Bank of Montreal (TSX:BMO)
224.49
-6.57 (-2.84%)
Nov 20, 2026, 4:00 PM EST
← View all transcripts
RBC Capital Markets Canadian Bank CEO Conference
Jan 7, 2020
Summary
Slower macro growth and rate pressure frame 2020, while all four businesses enter the year with positive operating leverage and a 2%-or-lower expense growth outlook. Credit is generally healthy; PCLs are expected to normalize higher and capital may build if lending slows.
Thank you for having me. Your boss is a tough act to follow.
Well, let's follow.
Let's follow.
But before we do-
Yep
Not to worry, though. Before we begin, I have been asked to tell you that Darryl White's comments today may include forward-looking statements. Actual results could differ materially from forecasts, projections, or conclusions in these statements. Listeners can find additional details in the public filings of BMO Financial Group.
Done it.
Thanks again for joining me this morning. For your opening question, I got the sense that you felt that we were entering 2020 with momentum. Maybe you can give us a bit of color around that, and how does the macro environment factor into that momentum that you are seeing going into 2020 for Bank of Montreal?
Okay, that is a good place to start, I guess. I would qualify what you have just asked, Darko, with relative momentum, because I think you framed it quite well. We have got the macro environment, I just caught the tail end of the last discussion, and we have got how our business performs within that macro environment, and I think it is important to talk about both. The macro environment, we saw the shift begin really. It is actually interesting, isn't it? As I am sitting here, I am having almost a déjà vu as you and I talked almost 365 days ago, coming out of what felt like a capital markets calamity in the last three months of calendar 2018, and the conversation that was omnipresent then was all about that and what was really going on.
And then, of course, we had what felt like a couple months of calm. Then through the course of the balance of 2019, that is when we saw really two things happening on the macro environment, which I think colors to a great degree where we are today and where we are going on your question. The first of those was the rate cuts that we saw, three consecutive rate cuts at the Fed and the flattening of the yield curve. We are still today in the environment where we are living with a yield curve that has a little bit of perceptible shape in the U.S. I think this morning between twos and tens, we were around 30, 35 basis points, and in Canada, almost none.
The second factor on the macro side is what we have all talked about, which is a slowing macro and economic environment in North America with us. Remember, about 85%, 90% of our activity is North America. When I talk about it, I sort of think about that slowing environment and the lower rates and the flatter yield curve. But when I step back from it, Darko, I look at that slowing environment, I say, "Well, where are we slowing to? Are we still growing?" We are definitely still growing. I mean, I think the U.S. economy this year will probably Nobody has got a perfect crystal ball, but if I had to cuff it, I would say it will probably be between 1.5% and 2% growth in 2020. Compare that to last year, we do not know the number yet, but let us say we land around 2.5%.
That is a slowing down, but there is still growth in that economy, and it is an election year, and that probably translates back to Canada with a similar range. With that as a backdrop, when I talk about momentum, I look at the decisions that we have made and the businesses where we traffic, and I am at the point now where I can say in every single one of our businesses, I believe with a stable environment, the one that I have just described, even though it is growing a little bit slower, we have got relative momentum that is quite impressive.
I say that when I look at our Canadian businesses, our P&C business in Canada, our P&C businesses in the U.S., our wealth management business, and our Capital Markets business, where if you look at our fourth quarter, in all four of our businesses, we had positive operating leverage, and we think we stacked up very well on almost any financial metric as we published our fourth quarter. It is that momentum that we bring into 2020 against the backdrop that I just described, which of course is the backdrop that we are all living with.
Given that, I mean, we look at last year's numbers, about, let's just say 5% EPS growth, about 14% ROE. You are targeting 7-10 EPS
Yeah
and a higher ROE.
Yeah.
2% operating leverage, which sounds like you are really emphatic that there is momentum on the operating leverage, right?
Yeah.
What about the other target?
Yeah.
Is it achievable in 2020?
Yeah, let's talk about the EPS. I think what we said at the end of the quarter is that we're not changing our view on our midterm targets on EPS. Ours is 7% plus. At the same time, we said that 2020 is likely to be more challenging in order to get there, and that's just math, right? If you look at the way in the year that I just described, in 2019, our revenue growth was 6%. That revenue growth at 6% was pretty good relative to the peers. I think the peer average of Canadians was 5%, and we were 6%. Layer on everything I just said carrying into 2020, absent inorganic growth, we've been pretty clear and declared that our expense growth, we think, for the first time in a very long time at the Bank of Montreal, will be 2% or better.
