Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to the MAA 4th Quarter 2019 Earnings Conference Call. As a reminder, this conference is being recorded today, January 30, 2020. I will now turn the conference over to Tim Argo, Senior Vice President, Finance for MAA. Please go ahead.
Thank you, Priscilla. Good morning. This is Tim Argo, Senior Vice President of Finance for MAA. With me are Eric Bolton, our CEO Al Campbell, our CFO Rob Del Priore, our General Counsel Tom Grimes, our COO and Brad Hill, Executive Vice President and Head of Transactions. Before we begin with our prepared comments this morning, I would like to point out that as part of the discussion, company management will be making forward looking statements.
Actual results may differ materially from our projections. We encourage you to refer to the forward looking statements section in yesterday's earnings release and our 34 Act filings with the SEC, which describe risk factors that may impact future results. These reports, along with a copy of today's prepared comments and an audio copy of this morning's call will be available on our website. During this call, we will also discuss certain non GAAP financial measures. A presentation of the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures as well as reconciliations of the differences between non GAAP and comparable GAAP measures can be found in our earnings release and supplemental financial data, which are available on the For Investors page of our website at www.mac.com.
I'll now turn the call over to Eric.
Thanks, Tim, and good morning. Our 4th quarter results were better than expected as improved rent growth and record low resident turnover continued to drive positive trends in overall revenue performance. Over the course of last year, we focused on an opportunity to prioritize rent growth and push that agenda throughout the year. As a result, we carry good pricing momentum into the New Year. Based on our updated analysis, we do now expect that the overall level of new supply deliveries in 2020 will run higher than in 2019.
This will of course vary by market. As has been routinely commented on, the majority of the new Supply continues to be higher end product at a high price point. Based on our detailed submarket analysis, it's important to note that the new supply forecasted to deliver in our markets in 2020 will be at rents that on average will be 25% Higher than the rent across our properties in the same submarkets. While we are certainly not immune to the impact of new supply, we see this pricing gap is generating good long term opportunity. The price point of our portfolio, the quality of our locations, the diversified nature of our submarkets, the strength of our operating platform and a number of new initiatives that we are rolling out in 2020, along with the pricing momentum that was built in calendar year 2019, we'll continue to support steady growth in NOI over the coming year.
One of the benefits surrounding the new and higher priced product delivering into the market is the expanding redevelopment opportunity created in a number of our properties. The price spread between the new supply and the existing rents at our properties creates opportunity to upgrade and still offer attractive value to our leasing prospects, while also generating a very accretive use of shareholder capital. Our property upgrade and repositioning pipeline will expand in 2020, supporting above market rent growth at a number of locations over the next couple of years. We continue to find select opportunities to capture disciplined new external growth. We began the year with our new development pipeline at 2,100 Units representing $490,000,000 in new investment.
In addition, we have 6.40 new units undergoing initial lease up, representing $146,000,000 in additional new investment. We did close on 1 new acquisition in Q4, consistent with the transactions we executed on over the past few years, this was a newly built property undergoing initial lease up. We partially match funded the acquisition with new equity issued through our ATM program, thereby retaining plenty of growth capacity and protection for the balance sheet. So in summary, our Sunbelt markets continue to capture great demand. MAA's portfolio is uniquely balanced and well positioned across the region to capture this demand.
Our redevelopment and new development pipelines are growing. Emerging new technologies and products will also support further NOI growth and the balance sheet is in a great position with ample capacity I want to thank our team of associates here at MAA for a great year of performance in 2019, and we look forward to another year progress in 2020. I'll turn the call over to Tom.
Thank you, Eric, and good morning, everyone. Our operating performance for the Q4 exceeded our expectations. With the steady demand for apartments and our enhanced platform, with continued momentum in rent growth and strong average daily occupancy. Same store effective rent growth per unit increased 4.3% for the quarter. This is the 7th straight quarter of year over year improving ERU growth.
As a result, our year over year same store revenue growth was 4.1%, the highest it's been since 2016. Effective rent per unit increased 60 basis points sequentially. Revenue performance was led by steady momentum and blended new and renewal lease over lease pricing, Average daily occupancy during the quarter remained strong at 95.7%. As we wrap up January, average daily occupancy is still strong at 95.5 and compares to 96 in January of last year. Our 60 day exposure, which is all vacant units and notices through a 60 day period, is just 7.2%, ten basis points better than this time last year.
Looking forward, as Eric mentioned, our overall supply in our markets is expected to increase in 2020, the Dallas, Houston and Savannah markets are expected to be the most challenging. Based on our pricing progress last year, Along with current rent and exposure trends, we expect our leading revenue markets to be Phoenix, Raleigh, Austin and Nashville. Of course, the new supply creates an opportunity for our redevelopment platform. In addition to our kitchen and bath program, we're underway with an amenity upgrade program at 10 Communities. This $20,000,000 to $25,000,000 investment in 2020 is primarily focused on legacy post assets where the product was built in excellent locations and new supply continues to push the rent of the submarket up.
