First Bank (FRBA)
NASDAQ: FRBA · Real-Time Price · USD
15.41
-1.33 (-7.95%)
At close: Apr 28, 2026, 4:00 PM EDT
15.41
0.00 (0.00%)
After-hours: Apr 28, 2026, 4:10 PM EDT
← View all transcripts

Earnings Call: Q3 2023

Oct 25, 2023

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by. My name is Cheryl, and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the First Bank FRBA Earnings Call, Third Quarter 2023 Conference Call. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. After the speaker's remarks, there will be a question and answer session. If you would like to ask a question during this time, simply press star followed by the number one on your telephone keypad. If you would like to withdraw your question, press star one again. Thank you. I would now like to turn the call over to Patrick Ryan, President and CEO. Please go ahead.

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Thank you. I'd like to welcome everyone today to First Bank's Third Quarter 2023 Earnings call. I'm joined today by Andrew Hibshman, our Chief Financial Officer, Darleen Gillespie, our Chief Retail Banking Officer, and Peter Cahill, our Chief Lending Officer. Before we begin, however, Andrew will read the Safe Harbor statement.

Andrew Hibshman
EVP and CFO, First Bank

The following discussion may contain forward-looking statements concerning the financial condition, results of operations, and business of First Bank. We caution that such statements are subject to a number of uncertainties, and actual results could differ materially, and therefore you should not place undue reliance on any forward-looking statements we make. We may not update any forward-looking statements we make today for future events or developments. Information about risks and uncertainties are described under Item 1A, Risk Factors in our annual report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31st, 2022, filed with the FDIC. Pat, back to you.

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Great. Thanks, Andrew. I'd like to start with some high-level remarks before we get some additional detail from Andrew, Darleen, and Peter. Overall, I think it's important to highlight, we did close on the Malvern Bank merger during the quarter. We also finalized our facilities and systems integration projects, which overall have gone very well so far. The numbers in our financial statements and releases include the impact of this transaction. Given the significant noise in the numbers this quarter, I'm going to focus my remarks on bigger picture items and the strategic impact of the merger. Most importantly, as many of you know, we added significant size and scale in our core Southeastern Pennsylvania market. We now have half of our overall 26 branch locations in the Greater Philadelphia market, 10 of them in Pennsylvania and three of them in Southern New Jersey.

And almost one-third of our loans are sourced from the Greater Philadelphia and Southern New Jersey markets. Second, we made significant progress on what we call Project Sculpt, where we're reshaping our balance sheet. As many of you saw in the release, we sold approximately $95 million in investment securities. We sold another $100 million in residential mortgage loans. We used these proceeds to pay off about $130 million in borrowings, and we also let $68 million in broker deposits run off during the quarter. The net results of these activities will drive better ROA, improved ROE, and increase capital efficiency, while also freeing up contingent funding availability. We continue to explore additional sculpting opportunities to shed non-core assets that have been mark-to-market through the acquisition.

This project should continue into 2024 as we use proceeds from investor real estate loan payoffs and paydowns to fund some of our newer C&I loan initiatives, with the goals of improving capital efficiency, getting more deposits per customer relationship, and reducing our overall investor real estate concentrations. Our focus for the remainder of this year and into 2024 will be portfolio optimization and strong profit growth, not overall balance sheet growth. Furthermore, merger benefits have already started driving our core profitability higher. When adding back one-time merger-related costs, we achieved the following results during the third quarter: EPS of $0.42, which is $1.68 annualized, a return on average assets of 1.13%, an adjusted return on tangible common equity of 13.23%.

The current earnings run rate could be even higher than these adjusted figures because they do not include a full quarter of interest rate mark accretion, and the numbers during Q3 also include some extra costs that will not continue into Q4. Here's a brief summary of the merger accounting. The final tangible book value per share dilution came in higher than originally anticipated, at 15% versus our estimate in December of 2022. But that change is entirely driven by the interest rate market environment and how that moved since December of 2022. The tangible book value per share impact when adding back the interest rate marks was negligible. That doesn't mean it's not real, but rather it reduces the risk and uncertainty in terms of our ability to earn back that dilution that was recognized during the quarter.

