Our next session, we would like to welcome back Perry Beberman. He is Executive Vice President and CFO of Bread Financial. Perry joined the company in 2021 after more than three decades at Bank of America and MBNA. Most recently at Bank of America, he was the finance executive for its consumer and wealth management lending products. Thank you, Perry, for being a frequent visitor of our conference. Listen, Perry, it has been five years into your tenure as CFO, and the stock is sitting at close to the high watermark over this time. Congratulations on that, because I know it has been a grind. Maybe you could just talk about all the work that has been done to getting to this point, and if you feel like the investment community is still missing something.
Yeah, I appreciate it. You and I think, met the first week I joined Bread Financial, and you kind of laid out a little bit of a roadmap of what we had to do to regain investor support. I would like to think we have done that over the years, but not by hyping up the company, but being very honest and transparent about what had to be done to run our company like a pure play financial services company with discipline and focus. You used the word grind, and I use that word often myself, because honestly, to transform a company, it does not happen overnight.
It is a grind, and it takes the focus of the entire organization in everything we do, from risk management. Look, risk management isn't sexy, but it is foundational to running a company well. I think the evidence of that is in us being able to merge our two banks together with, I will say, a clean bill of health with no conditions, which is fantastic. It sets us up well for what may be the next chapter if we decide to pursue a national bank charter. When we want to do something like that, it will not be about aspirations and trying to convince the regulators of what we would like to do, what we will do around compliance and how we run the company. It is how we do it. I think the investors probably do not understand as much of what is under the hood.
Yeah.
But that is also what has driven our ratings improvements over the past year or two. When you look at technology transformation, the finance balance sheet, the stuff I have had my personal responsibility for, delevering the company, paying down over 70% of our debt obligations. I mean, you can see that in the evidence of our senior notes had a 300 basis point improvement of the rate we paid compared to the initial rate we paid.
We have optimized around, we are doing everything right. Right now, I think maybe what investors, even when we go out on the road and we meet with certain investors who are not as familiar with us, of who we are today, they think of us as the old Alliance Data and the way the company was run back then, and it is not how it is run today. Today, I would say we are probably one of the best in class in terms of how we run from that, I will say, big bank financial discipline, but being a far more nimble company as we are today.
Yeah. It has really been a remarkable job that you guys have done. You have really been doing well on growth, and you have signed some new partnerships that are large merchant partnerships, as well as in furniture. Is that like a shift in the way you are going to market? Do you want to go for larger merchants with higher ticket prices, or does it just happen to be that way right now?
Yeah, I think when you are talking about the business development opportunities and what that pipeline looks like, it is kind of what you said. There are only certain partners that are, or potential partners that are in market at any point in time. You have a few years that you look out to see what is coming to market and what would make sense for Bread Financial, and use the word large partners.
I think the ones we focus on are more that medium size that fit our wheelhouse of where we know we can offer customized solutions, help them grow their products, and be there for them the way they want a partner to be. Whereas, we are not a behemoth where that 500 to billion-sized partner might get lost and may not get prioritized with the tech investments and things that are required. I don't think we have. We don't pursue the large partners that are $10 billion and above. When you say large, I don't-
Yeah, yeah.
you're not talking mega, but large. You're talking like good-sized ones. When you look at the furniture vertical that's now grown nicely for us, we were opportunistic. We saw an opportunity when one of our peers out there were changing focus, and they came to market, and we won more than our fair share of those furniture deals. They do come with a larger ticket. What's going forward might look different because different types of partners come to the market.
I guess, as we think about the pipeline on a go-forward basis, do you feel like it's pretty robust? Do you feel like the complexion is different? Maybe you could just talk a little bit about that.
Yeah, that's an excellent question, and kind of what I open up with. Every year, it looks a little different. Some years you have some new brand or retailers or people coming to market that are de novo, who've not had a program before. We have some of those. Others, we've got some signings that are winning, that you're winning from other existing partnerships that are out there. So it's a blend.
Got it. Perfect. And maybe you could just talk about your go-to-market strategy and what's resonating about Bread's products relative to the peers.