In these cases, we can update leasing centers, hallways and common areas, create shared workspaces, outdoor gathering areas and rooftop decks to allow us to increase rent, while still offering compelling value in these submarkets. Our technology platform also continues to expand. Our overhauled operating system and new website has contributed to our ability to attract, engage and create value for our residents. Our tests on smart homes have gone well. The technology was installed in 15 communities with minimal disruption and has been well received by our residents.
We expect to install 24,000 smart home units in 2020. Our high speed Internet access initiative is deploying and will be a contributor to 2020 NOI growth. We are also exploring a range of AI, chat, customer resource management and prospect engagement tools. We're pleased with the progress our teams made in 2019 and greatly appreciate their efforts. We have a solid base of earned in rent growth as we head into 2020 and are excited about the opportunities ahead.
Brad?
Thank you, Tom, and good morning, everyone. I'll provide brief comments on what we are seeing in the transaction market as well as on our transaction activity in Q4. As you are all aware, the transaction market continues to be extremely competitive with record levels of liquidity and demand for multifamily properties. Given the favorable migration and job growth trends that exist in our region of the country, investor demand for multifamily properties within our footprint continues to be robust, leading to deep bidder pools, aggressive pricing and compressed cap rates. Reflecting the positive job growth and with strong demand, we expect supply to increase in 2020.
This increased level of supply should continue to support we have a historically high level of acquisition and prepurchase deal flow. We remain disciplined in our capital deployment decisions, and Al and his team have our balance sheet in great shape, allowing us to respond to compelling investment opportunities as they materialize. As we've done in the past, we'll continue to focus our acquisition efforts on new lease ups. Set involving a developer and equity provider we've worked with in the past. The asset was still in its initial lease up with the equity requiring a certain and quick we closed by year end.
We were able to execute on the acquisition at a stabilized market cap rate of 5.1%. In 2020, we'll also continue to pursue prepurchase opportunities. As a reminder, this is a program where we partner with good developers that have access to great real estate. We bring the capital to the venture and in return, we get access to an asset at a reduced basis with a clear path to 100 Percent Ownership at Stabilization. This program allows us to selectively pick well located to be built assets while minimizing our overall development risk.
In Q4, we closed and started construction on a 264 unit prepurchase located 9 miles Southwest of Downtown Orlando in the very desirable high income Doctor. Phillips area. And finally, in Q4, we took advantage of strong investor demand and pricing and sold all five of our assets and exited the Little Rock, Arkansas market. We had over 25 qualified bidders offer on these properties. We achieved good pricing for this non core market with 24 year old properties, equating to a 5.4% market cap rate.
We will continue to selectively prune our portfolio on an ongoing basis we'll have more to say about our specific 2020 disposition plans in coming quarters. With that, I'll turn the call over to Al.
Thank you, Brad, and good morning, everyone. I'll provide some brief commentary on the company's 4th quarter earnings performance, major financing activity and then finally on our initial guidance for 2020, reported FFO per share of $1.68 for the Q4 was $0.05 per share above the midpoint of our guidance With the majority of this outperformance produced by property NOI as both operating revenues and expenses were favorable to expectations for the quarter. FFO per share was $6.55 for the full year, which included several items considered unusual or not core to our business, such as the market to market valuation of our preferred shares and gains on sales of land parcels. Excluding these non core items, FFO for the full year would have been $6.26 per share. As discussed more in a moment, we are providing earnings guidance for 2020 on a core FFO basis, which we believe will help provide a clear picture of performance.
We were active on the financing front during the Q4 as we issued $300,000,000 of new public bonds. We also retired $170,000,000 of unsecured loans and $17,000,000 of additional secured debt. The effective interest rate of the new bonds will be 3.1% over 10 years after considering the interest rate hedges related to the financings. We ended the year with 98.4% of our debt fixed with an average duration of almost 8 years, which is a record for the company. During the Q4, we also issued $20,000,000 in new equity through our ATM program, essentially match funding a portion of the Greenville property acquisition mentioned by Brad.
Finally, we are providing initial earnings guidance for 2020 with the release, which is detailed in our supplemental information package, providing guidance for net income per diluted common share, which is we have consolidated FFO, core FFO and core AFFO in the supplement. Core FFO for the full year 2020 is projected to be $6.38 of $6.62 per share or $6.50 per share at the midpoint. The definition of core FFO including a description of the items considered non core can be found in our supplemental package. The primary driver of 2020 earnings performance is same store NOI growth, which is projected to be 3.5% at the midpoint. Effective rent growth for the year is expected to be around 3.7 percent produced by 2020 lease over lease blended rental pricing growth of 3.4% at the midpoint combined with the 2019 blended rental pricing of 4.4% achieved.