Better meaning lower.
Exactly. 2% or lower. If you think you're going to get to 7% EPS growth, you have to have a view that you've got an 8% or a 9% or a 10% on revenue. That's not going to happen. I don't think it's going to happen for us or for others, absent something unusual going on in the environment. I can tell you I'm very confident in the 2% or better on the expenses. Revenues we'll have to see, because all of these environmental issues that we've just talked about, you and I, will play out over the course of the year. But I think signing up for 7% EPS growth is very aspirational. Somebody would have to have a very aspirational view, and I think you and others have validated that in the work that you've done on revenues in order to get there.
Having said that, we might get close. It depends on what happens over the course of the year. What we do when we look at our midterm targets is we have a look at what we think of the year. We do the analysis that I just took you through, and we began this work, actually, in our case, almost a year ago, to look out at the environment and say, "What would our reasonable response be?" Our reasonable response was a pretty definitive change in the shape of the curve on the cost structure. We, at the end of the second quarter last year, told all of you that the second half would have a growth rate in our expenses that would be approximately half of the growth rate of the first year. It doesn't roll off the tongue really well, but I think you can follow.
It's exactly what it was. In our fourth quarter, we were less than 2% on our NIX, and that's because we had this view going forward. That we know we can deliver. We can deliver that through 2020. We'll see where the revenues come out. Then the second thing you do is you say, "Well, are you going to therefore throw out what you call your medium-term growth targets and sign up for something less aspirational?" We say, "We're absolutely not going to do that." If I look back over the last three to five years, we have hit our EPS growth target four out of the five years. We've averaged over 7% in the three-year horizon and the five-year horizon.
We set aggressive numbers, but we think of them in that two, three, five-year horizon, and we're comfortable signing up for that based on our history and our view of the future, just not necessarily in the next 10 months.
Okay. One of the things that helped you last year with the revenue growth was strong loan growth. Actually, both sides of the board, but why don't we pick on the U.S. first?
Okay.
You had very strong loan growth in the U.S., and the question that I often get is, how do you get such strong loan growth without either competing on price or on credit quality?
Yeah.
And-
You're in commercial?
In commercial in particular, given the strength of what we saw last year. Maybe you can touch on and highlight what you're doing in the U.S.
Sure. For people who don't follow as closely Darko's question, our loan growth in the U.S. last year in commercial, in our P&C business, was low double digits. It was around 12%, which was clearly industry-leading. What I would do is kind of take you back to industry structure and strategy, which I've talked about before. Very different in the U.S. relative to Canada. To set up the commercial story for us, you always have to remember where we are from a relative perspective. We're the number 2 commercial lender in Canada. Maybe you'll come back to that after we go through the U.S. In the U.S., we're a top 10 commercial lender. In Canada, there are, I don't know, maybe 10 or 12 good competitors. In the U.S., there are hundreds.
We are a top 10 among the hundreds, and the top 3 or 4 or 5 sort of looks like Canada. They are fighting for a tenth of a basis point every day in terms of share growth. After that, it gets to competitors who have 1% and 2% and 3% market share, or fractions of that, as you get to hundreds of participants into the U.S. marketplace. BMO is in the top 10. When you put our U.S. and Canada together, we think we are the sixth-largest commercial lender on the continent. That is my way of starting by telling you we are really good at this. We have been at this. Some people around our place say we have been at this for 200 years. We have been at this for decades at least, and certainly since 1984 in the U.S. when we bought the Harris Bank.
This is not a social experiment for us. When we decided a couple of years ago that we wanted to drive more operating leverage out of our U.S. business, bring our efficiency ratio of our U.S. business down to the enterprise number, which the U.S. P&C number is now below the enterprise number, it was because we were going to make investments in people, create capacity with the technology, with the balance sheet, and with the client relationships. We started to grow that business faster than the market by taking advantage of that industry structure, which frankly has a lot of competitors who are half our size, a quarter of our size, a tenth of our size, who just do not have the ability to compete in the way that we do. It is a share game.
