A repeat guest that we have had the last few years here. We have Liren Chen, CEO of InterDigital. Thank you so much for coming again.
Matt, thank you for having me.
You operate in a really unique part of the market.
Yeah.
For those that are less familiar with the company, and just given your tenure, could you talk a little bit more about what InterDigital does today, and really what attracted you to the company and to the opportunity?
Okay. Good morning, everyone. Thank you for joining the meeting. I know it's a tough travel week, so glad you guys are here. We are one of the largest independent R&D companies in the world. We focus on solving the most difficult, challenging problems in wireless and video, and now AI systems. We build one of the largest patent portfolios, and most importantly, one of the most valuable patent portfolios, and we license them on a subscription basis to some of the largest customers and vendors in the world. We are talking about Apple, Samsung, and you name it, very large customers on a long-term basis. We keep on innovating, and over time, we're also frankly driving the standard creation.
We lead the development of industry standards, and that gives us, frankly, these two flywheels of innovation, R&D and standard, and that gives us an edge on the marketplace. Regarding what attracted me to InterDigital, I've been in the industry for 30 years now. My resume is relatively simple. I only worked for two companies, and the first one is Qualcomm. I spent 25 years at Qualcomm. I was an inventor. I was an attorney by training, and then part of my job at Qualcomm was running the IP business, including patent portfolio and licensing and others. What attracted me to InterDigital from Qualcomm was multiple things. One is InterDigital's business model is very similar to Qualcomm's technology licensing business. There's similarity there. There's frankly also opportunity.
Opportunity was what I bring to the table to add certain aspects to the business on assisting certain group of customers, and frankly, to grow the business into a new area on the cloud space. I joined the company five years ago, and it's a great opportunity for me to dig into InterDigital and frankly adding value to the company. So far so good.
When discussing the breadth of your portfolio on your last call, you mentioned that you're pursuing all these opportunities in parallel across smartphones, TV enforcement, and streaming negotiations.
But when we looked at your Q4 guide, it is based on existing contracts with these things being additive. Can you help us kind of think about which of these sources might be the most likely source of upside, and if there is any parts of these businesses that are maybe a little bit further along than the market appreciates?
Absolutely. If you look at our business, it is important to know that we work on foundational technology. That is in wireless connectivity, that is in video, that is in artificial intelligence, as some folks will call it super intelligence now. We build a patent portfolio, then we license them to vertical industries. The largest one for us traditionally has been smartphones, because it is large volume, high-value use case. Our technology also underpins connectivity on consumer electronics, TVs, laptops, IoT devices, and also increasingly driving value on the cloud side, right? The cloud, it is a number of different use cases. The most obvious ones are streaming video on demand. We have been working on those, frankly, verticals for multiple years now, and so far we have been frankly delivering results at various different stages.
Regarding your question on the Q4 guidance, which we have given at the Q3 earnings here, it is important to know, as I said earlier, most of our customers' licenses are long-term based. Think of licenses as a subscription to our business model, to our patent portfolio. When we license them, generally speaking, it is between three to five years as the average length of our contract. We do have these compounding growths as you add new customers on top of existing customers. The other thing that is important to note is we give annual guidance at the beginning of the year, and when we provide annual guidance, we do factor in new business that we hope and project to close throughout the year.
But when we get into the quarter by quarter, we actually do not put new customers or new contracts that we may be closing in the next quarter. That is for multiple reasons. Primary reason, it is hard to predict precise timing of those negotiations, and therefore, when we provided the Q4 numbers, we were very specific in our guidance was, hey, the Q4 numbers are purely based on existing contracts. The fact that we have exceeded our annual guidance in, frankly, before counting any new business that potentially can be closed in Q4, it strengthens our business. It is frankly a further indication of the subscription model that I described to you earlier.
I remember a couple of years ago, we had a very similar conversation about the total penetration of the mobile market, and clearly you guys have continued to grow that since then. You just recently signed a new license with a top PC manufacturer w hich I think gets your market share up to about 70%?
Yes.
When we think about how penetrated you are into that market and the remaining opportunity, could you just kind of expand on that idea? And also just maybe from like a per-unit economics, how smartphones and PCs compare to one another?
