Bank of Montreal (TSX:BMO)
224.49
-6.57 (-2.84%)
Nov 20, 2026, 4:00 PM EST
â View all transcripts
AGM 2016
Apr 5, 2016
Summary
FY15 adjusted revenue rose 8% and adjusted net income rose 6%; technology-led customer and efficiency initiatives remained central. Shareholders elected all 12 directors, approved the auditor and compensation resolutions, and defeated MĂDACâs reporting proposal.
Good morning, fellow shareholders, and welcome to the 2016 Annual Meeting of the Bank of Montreal. Thank you for coming. We appreciate your interest. My name is Robert Prichard, and I have the honor of serving as Chairman of your board of directors, and I call this meeting to order. We are meeting again this year at BMO's Institute for Learning. It always gives me great pleasure on behalf of all members of your board to welcome you here, because we are proud to showcase this amazing facility, which thousands of BMO employees visit each year to learn new things and improve their skills. It is also a much sought-after conference venue for groups from outside the bank. If you would like to use it, give us a call, and we will work it out. We are always open for business.
I want to take a moment to extend a special welcome back to arguably our most faithful shareholder and a former Director of the bank from 1973 to 1986, Mr. John Ellis. Mr. Ellis was unable to attend the meeting last year, which is remarkable since it was only the second annual meeting he had missed in 68 years of attendance. What a record. Take a bow, Mr. Ellis. We are very pleased to see you back again, sir, and I thank you for your dedication and long service to the bank as one of our Honorary Directors. We are also very pleased that Bob Astley, also an Honorary Director, is present today. He served the board with great distinction until his retirement a year ago. Bob, welcome back. Thank you for coming. We miss you. Please take a bow, Bob Astley.
I am joined on the stage this morning, by, on my immediate right, Bill Downe, our Chief Executive Officer. To his right, Tom Flynn, our Chief Financial Officer. To his right, Simon Fish, our General Counsel, and finally, Barbara Muir, our distinguished Corporate Secretary. Also joining me here today, seated in the first two rows, are members of the bank's board of directors and the bank's senior management team. Members of the board will be introduced when it is time for the election of Directors. Members of management should be alert, because I will be calling on them if there are hard questions during the question-and-answer period. The Secretary has confirmed that notice of this meeting was duly given in accordance with the Bank Act and that a quorum of shareholders as prescribed by the bylaws of the bank is present in person or represented by proxy.
I therefore declare this meeting to be properly constituted for the transaction of such business as may be properly brought before it. I appoint Steve Gilbert and Sonia Ciavaglia, representatives of Computershare Trust Company of Canada, to act as scrutineers for the meeting, and Barbara Muir to act as our Secretary. The shareholders' auditors for fiscal 2015, KPMG LLP, are present here today, represented by Jim Newton, the Lead Partner, and his colleagues, Naveen Kalia and Brent Elson. Perhaps the three of you could stand to identify yourselves. We are delighted to have you with us. You do very good work for us, and we appreciate it very much. Where are our colleagues from KPMG? Thank you very much. Now for some procedural matters concerning the meeting. Closed captioning is provided here in the room for those who are hearing impaired over here on my left.
The meeting is being broadcast live online in both official languages, and shareholders watching online are able to submit questions or comments to the meeting. Those wishing to do so should follow the instructions on the annual meeting webcast launch page. As the proceedings are being webcast, no photographing or videotaping of the meeting is permitted. We would ask that any questions or comments from the floor or submitted online be related to matters currently before the meeting, and when submitting questions, individuals provide their name and indicate whether you are a shareholder or a proxy holder. We will do our best to respond to all such questions during the meeting, but any questions not answered will be responded to immediately following the meeting. Facilities for simultaneous English-French interpretation have been provided, and you will find English on channel one and French on channel two.
You are welcome, of course, to address your questions or comments to the meeting in either English or French. At the appropriate time, any shareholder or proxy holder wishing to speak should go to the closest standing microphone. If you would prefer to have a roving microphone brought to you, please raise your hand. Each microphone is numbered, and once I recognize your microphone, you should address the meeting. In order to allow as many shareholders as possible to have an opportunity to speak, each shareholder will be allowed to speak only once on the matter before the meeting. Please keep any comments or questions to a maximum of two or three minutes.
Finally, regarding the layout, the physical layout of the room, in the event of an unforeseen emergency, I would like to point out that there are exits at the main doors where you came in, to my right, and also on the opposite side of the room, to my left, your right. The agenda today will consist of an address by our leader, CEO Bill Downe, followed by the three resolutions proposed by management. First, to elect the board of directors for the next year. Second, to appoint the shareholders' auditors for fiscal 2016. And third, to consider an advisory resolution on the bank's approach to executive compensation. Following these three matters, we will then deal with the one Shareholder Proposal No. 1 to be voted on at the meeting. Finally, we will conclude the meeting with a question-and-answer period, followed by a short video.
