Good morning, and welcome to Macy's first quarter 2018 earnings conference call. Today's call is being recorded. I would now like to turn the call over to your host, Karen Hoguet. Please go ahead.
Hi. Good morning, everyone. Jeff Gennette, our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and I would like to welcome you to the Macy's call to discuss our first quarter earnings and our outlook for the remainder of the year. Any transcription or other reproduction of the statements made in this call without our consent is prohibited. A replay of the call will be available on our website, www.macysinc.com, beginning approximately two hours after the call concludes. Please refer to the investor relations section of our website for discussion and reconciliation of any non-GAAP financial measures discussed this morning.
Keep in mind that all forward-looking statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause the company's actual results to differ materially from the expectations and assumptions mentioned today due to a variety of factors that affect the company, including the risks specified in the company's most recent form, 10-K and other SEC filings. I'm now going to turn the call over to Jeff.
Thank you, Karen, and good morning, everyone, and welcome to the call. As you saw in this morning's release, we continued our momentum from the holiday season into the first quarter, in fact, exceeding our own expectations on most measures. We delivered adjusted earnings per share of $0.48. Comparable store sales were up 4.2% on an owned plus licensed basis, and when adjusted for the estimated impact of the shift in friends and family from the second quarter to the first quarter, comparable store sales were up 1.7% for owned plus licensed. I'm pleased to report strong performance across all three brands, Macy's, Bloomingdale's, and Bluemercury, across all families of business and all regions of the country. It's very encouraging to see the continued improvement in our brick-and-mortar business.
We still have a lot of work ahead of us, but store by store, quarter by quarter, we are on the path to return Macy's Inc. to consistent comparable store sales growth. Based on the strong start to the year and the healthy macro environment, we are raising both earnings and sales guidance for the year. We now anticipate annual comparable store sales in the 1%-2% range for owned plus licensed, which is a one point lift from our prior guidance. We anticipate that annual earnings per share will be in the $3.75-$3.95 range, which is up $0.20 from our prior guidance. Karen will take you through the details of the quarter and give you some additional context on guidance. Before she does, I want to give you some perspective on the first quarter and an update on our strategic initiatives.
Looking at the quarter, we did have the wind at our back as consumer spending remained strong, and we saw significant improvement in international tourism spending. We anticipate this to continue through the year. In addition to healthy spending trends, the team is also executing really well. We have a very healthy inventory position, which helps our margins and our fashion freshness. Our focused merchandising strategies have resulted in great assortments and great strong fashion in our stores. The new loyalty program is having the intended impact on the spending patterns of our best customers. We're taking the necessary steps to improve the customer journey, both in our stores and when she's shopping online, and it's starting to pay off. Average unit retail, or AUR, was up 5% in the first quarter compared to last year.
It is encouraging to see the continued improvement in brick and mortar. We also continue to see sales pick up in nearby stores and markets where we've closed stores last year. Our digital business continues with double-digit growth. We also saw strong performance across all regions of the country and all families of business. In center core, fine jewelry was a standout performer, including our proprietary Star Signature Diamond Collection. We also saw improvement in accessories, handbags, and sleepwear, largely driven by our private brands. In beauty, we saw a meaningful lift in AUR for the quarter, driven by fragrances for both men and women, as well as skin care. We also saw standout performance in men's tailored clothing, in kids, dresses, active, and home.
All in, the first quarter was a good one for us, and I'm pleased to see our fourth quarter momentum continuing into the new year. When we look ahead at the rest of 2018, our growth plan is built on ongoing improvements in execution, continued strength in merchandising, and key strategic initiatives. I want to take a few minutes to take you through the five strategic initiatives. First is our Star Rewards loyalty program. You'll remember in October that we launched the first stage of the Star Rewards program, and our customers are responding enthusiastically. At the platinum level, our most valuable customer is spending more with us. While it is still early, we're starting to see improvement at the gold and silver levels as well.
Last week, we rolled out the second phase of our loyalty program, which includes a tender neutral option, allowing customers to participate in the loyalty program without having a Macy's credit card. This is what we call our bronze tier. There are no spending qualifications, and this program is open to all customers, no matter how they pay. We're also adding more unique experience-based benefits for our platinum customers. For instance, we're offering, or we did offer, private early store hours for our iconic flower show near N.Y. and Chicago and San Francisco locations. These new benefits will increase brand engagement and customer retention. The second initiative is our Backstage expansion. Last quarter, we said we would open approximately 100 additional Backstage locations within Macy's stores in fiscal 2018. In the first quarter, we opened up 18 Backstage locations.
We expect to open approximately 40 more locations during the second quarter. We're expanding Backstage to some of our premium malls and to the West Coast for the first time. We also announced that we're opening a new distribution center in Columbus, Ohio, dedicated to Backstage. This will allow us to move merchandise to our Backstage locations faster and with more flexibility. The third initiative is the expansion of products available for sale on our website, shipped directly from our vendors or what we call vendor direct. We're significantly increasing our online assortment in select departments. In stores, our customers will continue to find curated, localized assortments. On macys.com, they will have access to an endless aisle curated through personalization. In the first quarter, we started the vendor direct expansion and expect to have it fully underway by the fall season.
