Fintech space here at Stephens. Pleased to have with me Pagaya's CFO, Jon Dobres. Got that right?
Yep. Perfect. Great to be with you.
Yeah. Craig is in the audience from the company's IR. Pagaya provides AI-based credit decisioning tools that integrate with its various lending partners to source, analyze, and improve customer credit. The company funds its loans with a mix of ABS and forward flow agreements. Currently, they're focused on the personal loan, auto, and point of sale asset classes. With that, I will turn it over to Jon to run through the story in a little bit more detail and talk about some of the, how the company has evolved since going public in 2022.
Yeah. Thanks. Thanks for having us. It's been a great conference, a lot of very good conversations so far today. Pagaya, over its 10-year history, has essentially formed a credit network that on the one side has today about 38 consumer lenders. Again, as Kyle mentioned, in the personal loan, auto, and point of sale space. So these are large banks like U.S. Bank, Ally, most recently Citizens, fintechs, banks that used to be fintechs like SoFi and Upgrade, and Barclays Best Egg. On the other side of the network are very large pools of pre-funded capital.
So some of that is through ABS, some of it's through forward flow, and then we have flavors in between that are just long-term committed capital. In the middle of that network is our decisioning engine. We have over, at this point, $1.4 trillion of application flow that comes through the network every year, and a very large data science team that has built and improves models to evaluate credit that comes through the channel. Very simply, the way it works is, we will take Ally for example. You apply for an auto loan, you are sitting across from the dealer. We identify you in the Ally flow as a borrower that is relevant for us.
That could be because Ally first denied you, or it could be a certain type of borrower that we and Ally have mutually agreed we can do a better job converting than Ally can on its own. That application comes to us, we evaluate, make an offer. The dealer gives you the offer, and to you, the borrower, it is an Ally offer. You become, if you say yes, you become an Ally customer. Ally and Pagaya both sort of monetize you upfront. Very importantly, and this is a key part of our value proposition, from Ally's stan dpoint, you are an Ally cu stomer.
You are servicing revenue for them going forward, and you are in their ecosystem, which can be monetized in any number of ways. The loan is funded from the other side of the network, from those pre-funded pools of capital. When you really think about our value proposition, it is different for different asset classes, but it is quite powerful and it allows us to grow new partners and a pipeline that is the strongest in our history. On the personal loan side, for banks especially, we enable them to offer a product, a personal loan, that may not exactly fit with their balance sheet strategy.
If a bank cannot offer a 680 FICO borrower a personal loan, that borrower may take their deposits and go to a more nimble fintech. We enable the bank to grow their product strength and keep that depositor. On the auto side, similar to the Ally example I just provided, we enable a much improved auto lender-dealer relationship, which when you talk to these large banks, those two value props, keeping the depositor, improving the dealer relationship, are on the top of the list for how these banks are trying to grow.
The result of that is really a record year of new partner adds and a pipeline into next year that should bring us some very large auto OEM type customers, banks, and others to sort of support that.
That was a really good intro and a nice way to describe really the Pagaya model. I will lead with questions, but at this point in the day, I am kind of tired of my own voice, so please feel free to chime in.
I've been having the same conversation every half hour for the last six hours.
So yeah, help us out.
I have no sympathy for you. Yeah.
All right, let's kick it off. You guys recently reported a third quarter with double-digit revenue growth in which net income more than doubled. So walk us through some of the highlights. You talked about some of the recent partner adds and then kind of how you're thinking about Q4, and recognizing you don't have specific 2027 guidance out there, but how you're thinking about it from a high level.
Yeah. Q3 we were very, very happy with. We continued execution. It was our seventh straight quarter of growing net income. We were $0.52 at EPS, so $0.52 a share in the quarter versus $0.23 the year prior quarter. Really executed nicely while managing through a higher rate environment, which has its own challenges that we can get into a bit later. The story of the quarter, though, for me, is the 2026 growth we saw. Even though we added seven partners over the course of the year, that growth was more or less generated same store.
That is the story for us of product-led growth, which our President, Sanjiv Das, who joined three years ago, he is really instilled in the organization. What does that mean? It means that product-led growth has allowed our auto business to double year-over-year, and it is doubling on the same set of partners. A year and a half ago, when you looked at our Ally business or you looked at our Westlake business, we were just seeing the applications that were first declined. We are now seeing a much, much wider range of applications.