On behalf of those speaking today, I note that their comments may include forward-looking statements, and unless otherwise noted, they will be referring to non-GAAP financial measures referred to as adjusted results. Details regarding forward-looking statements and non-GAAP financial measures are on screen and can also be found in the bank's 2015 annual report, as updated in our first quarter 2016 report to shareholders. Actual results could differ materially from forecasts, projections, or conclusions in the forward-looking statements made today. With those preliminaries behind us, I begin the formal part of our agenda. Again, this past year, the bank's performance has been strong despite an uncertain economic recovery. As I wrote in the annual report, producing good results under favorable conditions is expected, but producing strong results in times of uncertainty is evidence of both a successful business strategy and an effective management team.
As shareholders, we benefit from both, as demonstrated by the total return on your shareholdings, which continues to outpace the market as a whole, having generated 13.5% on average over the past three years. It's also fair to say that as much as these may be challenging times economically, this is also an exciting time of technological change that is reshaping many of the ways we and others are dealing with the financial services needs of individuals and businesses everywhere. Your management team is well-equipped to tackle these developments, and your board of directors has great confidence in all of them. We are particularly fortunate to have Bill Downe as our CEO, the most experienced of all the current leaders of Canada's major banks, and in our view, the best.
We continue to be impressed by the strong and steady leadership that Bill and his senior management team bring to the bank, inspiring the efforts of almost 47,000 employees of the bank. On behalf of the board and all your shareholders, I thank everyone on the team for their results over the past year. You do a terrific job advancing BMO's brand, and you serve our customers and our shareholders exceptionally well. Bill, our thanks to you and your team, and congratulations on all you do so well for all of us. I now invite you to address this annual meeting. Bill Downe.
Thank you, Chairman, for those generous introductory remarks, et bonjour Ă tous. It's a pleasure within the crowded agenda of our annual shareholder meeting to have a few minutes to speak with you about the actions we're taking to continue to grow the business of the bank and the earnings that accrue to our shareholders. We're meeting this morning in a place that embodies our focus on the future through our highly visible commitment to continuing education and leadership development. The BMO Institute for Learning, as much as it makes a compelling architectural statement, is first and foremost an investment in our people, and increasingly, it reflects our resolve to push the boundaries of technology as a competitive differentiator and a driver of innovation.
This campus has conventional classrooms, but it's also a hub for remote knowledge sharing enabled by technology and operating on a scale far beyond this physical space. Our online audience is experiencing a version of that firsthand today, as many more of you than are present in this room are joining us on your personal devices. But if this kind of digital technology has become commonplace, its full impact on commerce, and particularly on banking, is just starting to take shape. That's what I hope you'll take away from our meeting this morning. Our bank is positioned not just to hold its own in a world transformed by technology, but positioned to reinforce the brand advantage we've been working so hard to build.
As we've left the Great Recession behind and as the largest emerging markets adjust and mature, much of the economy is in the midst of a major structural shift, and inevitably, so is our industry. Regulatory reform has changed banking on every level and changed it for the better. Just as significantly, our industry is being reshaped by the digital economy, which is changing how all products and services are produced, distributed, and consumed. Five years ago, we began investing much more heavily in the bank's IT architecture in order to harness the immediately scalable power of the big systems we've built. We've been implementing agile production practices, enhancing our ability to push out incremental changes rather than holding them until the date of a major release.
As a result, we're accelerating our speed to market, keeping pace with our customers' lives, enabling more personalized interactions, showing that we value their time. The systems that make all of this possible are complex, but what we're ultimately trying to achieve is not. We're simply trying to delight, in a manner consistent with our brand, the maximum number of people at the lowest cost to serve. By grounding BMO's technology leadership in the vision to be the bank that defines great customer experience, we're deepening the loyalty of existing customers while attracting new ones, because this is what drives quality business growth and delivers value to our shareholders. This morning, I'd like to take you through the key points of technology-driven transformation, talk about how it fits into our overall customer-focused strategy, and briefly examine the impact on the bank's current and future performance.
