Earnings Call: Q2 2014

Dec 4, 2013

Good morning. My name is Jody and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Brown Forman Corporation's 2nd Quarter Fiscal 2014 Conference Call. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. After the speakers' remarks, there will be a question and answer session. Thank you. I would now like to turn the conference over to Mr. Jay Koval, Director, Investor Relations. Please go ahead. Thanks, Jody, and good morning, everyone. I want to thank you for joining us today for Brown Forman's Q2 2014 earnings call. This morning's conference call contains forward looking statements based on our current expectations. Numerous risks and uncertainties may cause actual results to differ materially from those anticipated or projected in these statements. Many of the factors that will determine future results are beyond the company's ability to control or predict. You should not place undue reliance on any forward looking statements, and the company undertakes no obligation to update any of these statements whether due to new information, future events or otherwise. This morning, we issued a press release containing our results for the Q2 of fiscal 2014, and the release can be found on our website under the section titled Investor Relations. In the press release, we have listed a number of the risk factors that you should consider in conjunction with our forward looking statements. Other significant risk factors are described in our Form 10 ks, 8 ks, 10 Q reports filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. During this call, we will be discussing certain non GAAP financial measures. These measures and the reasons management believes they provide useful information to investors regarding the company's financial conditions and results of operations are contained in the press release. Now before I turn the call over to Don for his prepared remarks, Paul wanted to share some brief comments with you. Paul? Thanks, Jay, and good morning, everyone, and for joining us for this communication of our Q2 and half year results. In addition to Jay and myself, we're joined today by 2 of our colleagues who are familiar to most of you and to our investment community at large and who are the principals in a forthcoming transition in Brown Forman's financial leadership. That is Don Berg, our current CFO, who will be retiring at the end of this fiscal year and Jane Moreau, our incoming CFO, who will assume her new responsibilities on February 1. As is our norm, Dom will provide a detailed description of our results released this morning before we take your questions. But before we turn to that, I want to briefly touch on the first half results, give you a little more background on Jane and pay a much deserved tribute to Don and his service to Brown Forman. First with the first half results, I'm very pleased with how the company has continued to perform and be positioned, particularly in light of what appears to be a more moderate posture for most of our publicly traded global competitors. With the well balanced worldwide growth of the Jack Daniel's trademark leading the way, our company's growth rates and underlying sales, gross profit and operating income remain top tier within our competitive set. Our return on invested capital continued to be very strong on both an absolute and relative basis. We continued to invest behind our business via both the P and L and through the strongest level of capital reinvestment in recent memory. Our balance sheet remained in excellent shape giving us the flexibility to invest further as necessary and advisable. And our consistent return of cash to shareholders continued with both share repurchases and our recently announced double digit increase in the annual dividend. Alongside the vast opportunity we believe exists for our business around the world, these are some of the reasons for current optimism and they are enabling us today to reaffirm our earnings guidance and our expectations of excellent full year growth and underlying operating income. Don will give you more color on all of this in just a moment. Let me now turn to Don and Jane's forthcoming transitions. I'll first start with Jane, who has over 30 years of excellent business and finance experience, including 22 years here at Brown Forman. When Don became CFO in 2008, Jane was already his senior most direct report and was our Controller and Chief Accounting Officer. And at that time, she joined our executive leadership team. Over the years, she has played a very significant role in the company's business and financial operations. This is included to cite just a few, leading our implementation of and compliance with Sarbanes Oxley, leading the financial integration of our Spirit Brand acquisitions as well as the financial separations related to our dispositions of both consumer durables and wines, authoring much of the company's internal and financial reporting and forecasting, devising and leading the implementation of the company's planning and budgeting and being the company's go to corporate analytical resource for most of the last 15 years. Beyond finance, in recent years Jane has worked closely with our brand and regional operations, overseen our information technology function and for the last year provided excellent leadership to our production operations. She is a proven senior executive and her knowledge of Brown Forman's business operations is virtually unmatched. Jane has deep experience in our boardroom and while she has not been the face or voice of the company to the financial community to the degree that she will be in her new role, She is very familiar with our approach to Investor Relations, and I look forward to her carrying on Don and Brown Forman's track record of financial excellence. So Jane, welcome back to an environment I know you're quite familiar with. Would you like to add anything? Yes. Thanks, Paul, and thanks for the kind introduction. Keep this really brief, but I want to convey how excited I am to soon serve as Brown Pharmacy's F. O. I believe I'll be taking over at a great time when the finance organization and the company are both in very good shape. Our strategy is clearly defined and has been articulated and our organization is aligned around it. And of course, you all saw the earnings release this morning and you see from our first half results, which were very strong, our company is executing well and delivering what we believe to be top tier performance. I believe that the finance team is a source of strength for our company, I believe is a testament to the team that Don has created and led over the past 6 years. Finally, I'm really looking forward to getting to know our loyal shareholders better in person and on future earnings calls. Thanks. So thanks, Jane. You all will be hearing, of course, a lot from Jane in ensuing months, and I'm sure you'll enjoy getting to know her much more closely than you would have through speakerphone over the last many years. So let me shift gears now. And of course, I want to publicly thank Don for his superb contributions to Brown Forman's success over the last quarter quarter century. Think about that, a quarter century. His leadership of the company's financial operations as CFO over the last 6 years really can be measured by just studying our results that period. And as most of you will already know, they were very strong in both absolute and relative terms. Alongside the impressive quantity of our results, Don and his team have played the leadership role in ensuring Brown Forman continue to have an equally high quality of results. We have long enjoyed a reputation for financial transparency, integrity and responsibility and Don and his finance team