🎁 Black Friday: 50% off Unlimited and 30% off Pro annual plans
Smurfit Westrock Plc (SW)
NYSE: SW · Real-Time Price · USD
38.02
-0.61 (-1.58%)
Nov 20, 2026, 1:25 PM EST - Market open
← View all transcripts

Earnings Call: Q3 2026

Oct 28, 2026

Summary

Q3 adjusted EBITDA was $1.205B as energy and freight inflation drove FY2026 guidance to about $4.7B. Price recovery is expected to strengthen through 2027, while the 2030 plan remains intact.

Operator

Today, and thank you for standing by. Welcome to the Smurfit Westrock 2026 Q3 results webcast and conference call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speaker's presentation, there will be a question-and-answer session. To ask a question during the session, you will need to press star one one on your telephone. You will then hear an automated message advising your hand is raised. To withdraw your question, please press star one and one again. Please be advised that today's conference is being recorded. I'd now like to hand the conference over to Ciaran Potts, Smurfit Westrock Group VP, Investor Relations. Please go ahead.

Ciaran Potts
Group VP of Investor Relations, Smurfit Westrock

Thank you, Sarah. As a reminder, statements in today's press release and presentation and the comments made by management during this call may be considered forward-looking statements. These statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause our actual results to differ materially from our expectations and projections. These risks and uncertainties include, but are not limited to, the factors identified in the earnings release and in our SEC filings. The company undertakes no obligation to revise any forward-looking statements. Today's remarks also refer to certain non-GAAP financial measures. Where applicable, reconciliations to the most comparable GAAP measures are included in today's earnings release and in the appendix to the accompanying presentation, which are available at investors.smurfitwestrock.com. Before I hand you over, please note that Tony and Ken are stepping away from the board this morning and rejoining after our call.

In the interest of time, I therefore request that you ask no more than two questions. I'll stay on the line should we have any technical issues in Brazil. I'll now hand you over to Tony Smurfit, CEO of Smurfit Westrock.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thank you, Ciaran. As Ciaran has just said, we're hosting today's call from our Três Barras mill in Brazil, Latin America's largest country, with a population of some 213 million people. Três Barras is a state-of-the-art kraftliner mill with an annual capacity of approximately 700,000 tons. This operation is a great example of successful investments of approximately $350 million over the last five years, delivering superior returns. It is integrated downstream into our Latin American box system, primarily in Brazil, Argentina, and soon-to-be Chile, and significantly integrated upstream into our sustainably sourced forestry operations. As you will have seen, we've announced third quarter adjusted EBITDA of $1,205 million, with an adjusted EBITDA margin of 14.8%. These results show great resilience in the face of unprecedented and greater- than- anticipated cost inflation, predominantly, but not limited to, energy and freight.

To counteract these cost increases, we have, by necessity, implemented price increases across most paper grades, which are being passed on with the normal time lag. The period was characterized by a number of one-off events, such as extreme heat waves in Europe, earthquakes in Colombia, and a significant contamination issue in the agricultural sector in the United States, affecting our volumes both there and in Mexico. Since the formation of Smurfit Westrock, I am incredibly proud of the many achievements we have accomplished, especially the way we have brought the two companies together and formed one culture. Operating in 40 countries, we have unified the company under one banner with the focus being the owner/operator model, which resonates and is well understood both internally and externally.

We have developed a strategic plan, which we presented to you in February, that takes the company to a different level through our own actions and investments to improve efficiency and our offering to our customer base. And we refocused the company at our end customer through innovation, quality, and service. Turning now to a regional overview. Our North American business continues to improve in most areas, although this improvement is masked by the amount of increased costs that we have incurred. The third quarter showed sequential improvement in our corrugated volumes with a continued and developing strong pipeline. Our people have embraced our new Smurfit Westrock performance-led and owner/operator culture, and this is reflected by our improvements across all customer service metrics and our attention and retention of talent.

Today, our mill system across practically all grades remains sold out, allowing for us to prioritize orders and improve our business mix. The real benefits of this will be apparent as we move into 2027. In our converting businesses, we are progressively getting better through continuous investments with teams of highly motivated people across both business areas of corrugated and consumer. As we roll out our innovation centers, we continue to benefit from our cross-selling opportunities as a major competitive advantage. In another business area, we have seen a large structural shift towards our paper bag and sack business, where we are the largest producer in the United States. Finally, while demand in our Mexican business is as weak as I have experienced it in recent years, our footprint is continually being strengthened by significant cost takeout initiatives and rationalization measures.

Now turning to our EMEA and APAC region, where we continue to outperform our integrated peers. Our innovative offering delivers solutions to our customers that help them navigate an increasingly complex regulatory environment, especially in Europe. By partnering with Smurfit Westrock, our customers take regulatory compliance as a given, solving a key supply chain issue for them. As in other regions, we have implemented paper price increases to recover costs, which are being progressively passed through. These increases are primarily a consequence of the spiraling cost of energy that has shown no signs of abatements during the year and is reaching levels that we have rarely seen. Over the last number of years, we have made many investments in both our mill system and conversion operations that have considerably improved our quality and service KPIs, giving us further competitive advantage.