This pricing combined with a slight decrease in average occupancy to 95.8 percent average for the year brings projected total rental revenue to the 3.5% range. Fees and other income items combined are projected to add an additional 20 to 25 basis points to revenue growth for the year, with the primary driver being a 55 basis points contribution from the DoublePlay bulk Internet program, which is partially offset by other fees and reimbursement items, which are projected to remain essentially flat for 2020, primarily due to slightly lower occupancy. These items combined to produce our total same store revenue growth expectation of 3.75% for 2020 at the midpoint. Same store operating expenses will continue to have some pressure from real estate taxes and insurance costs for the year and we'll also have the additional expenses related to the Double Play bulk Internet program, which is recorded on a gross basis. These items combined to produce projected same store expense growth of 4.25% for the full year at the midpoint.
Our forecast also assumes a modest increase in overall overhead costs, just below 3% for the year and continued use of our ATM program to essentially match fund Expected acquisitions for the year with $80,000,000 of new equity issuance projected, of course, assuming we find accretive uses of capital during the year. That's all we have in the way of prepared comments, Priscilla. So now we'll turn the call back over to you for questions.
We'll take our first question today from Austin Wurschmidt with KeyBanc Capital Markets. Your line is open.
Hi, good morning, everybody. Brad, you mentioned supply is increasing in your markets in 2020, which I presume is off of your kind of detailed held supply analysis, could you quantify that thought and tell us which of your top markets are seeing the biggest increases or decreases?
Hey, Brian, Austin, it's Tom. I'm going to jump in. Where we really think that we'll see the most pressure from new supply is in Dallas primarily, it will continue to be challenged, but we're but it's that supply is coming in at 45% And then I think we would expect that Houston, Savannah and Charleston will soften Over time as supply comes online, but feel like we've got Phoenix and Raleigh, will probably lead the pack in terms of performance and we've We got strong momentum in the face of elevated supply with Austin, Atlanta and Nashville. And Austin, real quick, just to
clarify, when Tom says it's Supplies coming in 45% on top of us. That's a rent gap between what we have in place with new supply that's coming in is about 45 Higher in rent than what our assets
are. Yes, that makes sense. And then what's the supply sort of for the overall portfolio? What are kind of the numbers when you What it was in 2019 and what you're expecting for this year?
Yes. So if you look at our radius supply as a percent of inventory, This 2019 was about a percent of supply delivered and this year it will be 1.6% in 2020.
Got it. Thank you for that. And then kind of going back to the clarification, on the rents Four units being delivered versus what's in place. Eric, you kind of highlighted that across the overall portfolio, I think you said 25 And how does that 25% compare to the last 2 to 3 years of where new supply was coming in versus where your portfolio was at the time?
I don't have those numbers right in front of me Austin, but we reviewed them and it's very, very similar to what it is this year.
I think as construction costs continue to escalate, land costs continue to escalate, I I think if you go back over the last several years, you're going to find that that gap is going up. Certainly, the rise in cost of construction is accelerating at a pace faster than rent growth is accelerating. So I think if you go back over the last several years, you'll find that that gap is probably spread somewhat.
Got it. That's helpful. Thank you for the time.
And we'll take our next question
First question on the operating expense side. You talked about implementing technology through Several of the assets and units across your portfolio. I'm wondering if any of that is also pressuring Operating expenses or is all that being capitalized? And then, what are your expectations for payroll and insurance growth in 2020.
Let me make sure I'm understanding. Can you tell me what you were in the first portion, what expenditures were you talking about specifically, Neil, to make sure I'm clear?
Yes, yes. So the elevated operating expense this year is mostly related to the bulk Internet program, but I thought you're also implementing the smart home Okay.
I know I got it. Yes, we are and the majority of that is capital. So let's just give you a little breakdown of the expenses. I think The midpoint as we talked about was 4.25 growth for the year and about 65 basis points that is related to the bulk Internet program. And then you have real estate taxes, which are a third of our expenses as probably another 60 basis points.
So if you strip all
of that out, the other items, personnel, R and M, utilities and all those things are growing together about 3% for
the year. And I'll Neal, I'll add to that. You mentioned Specifically, insurance, we're expecting probably low double digit increase for our insurance program, which will renew in July.
Okay, great.
Recently, there's been some pretty strong homebuilder confidence. I'm wondering if You're seeing that play out in any way or anecdotally, in terms of the people who are moving out, if they're moving out to home purchase And or if the builders are starting to focus more on the entry level homes or still the sort of higher price point homes?
Yes, we're not seeing the folks move out for entry level homes. In fact, move outs to home buying was down 10% This quarter and that's part of what continues to drive our turnover down.