have been highly capable stewards of that reputation over the last 6 years. Unlike many traditional CFOs, Don's path to the CFO role encompassed a wide variety of important assignments ranging from leading the company's strategy and corporate development functions to overseeing Brown Forman's early emerging market operations. The impact of some of this work done earlier in his career can be seen in the results we are announcing today. Along the way, Don served on the company's highest level committees and councils for the better part of the last 15 to 20 years, where we witnessed a smart and experienced executive who brought us deep, balanced and often unique insights about our business and our industry. On behalf of everyone at Brown Forman, I want to simply say thank you to Don for his leadership and congratulations on the success he's enjoyed at Brown Forman over these last 25 years. Don, I hope Brown Forman will be a source of fond memories for you for many, many years to come. With that, let me now turn the call over to Don so that he very appropriately can discuss our company's excellent first half Thanks, Paul. This will be my last earnings call at Brown Forbin. And I can't help but feel a little nostalgic after hosting with Paul and Jane since early 2,008. So before I discuss first half results, let me make a few quick Listening to Paul and thinking about all those great memories, I mean, my 25 years at Brown Forman have been truly great ones. I've had some tremendous opportunities here in a variety of capacities. And as I think about it, of course, the company is only as good as its people. And I've been very, very fortunate to have worked with many exceptionally talented people here. I also want to say that during my 6 years as CFO, I've really enjoyed the time I spent with all of you, the investment community. I'm fortunate to have worked for a company that's been performing very well, delivering some of the best total shareholder returns in any industry, let alone the spirits world. You all have heard me tell the Brown Forman story countless times and I truly believe that the company is well positioned for the future. Having said that, I'm very much looking forward to the next chapter in my life as I retire from Brown Forman. While I'll assist with the transition through the end of April, the actual handoff of the CFO role to Jane will occur on February 1. And as you've heard, with over 20 years of finance experience at Brown Forman, including almost 5 years working together with her as the Controller and Principal Accounting Officer, I know she's very well prepared to jump into this position. So with that, let me move on to the business at hand and update you on our recent results. I plan on covering 3 topics today. I'll start with a review of our mid year results, then I'll share our updated outlook for fiscal 2014, And I'll close with a review of our approach to capital allocation, including an update on our capital investments. So let me start with my first topic, a review of first half results. We are pleased to report that our underlying net sales grew 7% in the first half of the year or 4% on a reported basis. Underlying net sales growth in the 2nd quarter was 8%, significantly ahead of the Q1's 5% growth. As you know, within the first half, we were faced with some timing differences versus last year, where our results in the Q1 were negatively impacted by year over year comparisons and where the Q2 benefited from easier comps. We believe that virtually all of that is behind us now and our 7% year to date net sales growth keeps us on track to achieve the high single digit full year outlook we shared with you last quarter. We are particularly encouraged by our ability to deliver such strong rates of growth despite recent announcements from industry competitors discussing how an emerging market slowdown has negatively impacted their own results and outlooks. We continue to believe that our balanced geographic footprint, our focus on North American whiskey and our premium contributing factors to our consistent delivery of industry leading rates of growth. So let's start by looking at our revenue drivers on a geographic basis. Underlying net sales in the emerging markets continued its growth trajectory, up 7%. The business we have is broad based and fast growing. Double digit rates of growth from relatively lower basis are China and Brazil. Thailand, Turkey, India and the CIS markets each also grew well into the double digits. Global Travel Retail was another bright spot for the company, delivering low double digit sales growth. Travel Retail now represents about 4% of our total revenues and has been a great place for us to innovate as well as launch premium product offerings such as Sinatra Select. We have seen some softness in 2 of our larger markets, Mexico and Poland, which were down low single digits. Remember that these markets were impacted by the price increases that we implemented at the start of this fiscal year for Finlandia in Poland and for new mix in El Jimador in Mexico, which resulted in significant buy ins at the end of last fiscal year that we've been working through in fiscal 2014. Excluding these countries, our emerging market business would have grown underlying sales by over 20%. In the United States, underlying sales grew 5%. It appears that the momentum behind distilled spirits continues with market share gains from beer and a healthy price mix contribution, particularly in aged spirits. The off premise in the United States has been a key driver of our results over the last few years and performed well again in the first half of this year. But it does appear that declining consumer confidence is negatively impacting on premise trends, which remained weak year to date. In the developed markets outside of the United States, underlying net sales grew 7% in the first half. Our spirits business in Western Europe enjoyed solid market share gains against a backdrop of declining spirit sales for many competitors. We attribute much of this to the strength and focus of our brand portfolio as well as the flexible approach we take in our route to market strategy. United Kingdom and France each delivered strong growth in the first half. United Kingdom's results benefited from retailers stocking up for the holiday season earlier than last year and we believe we are well positioned for an excellent holiday season there. After a sluggish start to the year, Australia delivered modest underlying growth in the 2nd quarter, resulting in low single digit growth for the first half. Our new distribution arrangement in Japan has helped us drive strong rates of underlying growth, up high teens, although we would expect these growth rates to moderate in the back half of the year as we begin to cycle against the January 2013 distribution changeover to Esahe. While on the topic of route to market changes, we are eagerly anticipating the January 1 launch of our own distribution company in France. We believe that this investment will allow us to leverage our existing scale over 600,000 annualized cases today and the 14% compounded annual growth rate in reported net sales that we've achieved over the last 10 years. Naturally, there is an incremental infrastructure cost associated with this investment and that will hit SG and A in the back half of the year. We made similar investments in markets such as Germany, Turkey and the U. K. Over the last number of years and we have seen firsthand that having a dedicated sales force selling a focused portfolio has enabled us to achieve strong rates of growth through market share gains in countries that competitors often describe as mature. We believe France has similar potential. Once France is online, we