But first, let's place this entire discussion in its broader context. In particular, I'd like to address a sentiment that's prevailed since the middle of last year. Analysts and financial media have been singularly focused on the impact of lower oil and gas prices, and commodity prices generally, on our bank and the interconnected regional economies that define our North American footprint. The level of apprehension about markets has been disproportionate to the evidence, largely, I think, because we've all become captives to the 24-hour news cycle. When everyone is continuously connected, it seems that news, to be interesting, has to feel lightning fast, often too fast, in fact, for the rate at which things actually happen. Real insight takes time to emerge, to be processed and understood. When information is speeding across the world in terabits per second, updates every few minutes can become a repetitive blur.
To the purveyors of news, or at least some, wrapping each new perspective in the cloak of catastrophe is often the only way to keep our attention. The case in point, the cost of energy. For as demand increases and the replacement of current production declines, it will ultimately lead to higher prices. But in the interim, in some areas of the country, we're seeing a significant negative impact on employment and consumer spending. This has caused understandable distress, both to energy-related businesses and to people who depend on the sector for their livelihoods. Within the bank, we're anticipating that loan loss provisions will rise from a very low level to one more consistent with this point in the commodity cycle.
The direct impact on the performance of the bank will be moderated by the experience we have in the sector and the relatively low concentration in a diversified portfolio, just 2% of outstanding loans. At the same time, our institutional memory allows us to take in the full course of the cycle, and what we know with confidence is that Canada's resource wealth has not gone away. Market price correction does not mean that an enviable national asset has suddenly become a liability. But if it encourages Canadians to rethink how much we should be dependent on natural resources for our wealth, and that spurs a further diversification of the economy, it will be a good outcome. Clearly, no one has a crystal ball, but our forecasts are not meant to be prophecies.
We establish a hierarchy of choices against potential rates of change, and then, having narrowed down the most likely future scenarios, we determine how best to protect the capital of the bank and position it to grow with our customers. In our open economies, prices are always adjusting. If the swings are wide in commodity markets, there can be short-term job losses and dislocation until a more typical cadence of supply and demand returns. It bears repeating that the economic fundamentals remain positive in Canada as well as the U.S. Consumer spending is strong in most regions, thanks to low interest rates and steady job growth and cheaper fuel prices. We continue to believe that we'll experience positive GDP growth close to 2% in Canada and above 2% for the U.S. for the full year.
But in the same way that a sudden change in the structure of global commodity markets is impacting the resource sector, the broader economy is also experiencing discontinuity. In every sector, innovative technology and breakthrough research point the way to the disruption of the status quo, to unprecedented cost efficiency, and to enriched customer relationships. This is the most promising dimension of the North American economy, where both public and private investment should be directed. And that investment is happening. We see many customers of this bank taking the lead to make their industries more globally competitive. The best-managed companies will emerge from this transition with lower expenses, cleaner operations, and more sustainable business models. And they're embracing the rapid technology-driven innovation that's benefiting even the most basic industries.
As the digital economy continues to gain momentum, we're seeing new kinds of companies and entire industries rising alongside older ones, not necessarily to replace them, but to complement and extend their scope. A lot has been said about disruptors like Uber, but we shouldn't overlook the fact that Uber's greatest rival, Lyft, recently received a $500 million investment from one of the big three automakers, which has launched its own car-sharing service. And the same firm has just announced a $1 billion acquisition of a California startup that develops driverless cars. It's hard to predict the outcome for any one company, but this is a telling example of an incumbent recognizing valuable innovation and taking it on board to challenge its own business model.
A central paradox for the banking industry is that incumbents are seen as powerful economic players whose key role in the financial system demands that they be subject to oversight. But at the same time, these old guard businesses are judged to be operating at a disadvantage to new unregulated entrants to the industry. The fact is, the pace of change is challenging to all incumbents. The future will be won by those who do not just keep up with, but stay several steps ahead of constantly rising expectations. It will be won by companies that challenge their own business models to be dramatically more efficient while delivering ever-greater value to their customers. Expressed another way, our bank's transformation agenda is defined by the same closely aligned dimensions: customer experience and efficiency.
What makes it possible to bring those parallel goals together is the same critical factor that drives all of the change we see accelerating around us, information technology. This is not so new. Technology has been a key enabler of BMO's success, from our pioneering use of automated check processing to the first real-time network connecting branches across Canada, to mbanx, our early move into virtual banking in the first days of the internet. We did not recently awaken to the power of organized, readily available information. It has been core to our operating discipline. Today, we continue to lead with innovations that make life easier for our customers, whether it is award-winning mobile apps, digitally enabled smart branches, or our new corporate Mastercard with biometric security features, a first in North America. But our investment in technology goes even deeper. We are introducing new business models and re-energizing older ones.
