This would Great. So good day, everyone, and thank you so much for joining us at the J.P. Morgan Ultimate Services Investor Conference. I'm Alex Hess, a member of the Business and Information Equity Research Team here at J.P. Morgan. We are led by Andrew Steinerman, who many of you all know so well. We are pleased to be joined today for the fifth consecutive year, I've checked, five, by MSCI CFO Andy Wiechmann. Welcome back to Ultimate Services, Andy.
Thank you for having me. Hopefully there will be many more. Always a good event and very glad to be here.
Great. So, Andy, I want to start with recent selling momentum. You noted on the October earnings call that last 12 months, so trailing 12-month, net subscription sales are up 26% year-on-year, so that's versus the prior 12-month period. So that's $207 million in dollar terms versus $164 million 12 months previously. Big improvement for you guys. What's changed inside the firm and in the operating environment that's enabled that acceleration?
Yeah, so it's important to stay grounded in what is happening in the investment industry, which is the primary industry that we serve here. As is always the case, there is an evolution in how capital flows, how capital forms, how it's allocated. You've seen an evolution over the last 100 years from, 100 years ago was the advent of a mutual fund that allowed an investor to easily get access to many different stocks.
Around that, you had The Intelligent Investor, where heavy emphasis on single stock research and fundamental research. In the '60s and '70s, you saw indexes and index investing come about. You saw in 1980s and, or '70s and '80s, we were behind a lot of this factor investing.
So this notion of systematic drivers of performance and risk being important to understanding the security. You've seen the advent of ETFs over the last 30 years here, and now other tradable products, technologies enabling multi-asset class portfolios, fractional shares, international investing.
The advent of systematic investing has arrived here, and this enables personalization at scale. It enables investors to achieve a specific outcome more efficiently and more effectively. You see that manifest itself in basket trades, in multi-asset class solutions, direct indexed portfolios, obviously indexation and ETFs, and we see it in the form of ETFs based on custom indexes, passive mandates. You are seeing this explosion of these outcome-oriented, personalized systematic strategies that are rules-based, and MSCI is in a unique position to provide the underpinnings to that.
The growth is enabled by these massive opportunities, and we have been aggressively moving to invest, build out our capabilities to serve this demand. To your point, yes, we've seen our new product machine be reinvigorated here, and it's been reinvigorated around these opportunities that I just talked about.
So it's not only developing those capabilities that are enabling this more rules-based investing, systematic portfolio construction and management, in the form of things like custom indexes, custom index services, risk models, ways to get into thematic structural considerations around the capital markets, but also allowing investors to do it across asset classes, including private asset classes. So we've had a feverish pace of innovation. That innovation has also been geared at use cases in newer client segments for us.
So client segments like, obviously hedge funds and traders, like wealth managers directly to asset owners, banks, insurance companies. With these innovations, which are enabled by AI, a more shared common infrastructure and enhancements to our go-to-market, we're unlocking growth in many of these huge wallets where we've historically been small, and you're seeing the compounding effects of that with some good momentum in the business. So, we're super excited about that virtuous circle of momentum that we've seen. We think we're just getting started on unlocking those big opportunities in front of us, and we think we're focused in the right areas to enable that.
That's super helpful. Obviously, you guys think long term about this stuff, but maybe we have to think a little short term too. Obviously, you've talked about hedge funds just now, and that's been a really nice growth vector for you. Maybe if we could, October and November have been a period of, let's call it degrowing for a lot of hedge funds. Is there anything to read into the environment in the last few months that, as far as that affects your-
Yeah
key KPIs?
I would say this. We see very strong engagement across clients, including with hedge funds and trading firms, broker-dealers, that are supporting hedge funds. They are still focused on doing a lot more with us, and we are continually innovating with products and solutions that are going to help them in all environments to capitalize in those periods of benign up rising markets, as well as periods of greater volatility and uncertainty. We continue to have conviction that that is a very attractive growth avenue for us where we're in early innings. It is a segment where you're going to see some slightly lower retention, higher client events.
I would call out that we are engaging more strategically on a more cross-company basis with these large hedge funds, who have been fueling a lot of the growth you've seen in hedge fund assets, where we are increasingly licensing them on a broader basis than team by team. That does also provide some stability to how we can support them. As I alluded to, we've got tools and capabilities that are very much in demand for them across many different parts of their franchises.