will own distribution assets or control the sales force in 8 of our top 10 markets. In the two exceptions, Japan and Russia, we have very strong partners in Asahi and Coca Cola Hellenic coupled with local ground foreman folks with strong market knowledge and the brand building know how that has been helping drive double digit gains in each of those markets over the last year. Now let me look at some of our results through a brand lens, beginning with our most important trademark, Jack Daniels. The Jack Daniels family registered robust underlying net sales growth, up 10% in the first half of the year. Its global appeal as the premium imported American spirits brand has helped to begin penetrating many of the markets the scotch and white spirits dominated through the 20th century. We continue to believe we are in the early stages of realizing the full long term potential of this trademark outside of the United States. And inside the United States, we believe that disciplined flavor innovation and brand enhancing line extensions up the pricing ladder will continue to drive growth. As we think about flavors, Jack Daniel's Tennessee Honey is now one of our largest standalone brands approaching 1,000,000 cases. Underlying net sales grew 30% in the first half, but we anticipate slower rates of double digit growth in the back half as we lap major launches outside of the United States and expect more moderate rates of growth in the United States. Combined underlying net sales for Gentleman Jack and Jack Daniel's Single Barrel grew 15% in the first half. Given the success of these super premium expressions of Jack Daniel's, we launched Sinatra Select last year in duty free and have been pleased with the consumer demand of this $150 limited offering. We also recently launched Jack Daniel's No. 27 Gold, a twice mellowed, twice barreled whiskey that will allow us to compete in the ultra premium whiskey segment. While it is currently sold exclusively Singapore duty free at about $100 a bottle, early results are encouraging and we anticipate rolling it out to additional travel retail stores soon. Similarly, the success of Winterjack in Germany led us to test this premium price ready to pour product in the United States last year. And this winter, we are selling Winterjack in 30 states. We believe that Winter Jack allows us to bring new consumers and drinking occasions into the Jack Daniel's family of brands. Our other whiskey brands also performed well in the first half. I'll start with our founding brand Old Forester. Year to date, underlying net sales are up 16% as we look for new ways to build brand awareness for this high quality premium bourbon that was one of the only bourbons legally sold before, during and after prohibition. Old Forester recently won recognition as one of the best buys in bourbon wine enthusiasts, and we are repositioning the brand at a more premium price point. The Early Times family of brands grew underlying net sales by 5%, and Canadian Mist grew 1%. And Woodford Reserve continued on its growth trajectory, growing 27%. With only 15% of our Woodford sales derived from outside the U. S, we believe the global growth potential for this brand over time is enormous. In vodka, Finlandia's family grew underlying net sales by 1% driven by double digit growth in Russia. Results in Poland, the brand's largest market, were down slightly as better price mix only slightly offset the volume declines after price increases were taken at the start of this fiscal year. Moving on to tequilas. At Adura's first half underlying net sales grew 7%, rebounding in the 2nd quarter after a sluggish start to the year. El Jimador sales grew 2% year to date as nice growth in the United States was offset somewhat by stubbornly competitive mainstream tequila marketplace in Mexico. Agave prices continue to climb, but we have yet to see that translate into better pricing discipline in the category. Southern Comfort's results were mixed in the first half. Results outside of the United States were a bright spot, up low single digits. Results in the United States were below our expectations, down high single digits. We believe that while the media campaign helped drive better unaided brand awareness, it wasn't enough to overcome the competitive pressures facing the Liqueurs category as well as weaker on premise trends. Also facing this environment, not surprisingly, Tuwaka and Chambord's underlying sales were both down in the first half as well. Comparing our underlying reported sales results, year to date top line underlying growth of 7% was negatively impacted by 2 points due to reductions in distributor inventories and another point due to the strengthening of the dollar, resulting in 4% reported net sales growth. Underlying gross profit increased 8% year to date as reported gross margins increased 1 percentage point. Underlying A and P spend increased 8% and underlying SG and A increased 4%, primarily due to the favorable timing of various expenses. In the aggregate, underlying operating income grew 13% or 9% on a reported basis. Diluted earnings per share also increased 9% year to date from $1.49 to $1.62 So all in all, we are pleased with our results in the first half and our continued industry outperformance due in no small parts to great work of our associates, our diversified geographic footprint and a portfolio focused aged spirits. So let me move now to my second topic, an update on our outlook for fiscal 2014. Despite a backdrop of slowing global growth driven largely by various emerging markets, we believe we are on track to deliver the high single digit underlying sales growth we shared with you at the beginning of this fiscal year, albeit towards the lower end of this range. In addition to the more challenging comparisons in Japan in the back half, we would also anticipate a difficult comparison in in Mexico in the Q4 as we lap last year's price driven buy ins. We expect our price increases, improved mix and benign cost inflation will help drive full year gross margin expansion, although at a slightly slower rate than what we achieved in the first half of the year. A and P has been growing roughly in line with sales and we expect this trend to continue over the course of the full year. But SG and A is running behind full year expectations due to timing, particularly as it relates to the January 1 transition to owned distribution in France. As such, we expect the first half's operating income growth of 13% will moderate in the back half and result in full year operating income growth of between 9% and 11%. In an environment where competitors have been tempering expectations, we are pleased to reaffirm the full year outlook that we shared with you at the beginning of this fiscal year. This should result in an EPS range between $2.80 $3 per share. Our full year outlook includes an expected impact from the French inventory buyback of minus 0 point expected to be roughly neutral versus fiscal 2013, a $0.02 improvement from our outlook at the beginning of the year. To help you model the potential impact from changes in foreign exchange, a 10% move in the dollar in either direction would impact EPS for the balance of the year by approximately $0.06 So let me now move to my final topic, a review of our long standing approach to capital allocation and a quick update on the capital investments we've been making as we look to the next generation of consumers of our brands. As you all know, our first priority at Brown Forman is to find high return investments that can drive long term sustainable growth and yield multiples of that initial investment. This includes the step up in capital spend last year to just under $100,000,000 as well as the $140,000,000 to $160,000,000 that