I look really carefully at spreads, and while spreads for the overall market in C&I, which you can see they are all quite well documented and published in the U.S., came down through the course of 2019. Ours came down too, but they did not come down faster than the market. We were participating in the market. We were not buying share with price. We were taking share with our competitive ability because we have been doing this for a long time. We put people in the market. We put more people in the market through the course of the year, and we invested in that with a balance sheet that, for us, when we look at our capital allocation strategy, has among the highest ROE efficiency and growth rate, and does not compromise our risk appetite.
For us, it was a little bit of a no-brainer, I have to say, when you go back two or three years and say, "Where do we have a real opportunity to differentiate and compete and put the marginal investment dollar?" We are very happy that we did. I will say, before you go on to your next question, we have also said that you should expect that to moderate. I do not think we are going to see double-digit increases in our commercial lending business in the United States this year. That will mostly be driven by demand. That is the slowing of the U.S. economy that I have talked about. We will have a demand reduction this year.
We think we'll still be pretty strong as we come through the early part of the year, but our forecast is, as the year goes on, we're going to see a reduction in the growth rate of that based on market demand. Whatever that market is, we think we'll continue to grow faster than the competitors.
With that slowdown in lending and the rate environment, one would expect NII growth to be significantly slower in 2020. That's a fair, I think, observation, but what's your view?
Yeah. It's harder to predict, I must say, in the U.S. than Canada. If you look at the NIM compression through the course of 2019, you saw the compression. We made no apologies for it because the marginal loan was generating better ROE than some of our other businesses in the historical legacy book, so we went with the market through the course of 2019. I think you heard us say in our fourth quarter call we would see a little bit more compression in the beginning of the year. I think that's probably going to be the case in the first quarter. After that, it feels like we've cycled through the rate change. If you think about where we now are in the calendar, we're in the second quarter calendar of 2020.
I think you'll probably see, my best guess, Darko, would be flattish from there on in for the rest of the year in the U.S.
Sometimes I get this question, and it is an interesting one because we just saw you deploy a lot of capital organically in the U.S., and yet the question often comes back to, "Well, what about acquisitions in the U.S.?
Yeah.
Given the environment that we are in, a little bit of a slowdown, are there opportunities for you to build out your capabilities?
Yeah, there are always opportunities, there is just not a lot of good ones. That is the problem. It is really not that complicated. We look at the comparison of the opportunity to do basically what I just said and build a business, generate earnings growth within the risk appetite, and build more clients for the long term, versus going out and doing an acquisition. We compare them all the time. We get shown probably most of what traffics in the space in the U.S., and so far we have not seen anything that has competed effectively from an IRR perspective, in addition to the other things that we talk about, of course, strategy, culture.
From an IRR perspective with what I have just described to you in terms of how we have built the business organically, there could be a point in time at which that changes, but we have not seen it in the last couple of years. You just do not know. It is also circumstantial, right? Sometimes these things come along. If I look at some of the great acquisitions we have done in the U.S., if you go back to the transportation finance business we bought from GE in Dallas-Fort Worth, if you go back to the M&I acquisition, book value acquisition in 2010, if you look back to some of the smaller ones we have done in capital markets have been fantastic additions, like the KGS acquisition, I could not have sat there and forecasted any of them to you three or four or five months before they happened.
Sure.
They happen, you look at them, but the ones that we've looked at in the last three or four or five months and the year before and the year before just haven't stacked up against our organic opportunities.
You mentioned KGS-Alpha. I was actually going to go there as a follow-through for the next question, which is, we've seen you build out the investment banking platform.
Yeah.
Are you finished? Is there more to do?
Yeah, I don't know if you're ever finished. I think the better way I think about it is, where are you in the trajectory of investments relative to harvesting returns in consideration of the environment as well as where the competitors are? I would say where we are right now is, absent something just too good to be true showing up on our doorstep, we're probably on some version of pause and harvest to get the returns out of what we've invested in, both people, capital, some small acquisitions. But at the same time, there could be something that just looks great, it's a capability that adds to what we're already doing, and we can fill in a hole in our offering. If that comes along and it's not outsized, we'll do it.
Absent that, Darko, I would say we are really happy with what we have built in the capital markets business in the U.S. and in Canada. There was a note out yesterday in one of the mainline press outlets on league tables and market shares. I think we showed up very well relative to any of our Canadian competitors. We were sort of in the top three almost everywhere in a slower market, I would say, in Canada. In the U.S., I remember talking to you and others three years ago about having an aspiration to get our U.S. capital markets business to start contributing over $70 million of net income per quarter. Now you have seen us contribute well above that, well above $80 million or $90 million, and that has been driven by the investments that we have made.