Yes. I remember meeting you two years ago. It was a pleasure. Now it is happy to look back at the past few years where we frankly have delivered on the strategy we have laid out. A few years ago, we were describing the growth we have in the smartphone industry, but we were at the time need to sign a bunch of new customers, primarily China-based, but we also have done really good job renewing our major license with Apple and Samsung. Now the smartphone industry, we frankly have more than 85% penetration. We also frankly focus on a bunch of other devices. PC, the one that we have signed a top five customer last quarter. That whole PC segment to us is relatively new.
Frankly, we signed Lenovo, HP, and the latest large customers all in the past few years. We have about 70% coverage now, and we obviously wanted to grow as much as possible to close to 100% because they all use wireless connectivity, they all use video technology. Some of them increasingly have AI built in. Back to your question, how do we decide PC economics versus cellphone economics? The fundamental principle is actually fairly straightforward. It is really boiled down to the benefit our technology enable on those devices. If you think about it, there are certain PCs having cellular built in, always on connectivity. Those use cases are very similar to smartphones.
Therefore, our economic for those cellular-enabled PC are practically identical, if you would, to the high-end smartphones. There are a number of PCs, frankly, depend on which market, does not have cellular built in. They are Wi-Fi only devices. In these use cases, we do adjust our expectation for value in the Wi-Fi only devices accordingly. That is a principle.
When we start to think about some of the more emerging growth drivers for your business, the CTV space has gone from $0 to hitting $60 million during this year.
Yes.
Could you kind of just help us think through more of like what the magnitude of the CTV opportunity is, what that ramp looked like over the year? Then maybe touch on like your agreement with Amazon, some of these like big use cases of where this business could be going.
Yes. If you look at our foundational technology, it's about connectivity, it's about video codec that driving immersive user experience. Then increasingly it's about AI or ISAC, right? The intelligence we bring to the table. Historically, our license are primarily focused on the device side, right? We're talking about smartphones, TVs, laptops, or connected cars. But increasingly, we are focused on the cloud side, right? Streaming video on demand, just one use case. You ask why? Why do we want to focus on the cloud side? Again, back to our business model. We try to license our technology to the industry that benefit the most. It's all about economic benefit. It's really about the codec technology that our engineer has developed that giving the streaming industry what they have, right? I mean, the latest video codec give you compression 1,000 time to 1 , literally, right?
It's 1,000x traffic we squeeze into 0.1%, allows you to maintain the user experience with the quality, with the connectivity, with the reliability that a streamer, frankly, service provider would not have other than they have the technology that we provided. That whole industry is very large. I mean, there's a lot of public report on. Annual revenue for streaming industry overall, exactly the same size as smartphone industry, around $400 billion-$500 billion per year in annual sales. And it's growing at much faster pace, having higher profitability, and frankly, that's just the beginning, right? We have focused on this particular area for multiple years. I'm very pleased that early this year, we have agreed to license Amazon's services and devices. Services, I'll be refer to the Amazon Prime services. But there's financial term will be determined by arbitration.
Under the proper accounting guidance, we are recognizing revenue conservatively, which is the $60 million that you are referring to. If I take a step back here, I'm really pleased with where we are on the streaming side. I actually believe we are ahead of schedule. If you look at the strategy we laid out in 2024, that's when we probably first time had the discussion. We said, "Hey, this is a growth opportunity. This probably will drive growth well beyond 2030." And we have been so far executing ahead of schedule.
I'm always impressed in our discussions how often you come to pretty quick and amicable agreements with a lot of these customers. But when they do go to binding arbitration, like what we're seeing with the Lenovo that's expected to get resolved in the first half of next year. Could you kind of talk about the varying outcomes that could come from this and how you kind of think about communicating growth to an investor base around that?
Yeah. It's important to know that vast majority of our agreement get completed through bilateral negotiation, right? You will see why. Primarily for several reasons. One is we have been in the industry for multiple decades now, right? Our company was founded in 1972. We have been licensing our technology to some of the largest vendors, I'm talking about Apple and Samsung, for multiple decades. We do have a fairly strong reputation in the industry for innovations, increasing value in our IP portfolio, and that's driving. In the last five years I've been joining the company, we have licensed close to 60 different vendors. Some of them are renewals, some of them are brand new, but majority of them, I'll say probably 80%+ of the agreement was done through negotiation.