That allows us to grow volume, both in PL and more significantly in auto, while still keeping conversion at that same ±1%, because the top of the funnel, the number of applications we are seeing is just so much higher. The story of the quarter and the year for us is working more and more closely with our existing partners and building that 2026 profitability that was so strong over 2025, but ensuring that that growth will continue in the future by adding seven new partners who take a year or so to scale, but will really start adding by the end of 2027, and ensuring that we have a pipeline that will continue to add very large, chunky partners in 2027.
When I think of it overall, it is that existing partner growth, which is very much product-led, and the pipeline. The other thing that I was very, very proud of from the quarter, and we talked about this a bit earlier, was the diversification of our funding base. Our funding strategy is to be diversified beyond just the single securitization market. We are now about 50% pre-funded securitization, which is still an incredibly strong product for us, but 50% forward flow and other forms of funding. That enables us, one, to be able to access several markets at the same time, and two, get a longer term, more committed base of capital.
Because while we have three or five months visibility on the capital from any one pre-funded ABS, these revolving structures, off-balance sheet warehouses, forward flows are two or more years in duration.
I agree. Yeah, those are definitely two of the highlights from the quarter. One of the things people were really concerned about going into the quarter was rates and how volatile rates were in late September, specifically the two-year. I think there was one day specifically the two-year jacked way up. Just walk us through how rates impact the FRLPC. I mean, you guys talked about how that's temporary. Then sort of other balancing factors on the FRLPC that keep it at between 4% and 5%, and what would make it be at the low end or the high end of that range?
Yeah. So our FRLPC, fee revenue less production cost, we'll just start calling it, for purposes of the two-minute answer, I'll just call it net fees. I get the letters wrong sometimes too. We look at that, the way we think about it is a percentage of our overall network volume. So net fees is a percentage of our network volume we think of in a 4%-5% range. In Q2 and in Q3, we were at the low end of that range. Q3 was sort of at a floor of 4.1%. The reason for that is twofold. The first, which is a much smaller component, is the fact that we added so many new partners in the quarter.
New partners, day one, as they scale, come in at lower margin. By contract, that margin increases over time as they scale. So it's not like a permanent degradation in margin. It's day one lower margin, build up that margin over time. The bigger effect on that is what you identified with rates. The two-year, especially in August and September, increased dramatically. That increases the cost of capital on our securitizations. Now, the spreads above the two-year, like what the investors are paying in whole, have actually remained stable or, on our personal loan book, actually decreased about 20- 30 basis points depending on the tranche.
So our investor demand remains actually as strong as it's ever been. However, the two-year does push up our cost of capital, and it takes time to pass on that cost of capital increase to the consumer in the form of an APR increase. While that pass-through is happening, and we talked about on the call how in October we raised APRs depending on the asset class between 100 and 140 basis points. But in the meantime, that higher cost of capital with an APR where the cost hasn't been passed along puts some compression on our margin, which increases sort of the sensitivity of the certificate we're putting on our balance sheet and causes us to price that securitization at more of a discount.
That discount lowers FRLPC and lowers the percentage. As the margin expands, which is happening right now with the higher APR, we will get back to kind of that middle of the 4%-5% range as you get into 2027, really to the middle, I would say kind of mid-2027. But we view that lower end of the range where we were in Q3 as sort of a floor, and you'll begin to see margin come back in Q4 and then more so in 2027.
Okay. Makes a lot of sense. Then, always a topic to focus on, just given the amount of application flows you guys see and how many consumers you touch, would just be great to get a sense for how the consumer's doing. A lot of headlines about inflation, fuel prices, balance that with a good employment number and decent wage growth, but yeah, just love to get a sense for what you're seeing.
Yeah. Credit now and for the last couple of years has been pretty consistent for us and performing in line with our underwriting and expectations. So we're seeing the consumer hold up, and we feel very good about all of our recent vintages. That being said, at the beginning of 2026, the market didn't like this. We thought we were delivering something very positive. Given the large increase of application flow we were seeing from working with new partners and working with existing partners more widely, we decided to kind of take a preemptive move of limiting our originations in our two riskiest PRTs.
Because we have so many lending partners, we normalize credit into different Pagaya Risk Tiers, one through seven. We limited tiers six and seven. The market, I think, viewed that as we weren't going to grow. We ended up growing faster from a volume standpoint than we expected, doubling auto volume and growing around 30% overall. But we viewed it as, in a way, future-proofing the portfolio against inflation. So, listen, everyone is affected by inflation. However, a $50,000 borrower is a lot more affected than a $90,000 borrower.
