Great to have you with us, Bettina.
Thank you, Kian.
A lot to discuss. Maybe, Bettina, we can start right away with an update. You discussed with the third quarter results, which is not too long ago, your targets for 2026. Maybe you can give us a progress on the 2026 targets, and that context maybe also a little bit about the outlookâ
Yeah.
âgoing forward.
Yeah. The good thing is everything is super stable. Top line is stable. Organization is still very resilient despite all the noise, and it is really on delivery modus, which is great. Having now seen October, having done also a little bit the forecasting for the rest of the year, I think the good news is that it come even a little bit nicer than we thought with respect to the cost side, and then we will also see some benefits on the tax side, which means that, I mean, our guidance was EUR 3.4 billion for the full year 2026, and we can now be very clear that it is not a larger or equal to EUR 3.4 billion, but it is clearly a EUR 3.5 billion, because we still talking about rounding down to come to a EUR 3.5 billion.
It is a very good number, very solid number, and it speaks about the strengths of the business model. That is great, and that also means that we start as a very good basis into the year 2027 with a solid cost base, because some parts, what we currently see is that some of the headcount increases we thought we would do in the foreign locations, we simply do not do. Because we also see that there are productivity gains kicking in from AI, and that will then have a trickling down effect also for the quarters to come, and then the revenue base and the top line is strong. It is a good starting point also for 2027.
Just on the 2026 figure that you said, because it is slight change from what we discussed in the third quarterâ
Yeah.
âresults. What is the delta? Is it cost or is it something else that you would highlight, or is it across the board?
I mean, top line is pretty stable, so the EUR 13.2 billion.
Yeah.
It is a thing. We also did not change anything. Stayed very conservative still with the risk results, so we are still stuck with the EUR 850 million. We will see where we end, because so far quarter has been very quiet. We also still have a certain amount included in the guidance for booking of first restructuring costs this year. It is unclear whether we will really be able to book it, because we need to start negotiations or complete negotiations with works council, and that is not so easy in this situation, so it might come next year, then the number is even higher. But it is very much cost line and then also the tax line.
Oh, good to hear.
Yeah.
Good to hear.
Which also brings the fact that, I mean, we said always that our CET1 ratio will be above 14.0%. We are now at 14.2%, and it looks that we will be even higher at the end of the year.
Oh, good news for us. Maybe moving from the 2026/ 2027 numbers, discussing a little bit your main shareholder. German Finance Ministry also came out with a statement yesterday, but more focusing on the UCG letter. Can you maybe give your conclusions on this letter, key points that how you interpret it?
Yeah. I mean, first of all, I think it's always good if we have some kind of alignment, some kind of commitments out there, also when it comes to Frankfurt, when it comes to the public listing. There are also words in there about protecting staff rights, keeping the social balance, to say it like that, but also keeping the business model for Mittelstand clients and the export-oriented Mittelstand clients intact. Specifically, the client communication or the points on client and business model fits to the press statement which we have seen two weeks ago, and where there was also some alignment ongoing between us and UniCredit. If you then look on some other messagings about restructuring heavily also when it comes to the international network, booking of very, very, very large restructuring costs and stuff like that doesn't necessarily add up.
One need to see how this is evolving next year. But overall, I think it is important that we can move on, that our organization needs clarity and transparency. I mean, there will be no closing probably, I don't know, in December, and that means we move on. We have to consolidate, and we also have, as Commerzbank, we need to publish a dependency report, and we really focus on that one to make that happen and to do it right and correct.
Yeah. You mentioned the international operation capabilities that were mentioned, commitments to that, even though a lot of the restructuring is likely to be in that area, so that was a bit of a surprise when I saw that. Also one that was a bit of a surprise to me is that the statement of UniCredit says, "Federal government no longer has a need to nominate representative to the Commerzbank Supervisory Board," and that UniCredit consulted and nominates two independent board members. Can you comment on that? I am a bit surprised that as a large shareholder, that statement was, so to say, agreed.
Yeah. My understanding is that they aligned on two candidates. I think we will all know more whenever there will be a public or an official request in our direction to call for an EGM, and then there will be also a list attached to that. And then most likely it will be visible what the two candidates are, which are allocated to this agreement between the government and between UniCredit.