The fourth initiative we are focused on this year is store pickup. We're offering more options for pickup and delivery, including the expansion of buy online pickup in store, and the implementation of buy online, ship to store or what we call BOSS. In the first quarter, we're focused on the rollout of at your service counters, which makes picking up orders in our stores, be it BOPIS or BOSS, quick and easy. By August, these will be in almost every single store. Our fifth initiative is what we call the Growth 50. These are 50 stores where we are implementing the best of what we tested in 2017. This work will complete in time for the fall season, We intend to come out of the year with a model that we can scale.
We're making a point of visiting each of the Growth 50 stores, I'm very excited by what I'm seeing. From merchandising strengths and strategies, more staffing in key areas, facility upgrades, as well as local marketing plans. What's really striking is the renewed energy of our colleagues that they are putting into serving our customers. Those are our 2018 strategic initiatives. We do anticipate that much of the impact of these initiatives will fall into the second half of the year, but we're already beginning to see some benefits, including from the earlier Backstage openings. While the strategic initiatives are key components of our 2018 growth plan, we're also looking more broadly at what we need to do to improve the customer experience. A few weeks ago, we announced that we had acquired STORY, a concept store in N.Y. City.
For those of you that are not familiar with STORY, the space reinvents itself every six to eight weeks, highlighting new themes that bring new customers in and keep existing customers coming back to see what's next. We're not in the commodity business. We're in the experience business. Rachel Shechtman, who is STORY's founder and CEO, is now Macy's first brand experience officer. Rachel has a clear vision of how merchandising and marketing strategies come to life in a store, and we're very excited to have her and the STORY team join us at Macy's. In the first quarter, we also introduced new technology both on our mobile app and in our stores that will help us eliminate friction from store visits and improve the shopping experience. One of these initiatives is mobile checkout. We know that the checkout process can be a pain point for our customer.
With mobile checkout, we are speeding things up. Customers can scan a product with their Macy's app, pay with a stored credit card, then go to a dedicated counter to remove security tags. We call it Scan, Pay, Go. We've been testing and fine-tuning mobile checkout, and we plan to roll it out to every Macy's store by the end of the year. We're also using virtual and augmented reality to help grow our furniture business. We like this business because it's high margin, but it's also a very high touch business. Like many of our competitors who've been looking at VR and AR in furniture, we have found a practical application. We've piloted VR in three of our furniture stores and found that it significantly increased transaction size and also reduced returns.
Using VR allows us to offer a full range of furniture in roughly half the space. We're now scaling this to 60 more doors this year. We've also launched an augmented reality feature on our mobile app that allows customers to see furniture in their actual living spaces. We've rolled it out to a portion of our app users as we test and learn, to date, it's been very well received. As you can see, a lot is happening with the Macy's brand. Let me take a minute to touch on Bloomingdale's and Bluemercury. Both had a great first quarter. Bloomingdale's opened its newly remodeled shoe floor at the flagship 59th Street location in New York City. All women's shoes have now been relocated to a single floor that's more than 25,000 sq ft. This is a 40% increase over prior shoe floors.
There are more than 100 brands, 17 that are new to Bloomingdale's, 34 that are exclusive. It's aligned with what Bloomingdale's customers want and love, initial feedback has been very positive. Bluemercury also had a great quarter. It's part of our business, but it's growing at a rapid pace. They launched a number of new products under their private labels, Lune+Aster and M-61, which have performed well. We continue to see potential for Bluemercury stores, both freestanding and within Macy's stores. We anticipate opening approximately 25 additional freestanding Bluemercury's this year. Before I hand it back over to Karen, I do want to note that a significant factor in our improved performance is that we have the organization aligned, focused, and rowing in the same direction. On our last call, I described the Path to Growth incentive that we've implemented this year.
This puts every Macy's colleague, full-time, part-time, hourly, and seasonally, on an incentive program tied to our growth plan. I'm pleased to say that about three-quarters of our eligible colleagues made bonus in the first quarter. I'm both proud and encouraged by the energy and engagement that I see that are out in the stores, in our call centers, and in our warehouses. Overall, we feel good about the quarter and the path we are on for 2018. This is the most competitive retail environment I've ever seen, and we know that we need to get up every morning committed to winning our customers' business. We're making the right investment in the business, focusing on areas where we see the best returns, and are confident this will support our commitment to growth in 2018.
Now I'm going to hand it back over to Karen, who will take you through the numbers.
Thanks, Jeff. As Jeff said, sales, earnings, and cash flow all surpassed our expectations in the first quarter. Sales in the first quarter were $5,541 million, up 3.6% versus last year, or up 4.2% on a comp owned plus licensed basis. As Jeff mentioned, we benefited from the timing of the shift of our Friends and Family event. We estimate that this shift is worth 250 basis points. Excluding the shift, comp sales on an owned plus licensed basis are estimated to have been up 1.7%. We are getting lots of questions this morning about whether this adjustment includes the calendar shift as well. It does not. This is consistent with what we experienced in 2013. It's frankly hard to measure that because when we follow a 53-week year, we shift promotional events around.
We do not think the impact is meaningful, although there is a slight benefit in the first half and a slight negative in the second half of the year. As Jeff said, we saw improvement in both our digital and stores business, with particularly strong performance at Bloomingdale's. In addition to our improved execution and our North Star strategy, we believe we benefited from both stronger customer spending and an increase in international tourist business. International tourist sales were up close to 10% in the quarter, which is only the second time since 2014 when we experienced an increase. Total transactions were up 1% in the quarter, with average unit retail up 5% and units per transaction down 2%. This increase in average unit retail reflects the higher regular price selling and distorted growth in our strategic businesses like fine jewelry, dresses, handbags, and furniture.
