million members on the app. One of the other things was just getting email addresses for everybody. You guys who've known us for a long time, we were a little later to the game than others in terms of even collecting email addresses years ago. We've had a big push in the last couple of years, and we've dramatically increased the number of members where we have good email addresses. Now, that sounds simple, and why didn't we do that? I can only tell you we are, and that's helping.
We're getting more people to open the emails and to click on things. I think one of the things I've talked about in the past, we still have these different buckets of money, starting with the improvement from the credit card transition 2 years ago, the membership fee increase, tax reform. All these things have helped, and as you know, we take that and make it a better value for the member. I think that's helped us, whether it's buyers, hot buys, and wow items, and I think that's given us a little bit of the leg up over the last 2 years in terms of helping achieve the numbers that we have. I think more connection to the member is going to help. Certainly, there's no slowdown in renewal rates. That's been good to us.
Beyond that, it's what we see every four weeks at our budget meeting from the buyers. New and exciting stuff, constantly improving existing items. There are a number of examples of whether KS items, what we continue to improve the item and lower the price point while an improved item and therefore increase the value dramatically. There's looking at exciting items, not just for us in the U.S. to ship to these other countries, but also to take some exciting items from other countries and bring them to other parts of Costco. When I think about from a merchandising standpoint, we're at the top of our game in a lot of things. On the efficiency side, we got a lot of expenses going on. We talk about e-commerce fulfillment. There's costs associated with that as we do that.
There's IT in general with everything that we've got going on, whether it's e-commerce or fulfillment and depot infrastructure, the new poultry complex. There's lots of things that are in our numbers in terms of expenses as well, and that we've done pretty well. I think we keep doing the kinds of things that we're doing as it relates to global sourcing and in some cases, some vertical integration, but ultimately just driving more value.
Thanks, Richard, and you've done a good job managing those digital margins overall. As you pursue the right kind of fulfillment options and supply chain and getting the smaller packages to customers with speed, what are your thoughts on those investments and how they align with what customers are looking for with speed of delivery?
Well, you're not going to be able to order something, and we'll drop it off an hour later anytime soon. For us, first order of improvement was, I can remember it wasn't that long ago where online, particularly on a big ticket item, a big physical item as well, it's an expected delivery time, 3-5 weeks. Now it's 3-5 days, and certain items with certain vendors are now on, you can actually schedule delivery and installation. Tires is a great example as well. It used to be with those online now, you can actually order them and schedule your appointment at the warehouse where you're shopping at. These are all basic things, but things that we hadn't done for a long time. I think you'll see continued improvement in that.
Okay, fine.
None of it's easy, and it all costs more than you think, but those are in our numbers.
You've really had good momentum, including with Diamonds at Costco and the big ticket sales of Diamonds. What's your strategy with that business, and how has it been going? Any things we should think about?
Look, it starts with great quality and great value. One of the things I think that has helped, the jewelry area is a good example with the lockers that we're now rolling out to a number of locations. A lot of people on high value, small size items, they can't ship it to their place of work, and they don't want to leave it at their front porch. We saw an uptick of some of those items and some other items like handbags and a limited number of electronics. As it relates to jewelry overall, I know we've got a lot of press because I mentioned a $400,000 Diamond a couple of quarters ago. We're selling close to 200,000 carats of Diamonds a year. That's a lot of carats.
Jewelry business is one of the things that hits you just past the electronics when you typically walk into a Costco, and it's all about value and trust.
Thank you. Best regards.
Thank you. Your next question comes from the line of Robert Ohmes from Bank of America. Your line is now live.
Hey, Richard. Thanks for taking my questions. One question I'm getting is just a lot on the chicken plant. Can you just sort of let us know how that is going so far versus expectations? Also, was it about $10 million of the pre-opening expense this quarter, and how does it affect pre-opening going forward? Maybe related to chicken plants, are there any other types of vertical integration things that you might be looking at to do further?
Well, look, this is a big plant. I think it's the most state-of-the-art plant that I understand in the country. It's going to be very efficient, but it's going to take close to a year to get to full production. The first several weeks have gone as planned in terms of the first chicken went through and more each day. You're going to get up to processing of 2 billion birds a year. I'm sorry, 2 million birds a week in about 40 more weeks. The pre-opening stopped effectively when we opened it on September 10th, so a little bit if you want, but not like that big amount. It's a huge facility and it's also air-chilled.