Okay. Staying with UniCredit, but moving away from the statement, how is your relationship with UniCredit? You had the results. Is there regular meetings? Where is the common ground? Where are the topics where you find gaps in what they want to do relative to the way you see Commerzbank developing going forward?
We are in constant interaction since two years, as everybody knows, because UniCredit has been, from the beginning on, an important investor, so we had very regular meetings about our results and everything. That clearly has increased now since the completion of the takeover offer, and that happens on different levels. We clearly have a point that, given that there is a de facto control, and it is for sure that then we will be part of the consolidated group of UniCredit, there is a lot of work to be done between the finance and risk teams of both organizations, and they basically work on a daily basis together to make it happen, because it is a very surprisingly limited timeframe to be prepared for that.
But then we also have C-level dialogues about not only our results, we just had clearly meetings after our results, but also about timeline, because I think it is in our joint interest to make it as smart and as smoothly as possible. Also, when it comes to a potential EGM as announced by UniCredit, but also, we have a full-year result presentation. We need to close the books for 2026. All the things need to be managed in a professional and collaborative way, because we have an organization of 40,000 employees with more than 10 million private clients and a very huge number of corporate clients.
You cannot leave this organization in any destabilized status, so it is really important to align and to make sure that everything is kept stable, that motivation is kept stable, that we keep the attrition of clients to a minimum, and all these things. And this is our commitment of Commerzbank management team.
And if you look at potential revenue dis-synergies, clearly Mittelstand is very important to Commerzbank, to Germany as well. How do you mitigate the risk in terms of losing German corporate clients, and how do you manage the risk going forward?
Our teams are doing a great job because they are literally out there every day, and there is more intensive coverage necessary. There are also a lot of debates, more debates ongoing than you would normally have, specifically when it comes to RFPs, which are more, there is a longer-term horizon. You have more questions about our business model, how the future looks like, and that is an active management which will continue. And the size of the dis-synergies or the revenue reduction very much depends on how we manage it in a smart way, and it also clearly depends on the future business model.
Because if I categorize that, it is very clear on the private client side, it all depends when it comes to the wealth management clients on the business model that we can show that we even improve the value proposition and that it is not getting worse, that relationship manager relationship keeps stable so that we do not have too much attrition on that part. That will very much drive on the wealth management part the way we see dis-synergies or not. That very much dependent if we have lots of cost-cutting ongoing, then it will definitely also leave some clients in part. But I think if we manage that nicely, we can limit our dis-synergies on that extent. On the corporate client side, you have probably to differentiate between corporates and financial institutions.
We know that financial institutions need to keep in mind that if there is a consolidated group, they need to look at us together. So whoever has done a lot of business with both institutions probably need to figure out whether there are any risk limits and so on hit, and we are in constant interaction on that. On the corporate client side, again, there will be dis-synergies just because of the fact that if the corporate client has done a lot of business with both institutions, they might think about moving and getting another bank into the banking group to just have the diversification to avoid any blocking vote and stuff like that. That is something which you can also need to manage in conjunction with the client.
The rest very much depends on whether you provide the business model clients are used to, if the relationship managers are on board, if you have the access to the international network, if not. That brings us back to what the future strategy is. I mean, we have a strong growth path laid out for Commerzbank, a 6% growth of revenues each year, with some very attractive targets, I think. You look on 2030, the 21% ROE and the 41% cost income ratio. We think you can even make that, you can even improve these numbers by taking the benefits of the larger group into account. But it is a growth strategy combined with transformation. If you do it differently, the benchmark is out there, and you need to compare whatever you do. You need to compare it in the interest of the minority shareholders against that.
Yeah, we come back to minority shareholders in a second. Also what we heard from Deutsche Bank yesterday is that they see some new client wins due to this merger, which is happening at one point, at least the phase one of that transaction, which has happened shortly. Talking aboutâ
I have not seen any numbers yet and any communications. I think it's for a good reason because, I mean, we also compare notes.
âyeah.
I think it's really one of the joint attention points we currently have because it's our joint interest to not lose the clients. I would say so farâ
You don't see it.
âwe have been pretty successful in not seeing it.
Interesting.
I think at least our motivation is to keep it like that.
Yeah.
Whether we will be successful is very much dependent, it is always dependent, it leads also back to the talent base and the business model.