We are redeploying unused capacity across the bank, and as a result of this, we are unlocking new sources of value for our customers and for our shareholders. This transformation extends to every line of business and is integral to the fulfillment of our long-term strategy. In fact, technology plays such a crucial role in driving overall performance that in the latest refinement of our strategic priorities, we have brought it to the foreground, making it a priority in its own right. I would like to take a moment to review some of the foundational elements of our technology transformation. First, our new architecture integrates more than 1,400 applications that previously operated independent of each other or were difficult to connect. It also enables us to create new applications quickly and easily, not one-off apps designed to solve specific problems, but adaptable software services we can use again and again.
Perhaps most importantly, this framework makes it possible to gather data from all areas of the bank and conduct detailed analytics of everything from risk management to the effectiveness of marketing programs. We have re-engineered our systems to allow a single relationship-based view of every customer. Our various businesses can perform as one bank, coordinating the delivery of diverse products and services, and it is now easier for customers and their bankers to access a wealth of knowledge as they explore options and arrive at better decisions. The result is a more personal bank for a digital world. A good example of this evolution is BMO SmartFolio, one of the best investment experiences in the personal wealth market. Unique in the North American marketplace, it was designed, developed, built, and launched in only six months, a fraction of the time it would have taken just a couple of years ago.
In the same way as adviceDirect took the guesswork out of self-directed stock picking, BMO SmartFolio, based on our proprietary family of ETFs, helps customers build a personalized portfolio in moments and build their savings through a smarter experience. If you haven't had a chance to try it, I highly recommend it. Our overall digital channel strategy is unfolding at the same rapid pace. In the next few years, we expect to see a further migration of personal service interactions, as much as 50%, from the branch and contact center to mobile channels. Customers who prefer to connect with us this way get the quick, satisfying answers and the on-the-go service tools that they're looking for, with the knowledge that a banker is always there when they need anything. We're also using technology-driven insights to improve the banking experience in areas less visible to customers, such as risk and compliance.
Streamlined processes and advanced technology have allowed us to reach key anti-money laundering milestones more quickly and at a lower cost than we initially estimated. Just as importantly, the work is yielding deep knowledge about how all our customers do their banking and how we can serve them better. In these examples I've highlighted, and many more I could add, the ultimate purpose of technology innovation and the test of its success is an enhanced customer experience. By digitizing our business processes, we enable faster, smoother transactions at a lower cost. But the real goal is to make things easier for our customers, to give them more direct control over the choices they want to make and make for themselves, and to show them that we understand and respect what they value most, their time. It isn't about launching apps and adding convenient features.
It's about saying to customers, "We're ready to meet you where you are, when it suits you best, with new tools designed to help you manage your financial life on your terms." We all know that our smartphones and tablets are amazing pieces of technology, but for most of us, they're also an extension of ourselves. They're how we connect with people we care about, find and purchase things we need, figure out how to get somewhere, and watch everything from last night's game highlights to a video of the new baby. Banking belongs there too. In helping people to connect with our bank in different ways, we're more supportive and engaged, and that's the point I want to underline this morning. Our goal in empowering customers through technology is not to avoid having conversations with them. It's to have more conversations with them.
In our digitally transformed bank, branches matter, but the transactions that bring customers into our physical spaces are changing, as are the skill sets of the people who are there to serve them. You may begin a transaction using your phone, then ask a question and get a response via video chat with a real person. Or there may be a banker next to you, tablet in hand, to see if you need help, and then either show you how to complete the transaction on your own device or introduce you to someone, a mortgage specialist, an investment advisor, for a more in-depth discussion with whoever can provide the guidance that you need. We're evolving the roles that our frontline employees play, along with the physical footprint of the bank, to complement what can now be delivered to our customers in a more contemporary way on their favorite device.
As always, it's the customers who are setting the pace. We can provide the products and services they need as quickly as they're ready to adopt them, and as changes in the broader environment, like more available bandwidth, pave the way for further innovation. Because advancing our capabilities with optimal speed doesn't mean doing things in a tearing rush. As we enrich the customer experience and as we limit effort or expense that doesn't add to that experience, it's changing how we structure our organization, how we design our branches and offices, and how we do our job as bankers. We're evolving from linear, sequential tasks to faster, more adaptive processes, and from vertically integrated teams to cross-team collaboration. This creates more meaningful work and greater prospects for personal growth.
We're also tapping into partnerships with third parties if they're using technology in interesting ways that complement our own thinking. Collaboration makes sense when we can see the opportunity to speed up change at an advantageous cost. A final thought on the work of innovation. It's anchored by a fundamental attribute of the bank that cannot be invented or bought, and that's trust. Even in a fast-moving world, in fact, precisely because things are changing so fast, all of our stakeholders expect us to manage our business responsibly, to act with integrity and transparency, to be accountable for our actions, and to give back to the communities where we live and work. To reflect the values of the people you serve, you start by holding up a mirror to yourself, because we know we only earn the right to manage people's money through the confidence that we inspire.
