Good. Welcome back from lunch, everyone. I'm Rishi Jaluria. I cover software and occasionally digital media as well here at RBC. I'm delighted to have with me mainstay of this conference. We've got Vivek Shah, who's the CEO, and Bret Richter, who's the CFO of Ziff Davis. Gentlemen, thank you so much for being here.
It's great to be here.
Maybe let's start with just a little bit. Look, I always say Ziff Davis is probably one of the more complicated companies in my coverage, especially relative to market cap. Maybe just give a little bit of a brief overview for who you are.
Yeah
Kind of the story from here, and obviously helpful for the brands that are household names that everyone doesn't know that you guys own that you do. Maybe let's start there.
Yeah. So, at a high level, we're a digital media and internet company. We are highly acquisitive, or historically have been highly acquisitive, so the entire portfolio was built through acquisitions. We operate in a handful of verticals, which I'm sure we'll talk about. We make money really three ways: advertising, subscriptions, and licensing. So, not that complicated.
And obviously dealing, which I'm sure we're going to talk about, with a lot of issues around search and content and discovery, et cetera.
Yeah, absolutely. That sounds great. Maybe let's start with kind of the big story with Ziff Davis this year, which is you had this big sale of the Connectivity business.
Yep
to Accenture. I think it was at a time where if anyone did any reasonable sum of the parts on you, it was very clear that there was a massive disconnect between where Ziff Davis was trading and what the value of all the assets were, so it was a great unlock. Maybe can you talk about the appetite to transact? What's kind of gating it from here? You've said that you're a little bit more open to these. Is it around the inbound offers? Is it your own kind of internal math, and how valuable do you think the assets may be themselves? Maybe walk us through that.
Yeah. Look, I think for the longest time, we were sort of a forever hold mindset.
Yeah.
We would do acquisitions, we'd identify opportunities, we'd look for ways to create value to improve these businesses, and we would continue to compound through that. It wasn't really until 2021 where we saw an opportunity to do a transaction to really unlock value, and that was the spin-off of a business at the time called Consensus. That was somewhat eye-opening. That was a big value unlock for our shareholders because a similar thing had developed where we felt that the value of the company in the markets wasn't reflected by the underlying value of the assets, and so we did something. Similarly, this year with the sale of the Connectivity business to Accenture, same thing. What I would say to you is, the first thing is I think we're very rational, we're not sentimental. We view it as a portfolio.
We view it as if we see opportunities to sell assets or to enter into transactions that are going to unlock value, we'll do it. To us, it's almost pure math, right? If we find ourselves in an opportunity where the value of the business in that transaction is a meaningful premium-
Yeah
over the imputed value of that business in the public market, we're going to do something about that. I think it was a great transaction for us. What I would say is that we're open. We've been very public about being open, and so we'll entertain transactions or we'll entertain inbound interest.
Yeah. Okay. I want to get to some of this, you hinted on this in your opening piece, on some of the search headwinds that we've been seeing. Obviously no secret, this is a broad base we've seen in my software coverage. Google themselves has talked about that. Maybe can you help us understand? You've seen organic Google referrals down, I think you said 37% year-over-year, not expecting that to rebound anytime soon. Can you maybe walk us through some of those headwinds? We'll get into the off-platform monetization as well, but just how are you navigating that? What's kind of the best way to help stabilize at least the loss that you're going to get there?
Take a step back and just explain the loss. As Google has reported, their queries are at a five-year high. People are using Google and they're using search engines. That hasn't changed. They're not clicking as much.
The value per search has gone down. We're feeling that, but everyone in the search ecosystem is feeling that. I will also say it's happened at a pace that I think is somewhat surprising.
Over the last two years, that 37% figure is more like 50% for us. What I've said is I don't think that's changing. I don't think that I think what's happened is users have clearly indicated that they'll do a query. The AI Overview answer may be enough. If it's not enough, they'll go into AI Mode, which is right there, re-query, and get to an answer. Clicking to the underlying source is becoming less and less an activity. We have to plan for that and expect that and not expect any change there. For us, it's a few things. First is, not the entirety of our business is based on web traffic, not the entirety of our web traffic is search.