Absolutely. Talking about Phase 1, in that context, creating a balance between value creation of controlling shareholder and minority shareholder in that context, especially on the controlling side, things like restructuring charge, et c. How do you see that going to be managed? How do you make sure that the value created from Phase 1 is proportionate, so to say?
Yeah. The ruling is very clear. We have the German [Non-Foreign language], the German corporate law, that is super clear for the Phase 1 we will be in. That means that we are consolidated but independent. Because if you are not independent, if there is a direction of the group, like we are UniC redit into Commerzbank, you would have to have a domination agreement, because that would give then the minority shareholders the possibility to either get a yearly compensation or even get paid out and get either cash or shares against their shares. The ruling is very clear.
Also in this next phase, the governing bodies for Commerzbank are the Supervisory Board and the Management Board of Commerzbank. These two governing bodies have just one obligation, and that is to act in the interest of Commerzbank and its institution and its stakeholders, and specifically shareholders. For that one, you have the concept of a dependency report. Whenever you decide something in conjunction with the controlling shareholder, which might be beneficial for the group but not for Commerzbank itself, you would have to make that very clear, and you could only do that if you can figure out what the disadvantage is and calculate and ask for compensation.
If you cannot do that, you are not allowed to do it. You also need to be very clear and concrete in this dependency report of joint transactions, joint agreements, things you have not done because of the situation and stuff like that. It is very important to understand that whatever happens in Phase 1, there is always the obligation from Supervisory Board and Management Board to very much focus on Commerzbank. There is now the specific situation that we are a bank, so you also have the supervisory regulation in the debate, which means you have a global function lead concept, which means that you have to align with procedures, with policies, and stuff like that, and guidelines. But also there, you really have to jointly see that it is not to the disadvantage of the minority shareholders of Commerzbank.
I guess the question that a lot of people are asking is if there's a change, a material change in the Supervisory Board, with the announcement yesterdayâ
Yeah.
âof the government, so to say, giving up two votesâ
Yeah.
âthe Supervisory Board will be in control of UniCredit, with that, decision-making will be in the control of UniCredit, so to say.
Still then, I mean, we know it also from mBank.
Yeah.
We also own 70%â
Yeah
âof mBank in this case.
Constraints.
In this case, we have 50% of the Supervisory Board of mBank are dependent.
Yeah.
Supervisory Board members are coming from Commerzbank, 50% are independent. The governing body is the Supervisory Board and the Management Board. I can't call the CEO of mBank and say, "Cezary Kocik, I want this or this." That's not possible. If I want something, I mean, if it's a global function lead thing, then you do it via the global function lead, otherwise, you have to have a discussion in the Supervisory Board. You have to decide whether it's in the interest of mBank, and then the Board of Managing Directors in mBank is deciding on that. That is a very similar thing. Regardless of how the supervisory board will look like, whoever is in the Supervisory Board needs to consider that whatever decision they take, also with respect to the strategy, it must not be to the disadvantage of, for example, minority shareholders.
You always have to compare. I mean, there's our strategy out there are targets out there, and it's very clear that if you're a minority shareholder, you expect that if there's a new strategy, this strategy should be better than the strategy already out there. That would be, I think, the expectation. I mean that not only when you look in 2030 or 2032, but also from a, let me say, net present value perspective.
Yeah.
It needs to be attractive. That is the job of whoever is in the Supervisory Board, that's their job. They then can clearly have the discussion with the Management Board, and apparently, most important job of the Supervisory Board in an AG is, besides monitoring and counseling, is the determination who's leading the bank, because it's a two-tier board.
Yeah.
The operational and strategic responsibility of the bank is with the [Non-English content], is with the Management Board, and not with the Supervisory Board, which is different in a one-tier board, clearly.
Maybe one more question on phase one with your controlling shareholder, then we go into the operational numbers a bit. Capital return, you have done a superb job of maximizing returns, but also optimizing balance sheet, payback capital to shareholders, so dividends and buybacks, hugely earnings are created, and this is a superb job you have done. You have this buyback of EUR 1.2 billion tranche, which is ongoing. How do you see going forward the buyback and dividend storyâ
Yeah
âof Commerzbank developing?