And those riskier PRTs tended to have lower income borrowers. So if you look at our book today, our average personal loan borrower is about $120,000-$125,000 a year of income, 670-680 FICO. Auto's a little bit lower, but still significantly higher than where we were a couple years ago. So if you looked at our auto book two years ago, we were at about a $60,000 consumer. Today, we're almost $90,000, and the collateral there has actually improved a lot also. But we think we have a borrower makeup today that can be pretty durable in this environment, and we haven't really seen stress to date.
That's great. Let's pivot back to kind of your balance sheet. Walk us through the kind of evolution in terms of risk retention, how you initially funded. Pagaya was initially funded primarily with ABS. Now you've mixed in forward flows. You did highlight that one of the highlights from 3Q was the improvements on the funding side in terms of extending out maturities, but walk us through kind of in terms of risk retention.
Yeah. So, I think that question sort of goes to both funding and the makeup of the balance sheet. So, on our funding mix today, you should think about the amount of capital that we're putting in from our balance sheet into these deals equals about 2.5%-3% of our volume on an unlevered basis. So when we can get some very, very attractive leverage on some of the tranches we put on the balance sheet, which then takes that capital closer to 1.5% or 2%, but let's think about it as unlevered. Our balance sheet a year ago was roughly 75% first loss positions and securitizations, 25% mezzanine bond positions.
So, low teens yielding bonds that have never been impaired in the history of the company. Today, we're more like 50/50. So 50% of the balance sheet are the certificates, the first loss positions in securitizations. They are very, very sensitive to any movements in credit, so you do see a normalized level of impairments of those quarter-over-quarter, and that obviously, we do not adjust that out of net income. Net income is post that. The certificate portion has been growing. Excuse me. The bond portion has been growing.
Those, again, are kind of low teens yielding, we view as very safe investments that both return a nice amount of capital to us through that 11%+ interest rate, and also dramatically improve the overall structure of the securitizations. When you take a step back, we are now in a cash position where we can, in a way, take advantage of that opportunity. When you look at, like, an Affirm or a OneMain or others, they are generally holding the entirety of the non-IG portion of the securitization on their balance sheet.
We do not quite do that, but we do think it is attractive for both the structure and an interest income point of view to hold a portion of those B and B B rated bonds on balance sheet. Today, the balance sheet, our investments line is about $1.1 billion, about 50%. The first loss piece is 50%. Those, what we view as discretionary investments.
Okay. That is great. You touched a little bit on this in terms of product expansion and what Sanjiv Das has talked about. The auto one resonates a lot, where if the person is only partially approved for a loan. Talk about some of the other products you guys have out there, particularly your relationships with affiliates, like the Credit Karmas of the world, and kind of other When you talk about new products, sometimes it goes over people's heads.
Yeah, totally.
Think about, it's not just a turn-down business.
Yes. Today we're about 50% turn-down. Second look, first look. We change the name for that every couple months. Yes, turn down, non-turn down. I always go back to the auto one because it's such an easy one to illustrate, right? It's obvious why a $30,000 loan for a $30,000 car works better than a $23,000 loan. There are a lot of others. On the personal loan side, just naturally being such a large issuer of personal loans in the U.S., we do a lot with Credit Karma, Experian, and a lot of the other affiliate networks.
The beginning of that was just because we're in the market, right? We would just get a lot of flow from those. We've developed an expertise over time in how to best work with those different affiliate networks, and actually sort of view that as a core competency. When we work with a U.S. Bank or a Citizens today, who is a lot less sort of natural in working with those networks than like a SoFi or a fintech, part of the package we start with them is essentially white labeling a product that can go into those affiliate networks, which becomes a deposit acquisition tool for those banks. We've started to do it with U.S. Bank.
We're doing it with Citizens. It goes through a lot of the different affiliates, but most notably Credit Karma, just because their sheer size, and Experian, just because it's a huge strategic growth area for them right now, really building out their Activate network. That's one piece. We also have a pre-screen product where we will proactively look at a selection of one of our partner's borrowers, attributes that we have about them in the network, and proactively go through our partner to them with a loan offer where they're essentially pre-approved.
There's a couple things they need to do to finish the approval, but that has essentially opened up an area of applications to us on the personal loan side that we just weren't seeing before. On the auto side, in addition to that sort of counter-optimization where we're actually the $30,000, $23,000 example where we're countering an Ally offer and Ally's deciding to use ours, we also have mechanisms now with dealers where they can more dynamically change levers on loans.
So maybe a different monthly rate versus interest rate or different things that still all fit into our approval, but may make the loan more attractive to the borrower sitting across from the dealer. There's a selection of things. They've all been in process for one to two years, but 2026 is really the year for us where a lot of them started taking off. And we see a ton of growth from them, all essentially first look as you get into 2027 as well.