Our projected earnings accretion moved much higher for the same reason. A larger interest rate mark equates to more interest rate earnings accretion moving forward. In summary, the integration thus far has gone very well, and we believe the economic benefits derived from establishing critical mass in the attractive market of southeastern Pennsylvania, and the benefits from creating significant scale and cost savings will make this an excellent deal for our shareholders. These benefits will materialize in the form of really strong earnings growth and capital appreciation as we head into 2024. At this time, I'd like to turn it over to Andrew to discuss our financial results in a little more detail.

Andrew Hibshman
EVP and CFO, First Bank

Thanks, Pat. For the three months ended September 30, 2023, we recorded a net loss of $1.3 million or $0.05 per diluted share, excluding merger-related expenses, the initial credit loss expense on the Malvern acquired loan portfolio and some other one-time items during the current quarter, adjusted net income was $10.1 million, or adjusted EPS of $0.42, and an adjusted return on average assets of 1.13%. The acquisition of Malvern closed on July 17th, 2023. The combined stock and cash transaction was valued at approximately $129.7 million, with Malvern providing $953.8 million in assets, $727.7 million in loans, and $671.9 million in deposits on the date of the acquisition.

During the third quarter, as Pat mentioned, the sale of certain acquired investments in residential loans netted us approximately $165 million in cash, which allowed us to reposition our balance sheet to manage interest rate risk and boost efficiency. Net of impact of the loan sales, loans increased by $581.1 million during the third quarter, primarily due to the Malvern acquisition. Excluding the remaining balance of acquired Malvern loans, which was $626 million at the end of September, loans declined by $442 million during the quarter. Total deposits were up $567.6 million during the third quarter of 2023, also primarily due to the Malvern acquisition.

Excluding the $671.9 million in deposits acquired from Malvern, deposit balance declined by $104.3 million during the three months ended September 30, 2023. The decline during the quarter was primarily due to the bank allowing some higher cost brokered and non-core funding to leave, but the overall industry-wide deposit declines and competitive pricing pressures are also impacting our total deposit levels. Primarily due to the benefits of the Malvern acquisition, our net interest income improved from 3.28% in the second quarter of 2023 to 3.36% in the third quarter of 2023. Because the Malvern acquisition closed in the second half of July, our net interest income only included two months of acquisition accounting accretion, which had an approximately $2.7 million positive impact on net interest income.

Also, the asset sales allowed for the reduction of certain higher cost deposits and borrowings, but most of this activity occurred later in the quarter. Deposit costs continued to move higher as market pressure persisted, but the weighted average rate on loans originated during the quarter also moved higher. We believe that a full quarter of accretion income, coupled with the balance sheet repositioning we have, will have a positive impact on the margin in Q4, even despite the challenges related to deposit pricing conditions and the inverted yield curve. Liquidity levels remained stable during the third quarter as we used the proceeds from the asset sales to pay off $130 million in FHLB borrowings, that Pat mentioned, and it also allowed some higher cost deposit runoff.

We have significant unused borrowing capacity and expect to enhance that contingent funding availability even further in the fourth quarter. As of September 30, 2023, our Allowance for Credit Losses to total loans increased to 1.42% from 1.25% at June 30, 2023. The increase, however, was primarily due to the impact of specific reserves on certain acquired loans. In the third quarter of 2023, total non-interest income declined, primarily due to losses on loan and investment sales, which were net against non-interest income on our income statement. The investment and loan sale losses were the result of the aforementioned sale of residential loans and investments that were acquired from Malvern.

These assets were marked to fair value at the time of acquisition, but saw some additional decline in value between the acquisition date and the ultimate sale date of the assets, primarily due to continued interest rate movement. Non-interest expenses were $23.5 million in Q3 2023, or $16.5 million, excluding merger-related expenses. Non-interest expenses, excluding merger-related costs, increased $2.7 million, or 19.5% from the prior quarter, primarily due to the new Malvern employees and locations. Annualized Q3 2023 non-interest expenses, excluding merger-related expenses, were 1.83% of average assets, compared to 1.93% in the second quarter of 2023. We realized a number of immediate cost savings after the Malvern acquisition, and we are confident that we will hit our announced goals on cost savings as we head into 2024.