Yeah, I touched on it a little bit in that last question. What makes us unique is that I think we're more nimble, more flexible, and we're not trying to fit partners into a basic homogeneous platform with a singular set of solutions. If they want a bit more of a flexible solution to meet their needs, we can do that. I'll use something on our Bread Pay platform, which is installment loans, and a flex loan product that gave the ability for the Home Depot customer to draw on a product for six months, and then it turns into an installment loan, like with a fixed sort of standard payment.
That was a new product that didn't exist for them before, and we were able to bring that to market. Depending on what the customer wants, we can do that. Whereas you're part of a big company, sometimes they're not willing to make the investment to give the flexible solution. We are nimble, and our technology stack keeps getting better and better and better. That's where we say we're gritty and we're nimble, and that's what we bring to the partners.
When we think about the technology stack, I know you guys have made investments in it. How far have we come? Is there more to be done, or do you feel like you're close to the end? Curious.
I would be lying to you if I said we're close to the end, because I don't think in technology you're ever at the end, right? Anybody who thought you're on a modern tech stack five years ago, the world's changing fast. I think the key is not making the over-investment where you're thinking that this is the end state for three years.
Right.
It's foundational with your data, and the tools that are available today look very different than what they were three years ago. The speed to market, the ability to push code through faster using agentic solutions, it's fun to watch, but it's changing rapidly.
Yeah.
I don't think we're near the end game of technology, and I think it's an exciting time for our brand partners and for our customers and for ourselves in terms of what this could potentially look like.
Got it. You've maintained your confidence in the ability to deliver mid-20s ROTCE despite a more skeptical sort of investor view. Maybe you could just talk about the building blocks to get to that
Yep
mid-20s ROTCE, and what gives you the conviction that those returns are achievable?
You may be talking to different investors than I do, or maybe they're just nicer to me when they're speaking to me directly, but I think they're less and less-
Probably the case.
Yeah, probably. They're less and less skeptical because they've seen the progress that we've had over the past few years, and they can see this manifesting itself into real, tangible results where our ROTCE continues to improve every year. Our efficiency ratio continues to improve. If you think about the building blocks, it's been optimizing our balance sheet. With our latest preferred issuance this month, that now we can say we have pretty much optimized our capital stack. That puts us in that 12%-13% CET1 as our binding constraint, which is check the box on that. We said we need to continue to improve our loss rates and get those down right around 6%.
We've continued to make significant progress on the loss rate. The third piece was scaling and growing so you get that efficiency ratio improving, and that's continued. I think we're not too far off from being able to deliver on what we said in the mid-20 ROTCEs. Those, we got to continue to make progress on the loss rate and continue to scale and deliver positive operating leverage year in, year out, and I think we're going to be able to deliver that.
Cool. I look forward to it. Credit quality is obviously a big discussion point, and you have this nice tailwind off of the credit normalization that you mentioned, but then you are also growing now.
Yeah.
At some point, those two intersect, and we level off in terms of improvement. I also think you have moved up more upmarket in terms of your portfolio in somewhat, just with the co-brand portfolios and such. Maybe you could just talk about the path of losses on a go-forward basis, because you do have the seasoning headwind at some point.
Yeah. The benefit that we get from growing, say, 7% ending loans, I would probably put that around 10- 20 basis points of improvement to your loss rate, as they call it, the denominator effect. That then carries into the following year. But then as long as you continue to grow in that mid-single digit to high single digit.
Right
We're not going to have that issue, because it's not like we're putting on a big bulky vintage that all of a sudden we're looking at and saying, "We don't like the performance of that vintage." It's just good, steady growth, and that's what we're looking for, is that steady growth. I don't see a seasoning effect being a problem, because at the same time, we do have that tailwind of continued credit improvement. So the growth benefit is not the big driver of what's going to get us at or below 6% losses. It's going to be continued, I'll say, diversification, product diversification, which is helpful, but also just a continued healing of the existing back book. So we underwrite every vintage to try to be around that 6%, and it'll all come together, and it is coming together. You see that continued improvement.
I guess, we obviously got your monthly data yesterday after the close. The stats looked great.
Yep.
