Live Nation Entertainment, Inc. (LYV)
NYSE: LYV · Real-Time Price · USD
154.75
-1.74 (-1.11%)
At close: Apr 28, 2026, 4:00 PM EDT
155.35
+0.60 (0.39%)
After-hours: Apr 28, 2026, 7:19 PM EDT
← View all transcripts

Goldman Sachs Communacopia & Technology Conference

Sep 6, 2023

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

All right, great. Let's get started with our next session. Thank you, everyone, for taking the time to join us today. My name is Stephen Laszczyk and I'm the lead entertainment analyst for Goldman Sachs. We're excited to welcome back to the Communicopia + Technology Conference this year, Joe Berchtold, the President and CFO of Live Nation. Joe, thank you for being with us today.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Well, thanks for having me.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Great, so I wanted to start off high level. Live Nation continues to execute against what is set to be another record year in 2023 across concert attendance, fee-bearing tickets, sponsorship revenue. That said, we're coming off two years of tailwinds from a global pandemic reopening, and we're still facing a somewhat uncertain economic environment. So with that as the backdrop, I was curious if you could start off by discussing some of the key drivers you've seen in the business so far in 2023, and what are the main opportunities and risks you're keeping top of mind heading into next year?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Well, it took till your second sentence to say, "That being said." I do think Goldman just downgraded the risk of a recession to 15% yesterday, didn't they? So-

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

They did.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

You clearly wrote your questions before that. As you said, you know, 2023 is a phenomenal year. I know we'll get into each of the businesses and the stats there coming off of a great 2022. We continue to see this as a tremendous global demand business, where it's our job to bring supply to that more and more fully globalized business with tremendous runway for continuing to do that. You know, we obviously focus on a lot of indicators on how the business is doing to look for any signs of weakness.

We look at our on-sales, we look at how shows are closing, how the casual fans are buying, we're looking at per caps when they get there, we're looking at secondary market to see what the demand levels are, to see what the pricing levels are. We haven't seen any issues at all, any signs of any slowness. On-sales, as recently as this week and last week continued to perform very strongly. So we're not seeing any issues. We're continuing to move forward with the expectation that next year will be an even better year. We think we have far more structural tailwinds than headwinds.

Again, some of the reports that Goldman publishes in terms of where consumer discretionary is when you look at the breakdown between goods versus services, and the fact that experiences tends to be still below 2019 levels as a percentage of consumer discretionary spending. I mean, that gives us a much larger headwind than student loans, as we've talked about. It gives us a, or, sorry, much larger tailwind than we have because of any student loan issues or any issues with the economy, which again, even the latest services report today, right? You can't win these days. If the economy is looking strong, the market gets mad, and if the economy is looking weak, the market gets mad. But we're not seeing any issues at all.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

And I say that being said in my second sentence.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

because I feel like there's been this consumer concern or investor concern over the last year or so, that the consumer is sensitive to discretionary spending-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Mm-hmm.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

on things like live events. And there's been other pockets of the consumer discretionary industry where we certainly have seen that.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

We haven't seen it as much in live entertainment.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

I'm curious if you could just unpack what you've learned over the last, you know, 12-16 months for us. What... has it surprised you? Is it some of this pent-up demand, or is there something more structural about how you're-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

seeing consumers prioritize and spend money?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah, I don't think it's pent-up demand. I don't think there's anything that we're seeing that's not consistent with what we've seen over a long period in the live events industry. Again, I would start by looking very macro. I mean, if you look over the last 30 years, there's been one year of reduction. So through four or five recessionary periods, you've had one year that you've had any reduction. Happened to be the same year that the Ticketmaster merger was completed, so there was a lot of distractions in that one year in terms of execution. So I start with that, and then I think that, again, we've got the tailwind that I talked about on a global basis of people prioritizing experiences over goods-

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Mm-hmm.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

which gives us a strong tailwind. You've got a business that in good times, people wanna go out and enjoy themselves and go to live events. I think for people that are more challenged economically, it's actually an affordable luxury. Right? You may not be able to afford to take the kids to Disney World for a week, but you can still afford to go to a concert. And there's very broad price points. There's a lot of focus on pricing on the front of the house and average pricing, which is true, but we continue to be equally focused on back-of-house pricing and making sure that every fan can afford to get into the show. Doesn't mean they can afford to buy the front row-

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Mm-hmm.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

But they can at least afford to get into the building, and that's important to most artists. So I think it is. It remains an affordable luxury, and the confluence of those factors continue to make it very popular. And then add on to that, the globalization, which gives us just a larger playing field. And the globalization, we've been seeing the globalization of demand over the past several years. Now, I think we're seeing another level, which is globalization of supply. And you're seeing. You saw the K-pop music over the past several years and how that's grown. You're seeing now Latin music, where Latin music is accounting for a large portion of the top artists this year. So you're seeing.