I think we're diversified across our portfolio in terms of web traffic versus non-web traffic, and even within web traffic-oriented businesses, the percentages vary in terms of how much relies on search. But then also really leaning into social platforms, leaning into inbox, leaning into apps and other ways of reaching audiences, and I'm sure we'll talk about that, but those are the offsets. We're playing right now is trying to manage the headwinds related to search and accelerate the revenue opportunities that are presented outside of search in those areas.
Yeah, absolutely. Let's dive into that in a second, but maybe just to round it out, because you brought up the AI search overviews, and we're obviously seeing this big shift from SEO to whatever you want to call it, GEO, AEO.
Yeah
Whatever terminology out there. But you are talking about the amount that your content's been cited. I think you said 2.7 billion times in Q3. Number one, just obviously you are a source of truth for these AI search overviews.
Yep.
How does that eventually translate into monetization? Is that something that's showing up in RFP conversations today?
Let me explain the 2.7 billion. That is last quarter, that is the number of times an article of ours was cited in a Google AIO answer. This is not all of AI, this is very specifically Google, but it is a very large number. Certainly a very large number in relation to the clicks we would historically get. I think it is 10X higher. The good news is we are actively cited, and that should not be surprising because we own brands that have a great deal of authority and trust and history, and it is great to see and recognized within that system. Obviously, we need to figure out how we get compensated for that if we are not getting a direct referral back, and that is something that we are actively working on as an organization, and I think as an industry. Yet to answer your question, yes.
Marketers themselves are saying, "Look, we want to be affiliated with trusted brands. We want to be in environments where there is truth and where there is journalism." There is that element of it too, and then the brands are also looking to work with us to help their own AI visibility.
Yeah.
Because in the end, they are seeing the same thing. The degree to which they were relying on search traffic for customer acquisition or for lead gen or whatever it was, they are now looking for visibility. Given that we perform as well as we do, the dialogue is how can we essentially carry them along
Yeah
in that journey? Look, those are things that are happening that I view as positives, but obviously the search referral is immediate. The impact there when you lose that traffic, you are losing everything associated with that traffic, the advertising, the affiliate links, all the monetization elements of that page.
Yep. Maybe let's now go into these kind of alternative monetization opportunities. I think you talked about IGN monetizing more off-platform-
Yep
versus the actual website. I guess two parts to this. Maybe help us understand what is that off-platform monetization, and what is IGN doing that it's seeing this success? Can you transfer some of those learnings to CNET or Everyday Health or some of the other properties?
Yeah, their success I would start as almost format. It's vertical video.
Yeah.
IGN, for those who are unaware, is a very popular leading video gaming and entertainment site. If you are into video games and certain types of streaming content, you're coming to IGN. That audience is very video-centric. Creating a format that is vertical video, historically it was horizontal in YouTube, increasingly it's vertical now, and that's on Instagram, and that's on TikTok, and that's on Snap, et cetera. Leaning into that format, we have very large followerships on those platforms for a brand like IGN. What has happened is the social platforms have instrumented themselves in a way that partners like ourselves can actually monetize. Historically, it was harder to monetize.
In the early days of social, that was one of the gripes that content and creators would have, which is, "Hey, there aren't ways for me to monetize this engagement." That's over, and there are absolutely ways to do it. I would say IGN's been first and early from a social video monetization point of view. I would say that in our tech and shopping businesses, social commerce, which we can talk about if you'd like, has also, they've had success there. But I think each of these, whether it's social video or vertical video, social commerce, are available to all of the brands inside of the company.
Yeah. Then maybe just, I think you had said that that sort of monetization vector does have lower margins than your traditional web-based display, the affiliate marketing. Can you help us understand as you get that mix shift there, how does that impact margins, and are there ways that you can drive efficiency from a headcount perspective, AI perspective, because I know you talked about this. Can that offset some of that margin compression when we look at a whole company level?