Some of those investments are also targeted at continuing to reduce our cost base and drive operating efficiency, which have helped somewhat to offset some of the cost pressures we have seen this year. We have also continued to rationalize our footprint, making our asset base more efficient, which will enhance future returns. Our experienced management team in this region has the skill to both navigate the current difficult macro environment and continue to outperform. In Latin America, while the region faces many of the same challenges experienced in other regions, our returns, and in particular adjusted EBITDA margin, remain at excellent levels. We have strong market positions, a well-invested world-class asset base, together with, again, skilled and experienced operators.

We continue to look for ways to develop our offering in the region, and I was particularly happy to announce our agreement to acquire the world-class packaging assets of CMPC during the quarter. This acquisition will strengthen our position in both Chile and the wider region, as well as adding further paper integration to our system. Also, during the quarter, we started up our circa $100 million investment in our biomass boiler in Colombia, which is helping to offset energy price increases in that country. Paper prices are rising in the region as international shortages feed into the market. For the full year 2026, we now expect adjusted EBITDA margin of approximately $4.7 billion. This primarily reflects the unprecedented cost inflation we continue to experience across the business. Freight and energy costs alone are expected to represent approximately $700 million YoY headwind in 2026, materially above our earlier expectations.

As we move into 2027, we believe the actions we've taken during the year will more than offset these costs. What I'm most satisfied with is the great work that has been done across the organization in every region to improve efficiency, reduce our costs, further develop our innovation offering, and improve our asset base. As a truly global paper and packaging company with an unparalleled product portfolio and the widest geographical reach, it is ultimately our customers who benefit most from our extensive offering. As we develop the company through our investment program and through our culture, I am confident of the foundation we are building for 2027 and beyond. And with that, operator, we will hand it over to questions.

Operator

Thank you. If you would like to ask a question, you will need to press star one and one on your telephone and wait for your name to be announced. And to withdraw your question, please press star one and one again. We will now take the first question. This is from George Staphos from Bank of America. Please go ahead.

George Staphos
Analyst, Bank of America

Good morning, everybody. Good afternoon. Thanks for taking the question in detail. I am here with Reinhardt van der Walt in Europe. So, I guess two questions, Tony. First of all, can you talk about the progression on volumes in North America? At one point, you expect to be up at some point in the back half. Is that still the projection? Relatedly, I think you had a profit improvement in terms of the bridge from volume, even though volumes were down in third quarter in North America. How do we reconcile that? And then, second, given that energy and freight would seem to be largely a box-related expense, certainly it is going to affect both converting and production.

But the fact that you are seeing so much pressure on where you had the least amount of margin headroom to begin with in converting, does that change your philosophy in terms of how you try to push pricing and improve commercial terms over time? Thank you, and good luck in the quarter.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thank you very much, George. With regard to progression, as I said that we expected either in the third or the fourth quarter that we would start to be there or thereabouts with the previous year. Obviously, the third quarter has been very heavily impacted by this Cyclospora. I have to remember the name of it.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Cyclospora.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Cyclospora and the E. coli situation that affected our agricultural region very significantly. And, you know, I think from the good news point of view is, and one swallow doesn't make a summer, but for October, we are line ball with last year, and it looks like our order books are reasonably good for November at this stage. So, I mean, again, as I say, one swallow doesn't make a summer, but I do think that we have, you know, our progress each quarter has been a bit better. And as we see the volumes that we gave up last year come out of our business and the comparisons becoming easier, we would say that we are going to be there or thereabouts in Q4 with, unless something happens with regard to the market that we don't expect. So, I think the progression is as we expected.

What I'm very encouraged about, honestly, George, is when I see the customer wins we're having. They're smaller in number, they're smaller in size than when you lose one of the big ones, and it takes a lot of them to replace a big one, but they are, you know, our quality and service levels have improved very significantly. Our attitude because of the owner/operator model, is very well- liked by our customers and liked by our internal people and our innovation offering as we start to roll that out is really a very big positive. So, I see, you know, us getting, you know, going where we want to go to, maybe sometimes a little bit slower because the underlying market is not as strong as we would have liked, b ut overall, I think it's going exactly as we would have anticipated. With regard to your bridges, I'll hand it over to Ken.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Hey, morning, George. Morning, Reinhardt. Yeah, keep it simple, George. The net positive volume in North America is, r emember, we have a lot of third-party sales, so the positive growth you're seeing there is around third-party paper sales.

George Staphos
Analyst, Bank of America

Okay. And then, on the pricing and the pressure seeing in converting.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Yeah. On the converting, I mean, I wouldn't say there's anything different. We are having to go to our customers and sort of recognize the fact that we've got other costs than just paper. And clearly, we have to recover those as we go through the year and either through negotiation or through making sure that we have a special tag on for certain customers. So, there's nothing. We're continuing to develop our margins in our corrugated business. We have reduced our loss makers very considerably. I think we're less than 30 loss makers. And some of them, it's a bit difficult when the paper price goes up. Obviously, there's a period of time where the corrugated operations slip backwards because they have to go into the market and get those paper prices up to see where we are right now.