This is how we build trust, the foundation of customer loyalty, and it is loyalty that drives sustainable growth. In 2015, the adjusted revenue of BMO Financial Group was CAD 18.1 billion, up 8% from the previous year. Adjusted net income was CAD 4.7 billion, or earnings per share of CAD 7, an increase of 6% over 2014. Just a quick reminder, we report financial results in Canadian dollars, but break out U.S. and Canadian dollar revenue and expense to reflect the underlying growth rates in constant currency. The importance of this view has increased with the size of the bank's U.S. business, which now accounts for 32% of our total revenue. In fiscal 2015, we paid common share dividends of CAD 2.1 billion and repurchased CAD 600 million of common stock, effectively returning over 60% of earnings to shareholders.
We contributed almost CAD 1.7 billion in government levies and taxes, and we acquired BMO Transportation Finance, North America's largest provider of truck and trailer financing, with an equity value of CAD 1.6 billion. The strong results across the bank's principal operating businesses were delivered against a set of clearly defined strategic priorities. They demonstrate the benefits of a deliberate approach to risk, backed by solid capital strength, reflected in a Common Equity Tier 1 ratio of 10.1% at the end of the first quarter. This past year's performance reinforces two fundamental strengths that differentiate the bank: an advantaged business mix across our diversified North American footprint and a well-established brand in all of the regions where we do business. Most significantly, the sustained growth of this bank reflects our deep understanding of what customers need and expect from us.
The transformation initiatives I have spoken about today are ultimately aimed at delivering a superior banking experience and growing our customer base. These remain the keys to value creation. We have grown share of wallet in Canadian personal banking for the last six consecutive quarters. Across the bank, we are focused on knowing our existing customers better, converting single product purchases to banking relationships, which yield higher revenue and generate more referrals. At the same time, we are targeting those segments that we believe will deliver high value, including small business owners, recent immigrants, millennials, who in many cases have yet to forge long-term banking relationships. Satisfied, confident customers lead to growth in both revenue and net income, delivering value to the shareholder. Transformation isn't something that's happening to our bank. We are initiating our own transformation and driving it forward.
At the point where customer experience and efficiency converge, we are meeting customers' changing needs in ways that win their loyalty and reinforce our brand in the digital marketplace. There are many ways to think about what lies ahead: change, disruption, opportunity, growth. We have gotten closer to our customers, made banking simpler, unified our businesses, expanded our footprint, invested in new platforms, embraced the better rule book, and through it all, delivered consistently strong results. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Bill. That's a great speech. Great job.
Thanks for helping me write that.
He's good. We will now turn to some additional procedural matters. I have been informed by our transfer agent that over 307 million votes have been received by proxy in respect of the matters of business to come before this meeting, representing approximately 48% of the total outstanding shares eligible to be voted. Given that our employees represent an important part of our shareholder base and to facilitate these proceedings, we have asked certain employee shareholders or proxy holders to move and second certain motions. I will call upon them at the appropriate times. The votes on the four items of business before this meeting requiring a vote by shareholders will be conducted by paper ballot, and the other motions will be voted on by a show of hands.
On registering for the meeting today, proxy holders and registered shareholders wishing to vote in person at the meeting today should have received a paper ballot. The ballot covers the election of directors, the appointment of auditors, the approval of the advisory resolution on the Bank's approach to executive compensation, and the one Shareholder Proposal No. 1 to be voted on at the meeting. If you have already voted by proxy before the meeting, you do not need to complete a ballot today. Any proxy holder or registered shareholder wishing to vote in person this morning and who did not receive a ballot at registration, please raise your hand, and representatives from Computershare will provide you with a paper ballot. Are there any such people wishing to vote in person who need a ballot? I see none, so we will keep going.
Now to our first item of business, the submission of the financial statements. In March 2016, copies of our annual report for 2015 were forwarded to shareholders together with the management proxy circular and notice of this meeting. The financial statements for the October 31, 2015 year-end were included on pages 135 to 201 of the annual report, and the auditor's report thereon can be found on page 133. We will take all of this as read. Are there any questions or comments on the financial statements? Questions or comments at this stage in the meeting must be related to the financial statements and not to other matters. Are there any such questions or comments? I see none, so this will bring us to the election of directors for the ensuing year.