Yeah, so there's no doubt that as dollars shift into social platforms and even some other partnership platforms, which I'll talk about in a second, many of those platforms come with a tax. So that tax is an incremental expense within our P&L, and that is certainly happening. You see that in our margins. And that tax is not just the social platforms themselves, but if you look in our health business, which is our largest ad business actually-
a big part of the consumer part of that is our partnerships with the Mayo Clinic, the Cleveland Clinic-
Yeah
University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, and most recently Harvard. Those are all relationships where we have essentially exclusive long-term partnerships to help them monetize their inventory, but at the same time, we're paying a rev share.
Yeah.
That's a tax, right? All of those partner payments, what we used to call TAC, traffic acquisition costs, do exist. What was nice about organic search is you didn't have that, right? That was all flow through. Yeah, look, I think there's a little bit of a trade here in terms of margins, but I think as we scale-
Yeah
I think we'll start to address that, and in the end, as long as we can get overall profit dollar growth-
Right
I think that's all we really, really care about. Yeah, look, I think that's part of it. On your question around cost out in other areas, it's interesting. If you read the Anthropic S-1, their TAM is essentially the labor market. If that's even remotely true, then companies like ours, where roughly half or a little over half of our cost are people.
Right.
I do see a scenario where AI brings efficiencies, material efficiencies over time within that. That is a potential offset. It is not direct, it is not related to that, but these are two things happening independently, but potentially at the same time.
Right. Okay. That is helpful. Maybe now I want to go talk a little bit about just the overall segments. So you saw all four segments, see a little organic decline in Q3. If you were to look portfolio, piece of portfolio by portfolio, and I understand there are multiple drivers within each segment, what gives you the most confidence in a return to organic growth within that segment? Then maybe let us add the level from a company level too.
What I will say is, when we get there, I think it is going to be fairly value creating. When you look at the company right now, at least the enterprise value of the company, because a lot of what has driven the stock is really the cash that sits on the balance sheet from the transaction that we did, the multiples are very low. The multiples imply a great deal of existential threat and questions as to how long some of these businesses can even survive. I do not think we are anywhere close to that. I think a return to growth in any and all of our segments, I think, is going to be very value creating.
I just want to point that out because I get a lot of the wins organic, and I go, "But when that happens, the multiples really need to move with it," which is what we are excited about. All four segments are cuspy. They are very close. So I am not going to say this one versus this one versus that one, but they are very close to getting back to top-line growth. Look, I think it really is the equation around how strong are those headwinds that we talked about, largely relating to search, but it is not only search, right? We have had headwinds in our pro business and some other areas, so I do not want to put it all on search, against what the tailwinds are, which there are many of those.
I can't give you a specific date, but I will say that we feel confidence that it will happen.
Right.
We feel confidence that when it happens, I think it can be pretty constructive around the stock. I really do. Because right now, I think it's hard. The market just hears this search piece, and everything else kind of gets drowned out after that. We've just got to put up numbers, and when we do, I think things start to work out.
Yeah.
The mix has not been in our favor. You can look at our third quarter results and sort of a single-digit decline on the top line, and nothing compared to the search pressures that we talked about individually. If you go through our four segments, there are positives in each of them, right? While our tech and shopping segment is still declining, it's declining at a significantly lower rate than it was a year ago. There are green shoots in the area of GEO and social media, a lot of the stuff that we covered. In our gaming business, there's an element of cyclicality in that business and product coming in the market on the IGN side. Humble has put up a number of record quarters, and that's had a great year. In our health and wellness business, we see pressure in a sub-segment within our pro.
Our consumer business has had elements of strength and recently signed two new partners for our hospital network program. Our cybersecurity business and martech business collectively has largely flattened out relative to the high single-digit declines that it was exhibiting a couple of years ago, but there have been pressures in certain of our martech businesses. We have an SEO business which is to the teeth of those search headwinds, and we've had some up-downs in some of our other businesses. There's a lot of positivity.