But overall, I think that we are making very good commercial progress across the business, and I am really happy with our commercial team and the customer wins they are winning and getting pricing going forward.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

And George, I think you can see that George a little bit if you look at the North American margin quarter one, two, and three, you see progression on the margin build there. Equally, you know, while we are dealing with the normal time lag, you can see progression on pricing also. So, sequentially, quarter two into quarter three, North American pricing up about 5%, and in Europe, equally, pricing up about 2%, quarter two to quarter three. So, the impact of the price increases from paper to box is beginning to take hold. As Tony said in his prepared remarks , you know, really setting that foundation for 2027. So, the actions we are doing are still on track, so no change to philosophy on that then.

George Staphos
Analyst, Bank of America

All right. Tell everybody [crosstalk].

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

George, we would love it to be quicker, but, you know, the reality is that, you know, we are being whacked by these massive cost increases in energy that we are going to get back. As you know, we announced the EUR 100/ ton increase. The publication recognized EUR 70 of that, and obviously, from our perspective, we would have expected to get EUR 100, but we will wait and see what happens going forward.

George Staphos
Analyst, Bank of America

Understood. Enjoy the trip. See you soon.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thank you.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Thanks, George.

Operator

Thank you. We will take the next question today. This is from Hillary Cacanando from Deutsche Bank Securities. Please go ahead.

Hillary Cacanando
Analyst, Deutsche Bank Securities

Hi. Thank you for taking my question. Just going back to the North American converting business. Last quarter, you mentioned that, you know, corrugating converting margins were roughly 3%-4%. Can you update us on where that converting margins stand today?

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

It's a little bit lower than that now, Hillary, because we take in the paper price into our converting business. We transfer at the market price, so therefore, it will be a little bit less than the 2% number now because we have to then go to the market and get that increase into our box system. But the underlying trend of margin improvement within our corrugated business is quite significant, and you will see that as we go into Q1 and Q2 of next year as we pass through this latest paper price increase.

Hillary Cacanando
Analyst, Deutsche Bank Securities

Got it. Thanks, Tony. And then, as a follow-up, you know, with 2026 EBITDA now expected at roughly $4.7 billion, how should we think about that lower starting point relative to the medium-term plan? Is the shortfall predominantly timing around price cost recovery, such that the underlying 2030 earnings opportunity is largely unchanged? How should we think about that relative to the 2030 plan?

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Hi, Hillary. It's Ken here. Yeah, essentially, it's timing. In reality, the plan was set up to bring us from call it 2026 to 2030. Nothing within the plan from a structural perspective has changed. And if you recall when we talked in February, that plan was largely built on internal actions and a lot of kind of internal opportunities that we had to kind of get through, like kind of working through the unprofitable contracts and getting some positive volume growth in North America, for example. So, pricing wasn't necessarily part of that kind of proposition, if you like. But clearly, the backdrop in cost for 2026 has kind of impacted the timing, but not the recovery or achievement of the targets, but only the timing in terms of when we get there. But the 2030 target is still bang on in terms of timing.

It will just be kind of a flex in between the ears with how we get there.

Hillary Cacanando
Analyst, Deutsche Bank Securities

Great. So, no change to 2030 plan. Great. Thank you so much.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Thanks, Hillary.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thanks, Hillary.

Operator

Thank you. We will now take the next question. This is from Phil Ng from Jefferies. Please go ahead. Phil Ng from Jefferies, your line is open. Please ask your question.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

We can come back to him, Sarah.

Operator

Sure. Let's move on to the next question. This is from Mike Roxland from Truist Securities. Please go ahead.

Mike Roxland
Analyst, Truist Securities

Yeah. Thank you, Tony, Ken, Ciaran, and team for taking my questions. First one I had, the industry has gotten about $170/ ton of price this year. Of that amount, how much do you estimate is for cost recovery versus margin for you guys in particular?

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

I would say that the first $100 is really just basically recovering the cost. You know, obviously, Mike, the cost thing is a moving target, as you have seen from our numbers, because when we were here three months ago, we did not expect TTF gas to be at $97 or $98 as it is this morning, nor did we expect diesel to be where it is or some of these other energy costs. We would have thought that the first 100 would have had some margin improvement in it. But clearly, I would say the vast majority of that has been gone in these current high prices. As we translate the other increases through the more recent increases, that would probably be all margin enhancement, I would say, broadly speaking.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Yeah, and I think as Tony kind of referenced it there, the July increases, that $100/ ton we put back end of July, I think up to that point, the increases to that date would have really dealt with the cost recovery piece and probably a bit of recovery on margin. That $100 would have overcome any remaining piece, but also purely margin. But as Tony just said, since then, clearly, the cost backdrop has continued to be elevated and unanticipated. Still, a lot of cost with a bit of margin in there, but probably again, pushing out the timing slightly in terms of 2027 versus where it might have been, but still on track.