We continue to believe that one of our strengths is our operating efficiency and believe the Malvern acquisition has provided us additional opportunities to improve our efficiency metrics. Although we continue to operate in a difficult rate environment, the Malvern acquisition, coupled with the balance sheet repositioning we executed during the quarter, has positioned us to improve our core profitability metrics as we move towards 2024. At this time, I'll turn it over to Darleen Gillespie, our Chief Retail Banking Officer, for her remarks. Darleen?

Darleen Gillespie
Chief Retail Banking Officer, First Bank

Thank you, Andrew, and good morning, everyone. I'll start off by stating that there were no big surprises relative to deposit activity in the third quarter. While we have initiatives in place focused on retention and acquisition, we're not immune from the unprecedented shift in funding mix and pressures on funding costs experienced within the industry. In the second quarter, we reported strong deposit growth, primarily in our government and commercial portfolios. In Q3, while total deposits were up mostly due to the Malvern acquisition, as Andrew has mentioned, we experienced a $104.3 million decline, of which $68 million was higher cost brokered and non-core deposits. We continue to experience declines in our time deposit portfolio due to the rate environment. However, we anticipate some stabilization and potential growth with some of the offers we've recently launched in the market.

We experienced larger than normal outflows from some of our commercial clients that move funds for rate and or business purposes. We know who these clients are, and while their balances may have declined, they still remain customers of our bank. Our cost of deposits increased 28 basis points in Q3, inclusive of the deposits we onboarded from Malvern, but it's less than the increase we experienced in the second quarter. Again, a result of the rate environment, but overall, we're managing this metric by letting go of higher rate funding. Our deposit mix continues to shift, with non-interest bearing moving into interest-bearing vehicles, and non-interest bearing funding remains a strategic focus as we build on expanding the relationships that our customers maintain with us. As we move forward, one of our key priorities is to continue to focus on deposit growth.

We remain steadfast with our strategic initiatives, and this month, we launched a fall deposit campaign focused on driving growth as well as retaining funds that are at risk because of the competitive landscape. We're excited about our eight new branches from the Malvern acquisition and the growth opportunities with expansion into the southeastern part of PA. The sales teams are engaging with our new customers and the feedback has been very, very positive. So at this time, I'll turn it over to Peter Cahill, our Chief Lending Officer, for his remarks. Peter?

Peter Cahill
Chief Lending Officer, First Bank

Thanks, Darleen. As you just heard, and read in our earnings release, third quarter was a busy one for all areas of the bank, and that includes the folks in lending. You might recall that we had a very good first half of the year, where loans grew $100 million, and we're right on plan to meet our annual growth goal. Despite the good results, we were seeing signs then of the impact of a slowing economy, rising interest rates, as well as our increased focus on growth in C&I lending and other loans, where relationships include increased levels of deposits. During the third quarter, we continued this focus while consolidating the Malvern loan portfolio into ours. As Andrew mentioned, we sold the portfolio of residential mortgages and onboarded the remaining loans.

We think going forward, we'll derive a lot of synergies by folding that portfolio into our existing sales teams. You can see in the schedules in the earnings release a breakdown of the portfolio by loan type. Obviously, these numbers are post-consolidation with Malvern, so the percentages are impacted by the merger. But we did experience some good organic growth in C&I during the quarter, despite some payoffs there. Absent the positive impact of the Malvern merger, overall organic loan growth was negative in the quarter as Andrew mentioned. We saw some loans, primarily investor real estate loans, refinance out of the bank for lower interest rates elsewhere. And we sold a couple of loan participations to smaller community banks. And we also saw a decline in loans of approximately $50 million because the assets securing those loans were sold.

Nearly 66% of this $50 million bucket were non-investor real estate loans, meaning they were mainly C&I, and in a couple of cases, businesses just got sold and was, you know, completely out of our control. Overall, on the topic of organic loan growth, we're pleased that the sales teams are holding firm on structure and interest rates while pursuing relationship business. C&I growth, where we find deeper relationships, totaled 73% of new loans booked during the nine months ending September 30, 2023. Looking at our loan portfolio, while we continue to focus on relationship business, our pipeline at September 30th stood at $212 million, up from the June 30 level of $171 million.

This is a healthy increase and puts us back at about the same level, as we were, at the end of the first quarter. In fact, our average for the nine months has been $214 million, so we're right in line there. And, the number of loans in the pipeline hasn't changed much either. At September 30th, it was 209, compared to the average for the year of 208. So overall, I'm happy with the way the pipeline stands. Regarding asset quality, due to the consolidation with Malvern, there are a lot of moving pieces, and Andrew's comments and the earnings release really lay out, well where we are. Overall, I believe that we know the former Malvern portfolio very well, and the pre-Malvern First Bank portfolio has not changed from an asset quality perspective.