Well, I mean, I can only take the perspective on what we have in our multi-year plan. We just had the debate about the multi-year plan with the Supervisory Board as we speak yesterday. There is a very intact capital return story to start with 2026. As I said, it is no longer EUR 3.4 billion, but it is EUR 3.5 billion of net income. We are far above our target ratio of 13.5%â
Yeah.
âCET1, which means that at least for the time being, our capital return policy kicks in, which says we return 100% to our shareholders as long as we have surplus capital. How we do now the rest of the two, or let it be EUR 2.1 billion, is something which we will decide in the upcoming weeks. But from our perspective, the capital return story is absolutely intact. We meet all requirements. We are also super bullish on the years to come. There will be an increase of net income every year. Next year, clearly, we also have, one should not forget, we also have the booking of the restructuring costs of Momentum, so the additional 3,000 which we have published in May, in addition to the 3,900 which we have already incorporated. But it is a constant increase in income.
And in any number which you have seen in our case with respect to CET1 ratios for the years to come, we never included any retention of net income. So, our CET1 ratio would be much higher. So, take the EUR 2 billion that would kick us far above the 15% for this year if we would not returnâ
Yeah.
âthat to shareholders. And, I mean, we are a publicly listed entity. That would be not very smart to do.
No. And you have been, as I said, you have done very good job on optimizing, and it sounds like it will continue, as you say. Moving into more the operational side, deposit competition in Germany, PSBC had EUR 3 billion of outflows in depositsâ
Yeah.
âin the third quarter. Your deposit beta in the third quarter was 40%.
Yeah.
Can you talk a little bit about competition currently? How is it developing, getting tougher, easing? 2027 in particular, I thinkâ
Yeah.
âI guess we are mainly interested in.
Well, I mean, unfortunately, competition is not easing, and we also prepare for the fact that it will also not ease in 2027, but we feel very comfortable with our NII guidance. One should also not forget that the EUR 8.5 billion, which we now target for this year, is also the best NII we had in the history. So it is a pretty good result. But you see the competition, and we also need to adjust to that, and we really have to think about different items, the funding, the deposit offerings which we have. We are now also out with some more offerings at comdirect side, but also for Commerzbank. We really tried to do a lot with bundle offers, so to create some stickiness of the deposits, because the problem really was this, well, I just have an attractive call money out.
You just have no stickiness anymore. You see that, I think, with your own subsidiary in Germany as we speak, that whenever you lower from this very attractive offering, be it 4%, to a smaller amount, there's so many other players in the moment out there, that this interest rate hoppers, you automatically lose as we speak. I think that is something we all need to plan in and we need to plan for, and we do that. We will also have attractive offers out there. But, I mean, there's now one player out with a 5%, which is a ridiculous number if you know where the ECB rate is. It's a cautious managing of sound deposit beta and being profitable, but on the other side, also keeping the overall model intact.
I think we have done a pretty good job, and we're also very optimistic that we will end the year as we thought we would end. I think the important part is really to create stickiness and to keep also your existing clients, because what you really see is that this 4% has been kind of a psychological hurdle where people start, even the non-interest rate hoppers, to think, "Wait a moment, 4%, that sounds pretty good.
Yeah.
Should I really invest in securities? Isn't that too unsafe? Should I go again into deposits?" Which we actually want to have it the other way around. I think we all also need to plan it for two factors, which hopefully happen. On the corporate client side next year, hopefully also corporates will invest more, will invest more also in Germany. That should bring the liquidity a little bit down.
Yeah.
That's at least our assumption. The other part is that on the private client side, hopefully the German government will introduce a pension reform for 1st of January. We all assume that will happen. That will also mean that if we are successful altogether in motivating as many people as possible to sign up for this very attractive product from client perspective and to really, yeah, increase investment culture, that we will see benefits on the security side, so the net commission income side. But clearly, it will also have an impact on the liquidity, which is available then to sit in fact deposits or call money, because people do not automatically have more money from January 1st on. I mean, they get some state subsidized into it, but they also need to spend their own money, salaries into it.
Yeah. There's a lot to unpack in what you said, German pension reform, loan growth in the corporate side. I want to talk a little bit about these things. Just coming back on deposits, I mean, you said that you want to grow deposits. Are you going to do that through price ultimately, and will you give a new deposit beta for 2027 most likely? In that context, just you mentioned a lot of things. I mean, loan growth is picking up. Does that drive deposit competition to some extent in the corporate side mainly? Is it higher rates, as you mentioned?