Additionally, as a result of having significantly less and also much fresher inventory this year, it was less selling in the quarter of deeply discounted clearance merchandise. Credit card revenue net was $157 million in the quarter versus $161 million last year. This too was better than expected, primarily due to higher balances. This is resulting largely from higher credit sales and new accounts also, in part due to our new loyalty program, which, as Jeff said, was launched last fall. Penetration on our private label card was approximately 45.5% in the quarter, which is just slightly above last year. This compares, though, to the 90 basis point decline in penetration that we experienced both in the fourth quarter and the full year of 2017. Gross margin as a percent of net sales for the quarter was 39%, up 70 basis points over last year.
We benefited from the much-improved inventory position during the quarter, and we ended the quarter with 5% less inventory on a comp basis. SG&A dollars in the quarter were $2.083 billion or 37.6% of sales. This compares to $2.057 billion or 38.5% last year. This increase in dollars is driven primarily by the investments we're making to support the North Star strategy, such as digital, the Growth 50 stores, Backstage, and the new Path to Growth incentive plan. The savings from the change in the tax law is helping to offset these sales-driving investments. Asset sale gains were $24 million in the quarter, $44 million lower than last year. Remember that this year's asset sale gains are expected to be back-end loaded into the fourth quarter, when we are assuming that we will sell the I.
Magnin building on Union Square in San Francisco, as we discussed last quarter. We booked $19 million in impairment and other costs in the quarter, primarily associated with the decision to end our China joint venture. We will continue to have an ongoing presence on Alibaba's Tmall platform, as well as social media channels in China, but it will now be managed by our digital operation in San Francisco. We expect to book an estimated additional $10 million over the next few quarters related to this change in approach. Benefit plan income net was $11 million versus $13 million last year. Consolidated EBIT in the quarter was $249 million, or $268 million before the impairment and other costs. This compares to $232 million last year. Excluding asset sale gains, EBIT on this basis was $80 million or 49% over last year.
Interest expense was $66 million, down from last year's $84 million due to our debt reduction. Tax expense in the quarter was $52 million or 28.4% of pre-tax income. This represents a $16 million reduction from last year and approximately 19 basis points lower as a rate. Net income attributable to Macy's, Inc. shareholders in the quarter was $139 million versus $78 million last year. Excluding asset sale gains in both years, the impairment and other costs this year, and the premium on early retirement of debt last year, net income was $93 million higher than last year. EPS on a diluted basis, excluding the impairment and other costs in the quarter this year and the premium on early retirement of debt last year, was $0.48 versus $0.26 last year. When we exclude asset sale gains as well, EPS was $0.42 this year versus $0.12 last year.
Cash flow was strong as well in the quarter with an $85 million increase in cash provided by operating activity. We spent $13 million more in CapEx and received $73 million less in proceeds for property and equipment sales this year. It really was a great quarter on every metric. We exceeded our expectations and as a result are increasing what we expect for the full year. We are now assuming a comp owned plus licensed increase of 1%-2% for fiscal 2018 as compared to the assumed 0%-1% previously. Comp sales on an owned basis are assumed to increase by approximately 20-30 basis points less than the comp on an owned plus licensed basis. Total sales are now expected to be -1% to +0.5% versus -2% to -0.5% previously.
Remember that total sales are impacted by the fact that fiscal 2018 has one week less than 2017. The comp guidance, however, is stated on a comparable 52-week basis. We still expect comp sales on an owned as well as owned plus licensed basis in the second quarter to be negative due to the Friends & Family shift. However, comp sales on an owned plus licensed basis are now expected to increase 1%-2% for the first half of the year, the first and second quarters combined. Total sales for the first plus second quarter, or the first half of the year, are now expected to be flat to +1%. As we have discussed, we are benefiting from stronger than expected external factors as well as the earlier execution of some of our strategic initiatives.
We still expect the comp sales in the back half of the year, or what we call the fall season, to exceed that of the spring season due to the ongoing rollout of our strategic initiatives. Remember though, that last year we had a much stronger fall season than spring, so that will impact the degree of improvement as we year round on the stronger performance, particularly in the fourth quarter. We are also increasing earnings guidance by $0.20 a share to $3.75-$3.95, excluding anticipated pension settlement, impairment, and other costs. This increase is a result primarily of the strong first quarter performance, the better second quarter expectations, as well as an increase in our assumption for annual credit card revenues to $675 million-$690 million. All of our other assumptions are unchanged. Like I said earlier, it was just a terrific first quarter all around.
It's encouraging to see the business getting stronger, and I feel good about both our own plans as well as the external environment in which we're working. Spirits are up, and this is an organization that is committed to winning and getting better every day. With that, Jeff and I will take your questions.
Thank you. If you would like to ask a question, please signal by pressing *1 on your telephone keypad. If you are using a speakerphone, please make sure your mute function is turned off to allow your signal to reach our equipment. Again, press *1 to ask a question. We'll pause for just a moment to allow everyone an opportunity to signal for questions. We will now take our first question from Lorraine Hutchinson of Bank of America. Please go ahead.
Thank you. Good morning. Karen, I just wanted to confirm, you talked about the second half comp guidance now being better than the one to two in the first half. Is that correct?