That's super helpful. You touched briefly on retention, and you noted, look, hedge funds typically, well, a little bit lower retention. But your retention overall, very strong year to date, or at least up notably year to date. How do you put retention in the context of MSCI's history, that 95.2% you're running at for the first nine months, and what's sort of enabling that improved retention versus
Yeah
the last year or two?
Yeah, to your point, we've seen, yeah, if you look at the year-to-date retention relative to last year, up slightly. If you look relative to two years ago, up a point and change. If you dial the clock back 10 years, 9, 10, 11 years, yeah, our retention's up nicely from there. There's a few things at play. One is, and I alluded to this with hedge funds, but this has been particularly the case with the largest investment organizations around the world.
We have become much more of a top-level senior partner at these organizations. We have broader licensing models where broader parts of the organization get access to the content. They're getting access to many different types of content. In the past, we might have been vulnerable to an organization closing an office or moving a team out of an office.
Increasingly, those things are not a cancellation trigger for us. One, because the client is licensing across a broader range of offices, but oftentimes the discussion with them is not about, "Hey, can we get this at this office location?" But it's like, "What additional content sets do you have, and how do we license those across organizations?" So it's been a key element to driving stable retention, but also upselling for many of these organizations.
That-
Yeah.
Super helpful.
Yeah. One other thing I would highlight that is important here is the nature of how our tools are being used is increasingly mission critical.
We are being increasingly embedded in our clients' investment processes and a critical component of their investment processes. We've always been standard. We've always been something that is mission critical, but now we're almost existential to these organizations where they're growing, which just inherently provides some stability.
Yeah. That's super helpful. Sorry for almost cutting you off earlier.
No worries.
Maybe a good point to transition is, if you are more mission critical, is that one of the reasons your deal sizes are growing larger? This is something you alluded to on the last earnings call, and is that solely because you are selling them more and selling them bigger packages, or is that also just for renewals factoring into that?
Well, as we are bigger with clients, there is going to be some larger scale renewals when contracts do come up for renewal. I would not say that is new per se, and we have renewals throughout the year, so that is not adding a tremendous amount of this kind of lumpiness that we alluded to.
It is more driven by the fact that we, and I mentioned this in your last question, we are engaging very strategically with our clients. We are in the areas where they want to grow, where they want to expand, and we are increasingly landing these, we refer to them internally as solutions deals, which is, it is built on existing products, content IP that we have, but it is a little bit of a bespoke implementation.
Or bespoke use case. Many of them are repeatable. Actually, most of them are repeatable. These tend to be longer sales cycle, and they can be quite sizable in terms of the gross sales size for us. That can impact both the recurring and the non-recurring sales. Just to give a little bit more color, because I think this is going to be a key driver of growth for us going forward here.
When you look at the third quarter, we did call out that we had a number of these large deals. Just to give some examples of what they are, we are working with a large asset owner that wants to incorporate risk and those systematic drivers of performance and risk into their investment process. They have historically been a big user of our tools within their risk function.
They want their investment team to get access to that. We are helping them build out a whole new investment process, investment system. Similarly, we had a large deal with a large wealth manager who is looking to roll out a more model portfolio-driven process across a broad part of their financial advisors. We are the critical underpinning or capability there. So it is built on our wealth manager capability, but it is also using broader content sets that we have, and it is something that they are embedding in a broader solution that they are delivering internally.
You've seen us talk about the UBS deal that we landed, which is a combination of capabilities we have within our private asset insights, but also our total portfolio, if you will, our total plan insights that allow their financial advisory business or their wealth management business double-click into the exposure that their clients are getting by being invested in private assets and what that means for their total plan objectives and risk that they're taking. These are things that are large ticket. They have long sales cycles, so there will be some lumpiness, but we are seeing more and more of these, and we think this is a key catalyst for growth for us going forward here.
It's-
One that I'm particularly excited about.