Mike Roxland
Analyst, Truist Securities

Got it. Very clear. Just one, when you think about 2027, in terms of EBITDA, given the lower stepping off point, can you provide us with an initial peek at what you are expecting in terms of either demand, maybe some of the larger buckets or guideposts around what is going to drive EBITDA next year? Thanks.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Mike, we have not done our budgets yet. So, you know, I do know that our guys are very comfortable and confident that our numbers will be, you know, significantly better based upon the run rate that we are going to come out of last year. But we have not actually got to do our budgets yet. We are doing those next week. But I would say that we're still, the early view is that we are very comfortable and confident that next year will be a very good year for us if everything stays relatively where it is today. I mean, clearly, there is still a lot of uncertainty in the world, and i f we have some relief on cost, then that will be very positive to us. But equally, if we do not have relief on costs, you know, we will have to look again as to what actions we might take to mitigate those costs as we go into Q1, Q2 next year.

Mike Roxland
Analyst, Truist Securities

Understood. Thank you.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thanks, Mike.

Operator

Thank you. Next question today is from Mark Weintraub from Seaport Research Partners. Please go ahead.

Mark Weintraub
Analyst, Seaport Research Partners

Great. Thanks very much. Obviously, we are in a pretty extraordinary period from a cost standpoint. So, I was just hoping if we could maybe get a little more color on some of the sensitivities and things like hedging, as well as the timing on price recovery as you roll containerboard through into boxes in the different regions. It was kind of the big-picture stuff. I would not normally be asking this, but again, we are in a really volatile market, and it is hard for us on the outside to get our arms around some of the timing, in particular, around these items.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Yeah. We have said that we expect to get the full cost recovery of the latest increase, you know, in Q1 of next year. And all of the paper price increases as we deal with some of the earlier-taken orders, as we get rid of those out of our system, those will translate into much higher export prices. You know, we talked, I mentioned in my script that, you know, we see very strong paper bag business that is growing very strongly because of some structural shifts. So, all of that will start to feed through into later in this quarter. All the paper stuff later in this quarter, but really strongly into early next year. So, as we go through Q1, Q2, we should start to see material increases in our numbers based upon these increases that will be passed from corrugated into, sorry, from paper into corrugated and into export markets and into other grades of paper.

And that is the normal, that it would be a normal situation for us. Europe has been a little bit more volatile in up and down pricing. And so, this is completely normal for the European business to have this time lag period. Obviously, when prices go down, that is also a benefit for the company holding onto margin. So, we are not seeing anything different other than the fact that if costs, as you say, Mark, it is a time when all of us are dealing with these escalating costs. If they continue to escalate, we will have to do something about it because clearly, they are affecting our numbers, and we need to recover. So, Q1 will be, you know, a continuing benefit from what we have seen in the announcement of the $70. And then, we will keep an eye on what we have to do based upon costs.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Hey, Mark, it is Ken here. I think, in overcomplicating either sensitivities on energy or freight, I think when we think about energy and hedging, clearly, coming into the year and where prices were, we still had a decent bit of hedging in the tank. Clearly, at these levels, we have taken a different view across the year. We have stepped into the market every now and again when the price has come to a level where we think it makes sense to hedge, b ut not hedging at these kinds of levels because, in reality, that can go against you if the price drops. So, the energy committees in both North America and Europe, and indeed Latin America, have been smart about how they have incrementally added small hedges along the way.

But we would not be at the levels where we would normally be, and that is clearly as a function of the market and where we see costs. But clearly, that is why the price increase we have announced on paper in both regions, you know, net $170 in North America, net EUR 140 in Europe, are designed to kind of take account of that situation too. But still a level of hedging, but not at the levels we would like, and the ranges would be quite wide in terms of the spot prices for that. So, we look at the forward curve equally. You would not be stepping into this market given where the forward curves for energy are. I think on the freight side, probably the most meaningful sensitivity for you, is around where diesel sits for us.

So, we kind of estimate that kind of every dollar on diesel probably has a direct impact to the business of something like $80 million. But then when you add in the downstream impact of that through the rest of the system, that is probably more like kind of $120 million- $130 million in total impact for the year for a North American system. That is probably the most meaningful sensitivity for that region versus, say, energy for Europe.

Mark Weintraub
Analyst, Seaport Research Partners

Super. That is super. And Ken, could you give us the sensitivity to nat gas in Europe, either how much you are consuming or similar to like the dollar translates into X million dollars? What it would be for Europe.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

It is a trickier proposition given the fact that we do a lot of our own internals through CHPs and our own kind of takeoff. It is a much trickier. What I will do is, Mark, I think we will deal with that one separately because it is a much deeper modeling question, given you cannot take the total energy piece and kind of model it out. It has a lot of kind of moving parts around internal energy, where we use renewables, how we step into renewables, the CHP and the corrugated systems. It is quite a different, more detailed answer, if that is okay.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

I think, Mark, it is very interesting. Like, you know, at the current levels, you know, just put into an American context, the TTF is about $30/ MMBtu for natural gas in Europe and in North America, it is call it $3. So, it is a 10:1 ratio for the European industry. And, you know, like, the reason why we are getting paper price increases in Europe is not because of the capacity situation. There is a lot of people that actually cannot afford to run the mills, and, you know, that is why the prices are absolutely necessary. And if this continues, there will obviously have to be other actions, either by closures or other pricing actions, because there is just no way that at these cost levels, that our European industry in paper, but also many European industries, will be able to continue to operate in any way profitably.