Yeah.
The mix hasn't gotten quite right because the top-line number is the top-line number. Again, I think to Vivek's point, does it properly relate to the overall valuation of the company? As a significant buyer of our stock, I think we've given the message of what our belief is there, and we'll just keep pushing forward and try to get the mix right until it's finally all in favor.
Yep. Maybe let's talk about then the buybacks and capital allocation. You spent, what, a little bit over a 250 million on buybacks year to date. Share count's down about 15%. I get that you're obviously going to buy when you think that your stock is undervalued, especially given the cash that you generate. But what needs to change on that side to maybe, number one, unlock some of that value from these buybacks? But maybe number two, as we think about the M&A environment, right, that you're not crowding out some of these potential M&A opportunities that may arise, right? Maybe while multiples might still be a little bit too high, but at a certain point, you might find something a little bit more synergistic. Maybe walk us through both of those pieces.
Good. Our top-of-funnel M&A funnel continues to be robust. We're continuing to see opportunities and look at deals. We're first principles thinkers and pragmatists. We're looking for cash-on-cash returns. One of the core tenets of our company is we're profitable, we produce cash. That cash has a flywheel effect and has for years and years and years, continues to fuel our capital allocation program. When our stock is trading at this level on valuing the cash flows, the adjusted EBITDA, the cash flows that we're currently generating at the multiples it's generating at, it's hard to compete with.
Yeah.
However, in an environment that we're in, certain of our businesses have the headwinds we've discussed and are facing those risks, and we're looking for risk-weighted returns. Looking at an opportunity to buy a fractional interest at a company like Ziff Davis that we know pretty well, which is what our buyback is, competes pretty heavily against alternatives. But we do want to grow the portfolio. We do want to find opportunities, particularly ones that we think are either highly synergistic or could de-risk the overall portfolio from a mix perspective. We've moved slightly away from our near 50% subscription and licensing portion of our revenue through the divestiture of the Connectivity transaction. That was not a strategic decision. That was a decision purely to unlock the value in that business.
Yeah.
The numbers hopefully validate that. Certainly, the movement in the stock price seems to. But every transaction offers that possibility. Entry price is the key.
The only thing I would add to that is, this company was built on a serial acquirer thesis around the shift from analog to digital. We are now going from this shift to digital to AI.
Yeah.
I think in the same way, it is going to present some very compelling opportunities, both businesses that are great brands but struggle with that shift, businesses that may have something interesting product-wise but do not have brand and do not have installed base, do not have market position and credibility. Both of those could present as interesting acquisition opportunities. But also, we need to prove it within our own portfolio.
Yeah.
We need to demonstrate, back to your question around return to growth, that we are capable of navigating this shift within what we own today.
Yeah.
So that as we go out and look to bring things into the portfolio, we do it with a high level of conviction. By the way, I don't think it's an either/or. I think given where we are in terms of the amount of cash that we have, I think we can fund both buybacks and acquisitions.
Yeah. Okay. Maybe let's jump into some slightly spicier topics, which is the two lawsuits going on here.
Maybe let's start with the Google litigation, right? You've given us some updates there, but maybe can you help frame the magnitude? What's kind of at stake here? What's the thought process, and how should we be thinking about, is there a potential settlement here? Just any piece you can give us on the Google litigation.
Yeah. So look, I think we feel very optimistic about the quality of our case, and I think we feel optimistic about ultimately a positive outcome. We've been deliberate in not attaching a number to it, but many others who have similar cases have attached numbers to it. We want the process to run its course. To be honest, I don't view litigation as a business strategy. We don't enter into these things lightly, but this is one where I think we feel that there are damages, and we'll let the process work-
Yeah
through the course. But I think there will be clarity hopefully in the not-too-distant future, but we will see. Look, we are open-minded to everything, settlements. We are fair actors in this, and particularly in this particular case, we are partners with Google on a lot of other things.