Mm-hmm.
You know, once you get 4%, people get excited. Is it just competition? Just trying to Has something changed? You know, should we take the deposit beta?
Yeah.
This is a, you know, we had the best of times, and there's a, you know, this kind of pivot.
Yeah.
Ex loan growth, leaving loan growth aside.
Well, I mean, we are very positive on NII just also because we have this very solid revenues coming from the replicationâ
Yeah, from the hedges.
âportfolio. I mean, we do not see really a change. I mean, the biggest danger for that one is a change in the interest rate environment where you see that forward rates make something funny, but we don't see that there. I mean, quite volatile, but still at a very high level, so that's great for us. But the deposit beta is clearly, and you know that we always had this dialogue because you thought altogether that we are always too conservative on the deposit beta, remember?
Yeah.
I think we were spot on right.
Yeah, yeah. It was always spot on.
I know that I had so many debates about, "Bettina, you're too conservative on this deposit beta. It will never happen that it comes at this level." Now we are. What we have done, that has not changed, is that for 2028, we assume a deposit beta of 44%, then for 2030, even a 46%.
Yeah.
Which means that for 2027 and all our guidance, we assume something in between, because we believe that, I mean, competition is not going away, so you have to keep that in mind, and we better plan for that.
Yeah. You touched on NII. I mean, consensus NII is EUR 9.2 billion. It was EUR 9.3 billion, I think, pre the results for 2027. That's a EUR 700 million increaseâ
Yeah.
âfrom your guidance. You feel comfortable with that overall?
Yeah, definitely. I mean, if you just look on this famous page, which we have included always in our presentation, with respect to the replication portfolio, it is pretty clear that a vast majority is anyhow already supported by that. Then you have bits and pieces. You have an increased deposit beta, which will clearly, I mean, reduce NII. But then we expect now another, or even two interest rate hikes for next year that will have an impact. Then we clearly see a positive impact stemming from mBank, but also from the growth on the loan and deposit side we expect for Germany.
Yeah.
Overall, yeah, we feel comfortable.
You mentioned, you touched on German pension reform, how that can have a benefit. Talk to us a little bit, when should we think about pension reform actually really having an impact on your P&L? Does it take a very long time? How is comdirect actually positioned for that?
First of all, yes, it will take a long time before you really see an impact because, I mean, it's a small product.
Yeah.
What we also currently see is that we still have to do a lot of campaigning altogether to convince German citizens that this is a great idea. We just did a survey over summer to understand how many people have really heard about the product. There's still a lot of work because there are still a lot of people who have never heard about the product, which has also a very difficult name.
Yeah.
[Non-English content] which I never can translate into English. That is one. The good thing is, whenever we are able to explain the product, then the willingness to invest is pretty high. Then clearly, that is a big, big benefit out of it, then people have a securities account. When they have a securities account, it's much easier to also convince them that they can put and take an ETF savings plans next, that the grandparents, instead of buying stupid presents, putting the presents into an ETF savings plans, taking the money they get from the state for the children, just instead of consuming it, putting it into the savings plans. But the prerequisite is that people really have already a securities account. I think that is the big trick why everybody is now keen to get these clients, because you get the clients in with their securities account.
That gives you the possibility to convince them, hopefully also. Then I think the beauty starts also for our P&L if we are really changing the investment culture. But one should know, it always comes at a price, so it will probably take some of our NII awayâ
Yeah.
âand fund it into net commission income. But still, it's, I think, the right thing we need to do. What we do with this product, we always use the two brands with different offerings. So comdirect will have the self-directed ETF solutions too, a real standard product at a very low price, very comparable to the prices of the neobanks and so on. Commerzbank will have an advisory or will have two alternative advisory products, which also will be priced differently, but will also include advisory, which is specifically important when it comes to all this question about Riester and what to do with your Riester thing and stuff like that. So there will be much more advice in there.
Interesting. Okay. Two-segment strategyâ
Yeah.
âI have to say. Pivoting to loan growth, corporate loan growth, 14% year- on- year. Out of all Europe, I think it's the fastest loan growth. U.K. is probably 11% on the corporate side, 11.2%, and Spain is quite strong. But what is driving that loan growth in Germany now, 14%? Do you think this is a sustainable double-digit, mid-double-digitâ
Yeah.