So, obviously from our perspective, we have our kraftliner mills which don't use as much gas and generate themselves. So, it's making them very profitable. As we get these box paper price increases, we have to pass them on through the box system which we will be doing and are doing. You already see the prices moving up in Europe step by step, and we'll start to see a big benefit of that in Q1 as we go into, as we pass through the contractual price increases that we have.

Mark Weintraub
Analyst, Seaport Research Partners

Appreciate the color. Thank you.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thanks, Mark.

Operator

Thank you. Next question comes from Anthony Pettinari from Citigroup. Please go ahead.

Anthony Pettinari
Analyst, Citigroup

Good morning.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Hey, Anthony.

Anthony Pettinari
Analyst, Citigroup

Tony. Hey. In North America, I think you indicated you are sold out in most consumer grades, and I am wondering if you could give any more detail on where the consumer business is in terms of cost recovery or just sort of overall performance versus expectations. You know, I guess we have gotten these hikes in containerboard, but in consumer, we have not necessarily seen the same kind of pricing traction. So, I am just kind of wondering if you can comment on that.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Yeah. On consumer, I would say that it is steady as she goes on the CUK market. That is carrier board market. There has not been any real decreases, nor has there been any real increases there. We had a look at that way back when, and it did not seem like the right time. SBS, as you remember, went down about $100. We are in the market with increases currently and we are sold out in that grade, so therefore we believe that it merits some increases to get more than back what we lost there in the last quarter of last year as we move into next year, as we move into 2027. So, that is a very strong grade for us. We have a very differentiated offering.

We are a little bit in the commodity side of that business, but we tend not to try and be in all the commodity side of that business in plate stock and cup stock. We've got some specific areas which we've grown, and as we've talked about before, we've made some switches away from CRB to SBS and indeed to CUK with customers and giving them benefit for that. So, I think, you know, I feel good about the SBS market right now, the way that we're positioned at least. Then, the CRB market, you know, we don't have, our mills are not the strongest in that area. We continue to be an alternative supplier for customers and our own internal usage. And that's an area which we don't necessarily see. When I talk about most grades, that's the one area that we don't really see any pricing momentum.

You'll know the reasons why that is, Anthony.

Anthony Pettinari
Analyst, Citigroup

Okay. Yeah.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Hey, Ken here. I think to follow on from that too, at the converting end in terms of consumer, we've seen reasonable progress in terms of volumes Q3 over last year. For food and beverage, broadly flat, but most pleasingly probably in our [inaudible] segment, you know, broadly, volumes up about 2% YoY. So, it's going to align that kind of sell position on most of the consumer grade forward wise, but also seeing progress in terms of volumes on the converting side is equally pleasing.

Anthony Pettinari
Analyst, Citigroup

Okay. That's very helpful. Then, just a quick follow-up on Europe and kind of your response to Mark's question. You know, given the spike in energy and freight and I'd imagine some volume pressure for the industry, are you seeing changes in industry supply demand in terms of supply coming off? Has that, I guess, has it surprised you that you haven't seen more supply come off? I'm just wondering if you can give any kind of general commentary on supply- demand situation in Europe and what's obviously kind of a stressed environment.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

I think it's inevitable that it will happen. I think we've seen a lot of people taking a lot of downtime because obviously, if you're going into the market and selling at the old prices, you're losing a lot of money on every ton. And as this price continues to rise for energy, then you're going to see continued stress, either through downtime. As you know, Anthony, in Europe, governments don't like to see paper mills shut down, so they try and keep them open as long as possible, and they give all sorts of subsidies and help. You'll have seen some of our competitors announce their results and they're making zero EBITDA on brand new assets. So, the question is how long they can continue to do that for, and, you know, I don't have an answer to that because there is often government support that keeps them going.

But inevitably, if the economics will trump out, then there will be some closures at these levels.

Anthony Pettinari
Analyst, Citigroup

Okay. That's very helpful. I'll turn it over.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thanks, Anthony.

Operator

Thank you. Next question is from Andrew Jones from UBS. Please go ahead.

Andrew Jones
Analyst, UBS

Hi, gents.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Hey, Andrew.

Andrew Jones
Analyst, UBS

Thanks. Thanks for the color. I just wanted to ask about the situation in Europe. We've had large price hikes, obviously driven by that cost pressure that you've mentioned, but I am curious what your thoughts are on as we go into the next year, some of this new capacity is coming online in Italy and obviously that Shotton mill in the U.K. I mean, are you seeing pricing sort of holding if the current cost environment lasts, or do you think that we are going to start to see some pressure as we go into 2027?