Yeah. What we had said in February, we would say again now is that we do expect the fall season to exceed the spring. Want to remind people that the second half is a much harder comparison, you really have to look to some degree on two-year numbers. We do expect the fall to be better, but maybe not by the magnitude that you might have thought for two reasons. One is the fact that the fall, and particularly the fourth quarter, is a harder comparison. Secondly, the spring has gotten better as well with the earlier execution of some of our initiatives. We still expect Q2 to be higher than I'm sorry, the back half of the year to be better than the first half of the year. We're just cautioning on the degree of the difference between those two.
Again, all of that is reflected in our guidance. The big increase has been in the spring season as opposed to the fall.
Thank you. When you look back on the first quarter, were there any challenges posed by the very cold weather, or is there anything that you can talk about in terms of cadence or how the quarter unfolded versus your expectations?
Lorraine, it's Jeff. We didn't see really any material difference in our business based on weather. You had some markets that were affected, and you had some markets that were positive. In aggregate, it did not have a significant impact on business at all.
The quarter was good every month. In fact, every week. The consistency of the good performance was really important as we're looking at the first quarter.
Great. Thank you.
We'll now take our next question from Bob Drbul of Guggenheim Securities. Please go ahead.
Hi. Good morning. I guess the question that I have is, on the friends and family, the year-over-year, was the 30% off the same as it was last year? Can you just talk a little bit.
Yes.
It was. From the perspective of the trend throughout the quarter, you said weather didn't have an impact, but around the comparisons as you look into the second quarter, can you just talk a little bit about how much you feel like you pulled forward? I think you said it was going to be a negative comp.
Well, no. The only thing that we pulled forward was the friends and family event. In the first quarter, it's worth 250 basis points. In the second quarter, it's worth about 240 basis points because it's a bigger quarter, but roughly the same. Whatever the second quarter turns out to be, add 240 basis points to that, and that would be the comparable to the one seven.
Got it. Okay. Okay, great. Just within the Backstage initiative, can you just provide an update on category learnings as you continue to roll this out, versus what's in the traditional store?
Bob, it's as we discussed on prior calls. The strength of Backstage continues to improve. The standout categories remain shoes and home store. We're getting traction really across all categories, which would be beauty and the apparel areas in kids, womens, and men's. What we're doing is we're tailoring the assortment depending on what building that we're in. We're strongly advantaged by having Michelle Israel, who basically leads Backstage, but she also leads Bloomingdale's Outlet. She's been at this for some time with the successful strategy that we're implementing in Bloomingdale's Outlet, and she has the full scope of a vendor menu that really spans all different price points that we can now tail on whatever store it's in.
As you heard us say earlier, our objective with Backstage is to start to test that in premium malls, in 2018, as well as entering the West Coast for the first time. We're still in the early innings of Backstage, and we're layering on another 100-plus stores in 2018, 18 of which we opened in the first quarter.
Great. Thank you very much.
We'll now take our next question from Matthew Boss of J.P. Morgan. Please go ahead.
Great. Congrats on a nice quarter. Karen, if this happens to be your last call, congrats on moving to the next chapter.
Thank you.
Jeff, with two straight positive comps, I guess if you broke down the drivers of the top-line inflection that you're seeing, I guess how would you rank the impact of the stronger consumer backdrop and some of the macro factors such as tourism versus what you're seeing and doing from a company-specific execution standpoint? I know you have a laundry list of initiatives. I guess, what's the best way to think about what are you seeing and where are you seeing the earlier than expected benefits, and what are you the most excited about incrementally for the back half?
Okay. I think the backdrop of a very healthy consumer is the tailwinds that Karen is referring to, certainly helping us. I think that the international tourism, it's good to have that in the plus column. What we started to see in the fourth quarter and what we certainly showed up in the first quarter, that trend we believe is going to take us all the way through 2018 at least. As you get to the execution issue, let me just kind of step back a bit. I think when we made the announcement last August, we really announced two things. We announced the new massive simplification of three organizations that went down to one merchant organization, and we also announced the hire of Hal Lawton. These two things have really helped our execution. Starting with the structure. Massively simplified the merchant structure.
We have five great merchants that are leading each of the families of business, that are veterans, that I go into battle every day with them. They're led by one amazing chief merchant, which is Jeff Kantor, who really is just breathing new life into our merchant organization. I think if you asked our partners or our vendors, they would say of Macy's that we're operating now with more courage and more speed and more agility, that we're making calls, and the divisionals are making calls without oversight. There's less meetings and just more accountable people. I think the new structure is really helping us in execution. You add Hal to the mix. Hal is very disciplined, and he's just got very solid retail chops. I think we're getting onto a more disciplined operational cadence.
You couple that with his deep technology background, that is really primarily focused on improving the customer experience. He's just very comfortable and confident in making decisions and tough calls, and we're moving better and faster as a result of his leadership and his work with all of our veteran teams. As you think about the back half of your question, which is which of these initiatives do I believe are going to give us the most continued traction? You'd have to put on there Backstage. Vendor direct is a big opportunity for us, and we start picking momentum up on that. We've obviously done vendor direct in the past, but the idea about adding new content and new categories onto that, which we will do a lot through our relationship and partnership with CommerceHub, that comes on in the back half of the year.
The new loyalty program is obviously bringing us new customers that are more engaged with us. The last thing I'd say, Matt, would be, which is really the Growth 50, which is our brick-and-mortar initiative to get each of these 50 stores right. You're going to see, and I can talk about that later, but that is really one of the most exciting things that we're doing right now.