we expect to spend in fiscal 2014. Year to date, we've invested about $60,000,000 behind these large scale expansions of future production. The construction is progressing well, currently on time and on budget. We would expect these capital requirements to moderate in fiscal 2015 and return to more historic levels in 2016. As the new distillery at Jack Daniels, the Cooperage in Alabama and the expansion at Woodford Reserve all come online. Given the efficiency and stability of our business model, strong and growing free cash flow permits us to target growing the dividend each year. And we announced our 30th annual increase a few weeks ago, growing the dividend by almost 14%, while maintaining a payout ratio in the mid to high 30% range. We've been clear on our M and A strategy and we keep our eyes open for assets and brands that would be complementary to the ones we already own. But with few attractive opportunities available at the right price, we've been able to return substantial amounts of cash back to shareholders through a combination of special dividends and or share buybacks as we did in fiscal 2013 and as we've continued to do in fiscal 2014. Brown Forman has a great track record of creating value for shareholders through disciplined capital allocation. We don't anticipate changes in approach that has served our company or shareholders so well. So to summarize, we feel really good about our results in the second quarter and over the first half of the year. We are delivering solid underlying sales growth and we are driving strong leverage to the operating income line. And we believe that these results keep us on track to deliver on our full year growth outlook. We are entering the holiday season cautiously optimistic about the back half of fiscal twenty fourteen and will closely watch the competitive environment and monitor consumer behavior over the coming months. Looking longer term, we believe is very well positioned. The business is highly focused on categories such as North American whiskey, which is enjoying superior growth in volume and price mix. We also have a geographic footprint and portfolio of brands that offers us the long term upside of growing our business in untapped parts of the world with little of the near term drag due to the recent slowdown in some of these markets. The Brown family's commitment and engagement continues to provide us with a stability to execute on a strategic plan measured in decades the Your first question comes from the line of Vivien Azer from Citi Investment Research. Hi, good morning. Good morning, Vivien. Let me be the first Don to congratulate you on a wonderful tenure at Brown Forman and wish you the best of luck in your next endeavors. And Jane, congratulations on your new role. Just to dive right into the questions then please, can we drill down a little bit in terms of U. S. Spirits category on premise versus on premise, brown spirits versus white spirits, please? What specific question would you like to add? If you could offer some color in terms of the relative growth rates on premise versus off premise in U. S. Spirits and specifically as that relates to brown spirits versus white spirits? I mean, I'll do a little, Don. You might think that's the same. I'd say I'll start with the brown white. I mean, I think the most significant thing, and there wouldn't be any sort of recent news on this, Vivian, that would be new to things we've said in the past as it relates to what's happening with the whiskey, particularly American whiskey business in the United States and where it's taking share, I think, from within total distilled spirits. And of course, I think Don mentioned this, where total distilled spirits continue to take share within beverage alcohol as well. And so all of those, as I think we've said in the past, we have those of us who've been around long enough at Brown Forman endured periods where we were on the receiving end of share other companies or other category share gains. And so it's really great to have the wind at our back. Now within it specifically, what I would observe is that there's been a real discontinuation. There's real appeal in this U. S. Whiskey business of really two dimensions of it. The ultra premium, the very premium pieces of it that are beginning to play. I'm going say, oftentimes we market at below or above the Jack Daniel's price point. What I'm talking about here, the price points above the Jack Daniel's price point have been very attractive in the Bourbon and U. S. And North American whiskey business out here for a while, the last several years. And so that seems to be continuing with great excitement. I mean, we know we can see that in the numbers and anecdotally. Additionally, this flavored piece continues to expand. And it's not just I actually don't think it's just a rollout of new flavors either. I think a lot of the brands that hit were the beginning brands in this have continued to grow organically. And of course, we have one of the foremost brands in this segment with Jack Daniel's Tennessee Honey. And so that has been where the excitement is. If you were thinking about it then converting it over to the P and L, those businesses have also been able to get moderate pricing over the last couple of years, more so than they were achieving in the prior years. So I mean, in terms of being positioned for momentum, you have ultra premium category in whiskey that's doing very well. You have innovation that seems to be driving the flavored aspect. And Don mentioned Winterjack, which we're just now introducing into, I think, 30 states in the United States, which is not as high approved as say Tennessee Honey, but it's still I think it's a 30 proof, it might be. So it's a lower proof, I think, in full strength, that's sort of mid proof. And but it's a very it's a flavored ready to pour, we call it. And so all of this is creating great excitement around Brown Forman's traditional business. And vodka is continuing to do well in the United States. We have seen a little bit of softening. We've been hearing about anecdotally in the flavored vodka arena, maybe some oversaturation with flavors or a little flavor fatigue. I don't know I don't have any data that tells me that people are shifting from flavored Vikas to flavored whiskey so much. But we certainly have been hearing some of that more anecdotally. Don, did you have anything on the on off? Sure. I mean, I'll talk a little bit about that. The key data that we use and just trying to get a sense of what's happening in that market generally comes from our NAVCA data. And you have to be a little bit careful. The NAVCA data, as you know, most of those markets tend to be more in the interior of the country, and they don't capture some of the bigger markets like New York and California and Washington, Florida, where some of the trends get set. But directionally, it gives you a sense of how the on premise trends are moving. And when you peel that back, I mean, basically, the on premise has been softening for a while. We've been watching it now probably since about this time last year. And it is now down to a point where it doesn't look like it's growing at all and could even be slightly declining a little bit. And when you step back and you look at it over a long period of time, there can be different things that really kind of drive some of the consumer behavior. Sometimes it's high gasoline prices. Sometimes it can be a little shocks in the market of one nature or another. But this has been trending down for a little while now, and it's hard to really say exactly why. As I mentioned in the script, I mean, we had tended to see some hits in consumer confidence of late. And there has been a lot that's been going on kind of