About 95% of U.S. poultry plants are still water-chilled, all the issues in terms-- it's considered a very high quality food item, and it allows us to deliver that while doing a lot of things for the environment as well. There's a lot of good things. It doesn't come without a cost. It was a big investment for us, and we'll know more in a year, but we're excited about it. Other things, a year ago, we added a second meat plant. We've had one in Tracy, California, for many years. We opened one in Morris, Illinois. We also, as you know, opened a bakery commissary in Canada that will also serve much of the United States in terms of things like cookie dough and croissants ready to bake off on premise. We're looking at a variety of greenhouse opportunities.
There's a lot of technology and new things going on in the area of agriculture. Wouldn't it be nice to greatly lower the price of not having to airship things to Hawaii, as well as being closer to the market and being better for the environment? I think given our size and given some of the things that are going on, we're going to hopefully benefit from that. But other than that, there's nothing else I don't think we've got planned in a big way. I would say, beyond the couple of things I mentioned in the last one and a half, and certainly this new chicken plant, a few things on the greenhouse side, but not the type of capital investment required that was done in the poultry complex.
Got it. That's great. Thanks, Richard.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Michael Montani from Evercore ISI. Your line is now live.
Hi, Richard. Thanks for taking the question. Just wanted to ask for an update on Executive program rollout, if you can just remind us kind of which countries have it now and which ones might be slated to get it next?
Well, we have it in U.S., Canada, Mexico, U.K., Korea, and Japan.
Just rolled it out in Japan.
We just rolled it out this month in Japan. Korea, we rolled out about a year and a half ago?
A year ago.
A year ago.
Okay, great. One housekeeping, one if I could, is around gasoline. Can you give us a sense, I had been thinking that was around 10, 11% of sales for the quarter. Also, what was the ASP for gasoline this quarter?
Hold on. I think it's on that summary sheet.
Yeah. 294 versus 305.
$294 versus $305 a year ago.
Okay. The last thing that I had was on Citi Visa. Can you give us an update just on how many members have that now and what you're seeing in terms of third-party spend, just how it's progressing?
I don't have those numbers in front of us. I can tell you we continue to add new members. The average reward per existing credit card holder on the Citi Visa card continues to increase. The rewards are substantial, and it's really working well. Probably better than we had originally had hoped, and it's done well for us and hopefully our partners.
Great. Thank you.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Kelly Bania from BMO Capital. Your line is now live.
Hi, good evening. Thanks for fitting me in, Richard. Just wanted to go back to the store potential question, really in the U.S. I think it was a few years ago that you noted you were able to go into some smaller communities than you maybe originally thought. Just curious, as you think about the next couple of years, what kind of size and demographics of the communities are you looking at and planning for new clubs? Also when you go back to the saturation question and think about how do you analyze when you think you are at saturation, what are some of the key metrics that you look at? Is it the pace of the ramp in terms of sales, the cannibalization of members? Just any help on how you guys think about analyzing that.
Thirty years ago, I think the view was, is you needed about a half a million people in the trade area, plus certain number of businesses and all that kind of stuff. Today, that number could be as low as 200,000 sometimes. It depends. Some of the smaller medium markets we've gone into in the last few years, generally are markets where our direct competitors were, in many cases for 20 or 30 years, and we had just never gone there. We've gotten probably a little more confident that when we go in it, there's room for both of us, and we've done relatively well. I think the other thing is, if you look back over the last few years, and my guess is in the upcoming years, there'll be some infill opportunities.
I've used the example on calls on the east side of Seattle, in the Bellevue side of Seattle, where historically we had three locations Issaquah, Kirkland, and Woodinville. About two years ago, we opened in Redmond. Let's say in those three locations had about 190,000-ish members between them, households, so 60,000, 65,000 each. We only added about 10,000 new members in the next year. You had a lot of loyal members that started shopping more frequently because we were closer to them. Part of that comes when you have high volume. In that example, I think, before we opened that fourth location on this side of Seattle, we had, I think, over $800 million aggregate sales, one in the lower threes and the other two in the mid to high twos.
When you get to that level, that gives you a little more comfort that you can afford a little cannibalization. In that example, I think, the first year, net of cannibalization, we did $120+ million of business, $120 million-$130 million of business. It's pretty easy to estimate and guesstimate what you think you could do, particularly when you have a loyal membership base. There are other markets, like if you look at the greater Los Angeles market, I'm talking the greater geographic market, I think we probably have 60-ish, roughly 60 units. The view is we can have another 15, but they're all very specific geographies which are not quite impossible but very difficult. We'd be thrilled to get one of those 15 open every couple of years, but you don't know if that can happen.