Of course, yeah. Let us go to the other one, which is against a big frontier model provider. We have seen some kind of shifting milestones.
You can say it. OpenAI.
Yes. As we have seen some kind of shifting milestones on there, maybe number one, what should we be paying attention to in terms of timelines, procedural markers? Then number two, at some point, kind of the same question around settlement, right? Is there that opportunity for settlement, royalty, whatever have? Because obviously, we have seen royalty arrangements between frontier providers and content providers out there.
Again, I think same statement, which is, it's not our goal to be in long-term litigation. I do think defending our copyrights and intellectual property is vital.
Yeah.
Where that case is right now, I think motions are almost done, then the judge will have to issue a summary judgment, and that summary judgment, that's their timeline, not ours, hopefully is clarifying. I think that's all you can ask for, is clarity with respect to what's going on. Here's what I will say, though, because if we get to a place where there are true incentives, where there's productive relationship, where we provide content and we get value back, what can happen with AI is what's happened in search. When you look at what goes on in search, you have the entire content industry that literally optimizes around the search product.
It sits there and works productively with search engines, primarily Google, who provide all of this data on what consumers are interested in, what they're looking for, what information they value, and as content providers, we supply that. We supply that within a search ecosystem because we receive traffic back which has clear value. Now, that's being disrupted as we talked about, so that trade now feels shaky.
Yes.
But in the chatbot piece, it's completely broken because you have no traffic coming out of these answer engines, out of these chatbots. But what I would say is if we can get to a productive place, everything flips-
Yeah
and we can help make these products so much better, because now we are going to get an understanding of what are the queries and what are users of all of these systems looking to achieve, and how can we be an incredible data provider for you? I just think that there is a lesson in what happened and involved with SEO that can absolutely
Yeah
be here. We just need some kind of fair value exchange. How we get it, when we get it, what is the mechanism, those need to be worked out. But when we get there, I think everything flips 180
Right
very quickly, and we become productive partners together, and that is what I would like. I would like to be a productive partner to every one of these systems.
Yeah. Okay, got it. No, helpful. Maybe then let us go to the healthcare business. Obviously, Everyday Health has been a fantastic acquisition. You have bolted on other things on there. You have seen a little bit of softness on the MedPage Today side of the business. That has been kind of the primary drag with pharma clients shifting spend. Can you maybe help us understand, what can you do to kind of, again, stem some of these losses? But maybe more importantly, is there a point at which the other side of the equation starts to offset some of the HCP advertising pressure?
Yeah, look, what we don't want to do is take two steps forward on our consumer pharma business and then just take one step back on our healthcare provider pharma business. Just for everyone's ed. What we do is we basically run advertising campaigns for pharmaceutical companies that either target patients or prescribing physicians, nurse practitioners, et cetera. Those are the two, DTC, DTP, direct to consumer, direct to provider. What does make us unique is we're one of the few companies that do both.
Right.
What we're organizing around now is more of a 360 approach. We've kept them separate, where the DTP and DTC pieces are almost independent of each other, with working through how to bring those together to bring a 360-
Yeah
approach to the essentially the promotion of therapies. We're optimistic that that can happen. But yes, what has happened is the consumer side's done very well. A lot of that has to do with the growth in the underlying partnerships. Harvard Health, Mayo Clinic, Cleveland Clinic, these are huge names in healthcare, particularly from a patient point of view, has offset challenges on the MedPage Today side where the amount of inventory in the marketplace that is available to target physicians has exploded.
Yeah.
Largely AI platforms, et cetera. What was once scarce has become less scarce, and that's put some pressure on our business. Our answer is the 360 approach.
Hopefully get to a point where we're positive growth on both sides of the business.
Yep. Okay, got it. Maybe let's now talk about the softer side of the equation. You talked about like Moz has had some headwinds from SEO, no surprise there. B2B cyber's been a little bit of a drag, but then you've seen some surprisingly, or at least surprising to me, positive outperformance on the IPVanish.