at the government level in terms of government shutdowns and different things that can affect different people's psyche and how much they want to go out and what have you. But it's been a concerning trend. And also, as I mentioned, we have a couple of brands that are skewed somewhat to the on premise that have been hit disproportionately. And as the on premise has continued to soften, it seems to be an environment where the competition within the on premise has continued to increase. And so we think it's one of the areas where Southern Comfort has been hit as well as some of our other Liqueur brands. I can't give you much more color than that other than we have been seeing it and you've heard others talk about it as well. And hopefully, this will stabilize and start moving back in the right direction soon. I mean, the one effective impact of these channel shifts, I think we've talked about it before, is for a consumer who may be worrying about their purchases and the affordability of spirits, it's just a fact that spirits buy the drink in the on premise are getting more expensive than their traditional retail purchases. And so we watch it closely because we're skewed so premium within the business that we want to make sure now we have not would look for in this on premise, off premise weaknesses, when they when you have a difficult on premise environment, do they not consume you at all is the worry you would have. And what we've been seeing over these last couple of years, yes, I mean, if you're if the premium is, you can have some challenges. But I've been pleased that when you shift back over to the off premise and look at those results that they're holding up pretty well. And not only are they just to add to that, not only are they holding up well, but the other thing that we continue to see is the return of premiumization. And so as you look at the different price points, we're pretty close back to what we saw prior to 2,008, where the higher the prices, the higher the growth rates. And again, just to Paul's point, when you've got the premium portfolio that we have, we tend to perform better than what you in the marketplace overall. Yes. I mean, just remember this is one unique thing about our business that for a bar to sell a bottle of Woodford Reserve to its completion, my $300 So it's a real value to get Woodford Reserve at $32 a bottle when you think about it if you're a loyal Woodford Reserve drinker. No doubt. That makes a ton of sense. And thank you for all that color. One quick follow-up on the commentary, Don, please on the on premise. You mentioned kind of that deceleration in the on premise the last few quarters. As you think about the most recent quarter versus the last, was there kind of a step change that did that deceleration accelerate? Or did the softness in the on premise accelerate kind of quarter over quarter? I'll tell you, the data that I tend to look at more is the 12 month trends. And when you look at the 12 month trends over the last 3 months, you basically saw kind of where it kind of hit a bottom 3 months ago. It went up slightly last month and then it kind of went back to the bottom this month. And so again, you have to be a little bit careful with that. I mean, I would look at it more broadly in terms of what the trends are telling you than get too much into data on any one month. It wouldn't surprise me if our business, like a lot of businesses, would have been influenced by the government shutdown, the uncertainty that was created by that. Would people have watched how much they were dining out for a few weeks there perhaps, and that could have shown up in those numbers. Fair enough. Thank you so much. Thank you, Vinit. Your next question comes from the line of Nik Modi from RBC Capital Markets. Hey, good morning, everyone. Good morning. So a couple of questions from my end and again congrats to Jean and Don on both your respective situations. On RTD, just it strikes me as those businesses have been kind of struggling. And I'm just curious on is there really a structural fix here? Or is this just a function of the flavored variance of across different spirits categories perhaps making those types of products less appealing to the consumer? And then just on travel retail, if you could just provide a little bit of perspective on the trend and how it is in relation to previous quarters and years. I'm just trying to understand if that business is accelerating or decelerating in this quarter? Thank you very much. So I'll start with the RTD business. When you look at our RTD business, there are 2 markets in particular that are pretty large and drive a lot of what you see in the overall results. 1 is Australia and 1 is Mexico. And there's 2 very different things going on in those 2 different markets right now. In Australia, it has been under quite a bit of macroeconomic pressure for the last several months. And so you've been seeing that and you've been seeing that hit the RTD market as well as kind of just broad based beverages overall. And so a lot of the performance that you're hearing about in terms of a little bit lower trajectory than what you would have heard us talk about a few years ago, just a couple of years ago actually, has a lot to do with just what's happening specifically macroeconomically within that market as opposed to there's a consumer problem or there's a brand problem or what have you. It's pretty much across the board that everybody is seeing this. In Mexico, it's slightly different. In Mexico, when we bought Casa Redura in 2007, they already had this very, very strong RTD market in new mix and had, if I remember right, something close to 50% share in that market that we've been able to continue with even through today. It has become such a great growth area and a great consumer area that it has been kind of a natural invite to a lot more competition. And so earlier this at the end of last fiscal year, earlier in this fiscal year, there was a bunch of new introductions that were coming out. We took some actions within that market to try to help us competitively. We also took some opportunity to take some price increases. And so you have a bit of a shift of where the volume went in terms of where our fiscal year ended. But in terms of the overall RQD market within Mexico, while it's become a lot more competitive, I think when you look at what's happening at the consumer level and just overall, continues to be a pretty good business for us. Yes. I don't I would categorize our RTD business, in addition to what Don said, as I mean, at a very, very low level of its potential development around the world. I mean, there have to be certain ingredients in place in the markets for us to seize the opportunity, most notably, the great access to marketplace through distribution. And that's the big thing. And that does exist in Mexico and Australia for us in a great way. So we could actually get these products into distribution and service them in a way there has to be a consumer need for single serve, which there is virtually everywhere. But we'd like to think of this as an opportunity to step into the single serve or the convenience. Sometimes it's called the beer occasion, not always, it's not always called that. And so we if you were to take our total sales or our cases and divide it by the denominator of the marketplace size, it wouldn't even register because it's our case volumes would be so small on a single serve basis. So I really feel like it continues to be a great area of exploration and innovation what I hope are RTDs or maybe even these RTPs, of what I hope are RTDs or maybe even these RTPs, which are slightly different language we use for it, which are ready to pours, which would incorporate the winter