You saw us take some action early in the year on our capital markets headcount. We took that action because we saw this environment that I am talking about coming. I think you will see us in the next bit here really work hard to deliver positive operating leverage out of the capital markets business, and we started to differentiate there towards the end of last year. I think we will start differentiating in the second, third, fourth quarter of this year on operating leverage. All the way back to your question, if something really interesting comes along, then we will add to it, but in the meantime, we think we are really well-positioned to harvest the gains from what we have invested in.
What we With Dave up here earlier, his view was that RWA growth would be slower in the cap markets business. Is that something that you are planning for your cap markets business?
Slower than?
Well, slower than past, I suppose.
Yeah.
Are you looking to extend balance sheet aggressively in the capital markets business and in the U.S. in particular?
Yes, we're continuing to grow the capital markets business, but we don't see ourselves growing the capital markets business at a faster rate than the rest of the bank.
Okay.
If you look at the amount of capital that we have to deploy, it would be surprising to me if you and I were sitting here in a year from now and you said, "Hey, gee, capital markets balance sheet grew at X and the rest of the bank grew at X minus something.
Okay.
So, we'll just continue to invest at a regular organic pace.
Fair. So, let's switch gears and go back to Canada, and let's touch on commercial lending growth because there too, as you say, you're a top 2 player, I guess, in Canada on commercial lending side. Strong growth last year. What are you seeing on the commercial lending side now? Are we seeing increased competition, lending terms loose or tightening? Any description there, because similar to the question in the U.S., the question that I get often is, what is BMO doing to get such strong growth in Canada?
Yeah. So there, well, the similarity with our business in the U.S. And by the way, we run them together, right? We run this as an integrated business. The sales spine is set up from an organizational perspective where we've got commercial lenders who understand sectors. We swap best practices across border every day, every hour some days. And so, we run this as a really tight integrated business, which we think is a real differentiator for BMO. Now, back to Canada, the difference between Canada and the U.S. is here we are the number 2 player. And so what we find on the competitive point is, yeah, there's competition. There should be competition. We've got good competitors. And the competition on price or terms comes and goes. I would say, when you're the number 2 player, a lot of people come at you.
We have seen more competition come at us, trying to knock us off the puck on pricing or terms or hold sizes, than the other way around. When we look at the data carefully, we can see no evidence, and I want to be clear on this, that we are out buying business. When I actually look at I look at it every month, and I look at the credit data every single month, and we can see no evidence in the Canadian commercial business that we are sacrificing spread. In fact, our spreads have gone up over the last few months. And then what we do is we look at where there are contested situations and how often do we end up winning or losing, and we actually lose more often on price than we win.
We make pretty disciplined decisions on returns, and that's the luxury, frankly, of when you have a leadership position. We do see some aggressive behavior in the marketplace today, but if you took me back over the course of five or 10 years, I'd be able to point to 20 different short bursts of time where that behavior has been aggressive, and then it might go away, and it might come back. I don't really read too much into it other than we've been really, really, really clear on our strategy, which is we're going to defend that number 2 position in Canada, and in the U.S., we're going to continue to grow the position.
What about the health of the commercial borrower? Are we seeing more leverage in the system for the commercial borrower, and however you want to describe it, that-
Yeah. Yeah, it's a good. I would say the commercial borrower is generally very healthy. I say generally because when you look across the board, you can't see any secular trends that would lead you. I spend a lot of time on this with our Chief Risk Officer, with our risk management committee, and we dissect it, and we turn it over, and we ask ourselves the question again. We say, "Do we see clear deterioration where we can draw trends or themes through the commercial book in Canada or in the U.S., regionally in Canada, regionally in the U.S., by sector?" The answer is generally no. The commercial borrower is healthy. Now, if I go specifically, you've heard us say we can see some hotspots.
The oil and gas sector, for sure, there are some idiosyncratic hotspots that are emerging, and we can see some places there. We talked earlier about agriculture as well. It's small for us, but certainly it's under pressure, particularly in the U.S., not so much in Canada. We do see some areas where the heat map sort of flashes a little bit. Then, of course, when you have a big commercial book, you're in a lot of credits in a lot of places, and you'll have some lumpiness. You'll have some idiosyncratic events that really have nothing to do with anything other than the borrower itself ran into some problems that they didn't foresee, and you'll always see that for us and others.