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

I think, morning, Andy. Ken here. I think the reality is that, you know, of all the new capacity coming on, they are all people who have skin in the game already, if you like, in terms of a system in play. So, you got to think about this from kind of a pure capital allocation perspective, or at least I would, in the sense that it wouldn't make any sense logically, you know, to be kind of trying to capture volume for a new mill on lowering price given the amount of capital that it takes either to convert these mills or indeed start up a new one.

So, for like the Shotton one you mentioned there, or even the Palm mill equally in the U.K. in the early part of next year, you would have to assume a kind of similar logic or pattern that we have seen in the last number of years, which is around, you know, Tony has referenced downtime, prioritizing maybe downtime in a mill system over reducing price in order to kind of make sure that the returns stay reasonable because irrespective of how you might want to fill a mill, the firing of the mills, the energy cost of those mills, and indeed trying to find a market in a kind of a okay kind of demand environment will all impact the overall return. And ultimately, it comes down to the ability to generate cash flow to be successful. So, I think we have seen in Europe two things happen over the last number of years.

One, it may have predominance to kind of take additional downtime in order to manage that kind of market better than it might have done before, but equally, the lack of independent players means that idea of a rogue mill trying to capture new volume on price is not really there anymore. It is a lot of systems who have a bigger game to play in the context of how they manage overall market share.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Yeah, I think Andy, Ken just made a good point. There are two very large independents have gone out of the markets, one to Saica and one to Mondi in Germany, Schumacher and Thimm Group.

So, the independent market per se is shrinking, so therefore independent mills that are coming into the market like the two that Ken has mentioned, have a less and less market to go for other than they go for export, and that's a road to perdition really. So, I think you'll find that for them to be chopping pricing will be, as I say, it will be a disaster for them. And you see that already with one of the larger competitors in the free-market competitors who makes nothing in their containerboard system. And that's before the recent price rises. So, I think, I worry less about that than how the energy price affects the demand outlook for our end customers. That's something that we don't obviously have a crystal ball on. But so far, at least because of our offering in Europe, we've grown this year.

We continue to see in October reasonably good growth in October. I'm very comfortable with our own system. But the overall environment, how energy affects Europe, is something that we have to think about at least.

Andrew Jones
Analyst, UBS

Yeah. Okay. That's fairly clear. Thanks a lot.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thanks, Andy.

Operator

Thank you. The next question comes from Detlef Winckelmann from JPMorgan. Please go ahead.

Detlef Winckelmann
Analyst, JPMorgan

Morning, everyone. Maybe my first question, you did call out, I think you said something to the effect that, look, price increases always lagged. Cost inflation has come first, that's fine. But over the next, on an annualized basis, price cost is firmly positive, or price will more than offset cost inflation. Just curious, is that only on the North American side, or should we be thinking the same thing in Europe as well, just after considering your kind of kraftliner kind of mix in there and the energy efficiency, that kind of side on that as well, please? Then, I've got a follow-up, please.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Hey, Detlef. It's Ken. Morning. No, you should assume that for all regions. The mechanism, if you like, in terms of paper price increase into the index or indeed the freedom negotiated is probably slightly quicker in North America than Europe by a couple of months. But ultimately, it's exactly the same pattern. And indeed, in Latin America, you'd argue maybe even quicker again, given it's a region that generally deals with inflation quite well. So no, there's a pattern in terms of normal time lags that we talk about very similar for North America and Europe. And given the level of index versus non-index is probably slightly higher in North America, you tend to get it through quicker, but overall, you end up in the same place.

Detlef Winckelmann
Analyst, JPMorgan

Okay, cool. Then, one more follow-up just on Europe. You know, we've been hearing in the last couple company releases that there's a bit of discounting downstream at the box plant level. It does seem to be isolated to certain regions. But just curious, are you seeing anything of that sort that could hurt you down the line as you pass on the price increase through to box prices?

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

I mean, there is one player particularly that is trying to get a little bit of volume, and so that has created some noise in the market. But overall, I would say, I wouldn't say it's that much different to any other pricing environment where people are struggling and trying to get some volume. I wouldn't say it's a particular massively different situation to what it normally is. But, you know, there are some players that try and use these times to get some volume in the downstream market, and, you know, you have to, you know, because of your quality service. I mean, when you look at the quality and service that we bring to our customers and the complexity we deal for them and look after for them, you know, we expect to get paid for that, and clearly, our whole innovation offering is making a difference. So, I wouldn't worry too much about that per se, Detlef.

Detlef Winckelmann
Analyst, JPMorgan

Cool. Thank you.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Next question is from Lewis Roxburgh from Goodbody. Please go ahead.

Lewis Roxburgh
Analyst, Goodbody

My question is on holding onto pricing. So, cost and energy inflation has clearly been challenging, but it will turn at some point. So, I guess what degree do you believe that you will have to give pricing back as Europe in particular more vulnerable to that given the oversupply and containerboard and energy security and comparably is the U.S. and LATAM in a better place given the industry consolidation tight supply, et cetera?