It sounds like you're really now moving towards, instead of saying, "Hey, look, we're going to sell you modules, and module by module," to saying, "Look, we're going to help your whole firm level up, and here's how we're going to have that conversation. Here's what it's going to start. It might take a little longer to get us the dollar in the door, but it's going to be
Yes. Yep. The addressable market for the module sale, as you call it, or the product sale, is still big. We're still going to see a lot of that. That's going to continue to grow. These solution sales are almost a whole new wallet for us. These are things that we historically have not done. We're tapping into processes and systems and parts of these organizations that we haven't served before. This is a huge addressable market that we're just starting to unlock here, and I think has some very attractive legs that are going to be a key engine of growth, as I mentioned.
Well, we haven't talked about agentic AI yet, but let's talk about agentic AI.
All right.
It seems like both from the client vantage, but also from internally, agentic AI is playing a key role in helping you guys build and surface new solutions to client. I'm thinking like IndexAI Insights, FactorLab, but can you provide any examples that come to mind for you of products where agentic AI has enabled or accelerated your development? What should we look for in the future there?
Yeah. You probably remember, there was a period when we were talking about the new sales from AI native products. Part of the reason why we've stopped doing that is because nearly everything that we are releasing to market, all these new products are enabled by AI in some form or fashion, and it's to varying degrees.
But most of them, either we would not be able to deliver without AI, or we would not be able to deliver it as quickly or as cost-efficiently as we have without AI. So, it underpins everything that we are doing. It's also been, as you know, Henry mentions, it's a godsend for us in terms of finding efficiencies to free up more investment capacity, and so it's doubly accelerating that pace of product innovation.
Our focus has been more around contribution to new sales from new products, almost all of which is enabled by AI. But to your question about examples, if you think about what are those meaty opportunities that are fueling those new product sales that we've alluded to, custom indexes is a big part of it.
AI is underpinning our ability to turn around a custom index faster, provide a better service layer on top of it, provide more degrees of flexibility, incorporate broader content and capabilities we have across the organization. So AI has been a tremendous accelerant for us on the custom index side. Also, these broader index modules that we're creating, we're able to produce them, turn them around so quickly because of AI.
As you alluded to, things like IndexAI Insights or analytic insights are truly agentic AI native capabilities that enhance the service, enhance the value that we're delivering to clients. You're seeing within the private asset segment a number of these new datasets and services, like our diligence and document management service is wholly enabled by AI.
It allows our clients to basically extract information from their documents, fundraising documents, to be able to compare it to their existing private asset portfolio and pull out the salient information to evaluate whether they want to invest there. You're seeing it within climate on our physical risk and asset intelligence tools. So yeah, AI has been a boon for us on a number of fronts, and it really does underpin almost all this innovation that you're seeing.
Got it. So, maybe that's sort of a good time to switch to think about the organic reinvestment opportunity. Obviously, there's maybe not a tension, but people often wonder how to strike the balance between reinvesting in the business versus demonstrating margin expansion. How should MSCI investors think about the firm's revenue and expense growth objectives prospectively, and specifically any nuances or changes to the fundamental algorithm of low double-digit revenue growth and high single to low double-digit expense growth?
No change. We are committed to delivering sustainable, outsized top-line growth while continually, period in, period out, also delivering very attractive profitability growth. As you see in our long-term targets, but also as you have heard us talk about in the past, we take that dual commitment very seriously, where we are going to invest in the business to fuel sustained outsized top-line growth, but also we have the levers and the proactive financial management to ensure that we deliver attractive profitability growth in good markets and in tougher markets.
You have heard us talk about our upturn and downturn playbook. We are obviously going to flex the pace of investment and spend based on that top-line trajectory, as well as a whole host of other factors.
When you see the business having tremendous momentum and very strong top-line growth, we have the ability to invest more and still deliver that very attractive profitability growth. When there are periods when there might be cyclical pressures at play, we have the levers that allow us to manage and flex the cost proactively to ensure that we are also delivering attractive profitability in those periods.
We are not solving for a specific margin in the business. We are consistently trying to deliver that attractive profitability growth through all environments while investing in the business, and it is a dynamic process, and we will continue to flex up and down.
That makes a ton of sense. Just to maybe dive into something I have always really found interesting and appreciated about MSCI is the Triple-Crown framework that you guys speak to on capital allocation. Specifically, that there is a very OPEX-centric lens to your capital allocation rather than say, "Oh, this is what free cash flow we are going to deliver, and we will figure out what we do with it after that.