So, I see, I see no areas of great concern from the combined banks. Credit quality, to me, seems in line with prior quarters. Our objectives for the remainder of the year and into 2024 are to complete the integration of the former Malvern Bank portfolio and continue to grow organically, loans and deposits, where we can gain relationship business. In addition to our regional relationship management teams, our new asset-based lending group has developed a nice pipeline. Our SBA unit has also been busy building its business and our enhanced focus on our Business Express product, which is for smaller business loans and deposits, has been producing good results. This, concludes my comments for the third quarter in lending, and I'll turn things back over now to Pat for final comments. Pat?

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Thank you, Peter. Well, at this point, I'd like to turn things back to the operator to open things up for the Q&A session.

Operator

At this time, I would like to remind everyone, in order to ask a question, press star then the number one on your telephone keypad. We will pause for just a moment to compile the Q&A roster. Your first question comes from the line of Justin Crowley with Piper Sandler. Your line is now open. You may go ahead.

Justin Crowley
VP and Senior Research Analyst, Piper Sandler

Hey, good morning, guys. Was wondering if you could maybe expand a bit on some of the efficiencies gained with the deal. Obviously real nice progress as telegraphed. Seems like there's maybe a, a bit more to come next quarter. Wasn't sure if you're in a position to get a little more specific on how that may look, and then, you know, maybe just more broadly speaking, not necessarily specifics, but just heading into 2024.

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Yeah. So, you know, obviously, well, I shouldn't say obviously, but you know, there's stages in merger integration, and when we closed on the deal on July seventeenth, you know, there were some folks who were not retained, you know, starting at that point. And then there was another group of people that we retained through the end of September to help with the systems and facility integration. So the kind of the stages of cost savings really reflect that process. And then as you move forward, there's always some inevitable attrition that comes from folks that you thought might stay, that decide to move on, or folks you thought you wanted to keep, but it doesn't work out. So, you know, things continue to evolve as we move forward.

But, I think on the people side, Andrew, we've gotten the bulk of, you know, what we expect there. And, you know, we're continuing to realize savings in other areas in terms of back office, professional service, and things like that. So, there'll probably be some lingering expenses that we'll need to incur in the fourth quarter just to kind of finalize legacy Malvern expenses and one-time merger-related things. But, I think we'll have a pretty good view of the run rate for Q1 when we regroup, you know, on our next call. But Andrew, anything you want to add there?

Andrew Hibshman
EVP and CFO, First Bank

I think that's a good summary. There's probably gonna be a little bit of continued noise in the fourth quarter as we wrap up some of the things that we need to wrap up, and still, there's still some people and things that we're figuring out. But yeah, I mean, I think as we head into the first quarter of 2024, all that quote-unquote "noise" should clear up, and we should continue to see some additional cost savings. Now, as you then head into the next year, there'll be other things that impact expenses, obviously. So there's a lot going on, especially with the size we're at now. But we expect to continue to get some additional benefits, but we did, I think, get more upfront maybe than we even anticipated. But there is still, I think, at least a little bit more to come on the cost savings side.

Justin Crowley
VP and Senior Research Analyst, Piper Sandler

Okay. Got it. Appreciate that. And then just looking at the balance sheet repositioning in the quarter, you know, a lot was expected and, you know, I think a big added benefit of doing the deal. But just curious if you could talk through maybe a bit more what continued opportunity could look like. I know timing can be tough to pin down for sure, but, you know, maybe just in terms of magnitude compared to what we've already seen so far.

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Yeah, I wouldn't say from a magnitude perspective there would be, you know, major additional sales along the lines you saw in the third quarter. There may be some one-off situations where there may be some non-core assets that could be sold, but again, I wouldn't expect anything in the size and scale of what we realized in the third quarter. And then, some of it is just more gradual, Justin, where, you know, you've got loans that you might view as, you know, not strategically necessary, and you have negotiations around rate and structure and price that you might hold the line on a little stronger if you're not worried about the loan leaving.