jack. So that's, I think, the way we'd summarize your question related to RTDs. On travel retail, we've been doing very, very well. I think we've largely been outperforming that market, but we needed to. We were really far behind in travel retail if you go back 5 or 6 years ago and made a conscious effort to step up our investment in people and in innovation. It so happened that this is a channel that works really, really well for the premium SKU of Ramforma's portfolio, but we weren't getting as much in terms of results out of it as we thought we could. And so we've had a very nice and steady run by putting some dedicated effort and being a little more innovative with not only the products that we're bringing into that channel, but also the merchandising we're supporting it with. And so we've been really pleased with our travel retail business. And just one quick follow-up. Since the government shutdown, just curious if you guys have all the stuff has ended with the government shutdown. I'm just curious if you've seen any improvement in the consumer's behavior, any near term color on kind of any changes in consumer would be helpful. Nothing. We're so we're a couple of levels from retail and the consumer's actual transaction. So anything in that narrow a period of time, we tried I mean, we just have a hard time making a lot of sense of it. So I can't really add anything. I wish I could for you. It would help us, too. So yes, we're prone to more of the anecdotal type of information that gets shared. Fair enough. Thank you very much. Thank you. Your next question comes from the line of Judy Hong from Goldman Sachs. Thank you. Good morning, everyone, and good luck to you, Don, and look forward to working with you, Jane, going forward. So a few questions from my end. First, maybe just from your perspective, what really explains the difference in terms of how you're performing versus some of the negative commentary coming out of your competitors in your view. Obviously, the category and country exposures are different, but do you think that you're actually outperforming in some of the markets and categories? So just kind of trying to understand your category company, I'll start with it. Actually I'll start with it. Actually, I might add, even though one level below category, for us, to be quite honest, it starts the brand and which is also very much a member of a category, which is Jack Daniel's. And I think Jack Daniel's, it's likely I looked at it recently, it's likely that Jack Daniels may be more important to Brown Forman than some of the top brands are for some of our competitors. And so we're very, of course, pleased with the continuing performance of that brand. And it's really on a couple of levels. 1, how appealing it has proven to be globally and its ability to travel the world as a trademark and be successful on a multitude of levels. And not only is Jack Daniel's Black Label, but the thing that we're very, very proud of actually over the last decade or more is how it's become such a nice basis for thoughtful line extensions as well. And oftentimes, when companies will do line extensions of very powerful trademarks, I mean, their greatest worry is, am I going to cannibalize the parent brand from which I'm extending it? And knock on wood, for because I think of the way that we've thought about these and the patients we've the patient approach we've used to introducing them and developing them, we have seen relatively low levels or very limited levels of cannibalization of Jack Daniel's Black Label. If anything, we think any cannibalization we get with the introduction of something like Tennessee Honey is more than compensated for by the positive halo effect to the trademark, which is almost 150 years old. So it's nice to keep it contemporary. So I think if somebody were to ask me in 2 words, what's differing our performance versus others, it's the great work the company has been doing on Jack Daniel's trademark and how that has enabled us then as well to do other great things alongside it with the Woodford Reserves and the Herraduras and just our confidence that we can take into the marketplace for developing premium plus or ultra premium brands. I do think just to talk a little bit about the geographic SKU. There are some pretty marked differences there. I mean, when you think about the larger players in the industry, we would skew more towards the U. S. Than what the larger players would. And when you think about the U. S, it's been performing fairly well over the last couple of years. When you think about the European SKU, while we've got a sizable part of our business in Europe, we continue to really buck the trends there. And when you've got the U. K. Growing at nice rates and Germany growing at nice rates and France growing at nice rates, it does help with our business given the size of our business there. When you look at our emerging markets, I mean, today, the emerging markets represent something around 20% of our overall business. And some of our larger competitors are out there at sizes double that. And so there's definitely a geographic SKU story here. But also, when you look into those markets, I mean, we're definitely out competing in many, if not most of those markets. And some of them have different reasons than others. I mean, when you think about the emerging markets and you look at, for example, we continue we've been continuing to do really well with Brazil. That happens to be one of the markets where we changed our route to market a couple of years ago, and we've been seeing some real benefits from having our dedicated sales force there. When you think about China, we're relatively smaller there than our competitors. We've gone through quite a bit of change there in terms of really improving the organization and putting different focus on where we're executing against our brands. And we've been seeing the benefit of having made some of those changes. And so a lot to market, but there's absolutely no doubt, as Paul said, a lot of what we've seen in terms of performance is really coming from the work and the efforts of our people that are on the ground there. Okay. And then just secondly, any early read in terms of the promotional environment as we're heading into the holiday season here in the U. S? And just given the commentary about the soft on premise channel, does that raise the competitive risk in the near term? Well, I think it's going to be very competitive. I mean, I don't know that I've heard anything done that says that it's any more competitive than it always is this time of year. I think we can expect, I mean, you have a very attractive marketplace at the most important time of the year. So I expect I expect it to be very competitive. And to be looking at the sometimes we always think about that as pricing, but our folks will be monitoring a full range of items, everything from value added packaging to innovation to all kinds of things. And we think we're pretty well positioned. I'll say that with just using the U. S. As an example. I mean, we would not have had the presence in the marketplace a year ago with this introduction of winter jack, which we think is a really nice thing for a seasonal introduction like this that sets a tool in our arsenal that we didn't have last year. So we'll be monitoring to see how that does. I would just you always hear kind of the one off or two off stories about different things are happening on individual brands or in individual markets. And so I would echo what Paul is saying in terms of what we're hearing in terms of it's going to be very competitive. But in terms of hearing anything about Amade doing crazy across on some kind of scale across the board, no, we really haven't we