More genres come in who are gonna have more audiences, which is then just more demand on a structural basis. And again, I don't think any of that is anything pent-up, because here we are, two years later, and the numbers we'll get into are showing tremendous growth over 2022, which is showing tremendous growth over 2019. So I don't think you'd have a transitory pent-up that would have this level of ongoing demand.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

You mentioned on your second quarter call, you sold 117 million tickets so far this year through July-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

- up 20% relative to this point last year. It sounds like that momentum's carried into the, to the fall, basically.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah, 100%. We're at 128 million now. I think we're probably-

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

$128 million.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

128 million tickets we've sold for shows this year. You will be in the high 130s million, maybe hit 140 million this year. So again, you look back, we were at 98 million fans went to our shows in 2019 and, you know, last year was tremendous growth and this year's even further growth from there. So, again, and it's really global that we're seeing it. We've talked a lot about how this, the second half, particularly international, has been driving a lot of that growth.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Let's talk a little bit about what could drive that growth beyond 2023, and you mentioned that a little bit, and that's the supply side-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

-of the equation. I think there's, you know, some concern after two, three years of some artists going on some pretty notable tours, they've been down the road for a while, that you could take a pause, take a break. How are you seeing the supply side of the dynamic shape up into 2024 and 2025? Should we be expecting some of these artists to take a breather from touring, or you mentioned the globalization factor coming in? Is that enough to make up for maybe some of these artists going off cycle over the next year or two?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah, and we talked at earnings about 2024 and how we were seeing the pipeline. What we look at at this point is, for your major venues that tend to book further out, your stadiums, arenas, your amphitheaters. If you look at what either you have confirmed or where you have offers in at this point of the year, that accounts for maybe a third of your expected shows. And we're up double digits looking at next year. So we're feeling very strong that we're gonna have that supply pipeline. I've heard some other theories that, well, that's all. You know, people are in the U.S. now, they're going international. No, the U.S. is up double digits as well. It's all looking strong on a global basis that we'll be able to continue to grow.

I think next year will probably have the growth will be more arena and amphitheater driven, which is what you'd expect after being so stadium-driven the past few years. But that doesn't matter. You know, it doesn't matter, in North America, international, stadium versus arena. What matters the most to us is A, driving the fan volume, and then B, to the extent we can be doing it at our venues, where we get to count the beer money and get more sponsorship and so on, that's ideal. We'll make more money with those fans. But again, number one priority is we can continue to grow that fan base every year, which the read so far on the show count would indicate 2024 is shaping up very well.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

I wanna get into how you monetize that fan relationship. One more higher-level question on the globalization of music, and both on the supply and demand side-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

There's some clear tailwinds to the globalization. Both in the streaming world, we're seeing it, but also in the live events sector as well. Could maybe talk a little bit more about how that plays into your long-term vision for the industry, how you can create demand on the back of tapping into this global supply that will emerge?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah, I mean, I really think in many regards, that's our business model, right? The global demand exists. The streaming platforms, social media platforms, artists are able to build their brands on a truly global basis now. So our job is working with artists to bring that supply to the demand, is to make it easy for them to tour, not just in their own markets, but in other markets. To providing the supporting activities around promoting the show, to provide economic support, and to make that market, if you will, between the supply and the latent demand. So we've had two primary vectors of growth, if you wanna think about it, one is taking the historically established artist population and just bringing them to more and more markets because that demand exists.

Second is identifying regions of music, and bringing that to a global audience that may have, may have been more local historically. So when you think about the genres we were talking about ten years ago, we were talking about, I mean, I mentioned this earlier, we were talking about, okay, how big is country? You know, EDM had its day, right? Where people were obsessed with, "Let's- EDM's gonna take over the world, and let's, let's, let's go all in on that." Well, the reality is, is that all of these genres have an audience, EDM, hip-hop, country, pop, whatever you want to talk about. And now you're seeing more genres emerge, of which K-pop and Latin are, are both massive, and so we can bring all of that together, right?