Right.
It starts almost at the OPEX line. For those who do not know, the Triple-Crown framework at MSCI is, as I think of it, is reinvesting in one, high-return projects, with two, a short payback period, and three, where good execution will fortify the MSCI stock's multiple. Can you remind us about how you-
That's impressive, by the way. Those are the three crowns of the Triple-Crown, yeah.
Three crowns.
Yeah.
I said crowns. Can you provide us a sense for how you think about applying this framework today, given the need to stay on the bleeding edge of AI, custom indexing, and all these sort of-
Yeah
trends that we're talking about?
I would clarify that our Triple-Crown, and it sits within our broader, we call it ICAP, Internal Capital Allocation Process, cuts across all of our expenditures. We do look at both OPEX and CAPEX expenditures, and we divide them into two categories broadly, among a number of subcategories. But run the business expenses, which are those expenditures that are going to support the franchise as it exists today, so serving the existing client segments with the existing products in the way that we've been delivering them, and then the change of the business, or what we refer to as investments. You can crudely think of that as our discretionary spend.
That is going into everything from new product launches, as we've been talking about, but also go to market, so feet on the ground and resources to support one of these newer client segments that we want to build out. It's also going into productivity enhancement or factory transformation, so things that we might be doing to drive our processes much more efficiently.
Within that investment portfolio, that is where we use the Triple-Crown. We are aggressively racking and stacking and prioritizing those investment areas that are going to deliver us the highest return, fastest payback, and be most strategically and value-enhancing and multiple-enhancing for us as an organization. It is a strong discipline that I spend most of my time on. We breathe day in, day out. Henry is the ultimate evangelist on it.
We are ruthless about where we put that discretionary spend because it is a very scarce resource against these tremendous opportunities that we see. We are also ruthless about squeezing the run the business expenses. This is where, when Henry says AI is a godsend, this is primarily what he's talking about. Henry mentioned this on an earnings call, but he and I, going back a long way, we've always thought about how do we get more investment dollars? How do we fulfill that dual mandate I alluded to in your prior question while investing more in the business?
AI is giving us an inflection change almost in that, where a lot of the run the business processes we can do more efficiently today, and we can do them faster, at a lower cost, with more degrees of flexibility, which inherently frees up more dollars for that investment portfolio. We are committed to that same financial algorithm that I alluded to before, but within that financial algorithm, we can invest more dollars.
AI is enabling us to invest more, but it's also enabling those investments to be more productive, turn around tools more quickly, and unlock new use cases and solutions, as we were talking about earlier. AI is a key ingredient to almost changing that structure of our run the business and change the business expenses to enable us to stimulate growth even more.
That's super helpful. Maybe we'll touch on a few of the product segments. For those of you who aren't aware, you've got in rough order of size is Index, by far the largest, then Analytics, then Sustainability and Climate, and Private Capital Solutions are nice. All, call it, low double digits, I believe, or higher percentage of total revs and run rate, but all sort of a balanced contribution from those four, Index being notably larger.
Within Index, just remind us, what does the cross-sell motion look like there, and what does new product penetration look like for you there? Do you start with the ACWI and then sell 15 indices from there? Are you selling people like end-of-day feeds and then modernizing and then sort of upselling them to further cuts of the data? Or how does that exactly, that motion work?
Yes, the answer to all that. We do all those things. This is something that we've been doing for a long time. It has been part of our business model. It's consistent with my answer when you asked about retention rates and how we've been doing more for organizations where we have, over time, moved from being, and we still do this at new organizations, smaller client organizations, but licensing DM Core, which is our Developed Market, market cap module, which includes hundreds of indexes on the developed markets and all the content that supports the constituents of those indexes. So we'll start licensing that to maybe their international investing team at one location.
When they decide, "Hey, we want our New York team in addition to our London team to get access," that would be a nice upsell for us, because we would historically charge by office location. Especially with the largest investment organizations, we've been on this journey for some time. So it's at the level now where for most large organizations, we're talking about, you have a license to this content set, again, DM Core, across most of your locations. Why don't we go to a multi-location deal, a global deal where all locations can access this module? And we'll give you a discounted fee as we expand across those, and that discount will step down over time.