Okay. I guess last one for me. Can you just talk about what cap rates have done? Just talk about maybe in your top five markets over the last maybe 6 months for A and versus B product?
Yes. Hey, Neil, this is Brad. I'd say just broadly speaking, cap rates just continued to decline. I mean, Certainly, the demand for multifamily, if you heard anything about the NMHC conference last week, attendance was up Record levels, so I think the demand for multifamily assets continues to be very, very strong. And every indication we have from selling properties to be very, very active in the acquisition market and the numbers we're seeing, cap rates continue to come down and I'd say the gap between As and Bs continues to compress
and we
don't we certainly don't see anything changing the liquidity in the market that's really driving that at this point.
Thank you guys very much.
Thank you. We'll go next to Nick Joseph with Citi. Your line is open.
Thanks. I hope you can give a little more color on the bulk Internet program. In terms of the contracts with the providers, how long are those And then from a rental perspective, do all units need to opt into the program or is there an opportunity to opt in or opt out?
No. On the first one, there are 5 to 7 year contracts, depends on the provider and we've got the option to opt out For 3 years, I believe, but don't hold me to that Nick. On the as the rollout goes, all residents participate in it. And when we did this, we've had the bulk cable program for a while, we had decided to add high speed Internet access. When we did that, we looked at our market and who's already Driving for high speed Internet access and 80% of our residents are already paying for the speed that we're providing Or less.
So it's an upgrade and they're paying less through us for that. Part of the reason that Our results were a little better than we expected in the Q4. Nick, we really assume that would roll in on new leases on renewals The number of existing residents that chose to opt in Middle East was higher than we expected.
Thanks. That's helpful. And then maybe to that point, where are you in terms of the rollout? And then how long will it take to be fully deployed?
We have one provider done and the next provider underway and I would think we'd be deployed by May, Fully deployed by Maine with some carryover the benefit of course into 2020 because they'll ramp up from there.
Great. Thank you.
Sure.
We'll go next to John Kim with BMO Capital Markets. Your line is open.
Thank you. Tom, in your prepared remarks, you mentioned current occupancies at 95.5%, which is 50 basis points lower than last year. Can you just comment on how concerned you are that occupancy may come in at the low end of your guidance or potentially lower than that given new supply?
No. As you will have noticed for the last year, we've really felt like and continue to feel that with demand the way that it is, now is The time to raise rents and build our effective occupancy and that is the basis for which our steady rent growth from quarter to quarter and the growth that we've seen throughout the year is built, and we're willing to give up a little bit of occupancy on that though 95.5 Very solid from our perspective, but we feel pretty good about that this time of year. I would expect it to be a little lower and I would expect that you'll see that climb as the year goes on. We're certainly not going to be shooting for 96.2, 96.4. We're very happy in the range that we're in and it's starting right where we thought it would.
And can you provide commentary on how you see job growth or other demand drivers in your markets this year versus last year?
Yes, I mean job growth we see no slowdown at this point and the we continue to see interest in the Sunbelt and in migration trends renewal rates continue to stay in the 6 The 7% range right now, but we anticipate those coming down a bit this year. But right now demand is very strong and for that reason we'll continue to prioritize rent growth.
Okay. And then your development pipeline increased to $490,000,000 this quarter. Can you just comment on how big you feel comfortable with the pipeline is going forward? And are you developing at any different spec as far as Adding smart home technology or any new technology as part of the development program?
This is Eric, John, we're very comfortable where the development pipeline is at this point. I mean, we've established the tolerance that we're very comfortable with the 3% to 4% of enterprise value, which would put the pipeline tolerance, if you will, at $500,000,000 to $700,000,000 So at $490,000,000 we're pretty comfortable with where it is at this point. We have several other projects that we're working on now, if you will, in a predevelopment sense. I doubt we will start anything else this year. We do have a couple of land sites that we either own or tied up, but I suspect it will be early 2021 before we get those projects going.
So we're very comfortable with where the pipeline is at this point. And yes, as this new product is being developed, the smart home technology and a lot of the new Technology Services and Products that Tom has alluded to, they will certainly be a part of what we build going forward.
Great. Thank you.
And we'll take our next question from Haendel St. Juste with Mizuho Bank. Your line is open.
Hi, Zack Silverberg here with Haendel. Just a Quick follow-up on John's question. How do you guys view new development yields against IRRs and how do they against
We're generally seeing right now that our stabilized yields out of our development are Somewhere in the 100 basis points to 125 basis points higher than what we are capturing on the acquisitions, as Brad alluded to the Green the deal we bought in Greenville, stabilized yield of just over 5%. We're seeing our projected stabilized yields on our development pipeline right now trending anywhere from 6% to 6.5%. So call it 100 basis points, 125 basis points spread.