However, there's once in a while we simply couldn't agree to the terms, primarily the financial terms. In those situation, we do offer, always offer, and sometime our licensee, our customer agree to do bilateral binding arbitration. We prefer binding arbitration primarily because it's an effective way, it's an efficient way to reach agreement, and that works by third party independent arbitrator deciding on the issue that we couldn't agree on, right? Once in a while, if the other party simply refuse to arbitrate, then we do have to eventually defend our IP by going for the enforcement route, and that's not our first choice. That's our last resort. Back to Lenovo arbitration, this process took, frankly, a couple years ago. We negotiated quite a bit, and we were able to close on many of the terms, but we frankly couldn't agree on the financial term.
That arbitration, the hearing has completed, frankly, in October. The whole process in my side has finished, and we are now just waiting for the arbitrator to decide. Just try to give a little bit color for it. Lenovo is a good long-term customer. It's a bit complex in the arbitration, primarily because they have two primary business. Lenovo is a number one PC maker in the world by volume, as you guys know, and it also one of the major top 10 smartphone vendor because they have purchased and continue to use a Motorola brand. Therefore, the arbitration involving getting value on both of their product line, and it took a little bit time, and we are confident the result will come out early next year, okay? Hopefully we'll get a good positive result, and we are confident on the value of our portfolio.
Maybe one more on kind of more the legal side. You got a preliminary injunction against TCL in Brazil.
Yep.
The court filing, I think this was the quote, said that their offer was an order of magnitude too low.
Yep.
Could you just kind of discuss how often you're dealing with these cases on a region by region basis versus a blanket kind of statement with a company like TCL?
Yeah. So what you're referring to is our latest win in Brazil. So just for everyone's benefit, TCL is a very large vendor in China, headquartered in China, and they are currently probably the number two TV maker by volume. We have been negotiating with them for multiple years, and we frankly offer them binding arbitration in the process, they refused. After years and years of negotiation, we decided we have to enforce our IP right, otherwise it's not fair to us because they have been essentially using our IP without paying us. It's also not fair to other paying customers, because by not paying us, they have unfair advantage in the marketplace for the people who are paying for the IP as they should do, right? So when we do enforce our IP, it's a multi-jurisdictional process.
We asserted our IP against them in Brazil, in the United States, as well as in Europe. The Brazil case went to trial first. It's important to know that case was decided by the court based on third party independent expert, not our expert, not TCL's expert. Third party independent expert had written a report based on our behavior, which the court had found we have satisfied our FRAND obligation. Basically, we have treating them fairly in the process. The same expert also decided their offer was magnitude too low, which means they have not step up as they should do, right? Based on those decision, the court has issued preliminary injunction basically to say, as the case is being decided through the process, they need to stop infringing our IP by not using the technology that's frankly essential to this particular video standard called HEVC.
It's a pretty important win for us, but it's a first step to get to a license agreement. So back to your question on region versus global, it's important to know that we almost always license our technology on a global basis, and here's why. Our technology is global in inherent nature. We are talking about global technology, global standard. We are frankly also dealing with very often a global supply chain, right? You have chips level, you have softwares, you have devices, you have devices being shipped across border. So we always prefer a global license, but we do factor in each vendor's different footprint, right? If they are selling devices in emerging country with lower selling price because it's not as advanced feature as some of the advanced market, we do factor in those in our negotiation.
We license on global basis, but we do factor in the licensee's uniqueness in their footprint on global product shipment as part of the economic calculation.
We've talked about mobile, we've talked about PC, we've talked about streaming. Can you help us kind of think about what the other logical adjacencies are to your product portfolio?
Yeah.
Where you're really investing when you start thinking about what are going to be the future growth drivers of InterDigital?