haven't heard anything that would be considered to be out of the ordinary of a very competitive environment. Okay. And then just the fact that this year you've got a shortened holiday season between us last year when we had a longer one. It didn't seem to have much. So I don't I mean, I'd be hard pressed to forecast anything related to Indeed. O and D. Yes. I mean, it's just we look at it longer than just December. We try to think about sort of a holiday period. And for us, because it's in this country and in many parts of the world, a cold weather season, it points very nicely sometimes to our category skew. So we've been pleased by this cold spell, of course, that's been going on. I mean, so we keep our fingers crossed that it gets real chilly out so we can have people sipping on our bourbons. Got it. Okay. Thank you. You're welcome. Your next question comes from the line of Bill Chappell from SunTrust. Good morning. This is Sarah Miller on for Bill. Hi, Sarah. Hi. My first question is kind of relates to the U. S. Market. Can you kind of talk about maybe an increase in some of the competitive pressures? We've seen some of your competitors gaining share. And in light of that, can you talk about any changes to your ad spend maybe behind Winterjack or behind any other major initiatives that would kind of drive the top line in the back half? Yes. I'll touch on a couple of those. Yes. I mean, we are we always invest we used to invest, to my point of view, far too strongly during this part. So we've spread out the seasonality of our media. I think that's helped us. But we do have nice efforts in the U. S. Market behind Southern Comfort and Gentleman Jack have these last couple of years newer efforts and steady support. I don't know that we have a strong media behind Winterjack. I think it's more at retail. I think that's the correct case. And but I do think it's going to be competitive, like as we just said here, because it's in a very attractive segment. And I mean, I think and that goes across all of beverage alcohol as well. I mean, I think, remember, it's not just the spirit companies that are out there trying to compete for the consumers' dollar this time of year. It's also the beer and wine companies that have some strong seasonality to this period, too. So we expect it to be as competitive as ever. If your question related to what might that bode for seasonal spending, I mean, we I think Don referenced this in his comments, we continue to think our A and P particularly will travel around the growth rate of sales for the full year. I mean, that's about what we've been targeting. And that can always vary within Q3 and Q4 depending upon where we're spending and what we're spending behind. But we would anticipate it continuing to travel at about the rate of growth sales. Okay. And then one last question about the gross margin line. I think Don might have touched on it, but can you talk about any nuances in the back half of the year? Because I don't think you're lapping the price increase for this year until Q4. So if you could touch on that that would be really helpful. It's mostly around pricing. The last year, not this current fiscal year, but last year's fiscal year, we did take slightly higher price increases than what we did this year. And so some of that fell into the some of the as you think about year over year comparisons, some of that benefit continued to come through in the 1st few months of this fiscal year, which is why we're seeing a little bit of higher margin pop in the first half versus what we would expect in the last half where we won't be getting that kind of benefit. But it will always depend as it does particularly on a quarterly basis to really mix. I mean, we get so many fluctuations as broadly sold as the Jack Daniel's trademark is, particularly to geographic and even portfolio mix can hit us during a particular quarter. So those could have as big an influence on variations of the gross margin in a quarter as anything. Okay, great. Thanks and good luck Don in your retirement. Thank you. Your next question comes from the line of Tim Ramey from Davidson. Thanks very much, Davidson. And Don, let me add my congratulations as well and to you Jane too. So a lot of ways you can address growth here line extensions like Winterjack or Tennessee Honey, new brand platforms either acquired or created. It's been now what 16, 17 years since you created Woodford Reserve. Is there any appetite to create new brands or in this period of high innovation with particularly brown spirits, Is it just more logical to be thinking about buying them if the prices were not prohibitive? I mean, I think it's probably a combination of both and, to be fair. You certainly can control your home destiny more by creating them. They just in the whiskey business, as you would well know, Tim, just take longer to go from inception of an idea to introduction of the market because of the aging. So you can the benefit of acquisition, assuming there's sufficient inventories for any of these products, would be that you could fast forward your entry. And so you're going to do a balancing act, I suspect there, of innovation and acquisition depending upon what the market segment is. I mean, so far, we found that it's what's happening with Woodford Reserve is really, really exciting for us. It's not just Woodford Reserve base brand. I mean, it is really this Double Oaked has been a great, great addition to the line the last couple of years. And it actually the idea for it came out of an original Masters collection idea that was a limited offering years ago. And then we decided, gosh, that was so well received. Why don't we do something with it more mainstream for later on? It's been very, very well received at particularly high price points. And so Woodford Reserve, Jack Daniels, Old Forester, Early Times, Canadian Mist, they're all great bases for innovation. And I would not rule out the possibility of creating a brand new trademark. It doesn't always have to be a line extension. So those I think can be very sound ideas. But we do think we're very well positioned with the production assets we have, having several distilleries from which we could create either line extensions or new products. But there are attractive segments of the whiskey business, that exist in the United States and around the world that we are observing and watching that where line extensions, innovation or acquisition could play a role in our entry. Terrific. Thank you. You're welcome. Your next question comes from the line of Ian Shackleton from Nomura. Yeah. Good morning, gentlemen. Many congratulations, Don. Thinking about Jack Daniel's Honey, you've flagged with slow momentum in the second half. And I just wanted to check where we were in terms of new market rollouts. And while we're talking about that, what about thoughts about new flavors in the Jack Daniel's range? Yes. So there's been a number of new markets that we've gone into so far this year, Germany, Mexico, and there's a whole host of them. The one that's left for this fiscal year to get started on is the introduction of Honey in France. We decided to delay that until we had our own distribution business up and running. So we'll see that coming through once we hit that January 1 target date. And then in addition to that, I think your question, Ian, was about flavors. And you might I know it's not technically might not fit the same mold that you were thinking, but you might think of what we're doing with Winterjack on a stage rollout as an additional flavor from Jack Daniel's in this space. It's not technically presented exactly like Jack Daniel's Tennessee Honey, but that might be a hybrid of additional flavors. So we're and I do think I've said