As determined by the Board, the number of directors to be elected today is 12, with all 12 current directors standing for re-election. I thank all of my colleagues for being willing to serve again. Information on each of them is contained in the management proxy circular for this meeting. I would like to take this opportunity to thank the Board members for their service. They are a special and immensely talented and dedicated group. They work hard and well for all of you, and it is an honor for me to serve with them as Chairman. I particularly want to note the contributions of Christine Edwards, Ron Farmer, Philip Orsino, and Don Wilson, who chaired our standing committees over the past year and did so to great effect. They are terrific leaders of our Board.
Also, I cannot let this opportunity pass without expressing our collective gratitude to Dr. Martha Piper, who served as a Director for over nine years until this past September, when she stepped down from the board to return to the University of British Columbia to serve as interim President. When the university called in its time of need, Martha agreed to return to the university she had led so brilliantly well a decade earlier. We understood and supported her choice. Martha was a superb Director, and we will miss her enduring contributions. She was an outstanding Chair of the Governance and Nominating Committee, but she was much more than that. She was an inspiration to management and Directors alike, as she brought her passion for Canada and for the bank to all of our work, and she set high expectations for all of us to meet.
She made an important difference to our work, and she made our bank better. On behalf of all Directors and shareholders, we thank her for being such a splendid colleague and contributor to our work. I would now ask each Director to stand when his or her name is called and to remain standing till all the names have been called. Among the names called is Philip Orsino, who is regretfully unable to be here today due to the death of his father on the weekend. I'd like to express our deepest condolences to Philip and his family. I call on Barbara Muir, our Corporate Secretary, to present the nominees for election to the board. Barbara?
Thank you, Chairman. I now nominate the following persons to be elected as Directors of the bank until the next succeeding annual meeting of shareholders or until their successors are elected or appointed: Janice Babiak, Sophie Brochu, George Cope, William Downe, Christine Edwards, Martin Eichenbaum, Ronald Farmer, Eric La Flèche, Lorraine Mitchelmore, Robert Prichard, Don Wilson III.
Thank you, colleagues. You can be seated now. I now call on Kelly Harper to second the motion. Kelly, tell us what you do for the bank before you second the motion.
I work here at the IFL, and I am responsible for customer and employee experience.
Thank you very much.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My name is Kelly Harper, and I second the motion.
Thank you very much, Kelly. Are there any questions or comments on the matter before the meeting, the election of directors? I see none. Oh, I am sorry. I am sorry, sir. We will have to get you a microphone so we can all.
So we color it in black?
You can do either. Both work. Tick, color, circle, any way of indicating your preference. Thank you for your question. The bank provides for individual voting for the directors. The Bank Act provides that you may vote for or withhold your vote for the election of each of the nominees. I remind you that the board of directors and management recommend voting for all 12 nominees set out in the management proxy circular. We will now proceed with voting. Please mark your ballots now, if you have a paper ballot. The polls will remain open until all the matters have been voted on, and then we will collect the ballots at the conclusion of the four votes.
If you've had time to mark your ballots, we'll move to the next item of business, which is the appointment of the auditors for the ensuing year. I call upon Faline Templer to present this motion. Faline, please introduce yourself and what you do for the bank.
Thank you, Chairman. My name is Faline Templer. I've been with the bank for five years at the IFL for four of them. I'm a program delivery manager, and my team supports personal segment learning for P&C Canada, Personal and Commercial Canada, and Personal and Commercial in the U.S.
Great. What are you going to move?
I propose that the firm of KPMG LLP be appointed as auditors of the bank for the ensuing year.
Thank you very much. I will call upon Greg Scott to second the motion. Greg, what do you do?
Thanks, Chairman. My name is Greg Scott. I work here at the IFL. I lead the Canadian Senior Facilitation Team. These are the folks who bring our courses to life in the classroom.
Thank you very much for your work, Greg. Do you second the motion?
I second the motion.
Thank you very much. Are there any questions or comments on the motion to appoint the auditors? I see none, and so I invite you then to vote on the appointment of the auditors and to mark your ballot. You are asked to vote either for the motion or to withhold your vote. I remind you that the board of directors and management recommend voting for the appointment of the shareholders' auditors, and we will proceed with the voting now. Please mark your ballots if you have a paper ballot. Again, we will collect the ballots at the end of all the voting. The next item on the agenda is the consideration of an advisory resolution on the bank's approach to executive compensation. I call upon Andrea Pitchinen to present the motion. Andrea, what do you do?
Hi. I work here at the Institute for Learning for the past four years, and I manage the customer experience learning and brand.
Terrific. Thank you. Your motion, please?
I move that the advisory resolution on the bank's approach to executive compensation, as set out on page six of the management proxy circular, be approved.