You know, as we talked, Bad Bunny was our number one artist in the world last year. This year, we've had Peso Pluma, RBD, Karol G, Kali Uchis, right? I mean, you've had massive volume. You bring them to the U.S., and by the way, you bring them, you tour them in Latin America. Then, as they globalize, you can bring them to other parts of the world. All of that is a long runway to continue to grow the business, and that's not something we do in a year. We're, we're still predominantly, or not primarily, majority is North America business for us. So that says is if you want to talk about the long-term growth runway of the business, then clearly international has a long runway.

Because if you buy the thesis that it's global demand and you look at the numbers and you say they're majority in North America, and clearly the population in North America is the vast minority, well, you have a huge unmet demand that you can bring the supply to. And the more that we can do to broaden the supply and support that, then the more business we can have and the more fans we can have going to our shows.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

That's helpful, and I certainly want to get into the M&A strategy on international as well a little bit later. But maybe getting back to the point on how you monetize fans once they're in your ecosystem. On-site spending per fan has continued to trend up nicely. It's up double digit amphitheaters again-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

This year. We've seen some pockets, particularly at theme parks, where some per cap spending has moderated over the last couple of months. I'm curious if you're seeing that at any part of your footprint. It seems like demand is broadly strong-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

... but perhaps not. And then-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

... over the long term, really the question is: how do you get per caps-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

... from $40 today up to the $50 or $60?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah. So, I mean, per cap's up at our amphitheaters, theaters up at our theaters and clubs, up at our festivals globally. So all of that clearly continuing to show growth. Amphitheaters expect to be up 3, 3-something this year into the 40s. So, very solid performance, right? I think a little better than the historical couple of dollars a year that we'd been seeing. I think the difference is our focus when we look at APFs and per caps is not about how do I get you to buy another beer, or how do I charge you another buck for a beer? It's how do I create a hospitality environment that enables you to spend all the money that you want to spend as the segment of customer that you are?

So what are the products that I'm creating? And some of those products can be very tactical. I mean, we've got, we created these shaker cup cocktails that have dramatically increased our liquor sales because we found that there was a large segment that didn't want to drink beer and get filled up, but they didn't want to go up to a bar and order a cocktail. But if you give them a pre-made, here's a tequila, margarita, watermelon margarita, I think here's a vodka drink, pre-set up in a product that makes it very easy for them, well, then we have a population that we weren't serving very effectively. We've created a great new product, now we're serving that population. And then, and then more obviously, it's the hospitality.

It's the, what are the VIP clubs, the viewing decks, the rock boxes, the VIP parking, the valet parking. How do I create a whole range of hospitality options so when you're there with another couple and it's a big night out, you want to spend money and have a great experience, you can do that. And we reduce the friction for you to spend the money that you want to spend to have as good of an experience as you can. I think that's what gives you runway, is this continuing to understand your fan base, how they want to spend money, and make it easy for them. For sure, if I'm just selling you more popcorn and another beer, then that's gonna hit a wall.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Great overview. Maybe shifting a little bit to the concert margins. With your second quarter results, you stated that you expected concert margins to expand this year relative to 2022.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

There's been a lot of focus on this number, just given the cost inputs and inflation. So I was hoping you could maybe spend a little bit more time talking about what the key underlying puts and takes of concert margins are for this year, and perhaps how investors should think about operating leverage in that segment over the next couple of years.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

So it's I think it boils down to a couple of things. The first is mix. So I alluded to it earlier. When we put a fan through a third-party building, we simply don't make as much as we do when we put them through one of our amphitheaters, one of our festivals, because we get all that beer money, we get all that parking money, we get our take, venue take as a service fee. We have our hands in more, and those pieces that we're in are much higher margin than just the promotion economics. So that's a piece, that mix. The other is the obvious, which is just what's the cost structure of operating the venues that we operate?

So you know, what happened to us was no different than what happened with the rest of the world, which is your lower cost employees got more expensive coming out of COVID. So you had a kick up in that cost structure in late 2021, 2022, that you know, kind of structurally reset some of those costs. Now, those cost pressures are off, so you're not seeing the big jumps anymore, but they don't go backwards. People aren't showing up for less money. So again, you could have debates. If you looked over a 10-year period at how little that cost was going up, you could argue that was just a catch-up as well. But in any case, it is what it is.