Great. Let's talk about the lending partner pipeline. You started personal. I think a lot of the growth recently you talked about has been auto. You guys also have point of sale as well. I think seven new partners today?
Yeah, in 2026.
Bringing us to 38 total?
I think with Splash this morning, we are at 38.
Okay. Well, yeah, walk us through the pipeline. Walk us through the sales process. Because if I am a lender, I am like, Why wouldn't you have Pagaya? But then, of course, there is IT departments and hoops to jump through. How long the sales process is, and then how long it takes for lending partners to kind of ramp and get towards maturity.
It is interesting. In 2026, growth from auto, we had good growth from PL, but growth from auto dwarfed it.
Right. Yeah.
We did not really add any auto partners in 2026. This was all more or less same store, product-driven growth. We added a lot of PL. We added three POS as well. You will see those partners begin to scale more in kind of the second half of 2027. It takes time for us to scale with partners, for the most part, because we want to make sure we are proving out the performance that we expected at the outset. We do a ton of work in onboarding, on historical information, and projecting out what we think performance will look like.
You can have the best AI in the world, you need to actually see three, six, nine months of vintage quality before you should really feel comfortable in scaling up a lot. That will kind of hit second half of 2027 and will continue to grow through 2028. In terms of newer partners, we have a strong pipeline for next year. We have mentioned that we expect a large auto OEM to come online and another very large bank to come on over the course of 2027. Why would someone not use Pagaya? There are sort of two answers to that.
One is we are not open to everybody anymore. We want chunkier, more impactful partners. We want to feel like we can get $30 million-$50 million of contribution margin with anyone we are bringing in. There are tons of smaller fintech lenders who would be very eager to jump on the network quickly, where we just do not see the ROI in it for us to bring them on. We like larger, chunkier bank partners today. We think the strategic alignment makes a ton of sense, and the 12, 24, 36-month scaling of that relationship can become massive.
It is difficult to bring banks online. It is easier now that we are not on Bank One anymore, right? We are not on U.S. Bank, which was our first big one. We are 10 or so banks in, and there is obviously a lot of FOMO in that business. Just being able to sit in front of a risk committee and say, But they are in with Ally and U.S. Bank and Citizens, gives people a lot of comfort. However, they are still taking. This is what sort of slows down the sales pipeline, but I also think it is a huge differentiator for us. When we bring on a new bank, they are not taking on credit risk, but they are taking on other types of risk, right?
When we facilitate a loan with a U.S. Bank, U.S. Bank is still the lender. U.S. Bank is regulated, obviously. If we do something wrong in the background, if we reject someone for the wrong reason or something, that risk is on U.S. Bank. The banks need to make sure that what we have built internally safeguards them. And we have. We've built a risk org led by a team that, with, depending on the member, 15-35 years of experience in some of the largest, most complicated financial institutions in the U.S. Our Head of Compliance led compliance at BNY Mellon.
We have the teams in place so banks can get that confidence, but it's still many constituencies at the banks and a long process. But once they're over the transom, once we get them on our side of it, the stickiness of that relationship and the trust and partnership that we have allows us to scale the business over time and makes the likelihood of them leaving extremely low.
Right. That's a good kind of segue, and I was going to ask about competition. It's almost like they're deciding between Pagaya or nothing, right? There's not a lot of alternatives out there.
We haven't really come across groups that have scaled this business in a way that we have. And it's hard, again, the reason why we've been around for 10 years, but it wasn't until year five or year six where we really started onboarding banks. If your value prop is we can bring more capital to you and just partner with us, which maybe our value prop was in 2017, you can bring on smaller capital-hungry partners very quickly. If your value prop is we're going to improve a bank's customer relationships, that's something that a small fintech startup can't do.
On a one-off type basis, there may be a large asset manager that has a partnership for some second look from a bank, but they're not doing the underwriting. They're generally not embedded, so it's not as seamless as a process. There is stuff around the periphery, but there is no one at scale who is doing what we do in an embedded, automated way.
Makes a lot of sense. Sorry, jumping all over the place here, but.
It is all right.
We talked personal, auto, point of sale. Do not get me wrong, it sounds like there is plenty of growth opportunities over the near term, but beyond that, any other sort of asset classes you would consider? I am just thinking of student, credit card, home.