So I do think we'll see some situations where some loans will mature or rates will reset, and we might see some you know, continued payoffs and pay downs, particularly in the Investor Real Estate portfolio. And you know, those are things that I expect will continue to happen as we move forward over the next couple quarters. But I don't think it'll be a big headline announcement as much as a gradual strategic transition out of some less relationship-based Investor Real Estate Loans into more relationship-driven, higher deposit balance C&I loans.

Justin Crowley
VP and Senior Research Analyst, Piper Sandler

Okay. So combining that sort of with some of the commentary on some loan growth, and just the size of the balance sheet is, y ou know, what is the right way to think about it? And I'm sure it's sort of a moving target, but, you know, a flat balance sheet or is contraction, you know, a more likely scenario, just looking out over the next couple of quarters?

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Yeah, listen, I don't know, right? At the end of the day, it's all about, adding the right types of customers and, transitioning out of, you know, potential non-core, non-strategic assets. But, you know, if our team does an incredible job, which I hope they will, in generating good new core deposit balances, then, we've got plenty of activity in the loan pipeline, as Peter outlined, to, to grow loans a little bit, over the next couple quarters. But, if the core deposit funding is hard to come by, then I'd say a flattish scenario where, you know, we reposition payoffs and pay downs into new loans, is probably more likely. But, you know, I'm not overly concerned about whether it's flat or 5% growth.

It's about doing the right kind of business, and in this environment, we can generate value without growing by, you know, optimizing the portfolio. But that doesn't mean we won't grow if there are good opportunities to add quality customers and relationships, so.

Justin Crowley
VP and Senior Research Analyst, Piper Sandler

Okay, understood. And then just one last one quickly for me. Just, just on the margin, Andrew, I'm not sure, are you able to walk through just the purchase accounting impact, impact and quantifying, if you can, and then just perhaps, you know, what the thought is on how that trends moving forward?

Andrew Hibshman
EVP and CFO, First Bank

Yeah. So I think in the remarks, I mentioned the kind of net impact of purchase accounting accretion was $2.7 million. And again, that was because the deal closed later in the month of July. That was two months. So you can kind of figure out what the monthly run rate. Now, that runs down over time, but not quickly, so it'll run down gradually over time. But yeah, I mean, that's all those large interest rate marks that we have going. So that's kind of the number that we saw in the second quarter based or third quarter, based on two months. You can kind of figure out what the run rate will be, kind of, then trailing off over time, going forward.

There's also some impact on some other areas, not just the margin, like Core Deposit Intangibles and things like that, that get amortized back through expenses on the core deposit side. So there is some other impacts, but those are more muted than the interest rate marks, which is the number that I that I gave you there.

Justin Crowley
VP and Senior Research Analyst, Piper Sandler

Okay, perfect. Apologies, missed that in the remarks. I appreciate it, guys. I'll leave it there.

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

All right. Thanks, Justin.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Manuel Navas with D.A. Davidson. Your line is now open. You may go ahead.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

Hey, just a big picture. I have your slide deck with the businesses you're focusing on. Are there any businesses that you've exited fully that aren't on that slide?

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

No. I mean, you know, we obviously sold a big chunk of residential mortgage loans that were legacy Malvern loans, but we haven't stopped making new residential consumer loans. But as you know, it's never been a real big part of our business. So, you know, continuing to make consumer residential loans where there's a larger relationship involved and it makes sense. But, you know, those are areas where we've historically been very selective, and I think we'll continue to be selective. And then on the investment real estate side, we're definitely not exiting that area. We're just looking to rebalance the portfolio as we move forward to bring down some of that real estate concentration, as well as grow in some areas where we think we can generate additional deposit balance.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

Okay, that's helpful. In the past, you talked about some of the repositioning, opening up room for buybacks. Are those still on the table? It looks like it mainly went to borrowings and the NIM is, t hat should help the NIM, and that's a very solid way to use the proceeds as well. But just wondering how you balance that versus buyback?

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Yeah, listen, I think in the short run, our focus over the next couple of quarters is going to be replenishing capital. Obviously, the acquisition, both with the cash component and the mark-to-market, used up some of our excess capital. I think we'd like to first replenish that, but if, if down the road, the buyback remains an attractive way to deploy excess capital, we would absolutely continue to look at it. As I think, you know, we did, we did some buybacks early in the year. As we, as we sort of project out, you know, with, with flat to slight balance sheet growth and significantly enhanced earnings, you know, we expect we're going to be able to replenish capital quite quickly.