You have to really be particular in the answer to this question, but I would come back to where I started, which is generally, we haven't seen a deterioration in the level of health. Those would be the hotspots that we're watching carefully today.
What would your expectation be for growth in this loan category for 2020?
You should look at the U.S. coming. I said to you before, in commercial, our U.S. loan growth was double digit, low double digit. I think it'll be not double digit this year. I don't know how to be more particular than that other than that I'd be surprised, quite surprised, I would say, if we showed you 10% growth in the U.S. We might be there in the early part of the year, but taper off as the year goes on, just from what I can see in the economy and the borrower appetite. In Canada, we'll continue to participate at the rate of the growth of the market, and we'll defend our share. What will that end up being?
I have to be honest with you, the market growth itself has surprised me on the upside in Canada for the last couple of years, and so I'm not particularly good at projecting that. I've been wrong before. But what I've been right at is saying that we're going to defend our share, and we're going to continue to make sure that we protect those client relationships. So wherever that market growth rate is in Canada, we'll be there or maybe a little bit better.
We had acute NIM compression in the U.S. What is your expectation for Canada?
I think Canada will be a little bit better. I think in Canada, we will see NIM flat to improving slightly over the course of the year.
That is with one rate cut assumed in the-
That is with one rate cut assumed. We could have a long debate on whether that rate cut will in fact happen.
Okay. Fair enough. Let's turn to some of those idiosyncratic one-offs that we saw last year on credit quality, and you mentioned, I think you were touching on it, just want to be sure that there isn't a particular trend that you saw that stood out for you. Maybe you can just talk to your guidance for the year going forward, because you guys had sort of provided a range on your PCL.
Right.
When I sit back and I say to myself, "Well, if you had all these one-offs, and I take out the one-offs, why would your range be higher in 2020?" Maybe you can just talk to that today.
Yeah. The range that I think you're talking about is, we've said and Pat said pretty clearly that we're guiding to the low to mid-20s on our PCLs. You really have to remember that the period of time where we and others were moving through really low PCL levels is pretty unusual. If you get into the low to mid-20s, we'll still be, you have all the data, Darko, but we'll still be materially below most of our peers in the low to mid-20s, of course. Your question is a good one because when you go back to last year and you say, "Well, if you have more idiosyncratic events," I don't know if we're going to have more idiosyncratic events, right? We may, we may not. There's always going to be something.
There'll be one this quarter, there'll be two the next, there'll be zero the next. You really don't know what there's going to be in the year to come. When you look back, you have to remember that not only might you have had that pattern that I just described, but you might have had idiosyncratic recoveries.
Sure.
Which we also call out, right? We have called out, and we had a couple of those last year, particularly in the U.S. You do not plan for that. You do not sort of put in your business plan, I am pretty sure that this credit that we wrote down by CAD 20 million four years ago is in fact going to show up in Q2 of this year. It shows, but it does. It just shows up. You have a big diversified business, and these things will come and go as well they should. I think that is generally the answer to your question. What we see is just a slight move up in the PCL trend overall, assuming you neutralize for idiosyncratic ups and downs.
You just see a slight move up, which for us, by the way, that slight move up for people who have not followed us closely is kind of from the mid to high teens. It is amazing that that is the case, but it is mid to high teens into the low to mid 20s.
Thinking about credit, we had the question earlier, which is, we are starting to see insolvencies rise in Canada. Why is this not a concerning trend? Why is not this something that has banks on high alert?
Yeah, I cannot speak for everybody else. When you say banks, I will speak for us, though. We are starting to see insolvencies increase. The headlines, I think, first of all, you have to be careful because you see these massive percentage increases basically coming off something that is close to zero. Be careful with the baseline. No question, in the meantime, insolvencies increasing are a concern. Speaking for our bank, remember, our Canadian consumer lending portfolio is less than 15% of the revenues of the bank. We are underweight the Canadian consumer relative to others. If things were really bad, they would be better on a relative basis for us. It does not mean I am not concerned about it. I am concerned about it.
I think the last point I would make is that it is really important when you look at the health of the Canadian consumer that you pay attention to both sides of the balance sheet. There is a little bit too much work out there, in my view, that talks about the consumer debt level, but does not balance it out against the consumer, the household assets, the liquid assets that are held in houses, and the investment portfolio of the average borrower in Canada. When we look at that put together, we can see a bit of a rising concern, but it is not nearly as acute as some of those headlines would lead you to believe when you just look at big insolvency increases or you just look at debt levels, absent looking at the other side of the consumer balance sheet.