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Yeah, I think that is a fair characterization, Lewis. If all of a sudden energy was to fall back, I think that it would put more pressure on the European containerboard price. But I do not think that will be the case per se in Latin America or the United States or the North American market. I think the structural change that has happened in North America has been very significant. As I say, we have been in a sold-out position for the last number of months, and we have still orders to fulfill from April and May. So, you know, I have no idea about the others, but I assume they are in the same sort of situation.

And we have a window into Latin America, and while Latin American customers tend to have larger supplies, you know, prices are going up in Latin America, and that is going to feed into a better situation next year and beyond irrespective. So, unless something really bad happens in the world, I think that your statement is correct.

Lewis Roxburgh
Analyst, Goodbody

Yeah, that is clear. Thanks.

Operator

Thank you.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thank you.

Operator

Next question, we are going to retry the line for Phil Ng from Jefferies. Please go ahead. Your line is open.

Phil Ng
Analyst, Jefferies

Hey, guys. Sorry about that. I had some technical issues this morning. Tony, if you addressed this already, I apologize in advance. I think, Ken, you were talking about earlier the question that in Europe, you feel pretty good that your box prices would catch up to containerboard pricing, you would offset inflation. I guess the one variable that would be helpful to kind of give us some color is nat gas hedges just because you had some hedges. So, based on what you have in place and your traction you are seeing, how do you feel about that dynamic, and how should we think about that hitting your P&L and your ability to kind of be on a positive spread next year?

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Hey, Phil. The price increases we announced, so that net $140 on testliner would have ultimately taken into account a lot of what we have done on hedging. And in effect, generally, the hedging would be a net incremental positive to anything you do on that paper price. There is no incremental P&L hit in that sense. They are not futures. Ultimately, you are just contracting gas at kind of standard set prices rather than spot in that sense. So, everything we have done and built around price increases around testliner, particularly in Europe, takes into account where we sit in the hedging curve. Generally, a conservative view on where that might go. But always with the idea that hedging plus the price increase should land you in a slightly better position overall at the end of the game. So, in reality, not that the hedging does not necessarily matter in that sense.

It always acts as a better moderator or better basis in terms of how you get through in terms of full margin recovery. But the price increases do take account of all the hedging we have and had in place indeed for these two.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

I would just add some color to that, Phil. We would not hedge at these levels because if the energy price falls backwards in a hurry and you are stuck at $100, you are going to be really seriously uncompetitive for a period of time. We just think that it would be, and we do not believe that anyone in the industry, to any great extent, is hedging at these levels because they are so remarkable that nobody would have actually ever anticipated that the gas could get to this level. Now, people would be very afraid, like us, that if you hedge at these levels, you could get caught with your pants down. So, we are not going to be in that situation. And we will ride it.

As I say, if it stays at these levels, either there will be a lot of downtime, or there will be further increases, or there will be closures because it just cannot, you know, y ou are a 10:1 ratio versus the United States on gas, which is just unsustainable for European industry.

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Because you know what, you have to step back. Phil, really, what you are thinking about in the context where hedging sits in an integrated system like Europe, which is broadly 100% integrated, it is about cost certainty at the mill site that you do not, as Tony says, get trapped on one side or the other of that kind of hedging curve. If you go back to kind of very high prices of energy back in 2021, 2022, equally, we would have stepped out of the hedging market while that happened and then brought back in when we needed. So, it is about through an integrated model, it really is about cost certainty at the start and recover at the end. So, hedging tends to be a bit of effect in the middle. It has been a wonderful friend in the past, and it will be in the future.

At the moment, though, as Tony says, it is not a place to go.

Phil Ng
Analyst, Jefferies

Okay. Helpful color. I guess bigger picture, Tony, you have owned the Westrock asset for some time now. In terms of your journey, in terms of some of the goalposts that you would want to call out and things that you still want to work on as we think about 2027 and beyond, what are some of the things you want to highlight? It might be your customer mix in terms of the mix of regional versus national, but anything that you just call out, just because obviously, profitability has been masked a bit by the inflation. So, just kind of give us some goalposts where you are and what are some of the next things we should look forward to as we look out to 2027 and beyond.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Yeah, I think, Phil, that is a really great question. I mean, I am sitting in the Três Barras mill down in Brazil, so just take it by region. Take our Latin American region. This is one of the most, one of the world's great assets, and with great management team and continuing to grow and have great ideas for the future. So, if I look around our Latin American business, really strong, great, th e Westrock combination between the two. I will give you a very good example because I was here yesterday. You know, they used to have a huge side reel issue in this mill that they would sell at heavily discounted prices. Because of the combination, we now no longer have a side reel issue in this mill, so we are able to run full out and get full contribution for all of the paper that we make. It has made this mill much more profitable.