Great. Just a follow-up. Karen, on the gross margin front, can you just touch on the drivers of the outsized merchandise margin this quarter? I guess how best to think about 2Q, given we still have somewhat of an easier compare. As we think forward, what's the best way to think about the spread between inventory and sales on a multi-year basis?
Well, let me start with gross margin in the first quarter. The merchandise margin was actually up a little higher than the gross margin, because again, the gross margin gets negatively impacted by the growth in digital and the free shipping associated with the loyalty program. What we said about margin for the year is that we expect it to be flat to up slightly. Again, I'd hold with that, and we'll see from there. There's nothing that happened in the first quarter that should reverse in the second quarter. The first quarter is clean from that perspective. In terms of inventory, one of our key initiatives is to improve our inventory turnover over time and over multiple years. Hal and Jeff Kantor and the teams are working very hard on that.
In part to help working capital, but frankly, more so to improve sales and margin. I'm pretty excited about that, but I don't yet know the magnitude of that over time. You could see that to be an important initiative for us going forward.
Great. Best of luck.
Thank you.
We'll now take our next question from Paul Trussell of Deutsche Bank. Please go ahead.
Good morning, Jeff, and congratulations, Karen. Wanted to just think about, in hindsight, if you could provide insight on what your internal expectations were for first quarter comps, gross margin, and the EPS. Really just trying to better understand how we should think about the raise in full-year guidance, to what extent it was related to the beat in the first quarter performance, or your expectations or increased outlook for 2Q and beyond.
Yeah, I'm not going to tell you what our plan was for the first quarter. We did beat it on every line. Again, I would focus on the two key things we talked about, the increase in sales guidance with no change really in the margin and expense. It was really all driven by the extra point of sale and also the change in the credit revenue, much of which happened in the first quarter. That's not all incremental to the rest of the year.
Got it. Then while you've touched on this, in terms of kind of ranking the impact to the raise in the point of comp to the full year, how would you kind of break down or prioritize the impact of tourism or the loyalty program? You've mentioned Backstage and merchandising. How should we think about that order?
Honestly, I can't give you a breakdown. I would just assume that's all in the mix as we raise the guidance.
Fair enough. Then lastly then on gross margins. As you just spoke about, the merchandise margins were very strong in 1Q. Why should the full year still end up in the flat to just up slightly range? I was surprised that wasn't adjusted.
Well, remember, this includes the digital delivery, as the platinum customers and gold customers in our Star Rewards program keep increasing their shipments with macys.com, that does go through gross margin. We also had a good gross margin performance in the back half of the year. The first quarter, as you remember from last year, was really not very good. Some opportunity in Q2, but it was really Q1. The comparisons get harder as we get to the fall season.
Understood. Thank you, and best of luck.
Thank you.
We'll now take our next question from Chuck Grom of Gordon Haskett. Please go ahead.
Thanks. Good morning. Jeff, incentivizing your employees is always a good thing. Curious how much you think that decision to tie comp to sales across the chain may have helped sales in the quarter.
It made a difference, Chuck. It's hard to quantify that. I think as we saw in the incentive program that we did in the pilot, which we basically did in the back half of 2017, that's what really informed our decision to do it company-wide in 2018. What we found is once they get that first paycheck, these frontline colleagues, these are part-time dock associates, these are frontline associates. They're serving customers, call centers, warehouses. These are our corporate colleagues. That when they get that first paycheck for that quarter, that what it does to kind of reinforce great behaviors and how they can lift the North Star strategy the next quarter. We think this is nothing but good news. Again, it was almost three-quarters of our full colleague population. We have the 130,000 employees that benefited from this.
They get that in their paycheck, particularly our frontline colleagues. They get that in their paycheck in the next week or next two weeks. We know that's going to make a difference in their reinforcing behaviors that we've seen them exhibit with such courage in this first three-month window of the quarter. I do think it's made a difference, but hard to quantify how much of our momentum right now is attributed to it. It's all part of it.
Okay, great. Then just on tourism, when you look back when the business from tourism starts to turn, just how long do you think that might have been last year, is it possible to quantify what the lift was?
It's really hard to know how long it's going to last. We know that the negative lasted a long time, my hope is that the positive does as well, Chuck, but I don't know the answer to that.
Okay. One last one for you, Karen. Leverage ratio is around 2.8 times. I think it's a touch above your comfort zone, given back-to-back quarters of good sales here, how are you guys thinking about stock buybacks in terms of capital allocation?
I think the issue is we still need to get the leverage ratio to the target level, that continues to be the priority. Should the EBITDA significantly improve versus what we would have expected, such that that happens faster, that could change. At this point, we're still anticipating debt reduction being the use of excess cash.
Okay. Congrats again.
We'll now take our next question from Kimberly Greenberger of Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.
Great. Thank you so much. Karen, I wanted to just follow up on Lorraine's question on the monthly comp cadence here in Q1. I think you mentioned every week was good, and there was consistent performance throughout the quarter. Is this compared to your plan, or is this consistent performance relative to the 3.9% comp that you reported this quarter?
No, it's compared to our expectations. Obviously, depending on the timing of promotions, it can be up and down relative to the quarter two overall. Relative to our expectations, it was consistently a strong quarter, week in, week out, month in, month out.
Great.
Kimberly.
And then comp-
Kimberly, we had our Easter shift, obviously. The big shifts for us in the first quarter was the Easter shift. When you look at the combination between March and April, we got the planning of this one right. That's what Karen's referring to in terms of exceeding our expectations in the way we planned the weeks. We planned the Easter shift right, then the friends and family shift that we've described that's affected the first quarter performance, we planned that right as well.