But so, so it's what's the cost and therefore the profitability, the cash generation on those fans going to our venues. So I think what happened was that took a hit. That was no big surprise. At the same time, we had, we had a lot of our growth coming from third-party venues. You can scale them faster and more easily because you have almost unlimited utilization opportunity in third-party venues. So that jumped up, and I think frankly, there was some confusion over the dynamic between the two....

and a level of concern that we've tried to alleviate and say, "No, it's not, you know, we haven't, we haven't structurally lost all of our margin." The margin is, is there, coming back, still attractive when we're operating in our venue, but also don't, I, I'm still a believer that margins are an output, not an input. So we're not turning down shows in stadiums that we can make money at and, have a nice return just because it's gonna hurt our margin. So it's why I try to say enough to give some comfort, that margins are gonna be better, better this year than they were last year.

It's why I'm not gonna let you pin me down, because I'm never gonna wanna look at a situation and say, "Oh, God, that tour we make $a few million on, but we shouldn't do that. We're gonna, you know, hurt our margin," and then somebody's gonna be upset that we didn't hit our margin target. So, I understand the issue and the concern. It's on the trajectory to increase. If we continue to book a lot of amphitheater shows for next year, then that'll help our margin. But again, that's as much of an output of the fact of the show mix as it is anything else. Obviously, as we grow our APFs, that helps as well, because of the margin flow through on that money.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Maybe turning to Ticketmaster. Ticketmaster sold 151 million fee-bearing tickets through the second quarter, which was up 22% year-over-year.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yep.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

On the call, you mentioned you're on pace to sell 300 million for the year, which is 7% growth over the 2022 figure. So really, two questions for you. First, could you walk us through some of the key drivers of the 22% that we've seen so far this year? And then, secondly, could you explain why your guidance for ticket sales in the back half of the year is implying just some degree of a deceleration in that figure?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Because I forgot to say over. Should have said over 300 million. That was a mistake on my part. I think I would have alleviated a lot of concern and then didn't have the public platform to add that word until now.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

So, just to clarify-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

So, uh-

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

The guidance should have been.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

The guidance should have been over 300 million, not 300 million tickets. If you look at the first half, the growth in ticketing year to date has, not surprisingly, been heavily driven by concerts. I mean, when you look at the increased number of concert tickets we've sold as an indicator in the rest of the market, other promoters are continuing to do well as well. I, you know, depending on how you want to measure it, probably 80-ish% of the growth has come from concerts and ticketing this year. So the... Really, the only question mark in where in the over 300 and what's the level of growth for the year comes down to timing of Q4 on sales.

So there's nothing that I've said that should be taken as any commentary on how the market momentum is going, which again, in hindsight, when I didn't say the word over, I understand people quickly got some concern. But it's really just gonna come down to, in the fourth quarter, what are the timing of on-sales for shows next year, Q4 this year versus Q1? I just said that a lot of the growth is gonna come from amphitheaters and arenas. Amphitheaters are really largely Q1 to Q2 on-sales. Arenas tend to be more Q1 versus Q4. So, you know, we haven't laid out the timing of all of our November, December on-sales yet, so it just comes... There again, zero comment on the underlying business.

The only question is, even if we have more shows, more fans next year, that doesn't necessarily translate into you sell more tickets in Q4 of this year. So we don't know. So, not trying to guide to exactness there. And, as you know, we don't. I'm not gonna. We're not gonna push any artist to be in Q4 because we wanna make sure we have a certain growth target. If the artist wants to be in Q1, that's what makes sense for their tour, that's what we'll do. I don't. We don't try to manage our business to the quarter like that.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Got it. Maybe on the pricing opportunity, Live Nation's made a lot of progress on the pricing front over the last few years with the adoption of Platinum. That said, you mentioned on your most recent call that the secondary market, the average ticket sale is still for roughly 2x primary. Could you talk a little bit more about how far along we are in the adoption of Platinum pricing, and maybe to what extent you think that could continue to be a tailwind over the next few years, perhaps to the same extent that we've seen it over the last few?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah, I think at this point, probably 80+% of our tours globally are using some sort of platinum pricing, which simply means we're using analytical tools to help the artist understand what's the value of your best tickets, and how do you wanna think about pricing those closer to market. You know, if you look over the past several years, we probably moved, over the last... since 2019, $2 billion from secondary to the artist's pocket. So on one hand, we made good progress, on the other hand, secondary market in the U.S. is bigger now than it was in 2019. So, you could also... So we made zero progress, and we still have a tremendous ways to go with pricing because of that.

So the best tickets have demonstrated a general, highly inelastic demand to them. So I think the opportunity now is not so much the awareness and adoption of pricing as a general concept, but continued refinement of it, and artists deciding for their brand, for what they're trying to accomplish, how much that money do they want to be capturing versus often letting the scalpers pick up?