We see a ton of growth in our existing asset classes. And we see it sort of based on a partner-by-partner basis. We think there is a lot of white space in helping banks in the personal loan space. And auto, the nature of the auto partner ads are just very large and very chunky that obviously they take time to scale, but once scaled, it is sort of step function growth. Listen, though, we are in the consumer credit space, so credit cards remain a very interesting area for us. You have to be careful with how you enter that space.
I mean, we will obviously keep the partnership model. There is a ton of advantages to that. But over the next 12-24 months, I think you will see us begin to enter that market. I don't necessarily see it as a 2027 event, but I do think it is something that we will move into over time. There are other forms of point-of-sale lending that I could see us leaning into more. So we have some exposure today to home improvement lending. So that is not mortgage or HELOC. That is literally just financing an HV AC system or something for someone.
We think that is actually a very interesting space and growing. We could lean into a space like that more. But in terms of the most likely next asset class at scale, I see it as credit cards. Our bank network, sorry to belabor the point, but our bank network is also extremely pertinent to that, right? If we can help Barclays or U.S. Bank with their co-branded relationships, that hits a pain point that is like a classic conflict between a Citi and a Best Buy or someone like that. We think there is a real fit there for us.
That makes sense. Let's see here. You've been CFO for six months?
Yeah.
Okay. You did talk about improving the right side of the balance sheet in the third quarter. Any other plans on the right side of the balance sheet? Then I guess if we go to the left side of the balance sheet, just walk through your capital allocation priorities.
Yeah. I've been at Pagaya for about six years. I was in the Chief Strategy Officer role before this role. Especially when I started, at a younger growing company, strategy is sort of a euphemism for, We have problems here, here, and here. Do all of those things. Much of what I've done for the last three years has been rebuilding the liability side of our balance sheet. I did that in partnership with Evangelos, our CFO at the time, but I led those efforts. A couple years ago on the corporate side, we had a higher cost private credit loan. We turned that out into a high yield bond at a more attractive rate.
We now have a revolver with eight bank partners at a very attractive rate. So we've done a lot to kind of rightsize that piece of it. In terms of capital allocation, we continue, for a number of reasons, to see the discretionary investments in the B and BB rated mezzanine bonds and those securitizations as a very high return on capital investment. Again, on an unlevered basis, they're yielding us more than 11%, and they do improve the overall structure of the securitizations, which then supports the funding side of the business more broadly.
Over time, especially if our stock remains at these levels, I don't necessarily see it as a 2027 thing, but over time, buying back stock can become an option as well. But we see a lot of growth ahead of us.
That is great. I wanted to hit on this, running a little bit out of time, but I think this is obviously important. Just the operating leverage within the model, I think is a big highlight and kind of talk about how much you have been able to grow network volumes and REVs and what your expense base has done.
Yeah. So over the last, we have had seven straight consecutive GAAP net income quarters growing each quarter. Our core OPEX, so below that FRLPC, below that net fee line, has really not grown over that period. The reason for that is we have one variable cost, it is our production cost, which essentially is fees going back to lending partners. That is completely success-based, completely volume-based. Below FRLPC, everything is fixed. We do not have marketing costs because we are not direct to consumer. We probably overbuilt our technology org early on because we are a tech-centric business.
We spent a lot of money a few years ago on building up those risk and compliance teams, both because it is prudent from an underwriting point of view and it instills confidence in our target customers. However, we can continue scaling our current business, whether it is product-led or adding partners with that expense base. So in 2027, other than inflationary increases, we really do not see an increase in that necessary, and what that leads to is kind of an FRLPC flow through to net income that is 80% +.
Yes. Makes a lot of sense. I think we are just about out of time. I will start by thanking you. Thank you, Jon. Thank you, Craig, for attending. Thanks everyone for coming. I will let you close it out though. Anything investors might be overlooking or underappreciating?
I mean, there are definitely things that investors are overlooking because we're trading at $16. But, listen, we grow in a differentiated way. We don't spend marketing dollars. We don't have to increase or decrease the credit box for growth purposes. We do it for credit purposes. But we add applications by working with existing partners more, and we add new partners. And that can lead over time to step functions in growth, and you saw some of those step functions this year. Our value prop is really resonating. Being a key component of banks keeping depositors is a very strong, durable value prop.
Improving that dealer-lender relationship on the auto side is a very, very durable value prop. We have this growth with, as we just talked about, very stable OPEX, and we don't expect that. I'm just sort of polishing off the 2027 budgeting now. We see very similar OPEX numbers, and we have a diversified, increasingly longer term funded capital base. So, we have the components that you need for a compounding replicable business, and I'm just excited to be a part of it over the next couple years in this seat.
Great. Thank you.
Thanks.
Thank you.