All right. Thanks. And could you provide an update on the quarter year to date lease rates between those legacy Post portfolio and the MAA portfolio and is there any extra opportunity that we should view this year between the 2 of them?
Yes. We do we are I do not have that information in front of me. We've largely You narrowed that gap or that gap is narrowed to be honest with you and differences between Post and Mid America assets In the same submarket are negligible. Now going forward, as I touched on with our redevelopment program and amenity upgrade, we do still have Opportunities in those very strong locations to update the exterior and amenity packages there and that is more of a 2020 one impact that we'll see from the work that we do this year. This year,
John is referring to the post, the legacy post locations for the upgrade. So we'll probably see more robust rent growth emerged out of the post, but it's more a function of the upgrade as opposed to market differences.
We'll go next to Rob Stevenson with Janney. Your line is open.
Good morning, guys. Tom, so Same store revenue guidance is 3.25% to 4.25%. What do you expect where are you expecting your top markets to come out? Where are you expecting the bottom Performers to come out, what's the sort of spread that underpins that 3.75 midpoint?
I mean, Rob, that range to be on a blended basis, the top markets in that Probably in that 4%, 4.5% range and the bottom markets in the 2%, 2.5%, something like that. I'm Estimating that to be honest with you, but that's rough feedback.
Okay. So nobody is sort of close to flat or even negative or anything. It's all sort of At least 1%, 1.5% positive at the bottom end?
Correct. I think on a blended basis, we would expect to get a full year traction And not have many people go backwards.
And Rob, I'll tell you, this is Eric. I mean, to some degree, the Opportunity that we carry from 2019 into 2020 because of the focus on prioritization on rent growth, it really puts us in a much better position to work through some of the supply pressures in these markets in 2020 and really enables us to avoid Any of the real weak performance metrics that you might that you were alluding to as a possibility, I think that we knew heading into this year that we likely would see some moderation of some sort occur And that was part of the reason behind the logic of focusing so intently on the rent growth last year, which really helps us this year.
Where are you guys on that topic? I mean, how are you guys thinking about turnover for 2020? I mean, it was only 47% last I mean, are you anticipating it being sort of flattish? Are you expecting more contraction, some re expansion there? And how big of a benefit is that to you if it
Yes. As far as our expectation, we expect it to be up slightly. We don't see any fundamental changes Coming across the board, but it is honestly hard to assume that it will continue to drop. And that plays into Our earnings forecast really minimally at this point. Al may add some color.
If you look at what we've got dialed in for occupancy, we've given ourselves about 15 basis points decline. There's a little bit of increase in turnover implied in that, but nothing significant, I would say.
Okay. And then did I hear you guys Correctly that you're going to do 24,000 smart home unit installs in 2020?
That is correct, Rob.
Okay. And what is the cost For that, how much are you doing per unit?
The average cost on that is $1300 on the install and that gives you Lox Thermostat, 2 lights, 2 moisture sensors and an interactive flat panel display that's The resident interface as well as their app. That's one of the
things that's important, I think, in doing your model, Rob, there, Smart home program plus the amenity redevelopments that Tom has talked about, we're investing about $60,000,000 in capital this year in that, Which is very strong returns, but a lot of that will begin to come more strongly in 2021.
Okay. So I mean in terms of units though that you Redevelop in 2020, instead of being 6,000, is that going to be wrapped up or is that going to be separate? So in other words, Are you going from essentially $6,000 to $7,500 a unit on the redevelopment? Or I assume there might be some sort of cost savings if you've got to Open up walls and do whatever anyway, but I mean is that going to be wrapped up into a higher redevelopment per unit cost for the Whatever number of units you do redevelopment, interior full scale redevelopment on?
Sure. And Rob, those programs are separate. And the reason that they are separate is because the timing is different in them. And if you'll remember on the kitchen and bath redevelopment, we do that on turn. When we install smart homes, we go in and we do the whole property at one time and then move people on to the product.
So those programs Are independent of one another.
And that's really why I mentioned them, Rob, if this is Al, if you think about it, the program that we've done for many years into your redevelopment program will continue along at basically the same pace, Call it, 7,000 to 8,000 units at 5000 to 6000 per unit spending on that. And it's been the same level and that will have a constant contribution to earnings growth. On top of that are the 2 programs that Tom is mentioning, the amenity redevelopment and of course the smart home and those together are about an additional $60,000,000 that are great investments that will begin to pay off more in That was really a point as you model it to help you lay that in right.
Okay. And then just last one for me, Al. Property taxes especially elevated in any specific markets?
It continues to be the same offenders. I mean, what we have this year when you're beginning in the year, you don't know
a lot. We'll go back
to that, Rob. And what we do know is about a third of our portfolio is a revaluation year. We continue to expect pressure in Florida, Texas, maybe North Carolina a little bit this year. So we dialed that in. And so overall, we do expect our costs to come down a little bit, the 4% to 5% range is 4.5% to midpoint is about 50 basis points down.