Yet, all the same, we saw from Bank of Montreal throughout the year, not a massive change, but we saw you go a little more pessimistic on your reserves in Stage 1 and Stage 2.
Yeah.
Slightly more pessimistic scenario that we saw in the annual report. Can you talk to the level of reserves? I guess the question that everybody is really interested in is, look, are they sufficient and are you prepared for, and is the bank ready for economic uncertainty that could evolve into a recession? How should we think about how prepared and how reserved Bank of Montreal is?
Yeah. So I will give you the long view, then I will give you the short view. The long view, when I look back, if you consider the Bank of Montreal's track record, and we have this chart in our investor presentation that goes back a couple of decades that shows how we perform through cycles on losses, on performing losses, and we look at provisioning, then we look at actual losses. We think we are pretty good at this, bluntly, relative to just about anybody. So we come from a culture of conservatism that we build in, and we have not just invented that in the last five years. It has been in the DNA for a very long time, and that is front line, second line as well.
When I look at the shorter run, if you look at the provisioning that we did through the course, I think the time period you are talking about is through 2019, you do adjust your view of the economic cycle. You do adjust your view from time to time on the scenarios that you use on the performing. When I look through it over the course of the year, then I look at the stack of our most direct competitors, there is not anything that I can see that does not tell me that we are not reserving at the conservative end relative to others. That does not mean, by the way, we are perfect and we are right. It just means we are reserving a little bit more conservative than the average of our peers, depending on which metric you choose. I think you have done this analysis too.
We might be the most conservative or the second most conservative relative to the peer group. Then, Darko, you have to kind of go down and spend time with sleeves rolled up and fingernails dirty and talking to the people who are in the businesses and talking to the customers. In our case, I talked about underweight personal, overweight commercial. If you go back to the commercial story and how healthy is the consumer and how healthy is the commercial borrower, as I said, the theme is general health. I compare that to our level of relative conservative provisioning, and I come to the conclusion that it feels to me like we are in a pretty good spot. If we pop up with an idiosyncratic event at some point in the year, it will really have nothing to do with anything I just said.
Because provisioning is an art and a science. You are effectively trying to forecast prudently the probability of every single credit in your book ending badly, then you bring that forward on a present value basis. We do that, and we turn it over, and we test it, and we bring the committee back together, and we test the models, and we bring the committee back together, and we test the models. Then you come out with the provisioning that we have got. It is quite a rigorous and elaborate system. Then, as I said, I match that up with the anecdotal work that we do through the client base, and we get pretty comfortable with where we are.
I want to ask a capital question here and there amongst all the Canadian banks, so I flipped a coin a couple times outside. Your bank came up for the capital question, so you are going to get the question on capital. I want to set this up. OSFI had created a Domestic Stability Buffer, and it increased it three times in a row.
Yeah
at every opportunity that it could. When we started the journey, the banks generally were at a level. OSFI increased the Domestic Stability Buffer three times, and today, the bank's capital ratio is actually lower from where we started that journey.
Right.
So the question is to you, I mean, is there an optimal capital, Common Equity Tier 1 ratio for you in 2020, irrespective of what's going on with the Domestic Stability Buffer, or how should I think about that?
Yeah, it's a good I think the short answer to your question is you should think about it as somewhere right around where we are now. If there's a slowdown in the demand for commercial lending, for example, that I talked about earlier, then you're going to see us build capital, and you're going to see by the end of the year that we'll have a higher capital ratio than we do right now. But if we ended the year where we are right now, that would be low relative to our peers, but it wouldn't be something that would be anywhere near the threshold on the Domestic Stability Buffer and the OSFI ratios, and the OSFI provisions. So, I think the way you should think about it is you look back over the course of the last year.
Here's an interesting This is right at the heart of the capital allocation decisioning that you make kind of every week, every quarter, every day when you're trying to run businesses and maximize the value for the shareholders. You asked me earlier about beating the market on growth and commercial lending. Had we not done that, this is quite interesting. Had we actually grown at the rate of the market in commercial lending in the U.S. and not increased relative to the market, our current CET1 ratio would be 30 basis points higher than it is today.