People have been very surprised, including ourselves, by the resiliency of the consumer with all of these headwinds that we didn't anticipate this year. Maybe you could just talk about what you're seeing.
Yeah. We tend to agree with you. I mean, one, first and foremost, the consumer has been through a lot over the past five, six years post-COVID, and where they had that period of high inflation, and households understood how to make choices. And I've used that term choiceful consumer. It results in a resilient consumer. And I think the number one thing of why the consumer's been able to be as resilient as they are, for at least the ones who we serve, and think about that as middle America, not low income. The people who are most affected by inflation are not the people we underwrite, but certainly it has effects on the average household, and that's a thing. But they're able to. We see it in our spend data where they can make choices. But the number one thing is they have jobs, right?
So long as the labor market's holding up, and it is, that's the most important thing for credit. Then inflation, you could say, is secondary. Fuel price is up, no argument there. Everyone sees it. But then do consumers have the ability to maybe make different decisions on travel in terms of, will they fly or do they drive, or do they pass on a vacation? When they go to the store, are they pulling back on certain things and buying instead of a name brand, go to something that's off-brand? And you see it. So we can see it in our spend data. People are still spending in restaurants. So fast casual, still very strong, but pulling back on full dining. So consumers can adjust, and I think they've shown that discipline and resiliency because of what they've learned coming out of COVID.
Okay. Well, that's good. We want them to continue to do well and hopefully
Knock on wood. I mean, right? It's good until it isn't.
I know. We will talk a little bit about some of the politics in a bit.
Oh, you were going to finish with that question because I had you started. I figured we would take the entire time to talk.
I am going to let it string along and then we will get there. We will get there. I will leave that as a zinger at the end, if that is okay. You raised preferred equity after earnings, and it seems like you are now at the $300 million in total preferred target that you set. You mentioned the 12%-13% CET1 too, which is you have hit your target there. Can you just talk about how we should think about your ability to flex that capital level within the range that you have targeted?
Yeah. When we give a range, you can think about it as probably being more close to the midpoint of where you may run normally. Your point that we have raised $335 million of preferreds, and that does have us at a nice optimal level. Again, as we continue to grow, we will have to issue some more to continue to be in that sweet spot. What it has allowed us to do is return an appropriate amount of capital to shareholders that we did not use or did not need for growth or investments in the company. Our capital priorities haven't changed.
Let's start with that. First and foremost, we're going to continue to invest our capital in growing the portfolio, sorry, with the discipline we have to date. We call it responsible growth. It's going to deliver the right type of return profile. Then we'll invest in the company and tech capabilities, AI, whatever we need to do, and then what's unused would then be returned to shareholders. I think we have a good track record of that now over the past year plus. As we flex, we are going to stay very disciplined with our capital policy, our capital targets. You wouldn't see us flex below our stated, it's called 12%, just because we grew more in a quarter. I think that's not the type of practice that we expect to put in place, particularly as a regulated institution.
Are there opportunities outside of organic growth and capital return? Are there large portfolio acquisition opportunities or other business opportunities?
Yeah. The one thing you've heard me say before, we have one of the best corporate development, business development teams out there, and we're constantly scanning different opportunities. When you first say, if there was something that was value-based that made sense for our company, we do look at it and we could pursue it, but it's got to be right for us, and it's got to have flawless execution if we're going to do something like that. Our investors seem very happy with the approach to date, and we're going to remain disciplined in how we approach the market.
Got it. And maybe just one more on capital. Basel III still out there. Maybe you can just talk about what kind of impact you feel it has and timing.
Look, we're very encouraged that this is getting addressed, and we think for us, because of our size, that the benefit we're going to get is from effectively a reduced risk-weighted asset calculation. So we should get a benefit of about 10% reduction in our risk-weighted assets. So if you just take $20 billion in risk-weighted assets and 10% less, it means you hold 12%, 12%, 13% less capital on $2 billion. You kind of do the math on that, so you're $200 million-$250 million of freed-up capital to deploy in other ways.
Got it. I mean, any thoughts on when it kicks in?
That you have to ask the regulators.