It's important to know that we are foundational technology developer. When we invest in technology, we try to be 5- 10 years ahead of time. But we do have three pillars of research. Those are generally in wireless communication, determined by cellular or Wi-Fi. Then we invest heavily in essentially enriching user experience, primarily based on the ability to deliver video, right? Currently, it's primarily 2D video, but there's a lot of research in 3D video, immersive user experience for gaming, entertainment, and it's for, frankly, a lot of very 3D use cases for AR, VR glasses, among others. And increasingly try to drive AI or ISAC into the end-to-end user experience. Those are our pillars. If you look at the adjacent licensing opportunity, a number of them will be the new area for physical AI, robotics.
A number of them will be enriched user experience on, frankly, services, real time on 3Ds, right? AR, VR, gaming, among others. And we demonstrate haptic, the sensor feedback. But there is so much more on the cloud side. When I mentioned earlier the streaming video on demand, it is just the beginning of cloud use case, but there is a bunch of other use cases based on collaborations, work product, entertainment. So those are, frankly, many, many years to go.
Maybe when we think about how you enter those markets, you have a really strong monetization engine. Obviously, M&A would be an option for you if that was the route you wanted to go. How do you think about M&A versus organic development? When you think about M&A, I mean, are there patent portfolios out there that are very attractive but maybe under-monetized? How you think about what the core capabilities of InterDigital brings to an acquired company?
Yeah. We absolutely do look at M&A quite carefully, and we look at them quite holistically in parallel with our organic R&D engine, which is very, very strong. When we look at M&A opportunity, we sometimes look at them for IP assets if we believe there's a tuck-in opportunity. As I said, we have a very strong IP engine. Just give you a stat. Every single day, on average, we produce seven new patents organically every day. Therefore, our bar is pretty high, right, when we look at the M&A opportunity on the market for patent. But we absolutely look at other companies sometimes for talent. Sometimes we look out for opportunity that we can introduce a technology into the standard process. By introducing them into industry standard, you elevate the adoption curve quite a bit. I'll give you an example.
About the same time last year, almost exactly a year ago, we acquired a company called Deep Render that's based in London, and they are a pioneer in AI research. They were focused on AI and video, and they tried to be, frankly, a software company, and frankly, they were too small to scale. We were attracted to that company primarily for their talent, but we also recognizing they have an earlier technology that if we can properly scale it and then try to demonstrate it, try to introduce into the next generation video codec standard, this will be a game changer. I'm very pleased we closed that deal pretty quickly, and we were frankly bidding against much larger acquirer, but the company frankly echoed with our innovative culture, and we acquired it pretty quickly. So far, we've done a lot of working elevating, demonstrating their software.
A few months ago, I think three months ago roughly, we demonstrated the industry very first end-to-end AI native video codec. Now we are in process to convincing the rest of the industry to consider adopting into the next version of the video coding standard. So that to me is a perfect example of what we were able to acquire a company that has very good foundational piece that we can elevate, combining with our resource, combining with our standard knowledge to get to the next level.
You mentioned a minute earlier that you like to look out 5-10 years and kind of see where the industry's going when you're building out your patent portfolio. There's been a lot of conversations lately about the rise in bot traffic within the internet.
Yeah.
Matthew Prince, the CEO of Cloudflare, recently said that he thinks bots are going to 1,000x from where they are today.
Yeah.
Could you talk a little bit more about what would need to change in telecom networks, I guess, to be able to support something like that? And then how do you position InterDigital to have the right product portfolio to help support and ultimately monetize a change like that?
Yeah. I think there is going to be a bunch of impact, as you mentioned here. Many people, including ourself, are projecting, predicting bot or AI or the physical AI will have a foundational shift of the network infrastructure, primarily because the traditional network is built for primarily downloading traffic, right? There is some uplink, but it is not really specified the same capacity. That is a major shift. When we design 6G, there will be more focus on uplink traffic, but that is just the beginning. There is also going to be a very in-depth, frankly, framework being done on treating those traffic differently. When you are talking about tokens, training versus inference, those traffic need to be treated with different priority, so there will be a different category of technology being put in there. 6G also has a very important technology called ISAC, Integrated Sensing and Communication together.