Yep
privacy side of the equation. Maybe help us put all these pieces together. Is that alone enough to kind of carry the whole business unit? Are there things that can kind of be done to improve the performance on Moz and the cybersecurity side, especially just given the environment we're in? Maybe help us understand those pieces.
Yeah, look, so the cyber and MarTech segment is a collection of software businesses that run the range from consumer subscriptions like IPVanish all the way to B2B, which is sort of like VIPRE. They are security solutions, the marketing technology solutions, et cetera. We have things that we're feeling very good about. IPVanish is one of them. SMTP, which is more email infrastructure. Again, as things shift away from search-
Yeah
social, inbox, messaging all become far more important. I do think that at some level, we have some of the plumbing around messaging, particularly in inbox, that is doing very well. But on the other side, you have something like Moz where, look, SEO is challenging, so the investment people want to put into an SEO tool is pretty challenged right now. So, there is a question there is, does that business need to evolve to be more GEO focused? But the GEO space is full of pretty well-financed venture-backed competitors. So we will see. We will see on something like that. But what I will say is what I love about this part of the business is it is fairly durable, stable because it is so subscription-driven.
It kind of softens some of the volatility in the advertising-oriented businesses inside the company. Obviously, with the sale of Ookla, we lost our largest subscription-based business and the fastest-growing subscription-based business. So, look, I think that they have a value to us. We like these businesses. They face some of the same challenges and opportunities because even in an IPVanish, the amount of organic search-driven customer acquisition has gone down, so we have had to find offsets to that. Some of that offsets include paid marketing. Again, comes with an expense that we did not-
Yeah
historically have in the P&L.
Yeah. And maybe because you brought this up earlier, talked about the kind of the opportunities you have in social commerce. I am assuming there are some opportunities in agentic commerce.
Yes.
If we kind of fast-forward down the line, can you maybe walk us through some of these opportunities?
So just to explain commerce for us, it's affiliate commerce. Historically, it's been somebody that's searching for a product, lands on a product review at CNET, or lands on a deal at RetailMeNot, clicks from our property to a merchant, conducts a transaction, we get a commission. So that's what we mean by commerce. So we're an affiliate, we're driving commerce. It's essentially CPA. What we've had a lot of success with recently is using social channels to do the same thing. Historically, we're very oriented towards finding intent and capturing intent within a search framework. We're now trying to capture intent within a social framework.
That's Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, Snap, finding audiences, presenting both product buying guides, product reviews, deals, coupon, cashback, that whole litany of content, having them go from social to commerce and getting a transaction percentage there. That's what we mean by social commerce. It's been a green shoot for us. It's been an area of some growth. We're hoping that we can roll that out and sustain that across a number of our properties. Right now, it's largely within the RetailMeNot group, so that's our shopping businesses, because we focused on deals and cashback in an environment where lots of consumers are looking for deals and-
Yeah
and bringing price down.
All right, last question in the minute we have left. Gaming, right? Hitting on it with IGN. Maybe one of the reasons gaming had been a little bit softer in years past was just the lack of AAA release titles.
Yes.
We are now getting potentially the largest AAA release ever-
Ever
coming out soon.
Yeah.
How should we think about that impacting kind of the overall gaming business, not only with this, but then the other AAA titles that maybe were on hold as we are waiting for this pending release? How should we think about that?
GTA has been delayed so many times, but now it is coming out November 19th, and that is going to be great for the industry. All of that IP that did not want to compete with it will start to come out probably next year. With that onslaught of IP, you are just going to get ad budgets and you are going to see. We see that cyclicality. It is really the slate. In gaming, it has always been the slate. Slate and console release cycles have been drivers, so we are optimistic that the slate will be strong next year.
Awesome. I think it is a great place to jump off. Vivek, Bret, thank you so much for being here. Thank you, everyone.
Thanks, Rishi. Appreciate it.
Thank you, sir.