âloan growth?
Well, the unfortunate thing is it's not loan growth in Germany. That would be great. That would be great news for Germany. I mean, also that our GDP growth is now at 1.2% for this year, or 1.3% even projected. No, our loan growth is, if you look into it's very much also driven by international expansion. So by corporates from Germany, Switzerland, and Austria investing somewhere else. So this whole localization after the whole tariff situation, but also the whole supply chain problems and energy crisis and whatnot, is still ongoing, and we have seen that. The appetite to really do investments and see loan growth in Germany is still limited, at least also in our client portfolio. Our expectation is that this should change, but we had this expectation several times, and then there was always something happening.
Whenever we thought now is the time where we will see the investments, there was the invasion, there was the trade war, there was the energy crisis, there was a government change, many things.
Yeah.
This year, it was the beginning of the Middle East conflict. We were absolutely sure in February that we now have the feeling that everything has stabilized. Everybody has also absorbed the shocks of the trade war and the tariffs, and now is the time where they would invest, because we also saw some reforms from the government, and then there was the Middle East conflict, and it stopped again.
Interesting.
That is the interesting part to look at, I think, when you look at 2027 in the first one or two quarters, to really look at the composition of the loan growth there, because you will then see whether also Germany is really kicking off. And it is not only the stimulus by the program of the government, but also finally, the addition which we need to really have a sustainable growth path for GDP for the years to come, if we really see the investments into Germany. And there are some. We know, and we had this Invest in Germany Summit Berlin.
Yeah.
There was some very promising messaging around that. But now we need to see that also basically in real numbers.
We can see it a little bit also in the data, in the Bundesbank data. I open up for questions. Mics on the table. Who will take us?
Somebody has a question.
I have a question on cost income. You have a cost income guidance of 51% in 2026. You want to go to 41% in 2030â
Yeah.
âexcluding compulsory contributions.
Which is not a lot.
Which is not a lot. Can you talk a little bit about the revenue cost driversâ
Yeah.
âof that? In that context also, technology, what role does it play on the cost side? What can you really do on the cost side in particular?
Yeah.
You've done a great job already of retaining cost.
Yeah, we also have done a lot on the cost side. If you look on the FTE reductions which we have done in the past, but also now as part of Momentum, there is nearly 7,000 FTE reduction in our plans, which means also a lot of transformation is ongoing. What we currently also see is that quarter- by- quarter, we learn more about the impact of AI potentially on the efficiency. I cannot rule out that all the plans which we have will always also be reviewed on quarter- by- quarter, because we see certain elements of efficiency gains which we haven't seen. Take the latest one is a complaint management, where we really now have identified a 60% savings potential. It's not a huge group, but it's something, and things like that are adding up to it.
But overall, we plan for It's a growth strategy. Momentum is a growth strategy, so we plan for 6% revenue growth in the years to come, by keeping, however, the costs stable, nearly stable. If you basically exclude mBank, because there the cost base is really increasing. The cost base for the group ex-mBank is going down. That also includes that we have a lot of inflation ongoing. We have a lot of salary increases. We have currently, as we speak, the negotiations with the unions about the pay scale workers in Germany. That will definitely also bring some additional increases, and we have embedded that in our guidance. Also lots of investments. I think you can ask every bank at the moment that probably we all have increased to a substantial amount our investments in cybersecurities over the past two, three months, four months, five months.
That will most likely go on. Those are all the things you need to balance out. You have the revenue growth on the one side, but then keeping the costs stable or even reducing that despite all the headwinds you have. That is how we come. It is a combination of very efficient cost management, and there clearly, and we have listed that in the Q3, there are some benefits we definitely would like to tap out of the group. The UniCredit Group is much larger, and when it comes to procurement, there are some hopefully easy wins, because I am pretty sure they have, at least with some of our key providers, better rates than we are, just because of the size. Then there are also some other things where we can definitely, where we do not need to have double investments.
By the way, cybersecurity is probably one of the most important parts where the teams have already started to work together, because it is so important that we align forces on that.
We ran out of time, Bettina. Thank you very much forâ
Thank you for your questions.
âbeing with us. Thank you.
Have a nice weekend. Bye.