Great. Okay. That's super helpful. Then I think you mentioned that the average unit retail price in the quarter was up 5%, Karen. I think you said that was because last year contained a lot of markdown selling. I think looking back at the comments you made last year, it was because of the carryover inventory from the fourth quarter. Given that it was such a significant driver here in the first quarter, I'm wondering how we should think about the AUR throughout the rest of the year.
Well, I said it was due to two factors. One is the one you mentioned. The second was much higher AUR on regular price selling, driven by the growth in our strategic categories, fine jewelry, dresses, that I had alluded to, talked about on the call. It's really both factors. One is ongoing and the other is more temporary. We don't forecast AUR increases, but it isn't all due to the clearance merchandise being less. What really encouraged us was the strong increase in AUR in the regular price selling.
I think the merchants are doing a very good job of really putting all of our goods, packing them with value, and really going after the fashionable spender, which is really our sweet spot. The sell-throughs on that product at higher AURs is really healthy right now. Just to amplify the second part of Karen's point. Fashion is selling. We're getting better sell-throughs, and we're getting more value for it.
Great. Thank you both so much.
You're welcome.
We'll take our next question from Paul Lejuez of Citi. Please go ahead.
Hey, thanks, guys. Karen, with the launch of the tender neutral card, do you build into your expectations any decline in credit penetration, or do you assume that that stays consistent?
We think it should stay consistent because you continue to get better benefits if you use our card. If you're a cardholder, you're going to always want to use your card versus take advantage of the tender, the Bronze level, or where you don't have to use our credit card. While I would say that is a risk we've considered, we think we have the risk contained, and that should not be an issue. We're hoping that it gets further engagement from the half of our customers who don't use the credit card, which will help sales.
I would just amplify that, Paul. We're staying very disciplined in making sure that the tiered benefits between Bronze, Silver, Gold, and Platinum are really clear, and the customer clearly sees the step-up. The fact that they're a Bronze player and they can pay in any payment type, we're going to make sure they're very clear about what they get if they were to change what level they go to, and those will be increased benefits. We're very hopeful that we're going to get new customers into our credit portfolio as a result of introducing the Bronze program.
Got you. Then, Karen, I think the comp metrics that you gave for the quarter include that friends and family benefit. Is there any way you can talk about outside of that friends and family period, what were the comp metrics on a traffic ticket, AUR basis?
No, I can't. We'll give it to you when we finish the second quarter, and we do the sprint. We don't have that restated.
Okay. How about if you look at friends and family versus the same promotion last year, how did it perform, right? We cross over quarters now, but I'm just curious if you kind of just separate that one event and look year-over-year, how did it perform?
It performed better for both Macy's and Bloomingdale's. It was to the earlier question, it was the same discount. The customers responded better to it this year based on the fashion content that we had, as well as some of the exclusive product that we had at both Bloomingdale's and Macy's. We were pleased with its performance.
Great. Thanks, and good luck, guys.
Thank you.
We'll now take our next question from Brian Tunick of RBC. Please go ahead.
Good morning. Thanks for taking our question. This is Belen on for Brian. I first wanted to ask about the Backstage lift you've been seeing as now you added more stores. I believe in the past you had mentioned a high single digit lift to the overall store comp when you added a Backstage to an existing store. Is that sort of the lift you're still seeing, and do you still have new customers coming in for that concept, where the Backstage store has been open now for over a year?
Your question is suggesting one of the things that we were most interested in seeing, which was how would Backstage that's within a Macy's perform in the second full year after anniversary and its introduction. What we've talked about is that the introduction means a seventh building versus buildings of that control set. What we're seeing now are those where we opened up Backstage in 2016 and in the beginning of 2017, that we are getting positive comps in those stores, in that Backstage location. That is really good news for us. As to the conversation about existing versus new customers. Existing customers are clearly, when they're experiencing both Backstage and the full price side in a store that has both, they're spending more and they're visiting more often. That is always good news for us.
We have not marketed really Backstage outside of the inaugural opening in a particular market. We don't market it nationwide. When we get to more critical mass, we will do that. With that, we expect that we will be attracting more broadly new customers into it. Right now, it's working quite well with getting more spend with existing customers. As mentioned, the growth rate of it is disproportional in those Backstage locations that have been open more than a year. That's all good news.
Great. Thank you. I believe you mentioned the strong recapture of sales from closed stores here in Q1. Does this recapture opportunity and very strong, obviously, e-commerce sales make you maybe reconsider the optimal store count for Macy's?
That's always in the math as we think about the store count. I don't think it makes us reconsider the store count, but it is great news that we have been able to retain the sales in nearby stores as well as online.
Great. Thank you very much.
We'll take our next question from Oliver Chen of Cowen and Company. Please go ahead.
Hi, thank you. Nice solid results. Congrats. Regarding the brand experience, as you're thinking about what you can do there and through the lens of curation, culture and convenience, what are your thoughts on what will be more shorter-term opportunities versus more longer-term opportunities as you reinvent the store on a customer-centric basis? I think related to that is the Growth 50, would love your hypotheses on which are the more profound differences in the Growth 50, which could be ported over to your larger store base. Thank you.