Thank you very much, Andrea. Monica Patel, will you be prepared to introduce yourself and then second the motion?
Thank you, Chairman. I am a contract specialist working in planning and facilitation here at the IFL, assisting in the management of third-party facilitators, and I second the motion.
Thank you very much, Monica. Are there any questions or comments on this motion? I see none. I would ask those wishing to vote on the advisory resolution on the bank's approach to executive compensation to now mark your paper ballots. You are asked to either vote for or against the motion. I remind you that the board of directors and management recommend voting for the advisory resolution on the bank's approach to executive compensation. Please mark your ballots. We'll take a moment to give you time to do so. The final matter on the agenda for voting is the shareholder proposal, known as Shareholder Proposal No. 1, relating to streamlining financial reporting. The shareholder proposal to be voted on today was submitted by MĂDAC.
MĂDAC's proposal and their supporting comments, as well as the bank's position on their proposal, are set out in full on pages 47 and 48 of the English management proxy circular and pages 51 and 52 of the French version. For your convenience, a copy of the management proxy circular containing the shareholder proposal was provided to you this morning. You already have the paper ballot that includes the shareholder proposal. You'll be asked to mark this ballot once the proposal has been presented. After we've dealt with the proposal, the ballots will be collected and tallied. I'm pleased that Madame HĂŠlène Dufresne is here today representing MĂDAC. Madame Dufresne, thank you very much for joining us today in Toronto for our annual meeting. I appreciate your traveling to be with us. Would you please present MĂDAC's proposal dealing with streamlining financial reporting, Madame Dufresne?
[Foreign language]
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. My name is HĂŠlène Dufresne, and I represent MĂDAC. Our proposal consists in streamlining financial reporting. It is proposed that the board adopt an action plan to streamline financial statements and make them more accessible, or establish a committee with small shareholders in order to streamline financial statements and make them more accessible. For nearly 20 years now, MĂDAC has been reading numerous financial statements and annual reports. Throughout the years, we have observed an information overload and noted that financial information has become a tedious exercise of compliance that is losing relevance for shareholders. In short, annual reports are increasingly voluminous and more often than not confusing rather than informative for readers.
It is imperative that the bank ponder this issue and commit over a certain period of time to revising its financial reporting in order to streamline it and make it more accessible. By way of example, the MĂDAC worksheet presents on a two-sided, 8 1/2-by-11 page the highlights of an organization's extra-financial and financial performance for the previous financial year. From a financial point of view, such worksheets contain information allowing less sophisticated investors to assess the ability of a business to generate sustained profits, as well as the level of financial security it may procure based upon its debt ratio, market capitalization, and credit rating with the rating agencies.
From an extra-financial point of view, they provide an overview of improvements made by management to certain aspects of its corporate governance, including the roles and composition of the board of directors, the senior executives' compensation, the pay gaps between employees and managers, the presence of women on the board of directors, et cetera. We offer our collaboration to participate in your streamlining committee and are making representations to the regulatory authorities and the Canadian Bankers Association to make this project a reality.
Thank you very much, Madame Dufresne. We appreciate your respect for everybody with the brevity and clarity of your comments. Thank you for that. We appreciate the ongoing dialogue we have with MĂDAC. Does anybody else wish to comment on this matter? I see no one else rising to speak. We will move to vote on the matter. This is Shareholder Proposal No. 1, streamlining financial reporting. I remind you that the board of directors and management recommend voting against this proposal for the reasons set out in our management proxy circular. I would ask those of you wishing to vote on Shareholder Proposal No. 1 to now mark your paper ballots. This brings us to the conclusion of the voting on the items of business before the meeting. I invite the representatives of Computershare Trust Company of Canada to now collect the ballots.
Those of you who have ballots, please raise your hand or pass your ballot to the end of your row. There is one behind you there. We will get them collected and counted promptly. Are there any more ballots? There are still some at the back there to be picked up. Any more paper ballots to be picked up? Raise your hand if you still have one. There comes one more. Any more in the room? I see none. We have decided this year we are going to wait while they are counted. We will take a minute or two, a little pause. Feel free to talk to the person to your left or your right. They are all part of BMO. Never met a BMO person I did not like. Get to know each other.
We'll just take a minute or two, and then we'll be back with the vote counts, and we'll proceed with the rest of the meeting. Ladies and gentlemen, our scrutineers are back with the vote count. They've completed their preliminary report on the results of the voting, combining all the votes that were voted in advance of the meeting with the votes that were cast with the paper ballots. I now call upon Steve Gilbert to read those results. The scrutineers report in final form will be available shortly after the meeting. Steve.