So we do have this nice upsell motion, which is as they expand usage to our content, particularly indexes, but similar things happen with other content sets across MSCI, they are paying us more, and they are getting more value. So going back to my opening comments about this move towards systematic investing, our Index content is much more than just the right to license a benchmark and to report your performance against a benchmark.
It is hundreds of indexes with massive amounts of data that underlies those indexes that can be used in more systematic strategies in that systematic portfolio construction process, in the research process. And so there is growing demand for broader access to existing modules, and then to your point, we are rapidly innovating with additional modules.
As you said, we have real-time modules, we have scalar factor modules, or climate modules, or economic exposure modules. We've just come out with our AI classification exposures, other thematic considerations, real-time, deep history data. We're seeing organizations that are just consuming more and more of that data, and it is something that underpins not only that upsell motion, but it also underpins price increases oftentimes for clients where, as I alluded to, we'll give them broader access to content together with a price increase because we are very mindful of continuing to add value to our clients.
We recognize long-term growth is going to be fueled by doing more for them, not just charging more for what they're getting. We're continually enhancing what we do and broadening our clients' access to what we do.
We are at different levels of that evolution penetration game across different client segments. Not surprisingly, outside of asset managers, we're still earlier in that journey of, as you called it, penetration of licensing modules across parts of their organization. We've got this smooth motion, as you indicated, to continue to fuel that engine of growth over time.
Got it. That's super helpful. Maybe just because to be mindful of time, quick word on analytics. I think sometimes we get clients who ask us, "Hey, what exactly is that?" You've got there these factor models that are really core for a lot of your clients, especially your hedge funds come to mind, trading firms come to mind. But you also have portfolio tools and then enterprise risk solutions, which maybe are used more by risk teams.
Yeah.
How should we understand your If you were to white sheet the index business and-
Analytics?
Sorry, analytics business.
Yeah
and completely reinvent the reporting, how would you break it out? What is the best way to think about it?
Yeah, I mean, it is a fair point. We have a lot of products. We have a lot of content sets and analytic engines within our analytics franchise. Going back to my comments earlier about solutions, we are increasingly thinking about the organization across these categories of solutions that we can provide. Actually, the way we break it out in our investor presentation, which is between two big categories, which is equity analytics and multi-asset class analytics, is a fair way to think about it. There are other dimensions that you can think about, which are more like front office portfolio management use cases versus middle office risk management use cases.
But broadly, what you are seeing on the equity analytics side is that franchise is built around our factors, and it is heavily, although it is used a lot by middle office functions, it is heavily driven by the front office use cases, those portfolio management processes. So we have many different factor models and modules that we license.
We also have applications and tools that enable clients to do things like portfolio construction, optimization, back testing, attribution. But it is the value and what underpins that is the factor content there. So while there are applications, really the sale is a client that wants to be more advanced in factor investing. Depending on their architecture, their investment process, the systems they use, we can either provide them the models or a broader service and application to enable that factor-driven investment process.
The other category, multi-asset class investing, it's fueled by our multi-asset class risk engines mostly. That's legacy RiskMetrics. Today it's RiskServer, RiskManager, the old BarraOne system, which is the multi-asset class factor-driven analytics franchise. Then within both of those, there are rich content sets that clients want to get access to around liquidity risk, around credit risk, around security pricing, security modeling, hard-to-get information about exotics and mortgage backs. There's a rich subset of content, and a lot of that is very unique proprietary, including on private assets. That is a big differentiator for us.
We have very unique private asset information that feeds into those multi-asset class analytics that historically have been, "Hey, we're going to implement a new enterprise risk service for you." Today, as I alluded to earlier, it's much more of, "We can help you transform into being a much more systematic investment-driven process." That's anchored to not only our factor content, but also these powerful risk engines and analytic engines that we have across analytics. There's a lot going on under the hood, but all that is, especially with AI and technological advances, enabling these solution opportunities that is new white space for us, and I alluded to at the beginning.
Great, Andy. We're up on time. Is there anything else you'd ask us to keep in mind as we move forward, or shall we break there?
No. I think you hit on the key points here. Very excited about the momentum we have and the opportunity, and thank you for hosting me here.
All right. Thank you so much, Andy Wiechmann of MSCI.
Thank you, everyone.