That is just one small example. In our European business, the combination, there were no corrugated assets, but the consumer business has improved radically in Europe and has really set for a very strong growth together with our corrugated business as we move to the owner/operator model and has been a really successful combination. When you look to the North American market, what I would say the most pleasing thing for me has been how the management team have really adopted what we talk about as being the owner/operator model. They are very enthusiastic. We are seeing customer wins in the corrugated area. Our consumer business, our end market consumer margins are not where we want them to be, but we will get there because the teams, the plants are in very good shape. The teams are very well organized.

So, we will progressively move that margin up without anything to do with the underlying paper pricing as we refocus that business in the future. If you take our mill system, what I would say is we have some really great mills, and we have some mills that continue to need work. Once we fix those mills that need work, then the mill system will be as good as any that we have anywhere else in the world. So, our mill system is progressing. We have got a whole new management team there that is really moving things forward in a positive way. We have recruited some great people into the business. So, our people aspect of North America has really progressed very strongly. So, if you say, why am I excited? Because I can see the potential of this business.

But of course, I am really frustrated by the fact that we are making all this progress, and it is not easy for anyone to see because when you get $700 million of unexpected costs, you start to go, you are scratching your head a little bit to say, "Okay, we need to recover that." We do, but it is pushing the game forward, which is never where we want to be. We want to be winning from the front rather than trying to catch up. But we are where we are because we do not have control over things outside of our control. But I am very excited about the future of this company and the combination of this company because it is going to be very powerful in the years ahead.

Phil Ng
Analyst, Jefferies

Okay. Appreciate the color. Thank you so much.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thank you very much, Phil.

Operator

Thank you. And the final question today comes from Pallav Mittal from Barclays. Please go ahead.

Pallav Mittal
Analyst, Barclays

Hi. Thanks for taking my questions, a couple of them. Firstly, clearly, energy and freight costs are much higher than what we were expecting three months ago, and you have said hedging levels are low for very obvious reasons. If we assume our spot rates and things stay this way, how much of an increase are energy and freight costs expected to be in 2027 versus 2026?

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

Pallav, I haven't got there yet. It's back to, you know, we haven't gotten near a budget yet. I think we have to kind of s ee that in the round where we think all those forward curves are. But I wouldn't, given if you like, my forecasting in energy and freight for this year has been kind of changeable as we go through the year. I'm not sure I'd sit here yet and forecast energy and freight for next year. I think our opening assumption would be, at some point, that cost factor has to abate slightly. But for the moment, I couldn't give you a view on freight or energy for 2027.

Pallav Mittal
Analyst, Barclays

Sure. And then, if I could just check on CapEx. It seems that you've lowered your guidance by $150 million or so for 2026. Can you just help us understand what has changed there, and does it mean that 2027 CapEx goes up slightly?

Ken Bowles
EVP and CFO and Director, Smurfit Westrock

No, not really. We decided to just slow back a little bit because when we took our number down for last quarter, we said we'll just get the money back in our CapEx. But our plans are still the same. It will probably mean that 2031 will have $150 million more or 2032. We haven't stopped anything that we need to do. It's just that we've delayed a couple of projects by a number of months. There's nothing of interest there.

Pallav Mittal
Analyst, Barclays

Sure. If I can just squeeze one on Europe, a quick one. You said the growth has been good in October. Can you just help us understand how your order books are looking for the near future?

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Well, in the very near future, we're actually okay. As I said, in North America, this month, as in October, we will be line ball with last year. I don't want to predict that that's going to be the same in November and December, but November feels okay. We have a large election happening in November, so we'll have to see how that plays out to demand in North America. I think that Europe, we expect to have a, w e're a couple of percent up on the same-day basis during the month of October. So, we hope that trend continues for the rest of the quarter, but we don't expect anything for it not to. Latin America, we have seen weakness in Brazil, actually, during the last couple of months as the uncertainty of the election down here fed into the marketplace, and it hasn't hurt our profitability.

But the demand levels were not where we would have expected in the last three months in Brazil. But still, as I say, it hasn't affected our profitability, and we're still very well-positioned in the country.

Pallav Mittal
Analyst, Barclays

Amazing. Thank you.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Thanks, Pallav.

Operator

Thank you. There are no further questions, so I will now hand back to Tony Smurfit for any closing comments.

Tony Smurfit
CEO, Smurfit Westrock

Yeah. Thank you, operator. As I mentioned on the call, you know, I remain incredibly excited about the future of this company. We have done a lot during the last couple of years, and obviously, we are not happy with the fact that we have absorbed so much cost so quickly during the last three months and into the next two months. So, obviously, that has affected our results. But we are in the process of recovering those costs, and we look forward to 2027 with great confidence, and we appreciate your support, and we appreciate the time you have given us today. Thank you all for being with us, and we look forward to catching up with you either in person or on the next conference call. And if we do not speak to you before year- end, we wish you a very happy Christmas and New Year.

I know it sounds a little bit early to be saying that, but nonetheless, good luck in case I do not speak to you.

Operator

Thank you. This concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating, and you may now disconnect. Speakers, please stand by.