Got it. RSAs have become a bigger part of the story, and I am just curious as we think about the path from here, the direction of travel on RSAs as a percentage of the total revenues or loan portfolio, however you want to define it. How should we think about its relevance, and why are the RSAs now coming in as a big part of the story?
I think the RSAs have always been a part of the story, and it is something that got a little more focus for us because I do not think that the broader analyst community or investor community really understood that this is going to become an increasing part of our story over time as more partners are going to have profit share constructs. We win more. As you can see, we are growing. We are winning more deals in the marketplace. There are more at-market rates that are competitive. When you do that, as well as things I have said three years ago, when we started to put some pricing things in place to get the portfolios to the right profit dynamics for the risk we take, as they improve the performance and the margins have improved, more of that will be shared back to the brand partner.
As that has occurred, that naturally means your RSA is going to go up as a dollar basis, and then you figure out how you want to calculate it on percent of credit sales or percent of loans. But it is just regrounding folks that as we are now growing, it is going to grow, and it will grow as a percent, maybe a little faster because of the dynamic of improved profitability. But again, this is all contemplated in our path to delivering the mid-20s ROTCE. While it is getting some more attention, it shouldn't be anything that is counter to what we have been saying.
Got it. I guess, as we think about the construct of these RSAs, are they pretty similar across the board, or they differ a decent amount?
I would say for any brand partner, anybody that's in the co-brand space, private label space, they vary pretty meaningfully across every partner because they each have different motivations, right. You may have partner A that really wants to be, I'll say, compensated as a percent of credit sales because they understand they want to pay for their loyalty programs. They understand what their credit sales projections are. They don't want to take on the credit risk side of things, which comes when you have more profit share. Some partners want more of a profit share construct, and they want, "Okay, we will, as a bank, we'll own a minimum return," and then they want all of their compensation to come that way.
Many want some of a hybrid, so they're getting a base rate on credit sales or a bounty for a new account that's open, and then they want some upside on the profit share. Again, it depends where they are on their sophistication and really their own risk tolerance of being able to absorb some lower payments in more difficult credit cycles versus others. I wish it were homogeneous. It's just not. It really does vary by partner.
No, in many ways, it can make the model more resilient, right. It's just understanding its impact over time, right.
Yes.
Some of your peers have it, and we kind of see how.
We prefer it.
Yeah.
I tell you that we prefer that hybrid model because it aligns us on growing the credit sales that we then can turn into loans, and we also prefer that profit share because it aligns us on that credit component that is so important. We are skin in the game together.
Perfect. I want to move on to agentic commerce and AI. Obviously, lots of discussion on this topic at this conference, and we are just trying to figure out how it evolves and how it becomes meaningful to every one of our companies. Obviously, you guys are very unique in that you are very integrated with the merchant, and you have your own financing solution. I am curious how you guys are thinking about agentic and AI and what kind of investments you are making and what role you think you are going to play.
What I love about our business is that we are at the intersection between retailers and the consumer, and the most important thing for us is to make sure that we can have flexible payment solutions at the time the consumer wants to purchase that item from the brand partner. The brand partner wants to make sure that their products are discoverable in an agentic world where the consumer's using personal agents or they go out on their own to find things, and then ensuring that if you think about it, if the card that we have with that brand partner is the best value.
And it should be nine out of 10 times because it's their offer that they're putting out there to make sure that our credit offer is, I'll say, there in that point of sale such that the agent, the agentic agent that the consumer's using, that our product pops up to the top, and that's important. We are working with everyone you would expect, like AWS, Google. I mean, you probably haven't seen us put headlines out about it, but everybody in the industry is working accordingly, and we are right in pace with everybody in the industry. I'm not sure it's going to be as disruptive to, I'll say, improving sales. I think it makes it more efficient for consumers to find the product they want and good deals.
Yeah.
It's going to be really important that the retailer has their products available. We'll come to this table with a solution to tap into their partner where they are in their agentic journey, or we'll build some full suite solutions that we can then offer to them if they're a smaller partner.
Got it. As you think about the agents and all these different various counterparties that have specific agents, how should we think about the way Bread integrates with everyone? I mean, you'd have your own agents as well, or? I'm just curious. I'm trying to think about, you have a closed loop, so you can offer more context because you have a lot of data.