That is basically the technology that bridging the physical AI, it is a logical AI in the real deployment. So those are just some of the examples. Regarding how do we predict or monetize our technology, two things. We invest heavily into new technology, try to be five to 10 years ahead of time. It is not easy. Therefore, we invest historically close to 50% of recurring revenue into R&D. 50%, that is very, very high. So we try to have a broad footprint. But second piece, which is super important, is our leadership in standard creation. We talk a lot about R&D, but we also send our best engineers to lead the industry standard creation. By able to lead that process, we have a better chance of predicting the future because we are helping creating it.
So I think combining those two major strengths of our company, that give us a better chance of getting the technology, getting the IP that is relevant for the future.
And maybe building off that point, when you are thinking about investing today for these revenue opportunities in the future, how does that kind of lead you into the revenue margin profile that you are aiming for?
Yeah, I mean, I am happy to please. By the way, our CFO is in the audience. We really enjoy our leverage for the business as we grow revenue, frankly, our new revenue drop to the bottom line. If you look at our past several years' performance, our adjusted EBITDA margin is close to 60%, sometime a bit above. That is obviously combining our double-digit growth for ARR in the last few years, so we are in the Rule of 70, not Rule of 40, right? Those are really attractive. We also are mindful that our business is driven by long-term R&D. My goal is not to maximize the margin, it is really try to find the right balance point to invest for the future and yet still deliver value to our shareholders as a shareholder back.
We try to, frankly, grow our recognizing recurring revenue by double digit. That is our goal. In the meantime, try to maintain our adjusted EBITDA margin around 60%. That we believe is the right balance.
Then maybe more of a broad-based question, but what have you seen as kind of the impact of gen AI and I guess the broader agentic changes, both on how you do work within InterDigital but also just how the market is changing around your company?
I think gen AI, as we touched on a little bit already on the broad question, it's a great driver for our company. Our company focus on connectivity, enrich user experience, as well as intelligence at the whole end-to-end network. Gen AI is probably one of the most foundational driver for our future, for the demand of technology. In the meantime, we are also using gen AI to improve our internal operating efficiency, quality of research, quality of, frankly, IP portfolio creation, and even as basic as quality of our financial forecast. Those are powerful technologies that we definitely adopting anywhere we can.
We started off talking about how you operate a really unique company within the ecosystem, or at least within the public space. What do you think is the biggest investor misconception about InterDigital?
Oh, I love our investors. I'll start with that. I think we have done a lot in communicating, better providing information. One of the large, one of the most, I think frustrating sometime is a strong word, perception for our company is, I hear this word, your business too lumpy. Lumpiness is something I do hear from investors. We try to explain why, because when we go license our IP, most of the time we try to get negotiate for both going forward, going forward for IP license, as well as past use. Our patents are very often enabling technology that's in the standard. Anyone who have been building devices, service according to the standard have been using it, sometime using it for a long time. When we negotiate a contract for the first time, we get paid going forward.
We also get paid for their past infringement of our IP. That past catch-up piece, depend on when it happens, create one-time payment in our business that can create lumpiness. That's sometime for someone who are new to our company, when they try to do year-over-year comparison, that time sometime is confusing. What we do provide is we provide the next level financial information. We provide the annualized recurring revenue. We break out the catch-up payment. In our earnings, we actually point out, say, "Hey, for this quarter, this is the catch-up portion, this is the ARR piece." In the end, we frankly like to have both. If people have been infringing our IP for a long period of time, we try to get paid. Going forward, obviously we add to the strengths.
We provide both information to our investor, and we have demonstrated we are able to grow the ARR as well as collecting, I think since the five years I've been here, like $800 million in catch-up payment. That's a very substantial amount. It provide value to the shareholders.
All right, we've only got about 15 seconds left, but I like to end. What is the thing you're most excited for in the next five years at InterDigital?
Technology. Look, I'm an engineer in my heart, so I joined the company because of technology. I get most excited talking to our inventors about what's new, what's coming. The future is super bright. We have 6G coming. We have the next generation of video codec that's being implemented. We are driving the 3D use cases, and super importantly, we are enabling AI end-to-end. So technology is really what get me excited coming to work every day.
Liren, thank you so much for joining us again. See you again next year.
Absolutely. Thank you, Matt. Appreciate it.