So, I don't think we'll be on the sidelines for too long on the buyback, but, in the short run, I think the priority is to get those capital ratios back up a little higher than where they are right now.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

What is that medium-term target on CET1, or what metric would you use?

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Yeah, I mean, we've got internal levels that we keep an eye on. Our Tier 1 risk-based capital is at 9% right now, which again, is a level we're perfectly comfortable with. But I think we'd want to see that, you know, a fair bit over 9% before we started buying back stock. So there's not a magic number. It depends on, you know, where the stock's trading and other strategic initiatives underway. But I think at 9%, we'd be focused on moving that number higher in the short run, and then, you know, as we build up some additional buffers, we'll take a look and see where the stock's trading, and if that's the right way to deploy any excess capital we might have, we'll absolutely look at it.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

The growth, the organic growth, took a step back, but the pipeline is rebuilt. Do you see fourth quarter as your back to normal? Or is it still gonna take a couple quarters before kind of the different loan and deposit channels are fully up, back, up and running again?

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Yeah, again, I think the loan pipeline is robust, so there's no shortage of good quality loan opportunities out there. At this point, you know, we're focused on funding the quality loans that we can fund with core deposit growth. And Darleen and her team, and Peter and his teams are out there pounding the pavement every day to find new opportunities and look to grow those deposits. I think we're doing a great job acquiring new customers. The challenge is, you know, there continues to be some seepage out of the banking industry into you know, money market, bond funds, et cetera. So you know, sometimes you're adding customers, but you're running in the wind a little bit, and so it may not result in a lot of overall balance sheet growth.

But, you know, that's gonna be the driver, and at this point, we don't need to force it. We can, we can drive strong earnings growth without the need for significant balance sheet growth. Again, that doesn't mean if we have good opportunities, we won't continue to do that. But, you know, the way we've been able to reposition the balance sheet and the way we can manage attrition and payoffs and pay downs, along with deposit growth, will allow us to continue to add new business. You know, whether that translates into, you know, modest growth or flat balance sheet, you know, time will tell, but I don't, I don't view that as, as a huge variable in terms of us hitting our, our goals on a financial performance perspective.

Andrew Hibshman
EVP and CFO, First Bank

And Nick, I would add that, as Pat, and I think Peter both mentioned, typically right after a deal closes, there is some workouts of loans. We're trying to work out if they're problem loans, and we're getting out of some strategic and non-strategic relationships. So that'll obviously impact the net loan growth as well, as we'll see. We will ultimately see some elevated payoffs and pay downs over the next couple of quarters.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

Hey, that brings up kind of my next comment is that pipeline can help generate i n the past, the projection was about $200 million in growth, just out of that pipeline. Obviously, there's gonna be that's not gonna be net fully next year, but is that kind of the production you think you can generate even as soon as next year? Just kind of some thoughts there in terms of that production side. Obviously, there's gonna be continued runoff. There's gonna be continued kind of keeping what you want to keep, but do you feel comfortable with the production side being at that $200 million level or could it be a little bit higher?

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Yeah, I don't see it being higher than $200 million. If I had to guess, I'd say it's gonna be less than $200 million. Not because there's not good loan opportunities out there, but just because, as we see opportunities to reposition the balance sheet, you know, we're not gonna force it, right? There's no reason in this inverted yield curve environment to be borrowing money to, you know, to fund loans. So, we're gonna do what we can based on our deposit growth initiatives. And if the headwinds in that market mean that we don't have as much in core funding as we'd like to fund all the good loan opportunities, then, you know, we may end up growing less than that $200 number that we've done in the past.

But it's not for lack of good loan opportunities. It's really just dealing with the rate environment we're in and the funding market we're in.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

Okay. And then, what levels of attrition are you seeing on the deposit side? And is that slowing? Is that progressing as expected? Just kind of some thoughts on customer retention.