Right.
How should we think about that?
Well, where we have the closed loop, that's fantastic. If, I'm not going to use any brand partner, but if that consumer is going there with their agent to purchase at one of our larger brand partners, well, they want that agentic, that ecosystem to be able to function agentically. I think the most important thing, let me just back this out a little bit, zoom out a little bit, for us and the entire industry is making sure that there's agentic authentication that it's robust. I think the more concern that's going on is the uptick in fraud and cyber concerns, so that you're really creating a protected environment that the consumer really knows what their personal agent is authorized to do and not do.
This is going to be an issue of who has the liability on this. Again, that closed loop, bit easier perhaps, but I think we're all trying to navigate this together. I mean, it's a lot of upside in terms of, I say upside in terms of the customer experience and making ease of things for them to do, but I think this is going to evolve over time as an industry around safeguards. For us, first and foremost, we've got to make sure we create a safe environment for the consumers to do their transactions.
And you don't think it's disruptive?
Disruptive in that I think it's, for us, you have to be in the space, you have to address it, because it can be I look at it as more of a defensive. First and foremost, I view it as a defensive investment. We have to invest in agentic because it is how our customers want to engage, and our brand partners need to protect their retail sales. If they don't offer an agentic, if their products are not discoverable agentically and can't transact if the customer wants to pay agentically, they'll risk losing some sales.
It's not going to grow the total economy in any way, shape, or form. The customers are going to buy what they are going to buy. They can only afford what they can afford. It's just how they pay for it and where do they buy from. So defensively, retailers have to offer that. Now, they can perhaps, if they're earlier to the game and they are first movers, they can maybe pick up a little bit of share, but I'm not sure it's going to be as disruptive as the hype cycle might appear.
Yep. So we've talked a lot about buy now, pay later as a disruptive threat in the past.
Yep.
I think definitely would love to get an update there. You've had other players come in that are offering co-brand/partnership-like products as well, in their view, with the better front-end platform that can then do more in terms of agentic. I mean, do you feel any pressure from those types of players out there?
I wouldn't say that we feel pressure. Again, we win more than our fair share of new partnerships, and we've been able to retain the bulk of our own partnerships. When I say pressure, competition makes us all better. I've been, I'm going to age myself, I've been at this for 38 years
Wow
in credit card space. There's been an evolution over this time, and the one thing you can count on, things will continue to change. New competitors emerge, some fall off. You never sleep on competition, and I don't discount them. I do believe that, like I said earlier, with technology advancements, we're able to do things today that might have taken you five years to put into production. Now you can maybe put things into production in three months. It's just, we're moving at the pace of technology. While I appreciate that, there's also companies are selling their own wares, and then, are they able to be as flexible as we are, deliver the scale that, and honestly, the strength of a financial services company like Bread Financial behind that partnership?
What about buy now, pay later and other embedded finance
Yeah
players? They've grown quite significantly. Do you feel like they've taken share from the private label/co-brand space, or do you think that they've created other verticals?
I think in part they've created a new vertical, and I don't know if it's a true vertical or it's more of a horizontal. As I think about, I'm going to use the word horizontal, if you think about paying for things in cash or checks or debit, I think they've created this little slice in there that fits between truly credit-qualified individuals, and they've bridged that very nicely. So people who can't afford things fully out of their debit card, but they're going to get that paycheck coming in next week, so they want the pay in four solutions, it's been brilliant, and they've really created that solution. For us, we don't underwrite a lot of those customers, right?
They need to have a certain credit criteria to get even private label or co-brand. So I think they've created a horizontal that's been good. For us, I mean, look, we just grew 7%. It's hard to figure out, yeah, are they nipping at the heels of some of the customers that would have preferred to get their rewards and the loyalty points and the like? Possibly, but it's hard to quantify exactly what that is. I think it's more so taken from the debit side of things.
You guys obviously got into that game pretty early, buying Bread. I'm just curious, I don't think it's necessarily proliferated as significant as one would have thought when you acquired it. I'm just curious what the learnings are there.