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Is that still a hard pitch to some artists that don't want to adopt Platinum pricing, or has it become more accepted in the industry?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

No, it's not, it's not a hard pitch. Again, it's every artist is figuring out for their brand what's the right balance. And, and again, our conversations are as much about how are you making sure the back of the house is affordable for all your fans, as it is figuring out how you're capturing the market value at the front of the house so that money doesn't go to scalpers. And it's just, how do you progress it? How do you move that along over time? And again, it's one of the reasons why we think we have a long runway, 'cause you look at the gap that still exists in secondary, how it's been growing, and the fact that it's gonna be an incremental, continued capture of that money by the artist.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Let's talk about the other runway in Ticketmaster, and that's account wins and market share growth.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Mm-hmm.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

So, so far this year, you've added 14 million net new fee-bearing tickets to the platform. That's on top of the 23 million last year and the 17 million the year prior. What continues to be the driving force behind this? And maybe looking ahead, how much more opportunity is there to go after these incremental net new fee-bearing tickets?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Well, since earnings now at the end of August, it's 16 million net add, so clearly the opportunity continues to exist even during summer vacations, that we added a few million more tickets. So, look, it goes back to what we were talking about first and foremost, this is a global business, and Ticketmaster is now organized and focused on treating it as a truly global business. A large portion of these wins are coming from international markets. A lot of them are coming because Ticketmaster has the best global platform for selling tickets.

And if you're a venue, first and foremost, or if you're a promoter, first and foremost, you want to know that you are going to be able to effectively sell your tickets, and you're gonna have all the tools to price the tickets, to market the tickets, which makes money for you, the venue, and helps attract artists that wanna play your venue because they know they can get the gross out of it, that makes it worthwhile for them.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

That's helpful. I wanted to touch on the legislative and regulatory concerns in the market. Ticketing practices have gotten much greater focus from the legislative side of Washington. You've been active in working with Congress to address some of these concerns. The FAIR Ticketing Act you proposed earlier this year, and more recently, your commitments around all-in pricing as being two examples of that. Could you update us on the legislative side of the equation-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

... right now? What concerns do you feel like you made the most progress on, and what concerns are still outstanding, and how are you planning to address them?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

I think one of the real positives that's come out of the past year with all the various legislative activities and discussions we've had is the level of transparency that we've created in the ticketing industry that hasn't historically existed. We recognized very early, going into the Senate meeting last year, that our number one strength was to create transparency. Because when you understand the complexity of the industry and how the pieces work, then we have no concern about how we look and what we do. We proudly stand behind the tools we create to help artists understand the value of their tickets, and we believe in the artist's right to charge for their art what they want to charge, just as we support sports teams and others in doing that.

So we don't feel like we have anything to hide from in terms of what we do in our support of content and our support of venues. But there was a lot of opaqueness in it, and that led to a lot of critique of us because there were assumptions about roles we played, things that we did, that simply aren't true. So as we've created that transparency, I think that's helped shift the dialogue away from: How do we stop that evil Ticketmaster, to how do we create some reforms that are going to help the artists, that are going to help the fans have a more transparent experience? All-in pricing is a great one. Our FAIR Ticketing Act, it has been very helpful, 'cause there hasn't been a congressman, a senator, who I've sat down with and walked them through the logic.

Give me half an hour with any of them, and I can explain the dynamics of the industry and why these different pieces are needed, and they all get it. So how that translates into any actual legislation, I've got no idea in today's world, and I don't expect the next year is gonna be very bipartisan, getting much done. I'd like to hope that this is down the middle enough, but it's never as easy as you'd like. So I think we feel very good about where we stand with a much greater understanding of the ticketing dynamics.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Mm

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

... and where the real issues are.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Investors have debated this past year to what extent potential legislative mandates, potentially around all-in pricing, the limitations around venue exclusivity or the length of those contracts-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yep

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

... perhaps restrictions on ticket resale.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yep

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

... the impact that could have on your business. To what extent do you view each of those particular issues as risks to your, your business model?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

I don't view them as risks at all. We operate with all-in pricing around much of the world. It works just fine. I don't have any major issues. We've long said that secondary is an adjunct business for us. It's not, it's not a focus. We're in it because we think serving the fans, being able to buy a safe ticket, with us, is an important part of the service. They can always come to us to find the tickets. It's an important service right now for artists to know that their tickets are always gonna be available, and that fans will continue to come to the primary location to buy their tickets, but we regularly restrict resale in a number of ways, when that's what the artist wants. So, so we're doing those things anyway.