I think it's all over the board in terms of smaller trade areas, markets where our competition has been and we are just entering, and then continued expansion and infills.
Okay. That is helpful. Maybe just another one on click and collect and how that is going and maybe what you are learning from a logistics and labor perspective as you do that for some of the big-ticket items. Any changes or thoughts with respect to broadening that to some other categories like grocery, which I realize are more maybe complicated and labor intensive.
Yeah. I don't see us going too deep. We're talking about tires and pharmacy and jewelry, handbags, computers, high value, small size items for the time being.
Okay, thanks.
Yes.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Laura Champine from Loop Capital. Your line is now live.
Thanks for taking my question. It's just a quick one on inventory. Your inventory receipts looks like grew a little less rapidly than they have in prior quarters and also relative to sales growth. Just wanted to get a sense of why you might have cut your ordering and whether that reflects on your thoughts on our current quarter sales trends.
My guess is it's a little bit of an anomaly that I don't read a lot into it. It might be that we've really built up, as an example, increased year-over-year inventories related to our e-com and things like that. Maybe less of that happened in this quarter. We've kind of cycled that for a year, I'm guessing. Other than that, there's nothing big to read into that.
Understood. Thank you.
Why don't we take two more questions?
Thank you. Your next question coming from the line of Rupesh Parikh from Oppenheimer. Your line is now live.
Good afternoon. It's actually Erica Eyl on for Rupesh. I just have one quick question, just flipping back to international. When you look at a market like China, when do you typically see an inflection point in profitability in those clubs?
Well, at the club level, it could be the first year or a few years down the road. You've got a big central expense. You've geared up whether you have one location or 10. There's not a huge change in the cost of a central-- with buyers and operations people and accounting department and the like. It'll grow some, not nearly from one to 10. It depends on the country. Usually, it can be year four or five. I think in Japan, which is now 20-ish years old, our original budget was to open five in five years and to turn the quarter to profitability towards the end of year five. I think we hit profitability near the end of year four, we opened six. That's probably a good guesstimate.
It's probably going to be slower in a country like France, where it took us 10 years to get one open. While we're just looking for additional sites, it still could be a couple of years out. You're not going to go from one to five in five years. That's going to happen. We're going to have a mix of those.
Okay, great. That's super helpful.
Thank you. We have your next question coming from the line of Chuck Cerankowski from Northcoast Research. Your line is now live.
Good evening, Richard. One housekeeping question. Can you talk about that tax reserve on the product? What drove that? Was that an excise tax kind of thing?
It was an assessment on a tax that some authority felt we should have been collecting. We're, again, going to file a protest and see how much, but I can't really talk a lot about it yet.
All right.
Again, it relates to a, I think, seven-and-a-half-year period that ended in 2016 that we were just notified of the formal assessment. Again, under GAAP accounting, we've reserved for it.
Okay. Looking at the tariff situation, could that be an impetus to use private label sourcing on more products as a result to get the price down? In general, what are you thinking about for new categories, new items for private label in the coming fiscal year?
Yeah. Not really for tariffs. First of all, some of our private label items are sourced out of China as well. It's going to impact everybody, and then nothing changes quickly overnight. In terms of KS items, I think that you have seen of late, and you'll continue to see a variety of items. Recent introductions are things like all kinds of specialty waters, essence waters, extra virgin olive oil that may have some impact on tariffs, chocolate chips. I'm just looking down the list here. Several apparel items for men, women, and children. More housewares. I think you're going to continue to see that grow, and raise the quality further of existing items, that continuous improvement cycle. You're going to see that on some frozen food items, diapers. I'm just looking down my list here. Soaps, coffee pods.
We've taken the KS coffee pod, which I think three or four years ago, we went fair trade. Since then, it's now organic and recyclable, and we've lowered the price by over 10% to the customer while improving, if you will, the value and the quality, and it's driving more sales. Again, there's lots of little things as regards to the types of items and what we're doing there.
All right. Thank you. Good luck for next year or this year.
Thank you. I think that's it. Thank you everyone, and the group here will be around if there's any additional questions. Have a good day.
Thank you everyone for participating. This concludes today's conference. You may now disconnect. Have a lovely day.