Well, learnings for us is that, buying a tech company, one, you better have tech people within your company that can really get under the hood and understand tech well, to understand what you are buying, and particularly as a regulated institution. It took a lot of rebuilding, and then when I came in as well, you get under the hood on the economics. We were a regulated bank, and we are disciplined with capital, and some of the deals that were out there and the business models that a couple of the large players were running, it was just not our game.
Yeah.
We are very disciplined, and you start to see our Bread Pay platform grow, and we focused on installment loans, and that is where we have had good success with the likes of Vivint, Cricket Wireless, the Home Depot I mentioned, and that is how we are going to play in this space. We will try to white label some products and solutions, but we are not going to pour hundreds of million dollars into marketing and trying to grab eyeballs into a super app. That is not our model.
Got it. I got a couple more, and then we can open up to questions. I guess, as we think, you talked about the bank and maybe evolving the bank and depository side of the business. Maybe you could just talk about what the path for that would be and what the benefits would be if you actually
Sure
got a consumer bank.
Today, we were operating as two banks, a bank in Delaware and a bank in Utah. We could take direct-to-consumer deposits out of our bank in Utah, but we couldn't do that out of Delaware. Delaware had more of the wholesale deposits, brokered CDs, and we had our ABS platform out of Delaware, not out of our Utah bank. By combining the two banks and having built out an ABS platform now that is in our Utah bank, which is where we consolidate into, and we already have 50% of our portfolio, or sorry, our company funded with direct-to-consumer deposits, this now allows our treasurer to fund the entirety of the business flexibly with all the instruments available. That's a big deal for us, and that means we can continue to march the direct-to-consumer deposits up to 60%, 70% to really be peer-like in that way.
Regulators and rating agencies like that. It's a preferred funding source. We've made tremendous progress, and that's really what that allowed, is a simplification, one larger-scale bank. Going forward, if we were to choose to go forward with a national bank charter, what that would do for us, again, I view that as more of a defensive mechanism, so you become less subject to what I'll call rogue state regulations.
Yeah.
Right? That's just a good thing. Those state regulations haven't been overly impactful to date, but it's one of those things that you just look at and say, "Is it worth the risk to continue to run a certain way?" If you believe you are well-run, great risk management, strong balance sheet, the right types of policies and decision-making, why not consider introducing two new regulators, would be the OCC and Fed? Again, you have to have built out the right leadership team, which we have. We have many experienced leaders who come from regulated institutions from the Fed and OCC. That's really the path forward. I wouldn't say that it opens up new opportunities, but what it does is it just further protects the company from those states.
Isn't the time now to do it?
There's a two-year window, I'd say it would be the time to do it.
Great. I think, yeah, I think that makes sense. I'm going to give you the zinger now. All right? Obviously, lots of changes in the political dynamics here, with the blue tsunami or however you want to say it. Big populist movement, it seems. There's lots of discussions about regulation and APR caps and like I'm curious how you guys think about it, because it obviously has meaningful implications to the entire industry.
Yeah. A lot to unpack there. So, kind of to the last point we just made is this current administration, and I think every , we work in any environment with any administration, but this current administration, I think, took an approach with regulation is to make it more fair, balanced, workable, and whether it's the Basel III changes that's coming about, or like we just talked about with the OCC or the CFPB. Again, if we do something wrong, we're the first people that want to identify it and remediate it, and not be penalized overly. And I think that there was more of a punitive approach before. Now it's more balanced and really focused on what matters, and I think that's been good.
Even with the chartering, like we said, it's an environment that if you're good and you're doing the right things, hopefully you can get approved to do things in a reasonable timeframe. So I think there's been some good change with the current regulatory posture, and it's been good to work with. Again, two years from now, things could change. I don't know. I'm not sure that It is interesting because I think there should have been an expectation that at midterms, there's often a big change in government. We see it almost every time. And so this is no different than most midterms. But your point is that there's certainly some headline-grabbing things like the 10% APR cap. And when I hear that, I think there's a lot of really smart legislators out there.