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Yeah, I think we knew we were gonna have some excess cash coming through the sales of securities and residential mortgage loans, so for a good part of the third quarter, we weren't aggressively pricing deposits. And if it was a rate-sensitive situation, we decided to let some of that money go. And as you saw, you know, almost three quarters of the decline in deposits during the quarter was a function of letting brokered run off, which, you know, is much more of a, you know, turn it on, turn it off type funding source. So, you know, we've got a nice new deposit campaign going. We've got our group laser focused on finding core deposits and, you know, we're seeing some initial good results from our current promotion. You know, I think we'll, we'll return to deposit growth in Q4. Darleen, anything you'd add there?

Darleen Gillespie
Chief Retail Banking Officer, First Bank

No, I would just echo your comment that, you know, we have some great campaigns out in the market. We have a great sales team that is focused on expanding relationships and acquiring new customers and deposits. So as long as we continue with that trajectory, I think that we'll continue to see positive deposit growth as we move into 2024.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

I appreciate that. But my last question on the NIM outlook, is the best way to kind of think about the NIM next quarter is taking that $2.7 million and adding an extra month? Because that was two months of accretion, add that kind of going forward, add some little bit of growth. How are there any other moving parts I should be thinking about on the near term NIM?

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Yeah. The market environment.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

Yeah.

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

I mean, look, that's, that's the right way to start the analysis, and then you gotta factor in where you think deposit costs are going and what you're seeing on the loan side. We do think, you know, we're getting to a point where the increase in loan yield is almost offsetting the increase on the deposit funding cost. So, you know, we hope to be in a position where the net impact of those two variables is neutral from a margin standpoint. I'm not sure we'll be there in Q4. I hope to get there soon, but, you know, even with some of those headwinds, you know, just the math of the interest rate accretion earn back, the margin should be moving higher for sure.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

Is there like, opportunities for security yield pickup? Is there opportunities, uhm, w hat, what are like, new loan yields coming on? I know, I know it's more C&I that should be higher. But what's in the pipeline? Those are the kind of things that I can't quite see that could be a nice benefit to the NIM going forward.

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Yeah, I mean, I think anything we're doing that short-term variable rate, you know, is getting priced, you know, really anywhere between 8%-10%. So plenty of yield on the new production, on the floating rate stuff. I think the term fixed rate stuff is, you know, now getting priced in the, you know, probably 7%-7.5% range. And so, you know, if you line up a new incremental deposit dollar, which is, you know, probably coming in at close to 5%, against a new fixed rate loan at 7.5, obviously that's only 2.5 spread, which would tighten your margin a bit. But I'd say of the new loan production we're doing right now, 2/3 or more is in the shorter term floating rate category.

I think the net benefit on the loan yield side is getting pretty close to matching what we're seeing in terms of the increase on the funding cost side.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

Okay. I appreciate that color. And would that kind of give you the expectation as that's bottoming out, that you could see some expansion in second half of next year? Like, what's any kind of thoughts on the NIM trajectory?

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Well, again, I mean, just with the math on the earnings accretion, it's gonna move higher significantly in the first half of the year. You know, at some point that does slow down a little bit, but, you know, the, the downside of larger interest rate marks up front and the, and the tangible book value dilution, just means there's more interest rate mark income to earn back in, so you get the, you get the benefit of that, quote, unquote, "Over a longer period of time." So, you know, I don't know, Andrew. We, we haven't finalized our, our budget for 2024 and beyond, so I don't think we're prepared to give you guidance beyond the next couple quarters at this point.

Andrew Hibshman
EVP and CFO, First Bank

Yeah. I mean, obviously there's, there's, it's all contingent on what the rate environment looks like. If it stays inverted like this for a long time, it'll continue to put pressure on the margin. If we get some relief from the yield curve environment, that will help. But Pat's point is right. I think over at least the next few quarters, starting in the fourth quarter, we should see some improvement, and then hopefully it stabilizes. But again, it's gonna be very contingent on rate environment and a lot of things out of our control.

Manuel Navas
Senior Research Analyst, D.A. Davidson

Thank you, guys. Thank you. I appreciate it.

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Thank you, Manuel.

Operator

At this time, there are no further questions. I would like to now turn the call back over to Patrick Ryan, President and CEO.

Patrick Ryan
President and CEO, First Bank

Okay, thank you very much. We certainly appreciate folks dialing into the call today, and we'll look forward to providing additional updates when we do our fourth quarter update later in January. Thanks, everyone.

Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, that concludes today's call. Thank you all for joining. You may now disconnect.

Powered by