Hi, Oliver. Let me talk first. I think that if I had to sum up, I think on the curation comment that you're making, that's certainly what we're looking to do with our brick-and-mortar portfolio, is to make sure that we've got the best possible assortment localized at a store level. You're seeing us make much more aggressive edits and really amplifying the fashion of the trends and the brands that remain. We tested that all the way through 2017. You're seeing us do that in 2018. That continues. I think in terms of the convenience question, us being able to make sure that wherever a customer wants to shop, if she's browsing online, but she wants to feel the fabric in store, if she wants to get into a store but get out, how can she transact without having to deal with any friction?
That's why we have mobile checkout. Making sure that we've got all delivery models, including same-day delivery for that last mile imperative. We've got that very well-focused. In terms of making sure that the store experience is heightened. That, just to lead you into how we're thinking about that, is really the nexus of what we're doing with the Growth 50. Really the recent acquisition of STORY and really all we're doing with Market by Macy's. Let's just start with Growth 50. Growth 50 was something that where when we sat down and looked at how are we going to improve our trend in brick-and-mortar, it was all with the thesis that Macy's is going to do best when we've got robust digital growth, we've got healthy brick-and-mortar, and we've got a mobile platform that connects customers to all channels.
We had the mobile piece well on way. We had the digital growth, obviously, percolating, and we're driving that very successfully. Brick-and-mortar needed a lot of work. We took 50 doors that are representative of a lot of other doors, and we're focusing on the five Ps, which for us are product, presentation, process, promotion, and making sure that they are right. The fifth is really people. What we're doing on each of those 50 doors is really looking at hyper-curated assortments, making sure that the facilities are in great shape, that we're putting capital into those buildings, but modest capital so that it can be scaled with what we learn. Really making sure that the marketing is localized. We're bringing communities into the store. The big win is really what we're doing with our teams.
Great store managers, great operational and sales managers, great frontline colleagues, particularly in those businesses where the customer likes that touch. Fine jewelry, big ticket, women's shoes, those and beauty businesses. All of those, we're in process of completing all that work. We're going to be done with that by mid-third quarter, and we expect to have strong growth in those 50 doors. If we do, based on the expense and the capital we're putting into those buildings, that will form our thesis for how we take that into more brick and mortar in future years. That is a very important initiative for us. As it relates to STORY and as it relates to Market by Macy's. STORY is, obviously you know the store in Manhattan. Rachel Shechtman, the founder of STORY, is now the Brand Experience Officer at Macy's.
We believe that not only will we see opportunities for the expression of STORY within Macy's stores, but also her work in really helping connect marketing and merchandising within the store experience, which she's really cut her teeth on over the years that she has been leading this subject. Very excited about what her leadership is going to be. She reports directly to Hal. Her peers are running marketing, running stores, running merchandising. She's going to work very closely with all of that. Market by Macy's is really our opportunity to take unknown brands or categories that can be hyper-localized in a space that we run and operate. It brings new ideas into stores in a scalable way with this kind of movable feast of content. So far so good.
We have like 500 vendors and products that are in the queue to come into this. We've got it in 10 stores, it's working quite well for us. Expect to hear more about that in the future.
That sounds really innovative. Jeff, as you think about Growth 50 and different CapEx decisions you'll make as you test, read, and react, how do you juxtapose that against thinking about different level productivity stores, whether they be A, B, and C stores, and what you think your footprint should look like in the context of stores really transforming as acquisition points and rethinking the bricks and clicks in a modern way?
I think Growth 50 is representative of not all of our stores portfolio, but a big piece of it, and certainly in all the premium malls of the nation, and certainly the stores that make up the bulk of our business and the majority of our store profits. I think we've got our thesis on this is that we're going to test all this. We're going to take what works. One of the driving ambitions of this thing was to make sure that whatever we did was scalable. I've got confidence that we're going to come out of 2018 with what that looks like. There is going to be other stores in which we're looking at new ways to operate them. They've got positive cash flow, but it wouldn't necessarily make sense for us to invest in them like we are the Growth 50.
There's new ways that we can hit customer expectations, potentially operate them more profitably, and we're hard at work right now figuring out what we're going to do with that subject. More to come on that.
Lastly, as you know, we've been focused on big data and data driving personalization and loyalty, and data also driving convenience. You've made a lot of strides with prioritizing data in your organization. Could you just brief us on what we should focus on in terms of your priorities in this subject and how it may impact our models over time? Thanks a lot.
Yeah, I think again, it's the notion that hyper-curation at a brick-and-mortar level is data will inform that. It's really going to be the crossroads of art and science, and great merchants to understand what's ahead, also to look at past history and to look at the particular community of that store and make sure that we're assorting appropriately. Endless aisle, though, online. Where Vendor Direct is taking us is the opportunity to massively expand our SKU count online and then use data to hyper-personalize that at a customer level. We're in the beginning stages of that, both in expanding the right now we're at about a 6:1 ratio of online SKUs to an average store.
You're going to see us take that ratio much higher, and you're going to see us use data to then personalize that messaging to a customer in the future so that that also is curated like their store brick-and-mortar experience would be. Expect to hear more from that from us.
Very helpful. Thank you. Best regards.
We'll take our next question from Omar Saad of Evercore ISI. Please go ahead.
Thanks. Great quarter, guys. Congratulations.
Thanks.
I wanted to actually ask you about a little bit deeper on the inventories. They've been running really lean for the last couple of quarters, and it seems like a lot of the initiatives you put in and the growing kind of centralized e-commerce business are giving you a greater ability to kind of turn your inventories faster and do a little bit more with less. Can you expand upon that and how you're thinking about inventory management and how it's evolving in this new digital era, given the potential for single-view inventory, et cetera? Thanks.