I sit there and I look back and I go, "Is that a good trade?" I think, "Absolutely, it's a good trade." Because what we've done is we've said the best deployment of that capital is so that I can invest in existing clients and new clients where I'm going to have real relationships within the risk appetite that are going to continue to pay us for years to come, relative to hoarding the capital or buying back shares. I look at that and I say we ended up where we are now at 11.4. That's a pretty good place to be. Absent really aggressive balance sheet growth or M&A, that'll build at the end of the year. If it doesn't, it'll be because we found more attractive deployment of capital opportunities.
I think you also heard Tom say that if it continues to build towards the end of the year, we could be back in the market buying back our shares, but we're not in the meantime, given where we are.
Okay, great. Solid answer. We're going to turn to the questions. The number 1 question from the floor is, restructuring charges are just a pull forward of expenses. Why can BMO not do this on a normal recurring basis? Is growth focus overwhelming management focus on other operating fundamentals?
Other operating fundamentals.
Sorry, my eyesight's terrible.
Yeah, mine too, but I got it at the end there. It's amazing, right? We're down to two minutes on the clock before the restructuring question comes.
No, it's my fault.
No, no, here, this is important though. I'm actually glad it's come up because it's important that we talk to shareholders clearly about this. We announced in our fourth quarter a sizable restructuring charge. We were very clear, I was very clear that we do not intend to pull this lever again. The reason for that is because there's a lot different in what we're doing right now. If you look at prior restructuring charges, we have heard shareholders when they have said that there's restructuring fatigue with respect to the Bank of Montreal. We've heard you loud and clear on this, and we have said at the same time, we need to do it this time, and we need to be clear with you that we're not going to need to do it again.
That is because if you look fundamentally at where we are in our trajectory today, our expense growth in the fourth quarter of 2019 fiscal was less than 2%. We are already on a trajectory that was very different from where we had been in the past, number one. Number two, we are driving very different accountability through. If you think about working for an organization that has a, I will call it, a habit of going to the well on restructuring charges and then going back to that well, what you create is a management incentive to wait and not manage through all the way down through very specific LOBs through the spine of an organization and not manage through the discipline of annual, "Can you keep, Darko, your expense growth this year at 2% or 1%, at 3%?" "Well, I do not know.
Maybe yes, maybe no, but if I go higher, I know that the gift is going to come along in a little while." We have said not just to shareholders, but internally, this is very different this time. We are going to have rigorous business plans that people are going to be accountable for delivering because you are not going to be able to use this technique, and we are using it for the last time because we actually have to eliminate real work in the meantime. So I could show you are out of time on the clock, but I could show you lots of examples of this current round where it is delicate to talk about right now, I must admit, because we are right in the middle of executing it. You can imagine, we just announced it a month ago.
There is some serious work going on to say when we execute against this, because we have said 5% of our population, we have to make sure that 5% of the work goes away. In order for 5% of the work to go away, we have to make sure that when this box is eliminated on the chart, that it is absorbed by others. It does not just sit vacant for six months before we have somebody else come in and fill it, in which case we have not satisfied our deal with our shareholders on the restructuring charge. We are doing that through technology. We are doing that through rewiring the organization on org chart, on work, on flow, and it is completely different from anything we have done in the past. Therefore, we do not think, as I have said pretty clearly, we are not going to need to do this again.
Thank you very much for that. That sounded like a key message, but is there another key message or two that you want to leave with your shareholders?
No, I think we've talked about most of them. I'd be very brief on it, Darko. I would say, I go all the way back to where we started. I think that the relative momentum of what we've built for this bank, two years ago, we talked about having increased our technology spend by 10% each year for the last three years. Now we feel really good on what we've been able to deliver digitally. We've got an offering in the U.S. where our digital bank is collecting deposits in all 50 states, number one in the App Store in Canada, top 10 in the App Store in the U.S., by the way. Our digital platform is enabling everything I've just talked about.
That's the only thing we didn't really touch on here, you and I, so I wanted to make sure I got that in at the end. Relative to our strategy, hasn't changed, but our operating agenda, all four businesses delivering with a balanced portfolio, we think we've got relative momentum that we haven't really had in quite a long time. So I feel quite optimistic about it, regardless of what the macro environment delivers for all of us.
Okay. With that, we'll leave it there. Thank you very much, Darryl.
Thank you.
Appreciate it.
Thank you.
Thanks, guys.