And also, we're cautiously optimistic about some of the changes in Texas, the new law changes. Hard to know where that's going to play out over the next few years. You don't yet know how that's going to affect both millage rates or valuations. So we've dialed in what we think we're going to have and over time we're Well, that line begins to come down a bit, but 4.5% for 2020 is our expectation.
Okay. Thanks.
Thank you. We'll take our next question from Hardik Goel with Zelman and Associates. Your line is open.
Hey, guys. How are you? Thanks for taking my question here. I actually wanted to touch upon supply again. The way we look at it, It doesn't seem to be as impactful as maybe you've mentioned.
Beyond Dallas and Houston, the 2 markets that you kind of highlighted, Can you give us a sense for supply in your maybe secondary, tertiary markets and how that's shaping up?
Yes, sure. Probably the market with the In the secondary group with the largest impact is probably Charleston moving from 2%, 3% as a percent of inventory to 4.8%. Now we're a little encouraged by that, because the where the supply has been, where it lines up to our A assets is in Mount Pleasant and the Mount Pleasant moratoriums have finally taken into effect. And so while Charleston is seen higher that supply has moved to the Upper Peninsula area, Which as you know is across the Ravenal Bridge from Mount Pleasant. So we were a little bit optimistic there.
But again, we see Charlotte at 2.5% to 3.7%. Others in the secondary market
Greenville goes from 2.1 percent of Apply to 2.3, so not a lot of change there. Probably the other market that has The biggest increase delta between 2019 to 2020 is in Savannah, Georgia. In 2019, they delivered 3% of the existing supply market supply into the market in 2020 that jumps to 7%. Now you recognize Savanna is only 2% of our same store NOI, so it's not a huge impact. But it's kind of hit or miss.
Some are up a little bit, some are up more than others, but because of the diversified nature of our capital across these particularly secondary markets, we it's not Particularly significant, but it varies a bit by market.
And just one quick follow-up, could you share the new and renewal for the quarter?
Yes, sure. The new for the quarter was 90 basis points down, renewal 7% up, blended to 6%,
Thank you. We'll take our next question today from Rich Anderson with SMBC. Your line is open.
Hey, thanks. Good morning.
Hey, Rich.
So, last year, your same store growth sort of cadence kind of climbed over the course of the year from 2 point 5 NOI line to 5% to end the year in the Q4. I'm wondering if that means sort of a mirror image in 2020 where You start the year somewhat stronger than you ended on the basis of increasingly tougher comps.
Well, I mean, certainly, I think the prior year comparisons will be a little bit more challenging for us this year. A lot of the momentum that we had last year was a function of our clear focus that we had going into last year About focusing on rent growth at the expense of a low occupancy give up and that momentum built over the course of the year. So, I think that which is really helping us this year as we carry a lot of that momentum that baked in, if you will, into 2020. We do think that as a result of some of the supply issues in a number of markets that are lease over lease pricing, if you will, the more Current pricing that's occurring in 2020 will be off a little bit from the trends that we saw in 2019, But a combination of the carry forward that we have from last year and the plans that we have this year Still offer up a blended lease over lease pricing performance for 2020 at 3.4%. We think that that's off a little bit from last year, but 3.4% blended pricing performance in 2020 In the face of some of the supply pressures that we see in these markets, we feel pretty good about that actually and still with strong occupancy That we think we'll capture as well.
So, I think these markets continue to show resiliency because of the strong demand and our portfolio in particular because of the diversified nature of the markets that we're in.
I'll just add to give the how it's laid into our projections to support What Eric was saying is all quarters in this year is going to be a little more stable just because of where we are. And all quarters are sort of in that 3.5% to 4% revenue range for the year and so second, third quarter maybe a little bit higher, but it's they're all in that range, much more stable.
I'll add One point, even though the blended pricing is a little bit lower in 2020, as the smart home and the bulk Internet start to take hold, it helps the back half of the year a little more than certainly the first half.
Okay, great. Thanks. In terms of the external growth sort of projections for this year, obviously more on the acquisitions. How much of that is sort of this pre purchase opportunity and how much of that is cost of capital that's making deals work A bit more easily in 2020 versus previous years.
Well, I mean, we think that it's more likely than not The vast majority of the acquisitions that we do will be some prepurchases of things to be built. We may particularly as you get towards the back half of the year, we see the opportunity set improve a little bit for buying lease up deals as we get closer to year end and developers or owners Get a little bit more motivated, get some things done. But certainly, our cost of capital has improved and it does at the margin generate a little bit more flexibility in this regard. But at the end of the day, I mean, we're really driven by Can we deploy the capital and create a stabilized yield on that investment that's going to be accretive to our existing earnings profile? And that's what really drives our mindset.