The ones that say that are clearly trying to get attention and focus on affordability. The root of affordability is, can they make housing more affordable? Can they make pharmaceuticals, medical things more affordable? Everything, there's an affordability, but then to come after the credit card side of things at a 10% APR cap, they can just figure out what tens and hundreds of millions of people do they not want to have credit anymore. No matter where you set that rate, look, today, for all the applications we take in, what do we approve? 50%? The bigger banks may approve less than that. Just decide where do you want to draw the line on this, right? They're going to take credit away from a lot of people, and that has downstream implications twofold.
One, it'll impact pushing people to shadow banking, to the streets, and getting credit in other ways, who otherwise would have gotten mainstream credit. The second thing it'll do is impact the retailers, right? It'll contract the economy a bit. I think it's I understand the intent of why it sounds good to commentators and politicians, but you got to ground yourself back in the reality of the economics of lending.
Do you think the industry is doing enough to educate the legislators such that this outcome won't occur?
I'd like to think so. From what I understand, there's some good people out there, and some of the largest banks have made some comments. Look, it really does come down to education. Once they understand that for, I'll make it up, for a $1,000 credit card balance, like the people we serve often, is that when we have to put up 15% regulatory capital, it's $150. You got to post up 11% for us in terms of a reserve rate.
Okay, it's $100. You got to operate that account, call it $60. You got to fund that balance at 5%. You start to do the math, and you understand what that means. What I don't think that they fully appreciate, they can say what they want, and they just think all of a sudden it's going to magically save consumers money, is that it goes back to what I said, it's going to restrict credit, and it has to restrict credit.
You think about being an OCC-regulated institution, or anyone, they come in and examine banks' underwriting practices, which means they want to understand your decision-making on the margin, those last accounts that you book on the margin, and that from a safety and soundness standpoint, was it responsible lending? You cannot reduce APRs to 10% and think you can underwrite almost anybody. I think that's going to be the key education part. They can say what they want, but the other side of government is going to come in and regulate it, and effectively, you have to operate within your risk appetite and return profiles.
Wonderful. Can't say I disagree with you.
I wouldn't have used the word wonderful.
I appreciate your response. I just want to know if anyone in the audience has questions. There's one over there.
Thank you. I think on the 3Q conference call, you had talked about if you could do a 22%-23% ROTCE, you'd be doing your job, I think was the quote, in and around that level. I think my math's right, that implies 16+ of earnings power, and clearly not looking for earnings guidance here today, but the street is sub 14 still. What do you think the street's missing? Clearly there's potentially more positive revisions to come, which would be really good news for your stock.
He said, "What do you think the street's missing?" Because kind of going back to what I was saying, it seems like the investment community doesn't believe that you guys can hit the ROTCE targets.
And just level of confidence in the low 20s, because
Yeah, I
sell side's not there.
Look, yeah, the level of confidence with investors, I would have said up until this political uncertainty, Sanjay, you can correct me if I'm wrong, I think we're one of the top, if not the top performing consumer finance
Yes
company over the past year. It is building that confidence. I agree with the point, some of what's happening is, Brian Vereb was out here with me, we go out on the road and meet with investors. There are some investors who honestly wouldn't take our meeting a couple years ago, I'd take the meeting and said, "Well, we know who you are. You're Alliance Data." There's still a hangover from the way this company used to be run. Then when we tell our story and they see the numbers, they go back and they dig through and they do the research, like, "Oh my gosh, this is really different." There is confidence gaining in our credibility and how we say things. One thing, right or wrong, is we do not get ahead of ourselves.
I think, Sanjay, you know this, we basically tell you what we're going to do, then we do it. We don't create over-aspirational things, we don't put these things out there and then miss. We try to deliver on what we say we're going to do, and opening up that word, grind. It's a grind. The progress that we've made, if you believe we're going to get to 6% loss rate, like I do, ROTCE starts to go up.
If you believe we're going to continue to grow, as I do and as we're delivering, that's going to improve our scale, if we can continue to contain our expenses as we have. It's all there. We keep saying the same thing, and we're just delivering against it quarter in, quarter out, and that's the goal. I think we just have to remain credible and keep doing what we said we're going to do, keep our heads down and grind this out.
Any other questions? I think we're out of time. Thank you, Perry.
Thank you.
Thank you. Appreciate it.