Length of exclusive contracts is largely being driven by venues in the competitive environment. No concern about the length of exclusive contracts or frankly, even exclusivity. Much of the world we operate in a non-exclusive market. I think we've seen with the experience in California, where there was some discussion of banning exclusive contracts, it was the venues and the sports teams that are monetizing those rights that rose up and said: "No, you're taking away some of my value. I own those exclusive rights. If I wanna auction them off to the highest bidder, that should be my right. Don't get in the middle of it. I'm not being forced to. I'm not being forced to take the most money possible. I wanna take that." So I'm not worried about any of those, what I'll call, discrete business practices, impacting us in any material way.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

On the regulatory side of the equation, you've acknowledged the DOJ inquiry, which was initially reported by The New York Times last November, and more recently by Politico in July. Could you update us on your understanding of where the DOJ process stands today, the nature of their investigation, and anything that could help us think through a range of outcomes or potential timeline from here?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah, and based on what I've heard, it's my opinion that there's nothing that our fundamental business model is not really being questioned or challenged. We continue to believe that our vertical business model of competing hard and paying the most for concerts, and then making our money on secondary and tertiary profit streams is both pro-competitive and pro-consumer. That it delivers the best outcome for all those parties, and I haven't seen any facts that would indicate otherwise. I think that with the focus on working through what are the different business practices, the DOJ is gonna take the time they're gonna take to make sure they've looked at them all, 'cause they don't, you know, they don't get another bite of the apple a year later, so they'll take what time they take.

We unfortunately aren't in control of that timeline. I'd love to get it done tomorrow. It's not up to me because they're gonna go through their process, and we simply don't control it.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Got it. Maybe one on sponsorship, and then I wanna end on capital allocation. The vast majority of your sponsorship business, I think 85% this year, has been, excuse me, over 90% this year has been committed. I'm curious if you'd update us on sort of the strength and momentum of the sponsorship pipeline, as we go into the back half of the year.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah, I don't have any concerns. We'll finish the year with our sponsorship business up double digits, as we consistently have over the past several years. And with so much now in the bank, the team has obviously turned its focus to now making sure that we're continuing to figure out how do you grow in 2024.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Great. And then just on the minute or two, we have remaining on capital allocation, venue investment-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

... and international M&A have been two of the top priorities for you.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Absolutely.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Could you just walk us through how you're thinking about the opportunities on both of those fronts? And then, particularly around M&A, I'm curious, on international markets, how do you know when you've reached the point where you can switch from inorganic growth to, to organic growth, and when you've successfully-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

-completed the land-

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Yeah

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

strategy before expanding?

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

Well, you're absolutely right. As I think about our capital, whether it's growth, CapEx or M&A, the two main focus areas would be venue expansion and international expansion, and there's obviously a lot of overlap between those two. We've seen a number of cases where the difference between M&A and organic is simply one of opportunity. It's timing. M&A is faster, lower risk, and more expensive. Right, CapEx is gonna be cheaper, take longer, and more uncertain on the outcome. But it depends on if you're going into a market. If you're going into a market, is there a festival? Is there a promoter that makes sense that you can acquire, that's going to give you that foundation, and then you can build off of that foundation? You see some very successful examples in Germany.

It's probably been close to 10 years ago when we bought the number one German promoter, and we've built that business, and it's been incredibly successful. We've largely built it organically. We've made a few other acquisitions. We've invested in some venues. That's now grown manyfold from what it was then. OCESA, even in the short time since we made that investment, we've talked about, has substantially outperformed. It's been a great business as we've really invested in their Ticketmaster platform, which wasn't on the same version as we had globally and have brought that up, as we've helped direct tours down there, as they've helped with our Latin strategy, bringing Latin into the U.S. So all of that has really been largely organic coming off of OCESA.

At the same time, we continue to do some M&A down in Latin America, that's gonna help us get to the critical mass down there. So, it's not a... There's not gonna be a one-size-fits-all. It's gonna be situational and opportunistic in terms of what's the best way to continue to build the business.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Got it. Joe, we're unfortunately out of time. We have to leave it there.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

All right.

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

But thank you for taking the time to join us today, and look forward.

Joe Berchtold
President and Chief Financial Officer, Live Nation Entertainment

All right

Stephen Laszczyk
Lead Entertainment Analyst, Goldman Sachs

to having you back.

Powered by