We pay attention obviously to our cost of capital, but just the idea that there's all of a sudden a better spread Opportunity in and of itself is not what compels us to go out and start putting money to work. We want to be sure we're adding earning assets they're going to be accretive to the existing earnings profile of the company.
So declining cost of capital doesn't mean You're willing to take a lower yield or does it influence your underwriting?
No, it really doesn't. We do not want to begin to just take on a bunch of lower yielding investments, just simply because the cost of capital is adjusted as it has. We're trying to compile a long term earnings growth profile for the company and we're trying to protect that long term earnings growth profile And just adding a bunch of low earning investments, just because our cost of capital happens to be where it is, It really runs counter to that long term objective.
Well, I'd say lower cap rates sometimes lead to higher growth in the 2nd year of ownership, but that's just
It can.
Okay, another observation. Anyway, last question for me. I appreciate the positive wrapper you're putting around the supply, which it makes sense to me in terms of premium relative to where your rents are. But clearly, You'd rather not be the case, right? I mean this is making the best of a not so great situation from a supply perspective.
With concessions that can be offered newer product and a strong job market, people might have a willingness to entertain optionality. So In your mind, while you see some opportunity out of the supply picture, what is the risk though that this could Actually have be more damaging when you consider that the health of job markets in your neck of the woods.
Well, certainly, I think the supply picture and the supply pressure as and we've we talked about it does create some short term pressure and as evidenced in our guidance, I mean, we assume that our lease over lease pricing in 2020 on a blended basis runs about 100 basis points below 2019. So there's no question that you get into these heavier supply scenarios, particularly where there's leasing concessions coming into the market, But there is some short term pressure generated. And as I mentioned, that can vary quite a bit by market. And in a bigger market like a Dallas, you're going to see More pressure than you are in a smaller market like a Greenville, South Carolina. And that's why we tend to be very focused in our efforts to deploy capital across the region, in both large and secondary markets in an effort to something you'll remember, Rich, in an effort to get our full cycle performance profile that we're after.
So I certainly acknowledge and we do that there is going to be Some near term pressure from some of the supply. We've got that dialed in, we think appropriately into our guidance. But I will tell you the fact that there's a lot of this new high priced product coming into our locations, we think that long term that's a good thing. It says good things about our neighborhoods. It says good things about the value of the real estate in those neighborhoods and Creates the opportunities that we alluded to, to continue over the next few years to get some not only good rent growth because of the improvement we're making in the assets, But also great returns on our capital.
This is the most accretive use of money that we have right now is this redevelopment initiatives. So, yes, we'll deal with a little short term pressure, but the long term value play is pretty darn attractive.
Got you. Thanks, Eric. Thanks, team.
You bet. Thank you.
We'll move next to Drew Babin with Baird. Your line is open.
Hey, good morning. Hey, Jim. A quick follow on question to Rob's question earlier on the Texas tax revenue caps. It sounds to me like that is not baked into your same store expense guidance range at all. It seems like maybe a longer term benefit.
Is that true? Or is there any Directional benefit that's beginning to influence guidance there?
No, I mean, I think we've dialed in what we think it's going to be our best estimate at this point, Drew. I mean, The cap is not at a taxpayer level. It is at the market level. And so I think there's still some things to be worked at Exactly how that's going to play each individual asset, the valuation and even the millage rates that we get in the year for all the markets. So we've got it what we think it's I think what we would say is over time hopefully those laws are helpful in restraining the fast growth of taxes in Texas.
That's hard to say taxes in Texas, but I think in the short term, it's yet to be seen exactly what it's going to play out. And so, that's when we put our best estimate on that.
Okay. And one follow-up on the same store revenue buildup, blended leasing spreads from 2019, blended leasing spreads in guidance, Marrying that with the occupancy guide and double play impact, it would seem like the revenue buildup goes towards the high end of guidance, which I would surmise there's maybe some other ancillary type items that may be a little flatter and dragging on that, which that was a trend kind of throughout 2019 as well. Can you talk about what kind of the growth in other aside from the double play, what was that other income growth in 2019? What will it be in 2020? And is there anything going on in that to kind of drive new other income into 2021?
Anything else you're kind of doing?
I I think that the easiest way to do that, quickest way maybe Drew is to just say talk about what our growth would have been, our guidance would have been without Assuming the bulk Internet program this year, and we
would have had a midpoint of
range somewhere around 3% to 2% growth for revenues, 3% to 6% for operating And 3 for NOI and then so you have the bulk Internet program on top of that. And so that can kind of help you. And I think the 3.2% on revenue is a combination of the Rents that we put on the table this year, the 3.4% blended lease that we expect to get combined with what we did last year is helpful, Giving up a little bit on occupancy, 15 basis points or so. And then the other fee income items other than the book and the reimbursement items and Other items, they're expected to be flat with last year essentially, which when your growth rate moves a little bit, gets you down to that 3.2% expectation for the year. The only expenses we talked about is 3.6%, and really everything but real estate taxes would have been about 3%.