I think, as I said earlier, it is a high priority for us, but not prepared yet to tell us how low we think it can go. We absolutely agree with your premise that both through technology as well as looking at our business in a way that focuses on curation more, we should be able to bring the inventories down. Again, I can't today tell you how much or on what timeframe.
Perfect. Thanks, Karen.
We'll take our next question from Michael Binetti of Credit Suisse. Please go ahead.
Hey, guys. Let me add my congrats on the performance in the quarter. Karen, I'll add our best wishes for you as well. I know you wouldn't normally comment on May trends, some other areas of retail this week have seen some really big growth rates as we get into the fiscal quarter. If we run the back-out math that, Karen, you helped us with, it looks like you're pointing to about flat to -2 in the 2Q, which with the help you gave us on the shift, implies that you guys feel like the core is just fine. Do I have the components there correct, have you seen any context you could put around May here as we get into the quarter?
We're not going to comment on May. Again, the guidance for the spring season, you have to do your own math, is the 1%-2% of comp and the flat to 1% total sales growth.
Okay. I guess Kimberly asked earlier, on the AUR, I know you don't forecast that either. That obviously had kind of a strange quarter last year in the 1Q in the baseline. As this year rolls on, you said a couple of these components are continuing and some roll off, you do start to accelerate Backstage, which I would imagine would be somewhat of a neutralizing impact on the strategic lift you're getting to the AUR that you think would continue. I guess the longer-term question is, if that is something that you think fades from the 5% through the year a little bit as we think about our models, maybe just a longer-term question, this is the first positive transaction count quarter you've had in a while. Is that something that you see as sustainable?
You added a lot of components here that you sound like you feel good about in the traffic in the stores. I'm just curious how you're feeling about that line.
Well, as I said earlier, we don't forecast AUR, so I'm not sure I can help you with your first question. The second question on transactions, I think we need to see the whole spring season before we can respond to that.
Okay. Fair enough. I guess just thinking out a little bit, getting away from the minutiae here in the near term. Are you ready yet to talk about more of how you're thinking about the margin outlook for the business over multiple years? I won't pin you down on a timeframe. I think as we look at the dollar amount the real estate has added, real estate gains have added the last few years. I'm assuming you'd say that that probably we're past the peak on the gains there and that that will be less of a contributor starting in 2019 and beyond. It becomes more important for us to think about the multi-year margin outlook.
Well, it's already.
as we think about this.
Yeah, asset sale gains are already forecasted this year to be significantly less than last year. That's already happening, which is why you hear us talking more about net income and EPS excluding the asset sale gains, just so you see the comparables. When you think about the fundamental profitability, the net income excluding asset sale gains should grow, particularly as we return the company to comp growth and growth. That's really the key message here. That's what we're focused on.
Got it. Okay. Thank you very much.
We'll now take our final question from Dana Telsey of Telsey Advisory Group. Please go ahead.
Good morning, everyone. Congratulations on the continued acceleration. Nice to see. On the private label side of the business, anything that you're seeing there or that we should be looking for as we go through the balance of the year? Jeff, as you think about the store, the mix of apparel versus other categories, in the future, where should it be? Karen, just on the platinum doors, was their performance more accelerated than the chain average? How do you look at it? Thank you.
I'll take your first two, Dana. Private brand is healthy, and you've heard us say that in the second of our five North Star strategy points, which is It Must Be Macy's, it's really all about taking our host of private brands as well as exclusive product with other brands up to 40% from its current 29%. We're well on our way on that. When you look at that and when we're doing it right with a number of our private brands, our margins are better, our supply chain is shorter, and we're getting more value on the products. The AUR is higher than the average. We're having some really great success with a number of our private brands, and it's our objective to get all of our private brands performing that way. We feel like we have the right number.
They're spread across the right FOBs. They're addressing the right lifestyles for our customer. We feel good about that. With respect to mix of apparel versus balance of store, we talked about the 8 businesses that we're really focused on, a number of those are apparel. We have some that are in the center core world. We have some that are in-home. What I tell you is that there's good success stories in each of those. When you look at the overall mix, apparel is not going to grow into penetration. Right now when you're thinking about vendor direct, our vendor direct first big initiative is to go after the home store, because there's a lot of non-cannibalizing categories that we'll bring into the mix with that. We're happy with our overall apparel business and very happy with our accessories business.
We're going to be looking at the individual components to grow them more profitably.
Relating to you said platinum doors, I'm assuming you meant Growth 50 doors. The first thing I would say is stores of all sizes and flavors did well in the first quarter. As Jeff said, close to 75% of our associates made the bonus, which means they exceeded their sales plan. Everybody did better across the company. Relative to last year, the Growth 50 doors are accelerating, beginning to, which, as we said, is a bit earlier than we had anticipated. We feel really good about the outlook for those stores.
The other thing I'd say on it, Dana, is that the range of store sizes that are touched by Growth 50 is $20 million all the way to much bigger than that. We are testing, through the Growth 50, all store sizes.
Thank you.
As there is no further question, I'd like to turn the conference back to your host for any additional or closing remarks.
Great. Well, thank you all for your interest and support. As always, if you have other questions, call Monica, call me, and we'll do what we can to get your questions answered.
Thanks, everybody.
Thanks.
This concludes today's call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.