this before, I think our approach to that will be more on the conservative side. I just I think what's going on with these whiskeys is really different than what was going on with vodkas. If you think about it, the difference here is that you are beginning to add flavor to a product that is already inherently flavored, which is different than adding flavor to a product in its base is quite neutral. And so how we do that, I think, has to be very thoughtful. And so far, I think we've done a pretty good job at it. But and then when you're dealing with the Jack Daniel's trademark, you're going to be extra careful. And so, so far, we're getting good feedback for the work we've done in Flavors. Obviously, Tennessee Honey and then the early results on Winterjack has encouraged us to do more, and I suspect we'll have more ideas that we'll treat just as conservatively. And perhaps just a follow-up thing about own distribution. It sounds the numbers you've given us on France today haven't changed from previous guidance. So it sounds like it's very much on track. The fact that you've now got 8 of the top 10 markets in their own distribution and the 2 with good relationships, does that really send the message that that's it for now for the next few years or are there more markets to move here? I would say all the big ones. I mean, you're always looking at how markets are evolving and what opportunities that there are out there. So there could be some that could come up. But at least in terms of the big ones, I think we're pretty good set for the time being. This was a big deal for us 15 years ago. I mean, Don will remember it. I mean, we had lots of conversations about how we enabled basically the development of Jack Daniels, but then Jack Daniels actually helped take Brown Forman's route to market around the world because of its appeal. And a lot of companies do it different ways. You can do it through acquisition, but we were fortunate to be able to do it largely organically. The Poland and Mexico examples were associated very directly with some acquired businesses. But we're really pleased with the position of our route to market around the world and how we've accomplished it. And I actually do think that, that there was an earlier question about whether or not, our results how might we qualify our results versus others. I mean one thing that is different a little bit about our business and it's captured a little bit in the geographic skews. We just don't have a lot of local mature businesses that we bought along the way in order to enable our route to market. We have some. I mean, we in particularly in Mexico and Poland, there we have good positions, but those are relatively mature categories where we have good positions. And so that can drag on us as it has a little bit in some of these emerging market figures we referred to today. But compared to other companies who did this develop their route to market through acquisition or have made very, very large acquisitions of local companies the basis for developing their global brands. We're just not as exposed to that. So if those businesses are soft in the local market, it can be a bit of drag on their growth and we just don't have that influence as much at our company. Understood. Thanks very much. You're welcome. Thanks, Ian. Your next question comes from the line of Bryan Spillane from Bank of America. Hi, good morning. Good morning, Bryan. Just wanted to add my congrats as well to both of you Jane and Don. Don, I didn't know if Nick Modi and I should take it personally, but we launch coverage and you go away. It made you look good, Brian. I don't know if that's ominous for you, Jane, maybe. I had a question about 2 questions. 1, just a quick one, just a clarification on SG and A. SG and A was I guess a little lighter than we thought it would be in the Q2. And is there just some timing shift? So did I hear that correctly you expect to see that kind of kick back up in the second half? Yes, exactly. I would anticipate by the end of the fiscal year, it will be somewhere in the mid single digit range. Okay. And that's if France is coming on, that's one of the big contributors. Heavily influenced by France. There's a couple of other little timing things in there in addition to that, but it's heavily depletions. You had a nice sequential if you look at it on the sequential if you look at it on the equivalent case basis, you had a nice sequential change in depletions from the Q1 to the 2nd quarter, the year to date trend improved. So can you talk a little bit about maybe what was happening in market to drive the improvement in depletions. I mean, it looks like Jack Daniel's family drove a piece of it and even El Jimador being less negative was part of it. But if you could just maybe talk a little bit more about that improvement in depletion trends. Is that more or less in line with what you were expecting? And just some more color there please. Yes. I mean, I would say that a lot of what we talked about in terms of easy comps and tough comps, I mean, it hit us at the depletion line as well as it hit us at the reported line. So I mean, you saw a lot of 2 years ago, when we took some pretty hefty price increases for the first time in 5 years, you saw some pretty hefty buy ins at both retail and the distributor level. And so we were going up against those tougher comps when we came out with the 2nd price increase at lower levels where we didn't see quite as large buy in in either tier. And so generally speaking, in terms of the when you look at the magnitude of that shift that you're looking at, a lot of it was driven mostly by what we've been talking about in terms of this comp difference Q1 to Q2. Okay. And now and more at a level now where there's not like trade inventories are or wholesaler inventories also are at a pretty normal level? Yes. I would say here's how I would think about that. Every year, you'll see kind of plus 1s, plus 2s, minus 1s, minus 2s. They'll fluctuate a little bit throughout the year. Generally, at this time of the year, where you're really in the early part of the holiday season, that's when you'll start see some of the inventory buy in starting to come in as different distributors and retailers are really loading in for the holiday season. And so it's not unusual at this time of the year to see our shipments slightly outperforming our depletions because of that effect. And then once we get through the holiday season, you'll tend to see that start to reverse itself in kind of the January, February timeframe. And so when you think about it from that standpoint, seasonality, what you're looking at today in terms of this depletion shipment adjustment is pretty much within the norm. Brian, the other thing that in addition to our price increases, the fluctuations that will influence some of these quarter to quarters are just the introductions of these land extensions. And it's we will we'll keep you all apprised as we go along. We all always do as to when we're introducing something and when we begin to work against that pipeline, we tried our best, particularly I'm talking about depletion pipeline. And we had some of that at various times on Tennessee Honey, where you begin you had you get the product into distribution, you only get to do that once and then you're dependent on the velocity. And so innovation plays a role in this in addition to the price increases. Price increases. Those have been the 2 big things over the last 24 months that would have explained variations from quarter to quarter. Ladies and gentlemen, we have reached the end of the allotted time for questions and answers. That concludes the call for today. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect. Thank you all.