So I hope that's helpful and gives you what you're looking for.
Okay. And it sounds like the Double Play program is being implemented kind of fairly rapidly. And so the benefits will be Mostly in 2020, is there anything else you're doing on the other income side that might help 'twenty one kind of coming off of that 'twenty comp? Any other additional parking fees, things like that, anything else kind of in the hopper that's being worked on or the technology element, might that move the needle as well?
Well, I will tell you that a lot of the double play, I mean, we're going to roll it out over
the course first half this year, but I really think the full year benefit will be more next year. It's about half this year and half next year because while we deploy it and will be deployed in May, Residents have to sign up for when they do on leasing renewal.
I think that that's going to build up over this year and we'll see more benefit in 20 The other thing though that Al alluded to and we talked about here is this repositioning effort that we're doing with Double Play and with the more enhanced amenity upgrades, what's happening is we're investing a lot of that Capital this year, this calendar year 2020 and the real rent growth from that will actually emerge in 2021. So that's really what's at play here. A lot of that benefit will play out next year, not this year.
Okay. That's all very helpful. Thank you.
We will take our next question from Rick Skidmore with Goldman Sachs. Your line is open.
Good morning. Thank you. Eric, you mentioned in your prepared comments some new initiatives in 2020. Perhaps I missed them, but can you perhaps speak to what those new initiatives are that you're focused on in 2020?
Well, Tom can jump in here. I mean, Al, it's the double play initiative, the high speed Internet program that we're rolling out was what I was Referencing, we've got the smart home technology implementation that we're going to be rolling out this year. And then as I was just mentioning, we've got some repositioning opportunities with some of the legacy post assets that we'll be rolling out this year and are working on this year. And as I was just mentioning, And then as Tom alluded to, there's some other new technologies, AI chat, some other things that we're self touring and other things that we'll testing out later this year, we don't really expect any impact this year, but we're going to continue to evaluate
we will go next to John Pawlowski with Green Street Advisors. Your line is open.
Did the NOI contribution or the NOI lift in 2021 is greater than the 50 bps in 2020? Is that accurate?
More comparable, I would say. I mean, we're rolling out just 2 phases program, 2 major providers that we're doing. In 2020, we'll have 1 of those providers will be building the second one. So I would say probably something it wouldn't increase, it might be something comparable.
Yes, I
think equal, maybe slightly a little less since we've got the biggest provider in line now and we're working on the rest of the portfolio.
Okay. And then, Tom, listening to your comments on which markets you think will lead the pack and which markets may lag, Is it a fair read that your as an aggregate, the smaller or secondary markets will be below average in terms of same store revenue growth?
I don't have them split exactly that way, but we've got some encouraging places On both sides of that equation. So I think we are the probably the runaway leaders Our Phoenix and Raleigh, but I'll tell you, Birmingham, Huntsville, and Memphis have been pretty solid players for us and we would
Okay. And then final one for me, if I could sneak it in there. Do you see revenue growth had been accelerating nicely for you year over year last few quarters and then slowed meaningfully this quarter. So is there anything idiosyncratic this quarter that hit the DC market or The fundamentals slowing in your eyes in the market.
Yes. We don't believe the fundamentals are slowing. It's really a comparison between the prior year, the 2 quarters. So last quarter in the Q3, we had a 30 basis point occupancy comparison tailwind reduced revenues a little bit. In this quarter, in the Q4 of 2018, we were 96.6 And we're 96 this go around, so we had a 60 basis point headwind.
Okay. Thank you.
We'll take our final question today from John Guinee with Stifel. Your line is open.
Hey, guys. Good morning. This is Aaron Wolf on for John. Two quick questions. Can you provide any detail on the price per unit on the Greenville That you recently acquired and also on the Little Rock, Arkansas portfolio?
Yes. So, this is Brad here. Let me get the details of that up in front of me. So the
Make sure
I get you the right number there. So that was $2.68 a unit The Greenville deal, which as we said a moment ago was a 5.1% cap rate on that asset. And then I'm sorry, your second question?
Little Rock.
Little Rock.
Yes.
So our Little Rock assets we sold, the total price there was just under 150,000 a unit was 109,000 a unit.
Okay, great. Thank you. And one last that's helpful. And one last from me. You may have disclosed this already.
I apologize if you did, but The average share price on the ATM activity in the quarter?
You can get from the press release Proceeds and the shares is around $136 a share, I'm pleased with that will come.
Okay, great. Thank you so much.
Thank
you. And this does conclude our Q and A session for today as well as our call. We would like thank everyone for your participation today. You may disconnect at any time.