Good morning, Mr. Chairman. We, the undersigned scrutineers, hereby confirm the following preliminary results. No director standing for election today received less than 95.5% of the votes cast for a director. On proposal number 2, for the appointment of shareholders' auditors, approximately 99% were in favor and less than 1% withheld. On the advisory vote on the bank's approach to executive compensation, approximately 92% were in favor and approximately 7% against. The vote on the Shareholder Proposal No. 1 for streamlining the financial reporting, approximately 2.3% of the votes were in favor, approximately 97% were against, and more than 1.7 million votes were withheld on the proposal. The scrutineers report to sign Steve Gilbert, scrutineer, Sonia Ciavaglia, scrutineer.
Steve, thank you very much for that. I therefore declare that the 12 nominees listed in the management proxy circular are all duly elected as directors. On behalf of my colleagues and myself, I thank you, our shareholders, for your confidence in us. KPMG LLP is duly appointed as auditors for the ensuing year. Congratulations to KPMG. The advisory resolution on the bank's approach to executive compensation has been approved, and the shareholder proposal has been defeated. We'll now move to taking general questions. Questions should be by shareholders or proxy holders only and should be of interest to all shareholders and not be of a personal nature alone. I would ask that in order for everyone to hear, please go to the closest microphone, or if you would prefer to have a roving microphone brought to you, please raise your hand.
Please stand by for me to recognize you to speak. Once I do, please identify yourself by name and state whether you are a shareholder or a proxy holder. Just a reminder that questions from those shareholders participating in this meeting online are also welcome. I invite anybody who has a question to stand and be recognized. Madame Dufresne.
I am surprised to see that there are no questions. I would like to tell you about a dispatch from the Agence France-Presse from last week. It is entitled "Israel Caps Bankers' Salaries." It is dated Jerusalem. The Israeli parliament adopted on the night from Monday to Tuesday the salary of bank bosses to CAD 862,000 a year. This law specifies that no salary paid in the financial sector may exceed 35 times the salary of the least well-paid employee within the same company, with a hard cap of ILS 2.5 million. This law meets both ethical requirements as well as the values involved in managing funds of the public, as stated by Moshe Gafni, member of the Parliamentary Finance Committee. End of quote. I would suggest that this dispatch is of interest.
This is an act passed in Israel to cap bankers' salaries, and I believe that our Canadian bankers would be well inspired to ponder this law. If bankers cannot discipline themselves in respect of their compensation, perhaps the Government of Canada might bring in similar legislation. Thank you.
Thank you, Madame Dufresne, for your comment. I do not think there was a question at the end of that, and so we will take it as a comment, and we welcome your observation and intervention in the meeting. Are there any other comments or questions any shareholder or proxy holder would like to make? I see none. I see no one rising. I will conclude the question and answer period and make my final comments. Before we do finish, there will be a video. Bill talked about a fundamental attribute of the bank that cannot be invented or bought, and that is trust, earning the trust of all of our shareholders. I invite you to turn your attention to the screen for a short presentation that reinforces this thought very well.
What does a 200-year-old company need to learn about sustainability? Fact is, we never stop learning. To reflect the values of the people you serve, you start by holding the mirror up to yourself, because we know we earned the right to manage people's money through the confidence we inspire. It starts with tracking billions of customer transactions moment by moment, flawlessly. It means protecting customers' privacy and the security of their information. We build confidence every time we are there with expert advice on a first mortgage or a merger. And trust grows when you prudently manage risk and empower a rigorous governance structure to oversee it all. At BMO, we know that when you promise to manage people's money, values matter.
What do we need to do to make sure that we remain ethical in the face of challenges?
Because stakeholders want to know that the things you do reflect their ideals and aspirations, you ask them what matters most to them.
Talking to our stakeholders helps us prioritize our agenda and the work that we're going to do.
For us, sustainability means respecting many environments. That's why we lend and invest responsibly to support green initiatives. It's why we're a leader financing housing in Aboriginal communities. It's why we strive to create a workplace that inspires our employees, one that's diverse and inclusive.
You set the tone for the environment where everyone can succeed.
It's why we donate to our communities to make life better for everyone. To protect the air and water that sustains us all, we work to minimize our footprint. Jacky, this is one of 140 branches equipped with a remote monitoring and control system. That's why we strive to make this a better place, better than the way we found it, and one ready for the next 200 years.
In closing, I'd like to thank all of the people who were involved in supporting today's event, including those who handled the closed captioning and the English and French interpretation. Most importantly, I'd like to thank all the shareholders and employees who took the time to join us today, either here in person or online. That concludes the meeting and its formalities. I declare the meeting terminated, and I thank you all for being here. Thank you very much.